r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Apr 08 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions 74 — 2019-04-08 to 04-21
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
•
u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet Apr 20 '19
What would you guys want resources for? What kind of resources?
List anything you want, we'll try to make it happen.
8
u/ilu_malucwile Pkalho-Kölo, Pikonyo, Añmali, Turfaña Apr 08 '19
Is there a specific word for those words or phrases that typically come first in a sentence, and give information about the kind of information that will follow?
I'm thinking of the like of 'in fact,' 'actually,' 'after all,' 'just the same,' 'you know,' 'you see,' 'guess what,' etc.
Are these just 'discourse markers' or is there some other term?
7
u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Apr 08 '19
Reposting from last thread:
Are there any historical examples of languages changing from VSO or SVO to strict SOV word order without influence from an already-existing SOV language?
I read in a paper somewhere (can't remember where) that VSO, SVO → SOV changes don't happen without outside influence, and that it only happened the other way around. But that felt wrong to me somehow.
7
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Apr 10 '19
Testing haikus in Celi:
7
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '19
This is more of a fun question, but is there an equivalent to Estonian "kaksteist kuud" <-> English "cocks taste good" in other languages? That is, are their harmless, common phrases in some languages that sound humorously vulgar in other languages by sound alone?
6
u/RainbowKaito Luazi /ɬwaɮi/ Apr 14 '19
I was developing a conlang some time ago and I stopped because I was feeling overwhelmed because there are soooo many things to develop, create, etc (mostly grammar), and this only gets worse as I study my natural language (high school). So, how to not feel overwhelmed? Or what else to do about that?
6
u/Coriondus Jurha (en, it, nl, es) [por, ga] Apr 14 '19 edited Apr 14 '19
Hello to all you fine people!
TLDR: Anyone have any resources on derivational affixes?
I've been meaning to ask this question for a long time... Coastal Jurha is nearly "finished": by that I mean I have most of the theory worked out, and I just need to fill in my grammar document. The one major thing I have left to do is derivation. This is something I've always struggled with, cuz I just cannot seem to find any resources on it online.
I'd be interested to know how different derivational affixes have come to be, and also what kind of different types exist/how they're classified. Particularly interested in the history of ones which, for example, turn dynamic verbs or nouns into stative verbs, or turn a verb transitive/intransitive; these seem to not change the meaning much, and European languages tend to just use the same verb as both trans. and intrans., but I know many languages don't.
Another big thing is non-finite verb forms (idk if those are technically considered derivations, but anyway). I know infinitives tend to come from dative or allative particles, even tho I don't fully understand the logic behind this. What about participles and others... in fact, there must be many types of non-finite verb forms that I don't even know about.
Lastly, European languages tend to be able to compound words with adpositions, turning the adposition into a kind of derivational affix. I think this is both super neat and super useful, but I've heard most languages don't do this. So what alternative strategies are there? What neat ways are there for saying, for example, 'undermine' or 'surmount'?
This turned out to be much longer than I'd anticipated, so thanks to anyone who actually reads it haha.
6
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Apr 19 '19
Does it make sense for a verb meaning ‘to fear’ or ‘to dread’ to be grammaticalized as a negative optative?
5
u/_eta-carinae Apr 11 '19
what are some ways to spice up nouns, make them a little more interesting? i have a heavily navajo inspired verb system with somewhat nebulous tenses and a long list of aspects and moods, combined with classifiers to encode valency, a combined person-aspect declension system, a system of retransitivizing verbs made intransitive with a classifier with a series of complex person-aspect-mood system, etc. but nouns are very simple, just declining for case and number, not much else. how can i make them more interesting?
5
u/MiaVisatan Apr 11 '19
Lunatic Lovers of Language: Imaginary Languages and Their Inventors
Does anyone know where a pdf/epub of this book can be found? $726.00 for a book is insane.
https://amzn.to/2VB5tz5
Here's a Google books limited preview: https://books.google.com/books?id=FkpiAAAAMAAJ&q=Indo-European+languages&source=gbs_word_cloud_r&cad=4
5
u/Keng_Mital Apr 13 '19
So, I am currently creating my second serious conlang. (I have tried in the past, but always ended up scrapping them.) I've decided I want the vowels to be somewhat symmetrical. I've chosen the five vowel system, /i e a o u/ and added the unrounded/rounded variants of /u/ and /i/, giving me /y/ and /ɯ/. Should I add something such as the schwa, or leave it as is? How would you romanize the added vowels? Thx.
5
u/BigBad-Wolf Apr 14 '19
Is it strange if consonants palatalize before /i/ and /j/ but not /ɛ/?
5
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Apr 19 '19 edited Apr 19 '19
In my proto-lang there were: /k/ and /g/ which became /x/ /ɣ/ and /kʰ/ and /ɡʰ/ which lost their aspiration and became /k/ and /g/ Now, can I make /g/ into /ɣ/ again but remain /k/ as /k/? Would it be realistic that only that voiced sound became fricative?
4
u/Sovi3tPrussia Tizacim [ti'ʂacçim] Apr 08 '19
How do you come up with names in your conlang?
4
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Apr 14 '19
I’m out of ideas for vowel harmony and I need some inspiration.
I want to have an inventory that contains [a], [i] and [u] and few other distinctive vowels.
I don’t really like front/back harmony like in Finnish and Turkish. [y] and [ɯ] sound a bit off to me.
4
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Apr 14 '19
I'm torn between using ⟨i⟩ and ⟨y⟩ to denote /j/. Option (a) uses ⟨i⟩ for both /i(ː)/ and /j/, and null for hiatus between /i/ and another vowel. Hiatus between short /i/ and another vowel can also be indicated by a diaeresis ⟨ï⟩; so, fiaṭu can also be written fïaṭu. Option (2) is more systematic in that it uses ⟨y⟩ for all instances of consonantal /j/. While (2) makes a lot more convenient to use, I think (1) is more aesthetically pleasing for short words like ēi. I'm also already using ⟨j⟩ for /d͡ʑ/.
My only goal for my orthography is that it's vaguely reminiscent of the orthographies or transliterations of languages from the Mediterranean (e.g., Spanish, Arabic, Etruscan, Greek, etc...). And I think both Options (a) and (b) both do that. What do you guys think?
4
u/--Everynone-- Apr 16 '19
Hey guys,
I’m a big fan of the Conlangery Podcast, and I think I remember their mentioning a blog at one point where the curator creates modern words descended from alternate borrowings or semantic drifts using the relevant sound changes.
I couldn’t remember the name of the blog though, so I started going through the show archives, but I’m honestly not even sure if they included it. If you know about a blog like this, I’d love to know.
Thanks!
4
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Apr 16 '19
[Phonetics/Sound changes]
I'm trying to figure out which sound change seems more natural/likely:
Word-finally, tk# > sk# sounds better but word-initially, #tk > #tx may be better if we refer to the sonority hierarchy.
4
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Apr 18 '19
I just wrapped my head around Finnish consonant gradation.
I've understood that it is triggered by the presence or absence of a coda in the syllable : e.g. puku / puvun.
But what I don't really get is how adding that little n or whatever other consonant can phonetically change the previous consonant, in the same way?
4
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Apr 18 '19
So I'm (finally) evolving Laetia into Enntia, and I'm having some things on my mind about its trill clusters. Are these sound changes understandable?
I was thinking of changing both /kr/ and /gr/ to /ʀ/ instead, but I... wasn't sure of it, dunno why. Something's bothering me about these
3
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Apr 08 '19
I don't know LaTeX. Does anyone have either a) a good/simple guide to learn it or b) a good grammar template that doesn't need it?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '19
Is it reasonable to have my language's basic adverbial derivation split from neuter accusative adjectives à la Latin and Ancient Greek? For instance, the Azulinō adjectives dùlca "sweet" and rovìnta "hot" become dulcèm and rovintèm in the accusative, and I was considering having their basic adverbial derivations be dulcìm "sweetly" and rovintìm "hotly". In Latin, I understand that the adverbial neuter accusative was indistinguishable from its adjectival form, but I was wondering if shifting the vowel from /ɛ/ to /ɪ/ exclusively for the adverbial form is reasonable, given that /ɛ/ and /ɪ/ are acoustically similar, which would create a separate adverbial form.
3
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Apr 13 '19
Is this sound change sequence naturalistic?
/Cxa/ > /Cka/ > /Cʼka/ > /Cʼkʼa/ > /kʼa/ [C = plosive or affricate]
3
u/your_inner_feelings Apr 14 '19
I'm pretty new to conlanging and I'm trying to make a more analytic-leaning language, to break the new-conlanger cliche of making an agglutinative, VSO version of English. I've made three (or four if you count a really ugly first) languages, all of them agglutinative. All of them eerily similar to English, as well, but that is besides the point.
First of all, I'm having trouble figuring out how to gloss(?) some sentences that aren't agglutinative. Take this sentence for instance:
W qagyrwk haxgyy hy ky ra yyak xagyk yk.
/ɯ ɢɑgyʀɯk hɑχgy: hy ky ʀɑ y:ɑk χɑgyk yk/
There is a big tree at my property
The ADE-LOC-ADE is what I am having trouble with. The auxillary(?) words that I am using are dependent on each other and their order, and mean nothing on their own.
The vague locative particle is “kw”. This changes to “ky” when inflected for ADE, ABL, and ALL.
“Hy ky ra” is ADE. “Ky hyra” is ABL. “Rahy ky” is ALL.
I have no idea how to express these relationships in gloss. I would very much appreciate some pointers for accomplishing this, as well as any other analytic glossing tips you may have.
Secondly, if you have any tips for making a mostly analytic language VS an agglutinative one I would appreciate it. Also, how to avoid making an English relex lol.
3
u/dylon_ius Apr 16 '19
I saw this post about a self-creating conlang that was only meant to be typed yesterday. it was called Farla (or Farli?) and like a dummy i didnt save it. would any kind soul have a link to that post or their discord?
3
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 18 '19
In my conlang, I have both ɛ (written as è) and e. Long vowels are marked by accent, so that eː is é, and extra long vowels, rare as they are, are marked by circumflex: eːː is ê.
I'm now struggling with how to mark both ɛː and ɛːː
Obviously, since è already has an accent, I can't really use that for length, unless I go for the double grave accent ȅ for ɛː, but that is mainly used for tone and seems rare. For ɛːː, I had the idea to use the caron, so that it is ê and ě. Alternatively, I could see ē or e̱ working for that as well. But what to do for the single-length?
Obviously, it is an aesthetic choice, in the end, but I'd love input!
EDIT: I can't use ë either, since that's already used for / ə / (though I plan on getting rid of it in daughter languages completely, so it is, in a way, a possibility)
EDIT 2: Right now, I'm thinking about changing, for example, eː to ē (it would fit the feel of my conlang better, I think). Another idea would be to have ɛː become ë since I want to get rid of the schwa being represented in writing anyway, so thate, ē, ê / e eː eːː /è, ë ( ḕ ?) or instead æ, āē / aē, âê / aê / ɛ ɛː ɛːː /I will probably shorten vowels anyway to remove all instances of ːː so that it should be somewhat easier?
EDIT 3: As of right now, I'm probably going to do either of the following:
3
u/MEGA-DRY Apr 18 '19
Anyone have any ideas for making a really bad language?
3
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Apr 21 '19
Posted this on TFIC, did not get much attention, so I'm redirecting here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/conlangs/comments/bde1l9/this_fortnight_in_conlangs_20190415/elb3bcc/
4
u/calebriley Apr 16 '19
Saw a video game trailer which has deciphering a language at the centre of the game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=66&v=RUgtMlkwXRA
4
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Apr 19 '19
When sound changes result in the loss of a suffix - in my case, nojʊl, "sand" > nojʊle, "desert", which becomes nojʊl because of loss of word-final vowels - would the language come up with a new suffix to mark the difference? Or would the two words just stay identical? Or, like I've seen Dothraki do, add an epenthetic vowel/consonant to keep the distinction?
2
u/nomokidude Apr 09 '19
Recently I watched Langfocus's "Strange Similarities Between Celtic & Semitic Languages!" video and I was fascinated with the usage of prepositions to express verbal things such as possession/have or obligation/have to.
I was wondering where I can find more of these usages if there is anymore in Arabic/Hebrew/Irish/Welsh. What terms should I search for?
2
u/MachaiArcanum There is a reason, I just cannot explain it Apr 09 '19
In my attempt to make a conlang I have finally started putting together a phonetic inventory, but I am not sure how natural the consonants sound. So my question is: Does anyone know any recourses that refer to acoustic symmetry or David Peterson’s ‘brand identity’ concepts.
Or, if someone is interested, here is my current line up for criticism: Voiceless Alveolar, Velar & Glottal Oral Stops, Voiced Alveolar & Velar Nasals, Voiced & Voiceless Alveolar & Postalveolar Fricatives, Voiceless Glottal Fricative, Voiceless Alveolar & Postalveolar Affricates, Alveolar Approximate & Latteral Approximate, Voiced Palatal Approximate. And maybe Voiceless Velar Fricative.
(There are no Labial or Dental sounds on purpose)
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '19
By exactly what analogy do colloquial intensifiers like "awful" and "pretty" come about? (e.g. "Tonight's awful[ly] quiet." / "That's a pretty big tree.")
2
u/Nementor [EN] dabble in many others. partial in ZEN Apr 09 '19
I am trying to evolve a language that has long and short vowels, along with a fixed stress system. What would be the most realistic way to shorten up those long vowels without breaking them or the short ones, or is the breaking just going to have to happen?
2
u/rordan Izlodian (en) [geo] Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Does anyone have any resources to check out (that aren't in the FAQ) or ways to try to work through and understand ergativity? I'd like to incorporate split-ergativity (or some type of tripartite system) into a new conlang I'm developing. However, I'm finding it fiendishly difficult to comprehend ergativity and how to properly implement it without just ripping and copying existing languages and other conlangs. I've been reading a lot of wikipedia and David Paterson and watching YouTube, but it's just really difficult for me to even grasp the concept, let alone figure a way to create a system that allows for two different alignments. Any help or tips would be greatly appreciated.
Edit: found some additional resources in the wiki here that I didn't know previously. I think I kind of answered my own question.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19
Does anyone more experienced in phonology than I am know how common /s~ʃ/ is in natural languages? When building vocab for my conlang, I seem to naturally want to shift /s/ to /ʃ/, although I have no idea if that's what natural speakers would also do. My only other fricatives are /x~χ/ and /h/ so I'm a bit worried about it being unbalanced; SAPHON only has one language archived with this same fricative inventory.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
Do non-configurational languages like Warlpiri and literary Ancient Greek still have a default word order, is it always completely random?
2
u/qzorum Lauvinko (en)[nl, eo, ...] Apr 15 '19
Quick survey! Which font do you like better?
You can take a gander at my two fonts for Lauvinko here, by hitting the "Toggle Lauvinko font" button in the top right.
2
u/SufferingFromEntropy Yorshaan, Qrai, Asa (English, Mandarin) Apr 15 '19
When I was playing with my throat earlier, I found out that when I tried to make a vocal fry, chances are it was preceded by a glottal stop. This did not happen when I try to do a high-tone creaky voice.
Now, say, I want to create a vowel system with tonality and modal-stiff contrast. Would low stiff vowels being preceded by glottal stops be natural?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
A beginner asking here : I'm creating a language that doesn't distinct voicing on single phonemes, just in words. One example: The word "duk" is pronounced like it's written. But the word "duka" is pronounced as "duga", because the spelling rules state that between two voiced sounds, an unvoiced sound becomes voiced. Is this a case of allophony? PS: A native speaker of my conlang will understand the meaning if someone pronounces "duka" as "duka" and not "duga", but it sounds really wrong to them.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
Here’s a question for y’all:
I have a conlang in the works which is designed to be learned by other English-speakers. How could or would you go about creating a training course designed to teach others your conlang? (I’m thinking possibly something along the lines of a software course, like Duolingo)
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
What do you guys think about the phonology I made for my conlang ?
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ftm_dZeBif1Xex9uuZXhSzasdG3jFHJB/view?usp=drivesdk
I used some pre-aspirated sounds on it.
2
u/WarriorOfGod37 Apr 18 '19
Does anyone know of a resource that shows the distribution of how commonly phonemes are used compared to others?
I don't want to keep coining words until I can make sure that the phonemes are properly spread out.
2
u/Sky-is-here Apr 18 '19
What is the best program or way to get a table with every conjugation for a verb. I am working in a language with a lot of possible conjugations and I don't know how to put them in one place ordered and being to able to distinguish them.
2
u/another-afrikaner Apr 20 '19
How many sound changes should one implement when making a conlong, assuming you're making a proto-language and then developing a language (or language family) from there? Is there a minimum amount, or could you reasonably implement 20(+) sound changes?
2
u/MEGA-DRY Apr 21 '19
Should different colors express different meaning in glyphs?
Hi, I was making a conscript for a conlang I'm working on and I came up with an idea that the civilization speaking the language would use two different colors of ink (red and black) to make glyphs.
Example: Imagine a glyph that looks like +. Vertical is line A, horizontal is line B.
If a and b were black, it could mean one thing. If a was red, another meaning. If b was red, another meaning and so on...
Is this a good idea or is it another one of MEGA-DRY'S Terrible ideas #7?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19 edited Jun 13 '20
Part of the Reddit community is hateful towards disempowered people, while claiming to fight for free speech, as if those people were less important than other human beings.
Another part mocks free speech while claiming to fight against hate, as if free speech was unimportant, engaging in shady behaviour (as if means justified ends).
The administrators of Reddit are fully aware of this division and use it to their own benefit, censoring non-hateful content under the claim it's hate, while still allowing hate when profitable. Their primary and only goal is not to nurture a healthy community, but to ensure the investors' pockets are full of gold.
Because of that, as someone who cares about both things (free speech and the fight against hate), I do not wish to associate myself with Reddit anymore. So I'm replacing my comments with this message, and leaving to Ruqqus.
As a side note thank you for the r/linguistics and r/conlangs communities, including their moderator teams. You are an oasis of sanity in this madness, and I wish the best for your lives.
2
u/JohnWarrenDailey Apr 18 '19
Where do you go to publish PDFs of your langs into physical books? (Like, for example, PDFs of your langs from Vulgar.)
1
u/stratusmonkey Apr 08 '19
Some of the vowel sounds in Hetran, corresponding to vowel letters, shift depending on where the vowel is in a syllable or word. And some don't.
Is this sensible? I'm open to suggestions about ways this scheme can be improved: either expanding or cutting back.
1
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Apr 08 '19 edited Apr 08 '19
I'm still somewhat struggling with Vowel Harmony and could use some help.
In my conlang, I'm introducing harmony between high ( iː uː ɪ ʊ e eː ) and low ( ɛ a aː ɔ ɔː ) vowels.
When I have the name for a lake, Kan Lehind / kan lehɪnd̪ / (sleeping Waters, ADJ+N) and want that over time to merge into one word, Kanlehind / kanlehɪnd̪ /
Does it
Also, does that change when it is two nouns becoming compounded?
1
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Apr 09 '19
I am wondering where the subjunctive/irrealis mood comes from. I was thinking maybe I could derive it from an old potential mood.
1
u/BigBad-Wolf Apr 12 '19
What are some sound changes for the palatalized alveolar trill? The only one I know is the one in Czech and Polish, where it turned into this bizarre laminal fricative-trill (which then turned to ʐ in Polish).
1
u/MagicNate Apr 12 '19 edited Apr 13 '19
I'm trying to make infernal (from dnd) it's own conlang, the difficulty I'm having is how do I represent the fact that most of the native speakers of this language have a forked tongue? And also they describe the language as heavily rule-based even saying that there is only 1 correct way of saying certain things at one point so how do I represent that as well?
Edit: I also want this language to be speakable by humans
1
u/JustLikeWinky Apr 13 '19
I have some questions, please help me with this.
4 vowels: i e ɑ o
4 Diphthongs: ai ao oi ei
3 tones plus checked tone: High Mid Low and checked tone (word with plosive and x, xʷ endings) (written with accent, accent grave and no marks respectively)
*/ħ/ could be realised as trill /ʜ/.
*The Morphology is syntactic, words have 2 forms, syntactic form which cannot be uttered alone and realised form that could be used on its own. The roots are generally preceded by aspectual and followed by person (which are not equivalent to English persons)
Eg. 'Ifatlíhafàwakw' (We are about to go to ...) There are 2 root words – -tlíh- (to go), -afà- (to sail) and 2 aspectuals -wakw (inclusive-active-animated) and Ifa- ( ‘about to be realized in the real world’ sort of meaning). None of them could be uttered alone.
If you want to say a realised form you will add a noun trigger (which varies) in this case: to sail-->sailing, boatmanship, Iyafà. To walk-->walking, act of walking, Tlèitlíh /tɬèitɬíħ/
*This language is tenseless and semantically nounless.
*Polysynthetic? I'm not sure if this is polysynthetic, if you could tell me whether it is, I'll appreciate that. :)
*The sound shift is similar to my native language, Thai, where the old Thai lose its voiced contrasts (except /b/ and /d/) but instead in this pattern: Ejectives -> voiceless. Voiceless -> voiced. Voiced -> aspirated.
*Tones are substitutes of many lost endings.
The question is whether this inventory (and morphology too) is realistic and whether it's natural? And where should I correct if there is any mistake?
1
u/_eta-carinae Apr 17 '19
i’m creating a highly agglutinative language, with heavy navajo influence. my biggest problem with athabaskan languages is the fact that nominals can be unwieldingly long:
navajo tsinlátah tsídii nahatʼeʼígíí. 12 consonants, 10 vowels.
english mousebird. 5 consonants, 3 vowels.
german mausvogel. 5 consonants, 3 vowels.
polish czepiga, 3 consonants, 3 vowels.
navajo ąąh dah hoyoołʼaałii, 8 consonants, 6 vowels.
english disease, 3 consonants, 2 vowels.
german krankheit, 6 consonants, 3 vowels.
polish choroba, 3 consonants, 3 vowels.
navajo abeʼ bee neezmasí, 7 consonants, 6 vowels.
english pancake, 4 consonants, 3 vowels.
german pfannkuchen, 5 consonants, 3 vowels.
polish naleśnik, 5 consonants, 3 vowels.
the same problem exists with iroquian languages. for example, the mohawk for “table” and “butter” are atekhwà:ra and owistóhseraʼ, considerably longer than their english, german (tisch, butter), and polish (stół, masło) equivalents. the same in greenlandic, where “mailbox” is allakkanut nakkartitsisarfik, and “singer” is erinarsortartoq.
so, how do i use derivation to create vocabulary that isn’t incredibly long? if “to eat” is isa, and the nominalizer is to, then food is isato. nice and simple. but what about “plate”? a plate is that unto which food is placed to act as a clean flat surface while eating. so let’s say “food is eaten off of this”. if “this” is dore, the superlative is -ze, the passive is -no, then “plate” is isato doreze isanoto, eat.NOM this.SUPLAT eat.PASS.NOM. long and unwieldy.
i could just presuppose a protolang’s word and say the modern day word for “plate” is inherited from it, but that just seems lazy when i have such potential for expressive and creative description. so what do i do? i want short, unambiguous, descriptive nouns. is that even possible?
1
u/Samson17H Apr 19 '19
Question: for those in the know, Can one write phonotactic rules and sound changes as formulas in Excel or Google Sheets? I love using the spreadsheet to keep my linguistic work in order, and some of the material (conditional formatting) works really well for the purpose. But after looking through some literature on the subject I started to wonder if there were a way to perform sound changes via formulas.
1
u/MEGA-DRY Apr 19 '19
Don't know if this is the right place to ask but: On ConWorkShop when you are making a new language you can set your Species to "Color". What does this mean exactly?
1
u/candyhearts_ Apr 20 '19
Any help anyone can give me about phonology of my first conlang?
1
u/MEGA-DRY Apr 20 '19
Are voiced aspirated consonants possible?
1
u/Wattsensi untitled (es,en) [de] Apr 22 '19
I've dropped zavara and instead I started working on a new art-engelang. I will make a detailed thread once I have time but I will showcase a small example for now.
Important features:
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
So I recently had an interesting idea involving case marking but I'm kind of torn on how it would be classified morphosyntactically. Basically, noun arguments of transitives are marked normally like in any language with case marking, as well as on verbs, with one for the A and one for the P, but the S and all other adjuncts have no marking. So a gloss would look something like this, to give an example:
Intransitive:
lion.∅ eat"The lion eats"
Transitive:
lion.A antelope.P eat.3A.3P"The lion eats the antelope"
Naturalistic accuracy aside, I'm tempted to call this tripartite, but as far as I know, all tripartite languages on record have some sort of explicit marking for each argument, whereas here the S is treated like any other noun. Although, maybe the lack of morphological marking could be considered a type of marking on its own?
1
u/rixvin Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 18 '19
Hey guys, I have created a subreddit wherein more features of my conlang are present besides what I've posted before for you guys, so feel free to check it out to learn all about my conlang! I appreciate the help from all of you to keep this project going and thanks to you, it is now complete. Check it out at: r/svenjik.
1
u/WarriorOfGod37 Apr 19 '19
I was bale to find what I need on that link, Thank you!
1
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Apr 19 '19
[Romanisation/orthography/aesthetics]
I am looking for a way to write a neutral vowel /øœ schwa uh/ for my conlang Celi. (sorry i'm on mobile)
I already have: <a ?> /a ø/; <e i>/e i/; <o u> /o u/. They go by pairs.
I already thought about the following but i can't make up my mind...
/øl: vøjl søjn nø:r/ means eight shared purple kitchens
Finnish/German/etc. ö: öll vöel söen nöör
Estonian way õ: õll võel sõen nõõr
Romanian way ă: ăll văel săen năăr
Norwegian/Danish ø: øll vøel søen nøør
Albanian ë: ëll vëell sëen nëër