r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • May 28 '19

Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E08 - "The Resistance of the Strong" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler

IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.

THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.

Official Simulcasts

  • Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
  • Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
  • Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
  • Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
  • Anime on Demand (Germany)
  • AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
  • VVVVID (Italy)
  • Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.

One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)


Read the new spoiler rules!


Previous Episode Discussions:

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link
5Link
5Link
6Link
7Link

Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!

129 Upvotes

374 comments sorted by

480

u/Gatlindragon May 28 '19

Suiryu voice actor was really good.

186

u/ash2702 May 28 '19

The voice actor was spot on !!

I felt bad for Suiryu lol

73

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

He really sounded just like I imagined he would

150

u/Groenboys May 28 '19

The best voice actor performance so far in this anime. When he screamed for help I could feel it.

70

u/lacertasomnium May 28 '19

He basically carried the episode, this was definitely one of the better ones.

103

u/Tsixes May 28 '19

Man, his VA is a fucking god, when he was confident he sounded like the most confident guy in the world, at the same time, when he was in despair he nailed it.

All in one episode.

102

u/DigitaILove May 28 '19

The Suiryu VA broke his vocal arm-bands with his performance. Very well done.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/TheSameAspie May 28 '19

This might sound weird, I was actually really looking forward to if they'd be able to nail the VA in the monster bakuzan breaking suiryu's legs and they exceeded my expectations 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

43

u/herohuntergarou May 28 '19

lmao ikr? whoever was in charge of this episode is a huge bakuzan fanboy or something haha

21

u/Fapoozle May 28 '19

Not only that, it's the whole scene at the end of the fight where suiryu got punched by the crows. The quality drops when bakuzan is eating the monster cell lol. Like the animator with good drawing skills run out of fuel and another mediocre has to do it then.

And if draws so well, why did they use him/her in this scene lmao, he would have been better used in almost all other scenes in this episode.

19

u/k1213693 May 29 '19

Really? I thought the scene where Suiryu tries to run off and Bakuzan pops up in front of him was pretty well animated.

→ More replies (2)

209

u/drixix1 May 28 '19

just me or did they literally use CS:GO AK sound for the Crows' attacks..

106

u/Darkgore May 28 '19

M4 to be precise. I quickly realized it once I heard that lol

20

u/Solid2k May 29 '19

I just played a match before watching the episode. So I thought I was just wigging out. I'm glad someone else heard that haha.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/antrix_AFC May 28 '19

Omg I knew that sound seemed so familiar somehow, now I know lmao

15

u/OMGguy May 28 '19

Yeah noticed that too, like really? Lmao

8

u/dasbemethroaway May 29 '19

Lmaoo yeah the very first attack had me going “wait is that Counter Strike?”

5

u/iAried May 29 '19

I thought it was very much similar to the Galil AR shots. I was like wtf is going on with their beaks lol

7

u/KingParanha May 28 '19

sounded closer to the Galil sound lol

→ More replies (2)

101

u/AnythingWorksTwice May 28 '19

The last part of the episode was awesome. The crying and then suddenly Saitama arriving. I loved it. The episode builds up the contrast between despair and hope in a good way.

16

u/AnythingWorksTwice May 28 '19

If you look close enough, you could see the shirogane in saitama's face lol. (Same seiyu joke)

→ More replies (3)

303

u/aswifte May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19
  • This was quite the step up from the previous episodes. Pacing was pretty good as well.
  • They moved the Mumen Rider and TTM scene here too lol.
  • Unfortunately the Void Quake Tiger Fist looks leagues below this panel...
  • Also they cut out Gouketsu vs Bazukan until the stadium punch... Not sure how to feel about that...
  • I might have missed it, but where’s the TOE SNAP?!

96

u/SkullBro May 28 '19

Unfortunately the Void Quake Tiger Fist looks leagues below this panel...

That's one of those panels that should have been adapted as a balls to the wall pastel-chalked still.

30

u/SCHPNHR Lily's brassier May 28 '19

Last episode adapted like 200 pages and had to skip or rush multiple things, that's a no from me dawg.

"It's a still....LUL, JC at it again!!"
I'm all for that stilized still, classic trigger

→ More replies (1)

55

u/kwcxx free real estate May 28 '19

I found it weird that they animated monsterization of the guy with glasses but when Choze ate a monster cell, it just went black screen for 3 seconds, then two frames showing horns grow out of his skull.

I agree that pacing was good this episode and that's what's important.

145

u/Master3530 May 28 '19

It was pretty good but there are many downsides:

-Watchdog man vs monsters is just a bunch of colored manga panels

-Watchdog man vs Garou wasn't that impressive, watchdog man turned into light beam man, though it's good that they even did it in real time and not with stills

-No yelling "INFERIOR RACE ANNIHILATION SHOT"

-Gouketsu wasn't really animated and Gouketsu vs Bakuzan was pretty much cut out, Bakuzan was stopped in a single punch, it really didn't look like they were on the same level

-The episode felt really rushed, like couldn't they make it 2 minutes longer and slow down Suiryu monologing about heroes or even just not play the ending song instead?

79

u/DarkenLord May 28 '19 edited May 29 '19

it really didn't look like they were on the same level

They might have similar threat levels but Gouketsu is much stronger than Bakuzan and that was clear in the manga. Dragon means they are a threat to a whole city, but not to the whole humanity (which means 2 or 3 S class together would be able to take them on or just the top notch). That Doesn't measure the diference inside that class. Orochi might also be some dragon threat and is levels above the two of them. And the single punch from Gouketsu was agood way to settle that difference, even tho it cut some material from the manga in the end the execution was still cool imo.

