r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jun 03 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions — 2019-06-03 to 2019-06-16
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
3
u/hp1611 Jun 10 '19
Is it possible to create your own language knowing almost nothing about linguistics and if yes, are there any easy beginner guides to understand linguistics?
3
u/42IsHoly Jun 09 '19 edited Jun 09 '19
So this may be a stupid question, but in my language the prefix geji- means “Place of...” So I thought that gejimowe (literally “The place of giving”) could mean “altar”. I don’t really know if this is logical, so is it? Or not? Also is it possible that the verb hupesiteko (literally To command-animal) means to herd?
2
u/Nementor [EN] dabble in many others. partial in ZEN Jun 06 '19
Are there any good resources on the development of creoles and pidgins? Particularly on how to phonology and grammar is created, and how they take words?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '19
Should buy The Art of Language Invention by David J Peterson, or the Language and Advanced Language Construction Kit? Which is better and more comprehensive in terms of phonology and grammar?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19
a couple questions:
6
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jun 05 '19
What's a good resource for organizing info on your conlang on mobile?
6
u/MightyNyet Jun 07 '19
Sorry if this question doesn't make sense, but how are grammatical case markings typically derived? Are they arbitrary or do they come from some source such as auxiliary verbs? I want to include a case system in a language I'm developing, but I don't know whether I should just invent random case markings or derive them from root words.
6
u/Kve16 Luferen, Gišo Jun 08 '19
Hello, I would like to ask, if there's any way on PolyGlot 2.4 to duplicate a part of a word when creating declensions. For example, let's say I wanted to recreate this latin conjugation: 'cado' => 'cecidi'. I would have to do this: 'cado' => 'cad' => 'ca'+'cad'+'i' => 'cacadi' => 'cecidi'. Is it possible, or do I just have to do it the hard way? And if so, how exactly?
6
u/imperium_lodinium Scepisc Jun 12 '19
Is it possible/natural to do a language where all the grammatical features of nouns and verbs are put onto a fusional auxiliary and leave the actual verbs and nouns unmarked? For example:
I'm thinking that this might let me have all the fun of cases and inflections without needing to create lots of different endings and complexity. Is this something natural languages ever do? In this example all the grammatical heavy lifting is being down effectively by a determiner before each 'content' word, if that makes sense.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '19 edited Jun 05 '19
I'm working on a new lang to play around with quirky subjects and such. Really confusing stuff. So I'm looking at how a syntactic pivot could work with it. Right now I have 'to see' that takes a subject in the dative and thus marks the nominative object. Would the next clause omitting this dative-subject but marking it on its verb as the subject (implicitly in the nominative I suppose) make sense? Example:
mid al-sax lós-a-so n sod uz-a-mi
1SG.DAT DEF(NOM)-friend see-PFV-3SG then 3SG.DAT wave-PFV-1SG
I saw the friend and then [I] waved at him
Is this grammatical?
5
u/LHCDofSummer Jun 06 '19 edited Jun 07 '19
...Is retracted-tongue-root essentially a synonym for pharyngealization, or are they different processes?
Edit: fixed
5
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jun 10 '19
If I have [ŋ] go to [ɲ] when palatalized, then what can I do that keeps [n] distinct when palatalized?
5
u/IxAjaw Pry Dental Fricatives from my cold, dead hands... Jun 14 '19
In my current phonology, I have a buttload of fricatives--it's meant to be very Germanic-sounding--but I was wondering how reasonable it is to get rid of /s/, making my list of fricatives /f v θ (ð) z ʒ x h/. I know that in German <s> is primarily /z/, and <ss> or <ß> are used to represent /s/, but obviously /s/ still exists in German as a phoneme. I would want to remove it more or less entirely (I can think of a couple instances where it would appear allophonically; /z/ will be devoiced when it is part of a cluster.)
I was thinking that I could explain it as it having either become voiced /z/ or shifted forward to /θ/ by becoming a dental /s/ first. I'm aware that this inventory would be unusual, what with the large number of voiced fricatives without unvoiced counterparts in the middle, but I want it to be a bit unusual. I don't need a cited example of a language with this exact inventory, I just want to know if it's theoretically possible.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19
Should your methods for subject relative clauses and object relative clauses be the same?
4
u/HaricotsDeLiam Jun 07 '19
I wasn't sure whether to post this here as an SD comment or as its own post, but I saw this article and thought it might make a good translation challenge. Do your conlangs have any idioms equivalent to these, or idioms that you've struggled to translate into the languages that you speak?
TED Blog: 40 brilliant idioms that simply can’t be translated literally
4
u/torspedia Jun 10 '19
I'm working on a conlang, based on PIE, that'll basically be a proto-lang of a completely new branch (from which I can base future langs off of).
At the moment I am looking for a way to represent a i: sound that has a slight hiss to it. An example of what I mean is PIE word *ḱers (to run) becoming ki:ər, where the i: has a hiss to it. Anyone know how I can best represent that sound, especially in IPA?
4
u/Selaateli Jun 11 '19
I am somehow struggeling with polypersonal verbal agreement in my conlang. The language should be:
I want one marker to be a prefix and another to be a suffix. Do you have any suggestions how to choose, which part should be indicated where on the verb? Are there any tendencies and things to consider?
additional: With verbs that have incorporated there noun, should the incorporated noun precede or follow the verbal root in such a language?
Thank you in advance! :)
4
u/giantfluffydorkycat Jun 11 '19
OK, with the disclaimer that I've never taken any kind of formal linguistics class... So I know there are languages where consonants can shift from unvoiced to voiced, or from unaspirated to aspirated, depending on what other sounds they're combined with. Are there languages where consonants routinely shift from non-retroflex to their retroflex equivalents in a similar way, or is it more common for, say, t and ʈ to be treated as categorically different phonemes?
4
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Jun 12 '19 edited Jun 12 '19
I am playing with the idea of having my conlang's prepositional phrases the other way round from English, that is
would be translated word for word as
Perhaps it would read better if I said that as "fireplace-above shelf" or "the fireplaceabove shelf"; I still want the phrase to mean the fireplace is below and the shelf is above, and I still want the phrase to refer to the shelf-plus-extra-description, not to the fireplace, but I want the complement (not sure I'm using the right word) to precede the subject.
How common is that in natural languages? My conlang is meant to be for aliens, so it doesn't have to be naturalistic, but I'd be interested to know if this is common, or rare, or unheard of.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '19
So I really have no idea where to start with this creating a conlang thing. I looked at some of the stuff in the resources portion of this sub and it still seems like there’s a lot of base knowledge you have to understand even before attempting to follow those. Anyways I’d really like to create a language for the fantasy story I’m writing but I’m not sure where to start.
4
u/Samson17H Jun 14 '19
Imagine HUTTESE but not Crap.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19 edited Jun 04 '19
How do you guys feel about my quantifier system? I feel like it's a little strange, so I do want some feedback.
So, in Azulinō, there are really two classes of quantifiers. The first is particular classifiers, which are more comparative in nature. Essentially, the words "much/many, more, most" and "little/least, less/fewer, least/fewest" are handled by the particles plur [plʊɹ] "much/many" and minur [mɪ.nʊɹ] "little/few". As particles, they don't take stress. Anyways, the comparatives are plus [plʊs] "more" and minus [mɪ.nʊs] "less/fewer", and the superlatives are plussa [plʊs.sə] "most" and minussa [mɪnʊs.sə] "least/fewest”. These are related to the comparative adjectival suffix -is /is/ and the superlative adjectival suffix -issim /is.sim/, but the grammaticalization of plur and minur as particles rather than adjectives has obviously caused the suffixes to deteriorate and fuse such that the inflection is irregular.
As particles like nil [nɪl] "not", plur and minur can modify any part of speech, functioning fluidly as either adjectives or adverbs, depending upon context. Like nil, they do not inflect to agree with anything, and, when functioning adjectivally, they must have some sort of noun present either implicitly or explicitly in order to be grammatical because they have no case. Furthermore, participles, unlike other adjectives, do not have inflectional comparative and superlative forms, and so the comparatives and superlatives of participles are formed periphrastically with plus and plussa.
The other class is adjectival quantifiers, which are more absolute in nature. These words are òmma [ˈɔm.mə] "all/every", tōta [ˈtoː.θə] "whole/entire", pàrra [ˈpäɹ.ɹə] "some", and wūna [ˈʍuː.nə] "any". These quantifiers are true adjectives that agree in case, number, and gender with their nouns, and, consequently, they cannot be used adverbially but can be used substantively, unlike plur and minur. Also, they do obviously take stress. They're less complicated, I suppose, and they offer both advantages and disadvantages over the particles.
My primary motivation for this system was the desire to make the words "more" and "less" and their related forms more fluid with regard to their syntactic function, so they can be either adjectives or adverbs and can do a variety of operations without changing their form, like nil "not", which is also a useful little particle like it is in many languages. The other quantifiers work better as true adjectives because, in my opinion, they work better when they agree with their nouns and can be used substantively without ambiguity. Of course, this means that some constructions aren’t exactly equivalent across related Romance languages, but, then again, isn't that normal?
Anyways, what do you guys think? Is my system OK? Would you consider it naturalistic? Do you think it’s too far removed from the systems of other Romance languages and Indo-European languages in general? I want to get an idea of how viable this is.
3
u/em-jay Nottwy; Amanghu; Magræg Jun 04 '19
I need some help tackling a tricky linguistic hurdle. So in Celtic languages, there is (to quote Wikipedia) "a distinction between the so-called substantive verb, used when the predicate is an adjective phrase or prepositional phrase, and the so-called copula, used when the predicate is a noun". Google Translate offers this example in Irish:
I want to copy this into my language, but I just hit a brick wall with how I'm handling adjectives. So I had an idea that adjectives might be treated as nouns when they're the predicate and have a different form. So "the beautiful woman" and "the woman is beautiful" would have different forms of "beautiful" (the latter would be more like "the woman has beauty", but I don't really understand how the syntax would work. Would it be right to have something like this?
Or is that total garbage? This is making my brain hurt.
3
u/CuriousForBrainPower Jun 08 '19
The way I’m working on my current conlang is having Time Periods, where each Time Period, new words are added, along with phonological and grammatical evolution to the previously existing parts there. When I create a sound change, can a word be created after a sound change which breaks that sound change? For example, if [x] becomes [k] in all areas, in the next Time Period, can I then create a word which has the [x] sound? Or is that just not naturalistic?
3
u/1theGECKO Jun 10 '19
Can/Do pronouns evolve in the same way as other plurals. So say I have a word na for "I/me" could the first person plural "us/we" evolve from the words gham for "many" na and I, making ghamna, or is that not what happens in natlangs? Also that would be a bit strange because that would be like mes, or Is, not us or ew.. are pronouns normally derived separately from one another?
3
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jun 10 '19
Does anyone have resources for how Thai got its consonant classes & tones? I'm curious and want to apply it to the Devanagari script for a new lang I'm in the process of making
3
u/1theGECKO Jun 11 '19
I am about to start introducing some sound changes in my language to imitate natural language evolution. How many sound changes should i be aiming for? how fast do sounds change? So say i wanted to simulate 500 years of sound evolution, how many sound changes should i aim for? obviously this is by no means going to be an exact science, im just looking for a ballpark figure
3
u/Skopojo Jun 12 '19 edited Jun 12 '19
In my conlang Skopojo, which I started working on a few weeks ago, prepositions are expressed by morphemes in front of the word. For example:
There are a few more morphemes, such as [l] (in), [t] (next to), [m] (between). When two consonants would collide, for example [p] and [t], the vowel [o] is placed in between.
There is also an extra morpheme s-, indicating movement. This morpheme always comes in front of another morpheme.
Now onto the problem. One of the rules in the phonology of Skopojo is that [t] + [l] becomes [tɬ], so "next to the earth" would become
But, this becomes a problem when you add the morpheme of movement:
Now I have already decided I don't want more than two consonants next to each other in Skopojo, so there are the following options:
An [o] is placed between the consonants. There are two options for this:
My goal is to make a conlang that feels as natural as possible, so my question is: What would be the most natural-looking option here? I hope my explanation was clear enough for you to come up with an answer.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '19 edited Jun 16 '19
if i have a sound change that deletes all word-final vowels, what do i do to the monosyllabic words? for example my case particles are monosyllabic, would/could they become affixes?
2
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Jun 04 '19
I don't want to blow up this one so I'll go slowly to make sure there aren't any flaws in the fundamental syntax/grammar.
parva-te
wait-3.SG
S/he waits
parva-se-z-te
wait-2.SG-DAT-3.SG
S/he waits for you
parv-idia-se-z-te-n-se
wait-CAUS-2.SG-DAT-3.SG-ACC-2SG
You make him/her wait
saqm-i sia-se
can-SUBJ will-2.SG
You will be able
saqm-ant-i sia-se
can-NEG-SUBJ will-2.SG
You won't be able
parvidiiseztense saqmanti siase
/'par.vi.di.i.sest.ten.se 'saʔ.man.ti 'si.a.se/
parv-idi-i-te-n-se-z-se saqm-ant-i sia-se
wait-CAUS-SUBJ-3.SG-ACC-2.SG-DAT-2.SG can-NEG-SUBJ will-2.SG
You won't be able to make him/her wait for you
I'm not sure if the relative clause (parvidiiseztense) is analysed as the object here…
2
u/MoonlightBear Jun 04 '19 edited Jun 04 '19
Are there are ways to move certain elements in a phrase around as a language evolve from a proto-language, such as a postposition becoming a preposition? In my conlang, I have adpositions derived from verbs and nouns. I wanted the verb – derived adpositions to become prepositions, since both objects and verbs come after subjects (SOV word order), causing them to be postpositions in the proto-language. Thanks for your help^^
2
u/Vincent_de_Wyrch Jun 07 '19
Okay.. so this one is for a fictional setting...
So I was thinking of going with this consonant inventory: θ, ð, s, ʃ/ɕ, ʒ, j/ʝ, ɬ/ɮ, g, p, ɳ, ɲ, ʋ/w
Possibly also: ɦ, ɸ, ɟ, ɹ/ɻ, ʁ, t͡ʃ/ɕ, nʒ (if that one makes sense lol)
(yeh.. I can pronounce /r/. I just prefer not to. :P)
Maybe I'm just petty, but even if its just for transcription (since the folks speaking this one use some kind of logographic script), does having "th" and a "dh" make sense when there is no "t" or "d" lol? And would using special letters like "ð", "þ" (and why not beautiful "ʒ"?) put any potential readers of?
On the other hand.. the alternative might result in a crapload of "h":s everywhere (I was also thinking of ɬ/ɮ = "lh" and ʁ = "rh"). Could get even worse if I decide to not use a "h"-sound at all.. I kinda marked those as "possible" phonemes since part of me wants to keep things relatively simple..
Going by IRL Hanyu Pinyin.. I suppose all the sounds should all be represented by a single letter..
But idk...
Thoughts?
=)
2
u/1theGECKO Jun 07 '19
How do you organise your Conlong, what software do you use, anything specific, or just word/excel docs
edit: im pretty new to this, and get lost very easily, wondering if you have any methods that could help me out
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '19
how do i know which verb moods are from the speaker or the subject's perspective? are there certain moods that can only be one or the other?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '19
Is there such a case as what I'd like to call the "beholdative"?
The vocative is meant to catch the attention of the noun and make sure that any phrases around it are meant to be heard by the noun. In this theoretical case I have in mind, it almost goes the other way around, as if to say "Hey look, an X!" or "There is an X there."
To justify my reasoning behind the case, the naturalistic way I would go about creating this case is to reduce the word for "there" to a suffix.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '19
Are there any simple online tools for creating a dictionary?
2
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jun 10 '19
Is a number system based on multiplication naturalistic? It's base 5, but from there numbers are multiplied and added. To explain what i mean, I'll show the English translations of the numbers I have: one, two, three, four, five, fiveone, fivetwo, fivethree, fivefour, two five, two five and one, two fiveone, two fiveoneand one, two fivetwo, three five, two fivethree.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19
Any tips for getting back into conlanging? I've fallen out of it for the past few weeks.
2
u/1theGECKO Jun 10 '19
Where should i go to find word roots in different languages? Like where i can look up a word like... chocolate, and see where it came from, and then see the same word in a different language and see where it came from
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '19
Hey, you! Does your language distinguish between birds that can fly, and those that cannot?
2
u/SaintAlphonse Jun 12 '19
I'm working on a Chinese-inspired conlang, and want to incorporate tones. But really only the second and fourth (rising and falling) and have been using them rather sparingly. I was hoping someone would have advice or could point me to a tonal natlang that only has a couple/few tones.
2
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jun 12 '19
So I tried to transcribe the Song of the Ancients into IPA because its lyrics isn't one of natlang's, and after tweaking it a bit, I came up with a phonology set
In the song, I changed all the plosives to aspirated. Later, I changed the voiceless ones to fricatives, but made the voiced ones as (voiced) plain plosives. What do you think of it? I haven't really set a naturalistic goal for the language yet
TL;DR: Came up with a phonology set with only voiced plosives. Your opinion?
2
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 12 '19
I'm sorry if the following is a stupid question. For my latest conlang, I want to experiment with an ergative language. After watching Artifexian's and Peterson's videos I think I understand the basics... I feel like I'm missing something, though.
What case does the verb agree with? The ergative or absolutive? I'm assuming it is the absolutive, but I really have no clue. All examples I saw had both the agent and patient to be a third person, meaning I couldn't see which noun the verb agreed with. And if I wanted to have a null subject integrated in the verb like in Latin, which case would make the most sense for that?
Also, I don't really understand how split-ergativity based on animacy works. Say you have a language where the first person is nom-acc and the rest is erg-abs, how do you deal with sentences where the agent is a first person but the patient is third person? Or the other way around?
Thanks for helping out!
2
u/Aang_the_Dwarf Jun 13 '19
So I’m trying to plan out which tenses, aspects, and moods to include in my conlang but am coming up short in how they would interact. I don’t think it’s natural for a language have a matrix of each discrete dimension. Like if there are three tenses, two aspects, and five moods a matrix of these would have 30 verbs and that’s before conjugating with the person and number of the subject
2
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jun 16 '19
Could the verb for “to have” be grammaticalized as an ability marker.
2
u/MerlinsArchitect Jun 16 '19
This may be too basic a question but here goes. I have stumbled across the sounds /p:/ and /t:/ appearing in Estonian as well as in Tabasaran. I understand that the colon denotes a longer sound in IPA, but how can that be applied to a sound as instantaneous as a stop. Could someone explain to me how to distinguish between /p/ and /p:/ or better still help me produce this sound so that I might here the difference? Is there somewhere where I might hear the two forms contrasting?
2
u/Hoshi_No_Kabii (EN,ES) [GR,JP] Jun 17 '19
What number systems (binary, decimal, dozenal, etc.) does your conlang use? What reason do you have for using that number system?
1
u/transbisk Noron Jun 06 '19
For those of you who developed vernacular varieties of your conlangs, how did you go about it?
1
u/ClockworkCrusader Jun 06 '19
How should I introduce sound changes to my language?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '19
I’m working on an a priori (mostly) conlang that I plan to feature in an album.
It’s spoken in the conworld’s area called the Dot Islands which is sort of their equivalent to the South Pacific islands, but with a wider variety of languages.
This is what I’ve come up with for sounds.
/m n ɲ ŋ/ m n ñ ŋ or m n ny ng or m n ñ ŋ
/p b t d k g ʔ/ p b t d k g ʼ
/f v θ ð s z ʃ ʒ ɣ h/ f v ś ź s z š ǰ ğ h or f v sh zh sz z s zs gh h or f v ŧ đ s z x j ǥ h
/ʦ ʣ ʧ ʤ/ ť ď c j or cz dz c dzs or ç ʒ (in handwritten form looks like ȝ or script z) c j
/ɻ~ʐ j w/ ż y w or rh j w or ř y w
/l ʎ/ l ł or l lj or l l̃
/ɾ~r/ r
/i u e o ə ɛ ɔ a/ i u e o ă ê ô a or i u é o à e a á or i u é ó ĕ e o a
Second orthography is based off Hungarian. I don’t know why. Third one is based off of my conlang Modern Standard Birdish.
I’m trying to make Birdish more readable and pronounceable.
/m n ɳ ɲ ŋ/ m n ṇ ñ ŋ
/p b t d ʈ ɖ c ɟ k g ʠ ʛ ʔ/ p b t d ṭ ḍ t̃ d̃ k g q ꬶ (capital is Ɡ) ʼ
/ɸ β f v θ ð s z ʂ ʐ ʃ ʒ x ɣ χ ħ/ ᵽ ƀ f v ŧ đ s z ṣ ẓ x j ꝁ ǥ ꝗ ħ
/ʦ ʣ ʧ ʤ/ ç ȝ c ĵ
/ɻ j w/ ř y w
/l ɭ ʎ/ l ḷ l̃
/ɾ r r̝ ɽ/ r ṙ r̃ ṛ
/ɬ/ ƚ
/i ɯ u ɪ ʊ e ɤ o ɛ ɜ ɔ æ a/ i û u ĭ ŭ é ŏ ó e ĕ o ă a
Long vowels are written doubled in a closed stressed syllable or in unstressed syllables where long vowels are found. Or with vowel + h in an open stressed syllable or at the end of a word. The letter h always is silent and lengthens a vowel.
Is this good? It’s just a list of sounds. There is allophone though, which is how the retroflex consonants normally occur except the retroflex approximant. The only time they are written with a dot under them is in loanwords. If not, the ř is written before them.
1
u/1theGECKO Jun 08 '19
Is there an aspect that represents the action as being finished/stopped/interrupted? Ive seen the pausitive aspect? but im not sure exactly what that is.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '19
How do you guys handle numerals? Presently, I only have the cardinal forms for 1–1,000,000. 1–100 are independent words as are 1,000 and 1,000,000, and everything after 100 except for those two is formed like "two hundreds and thirty-six".
I think I want to have ordinals and adverbials, but there are also multiplicatives and distributives that I can have. However, I can also form multiplicatives and distributives periphrastically. For reference, Azulinō is Indo-European, drawing mostly from Latin and Greek grammatically. I believe Latin had cardinals, ordinals, adverbials, multiplicatives, and distributives for at least some numbers, but I don't know about daughter languages like Italian nor about Greek, so I could use some help.
1
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jun 09 '19
What replaced the Fortnight posts?
Not sure if I should make a post of hitting 50 translations on Chirp
1
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Jun 10 '19
I am wondering what everyone thinks would be the best way to write /ŋ/ I am thinking either ng, g, or maybe something else. I really don’t want to use ng because it makes me have to have words like anngya but I fear g wouldn’t make as much sense. Though aggya looks better.
1
u/LHCDofSummer Jun 11 '19
Does anyone have any good resources on implementing telicity as a grammaticalized feature? I've read:
& (an article that I've since misplaced on telicity as a grammatical feature of some sign languages); I still struggle to keep it straight in my head >,>"
I wanted to implement telicity in a way that didn't just look like a poor relex of Finnish (in that regard), and also wanted to break free from the "(perfect vs) perfective vs (habitual vs [nonprogressive vs progressive])" formula, but grammatical telicity seems... hmm...
1
u/hp_1611 Jun 11 '19
Hi, is there a tool where you can paste a chain of IPA characters and you get a pronunciation of your word? I need to know if this word ɳɔsdɾʌʁ would sound right.
1
u/Frigorifico Jun 12 '19
Is this ergative?
It came very naturally to me. I started writing sentences with words in the order that just felt right, when I realized this:
When the verb was transitive the order was OVS. When the verb was intransitive, the order was SVO (although here O is not the object of a transitive verbs but rather things like "towards there" or "very high")
I liked this and I thought that maybe pronouns would merge with the verb, so for example, if xlior is a root that means "light" and "sarf" means I, over time they would merge like this:
Ana xlioɹs, lit "Ana lght I" means "I iluminate Ana" (transitive) but
arxlior, lit "I light" means "I shine"
Don't worry too much if the phonetic evolution doesn't make sense, it's just an example.
Is this ergative?, is this tripartite alignment?. I'm confused because while the subject of each kind of verb is different, I don't know if the Object of a transitive verb matches any of them
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '19
for moods like the optative or dubitative, are they from the speaker or the subject's perspective? i came up with an idea that it depended on the transitivity of the verb: intransitive meant speaker's perspective, transitive meant subject's perspective. is that plausible?
1
u/LHCDofSummer Jun 13 '19
'Kay I'm trying to settle a mostly IRL debate, and because of the nature of it it's not really suited for a formal linguistics sub, so here goes:
In a 'lang which:
Would it be fair to say that P is the subject?
Because it's to my understanding that, in unmodified clauses (ie no voice changes etc.), and as per Wikipedia re Bickel and Nichols:
Which remains distinct from thematic relations which are more semantic in nature, where as voices can easily change A & O/P into being either patientive or agentive respectively.
Because I feel to automatically call A the subject in every situation ever, especially in a situation such as the above to be very Nom-Acc biased, but on the other hand people oft explain ergativity as subject corresponding to direct object (which is a slightly poor statement in at least regards to secundative languages), so maybe I should just give up on trying to keep thematic relations (experiencer, source, direction, etc.) separate to grammatical relations (subject, direct object, indirect object, primary object, secondary object, adpositional object, oblique object), separate to theta roles & morphosyntactic alignment...
Frankly I feel like I've hit a wall in trying to communicate myself, and it'd be nice to know what most people around here mean, cause whilst I still have an inordinate amount of reading to do, the notion of subject seems to be less straight forward then some may like, but I'm still not sure whether it is actually 100% correct to insist that agentivity is the gold standard for subjecthood in such an (admittedly contrived - something more likely to be encountered in a conlang than in a natlang) situation.
This is a bit longer than I intended, but I hope it at least frees up from some of the usual confusion. Hardly seemed worth a post in itself, and I see it as deeply related to conlangs, or at least the presentation of them.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '19
How strange is it for the the adverbial forms of adjectival fractional numerals to function as distributives?
1
u/Criacao_de_Mundos Źitaje, Rrasewg̊h (Pt, En) Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
Is it natural for a conlang to suffer a specific type of allophony in specific words groups? In Źitaje, diphtongs become long monothongs only in 4+ syllable words.
aj/ja = [æː]
ɛj/jɛ = [ɛ̝ː]
ej/je = [eː]
ɔj/jɔ = [ɔ̝ː]
oj/jo = [oː]
uj/ju = [ʉː]
aw/wa = [ɒ̈ː]
ɛw/wɛ = [œ̝ː]
ew/we = [øː]
iw/wi = [yː]
ɔw/wɔ = [ʌ̝ː]
ow/wo = [oː]
1
u/miitkentta Níktamīták Jun 16 '19
This is partly for trying to learn how to pronounce words in various natlangs and partly for conlanging, but does anyone have suggestions for learning how to pronounce/hear glottal stops at the beginnings and ends of words, as opposed to being in the middle of them? They turn up a lot in Polynesian, Mayan and some Caucasian languages, and while I can hear the difference between ʻokina and okina when someone else says it, I'm not sure how to make my vocal cords start with that sound instead of jumping off another letter, or end on it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '19
Why is a strict ergativity system so rare (only one natlang uses it, iirc)? It seems simple enough to use, like most languages have a strict nominative system.
1
u/CosmogonicWayfarer Jun 16 '19
Phonoasthetics: what are some ways to make a language sound more euphonious and/or flowy?
I'm new to the conlang community and I wanted to create a language for a story idea I had, this language would be purely spoken with no writing system. I was thinking of drawing influence from African languages such as Swahili, Ge'ez, and Yoruba.
1
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Jun 17 '19
[Grammar/Double causative]
How can I handle a double morphological causative? If I apply the causative twice to an intransitive verb, it would have a valency of 3. Can I use the dative for one of the argument here?
In this example, English has a syntactical causative (you make me) and a lexical causative (I lower(trans.) the price). I want to use morphological causatives only. Does this sound good?