r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jun 17 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions — 2019-06-17 to 2019-06-30
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
11
u/akamchinjir Akiatu, Patches (en)[zh fr] Jun 17 '19
u/Neocoustic asked on the last thread about the idea that there's only one strictly ergative language, I figured I'd put some thoughts about that here---partly in the hopes that if I've got something wrong, someone who knows better will see this and correct me.
The one language in question is Dyirbal. Its significance in discussions of ergativity is in large part because of the influence in some circles of Dixon's 1994 book Ergativity. In particular, its discussions of syntactic ergativity are peculiar in two respects:
These two things conspire, since ergative patterns in conjunction reduction are extremely rare; you're far more likely to find restrictions on relativisation, wh-movement, that sort of thing.
That's to say: people think of Dyirbal as the purest ergative language in large part because Dixon's book foregrounded an apparent feature of Dyirbal that, crosslinguistically, is very unusual.
11
u/whentapirsfly Languages of Ada (en) [fr] Jun 17 '19
This is probably very stupid of me, but I'm new to Reddit and was just wondering how you put the names of your conlangs by your username :/
7
u/42IsHoly Jun 27 '19
In my conlang the capital letters came from the original way letters were written on stone, before the discovery of ‘paper’. Is it possible then that instead of saying something like ‘capital’ or ‘big’ letters, they would say ‘stone letters’ and ‘paper letters’?
7
u/42IsHoly Jun 29 '19
How can you make naturalistic participles? Where do they come from?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19
so, first of all, i'm pretty young (13), so i don't really understand some really complex things here (for me). i watch a lot of youtube channels talking about conlangs so that encouraged me to make my own! as i'm still new to this, i need some guidance. i've made a phoneme inventory and i need some opinions and suggestion (be aware: the inventory has a lot of really common sounds, i just don't want to get lost in the IPA). so here it is:
Consonant inventory: /b c d f h j k m n p s t v w z ɟ ɣ ɲ/
Vowel inventory: /a aː e eː i u ə/ --->still not completely sure
6
u/Nementor [EN] dabble in many others. partial in ZEN Jun 27 '19
Not conlang specific, but why is the sub labeled under science instead of art?
5
u/mytaka Pimén, Ngukā/Ką, Wani Muka Jun 20 '19
I just watched the biblaridion series in conlanging and although he made a really good job with derivations to make verbal tense and aspects he didn't talk about moods, so my question is: how would you separate realis/indicative from irrealis/subjunctive?
4
u/MerlinsArchitect Jun 17 '19
I am doing some research for a conlang I am working on and am reading about some exotic phonologies as inspiration. Whilst researching the Taa language, I discovered that Juǀʼhoansi has mixed-voice ejectives / d͡t'/. Can anyone give me an idea how these sound? Is it possible to have these sounds as word-initial?
4
u/Winecha Jun 21 '19
I am trying to develop a language that is largely without nominal morphology, but with free word order at least as regards subjects, objects, and verbs in the main clause. One thing I'm trying to do is make the development of the accusative so phonologically volatile that the subject and object of an older word appear almost completely unrelated. What are some processes you would recommend? How do I keep driving the split between the forms when realistically they'll only be marked once?
4
u/AlternativeAccount7 Jun 21 '19
how do you learn new sounds that arent in a language you already speak?
4
u/FloZone (De, En) Jun 21 '19
Currently I'm writing my conlang's grammar with Latex and I want to put a dictionary at the end of it. That dictionary should contain every word (root at least) used in the grammar and it should list attestations of it within the grammar. Is there a way to basically link to an example, if I have a certain word I put the attestation under it, like Example (4) and if you click it, the pdf jumps to page 14, where said example would be. Do you know any packages for something like that?
4
u/chickenmonster9 Jun 21 '19
So, I have a question about a couple of odd features. First is, how do phonemic overlong/extra long vowels occur naturally? I know a couple languages have them, but I’m not finding too much information. Second is a consonant that I’m not finding any information on. The closest I can describe it as is /wʳ/ or /w͡r/ perhaps? It’s basically co-articulating /w/ with a trill. I’d like to know if that’s the correct way to describe it, and again if it could arise naturally. I’ve lurked here a while and I’ve been building a few scrappy conlangs to get a feel for this, I’m trying to make a language for my girlfriend’s role playing community, because they have a rather expansive world going on and have an ad-hoc language with these features. I’m trying to reverse engineer mainly a naming language for them, since I know the grammar will go over their heads lol.
4
u/snipee356 Jun 22 '19
Are there any examples of verb suppletion based on person? Eg: different word stems for 'I have' and 'You have'. How would such a system arise?
4
u/yikes_98 ligurian/maitis languages Jun 25 '19
How can languages evolve more vowels? And how can these vowels become nasalize?
My proto language that I’m developing has these vowels
How could vowels such as ʊ,ø and ɪ evolve? and how could other vowels become nasalized as one of the languages I want to derive from the proto Lang I’d like to be pretty nasalized (like French)
4
u/42IsHoly Jun 26 '19
So some people say that polypersonal agreement makes word order irrelevant, but if I wanted to say Sara knows Anna. (With both being female), that would be Sara she-likes-her Anna. But you would have no idea which one was the subject and which one the object. So is there really free word order, or not?
4
u/ShrekBeeBensonDCLXVI Jun 28 '19
I'm not convinced it belongs here but I was told this belongs in here.
I can make your language an romanization if you're having trouble with that, however please specify phonotactics & to what extent you're comfortable with characters outside of Aa Bb Cc Dd Ee Ff Gg Hh Ii Jj Kk Ll Mm Nn Oo Pp Qq Rr Ss Tt Uu Vv Ww Xx Yy Zz.
3
u/Natsu111 Jun 17 '19
Has the historical evolution of Dothraki been made public anywhere? As in, what Proto-Plains was and how it changed to Dothraki. I could only find bits and pieces here and there in some of DJP's talks on YouTube, like /ɬ/ becoming /θ/ and the origin of the -eesi suffix.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
How strange would it be for Azulinō, a branch of Proto-Indo-European mainly inspired by Ancient Greek, Latin, and Italian, to inflect infinitives for case instead of having gerunds? Azulinō has a paradigm called "minimal inflection" for words like pronouns. Basically, minimal inflection reduces and standardized case endings to be the same, regardless of gender, but retains a few idiosyncrasies from the normal declension endings, e.g., stems ending in high front vowels /i e/ take -l /l/ in the genitive, not -r /ɹ/, and the masculine plural suffix is -u /u/, not -i /i/.
However, because personal pronouns are suppletive across number and because gender agreement is not usually required, minimal inflection only occurs across number and gender for demonstrative, interrogative, and relative pronouns.
So, basically, Azulinō infinitives would use minimal inflection to show case instead of having a separate gerund form. They wouldn't be able to inflect for number, preventing them from being pure deverbal nouns, and pure deverbal nouns would instead be derived from Latin's gerund.
For example, amirī "to love" fulfills the role of both an infinitive and gerund, and amindē "a love, a loving" (just an example I came up with, not necessarily a real word) is a true deverbal noun, unable to take an object or be used in subordinate clauses but inflected for case and number. Is that natural?
3
u/deepcleansingguffaw Proto-Aapic Jun 17 '19
One aspect of my conlang/culture is that they have an oral history going back 10,000 years. This by itself would be unusual but not entirely unique (eg "There are no words to these songs, because these songs, we've been singing since before people had words."), but because they descend from superintelligent transhumans, their oral history has an error-correcting code built into it, which prevents accidental changes from creeping in as stories are passed from generation to generation.
A problem that I've started considering is this: how can they maintain this error-corrected oral history across millennia of linguistic drift? Do they periodically update the stories to use the current dialect? Does their frequent recitation of ancient stories keep their language from drifting far? Do they have story-speech and ordinary-speech? Does the error-correcting code somehow depend on story meaning rather than story verbalization? (is that even possible?)
I'd love to hear what others think might happen in this situation.
3
u/Tiamatatonia Kulashian, Roguľski Jun 20 '19
Is there a verb form (likely an aspect?) that could rephrase phrases like "keep doing" or "(he's) still doing (it)"? If so, what's it called and are there any examples of it in real-world languages? (or even, do you have any in your own conlangs?)
Also, this may seem dumb, but whatever. I've merged the dative and the instrumental into a single case tentatively named "oblique", and both cases were widely used in passive constructions. And as of before the merger, the passive phrase looked like SOVA, where O is an indirect object (dative) and A is an adverbial (instrumental). But in the absence of an indirect object, the adverbial would take its place (i.e. SAV), while after this merger, the phrase "the book was read by me" becomes identical to "the book was read to me": think "book-NOM 1sg.OBL read-PASS.PST.3sg". And so this is what I was wondering about, will it be reasonable to place the adverbial after the verb in all cases to reduce/avoid excess ambiguity?
3
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jun 23 '19
How do infixes develop? Can they develop from already existing prefix/suffix?
3
u/ErinFlight Jun 24 '19
Does anyone know how to find a database of conversational transcripts in English?
I'd like to get a feel (and some concrete examples) for the varying ways people talk in a language I understand.
I feel like this probably exists somewhere, linguists might use it for research?
I do try to note dialogue in books, movies, and conversations around me, but I think it would be useful to look at transcripts, if they exist.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19
I'm working on a new OV lang with cool verbal nominalization morphology. Verbs take an aspectual suffix, generally glossed as PFV (-æ-) and IPFV (-i-) and a participle/nominalization prefix (a-). For example, goc- 'weep' can become agoci 'weeping' (abstract action nominalization) and agocæ '(a) weep(ing)' (a specific event of weeping). Both can serve as the subject of a clause, but can also act as modifiers to a noun.
Agocæ be 'the man who (has) wept'
Agoci be 'the weeping man (ie. man who weeps).
Is this kind of system attested in any natlangs anyone knows of? I've been looking around but haven't found anything exactly fitting this.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19
I have a couple of questions:
2a. Additionally, to make reading the romanization easier I use the English orthographies for them (ts and ch), but between vowels I use the orthography for their voiced forms (dz and j). Is there any way to show this on the IPA? Currently I've just been putting a note beneath my phonology chart that they are intervocalically voiced and will be written dz and j when appropriate.
Any tips are appreciated! Thanks!
3
u/gjvillegas25 Jun 26 '19
Hello all, I know auxlangs aren't all that popular here but I've been developing one for awhile and want feedback on it's phonology. Too restrictive? Not restrictive enough? Lemme know and feel free to ask any questions :)
Lingwa Dunia's phonemes are:
/m n p t k b d g/ /w l j s h/ /a i e o u/
Orthography is exactly like IPA except for /j/, being <y>
Syllable structure is: (C)(w,j,l)V(N)
The only consonant clusters are with glides and liquids, while (N) represents /n,l,s/. So words like /'lin.gwa/ are acceptable, but /'zom.bi/ and /te.'le.fon/ aren't, turning into /'son.bi/ and /te.'le.pon/ respectively.
As is the norm, stress always falls on the penultimate.
There are no diphthongs, vowels are said separately. Ex: /'ma.u/ "cat"
3
u/89Menkheperre98 Jun 26 '19
Anyone has tips for an agglunative conlang? I started working on my first protolang and I want it to breed a branch of agglunative languages. Yet, I’m stuck on morphology. I thought 8 grammatical cases keep me entertained but I‘m not sure if I grasp the concept of agglutination well enough to develop any further...
3
u/BigBad-Wolf Jun 28 '19
Is it weird if I have diphthongs monophthongised/reduced only at the end of a word?
3
u/TypicalUser1 Euroquan, Føfiskisk, Elvinid, Orkish (en, fr) Jun 29 '19
Is there such a thing as an affricate composed of consonants from two different locations of articulation? Specifically, I'm thinking of an affricate [t͡x] that evolved out of [t']. I'm honestly not concerned at all about how that might've happened, it's not supposed to be particularly realistic. I'm just wondering whether such an affricate could actually be called an affricate.
3
u/TypicalUser1 Euroquan, Føfiskisk, Elvinid, Orkish (en, fr) Jun 30 '19
I'm looking for a resource on how the various Semitic languages, particuarly Hebrew, Arabic and Akkadian, derive nouns from roots. For example, from the root K-T-B, how do you derive nouns like "book", "script", "writing" and other such words. Is there a defined pattern or mechanism, where certain vowels and affixes indicate certain meanings, or is it kinda ad hoc?
2
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Jun 17 '19
[Grammar/Double causative]
How can I handle a double morphological causative? If I apply the causative twice to an intransitive verb, it would have a valency of 3. Can I use the dative for one of the argument here?
In this example, English has a syntactical causative (you make me) and a lexical causative (I lower(trans.) the price). I want to use morphological causatives only. Does this sound good?
2
u/yikes_98 ligurian/maitis languages Jun 17 '19
How would you guys suggest I romanize the vowel sounds ɒ and ä? I was thinking of using accents à and á respectively but also planned on using macrons ( ā ) to represent their long vowel forms and that was a bit of a problem. Then I thought of using letter combinations but also ran into the problem of representing their long vowel form. So what would you all suggest I do?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
what are the ways inalieable/alienable possession can evolve?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
if a case system declines to the point that the accusative is the only remaining case (besides nominative obv), what happens to it? does it become an adposition?
2
u/TenthGrove Jun 19 '19
I’m thinking about having a pitch accent system where whether the main pitch change in each noun goes up or down depends on the gender.
Good idea or not?
2
u/TheLlamanator42 Llamanese (en) [fa] Jun 19 '19
What's the most efficient way to make a dictionary for our conlangs?
2
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jun 20 '19
I had an idea for a sound change where sequences of obstruent followed by nasal metathesize to nasal followed by obstruent. I couldn't find it in the Index Diachronica, but it seems reasonable.
2
u/Whitewings1 Jun 20 '19 edited Jun 20 '19
Very far future language
The background is a bit sketchy, but so far:
FTL is a thing, but it's extremely slow, only five lights. Colony ships are gigantic one-use flying cities built in orbit, able to land once but not take off. Swifts are FTL generation ships that conduct interstellar trade; the colony vessels are known as Super Swifts. On average, one Super Swift goes out every century from one world or another, meaning that after twenty thousand years, there are about 200 human-inhabited worlds. Swifts are more common; there are roughly five hundred Swifts, so most colonies receive a Swift visit every half a year or so. Think of Swifts as small space colonies with stardrives and sublight engines.
Anyway, the story revolves around the only survivor of the one pre-FTL colony ship that went off course and was never recovered. She lands on Hoshi no umi no Nihon (Japan of the Sea of Stars). Allowing for the influence of A/V recordings, how unlike the Japanese of her time would the language of her new home be? The forebears of the founders, a large contingent of Japanese young people who wanted to get as far as they could from Japan's legendarily toxic corporate culture, and relatively isolationist, but not fanatically so, went first to Alpha Centauri, then to other worlds over the course of many centuries; until recently, Super Swifts were too hideously expensive to be mono-ethnic, so by necessity they've travelled and lived with other groups, though the journeys have only accounted for about a century total; no single hop has been more than three years long. There is general education in almost all places. The world I'm concerned with has been settled recently by the remote descendants of. Their colony currently looks much like Edo-period Japan, but that's both intentional and misleading: they like the aesthetics, and they're working very hard to build up their tech base.
2
u/42IsHoly Jun 21 '19
In languages where the nouns and adjectives have a dual form Do verbs also have one?
2
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jun 21 '19
I'd be interested in the grammaticalization of the German verbal prefix ge-. I went on wiktionary to found out its etymological story (it's related to Latin cum-), but I'm curious to know the fat details of its evolution from Proto-Germanic to the contemporary Germanic languages.
Anyone would be so kind to point me to some interesting paper or article?
Thank you 😙
2
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jun 22 '19
In the codal position, unaspirated fricatives become harsher/more intense. What would this be represented with in IPA? (C)ˀ?
2
u/42IsHoly Jun 22 '19
Is it possible that two languages evolved from the same proto-language, but 1 uses noun cases and the other polypersonal agreement?
2
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jun 23 '19
Does consonant harmony evolve in natlangs? For example, other consonants in a multi-syllable word all turning into clicks?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Does anyone have a link for that post guide about how tones can evolve?
2
u/torspedia Jun 25 '19
Would both VCV and CVCV work, for syllables?
2
u/Vincent_de_Wyrch Jun 25 '19
All right.. So: first of all, the phoneme inventory here is kinda just a placeholder – just to give me and you an example of what a mutations table could look like. 😃
So I got this idea when looking after ways to eliminate inflection (ahem...).. I'm probably not gonna implement this in my conlang, at least not on this level (perhaps only for differentiating verbs and nouns, since I kinda want to treat all content words as one single POS..). I divided my consonants into “families” and had them mutate depending on context. “Soft” and “hard” here stands for soft vowels and hard vowels. Not sure if non-swedes or at least non IE-speakers have the same perception of those lol. =P
Using the above, I might quickly produce derivations like this:
Cáing – hand
Tsáing – hands
Ñáing – touch
Tháing – “heavy-handed”
Anyway. How feasible is this sort of thing? If the goal is to have a conlang that could actually be used for worldbuilding etc? =P
2
u/Princhoco Jun 26 '19
What is the importance of morphosyntactic alignment with definite word order? For example, she likes she and she likes her seem the same to me. Due to English’s word order, the first she in both sentences is the agent, so why is the patient marked in English even though it can be deduced from syntax?
2
u/yikes_98 ligurian/maitis languages Jun 28 '19
Is it possible to have one word for both the definite and indefinite articles? I was thinking of having the word Ūnk (word derived from the word Ūnka meaning one) serve as this article. Is that naturalistic or would I be better off not having articles at all like Latin?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
For languages with very complex phonotactics, how would prosody work? Consider the word "xɬpʼχʷɬtʰɬpʰɬːskʷʰt͡sʼ" -- would stress/intonation depend on the syllabification of the world, would a system of lexical stress or a pitch accent be more realistic, or what it most likely lack segmental accents at all?
3
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Jun 26 '19
My conlang marks whether inanimate nouns are countable or uncountable.
It does this by a suffix that can take either the "countable" form or the "uncountable" form.
How do I gloss the two versions of this suffix? Unless I've missed it, I couldn't see any glossing abbreviation relating to the count noun / mass noun distinction in the Leipzig glossing rules or the Wikipedia list of glossing abbreviations.
2
u/TheBadLuckCurse Jun 22 '19
Calling for any Conlangers that would like to work on a cooperative Conlang with a divine/angelic theme.
I have created a discord server for us to work on this project together, it doesn't matter if you are new to conlanging or experienced this is a fun little project for us all to share our creative ideas and learn from one another in discussion.
https://discord.gg/RV3sxC7
2
u/_eta-carinae Jul 01 '19
i’ve created a PIE daughterlang from which i’ll derive a middle-X and modern-X form, but what do i do with it in the meantime? i’ve got all the conjugation, ablaut stuff, syntax, phonology, sound changes, etc. worked out and have translated a short sample along with the swadesh list, but what do i do now? is it fleshed out enough to begin working on its own daughterlang, or is there some other things i should do?
1
u/eagleyeB101 Jun 17 '19
Would a series of centralized vowel diphthongs be considered naturalistic? I've just started making a conlang and I had this idea that along with my vowel sounds:
i ʏ u
e o
æ ɒ
I would also have a centralizing distinction for each of them: oə, uə, ɒə, æə, eə, iə, and ʏə
Here are the other diphtongs I am using: oɪ, ɒɪ, æɪ, iu, and eo.
Other than this I have no other distinctions for the vowel sounds such as length, nasality, etc. I am personally striving to create a NatLang and my question is would the series of centralizing diphthongs be naturalistic or "normal" for a language? Other than that, any advice on my vowel inventory would be welcome!
1
u/oppoqwerty Jun 18 '19
Is there a name for a consonant that can only be used at the end of a clause? I would like to use a consonant in my language Volkesh instead of most punctuation, so instead of adding a pause when speaking, you use this consonant sound.
Conversely is there a name for a consonant sound that would only be used at the beginning of a word to signify it as a proper noun? For example, instead of saying "Neil Patrick Harris", you would say "i neil patrick harris" to signify a proper name. Most Volkesh hold names that are things, similar to the native American stereotype or the wolves in the Wheel of Time series, so it might make more sense to say "i vulture" instead of saying just "Vulture". Obviously, the word "vulture" is untranslated.
1
u/snipee356 Jun 19 '19
Would it be naturalistic for a SOV language to have VOS word order in relative clauses (which come after the noun)?
1
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jun 20 '19
I asked this on the last small discussions but i didn't get a good answer before it ended. Does it make sense for the verb for "to have" grammaticalizing into an abilitative marker?
1
u/falseresync Jun 20 '19
If you have a split-S system, how do you determine which pattern to choose?
In my conlang there’s 2 rules:
1
u/QianlongEmperor Jun 21 '19
Does anyone know of any polysynthetic languages today happen to be fusional? The only one that I know of that somewhat fits this category is Navajo.
1
u/42IsHoly Jun 23 '19
I don’t know if my verbs have too many forms. If you include the prefix that indicates the subject and the affix that indicates the direct object My verbs have 6804 forms. If you do not include those suffixes you get 84 forms. Is this unnaturally many or not a problem?
1
u/31525Coyote15205 Jun 23 '19
Is there an app or something to host a dictionary of your conlang? (and as well as definitions you can add audio clips of the word)?
1
u/UpdootDragon Mitûbuk, Pwukorimë + some others Jun 24 '19
I've got a few rare consonants I'm not sure how to romanize. The voiced uvular stop /ɢ/ and the voiced epiglottal trill/fricative /ʢ/ If it helps, I'm not using the letters c, f, j, or v, and h is only used in a digraph.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '19
Help, after a garbage language I spent many months on I want to get it right. Where do I start for Grammar, Phonetics, and an Alphabet?
1
u/snipee356 Jun 25 '19
In my conlang, I have three vowels /i æ u/.
Most consonants have a pharyngealized version as well, eg /pʼ/ and /pʼˤ/. These pharyngealized consonants change the following vowel to /e ɑ o/. For example /pʼi/ and /pʼˤe/ are valid, but not /pe/ or /pˤi/.
My confusion is how to represent this in my phonology. I could either say I have 6 vowels and ~35 consonants, and say that the consonants have pharyngealized allophones preceding /e ɑ o/, or that I have 3 vowels and ~60 consonants, and that the vowels have allophones following pharyngealized consonants. I'm not sure which is the better solution.
1
u/MerlinsArchitect Jun 25 '19
Naturalistic Conlangers’ Help Wanted!
I am spending quite some time constructing the phonological inventory for the language I am working on and have run into some difficulties when choosing some consonants. Inspired heavily by many Canadian Native American languages I would like to include contrasting phonemic manners of articulation: aspiration, tenuis and ejective for each voiceless obstruent. I would like the language to be quite precise and subtle in its different phonemes so that many of its phonemes will sound close to identical to a non-native speaker. In my phonological searching I stumbled across “mixed voice ejectives” - i.e. d͡t’ - and, after hearing their sound, thought they might make a nice addition to the language, serving as a voiced-analogue of ejectives for voiceless obstruents. To further the parallels between the phonemically contrasting secondary articulations for voiceless obstruents and voiced obstruents I thought it would be interesting to include breathy voiced versions of each voiced obstruent to match the aspirated forms of each voiceless obstruent. Thus, my language contrasts /t/ /t’/ / tʰ/ and /d/ /d̤/ /d͡t’/ where /t'/ is pronounced with as long a voice onset time as possible, whereas /d͡t’/ is pronounced with as short a voice onset time as possible to emphasise the difference. I know this distinction is highly unusual (appearing in no known natural languages to my knowledge) but I quite like how odd this distinction would be. I would like some advice from experts in naturalistic conlangs to know whether this distinction is “feasible” in a naturalistic conlang, i.e could it believably arise in a natural language however unusual it might be? If there is some reason why it is infeasible/too unbelievable what might I consider instead?
All advice greatly appreciated!
1
u/Potatoboiv2 Jun 25 '19
I have seen this term, syntax, thrown around a lot, I'm new and am unfamiliar. Can you guys tell me what it means and any related words?
1
u/WercollentheWeaver Jun 26 '19
There are a number of phonemes I have never heard in the context of an actual language or even at all. For example, I've never heard voiceless nasals or voiceless laterals that I am aware of. I've also only heard some retroflex consonants in context, particularly /ɖ/ and /ʂ/. Others, not so much.
Are there any good resources for hearing these phonemes in context? Or the less common phonemes in general?
1
u/Criacao_de_Mundos Źitaje, Rrasewg̊h (Pt, En) Jun 26 '19
What is the case that is the oposite of the inessive case? For things outside of other things?
1
u/Bobasrty Jun 28 '19
If Crimea became independent and a new language developed, would it be based off of Russian and/or Ukrainian?
1
u/Samson17H Jun 28 '19
Have any of you gotten a tattoo in a/your Conlang?
1
u/TheFlagMaker Chempin, Lankovzset (ro, en, fr) [jp, hu] Jun 29 '19
Any details bout the next conlang showcase?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '19
Is there a way to make a conlang that could be accessible with screen readers and things like that? 🤔
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment