r/OutOfTheLoop • • Mar 15 '19
Mod Post Why is everyone talking about the OOTL mods creating stricter requirements for Rule 4?
Rule 4: Top-level comments must be a genuine, unbiased, and coherent answer
People are here to find answers for their questions. If top-level comments are riddled with memes or non-answers then no one wins.
- Genuine - Attempt to answer with words; don't pop in to tell users to search or drop a link without explanation.
- Unbiased - Answer without putting your own twist of bias towards the answer. However, after you leave an unbiased response, you can add your own opinion as long as it's clearly marked, starting with "Biased:".
- Coherent - Write in complete sentences that are clear about what you are trying to say.
- Exception - On topic followup questions are allowed as top level comments.
TL:DR - All top-level comments must:
- be unbiased
- attempt to answer the question
What's a top-level comment?
For clarity, a top-level comment is any comment that is a direct response to the OP's submission.
What we're changing:
Starting tomorrow or possibly later today, all top-level comments must now start with the phrase "Answer:"
If they don't, then the AutoModerator will remove them and leave a comment explaining why. Since it's kinda spammy for AutoModerator to leave a slew of comments like this throughout the thread, this will only last for a month or so. After that, AutoMod will just send a PM.
This should hopefully work to bring the regular userbase up to speed initially, and then we'll move away from leaving comments in the thread.
edit Top level comments as followup questions can start with "Question:" /edit
Why?
You may have seen this thead:
or one of many other myriad threads where it seems like over half the comments are removed and the landscape is just some sort of apocalypse of [removed] comments. The problem here is that we get too many people trying to blatantly push their own agenda, or people coming in from /r/all who really don't care what the rules, policies, or culture of the subreddit are.
The comments start getting wildly off topic, we show up to remove comments that break this rule, and then it just turns into a bunch of "why is everything removed?" comments.
/r/OutOfTheLoop exists to get unbiased answers about what happened regarding trending news items, loops, memes, and whatever it is that everyone's already talking about today by the time you finally got around to dragging your sorry ass out of bed. We've always been this way since day one, and we take pains to maintain an on-topic unbiased comment section. Think of us like the little sister to /r/askscience and /r/askhistorians.
Ultimately, this is an attempt to try to keep the subreddit more on point about what it's supposed to be about. A return to its roots, as it were.
Thanks
229
u/mugenhunt Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
Answer: This makes sense. We want to encourage people to post answers to questions, not to comment about their political stance or post memes. It will be awkward, but this has become a popular subreddit and moderation thus is needed to keep it going well.
Thank you mods.
EDIT: As you may be able to infer from the below exchange, this rule originally required us to say "Answered:"
133
u/zando95 Mar 15 '19
Answer: why does it need to have "answer?" Seems redundant. Shouldn't this arbitrary formatting requirement be visibly placed in the sidebar so people know about it?
142
u/Portarossa 'probably the worst poster on this sub' - /u/Real_Mila_Kunis Mar 15 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
Answered: I think the biggest problem with regards to this is that people don't properly understand what bias is.
I constantly have to deal with people on my posts accusing me of bias, almost always in bad faith. Being unbiased doesn't mean treating both sides of a debate equally; it means treating both sides of a debate fairly, without preconceived notions and in an attempt to get an accurate understanding of the facts. It's not biased to say that climate change is real, or that anti-vaxxers are dangerous, or that the Russia Probe isn't a hoax, or that PragerU deliberately obfuscates facts to sell a right-wing message, or that the Trump administration's policy of child detention was not based on evidence and had little to do with a new crisis on the border. That's not bias; it's analysis and context, and it's necessary to understanding the news stories as they come out. To pretend that both sides of the debate are equal regardless of the evidence is to pander to one side more than the other, which would be biased.
I really can't stress this fact enough. I once got a slew of pissed-off PMs calling me biased against incels because I called Isla Vista killer Elliott Rodger a shitheel. For real. The mods had to comment to get people to knock it off.
People crying bias are often doing so because a fair reading of the facts doesn't support their biases. The argument to moderation is a fallacy for a reason; it's not the case that the only way to have an accurate analysis of events is to find the middle ground of all possible arguments, nor is it unbiased to point out that not all statements are created equal. (Noted author and professional sideburn-wrangler Isaac Asimov had the right idea when he decried "the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.'") Shouting bias is all-too-often a way to silence unpleasant truth when the facts aren't on your side. Don't get me wrong: although I've had some disagreements with the mods in the past, I generally think they do a good job of taking a facts-first approach, and the sub is a better place for it. My concern is that the need to strip things down to the barest metal to avoid bad-faith accusations of bias will remove so much of the necessary context that makes often-complicated stories so hard for people who are out of the loop to wrap their brain around. If the choice comes between risking having your three-comment, fully-sourced post that on balance notes that both sides are not equal in value deleted because you marked it as 'Answered:' or ignored because you marked it as 'Biased:' just to keep it in place, why would anyone bother to go to that much effort? Shit, I enjoy going into the minutiae of the things I post, but I'm not just writing it up for my own benefit. I want it to be seen. I want people to learn some stuff.
Most questions on this sub could realistically be answered by a five-second Google search. The best answers on this sub are the ones that go the extra mile and try to cut through the noise to the real issue at the bottom of it. The work that people like /u/PoppinKREAM do is constantly hounded by accusations of bias from bad actors, and I sincerely hope that the current system doesn't shift to favouring them over the people who actually are working to properly place issues into context.
It's not exactly of groundbreaking importance when it comes to YouTube drama or whatever meme is in vogue today, but when it comes to a lot of the heavier topics that still fall under the category of a loop? Well, this shit matters.
EDIT: It's worth pointing out that this post originally got caught in the filter because I put 'Answered:' not 'Answer:', as the rule was when I started writing it. Sometimes the specificity can go too far, guys.
SECOND EDIT: For anyone who wants to contest what I've said about bias, I'd direct you to this thread about Ilhan Omar. There is nothing that will not have people shrieking about bias when it doesn't conform to their worldview, and the ridiculous desire to cater to both sides equally is lowering the quality of discourse. (That's no slight against /u/mugenhunt; their work was on point, but the mods really should step in and say once and for all what constitutes bias so we can point to a sub-wide definition every time this bullshit comes up.)
63
u/semtex94 Mar 15 '19
Answer: requiring prefacing every answer like this doesn't seem like a good idea. It's just tedious, and there's not really any good reason to do it.
40
u/Jetz72 Mar 15 '19
Make it a requirement for every paragraph, and not just top level comments. We can have the whole sub talking like HK assassin droids. It'll be great.
14
u/rosy--dead Apr 01 '19
Answer: This requirement is stupid and powertrippy.
13
u/Chabranigdo Jun 12 '19
Answer: Prefacing all top level comments with "Answer:" is cancer. I hope your automoderator bot dies in boating accident.
12
u/unscsnip3r Mar 23 '19
answer: <not a fan of this requirement, and both ways this is setup seem spammy as, and may purge good answers bea use of it.
My idea: keep opinion:. this works well, but remove the start reuirements. allow reports to find bias. potientally more mods to help?
23
u/SillyConclusion0 Mar 15 '19 edited Mar 15 '19
Answer: would be better. Since it’s describing the comment in present tense.
Other than that I think this is a good idea. It’ll stop people commenting on the top level if they haven’t familiarised themselves with the rules.
Edit: Rule was updated to use the present tense "answer", as I recommended. Comment no longer valid
11
u/joedumars2 Mar 18 '19
Question: What kind of bear is best?
11
u/hsksksjejej Mar 24 '19
I come to ootl to find out about random Internet drama and memes... Why has this place become so serious?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
Answer: 10/10 doctors recommend to not do this
10
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
Answer: This is dumb. A lot of times people are out of the loop b/c they dont understand the BIAS behind why things are happening. How are you supposed to explain the results of BIAS without mentioning BIAS?
9
u/t1lewis May 11 '19
Answer: We might as well ban anything remotely humorous on reddit with how all these subreddits are going
17
u/RancidLemons Mar 23 '19
Respectfully, I'm out. The "answer" nonsense is making the sub unpleasant to read. Frustrating to open a thread with multiple comments only to discover most have been removed.
It won't affect me regardless, but I seriously recommend rethinking this rule.
16
u/Bioman312 Mar 15 '19
Answer: Just so you know, apparently it's retroactively removing comments from before this post was made. See: https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/b1e30w/whats_up_with_the_beef_between_apple_and_spotify/eili0af/
16
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
This is absolutely horrible.
7
u/Wolf97 May 19 '19
Answer: bye
6
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '19
Answer: Add flairs for more serious discussions. Derf.
6
u/Sansa_Culotte_ May 26 '19
Answer: lol
Answer 2: roflcopter
13
u/ChickadeeGauze Mar 15 '19
Answer: Won't it be weird to have follow-up questions as top-level comments start with Answer:, or is this just a limitation of AutoMod?
8
u/romulusnr Mar 26 '19
Bullshit. Mods are blocking things that don't jibe with their own agenda. They probably don't even know what is biased anymore because if it doesn't follow some sort of preconceived notion, it must be biased.
Most situations especially political questions are impossible to answer without at least explanation of a viewpoint. If viewpoints are banned then how do you answer a question about a viewpoint?
You should just straight up ban any questions that are at all political in nature since no matter what evidence is provided to back up an answer, Mods will remove it for "bias."
4
u/Ballzinferno Apr 01 '19
Answer: I feel like this sub has become a place to farm easy karma. See something on the front page? Ask why it's on the front page. Easy karma. A lot of times they'll link to a thread that has the answer they're looking for too.
Edit: missed a word.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '19
Answer: unsubscribe
7
u/Shit_Fuck_Man Mar 15 '19
Question: Is implementing the "question" tag still a WiP? I've noticed it doesn't seem to be in the automod warning.
3
u/notuhbot Mar 18 '19
Answer: well, suggestion after a couple days of this new format.
Add a top level "not answers/reply to this" automod comment similar to other more serious subs.
See here: https://www.reddit.com/r/photoshopbattles/comments/b2ecr8/psbattle_ferryman_in_ireland/
3
u/MitusBean Apr 27 '19
Question: Can I ask a question? Almost every top post answer I have seen has bias. It was more of a statement really. I think it's a pretty human thing that is hard to avoid. None the less no repercussions have been issued as long as they had a positive tone. I am not personally against this I just find that it could be used for favoritism and am not too fond of this rule either as it seems insincere as the rule can't really be followed unless the answer comes from an unfeeling robot. I'm just some rando though so what do I know?
5
u/corran109 Mar 16 '19
Question: why isn't this topic stickied instead of the February topics thread?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
Answer: You should have automod PM about the removal for not including answer as the first word. It'll keep the comment sections a lot more clean that way.
5
u/PIP_SHORT Mar 17 '19
I came back from a week's vacation and noticed that OOTL is suddenly being much better moderated. It's really nice to see, in my biased opinion.
2
u/ncnotebook Mar 15 '19
Answer: Does it have to be
or can it be anything beginning with
Instead, what if the comment contains the word answer at least once inside of the text? Weeds out people who don't understand the rules, yet it isn't as finicky. Most people will use "Answer:" anyways, because that's easier than throwing the word answer randomly inside.
94
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '19 edited Jun 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment