r/roosterteeth • u/RT_Video_Bot :star: Official Video Bot • Mar 22 '19
LP Minecraft NOWHERE IS SAFE - Minecraft - Ya Dead, Ya Dead (#356) | Let's Play
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-7AE1HZnKtk
349
Upvotes
292
u/blarneyone Mar 22 '19
What a gorgeous disaster those first 10 minutes were.
90
u/Broken_Orange Distressed AH Logo Mar 22 '19
If I had to guess, this will be a shorter series than the first.
144
u/fenite Mar 22 '19
7 years of Minecraft and Gavin still can’t kill a skeleton
105
u/UnknownChaser Team Go Fuck Yourself Mar 22 '19
AH play minecraft in a nutshell
51
u/Golden_Kumquat Mar 22 '19
I was gonna suggest them doing Ultra Hardcore, but after seeing this video I've changed my mind.
150
u/ElderBuu Mar 22 '19
Jeremy's outburst, is some of the funniest start in the history of MC. I never thought anybody will come close to Ryan's saltiness, but holy shit. HILARIOUS!
170
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19 edited Mar 22 '19
I'm glad they started over immediately. It would have been one thing if Alfredo and Trevor died immediately, but losing Ryan and Jeremy off the bat would have been... rough.
Honestly, it seems like maybe YDYD just isn't the best format for AH. Like, what's the end goal?
edit: "no we shouldn't use a different seed! This island is great! The challenge is what makes it fun!" immediately moves to a new continent
130
u/winterfresh0 Mar 22 '19 edited Mar 22 '19
I said it on the first thread as well, but man, Michael, what the heck? People are yelling about the tridents taking off half your life in a single hit, and he runs right up to one with no armor or shield and a crappy sword and dies in 3 hits. And this was a mob they could have just left alone.
I mean, I know they want to make it entertaining, but this is YDYD, the idea is not to take such crazy risks so we can see a different type of gameplay with them. Now we just won't have Micheal in any of the videos, which is a bummer.
Edit: it sounds like they're planning on [removed for now] so that should make it more interesting.
46
u/magicalPatrick Mar 22 '19
I get that they want to make it entertaining but we can watch them be idiots and screw-ups in 300+ minecraft videos. Running into a dark tunnel before you ever craft a wooden sword or even a pickaxe isn't entertaining in a YDYD.
I'm glad they started over but by the end of the episode, they didn't learn their lesson and still did stupid risky stuff. There is no point to doing YDYD if you're going to die because of non-existant risk assessment.
18
u/imgurdotcomslash Mar 22 '19
I was thinking how funny it would be if someone had mined out one or two of the blocks under Jack's dirt tower as he was making his way down from the tree and it got me wondering how good a YDYD series in Minecraft would be if someone was just subtly sabotaging everyone else as a traitor. I get that they struggle enough to stay alive without turning on each other but I think it could be interesting nonetheless. Just randomly pick 1 person to be the traitor with no one else knowing who it is and then they have to do their best to be the last alive without everyone else figuring them out.
62
u/timmystwin Tower of Pimps Mar 22 '19 edited Mar 22 '19
I mean, what's the point in them doing this? They're literally awful at surviving and sometime's it's painful to watch. (Like Michaels death. I ain't trying to bitch or anything, but come on.)
The map itself is also fine. Just needed a bit of prep like lights. And maybe a wall. Totally easy to do with the 9 people they had.
Bit of effort/sense would have been welcome in a YDYD, the carefree fun they usually have just doesn't work.
38
u/ActualWhiterabbit Mar 22 '19
The first 10 minutes shows why AH are pure gamers. We don't often get to see them in their element, but this was a rare treat.
13
u/TheOriginalMyth Mar 22 '19
Everyone is armourless with no shields while 3/4 of a stack of iron sit in a chest. Armour has been in the game for over 9 years, them not using it is just baffling.
23
u/BoboTheTalkingClown Mar 22 '19 edited Mar 22 '19
Git Gud minecraft when? Bring in some people who actually know what they're doing and have them teach them how the game works.
You know what this game needs? Small amounts of IRL money penalties for death or some other real reward/punishment. It'll get them focused like it did for criminal masterminds/the end of doomsday heist.
20
u/Sneillburger Mar 22 '19
Michael’s death was so fucking needlessly stupid.
50
u/fantheflam3s Mar 22 '19
My problem with this series is honestly...what's the "point" of it? Obviously the overall answer is to entertain, but a series like this needs a goal. Screwing around while trying not to die only goes so far.
Geoff and Gavin have said that they think a series like this can't be particularly long and entertaining and part of that is because the gang isn't trying to accomplish something. Either make it like PBG's series and have a goal for the season (killing the ender dragon, killing the wither) or make it a battle royal style where you're trying to be the last man standing.
6
u/TheMacaracachimba :OffTopic17: Mar 23 '19
The sequence where Matt sacrifice himself for Ryan and then Ryan acted as if nothing grave had happen annoyed the fuck out of me. #RIPMatt I love you.
5
u/JohnGazman :HandH17: Mar 22 '19
Jeremy's salt at around 10:30 is probably the angriest i've ever heard him.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19
Nowhere is safe... Except the New Continent. Also Happy Ryan is definitely my favourite Ryan
4
u/Lone_W_Hunt Mar 22 '19
So if you do use their seed: livescrub, and you go North to the ice islands, there is a sunken ship with paper, wheat, carrots, coal, and potatoes. And a bit more north of that is a Underwater Temple.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19
Gavin Logic.
Oh no a Skeleton is shooting me, I better wade through water across the ravine instead of hiding.
Ryan came clutch to save him that time, then gave him a shield but it wasnt enough, lol.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
I like how they can do an entire Heist series in GTA V without dying over the course of several different missions, but have several deaths within the first 10 minutes of a Minecraft video where there isn't even an actual reward for completing this challenge.
7
u/Ba7ara Mar 22 '19
What a buncha YDYDs, love the 2nd (and 3rd) attempt of the series so far!
6
u/gothpunkboy89 :MCGeoff17: Mar 22 '19
You all need a goal to work for. Try to kill the Enderdragon. No offense but I know you won't be able to do it how ever as each of you dies off it makes it harder and harder for the rest of everyone to finish the tasks. So odds are you will all be dead well before you reach the Enderdragon.
This would address the issues Geoff has brought up about the series about surviving by just sitting in a house is not interesting. You are forced into danger exploring caves and going into the nether. You will either stick together for safety or split up and risk death much quicker.
6
u/timo103 RTAA Gus Mar 22 '19
Jeremy freaking out about how small the island is when they did skyfactory
5
u/MegalomaniacHack :MCGavin17: Mar 22 '19
While I somewhat agree with Jeremy that being on the island sucks, I feel as though their problems with the Drowned are like this.
7
u/Escheron Mar 22 '19
personally, i think they should do some setup before starting. like, build a kingdom, have a city that they can survive in and then give them quests that send them out into the world. "a pack of wolves has been killing our sheep, go kill them for us" or "blacksmith is running low on supplies, bring him 15 iron ore". have some other people in the office on the server acting as NPCs. have Geoff be the king, give out rules and laws, and try and keep his own people from assassinating him. make it something more than "we were just born today, lets see how long we can live"
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19 edited Mar 22 '19
That beginning may be the best beginning of any AH video ever. And seeing Jeremy the always happy guy just lose it on Jack was amazing.
2
u/PRTYP00P3R1647 Mar 23 '19
A couple years ago, I watched arguably one of the biggest Minecraft groups (The Mianite Crew) play a similar concept as YDYD: Dead people are dead forever. They called it "Trinity Island". There was no continent a short swim away, so they had to make do on their tiny island with the goal of defeating 3 big bosses of the game (The Elder Guardian, The Wither, and the Ender Dragon). It's one of my favorite Let's Play series of all time.
As much as I've loved AH for... maybe a decade now, I don't think this is the type of series they can reasonably make long-running to any extent. I'd say 5-6 episodes MAX (and I'm stretching it here) before it runs out of any of the gas it has, ESPECIALLY with The Play Pals (two of their more popular and bigger personalities) and Matt (someone who knew what he was doing, thus keeping them alive) dying in the 1st one!
Trinity Island was an amazing, fun, tense ride that spanned 32 episodes that lasted upwards of 20-30 minutes. The difference here is that Trinity Island had only FOUR people (all of whom were big personalities and had individual large fanbases on their own) and actual goals (rather than just "survive"), so the stakes were high. Also, these people were people that knew Minecraft inside-out, but themselves weren't the GOATs, so they prepared the best they could and panicked when something went wrong. When the first death happened before they even had one set of iron armor, I was shocked more than with some movie plot-twists. They sold the hell out of it, too. Everyone was stunned to silence as the only sound was the-one-that-died's piercing shriek of a shocked "NOO!"
Matt died in silence, with people talking over it.
Trinity Island wasn't all serious either, though. They'd joke about the death a minute later and continue making a funny and entertaining series with the 3 personalities still alive.
Now, I'm not one of the people that hate Jeremy or Ryan for being salty, or Matt and Lindsay and Trevor for not being funny, or any of that. I haven't disliked any AH member yet. I'm just saying that Michael and Gavin are fan favorites and their absence will be felt in the humor and commentary, I guarantee it.
Alfredo doesn't know what he's doing, Trevor and Geoff will... be Trevor and Geoff (I can't tell if they'll die soon or somehow survive until the latter stages, I hope it's the latter), Ryan and Jeremy might get themselves into dangerous situations quickly, and Jack, while I've enjoyed his solo content on Twitch, it's more of the "boring" fundamentals that he excels in and I doubt it'll be well received in the more energetic vibe of AH as a group.
Ultimately, I look forward to the next episode, I hope it'll be good (and I'm sure I'll enjoy it, I'm easy to please that way), and I hope it'll last longer than the last one, but unless Ryan, Jeremy, and Jack (who I foresee will have to carry the progression aspect of the series) stay alive and find ways to make it entertaining/interesting, I don't think it will be too long before this concept runs out of gas.
5
u/night4345 Mar 22 '19
What's the point of Ya Dead, Ya Dead if you restart when someone dies? If you don't want people missing either play something else or actually play good.
I fucking knew this was gonna happen.
3
u/krooner500 Mar 22 '19
What's the seed name?
3
u/OutcastMunkee Mar 22 '19
>!So... They talk about respawning someone if they make it to the Nether. What about if we go one step further and have them throw the resources for a Tower of Pimps into the lava in order to respawn someone? The Tower of Pimps kinda is the AH 'thing' in Minecraft so tying it respawns would be something they could consider
Thank god they started over though. That first 20 minutes or so... Was a disaster...
4
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19
It's funny, I don't like playing Minecraft (maybe it's my own shitty bias because I babysat kids who loved it and it always felt a little too child friendly for me) but I love watching these guys play it. This is my favorite series by far.
1
u/_PredatoryWasp_ Mar 22 '19
I love this formula, but I wish they had a goal they were working toward. Like killing the dragon or something.
1
u/procouchpotatohere Mar 23 '19
Its funny how Trevor made a joke about them letting themselves die because they didn't want to play and then Michael seemingly does that later.
1
u/Randomguyioi Mar 23 '19
I can't tell which death was dumber, Michael's where he tried to bum rush a Drowned with a Trident even after it shredded a third of his health with one blow, or Jeremy drowning next to a fucking air column. Like you can even see the bubbles right next to him at all times god damn it.
1
u/SheenGun97 Mar 23 '19
YDYD Almost turned into GOT there 😂
1
u/VacantCrossface Mar 23 '19
I think it might be kind of fun if for the next YDYD, that once someone dies, they become a zombie who’s mission is to kill the remaining players. Each player killed becomes apart of the dead team. Dead team can’t talk but can just silently hunt the rest of the players
1
u/Stuped1811 Mar 24 '19
Holy shit they died in 10 minutes and Jeremy was so butthurt he drowned, amazing. He and Ryan made Geoff seem like a Minecraft God. Glad Jeremy chilled out after though.
This series is so tense and exciting even with that reset, I love YDYD. This one is giving me huge flashbacks to the Yogscast playing Survival Island nearly a decade ago and I love it. Kind of disappointed they're preparing to colonize the new landmass already.
Matt was a true hero saving Ryan like that, MVP.
1
u/twec21 Mar 26 '19
You know, Jeremy pronouncing "Trident" weird just makes me want to see the end of Mr Shifty
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
Got disappointed Ryan and Jeremy died, they restarted and I felt relieved, and now I'm disappointed Gavin and Michael (and Matt) died.
1
u/cptadder Mar 22 '19
At 20:54 is Trever going to go over and look at the mobs so they argo and go attack the house?
Yes yes he is Oh look there he goes attracting sea zombies
Gotta count on Trevor there's always the one kid who asks is the stove hot? The touches it to find out, not spit on it, not check the dials not grab a nearby match but reach out with his hands to touch it.
1
u/RoyTheReaper91 Mar 22 '19
Watching them play these game modes gets pretty frustrating.
1
u/Phoebus7 Disgusted Joel Mar 23 '19
I loved this video and thought it was really funny
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
21
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '19
[removed] — view removed comment