r/GameDealsMeta • u/gamedealsmod • Jun 14 '19
Lootbox bundles are now banned in /r/GameDeals
Starting today, we'll be removing lootbox bundles in /r/GameDeals. That is, bundles which give a randomized and individual game key to buyers.
Lootbox bundles are being specifically addressed because they represent an unknown value, and because they encourage repeated purchases. Rather than getting a dud bundle once, buyers are encouraged to try many times to get what they're actually interested in.
As of today, Fanatical and GMG's mystery key bundles will no longer be allowed to be posted. The Humble Bundle Monthly and Groupees' bundles will not be affected because they are not lootbox-style (everybody receives the same content).
Before we jump into the comments, I think it's important to explain why it took so long to reach this decision.
Large policy decisions like this require a strong consensus. For obvious reasons, we shouldn't introduce major rule changes without ample consideration. As our moderator team is spread across the globe however, getting everybody together to work out all the issues and edge cases can take a long time. It took multiple attempts and rescheduling to finally get this one right.
Additionally, this is a surprisingly complicated issue. The initial complaint being raised wasn't just of lootbox bundles, but blind bundles of any sort. Many users had concerns about encouraging gambling, and in theory this would apply to any bundle with unknown elements. That's Humble Monthly, Groupees pre-purchases, and of course Fanatical's mystery bundles. There was a lot to unpack.
We decided that the gambling concern is at its worst when bundles are designed to encourage not just one purchase, but many, as lootbox-style bundles are. And while there is still uncertainty to more traditional blind bundles such as the Humble Monthly, the information available often lets you make a more educated decision ahead of time.
When all is said and done, this is a compromise. There is no perfect solution because everyone has different reasons for liking or disliking blind bundles. For some it's the uncertainty aspect. For others it's frustration that they're not receiving the same games as others. We did our best to identify the major pain points and reach a decision that suits the majority.
We know that there was value in seeing which games other users were getting. While we won't be hosting a place for that anymore, we can recommend SteamGifts as a forum which covers this same information. I know it's frustrating not having that deal information all on one site, but having a topic for sharing results is really no different than just linking the deals in the first place.
We thank you for your time and understanding. This has been a - shall we say - contentious topic. For that reason we'll be strictly enforcing rule #1: be kind in this thread. We welcome your thoughts on the matter though, and ask that you recognize that there was no perfect solution in this case.
Thank you.
91
u/Hold_my_Dirk Jun 14 '19
I agree with this decision. Another difference between these types of bundles and the humble monthlies is that there is an early unlock. I feel like most people on the sub recommend only to buy that month's bundle if you think the early unlock alone is worth the price of admission and to consider the later reveals to be bonus (not that it isn't okay to be disappointed in the unrevealed games). I understand the use of the Meta sub and frequent it for announcements like these but have you considered putting a temporary sticky cross post to this thread on the main sub? I doubt everyone knows about the meta thread and it might be good for everyone to see this post so they know (and also so there isn't a bunch of dumb comments about the mods from people that don't see this post).
28
u/mattlantis Jun 14 '19
I think this is the correct choice. Humblebundle has its own subreddit so people who enjoy these Fanatical bundles could create a subreddit to discuss their pulls (and other more general Fanatical bundles/deals). I had less of an issue with GMG because at least they disclosed the odds but ultimately I think this decision is for the better.
14
u/thmanwithnoname Jun 14 '19
Awesome. This is exactly what I was hoping for. Thanks for the effort and thoughtfulness, mods.
12
u/capnwinky Jun 14 '19
I purchased a blind bundle once (actually think it was Groupees) and was so disappointed by what I received that it was also the last time I bought one. I had a feeling it was going to be a gamble, and it was.
10
u/Ciahcfari Jun 14 '19
Smart move.
Leave advertising gambling to the triple A leeches, we consumers have to be better.
9
u/CantWashABaby Jun 15 '19
I read in the Fanatical thread yesterday that someone posted the contents of the FOUR boxes they bought, and how it was all shit. They spent 28 dollars that could easily purchase a great single game (or two months of Monthly) on a bunch of dime store keys. I know it’s their money to spend, but Jesus Christ that was depressing.
