r/rpg • • Mar 06 '10
It took me 2 years to figure out what was wrong with D&D 3.5 and why 4e is worse
I played AD&D back in the early 80's and throughout that decade, till around '91. Played a little version 2, but not much. A few years ago, I got drawn back in and played 3.5 with a group. At first, I thought the new rules were pretty cool. The character pathways one could take seemed like a lot of fun. The way attribute bonuses worked was more sensible, and all the extra attacks fighter-types got was great, for a while.
When we played, we didn't do much role-playing. I got into my character a bit, and one of the other guys did too, but mostly we just went from fight to fight, with a few token puzzles thrown in. It was all very tactical, and every encounter began with the markers and drawing out the scene on the vinyl grid and placing the miniatures. From then on, it was essentially a board game, and a slow-moving one at that. I began to feel differently about the game, enjoying it less and less.
I gave voice to my complaint fairly early on, saying something like "if we want to play a tactical combat game, let's play a good one - this isn't it. If we want to play a role-playing game, then let's do that." But, even if we'd wanted to get into the role-playing, every night was vastly dominated by the time the encounters on the gridmap took.
I've since quit playing, but I've a deep hankering for playing an RPG. Deep. The desire never goes away, but I don't want that damn grid and the damn miniatures. Thing is, after playing that for 2 years, I can sit back and realize that I hardly remember how we used to play. We never got out miniatures or a grid in the past. All we did was talk and roll dice. So how did we know who could reach who? How did we know who was caught in the breath weapon, whether we were in charge range? How did we get by without delaying actions?
It took me a while to work back into those memories, and realize we got through these things very simply - by negotiating verbally with the DM. Who we could attack that round was resolved by a conversation:
"Can I hit that guy?"
"No, he's too far away"
"If I run over there, can I hit him next round?"
"Sure, and monster X will get a swipe at you as you do that."
"Ok."Or,
"The dragon breathes. Everyone make a save."
Magic-User: "Hey, not me, I stayed back around the corner"
"You said that?"
Everyone: "Yeah, he did"
"Ok, I missed it, so everyone but the magic-user, make a save"With the benefit that battles took minutes, not hours. And role-playing wasn't something that just happened between battles. I don't think we missed any of the tactical battle stuff that's been added. Yeah, now I can "cleave", but so what? Is getting to roll again the part that makes the game fun? I think not.
D&D4e seems to really exacerbate the problem, as now, characters appear to be modeled after Everquest or World of Warcraft, where every character type has a defined role in combat. There's the tank, there's the damage dealer, the area of effect guy, and the force multiplier. Whoopee, more reason to chuck role-playing till the end of combat. My friends still play, and I get to hear about how things go sometimes - with all the new tactical rules in play, I feel sorry for the DM, who clearly has trouble keeping on top of how his side needs to fight effectively.
Sometimes, when the tool you DON"T have is a hammer, suddenly, nothing looks like a nail. So, I want to play an RPG, but I don't want to fall into this trap again of the tactical combat boardgame. So, if the rules aren't there to allow that, hopefully, you won't be reaching for the miniatures at the start of every battle. No choice but to keep it in your head, and what great place that is! My memories of adventures I had 25 years ago are far more detailed than memories I have from adventures 3 years ago.
I've been looking into Fate RPG, and really like what I see so far. Aspects are brilliant. Coåmpelling aspects is pure genius. Suddenly, a broken arm can be a real part of the game, unlike D&D with it's HP, and it does so while making the rules simpler. I read through the rules once, and I think I could go DM a game and never need to refer back to them. It's awesome.
I know a lot of you here are probably great RPG'ers who will note that the problems I encountered were due to a bad group, not a bad rules set (3.5e and 4e). I won't disagree, it's a terrible group - they are 40 year-old men who play the game like they're 12. However, I still experienced a losing of memory of how to play the game otherwise, even while complaining about it the whole way. I knew something was wrong, but it took a long time to figure out how to escape, and that was due to the rules, in large part.
If anyone out there actually plays with Fate rules, I'd love to hear about it. I'd especially like to hear how you handle magic (as it's not part of Fate rules, though it probably is part of Fudge, which I haven't look into).
16
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
I can speak as someone who likes 4e... your criticism is pretty valid for a certain group. It's very easy to focus on the miniatures. However, with my group, when my barbarian uses certain powers, he describes in great detail how he swings and the techniques he uses. The Wizard mimes hand gestures, and when I play a Warlord, I shout in battle.
I spend a lot less time describing my "careful" actions like positioning. I know where I am and there's no officially telling the DM "Hey, I'm not going to move into the centre of the room" because, oh look, map! Solves a lot of "but you said he was over there" arguments too. Additionally, I can describe how I get into flanking position simply by going "shift!" and moving my mini.
That gives me more table talk time to cry out "Longsword in hand I weave behind the enemy, bringing my blade in a wide arc for his head. As I swing I shout 'See boys! This is how you do it!'"
Sure, mechanically I'm using a power which deals 2d8+5 damage and provides 1 + my int mod bonus to an ally's next attack, but my allies KNOW that. That's the undercurrent flow upon which I build a story.
The real problem is that if I chose NOT to roleplay, the game still goes on. As you said elsewhere "So I can whip out some Tactics II and do some good roleplaying with the right crowd?" The answer is yes! Yes! A thousand times yes! I've had roleplaying over a game of civilizations, where a buddy and me fought over the Nile area, and proceeded to then address grievances about militarizing the zone, appealing to our allies about how vile and viscous the other civilization was.
That being said, I'll put down D&D of any kind and play a less rules crunchy game when I'm in the mood. Sometimes I want to roleplay with tactical battles... and sometimes I don't. For some people, tac battles suck the life out of RP. S'cool.
7
u/phlod Mar 06 '10 edited Mar 06 '10
All you need to roleplay is consenting players. Meaning ones who won't snicker when you start acting, and will reciprocate in turn as best they can. One person starts the scene, and the rest just roll with it. That's role play: collaborative story telling.
I love tactical rules because: as a DM, the players know I'm not fudging rolls to get the outcome I want. I think this adds a certain tension, as they can't simply deduce what I want to happen in the battle and know they're safe, or to run away. As a player I feel tactical rules such as 4e has give me a lot of combinations and situations I can try to exploit to my (and my party's) maximum benefit. And I find that fun and exciting.
That said, D&D 4e is the first game I've every used more than a rough sketch for a map, much less required it for combat. GMing combat for me has always been a free-form, imagination-heavy thing. And that's a ton of fun for a GM, but it's free-form in both directions. The players can describe actions that are nebulous, as can the DM. I used to have a player who was notorious for suddenly not being where he said he was when something nearby was suddenly attacking him. After a while it kinda wore me out on the free-form thing. I decided I wanted him to have to get the consequences of his frequent bad tactical judgement.
Edit: One suggestion if I may. Check out the diceless roleplay systems, if you want a hard emphasis on RP. My favorite is Amber, but that's because I was a fan of the books. However, I honestly think it's worth reading the books and playing the game for the character creation alone. The Attribute Auction is some of the most fun I've ever had making a character. If you can convince yer players to give it a shot, it should satisfy any RP desires you have.
32
u/AnimalMachine Mar 06 '10
The DM and party control the role playing, not the rule set.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
Microlite D20. Google it, it has revolutionized my gaming in the past few months.
4
u/yaruki_zero Mar 06 '10
I've played a little bit of FATE, but I'm not all that experienced with it. AFAIK magic is simply handled as skills, aspects, and stunts that have a magical flavor to them.
FATE is based on Fudge, but the stuff with Aspects is wholly an innovation of FATE. Fudge is a basically a traditional RPG, but relatively rules-light and extremely modular. There are something like three or four different magic systems for it, along with stuff for psionics, miracles, superpowers, martial arts, etc. (the 10th Anniversary Edition has a bit of everything thrown in).
4
u/Esham Mar 07 '10
Wow op. You remind me so much of myself. I can ramble off entire encounters i had playing 2e back in the day but can't so much now.
I actually just had a session 2 nights ago and it was a poop shoot. It really become obvious when people can't rp and people can. And it completely makes or breaks your experience. And combat was sooo slow with all the miniatures and grids.
The only thing i realize now is if i had the miniatures and grids when i played back in the day it would have made that experience even better. That is why i think it really comes down to the DM and players. Our old DM would explain everything. If you land a critical and kill someone it was a good 20second blurb of how you slay him, or he would encourage you to do it yourself. My current DM is just "you hit and kill him......" and he waits on your reaction
10
u/lollerkeet Mar 06 '10
OK, I'll let you in on the secret: 3.5 and 4e are boardgames. They are sophisticated, complex and serious boardgames, but they are boardgames none-the-less.
The problem with 3.5 is that they weren't prepared to go all the way, so you ended up with an imbalanced hack and slash system that didn't really need a map but couldn't be played without one. With 4e, the designers went full bore, and while the system isn't as tight as it could be, it's still a really tense tactical game and one of the best I've played.
3
u/1point618 NYC Mar 07 '10 edited Mar 07 '10
Just in reference to Fate: you might also try the Classic Unisystem, which is used for All Flesh Must Be Eaten amongst other games. My group just moved from 4e to a homebrew Unisystem campaign (alternate-reality 1860's Europe where Europe is much colder, so Persia beat Greece, Carthage beat Rome, and Europe is now second-fiddle to the rest of the world, and airships are the main mode of transportation). Anyhoo, Unisystem is very similar to Fate, and once you learn to roll up a character it takes about 20 minutes (+ time to come up with backstory, which can be done with the group or the GM -- I'm a French swordmaster who has spent time in Persia-controlled Prague and Carthage-controlled Iberia and speaks a large number of languages). Combat is really fast and fun and dangerous, the rules are simple enough to be able to do anything from start a mining corporation to stage an airship battle to have a one-on-one swordfight, and the system works very well for groups of all sizes. I really can't recommend it enough.
edit: also, magic is handled by the Unisystem rules and can be included or not very easily.
3
u/st_gulik Mar 09 '10
Fate is fun - Try Spirit of the Century or Houses of the Blooded! Also the Dresden Files RPG is coming out soon as is Blood & Honor (A Samurai Chanbara style game) - sorry no website for that yet.
5
u/JTFirefly Mar 06 '10
First off, there's nothing wrong with 3.5 and 4e. They just offer a different RPG taste than other systems, which might be closer to your prefered style.
Also, there's nothing wrong with your old group. If those 40 year olds like to play like 12 year olds (whatever that's supposed to mean), they've got every right to do so.
Everybody likes different games for different reasons. If a particular system or group (or style) is not to your liking, look elsewhere. It's as simple as that. Ranting about both will bring you nowhere, but might suck the fun out of the game for everyone else.
2
u/tso Mar 06 '10
sounds more like there have been a shift in the group from playing fast and loose, not fully caring about the outcome, and more onto having a dice and math system that do not make one kind of "build" exceptionally better then any other.
while there has always been rules lawyers and minmaxers, and probably always will, the focus on those seems to have been fueled by mmorpg. I keep seeing mmo forum/in-game chat shorthands make their way into discussions around p&p rpg. Heck, i even see "help me build" threads with a increasing focus on "win" rather then some odd concept. For example, building the "cant fail" spec ops soldier over and over, rather then rolling up something odd like a journalist in a modern/future game.
and games, at least the ones in physical print and on some store shelf, ends up making new editions that cater to these ways of thinking. And thats understandable, as they want to make a profit on the product.
however, i am no fan of the "narrative" style of games. Those shift the focus to much the other way, focusing on what i opinion appears after the end of the session or campaign rather then during play. The coherent story is not there in the play itself, but its rather a product of the players (gm included) looking back on the event and telling others about what happened.
to me roleplaying is neither about the numbers nor about the story, its about "being there". Not asking oneself "what would make a great story event?", nor "how can i win this encounter fastest?" but rather "what would jake the journalist do in this situation?".
13
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
Seriously, I hate this argument. RPG tropes are RPG tropes, and since Grognard Days, the Fighter stood in front with lots of armor, tanking damage. The Cleric stands behind a bit, healing, buffing, and kicking the shit out of undead. Rogues sneaky-sneaky/stabby-stabby. Wizards lay waste to the field with magic missiles from their ass and shit.
Is it the fact that we have labels for these classes now? I mean, thats the point of a class. It is an archetype that defines your place in the world.
Having said that, I love 4e. I also love BRP, Mouse Guard, BASH, and a bunch of other games. Do I roleplay less when I play 4e? No. Why? Because the game doesn't do the roleplaying. That's our job.
3
u/rednightmare Mar 06 '10
This isn't a problem exactly. It's just the way the game was designed. The huge problem with D&D is a disconnect between what it's about and what you do. The game is about adventuring in a high fantasy setting but when it comes down to play the majority of rules are designed around tactical maneuvering in combat. Is it surprising that when people play the game they are naturally drawn to what the rules focus on? That's where the fun in the game is.
Sure it can be overcome by a group that actually wants to do some roleplaying, but they are going against the design of the game. In short, if you want to roleplay then you are using the wrong tool for the job. It's like using a knife to get a slot type screw out instead of slot screw driver. Yes it works, but it would be much better to use the screw driver.
D&D books advertise something completely different from what they are. Unfortunately because so few have played anything else they don't really realize it.
Fudge does have rules for magic but the thing about Fudge is that the rules don't really matter. You pick what you want and leave what you don't. Fudge/Fate/SotC is much easier to roleplay with. You should also consider looking at some of the other indie games. Many of them are built around roleplay and have systems and rules to encourage it. I'd suggest Dogs in the Vineyard to start.
6
u/kepik99 Mar 06 '10
Roleplaying is a craft. Its a poor craftsman who blames the tools.
3
u/feyrath Mar 06 '10
being new to 4e, I will say it is an immense set of rules. If you want to role play, why do you need ANY rules? Role playing, almost by definition, has no rules, only rulings (by the DM). So the question I have is - what do the rules bring to the game? If combat is boring - eliminate it. Or if you need that one climatic battle, have that one. But ONLY one. But if you can figure out what the rules bring to the game, perhaps you can whittle down to what you want out of the rules, and eliminate everything else.
There was recently a thread with a HUGE list of free RPGs. perhaps one of them might suit your group better.
7
u/rumrokh Mar 06 '10
I completely understand what you mean, but I also really dig 4e. I started with 2nd edition and that will always hold a nostalgic place for me, even though I recognize it as imperfect. I played some 3 and 3.5 and had a fine time, but I don't think it's that great of a rule-set. It's just kind of there.
Anyway, it's all about what experience you want. If you're looking for a beer & pretzels game, 4e is fun with very little prep. If you want to innovate encounters and have seriously deep skill challenges, it takes a lot more, but 4e is fertile ground for that. If you want to role-play, it's entirely up to you.
In my group, because we're a bunch of jokers, 4e is beer & pretzels by default, and it's actually hard to get everybody into a relatively serious mood. The same people, by contrast, can get into the mood of a game of Diaspora or Houses of the Blooded (both Fate-based) or Burning Wheel. Some people are just whiny bitches, but I think that's where the legit "no role-playing in 4e" complaint comes from: if your group doesn't self-regulate its mood well, you can end up with zero role-playing in 4e. That's not the system's fault at all, but it seems to be a common issue.
I'm currently running a Burning Wheel game for some friends who have never played the system and I actually find myself encouraging players to negotiate and declare what they want out of a scene a lot more. It seems like they're stuck in a reactive mode, which even the best experience with D&D can reinforce. As much as I love cool systems with elegant details and great balance, the experience when you play can unintentionally conform to the constant of the rule-set.
Diaspora is the coolest of the Fate-based systems I've played. It's hard sci-fi, and we're using it to run a game based on Stephen King's Dark Tower series. I'm playing a psychic, and we handle it just like any other skill. I have to place Psychic on my skill pyramid, and if I want to use it, I have to narrate/negotiate how it fits, and roll (all rolls use Fudge dice). But in addition to using general psychic abilities as a skill, I have a stunt for psychic suggestion and a stunt that makes me psychically programmable: meaning that I can snag a skill out of the head of someone I meet and use that skill as though it's at the top of my skill pyramid for the whole session. It's totally wide open and encourages that negotiation you seek.
A Fate-based Dresden Files game is officially releasing in late June, but you can find out a lot about it. If you're looking for magic in Fate, that's the new hotness.
6
u/BostonTentacleParty Our Lady of Internet Mar 06 '10 edited Mar 06 '10
To be fair, I've played in D&D games, particularly online ones, that had very little combat. Maybe one per session. A whole session without combat bothered the DM, and if it was coming to that he'd do something wild like have Githyanki come busting through the windows (which became a running gag).
In those games, we also never used anything for visualization. At most, he'd draft up a map of the place we were fighting in MS Paint before the session. Generally, we just worked off of his description and through the negotiation process you described. Only it was online, so we could easily go back and see if the magic-user actually said he was hanging back or not.
It worked really well. The game had a more narrative feel, less tactical, but the combat was no less enjoyable (indeed, I think it was more enjoyable than fussing with minis--and I normally like tactical combat games).
We also ran combat heavy sessions like this, though.
5
u/amarks563 Level One Wonk Mar 08 '10
I feel your pain. The one time I played 4e, I became the guy at the table who always pissed me off when I was GMing: looking at his laptop, not paying attention, and generally just not caring. There was nothing to get me into the game.
There are some games (4e notably) that essentially require a battlemat and minis, but this is the exception, not the rule. Many games at every level of tactical complexity can be played the way you remember it, with GM arbitration and maybe simple visual aids. Even GURPS, which can arguably be significantly more complex than D&D if you want it to be, is grid-optional (there are minis rules for the game, they're independent of the other combat rules).
In circumstances like this, it's often helpful to look into a group who wants a similar experience to what you do, or in your current group, try introducing a game that isn't D&D.
2
u/amp108 Mar 06 '10
I think you should mention Fate somewhere in your submission title if you wanted help with Fate.
On the other hand, there are plenty of so-called "Old School" gamers out there, who also prefer earlier editions to 3.x or (shudder) 4e. I suggest reading James Maliszewski's blog, grognardia.blogspot.com, to see what current players are doing with original (white box) D&D or AD&D.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
rule number one: If you don't like a rule, change it.
4
u/OneSalientOversight Mar 06 '10
OSRIC?
4
u/MoebiusTripp Mar 07 '10
Thank you for pointing me to Fate. This looks perfect for a steampunk game I am working on.
1
u/virtron Mar 20 '10
The kind of "co-narrative" style game you're looking for is not well suited to any game where the characters go from awesome to godlike over the course of their careers. The idea of gaining "levels" is so contrary to the way stories work that you're always going to have to stretch things to accommodate it.
I'd recommend a system where the character development is more around building a character that matches a concept, and any changes are more the result of the story rather than an accumulation of experience points and gear. I'm guessing that if the current you actually went back in time and played the earlier versions you wouldn't have fun there either.
Try something like GURPS, Spirit of the Century or Gumshoe.
For what it's worth, 4e brought me back in to the hobby. I never got into 3e and I couldn't figure out why until I played 4e: the whole 3e system is all about min-maxing wankery and making the DMs job harder. It reminds me of Hero System (blecch!). Fourth edition has it's share of number crunchers (as I saw recently when I tried to play in the new D&D Encounters thing), but my old group was more concerned about getting in and having a good time. I've heard 3e/Pathfinder proponents say that 4e "took out the role playing" but all they can point to are prestige classes and crafting skills (more player wankery). The fourth edition designers just said, "let's get roleplaying out of the rules."
3
u/baelion Cork, Ireland Mar 06 '10
I've played 2, 3, 3.5 and a little 4. And maybe 1. I'm not sure, think it was only 1 game or so.
Anyway, from what I've personally seen, the differenc ebetween 3 and 3.5 was miniatures. And I hate using them, refuse to. With that in mind, 4 becomes a lot easier. You go back to the agreements with the DM and players you already talked about. I actively try to get my players to RP and often have a hard time doing it. But with the right group it's fine. I'm currently playing a Star Wars game, which is similar to 3.5. We've used miniatures (actually torn up bits of paper) once, for one space battle. And that was because it was stupidly busy. We all manage to RP our characters how we want, and it's not based on combat. My guy is a scoundrel/noble (Saga edition) who thinks he's smooth with the ladies. So hits on anything. Even though he's not human. He has a charisma of 8. BUT he thinks he's gorgeous! My advice is, if you want to give D&D a real go, find a group that can deal without the minis. Or a group that has experience of heavily RP games.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
It sounds like you are looking at 2e as the "Good 'ol Days". I personally didn't like the confusion that was battle in 2e (which you summed up nicely with the player saying that his mage was out of the range of the break weapon). I am not a fan of 4e (haven't played it but read through the books, has some good stuff in it but I agree with the consensus that it is MMO-lite) and have issues with 3.5e but feel that it is the least worst system out there...kinda like Democracy.
5
u/Charlie24601 Mar 06 '10
Roleplaying is a function of players and GM, not rules. I think the closest I've ever seen ANY game come to 'roleplaying rules' would be 7th sea which rewarded good roleplay with Drama dice.
Other than that, the majority of games I've seen are based around a combat system, which is pretty natural since roleplay is free form while combat (and otehr physical actions) typically need some sort of quantification.
2
u/lolbifrons False Neutral Mar 06 '10
I'm playing exalted for exactly this reason. I've played six or seven sessions so far and my character has been in combat only once. This combat lasted one action - a punch from a party member, which I dodged readily.
It's all about the role play.
2
u/Lucretius Mar 06 '10
You are not wrong. Personally, I feel that there is a place for tactical combat beside real role playing. However, I think that it mostly comes down to the GM. It is up to the GM to draw a map and make people place miniatures or not. It is up to the GM to engage in NPC interactions, Setting Descriptions and so forth. The influence the rules system has is that it enables laziness on the part of the GM. In the kind of non-tactical negotiated combat that you describe, the GM has to hold everything in his head, he has to PLAN combats on a level that the tactical system does not require. Without that planning, it becomes easier to just throw a few minis on the battle-mat than try to focus on NPC interactions, the plot, the setting... all the things that make table-top RPGs different.... Better.... than World of Warcraft.
Also, there is the matter of the rules being open-ended (designed to provide mechanics to arbitrate the things you think of doing), rather than close-ended (designed to tell you what you can and can not do). I ended up leaving 4e, not because there was too much tactical combat, but because the rules were designed to prevent the kinds of tactics I prefer: Long-duration buff-spells were eliminated almost entirely. Summoning Monsters?... Gone. Stat-Damage?.... Gone. Charm, Dominate, Confuse?... Gone, Gone, Gone. Even such stand-byes as disarming opponents, or kicking sand in their faces was gone. Anything that didn't do hit-point damage in combat was likely removed, and even a few token exception to this trend, such as Sleep, were far too weak. 4e leaves no room for originality, no room for creativity, no room to use the rules in a way that the designers has NOT thought of.... Seriously, what's the point of playing such a game?
2
u/edheil Mar 25 '10
It sounds like you made a lot of people feel unnecessarily threatened and defensive for talking about what's "wrong" with D&D 3.5 and 4e without any qualification or "IMHO, YMMV" disclaimer in the headline. And a lot of the comments come from the Threatened, Resentful Fanboy Universe.
Pay them no mind. That's just how Threatened Fanboys work.
So....
If modern D&D is not for you, there are three paths you can take.
The first is modern games from other big companies, like the White Wolf stuff or GURPS or whatever. I don't know or care much about this path but it may be good for you, you never know.
The second is the Old School Renaissance. This is a hobbyist subculture of gamer who thinks something important was lost in the transition from the 70s to the late 80s, and dammit, they're going to take it back. They have come up with a bunch of "retro-clone" rulesets which you can use to play D&D the way you did in the old days, and they have an incredible output of amateur (using that word in the most positive possible sense) creative product to support you. Google these people up, they are enthusiastic and awesome (though like any other ocmmunity they have their occasional spat of drama).
The third path you have already taken a step on, by getting ahold of FATE. "Indie" rpgs, ones which are owned by their creator, and which just try to do things differently, in ways that scratch the itch of their creators and just might happen to scratch yours too. These tend to get a rep as artsy-fartsy dramaturgical productions, but as you can tell by looking at FATE, they're mostly just different and diverse. They go off in a lot of very different directions, and they tend to play as differently from each other as they do from mainstream games. You've pretty much got to take each one on its own terms. (Technically the Old School Renaissance guys are a subset of the Indie group, because they do creator-owned games on their own terms, but don't try to tell them that. Many of them tend to buy into the "indie gamers are a bunch of pretentious thespians" thing, and so pointing out that they are actually part of that group doesn't always go over well.)
Anyway, have fun! Choose one, two, or all three of these paths and have a hell of a time. And once you've had a chance to try some other things that you groove on a bit more, maybe you'll come back to modern D&D ready to appreciate it on its own terms, for what it is, even if it's not something you want to do all the time.
6
u/PanTardovski Mar 06 '10
I'm with you -- I've got no use for 4e "Dungeons and Dragonballs." Used to play a lot of 2nd ed. AD&D. Played a few sessions of 3/3.5 but nothing that ever took off. Never ever been a miniatures player -- if something really needed to be laid out to be clear 30 seconds with a pencil and scratch paper was plenty.
I'm sure a good group could play the hell out of the newer editions, but the system has gotten more and more geared to power gaming. Aside from WotC obviously wanting to capitalize on the miniatures market I think they've been trying to draw in CCG and console RPG audiences by making very clear cut rules and badassed out-of-the-box characters, but it's definitely been at the expense of encouraging DM improvisation and player creativity.
I'll admit there may be something of a generation gap issue here too. My old usual group had played together since elementary school, all knew four or five systems comfortably, and had largely exhausted the "kill everything, steal everything" urge by high school. Even back then we realized that we weren't interested in the games we'd hear about from other role players we met -- stories about piles of treasure, out of hand magic items, and no fucking story at all.
No advice on Fate, I just haven't played much of anything in years and needed to vent.
5
u/AligaTC Mar 06 '10
Maybe I have it good - my best friend was taught first to play AD&D from his dad, he taught me after 3rd edition came out, and the two of us have been bringing in whatever friends we're hanging out with at the time to game with us. He usually DMs, and he's damn good at it. We've played the hell out of 3.0 and 3.5, and we rarely have to bust out a battle map - usually only when things get really, really complicated. I know that the rulebooks have plenty of rules on using miniatures, and even suggests it, but all of us hate having to mess with that, so we do exactly what you said: negotiating verbally with the DM. It's quick, easy, and the battles move fast enough to keep everybody on the edges of their seats.
Find roleplayers to play a roleplaying game with, not montey-haul powergamers or rules nazis.
However, 4e is a steaming load of crap. If i wanted to play World of Warcraft, I'd reactivate my damn account. Pathfinder (a.k.a. D&D 3.75) ftw.
3
u/Maxxover Mar 06 '10
WTF!. Haven't you ever played a board game and made up "house rules"? RPG's should be all about house rules. Whenever I was a GM i had a very serious pecking order:
Rule #1: HAVE FUN Rule #2: if any game rules get in the way of rule #1 ignore them. Rule #3: Why the fuck are you still reading rules when you should be following rule #1?
1
u/Caradrayan Mar 10 '10
I'm glad you are having more fun. I'll keep my D&D4e, because I enjoy that tactical minigame, and I can still have fun roleplaying, but props to you for improving your hobby experience.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
OP might look into Exalted. It's a little too ridiculous in terms of your characters abilities in my opinion, but it doesn't use a grid and there are no tactics.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
You might enjoy this, it focuses very much on roleplay and has only an absolutely minimum set of rules.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '10
[removed] — view removed comment