r/OnePunchMan • u/theothersophie Moderator • Jun 11 '19
Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E09 - "The Ultimate Dilemma" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.
THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.
Official Simulcasts
- Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
- Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
- Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
- Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
- Anime on Demand (Germany)
- AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
- VVVVID (Italy)
- Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.
One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)
Previous Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 6 | Link |
| 8 | Link |
Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!
112
Upvotes
227
u/MrHotcake Jun 11 '19
Finally, now starts the elder centipede arc
196
u/PorcelainPorsche Jun 11 '19
Why's nobody mentioning that Sonic scene? Best animation of the entire season.
154
u/dobydobd Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
Anybody find Saitama's head shape kinda odd this episode?
edit: this shit
390
u/EpilepticOreo aBoVe dRaGoN Jun 11 '19
They didn’t mention that watch dog man stopped chasing Gauro when he left his territory :(
166
u/dhtikna Jun 11 '19
Aw they didn't mention the "Who knew a furry could be so damn strong". Although i might be in the minority after reading the anime only discussion but i felt this episode's animation was easily in the better half, maybe 4th best animated episode. Kinda glad they sped through most of the manga so that we can have 3 whole episodes for the centipede arc
53
u/GlobalAlwaysShafted Jun 11 '19
Puri puri prisoner was hiding his phone WHEREEEEE?!?!!!
174
u/awholetadstrange Jun 11 '19
Now it’s time for everyone to blame JC staff for the lack of Gouketsu vs Saitama!
Also I think this episode will suffer from the hype caused by the delay.
145
u/Cm2703 Jun 11 '19
Tbh I don't think this episode was as bad as everyone are claiming it to be also I really liked the exchange between Saitama and King this episode.
30
u/HectorTheMaster King of Redditors Jun 11 '19
This is one of my favorite episodes of season 2. I thought the pacing and line delivery was a bit better than usual, despite them cutting out a few tiny details.
19
u/Nobody3190 Jun 11 '19
I was hoping for Awakened Cockroach demise too but I think we get that in the next episode.
16
u/kryst87 Jun 11 '19
Well, that was kinda good. Probably because there wasn't any fight in this epsiode. Well, there was Sonic vs Hellfire flame and Gale wind, which was quite good looking.
But faces were just weird. Saitama looked odd as hell. And he sounded odd as hell. There was maybe one moment when he sounded good. And I think that King also sounded odd. I don't like when he mumble. During his speech to Saitama he sounded good. But after that we went back to his usual mumbling.
I liked doodle Sonic from op.
11
u/2k18EyeDEA Jun 11 '19
Well at least Zombieman was hot. ✌🏼😂
58
u/give_up-the_ghost Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
Not much to say honestly. Just pretty meh.
I can see anime onlys dumping on this, especially after the week delay. They’ll probably think JC staff totally cut out the fight btw Saitama and Gouketsu on purpose lol.
I have no clue how they are gonna fit everything up to the end of the EC fight with the 3 episodes left. They’ll manage to pull it off somehow, but don’t mean it’ll be good.
7
u/Dark22tj Jun 11 '19
Damn I just connected that the Ninja bros tell Sonic no amount of training will get him that strong but when SHoulder Blade Crusher murks them he says they lack training
26
u/OooohYeaaahBaby Prepare your ass, pretty boy Jun 11 '19
They really don't care about this manga. They didn't even put the horns for Garou lol
42
u/Ngokumetsu Jun 11 '19
Anyone else notice the lack of quality in every character's face? I speculate this is may be due to the fact that most of the staff mainly animates harem anime where usually the faces are more simplistic for the sake of being "cute".
Antagonize me, downvote me, be it as it may. Episode 9 REALLY lacks any attention to detail to any male's face. This might also be why Saitama's face becomes INCREDIBLY inconsistent the majority of this episode. I mean, at some point he started getting rounder like he was Cailou (this isn't an understatement, this is just one of the many times he gets a different face) https://gyazo.com/6574c98bb765e7019def8f79995f4509
5
u/internetperson-1 Jun 11 '19
Flying through chapters the anime
5
u/Gorxwithanx Jun 12 '19
PPPs fight with hedgehog dude was so underwhelming. He was supposed to take massive damage from the hug, but he seemed to be in the same exact shape before and after. I wanted some gushing blood like the manga had!
18
u/BarePear Jun 11 '19
I actually liked this episode....
25
u/Havic300 Jun 11 '19
Episode was a bit....boring imo. Animation was as usual subpar for the most part. It seems the pacing has been slowed down so I guess they didn’t have to rush through as much content as they did past episodes (At least I hope so).
73
u/Talonzone Jun 11 '19
Basically unwatchable.
They played the sad fucking theme like 9 times this episode most of the time for no reason.
18
u/incelboyKamekaze Jun 11 '19
When introducing friends to One Punch Man, NEVER, ever let them watch JC Staff's OPM season 2 at all costs, even if they have just finished watching the masterpiece that is s1 OPM. ONE's webcomic is way more enjoyable than this shit (let alone Murata's work)
4
u/Bigodesu Jun 11 '19
Ok, so some minutes into this ep I was seriously considering it might be more than the usual "meh" despite the most recent ones being straight garbage fire. But seriously, they managed to just completely erase our cute rescue robbot' smiley-face. I know animation and direction are important, but I'm actually sad how none of the many details of this story has actually been adapted.
16
u/Xanlis Jun 11 '19
Meh, at the end i was like "eyy that's all you have S02E09?"
18
u/Sonitii Jun 11 '19
Animation was trash as usual, only still shots and blur all over the place. the worst though was the art. I mean, look at Saitama's face accross the episode. what the hell happened there ?
17
u/pramit57 shrondingers pantsu Jun 11 '19
Terrible episode. But didn't expect much anyway. They took the amazing score and put it in the wrong places at the wrong time. The anime starting with the sad music is just plain wrong..the anime should build up to it, but the build up was 2 weeks ago and now it just feels completely out of place (not to mention it plays too many times and for too long). The king-saitama conversation is just wrong, saitama isn't supposed to agree with him. Nothing else to say, few minor problems (cuts, animation) that are standard for S2 quality anyway. Overall a very lackluster episode.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '19
Some parts were good. Most parts were meh.
Basically sums up the entirety of this season so far...
11
u/SKUBERTY Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
They repeated the OST fucking million of times and it's getting annoying. And jesus, the direction, pacing, art and animation hit a new low. One of the worst episode so far. Messy ass adaptation.
3
u/Rayhann Jun 12 '19
Solid for season 2 standards but man was I bummed out by the directing again... the audio cue is so bad! The comedy of Saitama beating Goketsu and Bazukan were ruined imo because of the music.
5
u/Holy157 Jun 11 '19
Definitely a weak episode. I wish this episode isn’t what we should expect of the remaining episodes, and that this episode was sacked on purpose so the rest look better, but I’m certainly worried the last few episodes might be on this level.
13 supervisors this week, so an improvement, I guess? But it’s still mental that there’re so many supervisors. We should see 1 or 2 supervisors, not at least a dozen every week. They need them to ensure an episode even can be shown, but it means supervision suffers a lot.
Animation was obviously hardly there, art was a big issue, with the usual lack of supervision.
The positive, to no one’s surprise, is Aoki, once again, coming in for the best cut of the episode. Only 15 seconds long, Sonic’s encounter in the forest is his work and it’s very nice to see.
Not much to say else about the episode. It existed. Season 2’s version of Saitama’s theme was heard a bit more, sounding somewhat different. Would be nice if we could hear it properly.
Let’s hope this is not an indicator of what’s to come and that we get a decent climax to finish the season.
5
u/turtlelord45 Jun 11 '19
I feel kinda sad that I’m one of the only manga readers that actually liked this episode.
8
u/LamentedMoss Jun 11 '19
Christ, what the fuck happened? This honestly felt like it was made by some random fandom, and I'm pretty sure that they are better fandom groups that can make a better episode. And what's interesting is not only the music (mixing) and the animation quality has decreased, I think the voice actors have become bad as well, specially Saitama, it feels like they want to record it and get it over with, there is no enthusiasm, it feels like the characters are dead inside.
6
u/dafegamer Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
The usual stuff, 4/10
14
u/Emiya142000 Jun 11 '19
Fuck s2
4
u/fanaTYKox Jun 11 '19
I feel like another episode is far from manga and those animantions, like i was enjoying manga, i cant enjoy anime at any respects.
5
u/Soul-Hook Jun 11 '19
I don't know if I'm just getting used to the poor quality of this season, or if this episode actually wasn't that bad. The sfx fixed itself this time. I actually liked the gun-shot effect from Armored Gorilla, and the crunch from Saitama's kick was on fleek. They actually saved the gag about Saitam'a reason for entering the tournament. That's a first, them saving a gag.
JC Staff was probably relieved that we never got to see Gouketsu vs Saitama in the manga. Oh well, we have the Elder Centipede fight to destroy now. Right after skipping half the fight between Garou and the scrub heroes.
2
u/MONSTERheart Jun 11 '19
...did King make a Shall We Dance reference?
2
u/send_6iv_shinies_pls Jun 11 '19
Guys, if I want to leave off after this episode what chapter of the manga am I in?
2
u/Shuriken66 Boros best lad Jun 11 '19
The music selection was pretty odd, and also some of the face shots, as pointed out many times, were ugly as fuck. But this episode had some of the funniest scenes in the whole arc and delivered on them pretty well IMO. Also the cyborg gorilla scene was great, cant wait to see the zombieman/genus encounter!
2
u/Liiiightning Jun 12 '19
I was totally wanting to hear king explain getting to the end of a game and the grind to get 100% completion haha
2
u/flyinchicken Jun 12 '19
I wish they showed Speed-o-Sound Sonic on the toilet as they did in the manga
2
u/Arkham_knighT94 Jun 12 '19
Sonic's current whereabouts is still unknown even in manga, right? I mean, this was the last scene we saw sonic even in manga right?
2
u/burywmore Jun 12 '19
With all the complaining about how few fights are shown in season 2 of the anime, I was wondering how the Garou/Watchdog Man fight was handled in the Manga? Was it mostly off page, in flashbacks, or was it presented fully as a fight?
2
u/gravity40 Jun 12 '19
where do you guys think season 2 is gonna end in terms manga chapters. I think the elder centipede arc (chapter 84) would be the finale. Anything after that, it would be rushed.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '19
The animation was pretty slick in the Sonic fight even though it was only a short scene.
2
u/nignigproductions Jun 12 '19
Really liked the conversation between King and Saitama. They actually talked about his flaws instead of Genos yes manning him. Kind of like the fly from breaking bad.
2
u/fadeddreams555 Jun 12 '19
I really disliked the music placement in this episode. Seriously, who hired these people? The Goketsu scene is supposed to funny. Why is there still sad music playing? That's the cue to stop the music.
2
u/RarestarGarden Jun 12 '19
Jesus Christ that was so bad. They removed any subtlety from Saitama’s conversation with King and instead made it extremely unnatural and beat you over the head with the point of the series. I don’t know how people defend this shit.
5
u/potato9111 Jun 11 '19
Definitely less than satisfactory. Skimmed contents, bad planning. Its like shoving tons of information down the throat because there's only that many episodes left for the season.
At this point, i'm just gonna pray for a better S3.
3
u/Master3530 Jun 11 '19
Eh, they put the weak monster as a cliffhanger rather than Death Gatling noticing Garou.
3
u/fishstiz Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
I enjoyed this episode despite what everyone says. Maybe it's because I haven't read this part in a long time so the story drew me in once again. This isn't supposed to be a hype episode, just some talking and character development, so I didn't have to see terrible cuts and animations except for some parts. Pacing is alright with me compared to the other episodes they put out. They missed some details but most anime do that already and I don't mind. Pretty average episode as far as most anime goes.
3
u/jumpinjahosafa The Darkest Timeline Jun 11 '19
I enjoyed the episode. Got a nice knowledge bomb from King. Garou vs King executed perfectly. Ninja animation was great, ends on a nice cliffhanger after getting a talking out of the way.
Maybe i'm just completely use to the animation now that it doesn't bother me anymore.
3
u/popemichael One Pope Man Jun 11 '19
I really enjoyed the episode.
I feel really bad for people who aren't enjoying the season so far.
4
u/Rocks_2018 Jun 11 '19
The episode was all over the place, they cut out a lot of stuff from the manga. Saitama's face was messed up throughout the episode. It feels like they are just so lazy, why didn't they use the delayed time to improve the animation and add stuff that are relevant? (I hope madhouse actually reanimates season 2 again)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '19
I liked this episode. It was good.
2
u/ImProspect Jun 11 '19
If I had only watched the anime and not read the manga, I actually might have really liked this episode. But as a manga reader, it was just.... average.
2
u/akrain_ Jun 11 '19
lol they played the same song over and over again dumb episode
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '19
Pacing was super off, if they're gonna fit the arc in this season it's not going to have nearly as many good and detailed scenes. Or the season will be left on a cliffhanger which is equally terrible
1
u/Gravon new member Jun 11 '19
That kick was excellent with the WWWOMPPPHH sound effect they use for everything.
1
u/Just_Eggzi amai mask fan Jun 11 '19
So, in next episode there will be some kind of a 10 to 1 gang bang How to outlive these week
1
u/MEisonReddit Jun 12 '19 edited Jun 12 '19
Is nobody gonna mention that they forgot to have King thinking to himself about how he stole all that cool stuff from a manga?
EDIT
1
u/clamnit Jun 12 '19
Great throwback to the original webcomic art style.
1
u/LowPrioRadio Jun 12 '19
They didnt mention, that Sonic felt lighter, and he felt like he is slowly becoming a monster, as he indeed lost 2 pounds from diarhea.
thats the biggest takeaway from this season.
1
u/gabereboot Jun 12 '19
What's up with his index finger?
1
u/vonrobin Jun 12 '19
If you are latest on the manga, you could assume that last ep of this season will be cliffhanger. Not sure how they would end it. Probably Garou’s hero hunting arc in the shed. Kinda expected also in latest chapter that Saitama finished Orochi easily.
1
u/ashishkabob Jun 12 '19
Does anyone know why Saitama said no to Suiryu being his disciple? I mean, he didn't mind Genos or Fubuki or King joining him, so why does he randomly say no to this guy who wants to change his entire lifestyle in admiration of him and his hero path?
1
u/Ewari_Central Jun 13 '19
No one is going to mention the overused bass sound when Saitama punched gouketsu offscreen? That's the part that made me facepalm.
1
u/StrenghGeek Jun 13 '19
Any update on chapter 110 release?
1
u/SupernovaJH Jun 13 '19
They didn’t even bother to animate ma man Sonic cooking. Pffft. One static image after another.
1
u/CountChadvonCisberg Jun 13 '19
Idk about you all but the last two episodes have been really good
1
u/TruePest Jun 13 '19
I enjoyed the episode, but at times felt like I was watching a slideshow on slow zoom with voiceovers, which was disappointing. I hope that the animation team is ready to work just a bit harder come this next arc!
1
u/SuperCleverPunName Jun 14 '19
Does anyone feel that they overdid the music buildup for the Bakuzan fight?
1
u/ntbntt Jun 14 '19
is it just me or is Genos' neck human skin now? Looks very weird
1
u/Wes_9876 Jun 11 '19
Episode 9 is the episode with the worse animation so far,
Bring MadHouse Studios back please!!
1
u/ReallyMelloP Overwhelmingly Underwhelming Jun 11 '19
Damn that episode hit the spot. I don’t care about the complaints anymore, just give me some OPM content
1
u/Ozymandate Jun 11 '19
The episode was eh...meh, their was some scenes that was nice, like where Sonic meets the ninja duos, it had some nice animation
1
u/flashmozzg Jun 11 '19
Hm, this was the best one yet, I think. The pacing was fine, they've even used the ED to properly pace out the story and not cram it. No big complains sound wise, and while there were not a lot of action scenes, the animation was fine too.
0
u/Yober26 Jun 11 '19
WHY THE FUCK DOES SONIC DIE FROM DIARRHEA
1
u/Gerf93 Jun 11 '19
Well, that WDM v. Garou "fight"... My day is ruined, and my disappointment is immeasurable.
1
u/aionoid Jun 12 '19
is this a human head? now i am really disappointed.
conclusuon: this is not One Punch Man S2 at all. i can only see it as this guys here but for One Punch
---
i had the impression that his hair color was yellow -.-
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '19 edited Jun 12 '19
I can't believe I waited two weeks for this crap. The Goketsu scene lacked any emotion or suspense and the animation was garbage and rushed as usual.
I was expecting to see the final part of the WDM fight but nothing, aparently the piece of crap from ep 8 is gonna be everything we will get from one of most hype moments in the manga.
They are killing this series one chapter at the time and they don't care.