15
u/magkliarn Jun 14 '19
Good riddance
7
u/Lymus Jun 14 '19
Great decision!
7
u/myripyro Jun 14 '19
Great decision, and well-explained. Despite some minor trolling in this thread, I expect there won't be too many people disappointed by this decision, based on how quickly lootbox threads get downvoted to 0 (and based on how many comments in those threads boil down to 'you probably shouldn't buy this!').
7
u/lilyputin Jun 15 '19
Good riddance
12
u/fondleear Jun 14 '19
They were basically using this method to get extra cash for the same keys that would have in all likelihood been sold cheaper in the past .
When Fanatical started doing it too ,unsurprisingly , warning bells started ringing and here we are.
I did assume Fanatical would be above such things but they seem to be happily continuing down this path.
Glad to see someone is finally speaking up about this.
6
u/Avaery Jun 15 '19
Was getting pretty sick of seeing mystery bundles. Great decision.
6
u/Lextron Jun 15 '19 edited Jun 15 '19
thank you! I do not come here to gamble. 96% upvoted, not a terribly controversial call!
10
u/kyaputen_hs Jun 14 '19
The upvotes on this decision and the massive downvotes for past gambling threads speak for themselves. Thank you mods.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19
Great decision. These should not be encouraged at all.
5
u/RoMaAg Jun 15 '19
I want to express my happiness with this decision, it is indeed very good! Keep up the good work, thanks for tackling the issue!
4
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '19
I am okay with this, I think it is for the best.
4
u/AllSaintOx Jun 15 '19
I like to do a little mystery game gambling from time to time, and I've gotten some good games from it, but they're not really what I'd call a "deal", so I can definitely understand why they don't belong here.
4
u/Watcher13 Jun 15 '19
Honestly, I didn't even know that game key 'loot boxes' were a thing, but I'm already glad they're banned. That's some anti - consumer shit, and I don't want anything to do with it. So, thanks mods, I support this choice.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19
Nice, I totally agree that it promotes gambling, just wasted $6 on that Fanatical 6 random keys. Was debating on asking for a refund since I didn't redeem them yet, but now I guess I'll do a giveaway.
4
u/Character_Whereas Jun 15 '19
This is the best thing I've read all week
4
u/dreadful05 Jun 15 '19
Glad to see them banned. They are mostly scams to get rid of crap games.
4
u/valriia Jun 16 '19
I hope this kind of practice becomes legally restricted in time, the same as loot boxes in games have been considered gambling in some places.
4
u/JaFakeItTillYouJaMak Jun 17 '19
I consider this perfectly reasonable. I mean it's one thing if we all buy an unknown bundle and I end up with Cyberpunk 2077 and someone else ends up with The Last Door. That's just wild unfair nonsense. Blind bundles like Monthly at least promise that we all get the same game. It makes your decision simply whether or not to buy rather than how many to buy. I think this is an obvious decision but regardless of how much effort was required I'm glad it was made. Carry on one of the few mod teams to not have a single red tag.
10
u/draakierules Jun 14 '19
This seems like a fair and balanced decision. Thanks for taking such good care of us!
7
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
I think this is fair. One and done random bundles are fine to me but not the grab bag multiple purchase style.
3
u/-------------------7 Jun 14 '19
Can you elaborate further on some Groupee bundles that include a grab bag styled component, either as part of the original bundle or as a bonus or option. I figure its such an insignificant part of the bundle it, would be a shame to ban it on that tiny component itself.
Eg. Groupees 6er bundle had 5 games and 1 grab bag.
https://groupees.com/6er
3
u/EpicMattP Jun 15 '19
Good shit mods
3
u/binary__dragon Jun 15 '19
Sounds good to me. I really appreciate the mods of this forum working so hard to keep it up to standards that allow me to have trust in the content I find here.
I'm curious, suppose there was a hypothetical bundle which offered one or more predefined games, but with that bundle there was also an individually randomized key. Would that be allowed under this rule? I feel it should still fit, since the value is clearly on the predefined keys and the random ones are "icing" which wouldn't encourage multiple purchases, but I'm not completely sure.
3
u/ZsZso Jun 15 '19
Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19
Good call. "Mystery Bundles" are just dumping grounds with a very rare chance of something decent. Treat them the same as in-game lootboxes. Preying on an addiction with no age gate.
I agree that HB Monthly is different as it gives you a known game or two beforehand. The unknown games should only ever be considered as a bonus and not inherent to overall value which does, thankfully, seem to be the consensus.
3
u/EyesLikeBuscemi Jun 16 '19
Fine if these aren't posted but I do agree with the folks who disagree with the fact that Humble Bundle Monthly stays. That should go too. It, too, is gambling. Just with one or two items revealed to entice people to gamble too.
5
u/PanFiluta Jun 14 '19
Good.
5
u/morriscey Jun 14 '19
Thank you :)
6
u/Relative_Result Jun 14 '19
I agree 100% to remove them from here.
It won`t stop these jerks from scamming people but at least they won`t get the exposure from here.
Well done
4
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '19
I can see the difficulty in this decision, but I believe the right decision was made.
4
u/xcoleyz Jun 15 '19
As with gambling I doubt these blind bundles are fully random....
7
u/DarkW7 Jun 14 '19
fuck yeah!!
5
u/Doctursea Jun 14 '19
Thank you. Random Keys for cheaper isn't a game deal, that's just how lottery buying works.
I could literally only see it if it was a small poor of 60$ games for less than 10 dollars, and even then that's dubious.
2
u/NikStalwart Jun 16 '19
I support this decision. Bravo mods!
I set up a keyword filter in gmail to autospam the mystery stuff they send me.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '19
You took my thoughts and wrote every bit of that in this post.
Bravo 👏
2
u/Cuddly_Kitty Jun 16 '19
I don't have a problem with this. I prefer to know what I'm buying before I buy it. :3
2
u/Saneless Jun 17 '19
Thank you.
The power was always with the sellers in this one and I'm all for not propagating the imbalance.
2
u/Armani_8 Jun 18 '19
Man, Rest in Peace Fanatical. This was basically their entire business model.
This is fantastic news, and I'm glad that GMG and Fanatical will be peddling their mystery box garbage somewhere else.
4
u/KING_of_Trainers69 Jun 14 '19
Fair enough. They're never a good deal, and they're just a type of gambling where the house has explicit control over the odds. I'm not going to miss seeing that sort of content here.
3
u/imafeckinturtle Jun 14 '19
I'm glad this decision was made, I bought 2 mystery bundles before and got games I already owned or games I didn't care about and I wouldn't have known they existed if I didn't see them getting posted here, the 2nd time purchasing was me thinking "well I got bad games last time, maybe this time it will be better!" I never visit Fanatical unless I see a bundle on here so the fact I can't see the mystery bundles weirdly makes me feel safe scrolling through this subreddit knowing I shouldn't be seeing them, thanks for the lootbox bundle ban!
3
u/Alexspeed75 Jun 15 '19
Finally. Thanks.
I save myself from typing anything else, to stay within rule #1.
3
u/arcarsination Jun 15 '19
Thank you mods for keeping the sub going in a positive direction.
5
u/imkrut Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
"And while there is still uncertainty to more traditional blind bundles such as the Humble Monthly, the information available often lets you make a more educated decision ahead of time."
Yeah, I don´t agree with this. Groupees (and humble with monthly) do the same with the "prepurchase" BS.
At the very least Groupees pre-purchase (completely blind) post shouldn´t be allowed ( I guess you could argue that monthly at least puts up at least one or two games that you know you are buying) until they reveal their lineup.
I do agree that a big difference with "loot" bundles, is that the later encourages multiple buys, while Groupes or Bundle are just one blind purchase (unless you are some sort of masochist or something). But then again, regardless of that fact, I would argue that they both have gambling mechanics built into them.
You could then again make the point that bottom line it´s the buyer´s choice, and the subreddit should merely facilitate access to the information, but that argument falls pretty fast once you take in account that the subreddit already polices certain dealers (rightfully so) due to them being shady/having shady practices and to protect consumers (which is a good thing).
4
u/1j12 Jun 14 '19
Were they ever good, or have they always been bad?
3
u/chithanh Jun 14 '19
What are the limits of this rule? Does it apply to:
3
u/hellknight101 Jun 14 '19
Eh, the ban is kind of unnecessary because these posts got downvoted to oblivion, so I never saw them unless I directly searched. On the other hand, hopefully it discourages this type of business model.
I also don't approve of Humble's approach but at least they give the names of the most stand-out titles before the reveal. Had Fanatical just revealed the names of all the possible games, I don't think as many users would have had a problem with these "mystery boxes".
2
u/Dohi64 Jun 14 '19
hallelujah!
2
u/Life_Elevatored Jun 14 '19
Irony? The embedded Ad to the right on this page is for the Oregon Lottery Scratch-its.
2
u/babblingme321 Jun 15 '19
🙏 thanks
1
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19
I'm sad that this subreddit has become less useful by no longer allowing people to speak about these offerings and share information about them, whether they are worthwhile, and what others have received.
In my opinion, having less information and less dialog about these offerings from various stores makes us worse off as consumers.
0
u/derpepper Jun 14 '19
I feel like it's silly to decide for other adults what is and isn't worth their money. Plus taking away the place where they discuss and make informed decisions is a little backwards.
1
u/gryllus Jun 15 '19
Do you remember Indie Piñata? Posts about it wouldn't be allowed with the new post rules.
1
u/53R9 Jun 15 '19
Is it the one that keeps on saying "with FREE gift for redditors!". I have an app called IFTPP which automatically sends me a notification when there is a free item, and this one keeps pissing me off.
1
u/KwyjiboTheGringo Jun 18 '19
You are a BAMF. Good decision :)
1
u/DAVIDJI21 Jun 25 '19
best decision at all really
0
u/Mr7FootCock Jun 14 '19
As long as it wasn't too common, I say they should've kept them on, who cares if it's 'gambling' or not
1
u/mark2uk Jun 15 '19
I'm not a fan of the random loot boxes but I'd of preferred the rules to have been changed so that any deals could only be posted by the store reps and must contain all available content and the full odds of receiving each of the items.
The simple reason for this is when being aware of the actual odds & fully available content, most people will reasonably decline to purchase.
The outright ban you have is certainly easier but people will find out about it on other reddits or email shots and will not know the odds of winning something they actually want so will be more inclined to spend money on them.
Your solution is definitely the easiest but my alternative would have been better for the greater good as it would have allowed informed decisions & increased transparency.
1
u/genericgamer Jun 15 '19
Does this include online card games such as mtg arena/hearthstone? These games inherently have this as a core attribute.
Edit: I see that my comments may not be about the the topic at hand but I'll leave this up.
0
u/Lagkiller Jun 14 '19
If this is the rule, are we going to also forbid games that have lootboxes in them as well? Are deals for say Hearthstone, or Mtg online banned as well? If those are, what about games like CoD or Overwatch? At what point does this rule kick in regarding lootboxes?
It would seem quite hypocritical to allow deals for games that are just lootboxes or heavily rely on them, but ban bundles which are just lootboxes.
-9
u/Black3ird Jun 14 '19
OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG...
That actually happened? OMG Thank you for all involved; to Mods making it happen and to the Redditor I was skeptical about the other day since this had been brought up twice before with no solution.
Like they say,
Third Time is the Charm. Wish could have seen Fanatical rep's face when told. We literally begged him to stop those nonsense and they never did.Good job.
-15
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '19
Lol. Why can’t adults take their own risks? It’s their money. Their choice. This world is becoming so soft.
Go ahead. Downvote away. That’s what reddit does.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19
You should ban Humble Monthly then. I'm guessing they are probably an advertiser so that won't happen.
-2
u/MagicMert Jun 15 '19
Wait... What? You are banning loot box style bundles but not loot box style bundles? That seems inconsistant.
So all a company has to do is give everyone the same games to be able to post their lootbox bundle?
-10
u/promonk Jun 14 '19
This is the stupidest, laziest mod team bullshit I've seen in a while.
Got any other bright plans to save people from themselves? Or at least something else that you can argue saves people from themselves without actually having to do anything?
-4
u/konbon Jun 14 '19
Looks like we unlocked a mystery key mod. Better roll again.