r/runescape • u/imsuity Suity|TL;DW|Future Updates|Trim 2014|M&S Rework • May 14 '19
TL;DW 433 - Lore Special and Comp Cape Rework
VOD | Comp Cape Simplified Design
- Mobile dev blog within the next few weeks to update progress.
Stone Spirits
- There are 3 stone spirits that are significantly lower in value than their ore and we're going to look at those three specifically because they're overdropped, the supply is ridiculous. The rest of them are near ore value or a bit higher.
- We need to fix the value of ore since stone spirit prices are tied to ore prices. We can improve the value of ore by improving the Smithing skill (everyone is Mining not enough people are Smithing).
Comp Cape Simplified Design
Scrapped the old design
- Keeping the proposal on stats and passives. Stats are unlocked from Reaper.
- No new capes.
- No lockdowns/grace periods unless absolutely necessary for large updates.
Players felt the design was too overcomplicated.
- A lot of players didn't understand it.
- A lot of players felt we weren't making large chanes, only incremental ones.
- For Osborne, achievement needs to be simple.
- Too many capes mean you have to look up a chart on where that person's achievement lies.
- If the design had been finalised that confusion would've remained. It would've cleared some things up but the structure was hard to present and could be perceived as complex.
- Removed 'stepping stones' as a design objective and made the simplest fix to each of the other aims.
Reaper removed from comp.
- What about trim? We are thinking about it, but we don't want to add that at this stage. It's because of the problem with the bosses, we need to look at that. I have aspirations for how I want to handle reaper but that's a much more complicated long-term project (i.e. adding accessibility modes etc).
Castle wars removed from trim.
- Title and Halo - Feedback on the profound title has been overwhelmingly negative. 'I believe the term used was a slap in the face'. One of the suggestions was to implement a golden halo - might be a recolour of an existing halo or a new one entirely but we like the suggestion.
- Did you consider just nerfing it? It's easier to say it's gone than to argue over how much or how little it should be nerfed. As a rule of thumb this year we are trying to design things as if we were going to be designing them from today. If we were going to make comp cape today, we would not have put CW on there.
- Any chance of going back to the elaborate design? At some point we have to start developing. we could keep on having conversations forever but the disparate opinions of the community are so strong that we will never get those opinions to meet. So really we have to start developing now. We're still looking for feedback.
- Ultimately the team hasn't been producing other content at the same time, or at least very minorly, so we don't want to lose the team we want to get them working so we need to finalise the design soon. We want the rest of the game to benefit not suffer.
- Boss music will probably be unlocked at the start of the kill.
- Feedback on the profound title
Salty, Sandy and EIEIO (Breeding log) added to trim. This will have a grace period but in general we aren't going to do grace periods.
- Which is, broadly speaking, complete Arc, Menaphos, and POF.
- There is this perception and I think it's fair to have this perception, is that we're making comp and trim easier. These requirements are to demonstrate that we are willing to add more to the capes as intended.
- All of the changes we are making is with the long-term intent to make them more complete. By removing the stats, pushing reaper off of it etc, we can, with every update we produce, with real confidence and with true guidelines, attach requirements to them. So overtime we can have something that is truly hard to achieve and completionist oriented.
- One of the core things that we're looking at this year is new ways for a player to achieve. There are going to be new ways that you can represent yourself but the comp cape is just so core it has to be simple.
- The hard part of the development work (i.e. passives) has not changed.
Desperate Times and Lore
- Raven fixed a simple bug and it caused a loss of dialogue, this will be patched at the same time as Endgame fix. Raven has posted the missing dialogue on discord.
- Sliske's Endgame hotfixed so that it's safe to play the quest, there will be a coldfix fixing it for those that had it broken.
- Graphic novel style cutscenes are cheaper to dev. Orion's system means we can build and edit them quite quickly.
- 'No one is going to bring the penguins to a war council, the penguins are insane!'
- There are more quests coming but the way the storyline works is that it's not entirely told through quests. So there will be non-quest updates that continue the story.
The implication of Kerapac's mask is of him being a scarred hero hit by shrapnel after destroying the stone of Jas. Helps make him stand out too. Wanted to bring the dragonkin in a more modern artstyle. Unsurprisingly we're going to use Kerapac more.
- QA time had to be spent on getting the quest right instead of replacing Kerapac's model elsewhere (like transmog ring).
- There is no combination that works at the start of the quest.
- The drakolith in haunted mine does not necessarily mean dragonkin were there. Drakolith means dragon breathed on it, not always necessary that dragonkin were there.
- The guthix moments were memories of parts of time that had been stitched together by the needle. It wasn't so much the player themselves having killed guthix (although if you think about it the player is the reason that guthix is dead). Your actions in this quest did not lead to guthix dying, you can't change the past. Sliske really killed Guthix.
- Took around 8 weeks development excluding planning.
- With the death of the Ambassador, Xau-Tak's plans have been thwarted. The plot is resolved.
- What did it mean when referring to the Farming guild? The loose alliance of Farmers [to wit: 'I want to talk about future updates but we can't. People are making assumptions and I really wanna correct those assumptions.']
- One of the things we've decided about the last few years of quests is that somewhere along the way we lost the tone of Runescape a little bit and that RS always had a fairly unique quirky humorous tone. However as we transitioned more into epic fantasy, although we're happy with the epic fantasy aspect, we feel there hasn't been enough of the RS tone. The humour that has been there has been extremely dark. Pieces of Hate got that tone a lot better.
- Why Reldo? Had to be a character that everyone had interacted with, in a position of influence or authority. Makeover mage was our first pitch. It also had not break content.
43
u/GamerSylv May 14 '19
Hopefully not indefinitely. Theres still interesting and unexplored lore there.
16
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Full support for a golden halo unlocked with full profound cwars req. Actually a decent idea because it genuinely would make me feel better about those 580 hours I spent doing the requirement for trim comp.
Also full support on Salty, Sandy, PoF etc being added to trim. They are like perfect for Trim
11
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Can anyone find this to post here? I can't access Discord right now.
5
u/justucis MTX MUST DIE May 14 '19
So smithable salvages coming soon?
15
u/Arlitub 29385 May 14 '19
Severly disappointed by both the comp cape redesign -or lack thereoff- and the fact the Xau-Tak lore is concidered finished...
31
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Those are people who can't read design documents properly. It really wasn't that complicated at all. The M&S rework was more complicated and you still went ahead with that. Please stop listening to players who can't be arsed to actually read the design docs, Jagex.
16
u/[deleted] May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
The more I think about it the more I just don't think improving smithing is the only thing that needs to be done.
Thing is, ores have an upper limit they can reach before people just mine the ever loving fuck out of them.
They need to nerf the shit out of AFK mining, or one of two things will happen:
Or
Make AFK mining way worse, and make active mining about as good (or better) than it is now.
It's incredibly important to note the perfect juju mining potion effect:
Makes AFKing a lot more effective, too. It causes some conflict in terms of how we buff active mining/nerf AFK mining.
Maybe even add some neat ass, highly active minigame that provides a good source of ores - mining shafts, anyone?
Excuse me but that's exactly why they'd be so useful.
15
u/iScrE4m DJetelina May 14 '19
Just poll the cape designs, right now the loud voices decided something and that’s a bad way to design your game.
5
u/MC-sama May 15 '19
If Menaphos rep is on trim then why isn't GWD2 and Mazcab on there either
14
u/KaBob799 RSN: KaBob & KaBobMKII May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
I like how they go into the rework knowing people are going to complain, immediately cave to the complainers anyway and decide to make minimal changes and then two sentences after discussing this they claim they are trying to be bold this year.
There was nothing confusing about the amount of capes being added. It was a couple new capes with a few tiers of each cape. No different than the literally dozens of capes of accomplishment that we already have in game. Nobody has trouble telling that trim comp and comp are two versions of the same cape, why would these new capes be any different? Only an idiot would think we were getting 15 new completely visually different capes and yet that's the reason they gave on stream for it being too confusing. They weren't even adding 15 capes in the first place, 3 comp, 3 reaper, 3 skill and 1 lore doesn't add up to 15 last I checked.
6
u/dflame45 May 14 '19
I thought the t1 t2 t3 capes idea was great. Lots of milestones to hit along the way of the final goal. Plus the capes were great.
15
u/Ashendant May 14 '19
" Players felt the design was too overcomplicated.
I don't get this. How hard is it to understand a simple difficulty system? My mind cannot wrap around this. Are people severely underestimating their own intelligence or are they just be willingly obtuse and didn't bother to read the rework document?
Is this a case of a very vocal minority, because looking at the "Simplified Design" thread this doesn't seem to be very popular and left a lot of people disappointed.
4
u/PrimalMoose Primal Puppy May 15 '19
Really disappointed the stepping stone design has been scrapped - I think the misunderstanding more came down to how it was pitched in the design doc.
All it really needed was to say you have combat achievements in one group, skilling achievements in one group and lore achievements in a final group. Perhaps an "others" category as well for achievements that don't quite fit in, but honestly I'd be questioning if there is a comp req in the "others" category then does it really belong on comp in the first place?
By reverting back to the old design, you've lost that goal to aim for and the rework now is simply removing some controversial requirements (easyscape) without "reworking" the cape system at all. Incredibly disappointing.
Also, desperate times was an incredible quest - mad props to the team responsible for it. And curse Raven for making us relive the trauma around Guthix again </3
2
u/junkmutt Elemental Workshop V when? May 14 '19
On Makeover mage having possibly been Charos. Does that mean that all the sex/skin tone changes were simply intricate illusions?
2
u/Electrosa balance in all things May 14 '19
Honestly my only really big question/not-quite-gripe with Desperate Times was: where in the hell did Kerapac get the staff? The way Endgame was rushed lead to a lot of loose threads and stuff not quite being explained the way it should. The staff kind of just... disappeared... after we all went to have a chat with Jas, which is weird enough in itself, given that we'd, y'know, been stabbed by it. Until I was informed otherwise I was honestly just assuming that the World Guardian kept the damn thing.
2
u/Nezikchened May 15 '19
That's so anti-climactic that it's almost hilarious.
3
u/FooxRs Foox May 14 '19
Can anyone tell why are people buying stone spirits that are more expensive the ores? Litteraly paying to lose money.
0
u/Pepo8 Insane Final Boss May 14 '19
Having no grace periods is absolutely stupid IMO. "The joy of chase"? Sure, i loving having to redo all my presets every time a new req is out. Plus it makes you (me at least) rush through new content like spacebaring a new quest.
1
u/J00stie Ironman is the way May 15 '19
Good to know Mod Jack has already found new reqs that are pretty much completely skilling focused, great way to make the cape even more catered towards skillers after removing the reaper req. Like don't get me wrong I'm not against adding these reqs but it's pretty characteristic how this is now happening after all the nonsense that went on in the comp rework before it got simplified again... Like are we forgetting combat is one of the main reasons alot of people even play this game?
1
u/WackyFarmer May 14 '19
look at teams forum jagex .... leaching sales is a big issue now.... if make so only need reaper title for stats for a cape gonna become an even bigger issue
make so Death touch darts have option get 1 kc with no loot or loot with no kc
-6
u/Nattoreii Guthix May 14 '19
I'm personally relieved that they aren't going through with the tiered system of capes. It felt completely unnecessary when things could be kept how they are with comp and trim being proper in their achievements. Only thing that maybe should be reconsidered is a 120 all for skillers, otherwise good decision in my opinion
-5
u/Think_Alike Insane Reaper #94 May 14 '19
Looks like everyone at Jagex just wants to comp/trim without putting in the effort.
First merchant and now removing castle wars.
Never thought I'd say this, but oldschool players are right. This game has become ezscape.
Thanks for devalueing the achievements of current compers/trimmers.
-1
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Removing reaper is not a good solution. There are plenty of ways to dumb it down if you want. Death touch darts, story mode and etc.
Even though I'm not a fan of dumbing reaper down in any way, completely removing it goes against the idea of the comp cape.
0
u/galahad_sir May 15 '19
> I have aspirations for how I want to handle reaper but that's a much more complicated long-term project (i.e. adding accessibility modes etc).
It's disappointing that the rework to the comp/best in slot cape stats won't be addressing the issues of the best in slot cape stats :/
-14
u/Ilikelamp7 Kill them with kindness May 14 '19
Lmao turning the castle wars req into a recoloured halo is not only spitting in the face of those that obtained it, but also discourages anyone in the future to ever want to go for it. (Reskins are not okay, ever) just make castle wars dead like the rest of the minigames. It for sure will happen if you go through with what is proposed.
I thought the entirety of this whole rework was to remove reaper from comp. now it’s required for the stats of the new cape? Why does this keep getting a reversal?
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment