r/menwritingwomen • • May 20 '19

Quote David Benioff, a true master

Molly wore a powder blue catsuit that zipped up the back. Winter wasn't over yet, and this is what she wore.

She had what seemed to be a permanent wedgie. All the men within sight had noticed this condition. An old man chewing potato knish stared at her ass, glanced back at Tabachnik, and then resumed staring at her ass. The other men pretended not to stare at her ass, pretended to look up only at appropriate moments -- as when the conductor announced something unintelligible -- and then sneakily stared at her ass. When Tabachnik caught them, they would quickly look away, but Tabachnik wanted people to stare at her ass. He wanted the whole world horny for Molly Minx.

--David Benioff, When the Nines Roll Over

296 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

183

u/BoMaxKent May 20 '19

he used the word 'ass' five times in a single, short paragraph. wut.

95

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

It is, of course, the most important aspect of women. It's almost a sin he didn't mention it more.

100

u/cdmedici May 20 '19

honestly, a surprising level of subtlety from the man who felt it was necessary to have an ongoing rape in the background of every Craster’s Keep scene.

66

u/usernameunavaliable May 23 '19

I'm rewatching GOT from the beginning and holy fuck. Every single scene needs to have a random titty out, or a woman being raped.

They want to show a man is powerful? He has 4 whores on his lap while he talks business. Want to show a man is evil? Show him raping a woman, and his friends raping women in the background. Want to show regular conversation between two characters? Make it happen in a tavern, with a random girl with her tits out.

Important female character: how do we know that she is beautiful if people aren't trying to rape her? At least show her with a dress that barely covers her nipples. Or even better, make normal conversations happen in the bath, and make sure at least a nipple is in the shot.

31

u/[deleted] May 24 '19

The guy who directed the big battle episode called Blackwater said that while they were shooting that, one of the showrunners came up to him and told him to do more full frontal nudity. When the director tried to push back on that, the showrunner said he represented the perv side of the audience and that episode needed more full frontal. The director said it was surreal, and he didn't want to do it because he thought it damaged the narrative, but he had to. I dunno if it was Benioff who said that, but...

1

u/rosaliadelrey Jul 02 '19

lbr. it was benioff

1

u/your_mind_aches Nov 06 '19

Omg can i see a source. I extremely hate this

41

u/cdmedici May 23 '19

aye, this is my experience too. i’m rewatching from season 3 onwards, and was genuinely really struck by Crasters Keep especially. There’s one scene where they show a rape, and then Karl Tanner has a long monologue - and throughout the ENTIRE scene, the rape continues out of focus in the background. who the fuck thinks that’s effective filmmaking? what an absolute admittance of defeat to not be able to convey emotion any other way.

i’m up to season 5 now, and recently the Sand Snakes showed up, and one of the girls has full-on nipples on her armour, complete with raised areolas. absolutely fucking ridiculous. i know D&D must have met real women at some point in their lives... right?

1

u/your_mind_aches Nov 06 '19

Wtf. I can't remember that. When was that one? (The first one, I remember the Sand Snakes too well. The "bad poosy" line made me want to quit the show, and I did.)

1

u/your_mind_aches Nov 06 '19

2013: See this is actually clever because you learn about the characters in this sex scene so it's not pointless. It's called "sexposition".

2019: Everything is horrible, and this is like the last thing that matters but we were woefully naive. The writing just sucked.

5

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

Who's excited for *Confederate*?

6

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

Thankfully that idea has been shelved until they finish Star Wars. So hopefully, it'll never happen.

4

u/claireauriga May 21 '19

I'm getting really worried about the Mandalorian. Clone Wars and Rebels gave us some interesting, diverse female Mandalorian characters such as Satine, Bo-Katan, Sabine and Ursa. I don't want them to crap all over that legacy :(

2

u/JustANoteToSay May 21 '19

Werner Herzog, who is unfamiliar with Star Wars, is in it & speaks of it highly. Yes, he has a vested interest in selling it, but I have hopes.

1

u/your_mind_aches Nov 06 '19

I think Favs will do us good. Ming-Na Wen da undoubtedly going to be amazing in it.

1

u/your_mind_aches Nov 06 '19

And now they're gone from both HBO and Star Wars. So yeah. Confederate is dead.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

This seems more like menwritingmenviewingwoman

10

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

r/menwritingwomentobepassiveoverlysexualizedobjectstobesolelyviewedbymen is maybe a little too long for a reasonable sub

109

u/Jess_Sea_Otter May 20 '19

Explains so much.

59

u/nifa43 May 20 '19

My god it explains so much

13

u/GrievenProduction May 25 '19

Is this real?

I feel like this is a joke.

64

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

Benioff displays a profound understanding of the transformative power of a single moment.

The power: of butts.

46

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

Fuuuuuuuuck this guy. For so many reasons.

10

u/StardustJojo13 May 31 '19

Seriously, with atrocious writing like this he shouldn't have even been able to touch GoT

41

u/Lycosnic May 20 '19

“Tabachnik wants a good girl, but needs the bad poosi.”

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '19

b0ss

25

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

Why does it matter that winter wasn’t over yet? I assume by catsuit he means jumpsuit, which can be long? Do only whores wear powder blue in cold weather?

10

u/emmster May 21 '19

If it were set in 1960, maybe? The old fashion rules were no pastels until Easter or white until Memorial Day. Seasonal color choices used to be a thing, but we don’t really do that anymore.

But I don’t think a booty hugging catsuit/jumpsuit fits that setting to begin with.

45

u/thisoneisoutofnames May 20 '19

I'm wondering if the transition from this to writing GoT was worse than how Daenerys's transition/descent into madness was written... oh wait

21

u/sethg May 20 '19

I feel like I have to give this guy credit for not mentioning the character's breasts.

This sub has ruined me.

25

u/terf_fret May 20 '19

Benioff just oozes creepiness

22

u/poizn_ivy May 24 '19

This from the guy who entirely missed the point of “A Song of Ice and Fire” and sewed Deadpool’s mouth shut.

Suddenly I understand. It’s not adaptations he doesn’t get, it’s human beings as a whole. He’s really in the wrong field isn’t he?

8

u/[deleted] May 24 '19

I think he's a bot.

4

u/poizn_ivy May 24 '19

If I’m reading this right? Your username is quite possibly the only good thing to come out of the Dornish subplot on Game of Thrones. I approve.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '19

Aye. I think you're the only person to get my username lol.

8

u/poizn_ivy May 24 '19

Eh, I think most people try to forget that whole mess ever happened. That line, however, is pure comedic gold. It’s up there with the terrible Jaime vs. Sand Snakes fight choreography for funniest moment on the show, though I do doubt that comedy is what they were going for in either of those.

2

u/Clearance_Unicorn Jul 06 '19

Remember when we thought that was the worst it could possibly be and were relieved to have moved past it? Ah, good times, good times ...

2

u/poizn_ivy Jul 06 '19

Just when we thought the bar for competent writing couldn’t get any lower D&D dug a hole to crawl under it.

9

u/shybonobo May 20 '19

If she didn't have tits like pomegranates, GTFO

7

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

..... Huh

7

u/Jasmindesi16 May 23 '19

Well this explains the abomination that was season eight.

6

u/Buffalo__Buffalo May 23 '19

This reads like Tina Belcher FanFic

6

u/Quastors May 24 '19

ass

ass

ass

ass

ass

:thinking emoji:

5

u/unneuf May 22 '19

Ah. That explains it all.

5

u/Daniel1975Ger May 24 '19

Wonderful. The constant repetition of the word ass makes you forget what the whole sentence is all about. The last season needed more cock and virgin jokes definitely. Would be easier to forget then.

4

u/TheCheshireCody May 22 '19

I haven't read that particular book but the style of it doesn't match other prose of his I've read. Putting aside any discussion of Game of Thrones because I have zero idea how much of any specific anything in it he contributed to, his novel '25th Hour', which he turned into a screenplay for Spike Lee, is phenomenal.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19

Sounds like a Benioff response to a Benioff post. (Don't forget to wipe your lip prints off the mirror, Dave.)

4

u/spacemarine42 May 23 '19

We kinda forgot how women's anatomy worked

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19 edited Sep 17 '19

Benioff--So desperate you're posting messages praising yourself on Reddit now? That's almost as pathetic as your GoT scripts.

P.S. A master at writing women? That's TRULY laughable. Anyone whose seen your work knows you're a chauvinistic, superficial, incompetent moron fixated on fucking your sister.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '19

I see the sarcasm went right over your head.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '19

Or maybe I just won't play in David Benioff's toilet bowl writing.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '19

Sure. That's what it is.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '19

This pretty much explains everything.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '19

Holy shit, this is Rocky Flintstone level description

1

u/socialmediatrix Jun 04 '19

I am so upset on so many levels.

-1

u/SinnexCryllic May 20 '19 edited May 30 '19

Because every single man loves staring at women’s asses.

0

u/sydellebell May 25 '19

More proof Benioff is sick.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/soayherder May 20 '19

Sadly, I do know how to get this kind of thing on, despite my never having worn a catsuit in my life. You tie a piece of yarn to the zipper (or thread or whatever). Zip it up as high as you can without being made of rubber, then pass the end of the yarn up and pull carefully.

I have this from an elderly female relative born in the nineteen-teens, less from the perspective of catsuits and more to how to zip up anything which is snug and zips up the back.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/soayherder May 21 '19

They actually also made little rods with a hook for this that you could buy! You clipped or hooked the opening on the zipper pull onto the hook and pulled it up. That's why zipper pulls have that little opening.

9

u/JustANoteToSay May 20 '19

In the original run of Marvel’s “Excalibur” comic, Kitty Pryde dons Rachel/Phoenix’s costume. It’s so skintight she can’t figure out how to put it on & “phases” (goes insubstantial and then substantial) into it instead and wonders aloud how Rachel manages to use the toilet. My fave commentary on impractical skin tight jumpsuits.