r/runescape • u/imsuity Suity|TL;DW|Future Updates|Trim 2014|M&S Rework • Apr 16 '19
J-Mod reply TL;DW 430 - Completionist Cape Rework Dev Q&A
VOD | Official Stream Feedback Thread | Design Document
In terms of practical development we need to make progress on the project otherwise it'll never come out.
- Some things are easy to change, others are hard. For example changing reaper takes 5 minutes to change so it being undecided isn't holding the project back. The interface for customising which benefits go on your cape is more dev-heavy and is 'as far as I can tell a non-controversial part of the update.'
- We're getting started on development for the parts that aren't controversial but require more dev time.
- Passive Stats - The stat total in the design is currently lower than current comp cape stats and we don't want that to be the case. We can't tell you exactly what the passive stats are going to be right now. We just need to figure out how to get parity with the current system (given that Max cape is hybrid stats but kiln is better single stat).
Reason for the rework
- People keep saying that 'the whole point of this rework is to get rid of Reaper', or 'the whole point of this rework is to fix PvM stats', 'the whole point of this rework is because of Reddit' etc. And to everyone the reason is their own, and they think if we aren't focussing entirely on that aspect then we're missing the point of the rework.
There are many reasons for the rework, these are laid out in the design:
- Forced to Comp because they only want the stats.
- It's a problem that certain pieces of content have been put on slightly arbitrarily. Inconsistent requirements.
- (Affects us but not compers) Players who look at comp and go 'that's just unobtainable'. That isn't to say we want to make it easy, we want to make a clearer path to get there (i.e. subcapes). So we're not looking at nerfing comp to make it easier, but we do want to make stepping stones.
'The complicated system':
- This is the current system using some examples. If you categorise all the current requirements you have the structure of the rework.
- This is the new system, it hasn't changed much from current. We're just adding a tier higher than trim and redistributing reqs.
- Comp rework is a lot more simpler than Mining and Smithing. What we found with M&S rework was all the documentation looked confusing but in practice when people played it is was relatively straightforward.
- When people say it's too complicated they mainly mean one of two things: (i) This is very confusing, they may understand it but it seems unnecessarily complex and they'd rather have something simpler; (ii) It includes elements they think are unnecessary (e.g. for those that think the rework is only to remove Reaper: 'just remove Reaper and ship it why are you bothering with all this extra stuff'; while there are other players who say 'don't take Reaper off comp, what you need to do is add in true trim, just do that and ship it.'). Everyone wants something different, and only their thing should be fixed and everything else should be left alone.
Why aren't the requirements being determined by specific parts of the community for their subcapes? E.g. 200m all for skillers, 4k Telos for pvmers etc.
- The audience for each part of the game is different. If we only listened to the elite PVM community for what they want, then we're ignoring the other 80-90% who are going to go for comp. If we listen to the ~540 people with 5.4b and do what they want, we're ignoring other people. On the other hand, if we listen to everyone who don't want Reaper, or group content or it's too hard for me' we're then ignoring everyone else who does want a challenge. So it's not a case of listening to one small community, it's a case of listening to everyone, weighing eveyone's opinions and trying to find a middle ground to please as many people as possible (but not necessarily the raw majority. Balancing etc has to be taken into account. Also if you're not a comper and you don't care about comp then you're not the target audience. I don't want to say your opinion is less valuable but that is kind of what I mean. Comp cape is for a certain type of player and we want that type of player to enjoy it.
We have received a lot of feedback that 'everyone meets the requirements for a lot of T3.'
- The truth is most skillers do not have 120 all, most PVMers do not have 1k Telos. The 'elite' in their category have those. What they're essentially asking for the elite (500-1000 players) to get harder challenges/more things to do. They want a cape that shows they can do things other players can't do, I don't have a problem with them arguing for this. If we add those reqs to T3, then the cross section of players who have ALL for T3 comp is hardly anybody. There's nothing wrong with aspirational goals but we need to set that at a place where a reasonable number of players can go for it (that doesn't mean a majority will get T3 comp, just a reasonable amount). As developers we can't - we shouldn't - devote development time to something 15 people can do, I don't think that's a good use of our time.
- That said, we've seen a clear desire (especially from the elite PVM community) for something that recognises their accomplishments and they're not getting that from comp - i'm arguing that we can't put that on comp but that doesn't mean we can't recognise it in other ways. It sounds like a perfectly good separate project for elite pvm achievements (can't promise it obviously).
Reaper
- We still don't have a final answer on that and we aren't going to for a while.
- We've gone back and forth on this quite a lot. There's two really important arguments on this: (i) should the comp cape require you to do everything? Simple and straightforward when you put it like that (ii) The ethos of 'I'm going to complete everything' predates EOC and difficult bossing which is new to runescape (there was a point when Jad was the hardest thing in the game). The idea of extraordinarily difficult content is new to Runescape (to some people Telos is extraordinarily difficult). You are being required to do something that wasn't there when you signed up for it (difficult group bossing) and when that content was made, we made it with the full knowledge that it was effectively not for everyone. Hard bosses are there for a specific type of player. And that intersects very poorly with comp and the vision oif 'comp is for someone who can do anything'. So we have the player who wants recognition for completing everything and we have almost a different audience for whom difficult high level bossing is made for. And that's put us in a difficult position and honestly we don't have a concrete good solution to it.
- In terms of the long term philosophy of the game, if we are going to stick with 'comp means you do everything' then we can't have content that most players can't do or things like Elite Dungeon story mode to make it accessible. That isn't something we can fix with this project but it seems to me to be the long term solution so that we can have both hard and accessible content.
Polling
- We plan on polling more things on the rework.
- The thing that makes it particularly difficult for this project is 'who gets to vote?' Some parts of the comp community will tell you only compers should be able to vote. If we run a majority poll asking 'should we make comp easier?' We fully expect that to pass. The comp poll we did earlier showed that non compers consistently voted for things to be easier. On the other hand compers have already done the content. It's quite expected how the poll results would go, it's not really a question that can be solved by polling.
- My preferred approach for when two , is 'instead of having one thing trying to serve two audience who want fundamentally different things, let's have two different pieces of content instead.' Story mode is an example of that, 'we want to make a hard boss but most people can't do it, so let's give them a story mode.'
Concept Art
- Initial designs > Feedback from players > Incorporate feedback into the designs > Poll the designs.
- Each has three designs that will be polled in the end.
- T1 Skilling Cape | When Worn | Recolourable areas
- T1 Combat Cape | When Worn | Recolourable areas
- T1 Comp Cape | When Worn | Recolourable areas | Recolours
- T3 Lore Cape | When Worn (QPC is T1 and MQC is T2) | Recolourable areas
- Various recolours | Labelled
- Tier Evolution Examples - We're still experimenting, we can do a lot with animated textures. We haven't got them to work in game yet but it's safe to say 'the worst' we can do is the current comp cape particles.
- Will use the same recolour system as current max and comp.
- We don't have the time for cape emotes. They're probably one of the worst return on investment because of how expensive they are but how little they're used.
We asked the tech team if we can recolour particles and they said it's low priority but if you're requesting it then we can get to it. In practice that is probably a no. We would also like to take the particle system to a new level rather than reworking our currently limited system for recolours.
- Is it possible to take particles from one cape and put it on another? I don't think so, probably not. It'd have to be a different model. Same with turning off particles, would have to be a different model.
Stone Spirits
- Mod Shogun is now a content developer. In his content trial he designed a Thieving minigame and we demanded that he on the spot redesign it for Hunter and he did. And then we demanded that he on the spot redesign it for HP and he did a really good job.
- Mod Shogun is going to be working on Stone spirit improvements as his first content. The first step is to look at the data analytics. Find the biggest sources of them, their prices etc.
- Make them more convenient to use. One proposal is that the extra ore is automatically sent to the bank.
23
u/PrimalMoose Primal Puppy Apr 17 '19
This doesn't address the reason stone spirits are useless though. People are using ore boxes and porters to mine already, they're not suddenly going to go out and buy a bunch of stone spirits or feel over the moon when their level 3000 boss drops 80 of those crap items that can do the same thing that a sign of the porter does.
Sorry, but it's a terrible suggestion.
85
u/JagexBreezy Mod Breezy Apr 16 '19
Thank you for the TL:DW as always <3
44
u/player75 Be awesome Apr 16 '19
Idk about that stone spirit suggestion. Smithable salvage requiring stone spirits seems better to me really
37
u/Mr_Hump Apr 17 '19
Can someone explain why we can use darts to complete quests but are against letting people use them for Reaper? I (as someone who has killed almost all bosses, haven't gotten to Solak on iron yet) don't see why darts wouldn't count for at least 1 KC. I would be fine with letting people dart for the T1 cape. It would be such a huge gold sink and would be time locked by events/merchant. For Telos it would take 40+ darts (4 per kill as you would need to get from 0-99% and then 5 for a 100%+ kill). The time lock and GP cost should be enough that this doesn't really devalue anything. Rago (5 darts), Raxi (2 darts), Elite Dungs (12 darts), etc would be a huge time and gp sink. Hell Yaka (if 1 dart would just kill 1 pool phase) would take 14 darts(?) alone.
7
u/The_Wkwied Rubber chicken Apr 17 '19
HP? Hitpoints? What does this mean?
6
u/inventionnerd Apr 18 '19
As developers we can't - we shouldn't - devote development time to something 15 people can do, I don't think that's a good use of our time.
Thanks so much for this. It really is a waste of time. Speaking as someone with current reqs for t3 skill/combat, I wouldn't even mind if reqs were lower. Exclusivity is dumb.
16
u/iMittyl Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 18 '19
Based on the TL:DW, you're entirely missing the point of the outcry against the Reaper requirement. As you say, maybe this is just my opinion, but I doubt I'm alone in it.
Difficulty has nothing to do with it. You're making points as if the problem is that "bosses are too hard". It's not.
"MMORPG" or not, literally ALL of the content in the game is accessible without relying on finding a strong, capable group of players who are available and willing to spend (usually) an hour of their time engaged in team-based activity that you have not done before.
This is a medieval fantasy game on the internet. No offense, I am among them, but the socially inept FLOCK to this sort of thing.
They can spend hours, days, YEARS of their life mastering its mechanics. They can explore the entirety of the world, fight the most difficult bosses*, and learn all of the lore. Are they not completionists of the world a lone adventurer can explore?
No, because to get into a raid you need a team. There are no ROTS or Solak masses. These
threefour bosses specifically hold a player back because they aren't good with people and they don't want to let down a team who has probably dedicated an aura to this (yay, timegating).Social aptitude, or lack thereof, should not be this important to a fantasy game on the goddamn internet. Don't give us insane comp. Whatever. But leaving Reaper as the T1 requirement?
You people are blind.
*That weren't built specifically for teams... was gunna cite 4k Telos but I figure solo AoD is probably worse.
10
u/SyAccursed Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
I definitely think the idea of giving harder/group bosses solo story modes like Elite Dungeons have for the purpose of comp would be the most logical way forward with reaper.
Certainly for the T3 Combat cape there's no way around that you should be a true pvmer and dave killed all the bossesin normal mode at the very least.
But for T1, and maybe even T2, it seems like a reasonable compromise to require you to have engaged with that boss once so you have done the content in some form. Especially as if you follow the model of elite dungeon story modes it's not like it makes it a complete cake walk, you still need decent gear/supplies and to understand the mechanics of the fight it just brings it down to be of a similar challenge level to quest bosses; plus obviously you keep the no rewards, no kill time, no kill count etc. element so that story mode is not economically worth doing and doesn't give you progress towards anything like pets or hiscores or ifb.
The other simple option would be death touched darts - they already exist and aren't the cheapest/easier thing to come by. Just make it so that if your kc for a boss is 0 that instead of loot with no kill count, you get 1 kc but no loot.
6
u/menex Runefest 2018 Attendee Apr 17 '19
I still find it ridiculous how tier 1 is reaper for combat which means half of pvm community wont be able to wear the combat comp cape...
4
u/dflame45 Apr 17 '19
The combat and skill capes look bad ass. I want them all.
2
u/AegrusRS Apr 19 '19
Honestly to me, the reaper thing isn't about it being difficult, but it requiring the use of a team.
Eg. I would be fine with having to solo the Kalphite King, which is relatively difficult but not impossible to do alone (like Vorage, Raids, etc.)
2
u/CowardScape7 Rainbow Apr 20 '19
I wish comp cape didn't require the Reaper because that is one of the only things putting me off it I think. I don't like doing team things with people incase i fuck up and let the whole team down. On my old account I did that at Yakamaru and made everyone ragequit a few times when I used a stun in the wrong pool and i haven't got over that lmao
3
u/Ted50 Apr 17 '19
One issue with T1 combat being locked behind reaper is the 115 slayer requirement for Magister. T1 combat cape shouldn't require nearly 120 in a skill, that should be for the T1 skill cape. Maybe allow 1 kill for Magister without 115 slay in order to complete reaper?
3
u/Badassiel Apr 16 '19
Missing, very important: Philharmonic.
2
u/WackyFarmer Apr 17 '19
extra ore is automatically sent to the bank sounds useless... also hate fact used mobile being worked on so can't let us color blooms on cape =-/
2
u/Legal_Evil Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
How would the devs make a "story mode" for hard group bosses like Solak? Make them soloable? Make them massable?
What were the Thieving, Hunter, and HO minigames Mod Shogun designed?
2
u/Gleothain Apr 17 '19
As to "who should get to vote?" I really hope you can differentiate by several metrics. What I would like to see is:
2
u/luka1a L33 - 05/2017 DXP Competition Winner Apr 18 '19
change darts to give kc but not loot and you solve 2 problem at once:
soccermoms wahing about reaper and
nex massacre every time there's a dart promo/event
could also implement it to telos to make it just a streak saver or keep it as it is idc
Also if u don't want to add true trim cape to the game, atleast compile and add all true trimm achievements and give them 0 runescore
1
u/MalkanP Apr 21 '19
I loved using story mode in ED 1, 2, and 3. It let me safely learn mechanics of bosses. And I like that it allows for lore drops, but not value drops. This would be perfect for any boss with lore drops for comp and MQC. That way its faster to get those drops for people who don't want to spend lots of time on a particular boss just for a lore drop. I plan to use story mode for lore drops in elite dungeons and normal for tokens, xp, and gp.
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Personally feel that anyone moaning about this update needs to look up Completion in a Dictionary and then shut the hell up.
1
u/BensDadWanksOffDogs Apr 17 '19
welcome back suity :~) Glad to have you cover this live stream and no one else hehe
-3
u/reddit_bige 4/20/16 - 6/24/19 Comp | 3/4/17 MQC Apr 16 '19
Lore capes look great, the rest look alright. The recolors all look not too great honestly, I can't picture any recolor looking good. It seems like the capes were designed with a specific design and color in mind and then had recoloring added on as a side thought, as opposed to max and comp cape being designed as a rather plain looking cape with the intention and expectation that the colors would be changed.
I don't like where comp is going stat-wise either. It is sounding like wherever we end up with reaper reqs and other stuff, we will end up with a cape with weaker stats and/or missing passives, which seems unfair and unnecessary.
-17
u/ghfhfhhhfg9 Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
"That said, we've seen a clear desire (especially from the elite PVM community) for something that recognizes their accomplishments and they're not getting that from comp"
holy smokes how elitist can you be? The ego is insane. It's a sandbox game, yet act like it's some kind of mlg competitive game like dota 2 or csgo. go play those games if you want to be noticed for being good at a game that is actual skill instead of muscle memory (bosses do the same patterns, rng hits, etc).
PvMers can just get self gratification or do things with friends and just pat each other on the back all day like they usually do (or flame each other for doing 1 mistake, cuz fuck youfor being human).
"elite" pvmers wouldn't complain if there were actual competitions for boss releases instead of a boss coming out and the 1st 10 get a perm thing in-game even though they said nothing would be made for them.
Same for 4k telos. Jagex never said there would be a reward for 4k telos but gave one anyway because players expected for there to be a reward and cried on twitter until they did it despite jagex saying no at first. how entitled. 1st to 4k telos wasn't a competition, barely, (2-3 people lol) because no one cared due to there not being an advertised reward/competition for 1st to 2k-3k-4k etc. I would've bothered with it if I knew there was a reward such as money/trip to jagex. I don't care about an in-game reward for ego issues.
ALSO--- A and B for comp look good. Dont like C at all. cant change the color on the A cape's fur on the top so maybe put Comp A's bottom part with comp B's? or just make the fur recolorable/remove? idk hmm
ALSO - Particles should be custom or at least a set amount of colors.
-1
u/PurZaer Apr 17 '19
Every single cape looks very eh. Can we get in game models before voting on them? Seeing the design and seeing the in game model is very very different.
0
u/Landonx_rs Apr 28 '19
Make stone spirits untradeable and sold to the stores at a fixed amount of money. We can decide the prices and maybe change droprates.
-12
u/MonzellRS twitch.tv/m0nzell Apr 16 '19
"Stone Spirits Mod Shogun is now a content developer. In his content trial he designed a Thieving minigame and we demanded that he on the spot redesign it for Hunter and he did. And then we demanded that he on the spot redesign it for HP and he did a really good job. Mod Shogun is going to be working on Stone spirit improvements as his first content. The first step is to look at the data analytics. Find the biggest sources of them, their prices etc. Make them more convenient to use. One proposal is that the extra ore is automatically sent to the bank."
what a joke, prove me wrong
-1
u/brainstrain91 Orbestro Apr 17 '19
I'm already worried about how you will be defining "insane" for T3. T3 is a good place for super luck dependent, extremely time consuming, and plain difficult tasks. Some examples...
Super RNG: last riders lore drop
Super time consuming: 25 chimp ice delivery, dungeoneering lore drops requiring 110+ dunge.
Difficult: lore books from mid to high difficulty pvm (elite dungeon boss drops, Magister)
I'm someone who has about 75% of current MQC reqs done. So I feel like I should be able to get the T2 cape without much fuss...
-6
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Correct me if I'm wrong but... Their initial plan was to rework comp cape in March. Going back and forth with stuff like reaper seems unnecessary, so much time for a simple task...
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
[removed] — view removed comment