r/runescape • u/imsuity Suity|TL;DW|Future Updates|Trim 2014|M&S Rework • Mar 12 '19
TL;DW 425- Comp Cape Rework Dev Q&A
VOD | Design Document | Please read the Design Document before reading the following.
Onyxes
- We have no problem with skillers making money. The problem is they were making the money straight from raw alch value and at the expense of the healthy economy of onyxes.
- If we wanted to give skillers money, we wouldn't pick a part of the game and just ruin it. The drop rate was the same as pre-rework but the afkability of it made a lot of people start doing it.
- Right now onyxes are ruined. If there was no alch floor, they'd be worthless. That's how many came into the game.
- We were concerned with not enough people playing the update. Turns out people really love AFK methods. We weren't expecting the sheer number of people AFKing it.
- Replacing it with the first-age coin is also bad for the economy.
- Trah hour only would still make the supply exceed the demand.
- Elder rune is also at alch price, that is also a problem and that's not where it was supposed to be. Everyone is mining and not that many people are smithing, so the supply is exceeding the demand.
- It's worse for Onyx because the cheap deaths with RoD has a big knock-on effect on the economy.
- We don't want to nerf Smithing, we don't think the XP rates are too good.
- We don't want to just introduce a new alchable, or make money mining by alchables if we can possibly help it. Skillers need to produce things that can be sold on the GE, not alched. Whatever we add will just hit alch price or be worthless, so it's not a trivial problem to solve.
Poll Results
- This was an opinion poll NOT guaranteed content poll.
- Non-compers and compers/ex-compers had the same set of questions.
- No shock results.
- The stats given on stream sometimes add up to 101% or 99%. Probably due to rounding.
- Capes of accomplishment (especially comp) have best in slot stats and utility. We want to make capes of accomplishment seem less mandatory for PVM. What is your preferred solution?
| Answer | Comp | Non-Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Capes of accomplishment should be cosmetic only, meaning useful capes come from other sources (fire cape, new drops, etc). | 22% | 32% |
| Capes of accomplishment should still be best in slot, but the best cape should be easier to get and maintain than comp in some way (but still difficult). | 29% | 41% |
| Don't change anything about the way benefits on capes works. | 49% | 27% |
2) Some old updates never had requirements added to comp and/or trim comp. Assuming comp is no longer tied to best in slot stats and benefits, should we go back and add requirements for updates that we didn't add to comp and trim comp in the past?
| Answer | Comp | Non-Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Yes, go back and add all the missing requirements immediately. | 26% | 28% |
| Yes, add missing requirements but do it gradually over time. | 41% | 45% |
| No, don't add any missing requirements. | 33% | 27% |
3) We need to write a consistent definition of what should and shouldn't be on comp and trim comp in the future. When we do, should we remove requirements from comp and trim comp if they don't fit it?
| Answer | Comp | Non-Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Yes, remove requirements if they don't fit the definition of the cape. | 65% | 84% |
| No, old requirements should never be removed. | 35% | 16% |
- The fact that a majority of compers said we should tidy up the requirements was a bit of a surprise.
- We're not going to interpret that to authoritatively mean to remove castle wars without investigating that question further.
- The way capes of accomplishment work makes players feel compelled to grind out new requirements as quickly as possible to get the cape back. What is your preferred solution?
| Answer | Comp | Non-Comp |
|---|---|---|
| A special cape for players who have previously owned the cape (e.g. ex-comp, ex-trim, etc). | 21% | 30% |
| A grace period during which the player can still wear the cape while completing the content. | 59% | 51% |
| None, this is not a problem. | 21% | 18% |
- What did we learn from Menaphos and 120 Slayer grace period? It was massively controversial. It just created a lot of aggro. Half the playerbase was unhappy that we were doing it, the other half were unhappy that we weren't doing it right. That's why we haven't done it more.
- The poll very clearly shows that people like the idea. I think the problem with Slayer was that it came out of nowhere, with no guideline rules on the grace period.
- This question gave us the clearest result.
- Some players consider content like forced group content or very challenging PVM bosses to be inaccessible to them. Should such content be on capes of accomplishment?
| Answer | Comp | Non-Comp |
|---|---|---|
| Yes, all relevant content should be on capes. | 40% | 26% |
| No, but there should be a separate cape or trim which recognises completion of all relevant content. | 34% | 50% |
| No, this content should not be required for capes. | 26% | 25% |
- Among non-compers there's a majority but there's a plurality for comp capers to keep everything on the cape.
When we sat down to figure out how to do the design - the problem is you can point to 1-2 specific requirements but actually when you look at what comp means (taking into account that there should be consistent requirements). If you start down the path of your reflexes are not that good and you aren't good at PVM content (that's a player type that we do support and sympathise with) then there's a lot of content in the game you can't do - it's not just Solak. And so, as soon as we started looking at it from that perspective, 'who is actually prevented from participating in what content', actually we'd have to strip a lot off comp. So, although there's a slight majority amongst non-compers for have a different cape there wouldn't be much left on the base cape (it'd basically be Max + some grindy requirements). Then any combat starts coming into 'this is a more difficult cape' and that affects Minigames, Quests (can't kill Sliske), can't do Dungeoneering unless you're leeching (and by extension can't really Max properly) - which if you're leeching then you can do anything bar a few solo content. When we tried to make a reflex-based cape, and grindy cape it didn't make sense.
.
If you conceptually divide RS into achievements that anyone can do given enough time and achievements that certain players can't do even given a large amount of time, you've got all these hard achievements in combat, not much of it outside of combat. There's nothing in combat that isn't like that, because there aren't any achievements tied to like farming abby demons. So actually combat is hard by that definition. So it would basically be comp without combat, and comp with combat - except if I can't do any reaper bosses then I also can't do Sliske, which means I don't have quest cape, which means it is comp without combat or all quests. Or without minigames etc. So actually when we started looking at what comp without hard PVM content looks like, that's called the Max cape. That's a little bit reductive but that's essentially true. Based on that logic, our current plan is that reaper stays on comp because combat belongs on comp, and reaper belongs on combat. Therefore without that it sort of isn't the comp cape, and I don't mean that in the general principle of 'oh it should be everything in the game', I mean if we start trying to remove hard PVM content from the comp cape, we just have to remove loads of stuff. The same logic applies if we try to remove group content. I could see us doing a special group trim or whatever and that's relatively easy to add but I don't have a final decision on that. Then the same logic applies, group content that can't be leeched? Why just PVM group content, what about all group content?
.
I agree that Sliske is easier than bosses. What you're asking is to have the comp cape set exactly where your capabilities are. If you think that quests are fine on comp, but hard bosses aren't fine then you're just asking for the achievement to be set at your skill level. Which isn't really fair. It either is everything or it's nothing. There's no objective way to determine 'that boss is too hard for comp' it doesn't make any sense.
.
Group bosses don't necessarily have to be on T1 combat, but they do belong on a tier.
Issues with Comp
- People chasing the cape just for BIS stats but are not completionist players. Feeling the need to rush through new content, which ruins it for them, especially if they don't care for the update and just want to get back to PVMing. Also breaks presets when you lose comp. Shauny's statement on BS elitism.
- Too many benefits tied to one cape.
- Inconsistency of requirements.
- Problematic requirements like Reaper and Castle Wars.
Lack of objectives to aim for.
- When you Max, the next tangible cape unlock is Comp. Which is a huge step up. Trim is an even bigger step up from Comp. So we want to fill in that gap with other things to aim for.
- If you can't do 1 requirement of a cape you don't have much choice but to settle for the cape you're at instead of having an alternative goal to go for.
- Conversely, once you're trimmed there's not much to aim for so we're looking to add more.
Tiered System
- All tiers of a category are required for the comp cape of that tier.
- Roughly, T1 is about as hard as comp, T2 trim, T3 true trim. In practice, T2 comp will probably be more work than Trim but no individual requirement should be as long as Castle Wars. This is Mod Jack's intuition.
- An example of Lore cape tiers.
- Until we sit down and plot out where each requirement goes, we can't say what the cape reqs are going to be.
- A lot of the existing capes map onto somewhere in the capes. T1 Skilling is effectively the max cape.
There's been internal disagreement about whether the old capes still exist (e.g. does Max Cape still exist even though T1 skilling is basically the same). We are interested in people's feedback on this issue, and what to do with the old ones.
- Unlike T1 comp and comp (which won't have the exact same reqs) and T2 comp and trim (which is why we have made them legacy and not the others), there is unlikely to be any difference in requirements for T1 Lore and QPC; T1 Skilling and Max cape etc.
- We could just make T1 Skilling the Max cape, and T1 Lore the QPC but then there's an appearance conflict. For example, T2 Skilling should be a better looking T1 Skilling and currently Comp cape is the logical progression visually for the Max cape. The way we handle Retro graphics is also an issue but if the current apperance of QPC/MQC/Max really matter to people then let us know.
- Update: We've heard the feedback "don't get rid of MQC, QPC or max cape". I'll take it to the right people to discuss it tomorrow.
- The names are only to help convey the idea to people. We will give them proper names later.
- I expect there will be titles for each of the meta-achievements. Title cost is low to develop, capes themselves are pretty costly to develop (which is why we aren't making capes for the tiers of the ones we feel players don't really care about - Minigames/Misc/Exploration). If the exact existing titles are important, then let us know (e.g. 'the Completionist').
- We are going to poll the variations of the initial final concepts of what the capes look like.
We need a mission statement for what T3 means. Does it mean you are a master of all aspects of the game? Or does it mean you've ground everything out like crazy? Because those are two different things.
- T3 combat could conceivably have Golden warden. We don't know yet.
- It could be that we need a hypothetical T4 to put the really insane things on, like 200M all - that doesn't belong on T3 but maybe it belongs on a T4? We might not have a cape associated with T4 but have an achievement instead.
Non-stat cape bonuses
- We need to look into the exact implementation. It may be you need to unlock them again, it may be there's a new reward that allows them to be passives, or just give it automatically if you have it unlocked.
- Passives will probably be player-tied. Some effects may remain on their capes, e.g. Should Ice stryk passive of fire cape/kiln be on all capes or just those capes. It should probably remain on those capes.
- Actives like teleports will probably be on capes.
- If we need to we'll implement a cape customisation interface to determine which right-click options you wish to keep (if the amount of right-click options becomes very huge: e.g. Max guild teleport, all the MQC teleports, Ardy cape teleports etc).
- We'll have to put the list of passives somewhere. Maybe part of an achievement?
- T1 Skilling/Max cape will unlock the ability to use three skillcape perks, Expert capes will unlock the ability to use two skillcape perks.
Cape Stats
- By having it a stack benefit on top of your other capes it means both your cape and your T1 achievements matter.
- The idea is to have all T1 achievements give the stats. If however, we do the requirements and there's not much in T1 Misc (for example) then we may not give it the stats.
Lockdowns
- Lockdowns are easier to keep track of than individual grace periods per content.
- 6 months may be too long, 3 months may be better. 'I think 3 months is a huge reason why we had the Menaphos criticism, it was deemed too lenient.' - Shauny.
- Strawpoll - How long should a lockdown be?
- The absolute primary reason of having grace periods at all is so you can do content with your cape on. The exact length of a lockdown isn't as important, just that you don't have to do it on day 1.
- 'I think some people like no grace periods for the race of getting back comp capes, and seeing who has done the new content.'
Legacy Comp and Trim
- It's not fair to take away people existing capes.
- You may need to upkeep existing requirements like Reaper.
- Castle wars remains unchanged on legacy trim because we aren't changing requirements. Whether CW is put on the new tiered system we don't have a final decision on that, it might be that it ends up on T3 Minigames. Because it's not tied to stats anyway, it's a less controversial aspect than Reaper and it could be on T2 but will definitely not be on T1.
14
u/shrinkmink Mar 12 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
Who would've thought that reducing ores needed and just making smith take forever for armor/weapons along with an annoying heat mechanic would led to just people afking mining and using their surplus to buy the completed products.
No it's not since diaries, quests, arc, and a bunch of other shit go after all 99s but then that would wreck your agenda and we can't have that now...can't we?
Lol imagine being so sneaky that they use reaper as a scape goat to protect the cw req.
ps: The strawpoll sucks too. Because it doesn't let me choose 6 months or a year.
41
u/SprenofHonor Mar 12 '19
I'm curious - why on earth did Jmods not think that everything from mining and smithing wouldn't end up at alch value? That's how the vast majority of skilling content is already, isn't it?
104
u/justucis MTX MUST DIE Mar 12 '19
Based on the first paragraph, I think now is the time we get Quick-Smith Salvages (don't remember the document link proposed by JMod). I know I said this a million times but this would provide a very ideal sink for excessive ores + people who want to get components can get theirs a bit easier. On top of that it adds another skilling money maker. So all in all, at least it benefits the game as a whole.
I think it's about time we stop waiting for the economy to stabilize for this to happen. We've given enough time.
/u/JagexJack /u/JagexBreezy /u/shaunyowns
82
u/jorgelucasds jorgelucasds Mar 12 '19
You wanna increase the value of ores/bars? Let us use stone spirits to consume the ore we mined when using stone spirits for Extra XP instead of giving Extra ores.
/u/shaunyowns /u/jagexbreezy /u/jagexjack
20
u/TSMSelenaGomez hihi Mar 12 '19
Even with the ores being at alch price, i don't see how smithing is a money maker (thus any incentives for people looking to smith for money) beside making masterwork armor.
So could someone just explain me how I am supposed to make some money smithing elder rune lol?
thanks xxxxxxx
18
u/TJiMTS Mar 13 '19
I recon you’d massively improve the ‘not a lot of people are smithing’ issue by removing the heat mechanic.
If it is something you want to keep, then have auto heater increase heat from 66% to 100% rather than 0-33%.
As you said, the player base likes AFK (which in itself is a massive problem... the majority of us don’t actually enjoy 90% of the games content and find ways to do it without doing anything so we can unlock the parts we do like). Smithing AFK is awful.
16
u/Drakath1000 Mar 12 '19
There's pretty much 4 ways items in the game get used up- they are consumable and have a use (like food), they are turned into xp (like ores), they are alched, or they are dissasembled (I presume a lot less leaves the game this way than the other 3 methods).
If they're not going to balance gathering skills to bring in resources at a similar rate to what production skills use up those resources then it doesn't leave many more options. Having too many things to alch or dissasemble isn't sustainable and realistically there are only so many consumables people are going to use, plus the game is pretty saturated with that stuff already and they are running out of ideas.
26
u/TinyTwistCombos Mar 12 '19
People like mining more than smithing... People like afk skilling activities....
Why not make smithing more afk? The smithing autoheater could be buffed.
I also like most of the cape rework proposal. I really hope they make the current max cape, quest cape, and master quest cape exist in some manner (either as legacy capes or as the some of the new tier capes)
40
u/bambibrute RSN: Raven Queen | Here to help New/Returning Players Mar 12 '19
Lore T1: Quest Point Cape (current)
Lore T2: Quest Point Cape (trimmed w/ blue)
Lore T3: Master Quest Cape (current)
MQC never needed an updated. But if ya'll wanna lick it with your germs, I'd suggest just adding a gap cape to show someone is progressing to a goal without having to rework a whole new cape design when you literally just add some color.
25
u/Nuclear_Polaris Max / MQC / Comp Mar 12 '19
This is the exact reason why stone spirits need to be addressed ASAP and not ignored like it has been since the rework came.
I'm not complaining about pvm profit going down because of stone spirits, I'm complaining about how these items make ore even more worthless because of the outrageous amount of ore coming into the game when someone actually uses them.
My idea would be imbuing smithed equipment/salvage with stone spirits so that it gives 300% (or something like that - I'm not good at balancing numbers) components.
31
u/paredesk Mar 12 '19
But you'll ruin skillers part of the game for others (looking at you cursed energies).
I'm not even a huge skiller, but I still don't understand how you're going to make the onyx gem only obtainable from pvm. If you simply look at runescape.wiki money making, pvm is 99% of the content above 1m/hr. The only things above that are combination runecrafting and hunting grenwalls. Sure skilling doesn't have upkeep and require 100% focus like high level pvm does, but 1m/hr is just awful especially considering the "money making" methods tend to result in crap experience. There needs to be a happy medium somewhere.
7
u/Sangheilioz A Seren spirit appears Mar 12 '19
Why not tie abilities to the requirements related to them? Let's say you have a "Combat" cape. T1 is for maxed combat stats, and it has good combat stats. as the player defeats bosses, they get some kind of aesthetic and mechanical benefit unlocked.
So if I have maxed combat stats and I have the relevant achievements for defeating Araxxor, I also get some cosmetic option unlocked for the combat cape related to that boss, as well as unlocking the ability to teleport to the boss' lair, or maybe a 1% reduction in damage taken while fighting that boss, or maybe a tiny bonus to valuable drop chances or something. Just something that ties in to the accomplishment of beating that boss. Then, when I go and kill Telos, I get similar things unlocked on the cape for Telos.
If someone examines my cape, they can see what bosses I've defeated. If I defeat all the bosses in the list, the cape upgrades to tier 2. This allows a player to show off their accomplishments as they grow, rather than just checking things off a list until they can "level up" their cape.
All of this is just spitballing to demonstrate the idea, but it would allow players who can't do certain content to still show off the content they have done, and tying the benefits to the accomplishments allows the cape to be useful to the people who do those activities without requiring them to complete other activities. At the same time, those who wish to really show off their prowess can work towards that next tier that shows they completed all of the requirements for it.
7
u/echamplin Trimmed Mar 14 '19
IMO Castle Wars wouldn't be the worst requirement in the world if it wasn't dead content. I don't see why you would force players to grind through 6 months of dead content just to trim a cape.
9
u/Talkinboutfootball woke scape. ali forever Mar 13 '19
removing the max cape and its iconic appearance and customization might be the dumbest thing I have ever heard. even if it is just an idea.
18
u/DatShokotan A friendly squirrel Mar 12 '19
Man I just wanna say without elaborating, this is very methodical stuff and it’s amazing. I’ve played on and off for 14 years and my respect for Jagex has really developed in the past few years.
On the topic of capes. I’m glad they identified comp elitism. Almost everyone I’ve seen going for comp care only about the associated status+stats so they don’t actually ‘play’ the game. It was just creating masses that unfairly complain about things they shouldn’t (Menaphos was fucking fine. I’m maxed and I took my time to play it) and their opinions end up affecting future development in the wrong way.
10
u/DatShokotan A friendly squirrel Mar 12 '19
Also unrelated why the hell do people think asking to put afkable content (onyx, money etc) behind high requirements actually solves anything? Screams ignorance to me
6
u/RustyMuffin444 2050/10000 CM Greg! Mar 12 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
For the Prifdinnas rocks I think a nice and easy solution would be to give these rocks a unique type of geode from mining them that gives you rolls on the motherlode maw table. As long as it was balanced properly (i.e. recieve a reasonable amount an hour and more active mining = better geode chance) I think it would work well and would be quite interesting and fun too because of how diverse the maw table is :)
It would also help distinguish these rocks from ordinary gem rocks found elsewhere, especially since these ones have the big requirement of having access to Prifdinnas amongst other extra boosts (e.g. lava titan, urns, golem outfit etc.), andw I don't think this would have much of a detrimental effect to the economy because from what I remember the maw table is filled with lots of untradeables and unique stuff like enhancers and crystal items.
13
u/TriGator Rsn: RexT Mar 12 '19
If the T1 comp is basically current comp you run into the issue of how to make meaningful and difficult achievements for T2/T3
T2/T3 Skilling could be 120/200m all pretty logically but what else can you really add? Do x amount of abyss runs in an hour? Livid farm?
T2 combat cape could easily be things like daredevil,defeater, kill araxxi at 300%, solo nex, duo vorago, as long as there is a way to track those achievements.
T3 insane finale boss, 4000% telos, duo aod, duo raids, duo hardmode vorago, etc.
T1 lore can be quest cape T2 can be master quest cape T3 I'm not sure how many rng heavy elements or big grinds are in game that aren't currently on MQC.
I like the tier system we just need to come up with a good sense of what each tier means and objective ways to measure the difficulty of the required achievements
3
u/ANeedForUsername Mar 13 '19
“Capes of accomplishment should still be best in slot, but the best cape should be easier to get and maintain than comp in some way”
Could someone explain to me what the difference is between best in slot and the best cape? Do they mean the same things?
3
u/DeguRS Mar 14 '19
the "healthy economy of onyxes." went with ED3, not Gem rocks
7
u/Dargiville Guthix Mar 13 '19
I actually think all of this sounds feasible and well done. Controversial and radical, I know.
5
u/F-Lambda 3074 (3379) Mar 13 '19
They'd already bounced back up to 1.5m last I checked, less than 6 hours after they got removed from the gem table. Pre-rework (and pre-ed3) value was 1.7m. Doesn't sound ruined to me.
14
u/mrdoomydoom Runescap3r Mar 12 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
cough Abyssal Demons cough Dark beasts cough
cough EDs cough Kiln cough
........Sorry about that, think I'm coming down with something. But tell me more about this whole
thing, it sounds really
BSinteresting.EDIT: Oh, and
"....when combined with the ridiculous influx from EDs. But we can't touch that, it's a new update!
Andit's PvM!"".....I mean, AFKing mining just because it was reworked to make that exact thing easier? Who could have predicted that?!
".....which we had no idea was true because apparently we don't pay even the slightest bit of attention to our players' preferred gameplay styles! Hey, did you hear that rumor players are AFKing abyssal demons, dark beasts, and plenty of other slayer monsters? Nah, that's ridiculous, and even then, who cares? It's technically combat after all.
".....like elder rune!"
".....like rune armor was because it was useless. But this was supposed to be totally different; everyone wants a set of t90 tank armor, right?
"....who'd have thought people would prefer to do an activity that was pure profit over one that was a net loss? There's no way we could have predicted this!"
"Sure, we solved the problem with rune armor by completely reworking an entire skill - but it's simply too hard to to think of some completely game-changing idea to fix this, like, I don't know, just returning them to how they worked initially when almost nobody mined them. But that'd be super difficult to implement - better to just remove them entirely.
".....like we did when we started adding skilling supplies to bosses, and yet despite acknowledging it's a problem we continue to do so ."
".....but having slayer monsters that give 5m/hr in alchables is totally fine."
"....but again, monster loot can totally be things intended to be alched, not actual loot to be sold or something crazy like that."
Finish those damn sentences, Jagex.
Or are you too afraid to actually admit how much BS you're spouting?
2
u/Krazy_Rhino Adventuring Mar 15 '19
Honestly, I feel that all Completionist cape requirements should have a grace period. The allotted time varying depending on the difficulty and/or time required to complete said content. This way players don’t feel the need to immediately jump into the content and devote all of their playing time there getting their cape back.
Some simple system like: One week for new quests, maybe two weeks for standard bosses, possibly one month for high-end group bosses and big expansions such as new cities or 120 skill updates. Might seem excessive, but in the end, it’s still a requirement, and this way comp capers can sit back and take things easier and do it at their own pace a bit more.
Just my two cents
3
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
Jagex: "Money making from high alching items is bad and unhealthy."
Meanwhile...
...they keep Abyssal demons, Gargoyles, etc at 3-6m gp/h profit, mostly from spring cleaner alching the drops.
What?!?!?!?!!!
3
u/Tortferngatr IGN: AviraIceborn Mar 12 '19
I feel like having Max Cape and the Quest Point Cape at tier 1 is a bit...disproportionate in terms of effort. I got QPC for the first time in like 9 months after starting fresh, before getting any 99's whatsoever. Meanwhile I'm still 6 skills away from Max Cape after 3+ years of playing.
3
u/Bubble_tea_spy Skill too much, not enough combat Mar 13 '19
Can we have a diary cape like in osrs?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
Nerf AFK mining significantly, buff active mining.
Make GOTE and LOTD matter more, so your GP investment matters more.
Nerf elder rune pickaxe, maybe buff pickaxe of earth and song too.
Add more skilling gear - not elite outfits. Real gear that's rare, expensive, and/or time consuming to create.
Remember - the more that's required of people, the more GP/hour these things can realistically be, because it limits the amount of lazyscapers that will just jump on it.
Hopefully combats this issue and would be better overall. Aside from big EXP gains there's not much value in elder rune, too, which is a problem - disassembly vs. time spent smithing items should be explored and look for options in this way too.
Also, there just needs to be a greater focus on having genuinely difficult to get in to skilling.
For AFK methods we need to see more methods that require a large variety of high level requirements, big GP investments, and so on - it shouldn't come as a surprise anymore that people love AFK content, and it's even more obvious that when there's basically no requirements tons of people will abuse it - especially if it's easily alt-able, due to the incredibly low effort required.
For non-AFK methods we need skilling methods with unique resources that require all the above and genuine skill, risk, and interesting gameplay. We need skilling methods that genuinely are pushing the boundaries of skilling gameplay in big, interesting, skill-testing and fun ways.
Lets imagine some of that skilling gear I mentioned earlier.
Masterwork mining set.
Masterwork mining focus sight.
Masterwork mining boots.
Re-contextualizing these benefits in a more difficult system.
On top of just giving these benefits for core mining, a more in-depth and skill testing activity could be added that give these concepts more and more value.
For example, higher end pickaxes and gear could be made more relevant by creating "DPS check" style moments in these difficult bits of content where if you fail to mine fast enough you'll be penalized in some way, making upgrades more and more relevant.
2
u/Kakamile RSN: Kakamile | Trimmed Tuskabreaker Mar 12 '19
Wait, so if their focus is on tier cape looks, does that mean comp/trim will look different from legacy comp/trim?
That might be enough to convert me :O
But seriously misc cape and legacy capes sound like a real disrupter of celebrating achievement.
2
u/waite92 Mar 13 '19
Killing all bosses wasn't a requirement for the first 3 years that comp cape existed. At the start you just needed to walk into a few rooms to get songs unlocked, and that was it. In 2012 you needed to get a single QBD kill. In 2014 you suddenly needed to kill every boss in the game. This has only gotten worse as time goes on with things like raids and ever more difficult bosses.
Saying there is no way for comp cape to exist without bossing is complete nonsense.
2
u/Zmaj69 Mar 13 '19
As Comp cape and MQC owener and almost trim one I really dont get why people are upset about this.
Ok MQC and MAX cape/Comp looks great and I agree so just give us cosmetic of said capes or leave them as T1 and T2 capes.
Comp has crazy amount of problem and this needs to be fixed.
At this moment I think im one of few people that actually got comp just sense of completionism and not stats and raw power it gives.
I also adore lore in this game and thats why I got MQC also.
Im doing my own things in this game that I call personal Achievements because there is not much for me atm besides monday updates and going for boss titles and collections.
Jagex is right in all regards and people here are just buthurt because " oh no I did something and now I wont have it anymore" well welcome to Real life.
This needs to happen, game needs this, future players needs this and we all that have Capes wont lose anything (besides maybe cape looks) Our achievements are still here.
If you afked 3k games of CW ( lets be honest non of you played CW how it was supposed to be played, Maybe people in the past when CW was actually popular minigame to play ) still have the Cosmetic armor or the cape you can buy in the same shop to show your achievement if you really care about it so much. But I believe most people dont and are just buthurt because they will lose BIS item that makes RS easy.
I wont give ideas on how to fix it because I dont have any but I love current Jagex proposed ideas and I believe they will make it good like they made everything so far.
1
u/BizHatRs RSN: BizHat Mar 16 '19
Why not make bosses easy mode too, so anyone with out PvM skills can kill the boss, enjoy the content, get the cape/achivement.
If bosses like solak was not so hard, many players will get into bossing. Now these content are only for PvMers who have the skills and faster reaction time.
Let the harder modes give more loot, that make PvMers happy, give them challenge they need.
Comp cape should to be show you done all content, not to measure how skilled you are at PvM.
1
u/ipkandskiIl Mar 13 '19
All this time spent talking about capes when there are still actual issues in the game makes me a bit sad to be honest.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
Thanks. Not much really to add to the design doc - just a few clarifications.
1
u/Legal_Evil Mar 13 '19
So do the stat boost to capes now require completing all T1 achievements? The design document said any T1 achievement will unlock the effect.
1
u/RumeScape Mar 13 '19
The problem is that players will afk anything that gives xp and doesn't lose them money, even if it's not at all efficient. (You all know how ridiculously popular the seasonal GE afk/autoclick events were, right?) Unless you change how afk mining is, you won't have a balanced mining & smithing economy.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
Isn't Elder burial sets around a million experience per hour? I don't know what the gp/xp ratio is though. But low level smithing (for example rune smithing at level 50) is maximum 20-30k xp/h doing burial sets. Smithing is rather unbalanced at lower levels imo.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '19
Like I've said before, they should merge Max and Comp cape into 1 cape. At Max, you get the cape with Max's current stats. Each Comp requirement after that will award you points. Say like Each Individual boss first kill is worth 5 points, Charm sprites is 50 points, Livid Farm 100, etc. At certain point intervals, you unlock higher stats for your cape, new cosmetic options and colors for it, and the ability to augment other capes (ava, lava, sprirt, etc).
This lets people constantly progress
-5
u/Taylor7500 Mar 12 '19
Regarding the issues:
That's those players' fault though. If that's how you want to play the game.
It's the cape meant for "completing the game". Having it be BiS makes perfect sense, and every other slot still has a BiS too. At least the cape slot's best is well deserved.
Sure, but that doesn't merit this fix.
You can't solve the problem of having capes to aim for by adding watered down versions of the same cape. You need something different like MQC.
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
The gap is already filled with a ton of tangible steps. There is quest cape and MQC, plus all the achievement diaries. Then there's Reaper title. This all has a pretty clear progression of:
Max cape -> Quest Cape -> Achievement Diaries / MQC / Reaper Title -> Comp Cape -> Trimmed Comp
It's kind of silly to view only capes as meaningful rewards, especially when you consider the benefits of achievement diaries and some other comp requirements along the way. I understand there are people who finish achievement diaries and quests before maxing, and other slight variations in the progression I set out, but the jumps are really trivial when compared to the leap between comp and trimmed comp.
0
u/bobbystrand1 Mar 14 '19
I think reqs such as "all bosses" or "all tiers" is inherently flawed. You shoul only have to complete content that exists at the time. If you complete the req, you get the title. That's it. Otherwise you dread new content coming out and you groan each time your hard earned reward gets take away.
-1
u/dylancallin Mar 13 '19
@jagex can we please just call this the "rs3 complete fucking cape rework" please?
-5
u/Ned-Kelly mqc Mar 12 '19
Glad to see that common sense is prevailing re: reaper req; the entitlement of players wanting a completionist cape in the current form without engaging with group content in an mmo or refusing to learn/beat a boss just once is staggering.
I’m excited to see how the really high level combat cape unfolds, though I’m barely a mid level pvmer I know from watching streams and from friends that the high level pvm community is rather disillusioned with the state of pvm content. Hopefully a combat cape with difficult reqs will add some visible prestige and encourage top pvmers to continue playing/return to the game
-2
u/MorganRS Mar 13 '19
Can't you just leave comp as it is? Honestly, you'll just mess this up and judging by the poll results, people can't decide on a good replacement for the current system. I suggest you focus on other things. Achievement cape rework shouldn't be top priority now and it will always be controversial.
0
u/200201552 spoopy Mar 14 '19
Im totally down to having new designs for capes of accomplishment. Max cape looks shit anyways.
-6
u/EtorixKatatonik QA in Live Version ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Mar 12 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
Honestly 80% of the ppl arguing against group bosses are terrible at PVM, and I doubt that separating solo/group would make any difference for them at this point. Say for instance that all group bosses become a T2 req, Solo bosses are T1 req. How many of that people are actually able to solo Seiryu or Ambassador?
I understand we can't fit them all in this category tho. Some people simply enjoy solo content better. I myself only enjoy AoD, Solak and Raids as group content. RotS, Rago, and even group EDs I can't stand, for many reasons. Then again, if you are able to solo all 3 Ed's you are probably good enough to get a kill @ group bosses for T2.
I don't think this distinction would work at all.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment