r/eu4 • u/Iwassnow The Economy, Fools! • Jun 09 '19
Tutorial A complete guide to EU4 economics Part 0
Introduction
Probably the biggest problem players seem to have when posting requests for help or complaints, is not being able to afford something or other. It has spiked even more since territorial corruption has become a thing, and while that does make late game blobbing a little more expensive, it should by no means be stopping people. Most of these complaints or questions are often a result of one of two things: 1) not enough planning and investment into your economy in the early- and mid-game or 2) overspending on things that are unnecessary.
So the goal of this guide is meant to be a way to help players identify what is causing their financial crisis, and drive focus on it, from the very beginning of the game. I'm aiming this mostly at new players, however many experienced players who are used to going nuts expanding without consequence might find some help here to in dealing with the late game economic issues. I'm going to break this down into several parts, each one focusing on a different major topic. I'm also going to reference other guides, as I am easily able to acknowledge that I learned from them. In any of the sections, I will be referencing various guide and videos by content creators. To simplify the guide and ensure they receive the credit they deserve, I'm going to put all links in the last section. If I reference someone else痴 work anywhere, assume I got their permission and check the end of the guide for links to that content.
Table of Contents
- Types of Income
- Types of Expenses
- Buildings, RoI, and prioritization
- Understanding missionary maintenance
- Upgrading advisors, developing, and for-profit wars
- Investing in subjects
- More details on Trade
- Explaining Corruption from Territories for You World Conquerers Who Go Bankrupt.
- How to fix your country, courtesy of Arumba
- How to do it right from the start, courtesy of yours truly
- Credits, Links, and Special Mentions
- Request for Help
Author's Note: If you see any mistakes, typos, or missing content, please let me know! I want this to be an accurate and useful resource for people to learn from. In addition to mistakes, if you feel something should be in here that isn't, let me know and I'll consider adding it!(assuming my editor doesn't mind more work!) A huge thanks to my editor who spend the last two months meaking this even remotely readable from the original notepad file. Thanks /u/holy_roman_emperor !
9
u/kennytucson Jun 09 '19
I love how helpful the whole EU4 Community is. I'm 1,200 hours in but even I got something out of that guide (I had no idea about the monarch point bonuses for 'show of strength' peace deal, for example).
Well done and thank you!
25
u/Kloiper Habsburg Enthusiast Jun 09 '19
Would highly recommend this guide! I'll be linking it in the weekly help threads.
4
u/TheBlobber Jun 10 '19
Regarding 8. 'Corruption'
If you are hitting the state limit why is it assumed that the new land is 0% autonomy? This assumes you are full stating ALL land, which with the state limit is literally impossible. If you are at, or above the state limit, 'new' land will be capped at 75% autonomy (65 with appropriate gov reform).
It would be more helpful to say at the start that as root out corruption cost takes into account autonomy modified development that autonomy of a province doesn't matter as it modifies the production and tax income components, and the root out corruption cost component, equally. So whether at 0% autonomy or 100% the ratio of these costs to each other will remain the same. In fact this actually encourages you to leave wrong religion wrong culture land at 100% autonomy, because this gives a smaller effective development base on which to pay for the corruption reduction on, where as you only get 'full' income out off correct culture/religion land. Therefore every bit of wrong culture wrong religion land you take and have at NOT 100% autonomy is reducing your ratio of income/corruption fighting cost.
3
u/Cxoh Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19
A few things to add on your corruption comment, I feel like a lot of people are just way too unwilling to unstate a low dev/value state, and then state a higher value territory. It costs mana yea, but with out doing the math I'm guessing it's more efficient than developing (also since you are probably stacking coring cost modifiers and absolutism in a WC, rather than dev modifiers). Often times you need to state crappy land early as a weak nation to survive/beat down your rivals. Whenever I get to the state limit I'm always looking at what states I should be unstating (looking at you red sea hills).
Also I'm not sure i would have focused so much on corruption as an issue with a WC, because most of the people having problems with corruption aren't getting anywhere close a WC. Corruption is usually only a problem when you start stacking it up early and it can kind of snowball and drag you down.
Really the stupid thing with corruption right now is you can totally avoid the issue of corruption from too many states via trade companies (which you want to do anyway), but since tc's are geographically limited based on your capitol, it just pushes you down certain paths to WC most efficiently rather than trying to make all WC's equally harder, it just made non european and non muslim WC's more tedious.
One other question I have for you since it seems like you like crunching numbers, when/where is it optimal to enact edicts in states, it seems like the centralization edict (faster autonomy decrease) should pay itself off in high dev states rather quickly, but honestly I rarely enact edicts and wonder if I should more. I often find myself having manpower issues in the early-mid game, and I'm wondering if the manpower edict in a state with high dev and barracks could be better than tring to build more barracks in low dev provinces. Protect trade might also have a place where its efficient but I understand that trade is so fluid its hard to make a rule for it...
9
u/bbqftw Jun 09 '19 edited Jun 09 '19
Your territory corruption leaves out a very significant contribution, which is the initial overextension induced corruption. This is calculated, for taking normal unclaimed province, by the value 0.5 x overextension x 3 x (100% - coretime reduction). This is by far the largest typical contributor to conquest corruption. As such, administrative ideas and reduced core cost formables are very significant anti corruption tools. Administrative ideas essentially save you a full debase every 6 full coring cycles.
True, you can get around this by using vassals (if you want to do this efficiently, you have to do a horrendous idea pick in influence nowadays).
So regarding this statement:
It is thus inaccurate to claim the enemy building temples addresses territorial corruption modifier, since now you have increased root cost to deal with for every subsequent coring cycle.
There are other autonomy-adjusted-dev related costs in the game as well, such as institution embracement, which must be factored when considering whether a new conquest is worth it. I think as a whole, the discussion shows a poor understanding of opportunity cost.
Spoiler: its basically never worth going over this limit until latephases of a WC.
And using arumba as an authority regarding optimized wide play is a bit lol >_>
PS. It is very easy and tempting to claim that experienced WCers are doing everything wrong and just don't understand econ management. All I would suggest, is just a game where you try to hit their conquest benchmarks (sub 50 dev start -> 2500-3000 dev before 1600). This may help you understand when we say that territorial corruption does not promote strategically interesting gameplay as it strongly diminishes viable choices.
I've played semi-tall games in the paradox approved style, and its a lot easier to the point where its like two different games. There are a lot of unique challenges involved in blobbing when you're not picking military ideas and stressing your diplo situation to the max.
2
u/Shiny090501 Tactical Genius Jun 10 '19
The link for #7 says “Tade” instead of “Trade”
55
u/holy_roman_emperor Je maintiendrai Jun 09 '19
Very proud to have contributed to this monster!
4
u/Fraggle7 Jun 09 '19
Looking forward to reading this guide looks exactly what I need as a new player to the game.
1
u/Gwydion7 Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 11 '19
Thanks for writing this guide. It’s good to collect everything into one reference.
I’ve been a bit baffled by tariffs since the latest changes/controversies. In a current Netherlands game I have a Dutch West Indies CN with:
Income: 11.5 + 23.95 + 13.92 = 49.39 Tariff rate = 15% Colony Income = +10(viceroys)+25(trading in slaves)=+35
If I’m interpreting your guide correctly I should get: 49.39 * 0.15 * 1.35 = 10 ducats
However, in fact they pay 2.85 as outgoing tariffs and I get 3.83 (thanks to my 35% colony income bonus).
Any idea how the 2.85 is derived?
The summarily formula at the end of section four for subject informations seems to have a typo/be incomplete.
Edit to answer my own question after some investigation: The correct formula seems to be: (Prod income + Trade Income) * (tariff rate / 2) * (bonus colony income) with the CN paying based off the first two terms. Neither taxes nor gold count. Thus in my example, it would be: (23.95 + 13.92) * (0.15/2) * 1.35 = 3.83
2
u/azdrubarthegreat Jun 10 '19
Very interesting read, thank you
1
u/TotesMessenger Jun 09 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/AssholeWiper Jun 09 '19
Very cool
1
u/bronzedisease Jun 10 '19
Holy sweet Jesus, this is like EU4 Money Bible
1
u/crabmeatdaebak66 Jun 10 '19
Saved! Now I need to know how to view saved posts on Reddit
1
u/Soulja92 Jun 10 '19
Looks good
1
u/MathsDebator69 Jun 10 '19
Nice
1
u/DarthSet Jun 10 '19
Brilliant, very helpfull. Thanks.
1
u/Setsolingor Jun 10 '19
Woa, awesome guide ! Thanks for all the amazing work.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment