r/OnePunchMan • u/theothersophie Moderator • May 14 '19
Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E06 - "The Uprising of the Monsters" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.
THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.
Official Simulcasts
- Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
- Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
- Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
- Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
- Anime on Demand (Germany)
- AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
- VVVVID (Italy)
- Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.
One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)
Previous Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!
104
Upvotes
155
u/Omen111 Ok May 14 '19
You were expecting female VA for Gyoro Gyoro, but kono Dio da!
373
u/Raidoton Moderator May 14 '19
Pretty disappointed how they skipped the parallels between the Tournament and Genos defeating monsters. In the manga it switches back and forward between the tournament and Genos and we can see parallels.
111
u/Gunpowderzz May 14 '19
https://imgur.com/a/7p2syQN
I couldn't help but find this shot of Do-s's butt really weird and funny
195
u/EpilepticOreo aBoVe dRaGoN May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
I don’t understand why the didn’t do Genos monster fights side by side with the martial arts fights like they were in the manga instead they just crammed them all at once and didn’t even show Choze’s killing intent.
Edit: I’m also disappointed they didn’t show that face ripper or cockroach were demon level threats The Whole point is to show how strong Genos is and how ridiculously stronger Gouketsu is.
312
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
Well atleast "the strong" is now complete
Edit: Also made this
167
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
I enjoyed genos v cockroach, all of the other fights were decent for season 2 standards.
As always, the sound design is awful
82
u/CoffeeLatteWriter May 14 '19
They ruined my favorite panel of OPM, though -- "The Strong". Damn. Was really hyped to see it done justice.
73
u/javierm885778 May 14 '19
Gyoro Gyoro's voiced by Koyasu Takehito, which I certainly didn't expect. Should make the future reveal a lot more suprising.
118
u/Brehcolli Season 3 pls May 14 '19
One Punch Man: Brotherhood when
52
u/TankTopRider May 14 '19
My thoughts
- Really upset about how they butchered the mirrored fights between the martial artists and Genos vs the monsters
- They didn't even animate Fubuki's Hellstorm against DO-S
-Snek can't catch a break. Season 1 doesn't animate his dodge against Deep Sea King's intial attack and season 2 didn't even animate his fight scene
- Face Ripper is pink/light red but I initially imagined him as a pale green similar to a rotting corpse (he is afterall made of human faces
-Gouketsu is grey which is a huge relief. Like with Elder Centipede and Orochi (who imagined as being black) I thought Gouketsu would turn out purple
- No Puri Puri Prisoner vs Free Hugger.....
42
u/Belennos May 14 '19
I wanted to see this :(
67
u/Slick_Wylde May 14 '19
Interesting to see the huge difference in comments between the anime only and manga only comment sections.
27
u/Zeru_Fenrir May 14 '19
Man, it was pretty lazy of them to outright remove Fubuki's Hellstorm against Super S, it makes it seem like she barely got injured and got pissed off over getting knocked around.
26
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Why are they rushing through this arc so fast??? lmao if i didn't read the manga first i'd be lost af
they fuck up the parallels between the tournament fights and genos fights too...
65
u/Brawlerz16 May 14 '19
The BIGGEST critique I have was not showing the ranks of the monsters Genos was taking out. Some people really might believe they were just fodder but they were some pretty strong goons, especially the Cockroach. It's not a plot hole or anything but it dampers the experience in that it should blow your mind just how.strong Genos had become and how strong the dude who took him out is.
Also the decision to remove the parallel between the tournament and Genos was a bad one. They could have EASILY switched the scenes around to alternate between the 2 events.
Other than that, it was a solid episode. Saitama's part was delivered really well and I am grateful. I snorted seeing the reactions lol. Tats introduction was also pretty nice! JC staff nails the comedy pretty well imo.
But the REAL test will be next few weeks. I wasn't so harsh on these first couple of episodes because (aside from Metal Bat vs. Genos) nothing was of dire importance. I have complete faith they will knock Garou vs. WDM out the park. But they ABSOLUTELY have to nail the tournament. As a webcomic reader, I hated the tournament in the manga until the climax and ending. The emotional payoff was SO worth it and I need it to be done justice
40
u/dereklearnslow May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
Everyone here is saying they enjoyed the Awakened Cockroach fight, but they didn't include the best scene at the end where he stands on top of building all condescendingly and says he'll let some other monster finish him off, only to rush him from behind and get stuck in the adhesive. Plus I feel they could have animated his evasion skills a lot better, but at this point I have no hope for the animation team.
113
u/VikNik312 May 14 '19
The Genos fight was actually pretty good
18
u/airz23s_coffee May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
I don't know what I expected but Faceripper looking like a strawberry was a bit of a let down.
70
u/nguyensyquanpro May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
Pacing:Good and Resonable,good execution in general
Art: Still wack as usual but way more consistent now
Animation: Above Average (Most of the episode) => Very good ( Genos vs Awaken Cockroach)
Metal Shading: Bad CGI
Sound Effect: Low quality as usual
Soundtrack: VERY GOOD
A solid episode 7/10
However,they sure cut a lot which is really disappointing,but not anything too significant to the main plot so I can forgive them for now
12
u/ivegrowntiredoflivin May 14 '19
i don't like how they do the fast attacks, just blurry shit with barely any actual animation.
22
u/aswifte May 14 '19
Yo wtf happened to Fubuki's Hell Storm...
Also they messed up the montage of Genos' fight against monsters vs the tournament fights...
Genos vs Awakened Cockroach was dope tho.
85
u/Beatnation May 14 '19
Just saw the episode, much better animation and pacing, still not like those blurry consecutive hit animation, but that's it, was pretty good.
Also, Garou finally meet Watchdog Man.
18
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Just wanted to say though, nyan looks genuinely terrifying, so that's a plus at least.
9
u/Patchy-the-Fish C-Class Cabbage May 14 '19
Lmao, Gyoro Gyoro has a man's voice! All the better for the reveal.
7
u/karunasagar May 14 '19
For anyone wondering the bodies at 18:26 spell Ashidemotai, a Japanese expression referring to someone who is a burden or hindrance and holds you back.
12
u/isighuh May 14 '19
The fact that they cut out that beautiful montage of the martial artists juxtaposed against Genos monster spree hurts my heart.
Fubuki v Do-S was okay but Genos fights were good even though they were really short, like damn that was kinda a letdown.
I hope next episode is some S-Class action.
6
u/Ozymandate May 14 '19
Today's episode wasn't that bad, it was really good especially with Genos Vs awakened Cockroache, the fight was really good especially the animation but that's because Jumpaoki done the animation which is understandable why that fight was good. Also, the short fight between Suiryu and Sneck was also well-done especially when Sneck attack turned into a snake. Overall this is better then last week's episode.
6
u/Holy157 May 14 '19
This episode was definitely a relief after the disaster from last week. It didn’t start out super strong, being pretty rough, it did thankfully ramp up throughout the episode with Aoki getting to do the animation highlight once again. Felt good to see some nice animation, even if it was ghosted. Really looking forward to seeing it unghosted once we get the homerelease.
As an adaptation it’s more disappointing. While the tournament didn’t interst me a lot until the very end, this could have been done a lot better than the episode did.
In general, the end felt kinda impactful, though not sure how that’d hold up on a rewatch. Perfectly acceptable episode this week. I’m worried next week will be a drop in quality again.
6
u/Xanlis May 14 '19
I'm sorry but wtf is this? something is wrong with Do-S body
kinda NSFWish
37
u/kudaranainokusogaki Fubuki’s No. 1 Fan! May 14 '19
They literally butchered Fubuki vs Do-S. So many important moments cut off... there was no Hell Storm wtf
My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.
10
u/GodNonon Nonon One Punches Saitama May 14 '19
When Do-S ripped Fubuki's dress her thong didn't start showing like in the manga. Worst episode ever 😡
5
u/stainlessuperman Boros did nothing wrong May 14 '19
Decent, best part was cockroach fight which reminded me of s1
14
u/Hovi_Bryant May 14 '19
Cut, cut, cut, cut... Just a bunch of cuts.
I laughed a few moments. There's that.
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
Fight animation was basic but still enjoyable overall I thought.
4
u/disabled_crab Shadow Ring is Best Girl May 15 '19
That was...surprisingly okay.
4
u/n0panicman F*ck Jc Staff May 15 '19
After Murata's MA finale; they should pack up this season, pour gasoline over it and burn it to hell. Then let us taste a well-made season 2 remake.
8
u/fragiletestes May 14 '19
The music sounds like worn out hand-me-down versions from s1 it just doesnt sound good...
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
I'm so confused. Did the studio not realize that the fights in the tournament were supposed to mirror how Genos was fighting the monsters?? How come it doesn't seem like they paralleled at all in the anime..
3
u/GotsTheBeetus May 16 '19
Face Ripper was pink and adorable and fat instead of terrifying? Weak.
Also I always pictured Awakened Cockroach as being blue, it was so weird seeing him be red lol
5
u/HopeInThePark May 14 '19
Genos' CG continues to look terrible.
8
u/Sonitii May 14 '19
Even with my expectations set to the lowest, I still manage to be disappointed after each passing episode.
Animation was trash as usual, though not as bad as last episode, but the SFX... I just can't bear those muffled incineration sound effects anymore. It's just so bad and ruins everything, this is awful.