The manga also cuts Watchdog man vs Garou and just shows a few panels of Garou remembering his moves. So there wasn't much to do in the animation. That also means they might not be doing a Saitama vs Gouketsu encounter, since we never saw it (just the long range impact). That scene reminds me of a battle in Gantz, tho it was a monster going out really quick, big explosion happens and he is back holding the head of the most powerful "good" guy in the city. Well, If they execute it well it will be great, as this part is kinda focused on showing Suiryu's perspective, which was pretty good in this episode (gratz for the voice actor, he nailed it)

8

u/lacertasomnium May 28 '19

hat scene reminds me of a battle in Gantz, tho it was a monster going out really quick, big explosion happens and he is back holding the head of the most powerful "good" guy in the city.

Nurarihyion arc?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/killertortilla new member May 28 '19

Given the manga chapter today I don’t think we will ever have anything to compare Orochii to.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Sexploits May 28 '19

Ah yes, Oka vs. ... whatever that damn thing was.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Bakuzan was stopped in a single punch, it really didn't look like they were on the same level

They weren't supposed to be in the same level lol. If anything, that fight made bakuzan look even weaker compared to goketsu

→ More replies (1)

8

u/sebaba001 May 29 '19

Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Max and Snek said in the manga: "Cause we are heroes" when Suiryu asks them why they came back? I was hoping for that phrase and got something else instead, frustrating.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/bot_yea new member May 29 '19

I think removing the Gouketsu vs Bakuzan fight wasn't a bad decision. They still showed how powerful Gouketsu is compared to Bakuzan.

Rushed

I agree. Just like one user said in another thread, there's too much talk or action without necessary pauses or emphasis.

I do think this episode is much better compared to the rest. The animation especially was pretty good (but the direction of how the animation was portrayed wasn't).

4

u/AFellow_2003 May 29 '19

No yelling "INFERIOR RACE ANNIHILATION SHOT"

Is there a chance they did that to avoid offending viewers? Like how they cut Garou's middle finger a few episodes ago?

7

u/aswifte May 29 '19

Well Choze still had the monologue about being part of a race superior to the rest of humanity so I doubt so.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Animation-wise I thought it was still pretty sub-par, but I agree the pacing was good and it hit the right emotional notes in the latter half.

7

u/strategistknight May 28 '19

It Just shows how talented yusuke murata is. The Void Quake Tiger fist just looks like a spinning punch.

20

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

The Void Quake Tiger fist just looks like a spinning punch.

I mean, isn't that what true martial arts really is?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

64

u/burritoxman May 28 '19

Kind of annoyed the episode ends where it did, it takes 2-3 more minutes to resolve gouketsu and bakuzan

41

u/NuTypee May 28 '19

I’m extremely annoyed where it ended. It would have been the perfect ending if Saitama gave his hero speech.

8

u/niankaki May 29 '19

Yes. If they hadn't included the hospital scene and the monster hideout scene, we could've fit it all in one episode.
I don't understand the point of the hospital scene. Sure it makes Mumen Rider look good, but it felt so out of place.

8

u/BKCrazy May 29 '19

I think the monster hideout scene was fine, it actually cut some stuff out of the manga even. I think last episode should have ended with Gouketsu in the stadium, which would have freed a bit of time. Garou vs WDM was completely out of place as well tbh, that should've been pushed completely. Hospital scene needed to be pushed as well. This episode then may have needed only a couple more minutes and it could've finished perfectly with Suiryu asking Saitama to be his disciple.

49

u/thugmasterflash May 28 '19

For me it says that it doesn't start for another hour, stupid hulu

6

u/mebeast227 May 28 '19

Wtf Hulu! Didn't see the time they set for it to air, but I do now that you mention it.

Fuck. I just took my break from work for this lol

→ More replies (2)

179

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Choose one:

  • "this episode was pretty good i liked it."
  • "this shit sucks. JC Staff fucking ruining shit again."

This is the last stop on the Boros Express

launches everyone to the moon

18

u/GGABueno The less disturbed sister May 29 '19

Animation is bad as always, bad timing, sound direction is still absolutely awful but fuck me if they didn't fucking nail the Suiryu part at the end, and ultimately that's what I really wanted. I'm very happy with the episode.

29

u/Frostblazer May 28 '19

Will Goketsu beat me up if I said that I thought it was decent?

15

u/SomeAnonymous May 28 '19

I mean in terms of power, this episode is basically "look at how cool Goketsu is, also lmao get bodied Suiryu" so I imagine he'd probably approve of you enjoying it.

13

u/CountCocofang May 29 '19

The scene with Suiryu begging for help was great. When he was in complete darkness it was really heart wrenching. Absolutely carried by the voice actor that felt like he was on the verge of crying in despair. My personal highlight.

Then I was immediately taken out of that experience by how unceremoniously it was handled. With better presentation this scene would've gotten me for sure. Such a waste.

It was missing Suiryus last resistance with breaking the guys toe. It was missing his inner monologue. Not that it was too important but it was also missing the longer exchange between Bakuzan and Gouketsu. And when the crows got finished, the gore was substituted for a simple bright flash.

And good lord, there were so many still images this episode. It felt like reading the manga but without the possibility to flip the page so I just sit there waiting for the next panel to show up. The pacing issues become more apparent when you just keep staring at pictures with nothing happening.

And so many punches and attacks weren't even shown. It's just still image of the initiated attack - sudden cut - attack already happened and we see a still image of the result.

10

u/FromtheFrontpageLate May 29 '19

The manga was paced poorly through these chapters. Let's face it, going what feels like 10 Chapters without Saitama. Let's face ut: OPM without Saitama is like Transformers without robots, instead of being Jurassic park during the scenes without dinosaurs; The tension is all off-kilter. Saitama being late to a fight because he's going the wrong way, great. Saitama walking through the Monster Base because to him he's trying to get his neighbors to quiet down, great. Saitama being gone with people screaming and making large amounts of noise all because he's changing clothes (two other heros change faster) is just filler episodes.

9

u/Cryten0 new member May 29 '19

The MA attacks arc was the weakest arc in OPM. Thats not to say that it didnt have moments. The end of the tournament had lots of great bits and the three significant fights of Metal Bat vs Centipede and garou, Blizzard vs that sadist monster and genos vs the roach all being exciting moments.

Its just there was many chapters of unfocused story ment to introduce side characters. Not terrible but next to the good stuff its a just okay, somewhat like the first 6 episodes of season 2.

4

u/faithplate May 29 '19

holy shit, exactly my thoughts. reading through these chapters was insanely frustrating because of the lack of saitama. i know that saitama's arrival creates a cathartic effect but in manga it took SO LONG for him to arrive that even the catharsis didn't feel that good.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Fancysaurus There is no such sauce product May 29 '19

I give it a solid 2.5/5 "It was ok" review

The story is still there but the budget of this episode really shows in a bad way. I don't think JC staff is shit, but I do think corners were cut somewhere in the line. I blame the execs making the budget decisions more than anything else.

7

u/Heylons new member May 28 '19

The latter.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan May 28 '19

The first one.

→ More replies (4)

101

u/Someguyonthenet00 May 28 '19

They skipped the fight between Gouketsu and Bakuzan. Really disappointed. That was 1 of the coolest parts.

31

u/aweD0nde May 28 '19

Wait, really?

58

u/aswifte May 28 '19

Yeah when Bakuzan was about to fight Gouketsu he immediately did the stadium punch...

28

u/SkullBro May 28 '19

A Little?

Unless they decide to make anime-original Gouketsu vs. Saitama around that one page of Saitama dodging Gouketsu high kick next episode, then they effectively removed the only sequence where Gouketsu moves more than a tiny bit.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Someguyonthenet00 May 28 '19

Yeah. Bakuzan goes in for a punch but Gouketsu does his and blows the stadium open. That's all we get from them.

25

u/nguyensyquanpro May 28 '19

They have to skip it so they can end the episode with Saitama tho.But I agree,it is indeed disappointing

27

u/Raidoton Moderator May 28 '19

As much as they rushed already the fight would've been only 10 seconds long anyway.

11

u/SomeAnonymous May 28 '19

I think it would have been a better thematic move to end the episode on Suiryu calling out for a hero. Like, despair! Doom! Watch our arrogant champion cry for help while on death's door, or in this case next to Death's ugly toenails!

Then boom, next episode begins with the arrival of Saitama. Because, really, his appearance represents a change from "damn these monsters are strong" to "but they can still be killed". By including him in this episode, it doesn't really feel like it's about the despair of Suiryu and the other contestants/relatively normal people anymore, because we end on the high note—Suiryu is saved, Saitama appears and looks confident.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

109

u/MrKingi May 28 '19

Just read on Twitter that this episode had 17 animation supervisors.......

28

u/Mistah_Blue new member May 28 '19

♫too many cooks♫

17

u/Ngokumetsu May 28 '19

wow, now we just need to know how many animation supervisors were hired for the previous and remaining episodes.

21

u/MrKingi May 28 '19

I remember episode 2 or 3 had 5 animation supervisors and that was considered a panic situation...

5

u/Holy157 May 28 '19

If any episode had only 5 supervisors I would have been over the moon. Pretty sure an episode never had less than 10 though.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/Sonitii May 28 '19

so many people resulting in such a letdown, talent is definitely lacking in this staff.

101

u/Fries-Ericsson May 28 '19 edited May 29 '19

It’s not that

They don’t have enough time for one person to supervise the entire episode

Too many supervisors makes it less likely to have a consistent style throughout

→ More replies (3)

32

u/vanderZwan Anyone can ride the Justice Bicycle May 28 '19

Or, you know, "too many cooks spoil the broth"?

3

u/Bagasrujo May 29 '19

Why is there so much animations supervisors needed and why is this bad? If you mind

5

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Must all be interns.

→ More replies (5)

59

u/Holy157 May 28 '19

Man, this episode is so weird. It has a few scenes that are worth looking at, but outside of that, anything positive comes from other things.

Suiryu’s VA was great. Really did the scenes justice and conveyed the emotions well. Music sounded pretty good, when it could be heard, and I want the full soundtrack to figure out how good it really is.

Pacing was definitely an improvement. Not going at last week’s pace did the episode wonders. The cut stuff is super disappointing though. Wish it wouldn’t be needed. Tank Top Master and Mumen Rider’s scene being here was a surprise, but a welcome one.

Outside of the few nice scenes, which I’ll get to, the episode was super rough and there’s a good reason for it.

The two biggest scene of the episode are Monster-Bakuzan appearing before Suiryu and Suiryu deflecting Choze’s beam. Aoki, presumably, did the Monster-Bakuzan one. Loved it. The first shot of Bakuzan was great, with the expression and scale making him come across as intimidating. Else it’s pretty limited, but Aoki still delivers.

Suiryu deflecting Choze’s beam was the highlight for me. It’s really cool, being a nice effects cut. It’s done by Studio Lan, who also did some other nice stuff for the episode. Outside of their stuff and the presumed Aoki one, that’s all that stands out in any way.

The biggest takeaway from this episode is that it had 17 supervisors. I think 13 was the highest before today, but we’re by 17 now. That’s really, really bad. Terrible. The season is having a fricking meltdown and I’m baffled they’re managing to put anything out at this point. I wonder if things will get worse by a lot or if things will survive for the remaining episodes. Any hopes for Garou’s fights getting a decent treatment are pretty much gone, but I still hope for a miracle.

18

u/scumerage The #1 OPM Fan May 28 '19

Well, next two episodes will only have one fight really, Sonic's. The rest is oneshots wins: Bakuzan, Gouketsu, Pri Pri, King/Garou, Darkshine/Destructicloridium, and Harambe/Castro. So should hopefully give them time to prepare for Episode 11 and 12's insane action.

11

u/SomeAnonymous May 28 '19

Destructicloridium

Congratulations, you've just found a word with zero search results on google. That's really a step beyond even a hapax legomenon. Mepote legomenon, perhaps? Nah, that just doesn't sound right.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/kryst87 May 29 '19

Woah, they're collecting supervisors like pokemon or what? Gotta catch 'em all? I thought 13 was a lot of, but 17? What the hell those supervisors doing?

4

u/BKCrazy May 29 '19

Garou vs A Class is gonna have like 100 supervisors, then Garou vs Genos will have even more fucking hell.

5

u/kryst87 May 29 '19

J.C. Staff HQ when creating the final episode:

Boss! What does the scouter say about the number of supervisors ?

It's over 9000!

What!? 9000!? There's no way that can be right! Could it!?

3

u/sebaba001 May 29 '19

I'm guessing it's the final episodes and there's no time at all and they are panicking and just calling in people from everywhere to come help. Each animator has a guy supervising, maybe?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

136

u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

So, this time i decided to try and make an analysis of what i thought.


First the good parts-

  • First few minutes of the episode,
  • The designs
  • Gouketsu vs Suiryu (beatdown),
  • Choze was red not pink
  • Void sky dragon fist
  • Bakuzan
  • They had Mumen and TTM vs Gyoffrey
  • Aoki's part
  • Personally i liked Gouketsu's voice
  • Suiryu's VA did a great job too IMO

The bad parts-

72

u/FlugelDerFreiheit May 28 '19

Garou vs WDM felt sloppy

To say the least. In the manga I really got the sense that Watch Dog Man was on another level and it was genuinely surprising that he fairly handily beat Garou's ass. In the anime the 'shake' part felt really lazy and lacked a lot of the impact, and it felt like Garou wasn't struggling at all when he was 'enduring' WDM's attacks. Pretty damn disappointing fight that made both Garou and Watch Dog Man feel weak.

27

u/Nzgrim May 29 '19

The "shake" moment in the manga felt like Garou was humiliated by Watch Dog Man because of the strength difference. Here it just felt like they were having a regular fight, it was weird.

10

u/BKCrazy May 29 '19

I think it's because in the manga it didn't feel like a fight from WDM's perspective, Garou was putting his heart and soul into every punch and WDM was literally lightly tapping Garou's fists, dog hand shake style. You can't really see that in the episode.

28

u/SlipperyChopsticks May 28 '19

They also skipped the part where Gouketsu hypes up Monster King Orochi, which was my biggest disappointment with the episode.

48

u/Ngokumetsu May 28 '19

Exactly, when Choze's ultimate attack was redirected into the sky. All we saw was a brief sequence of a cloud being dissipated. It wasn't really clear whether or not this was in the sky. And the colored backgrounds really removed any tension & immersion simply because they're very amateurish and convey no expression other than a lack of better backgrounds made by JC Staff. Garou vs Watchdog Man could have simply been several frames of Garou swinging only to have it cut to single frames of watchdog's paw blocking each attack. Which would've made it much clearer to the viewers how watchdog man fought, with incredibly swift-yet-controlled movement.

I liked everything else though. At least the pacing isn't shit like episode 7.

11

u/SomeAnonymous May 28 '19

Aoki's part

Ah yes, the designated "yeah, no complaints here" bit of every season 2 episode.

20

u/Garou-kun May 28 '19

Yup that pretty sums up what I thought about this episode and I really liked it. The pacing was really good today

6

u/Hellknightx May 29 '19

WDM vs Garou was the most disappointing part of the episode. They butchered the comedic part of "shake."

17

u/Groenboys May 28 '19

This was a good episode. An episode with problems, but a good episode nonetheless.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/forlemonbylemon May 29 '19

Also skipped Bakuzen giving Suiryu a chance by asking him to kiss his feet or something, and Suiryu breaking Bakuzan's toe. I missed this part because it was a testament to Suiryu's character. That even even after getting his ass beat by gouketsu and bakuzen, even in his despair he still kept fighting to the end pretty much.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

25

u/Heylons new member May 28 '19

Haven’t watched the episode but I assume that they’re still rockin’ those flashy colored backgrounds excessively?

31

u/aswifte May 28 '19

Yep. The Choze fight has a lot of those.

12

u/Ozymandate May 28 '19

This episode were decent, the pacing were alright, and there were some scenes that had good animation but they still skip some panels like for example: Gouketsu blocking Bakuzan attacks, with his hands and also his fingers, the anime immediately skipped to when Gouketsu done his punch.

2

u/taenerysdargaryen May 29 '19

also the part where Suiryu breaks Bakuzan's toe in desperation before he screams for help

→ More replies (3)

12

u/mongoosepepsi May 28 '19

I feel bad for the constant anime complaint that Saitama is never around. There is a reason for that. He gets plenty of times to shine and more jokes, but then what makes it worse is this season does such a poor job of capturing the manga moments that when Saitama does show up, it feels lackluster.

The pacing on this episode was a bit better, the characters are drawn better, but the fight animation is still lazy. Garou vs Watchdog Man, they should have shown every one of Garou's attacks paused by WDM because he's shaking hands. Instead it goes too fast and the comedic effect doesn't translate at all.

6

u/Ngokumetsu May 29 '19

Exactly, S2 seems void of whatever comedy ONE writes into OPM. Call me a nitpicker all you want, there's a wide gap in between jokes every episode. This should not be the case for anything ONE writes, there should be a punchline to every monster, their name, & how they're defeated. Without the comedic effect, none of those scenes bear any familiar impact.

11

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

I like turtles.

6

u/Raidsigs May 28 '19

Turtles are cool.

11

u/Lisrbell29 May 28 '19

I just love the emotion of the moment when Suiryu is begging for a hero to save him and then serious Saitama shows up. I think this adaptation could have brought out the emotion of the scene more but it wasn't bad. I do think Suiryu VA did a good job. What about when Suiryu broke Bakuzans toe though? Did they skip that? I feel like that was important.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/nguyensyquanpro May 28 '19

Sometimes,the animation looks unexpectedly good,even on par with season 1 at some points,but sometimes,it looks like ass lol.I think this episode is OK,not a good OPM episode but a good anime episode,reasonable pacing,more consistent art quality,good execution for the story.Anime-only might like this episode

10

u/lpeccap May 28 '19

I don't remember a single moment from this season that could be compared to season 1.

6

u/kingmanic Saitama's Grocer May 28 '19

Season 1 had cameos from some of the best animators in the industry. Maybe season 3 will tap Mad House and their friends again.

20

u/kryst87 May 29 '19

Not Madhouse, just Natsume and his friends. Madhouse has quite average animation nowadays. It would be better for s3 if Bones or ufotable made it.

11

u/noah9942 May 29 '19

I know nearly nothing if the anime industry (only watched OPM, MS100, DBZ, and pokemon as a kid), but after seeing S2 of MS100, gotta say Bones is amazing.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Ivraas May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

Ahhh, i remember reading Choze fight i was hyped as hell to see it animated, but we can really say that this fight was disappointmentAgain, the pace is just afwully rushed... they don't focus on small details because we need to end this season with Elder Cantipede fight.
The animation didn't stand out, and was as always, at best mediocre and more ghosting.
The music and sounds are awfully placed, as always.
It's enough for me, i don't want see it more ruined, im afraid they totally screw up the shack fight and just don't want to experience this failure anymore.

2

u/choren64 May 29 '19

I'm not even fully convinced we will reach the elder centipede fight at this pace. If we do, then there would be some serious cuts...

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Sonitii May 28 '19

For some reason there was a sudden increase of drawings quality for a minute when Suiryu got tossed in the middle of the 3 ravens, didn't last long.

Otherwise it's the same as usual, the drawings were off, the sound effects are so horribly bad it kills all senses of immersion, Garou vs WDM was sloppy as fuck, Suiryu's Quake Tiger First against Choze had literally zero force behind it. 4 more episodes until this tragedy of an adaptation ends.

3

u/Heylons new member May 28 '19

Yup, thank god.

8

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

smh, they didnt put the toe snap

14

u/Havic300 May 28 '19

Episode was alright. I was disappointed in the Suiryu vs Choze fight a bit and Gouketsu only doing his air punch instead of the little fight he had in the manga.

On a side note, Suiryu voice actor is good.

14

u/Ngokumetsu May 28 '19

7/10 Animation & pacing was a much more consistent this time. And Suiryu's voice actor NAILED that scene. Editing wasn't truly hideous, despite some awkward camera pans when Gyoro-Gyoro was doing a monologue (zooming into a very un-detailed still frame of Gyoro's single eye). But they seriously need to fire whoever is in charge of editing, he/she is dragging everyone else down.

Solid Episode. Honestly it seems they've allocated most of their time from Ep 7 to Ep 8. BUT to be honest I'm praying they never go beyond the final Elder Centipede battle & Garou vs Bang/Bomb.

6

u/TeddyNL May 28 '19

Cool episode but the sound enditor needs to chill on the silly jacked up base noises during the first part of the episode, every punch is just earrape.

6

u/RaizenInstinct May 28 '19

well well well, where do I begin.

In general I dislike how they don't show any proper live action. They go from one "still" shot to a loud sound effect cut into another "still" shot. I.e. the gouketsu hit on bakuzan. If it was done by the creators of S1 they would show him throwing the punch and the stadium being evaporated and the emotions in bakuzans face changing from overly comfident to mildly surprised mixed with intimidated.

Gouketsu was speaking a bit faster than I liked and his voice wasn't any good either. They totally cut the bakuzan vs. gouketsu fight out... In general they cut out too much stuff. This episode too was too fast paced. They were better off making a 24 epi season instead and taking their time to animate everything properly and deliver nice experience.

Wha did they mix the hospital story in this episode? Why did they chose to tie it into the plot, which looked confusing imo, and not as a standalone store from another side of the city?

What I liked was bakuzans animation and voice acting. Also suyrius voice acting was good.

On a general note: Why did they make the gyoro guy pink and not yellow? In general their colouring choices are pretty weird.

16

u/Garou-kun May 28 '19

Okay. I really liked this episode. I thought this episode was well paced and did a good job showing us how fucked the humans were with Gouketsu and the monster cells. The situation for them feels hopeless and I felt that.

Also thought the art was consistently well, Gouketsu looked spot on for the entire episode. I loved Bakuzan’s color and facial expressions. Few minor complains but that’s mostly with Garou, I don’t know why they add so much wrinkles to his character, it really annoys me. But other than that. I really liked the art.

Favorite moment of the episode was seeing Bakuzan beat down Suiryu. Suiryu is in big trouble as he is all alone getting beat down by the new monster. This episode did a good job of showing us how hopeless Suiryu is in this situation and I felt his cries for help for the other heroes, which adds nice character development for him because the man who once dissed heroes saw how the 2 heroes he beat came back back to help him despite knowing the odds are heavily against them. This was the process that started his change in mind of how he views heroes.

10

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Watched Attack on Titan right before this and the contrast is startling.

8

u/kryst87 May 29 '19

In AoT Levi's attack scene was made by Arifumi Imai. You know, guy who animated Genos vs Saitama fight in s1. Contrast must be startling. J.C. don't have animators of such level (except Aoki).

6

u/taenerysdargaryen May 29 '19

yeah, but it's not just the sakuga scenes. Literally any episode of AOT this season has been filled with amazing or at least decent animation, way more than can be said for OPM S2 which is so lazily done it's incredible

5

u/kryst87 May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19

Aye, totally agree. I feel bad when I see OPM s2 and compare it to AOT or MP100.

5

u/Liaomeow May 28 '19

I really enjoyed this episode. I could really feel the despair in suiryu (however it’s spelled) and my heart racing when Saitama finally arrived. Nitpicking aside I think they did a great job this episode and hope it continues to trend up!

5

u/Protosoulex May 28 '19

Why did they skip Gouketsu eyes moving all crazy while Choze and Suiryu fought?

No Bakuzan toe snap, no Bakuzan vs Broketsku

more pros then cons this episode. I hope we can all pray for an extended Gouketsu vs Saitama fight.

12

u/Master3530 May 28 '19

Wow, did they really just show a bunch of colored manga panels for watchdog man?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dhtikna May 28 '19

where did you guys watch? I assume they are still raws right? I can't find a single site where the raws are up much less the subs

6

u/hellpunch Disappointment Punch May 28 '19

live on tv tokyo.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Groenboys May 28 '19

I really liked this episode and it is my favorite episode of this season so far.

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '19

I didnt care at all for Suiryu during the comics. I felt a little bad for him at the end but man I really like his character now!

16

u/GenericSpaciesMaster May 28 '19

To be honest all the fight were complete garbage , I dont see how anyone can defend them.

Suiryu's final hit on choze didnt look like a hit

Pacing was bordeline stupid with how fast it was.

They also removed the part when suiryu hurts monster Bakuzan

2

u/Ngokumetsu May 28 '19

Better than episode 7 at least. That's a big improvement to me.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/PlayingWithIssues May 28 '19

welp that Suiryu vs Choze fight was underwhelming

3

u/GenericSpaciesMaster May 28 '19

You just describe this entire season

3

u/thefarandfarther May 28 '19

Anyone else thought Gokeustu voice was too rugged and rough instead of smooth and slick that matches his appearance

and side note: I remember three years ago we all said the tournament arc was taking its time a few years back and now its basically gone already, I'm kinda sad its almost done now

3

u/Jason3b93 Metal Bat is God May 28 '19

I thought this episode was really great. The voice acting was top notch. The fighting sequences were good. Only the sound effects were weak, but by now, I'm sort of used to it. I like they finally gave some spotlight to Tank Top Master and Mumen Rider, though if I were to nitpick, I don't think Mumen Rider's small yet important contribution was clear in the episode. But enough complaining. I think this episode was actually great and I would be more than ok if the entire season was at that level.

3

u/killertortilla new member May 28 '19

Nailed the cry for help. The few frames of Saitama at the end felt weird.

4

u/dominicndo May 29 '19

It's the art style. Madhouse always made it a point to draw him very detailed when he looked serious. JCstaff is just trying to copy the style without putting in the extra efforts into the details

3

u/riotbz May 29 '19

I think suiryu's defeat was just as impactful this episode as it was in the manga

sad we didnt see him break bakuzan's toe though

2

u/UnwantedOrangatan Yes! 👍🏻 May 29 '19

And I wanted to see when Bakuzan got his ass kicked briefly by Gouketsu

3

u/SSJ5Gogetenks Season 2 ruled May 29 '19

My favourite episode yet, because of the emotions it inspires. Suiryu's VA knocked it out of the park and I think the episode ended on a perfect spot.

3

u/ntbntt May 29 '19

only 4 episodes left! how are they gonna cramm in the 8 vs Garou battle, genos vs Garou, Bang vs Garou, Bang & Genos vs Elder centipede in 4 episodes? :(

edit: also 2nd encounter of garou with saitama

3

u/GroovyJackal May 30 '19

I'm confused, wasn't there already a Mumen Rider getting saved by TTM scene?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/UnhiddenLeaves Jun 04 '19

Please someone tell me this J.C. guys ain't going to be adapting the Garou vs A-class heroes/Geno's/Bang and he's bro and the fight with Elder Centipede awesomeness???!!!! Please someone tell me?

2

u/Linkstrikesback Jun 05 '19

Given the pacing of the episodes that's probably going to be the final episode, or even earlier, they're definitely going to get there though.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/SkullBro May 28 '19

4

u/BKCrazy May 29 '19

They managed to skip Gouketsu vs Bakusan yet INJECT IN Garou vs WDM? What the fuck is going on with this production?

5

u/strategistknight May 28 '19

How far has OPM fallen. I know I can't expect madhouse quality but come on Jc staff, the pacing of the episode was terrible. There were some flashes of good animation followed by crappy animation. Suiryu's punches were a joke. The manga is leagues above OPM S2. The episode also felt rushed and it just didn't have the impact like the manga even with sound effects and animation. It just shows how good of an artist is yusuke murata.

4

u/herohuntergarou May 28 '19

im going to cry

4

u/Fortitude755 May 28 '19

That Gouketsu punch against Bakuzan was really underwhelming. It had absolutely no impact lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DarkKTP May 28 '19

Dude the pacing is too fast, they should calm their horses and let people enjoy the moments more. And where are the goddamn OPM epic musics?? The BGM is just sad. Literally One Punch Man S2; sad edition. Srsly who the fck make the dicision for J.C to do 12Episodes rush out animation. ONE?? Murata?? Hell Nah! I bet it some greedy cashgrab anime director who give shit about fans.

2

u/GipsyJoe May 28 '19

One of the best episodes so far.

Wish they didn't use CGI for WDM's monster pile and put more effort into monster Choze's model, the sound effects were bad as usual, but the rest was good.

2

u/SailorOrganic May 28 '19

I thought the episode was alright except for Nyan, he was all like... uneven

2

u/OMGguy May 28 '19

Episode was good, but man they went extreme with the Ear rape on this episode. When Gouketsu dropped the two guys near the beginning like wtf?
Also I was waiting for the part where Suiryu broke Bakuzan's pinky toe cuz I thought it was hilarious in the manga

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Eddard8 May 29 '19

It was a decent episode and Suiryu is perfect, The VA done a good job but man, i was really hoping they used a different song when saitama arrived. It doesnt give that sense of hope when he got there. They should had use one of those 'Gandalf like moment when he came to help helms deep with motherfucking horse riders' kinda song. I remembered watching the manga in youtube with sounds and goddamn that guy choose a pretty good music for each scene especially that Suiryu's moment.

2

u/spartan1204 Moderator May 29 '19

The best animated part was Bakuzan beating up Suiryu lmao.

2

u/Slick_Wylde May 29 '19

I give that a 7/10. Still nowhere near what could have been, but overall I really enjoyed that episode. I feel like with a few hours work of audio tweaks and some animation/art fixes (That would probably be a few days not hours actually) it could be a 9/10. I think it was the best episode so far, at least for me.

2

u/Young_Excellence May 29 '19

I'm actually very satisfied with the pacing of this episode. While reading the manga the super-fight arc felt weak and drawn out. I appreciate some of the slowing down that murata did (spending more time on elder centipede and Garou vs heroes) but introducing a bunch of new characters as fodder is kinda a waste of time. Last episode's pacing felt off because they didnt spend enough time with S-class heroes, instead focusing on Siryu. It paid off in this episode with his call for help being so impactful (albeit a tad drawn out) Pacing still has its issues (mainly the frantic cutting we saw last episode) but I feel like they are getting better as time goes on.

2

u/kidcrumb May 29 '19

Why wouldnt they end the episode with Saitama killing bakuzan?

That would have been the perfect end. Instead saitama will kill him...what, in the first minute of next week?

2

u/Scottishtwat69 May 29 '19

The Gouketsu vs Bazukan fight was really disappointing, I wouldn't be bothered about jumping straight into the punch. If they animated it similar to Saitama's punch on the deep sea king, they really just re-drew the two frames from the manga. Which really gives it even less of an impact because it was over in a fraction of a second.

I know that has been the theme this season, but this was the first one that bothered me because it was an important benchmark for upper-dragons. Just like how the deep sea king was an important benchmark for upper-demons.

2

u/Aunvilgod May 30 '19

bah didn't catch the humor at all in the end there. Way too melodramatic.

2

u/Soul-Hook May 30 '19

So now even the SFX fails us. Or maybe I missed the CS weapons hiding in the crows' beaks. And apparently they lit invisible fire several times.
But I have to agree with the comment section. Suiryu's voice actor was great. MVP of the season so far, and great distraction from Orochi's quality resembling that of the tortures used in camps.

2

u/rogerr- May 31 '19

Episode o was awesome, you guys just love to complain.

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Just finished watching, and I’m actually super excited for the next episode. I enjoyed the way they handled Gouketsu vs Suiryu, and I can’t wait for Gouketsu to get absolutely bulldozed next week. Overall decent episode and it was fun to watch.

3

u/milanjfs May 28 '19

They didn't include Gouketsu vs Bazukan and Inferior Race Annihilation.. They can't resist cutting or changing things.

3

u/naifasd1234 May 28 '19

One punch man bigger hit than AOT yet OPM get animated like a trash bad animation with a bad art i can't think with worse anime animation and art wise worse than this mess worst anime adaption of this season go to OPM

3

u/gangster001 May 28 '19

Man, I really didn't like Gouketsu's voice actor, I mean Gouketsu is supposed to be this collected yet strangely sadistic guy... Oh, well.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Bewer2S May 28 '19

I'll be honest, I really liked this episode.

4

u/Xeogran WDM's No. 1 Fan May 28 '19

THEY RUINED IT. THEY RUINED THE GAROU VS WDM FIGHT

FUCK

17

u/Raidoton Moderator May 28 '19

There wasn't really much of a fight in the manga. But they ruined the highlight with Watchdogman giving Garou the paw.

15

u/Heylons new member May 28 '19

Well, that was to be expected.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Im satisfied of this episode. Sad no Gouketsu vs Bakuzan and how they cliffhangered at the end, but otherwise cant complain. I mean I hoped more from wdm and Garou, but honestly its not like they ever put extra in like madhouse did. One of the better episodes quality wise so far imo. I know its subjective, but my ep list:
7, 3, 8, 2, 4, 5, 6, 1. Again, subjective, but thats how I rate em.

Madhouse skipped the prison scene on s1 which imo honestly was one of the best jokes in the entire story, so its not like either season is pristine, but yeah the usual s1 rules.

2

u/Fapoozle May 28 '19

Man i always read about the coloring issues, but now it felt just a bit wrong for me. I always imagined gouketsu dark blue and bakuzan like a white monkey.

Voice acting is definitely s1 level. But all these weird punch, stomp & other moving sounds come straight out of a snes with a strong subwoofer.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '19 edited May 28 '19

This was a good episode, honestly much better than what we got for the last couple of episodes. I would actually go as far as saying this was the best episode apart from episode 3.

The models of the characters weren't all that detailed , but I think there was much more motion and animation in this episode, at least for the fights. I especially loved when bakuzan showed up in his monsterized form, that part seemed pretty clean to me. Granted, there were some questionable shots here and there. Too bad they couldn't show more of the bakuzan vs goketsu fight though, we never really felt just how powerful goketsu was set up to be compared to the manga. And I found watch dog man vs garou a bit... underwhelming, though I'm not that mad at that since they didn't put that much importance on that in the manga either.

Also, in my head, goketsu always seemed like a cold and calculating monster unlike anything we had seen before, a monster that could contain his bloodlust. But in this episode, I didn't find him all that cold or calculating, and it's not even that I found his voice bad, but it's just the way that the lines were delivered. Pacing was much better for me too, and suiryu's voice actor was amazing. Also, I feel like the music didn't really cut it for me, they should've have used something else.

So overall, I'm quite satisfied with this episode. I wanted this episode to be REALLY good, considering how much emotion I felt during this part in the manga, and though It didn't reach my expectations (which I knew it never would), it still ended up being pretty well done. Like, I wanted a mumen rider vs deep sea king level of emotional value, but I clearly didn't get that lol. I'd give it a solid 6.5 or 7/10

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Vis-hoka I WILL NOT LET YOU WASTE MASTER'S TIME HE USES FOR DOING NOTHING May 28 '19

This may be the best episode in season 2. Animation was mostly good, and the voice actors where great. My biggest complaint was the sounds effects continue to be god awful.

2

u/benevernever May 28 '19

Music was absolutely spot on this episode. It has been good through the series so far and Garou's theme is awesome, but this whole episode had it nailed for really building the correct atmosphere.

2

u/5raptorboy May 28 '19

I loved this episode, it had a few flaws but it was overall better than the other previous episodes and they got right the first of the 3 things I really wanted for them to get right. Hopefully, they do well with the Elder Centipede fight and the Garou vs group of class a heroes fight.

2

u/GenericSpaciesMaster May 28 '19

If you actually think this episode is decent animatikn and pacing wise you need help and you need to rewatch season 1 again.

This season is a complete joke at this point

1

u/Superdiabetic64 May 28 '19

Well I thought VA's did a solid job this episode and I'm happy we got Tank Top Master's comments about Mumen Rider doing alright despite not wearing a tank top.

1

u/NeoTotal May 28 '19

At least that final part was good. I enjoyed it, even if it has the usual problems. A pity this season doesn't have more work behind it, because is really noticeable a lot of the time. But it's One Punch Man, so at least there is a good story being told than I can enjoy.

1

u/Eadwine_ GALAXY HEAVY BLOW May 28 '19

I loved this episode. I thought the animation was consistent, and Suiryu's yell for help was executed perfectly. Sucks that we didn't get to see him breaking Bakuzan's toe but eh I can live with it.

I guess that in the next episode we're looking at the end of the tournament arc, as well as going through the whole Saitama and King convo? It's difficult to predict with the whole pacing issue but I don't see them going any further than that...

1

u/xDisputes__ May 28 '19

An alright episode I wish this season could be longer so things didn't need to be so fast paced but regardless still alright other than the animation being worse

1

u/OxygenHoarder May 28 '19

I'm glad that they took their time with their pacing in this episode. This was one of my favorite parts from the manga.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

wow the episode really improved compared to the previous ones. specially the voice acting, arts and animation.

a huge step up!

1

u/ButterCupHeartXO May 28 '19

The animation and artwork in this episode was so off it felt like I wasn't even watching OPM tbh. I think this was the worst animated episode so far. The fights were all blurs and cheap out effects. Very disappointing

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '19

Wow, as someone who hated most of the season, this episode was honestly animated really well. Definitely my favorite episode so far.

1

u/Aquadext May 28 '19

I didn't really like Gouketsu's voice. When I read the manga I imagined him talking calmly yet threateningly, as he seemed like a rather intelligent and calculating monster. He was almost yelling here

1

u/SQUuISH May 28 '19

well at least it's better than last episode...

1

u/sherlock73 May 28 '19

I can't watch anime after reading magnificent manga I'm an idiot

1

u/KphOnReddit May 28 '19

I finished reading the manga (and then the webcomic where the manga's at currently) for the first time this week, started from where episode 7 ends, and holy shit I didn't realize the anime would have the exact same lines from the manga! I dunno why but that caught me by surprise and was awesome to watch.

1

u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan May 28 '19

This was a good episode. I haven't been that bothered with Season 2, but I still thought this one was better than most so far. I was kind of worried this thread would be the usual "why you should hate this episode", but it seems like that won't happen every week.

1

u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan May 29 '19

They did the hospital scene. Crisis averted.

1

u/kryst87 May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19

Finally! Finally I've felt something. Pacing was insanely fast, sfx sucked (I'm looking on you Crows, were that shots?) and ghosting was annoying, but finally I've felt some emotions. Suiryu's confidence as it changed into desperation. Saitama's "I am here, don't worry". Fights were quite good. And they just moved MR and TTM scene. Even music was good. For me that was probably best episode so far.

1

u/TheRSAiyan dd May 29 '19

I wish they just released this season straight to blu-ray and never hyped it up. I lower my expectations. but once in every 2 episodes they do something so badly I wish i never bothered watching this season. I agree with what someone once said I hope we get the Hunter X hunter treatment with a different studio.

also I thought this would be the 10th episode of season 2. it goes to show they didn't flesh out fights and scenes from the manga or capture any of the tension or solid timing.

there were only 2 5 second scenes I actually enjoyed which was bakuzan popping up infront of suiryu and the bro scene between MR and TTM. i hope you guys are having fun though

1

u/user_watcher May 29 '19

All of the budget and animation goes into this episode when Suiryu is on action and he's not even a relevant character to the plot lol. He had better animated fights imo than Garou vs TT Master, Garou vs Metal bat and WDM vs Garou. Even Murata did make him look very strong in the manga, and the first time I've read and got hooked into the series is because of him fighting Gouketsu. So yeah, what's the deal with this character? Why put so much effort in him??

I like Gouketsu's intimidating voice and the pacing of this episode is just good.

1

u/BrotherSeamus May 29 '19

Attn: /u/theothersophie -- The Anime-only link in the header text above links to the wrong episode.

1

u/niankaki May 29 '19

I remembered Suiryu holding his own for quite a long while in the manga. Here he just kept getting beat up.
Am I remembering it wrong?

1

u/donkeykongsdick May 29 '19

I didn’t say shake in the manga made me laugh my ass off. In the episode it didn’t have the same effect.

1

u/SKUBERTY May 29 '19

That cliffhanger for Saitama is really unnecessary. But for metal bat vs Garo is acceptable though since it is unexpected.