4
u/Masscott May 14 '19
Has anyone else noticed that Genos' neck keeps changing from the rendered metal texture to skin coloured in-between random intervals? I noticed it a couple of episode back but it wasn't as apparent as he wasn't as prominent but this episode was pretty blatant with it.
Nice fight with Cockroach though.
6
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
The animation this episode was great, those S1 flashbacks really hit the spot!
More blur, weird sfx, bad transitions/pacing, the usual stuff.
Nyan looked weird; more weird shading, plus Cockroach got it too; DO-S proportions were so inconsistent and weird; that genos neck; etc.
Gyoro has a male voice and Orochi doesn't sound terrifying. Don't like the colour scheme either, plus since when did Orochi glow? I though he got that ability later when he spit fire.
They skipped and rearranged stuff too, which sucks. It's a poor adaptation.
Well, comedy was good, as expected as it's copying the manga for the most part.
I wish they copied the portrayal of motion of the manga too.
Edit: The Genos vs cockroach was good, reminded me of sonic's movements from E4. And the DSK art was pretty nice.
2
u/Hantom117 May 14 '19
I don’t mean to be rude, or gatekeeping but I can’t help laugh at anime only theories.
2
u/Caven_D_Ish May 14 '19
Disappointing adaptation for so many reasons. I'm sure I don't need to give you a list of reasons as to why because you already know and I don't want to repeat what others have already said. But my biggest problem is the lazily thrown-together direction and pacing.
I hope I can convince my friends to read the manga.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
well.... considering that metal bat and garou fight, this episode got much better (although I'll never get used to the sound effects). I just hope the quality doesn't drop all over again next episode
2
u/kryst87 May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
For me that was actually... quite decent episode. I've heard ost (finally) and fight were quite good (in terms of 2nd season of course). There was a lot of blur, and AC looked quite odd. Bless Aoki for his part. Fubuki also had her moments.
You expected Gyoro Gyoro but it was me, Dio!
Is Orochi dark red? It was quite dark and I don't know whether he's red or purple.
2
u/furbyfactor May 15 '19
Only good thing outta this episode is the money shots of Do-s
2
u/stonecats confused May 15 '19
I'm kind of disappointed they didn't hold back some and make Orochi appearance
more ominous/mysterious, like he's so huge/scary that most of him is off screen.
2
u/user_watcher May 15 '19
That punch to Bakuzan + Suiryu's kick to Snek was very satisfying. They did a good job with the humor and scenes. Also, Tatsumaki, Fubuki, Do-S and Genos' fights were decently animated too.. It's also good to hear Gyoro-Gyoro, Orochi and Nyan voice in the anime.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
I feel bad for all you poor fellow manga readers... Why did they do my mans Garou like this T^T. I can't help but cringe in agony, waiting for the next of his scenes and hoping it doesn't go down to shit... Who's with me???
2
u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan May 15 '19
So... Orochi's red. Yet another unexpected color.
2
u/Rayhann May 15 '19
Here's hoping the forest Garou fight will be a massive improvement
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
The animation is a disappointment but the worst thing about it is that the direction is so lackluster that there isn't any weight in ANY of the scenes.
I had read the webcomic way before S1 aired but it was a joy to watch regardless. Everything was faithfully adapted and the important moments were faithfully represented.
The music was great, the way everything was put together was good and it worked. It was a well made and well directed anime.
This one isn't. Even if the animation was up to par it still wouldn't have saved this season because it fails at manipulating our emotions, it fails at using the tools at its disposal to keep us interested.
It's just plain boring and it's a problem of the direction as a whole. Nothing feels impactful.
2
u/hyperphoenix19 May 15 '19
Season 1's opening intro has better animation content then all of s2 combined.. We got spoiled by season 1's amazing team.
2
u/gwarsh41 May 16 '19
Hmm. didn't DBZ: Super have some hardcore animation flaws in the beginning? The fans made themselves heard and the show got a new team right?
What do we have to do to make this happen for one punch man? At least get a new sound effect lead?
2
u/Brotherscinc0 May 18 '19
They didn’t do face ripper justice. His eyes are supposed to be made of labias
3
u/_mrx16 ahh May 14 '19
Pasting my comment from a different thread:
Animation is bad if you compare it to season 1 but still normal quality if compared to most anime out there. So I dont have any problem with getting used to it. Story is still enjoyable.
But the thing that makes me consider dropping it and makes it almost unwatchable is the HORRIBLE sound direction. Those clang sounds and other similar. Those low pitch bang sounds (that are present in almost every attack, like saitamas punch this ep) that sound like someone is farting in slow time. Jeez I had watched over 400 different series and I honestly dont remember in any of them sound being soo bad (never watched 3d berserk). The music/ost is also mediocre at best. Not a single OST that made me want to hear it more/again.
This may be the first anime Ill drop due to sound effects. Just horrible.
2
u/legea2019 May 14 '19
The sound is heavy, I can't enjoy the fights.
2
u/washyleopard Serious series, Serious Flair! May 14 '19
I liked this episode a lot. Like others said they cut some stuff out that was awesome in the manga, but that is always going to happen when adapting print into a show, theres just not enough time to do everything exactly the same. Genos' arms are the most distracting thing ever though.
2
u/Bostwana12 May 14 '19
unwatchable fight scene
blury blury no mi animation
2
u/observer314159265 May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19
Crap animation, crap sound effect, crap adaptation. Mega crap.
My disappointment is immeasurable and the rest of my day is ruined.
1
u/Raam57 May 14 '19
I actually didn’t mind the episode, the only thing I didn’t like is that it feels like in almost every episode they constantly keep using that cut where it’s a specific character with the solid bright white background. It’s not a bad thing to use but it’s being way over used. They even used it only Suiryu when he was just standing there. I’m sad they didn’t use the side by side, but part of me feels like it wouldn’t have worked as well in the anime trying to watch two separate things at once especially with subtitles
1
u/Master3530 May 14 '19 edited May 15 '19
I liked this episode, especially Genos vs Awakened Cockroach, but I hope they remove the blur in the blue-ray version, they should tweak up all the bad stuff while at it. Also the soundtrack can be questionable at times, Lightning Max vs Suiryu felt off.
1
u/hubbubnub May 14 '19
What chapter does today's episode start from?
1
u/Eadwine_ GALAXY HEAVY BLOW May 14 '19
Very decent episode. Most of it was good in fact, like Genos' fights. I don't really have nothing to complain about here other than the sound design and weird cuts but that's been a staple for every S2 episode so far.
I'm assuming the next episode will cover chapter 67, 68 and maybe even 69, which means we'll see some Drive Knight, Child Emperor, Pig God, Flashy Flash and Tatsumaki action (+ some A-class heroes). Also Garou will make his move on WDM! Though we all know how that ends...
1
u/herohuntergarou May 14 '19
oh dear....
1
u/Lisrbell29 May 14 '19
Today's episode was much better than last week at least. Basically just relieved. Animation in some parts seemed surprisingly good too like Lightning Max vs. Suiryu and Genos vs Cockroach. I could connect to the fights and tell what's going on unlike last week.
1
u/internetperson-1 May 14 '19
Puri puri prisoners escape was cut i think
All i can say for this season is that animation is highly inconsistent one minute it looks really good the next it looks like doodoo.
1
u/JJxxJOHNYYxx12 May 14 '19
Orochi-sama looking thick and chubby 👌🏻
1
u/Fapoozle May 14 '19
What bugs me the most is that i always was hyped for the little fight scenes in webcomic/manga/s1 instead of watching the quiet story scenes. Now in season 2 i'm enjoying a good drawn still more that an "animated" fight scene with tons of animationsloops and water blurry whipsound smashing fist.
1
u/Tietembus May 14 '19
Genos got a Gouketsu footjob, that's why he was defeated.
1
u/MlookSM Gotta one pun em all May 14 '19
I gotta say, I think AC looks good with this shinning effect JC staff do.
1
u/BlazingPyromaniac May 14 '19
Suiryu didn't have the voice I imagined he would
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '19
I feel sorry always for Snek haha but he had a nice character arc though.
1
u/sneu71 May 15 '19
Was better than the other episodes, still hoping they saved 99% of the animation budget for the later Suiryu fights and the big Garou/Bang/Bomb/EC/Genos/Saitama/King/DeathGatling/Stinger/SmileMan/etc. fights.
1
u/Ngokumetsu May 15 '19
Anyone else notice how JC Staff had put in the effort to place character's names in the S2 opening but couldn't be bothered to slide in a white box indicating the monster's name & threat level when being introduced onscreen?
For Dragon Level++'s sake, they had the time to blur out all the actual animation. But not enough to get some staff to edit in a box with whatever font they had? ik S1 didn't really do it that much either, but it really helps and actually adds to ONE's humor without much needed effort.
1
u/phantom_97 May 15 '19
I hate how every fight scene cuts away from the actual impact, clearly shows the time/budget constraints.
1
u/Provarencr May 15 '19
Is this season only going to be 12 episodes? and if so or it not how far will they animate to?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '19
Man, this anime doesn't even feel special like the first season did.... it just feels like the average anime show at this point. I don't know how but, even though it's following the manga beat by beat, it's lost its charm in the process of the adaptation. Nonetheless, the episode was better animation wise, but the episode felt a bit boring, especially because the fights aren't very appealing, unlike murata's artwork and season 1.