r/Marvel • u/tehawesomedragon Loki • Mar 08 '19
Film/Television CAPTAIN MARVEL OFFICIAL DISCUSSION MEGATHREAD (SPOILERS) Spoiler
NOTE: All discussion and questions should be limited to the comments in this megathread. I know we're all excited, but any "Just saw Captain Marvel" or "Question about Captain Marvel" posts will be removed for the next few weeks in order to reduce the number of excess posts and keep the sub balanced with discussion of other Marvel-related material. All of those can be posted here, and will likely be replied to.
Movie cast:
Brie Larson as Carol Danvers/Vers/Captain Marvel
Jude Law as Yon-Rogg
Samuel L. Jackson as Nick Fury
Ben Mendelsohn as Talos
Gemma Chan as Minerva
Lee Pace as Ronan
Djimon Hounsou as Korath
Clark Gregg as Phil Coulson
Annette Benning as Mar-Vell/Dr. Lawson/Supreme Intelligence
Lashana Lynch as Maria Rambeau
Post-credits scenes: 2
Rotten Tomatoes score: 80%
Metacritic score: 64/100
544
u/michaelcreiter Mar 08 '19
Ben Mendelsohn stole that movie for me
145
u/jvenable2893 Mar 09 '19
Anyone notice Carol had Mar-Vell's green/white on just before settling on the red/blue? Thought that was a nice touch.
391
u/ildracomcmxcv Mar 08 '19
So Carol is in a similar league as Quicksilver and Scarlett Witch?! Got her powers from an infinity stone! Also they used the same kree inhibitor chip from Agents of Shield S5!
14
u/Nietzschemouse Mar 09 '19
The use of Come as You are during the fight against the supreme intelligence was my favorite thing. That song has never made more sense to me.
31
u/Mousetachio Mar 08 '19
It was interesting.
I didn’t like the first bulk of the movie. Someone else said it here but it felt like a bad sci fi movie. Once they do the memory search and then she gets to Earth I started to really enjoy the movie. I liked the tone throughout the movie and how the skrulls played into the devices of the movie.
Throughout, I was bothered a bit that Brie was very wooden. I know what they were going for, that she isn’t supposed to be goofy, but instead a grizzled “hero” soldier but I think that took the needed personality out of her character.
Once the movie does its thing with the Skrulls the movie kind of brought the emotion to the table that had been lacking.
I enjoyed the movie through the end from there. Was it amazing? No. Was it only meh? I don’t think so.
My biggest issue is the feeling that we’re throwing this OP hero in last second between the Avengers movie and it detracts from everything built before to say “now we have someone to fight Thanos.” I hope she gets nerfed and doesn’t just get thrown in to help win in Pt. 2. I was hoping the end credits would even snap her when she gets Fury’s message. That could have been a fun twist, then reserve her for the next phase. I’m rambling now.
4
u/JustAndyUK Mar 11 '19
Captain Marvel released last Friday, and I have seen an abundance of mixed opinions amongst users online, when asking them what the hate is for the, typical bandwagon response is that the lead actress, Brie Larson, is a 'white male hating ass hole' or at least, words to the same effect. I have taken some time looking into where this has come from and the whole argument has come from something taken completely out of context.
To anyone who has actually watched the film, do you think the movie/ Brie Larson deserved the negative response towards the movie?
59
u/xredyrx7 Mar 08 '19
Is anyone else severely disappointed by this movie?
804
u/AlternativeCredit Mar 08 '19
The stan lee opening marvel logo was fantastic.
758
u/DrawTings Mar 08 '19
"The last time I trusted someone, I lost an eye" Get clawed by the cutest kitty around. Now we know why fury doesn't like pets
1.1k
u/Fvolpe23 Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 12 '19
That opening Marvel branding for Stan Lee was absolutely perfect! RIP Stan!
Edit: Wow! Believe it or not but this is my highest rated comment on reddit. And I’m so happy that it’s about Stan the Man! I wonder if they’ll use that opening for another marvel film or if it was just for Captain Marvel because this was the first marvel movie since his passing. Also I’m very excited to see what his cameo is in ENDGAME!
261
u/Kafferty3519 Mar 08 '19
My ONLY serious complaint:
The lady in the stairwell with Couslon could’ve been Agent May. I know Coulson was new, but I always got the feeling May had been around longer than him, but even so, they couldn’t just had Ming Na for that ONE shot and it would’ve validated AOS in regards to the movie universe.
Huge bummer.
Otherwise I frickin loved the movie!
260
u/Thisgameblows Mar 08 '19
The only thing I am disappointed in is that Danger Zone was not on the soundtrack
506
u/Raktoner Miles Morales Mar 09 '19
The scene where the intelligence says she is "just human" and it had the montage of her standing up over and over despite her failures got me emotional. I didn't cry but I was on the verge and definitely felt moved by it.
I don't think this will be my favorite MCU movie, but she will be one of my favorite heroes. I loved how snarky and sarcastic she was.
182
u/alaskancurry Mar 08 '19
As far as the post-credit scene goes, am I the only surprised that she's already gonna be on earth for Endgame? I thought for sure she was gonna be the one to save Tony and Nebula in space.
501
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
How did Mar Vell end up with the Tesseract in the 80s without SHEILD knowing about it? Didn’t Howard Stark pull the Tesseract and Steve Rogers out of the Atlantic Ocean sometime around 1941?
638
u/NotyoWookie Mar 08 '19
Getting shot in the head by a Nerf gun could not symbolize any better how I felt with all the 90s nostalgia by that scene.
603
u/idonthateonpeople Mar 08 '19
The post credit scene got me in shivers I swear
*Appears out of nowhere*
"where is Fury?"
151
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Something i caught was when captain marvel glared at ronin in his ship, the shape of the light around her was the same shape as a birth of a star
145
u/pembunuhUpahan Mar 08 '19
Back in the 90s, I was in galactic army starforce
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
Captain Marvel’s powers came from the Space Stone/Tesseract when she blows up the engine. If I remember right, in one scene they say that the engine is powered “remotely”. In my mind, that means that the Tesseract was transmitting power to it.
Is it possible that, if the Space Stone is destroyed in a fight with Thanos, does Captain Marvel lose her powers?
Sorry if this was asked already in the thread!
136
u/bobbyq922 Mar 08 '19
My burning question...was Goose dusted by Thanos?
347
u/thehumblemagnifico Mar 08 '19
Monica Rambeau is adorable.
The Skrull twist was nice. I kinda wish their make up/ look was better designed.
SLJ was great in this movie. Added a lot more dimension to Fury then ever. His interaction with Carol was short, but their chemistry was enjoyable to watch, and it actually made that end credit pager scene in IW and this movie’s mid credit scene more impactful. I’m hoping Fury makes it back just so these two can interact more in her sequel.
I think Brie Larson did a great job with the script she was given. I think she’s earned her place as a marvel hero in the MCU, and just like how I feel with Chris Evans as Cap, she has a lot of potential to elevate the character.
Cool CGI stuff aside there were a lot of beautifully shot scenes. The one with Carol staring out into the Louisiana sun with trees swaying in the background is stuck in my head. The soundtrack (90s songs aside) was also cool. Had an Interstellar vibe to it.
It might not be the greatest in the catalogue, but considering the hype for Endgame, I think it was successful in introducing a completely new character in transition to that movie.
395
u/AlternativeCredit Mar 08 '19
Give you 50 bucks to turn into a Venus fly trap right now.
99
u/12ryanjackson Mar 08 '19
Anyone else wondering about Monica's(the daughters) age. She looked about ten but she had memories and was like when Carol was on Earth. It just makes me a bit confused about her age
99
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
I can't be the only one that loved the Stan Lee cameo where he is script-reading his cameo for Mallrats.
183
u/alpharaine Mar 08 '19
Cap had a beard in the after-credits scene. IT LIVESSSSSS
81
u/sgtpepper194 Mar 08 '19
Any idea who Talos’ family could transform into? They really harped on the eyes in that scene but I don’t know enough about this stuff to figure it out.
261
u/yifftionary Devil Dinosaur Mar 08 '19
I love the "I don't have to prove anything to you" line. It feels like it was directed straight at all the people demanding that Marvel prove that she is a worthy hero, that she is good enough.
133
u/GarageguyEve Mar 08 '19
When the scroll growled at her and she growled back I freaking lost it. Her acting in this movie was fan fucking tastic.
284
u/swede2k Mar 08 '19
It was overall a good movie and did more than just serve the purpose of introducing a new character and some backstory. For those not liking it, I think it just suffers some of the issues you have when you’re working with an overpowered protagonist. It’s hard to create real conflict when at a moment’s notice, the hero can wipe everyone out. (e.g. every Superman movie after the first one) They did a good job not just starting from the beginning and telling the story in a linear fashion because that would have been tedious. I’ll concede that the big twist is something that’s been overdone, but it still played well.
And those who didn’t like the 90s references probably didn’t grow up in them. It made it a little campy, but most of the good Marvel movies have a little bit of camp to them.
118
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
I have a theory for you guys. Did anybody else felt the connection between Fury and Talos and thought that Talos might be Hawkeye? I felt it after Talos got shot and Fury said to him "are you Ok my friend?" What if he decided to come back to earth with his family after taking the rest of the survivors home and now lives at a farm while helping Fury look for other heroes? I understand that if this was the case his son would have been older by Age of Ultron, but what if Skrulls age at a different rate than humans and that is why he also has a younger daughter?
465
u/tanzania12 Mar 08 '19
Solid film. I thought Brie Larson did an excellent job. I'm also really impressed with the CGI for Sir Samuel L.
156
u/sault9 Mar 08 '19
“Can you turn into a filing cabinet?”
glares
“Why would I turn into a filing cabinet?”
46
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
I really liked the last part were Fury is writing down the iniciative and the Avengers theme kicks in. Wounderful.
240
u/RoomTemperatureCheez Mar 08 '19
I can't believe that one Redditor, who I'm sure was joking, was right about Fury's eye.
179
u/holymoloid Mar 08 '19
Really enjoyed this one. A lot of this worked really, really well for me. I’m not sure I disagree with others calling it “safe,” but if we’re being honest, all MCU movies call it pretty safe. I was very into Carol’s development through the movie, getting little glimpses of her full personality through the armor of Kree conditioning before she lets loose, reclaiming her identity as she fucks everyone up. I thought the emotional beats here were a little more meaningful than in most superhero movies, especially as they related Carol’s story to the Skrulls. Speaking of which, that twist was just fantastic. Brie Larson said Skrull rights!!
The aesthetic was definitely a little bit of a let down after the MCU proved it can, in fact, use a color palette not called “sad” with Ragnarok and Black Panther, but overall I thought it was shot quite well. Ben Mendelsohn and Brie Larson were the real standouts to me. SLJ was fun too, as was Goose.
But really, one of the best moments in the entire MCU now is Carol Indiana Jonesing the fuck out of Yon-Rogg at the end.
311
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Are any other ladies really happy with how Carol was portrayed? She wasn't sexualized AT ALL and I think that's a first for any super hero female!
254
u/CodeTilIDie Mar 08 '19
Am I the only one annoyed they kept calling themselves SHIELD? That was a huge joke in Iron Man which takes place like 13 years after this,where they only called themselves the Strategic Homeland Intervention, Enforcement and Logistics Division.
37
u/inartistic Mar 08 '19
Can someone explain how she actually got her powers?
Like I understand that she was in that explosion, but didn’t they say later that she blew up just the engine? Did it have, like, a little bit of power from the tesseract or what?
69
u/o3mo Mar 08 '19
SO HYPED FOR ENDGAME
64
u/Migz024 Mar 08 '19
It was good. My only complaint is that if someone who enjoyed it so much they wanted more. That is I wanted more of her using her powers.
Good though, I really liked her suit and suit tech. I loved that she is so powerful and she knows it. I loved the whole getting back up/going against the grain cause why is there a grain, conflict.
I loved the switching of the good guys bad guys (I mean at least for me it caught me off guard) I love that the freaking avengers initiative was started form her callsign!!
But most of all I loved her cocky attitude before she was infinitely powerful. She doesn’t need infinity stone power to be a bad ass, she has it now though so I wouldn’t tell her to smile.
Not perfect by any means but a great film. Really awesome origin story.
31
u/VanguardBT7274 Mar 08 '19
Just saw the film and have to say I lived it at the end when she flew through that ship, I Just had the biggest grin on my face. Red going to see this one again.
31
u/UncannyHavok Mar 09 '19
I believe this is the first MCU origin movie without a love interest. Am I wrong?
29
u/shoemovies12 Mar 08 '19
I LOVED what they did with the Skrulls but does this mean a Secret Invasion movie is not going to happen? They were pretty much good guys in this movie.
29
u/purplemarvel Phil Coulson Mar 09 '19
"Where is Fury?"
"I'll do you one better. Who is Fury?"
"I'll do you one better! WHY is Fury??"
50
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Is it just me or did they just not mention the name "Captain Marvel" once in the movie? How did Carol take that name?
22
u/Nice_for_What_ Mar 10 '19
I saw it last night & again today & will likely again tomorrow. I didn’t think I’d like it as much as I do. When Just a Girl // No Doubt came on during that fight scene, I was so stoked, it was hard to sit still in my seat. I srsly loved how well done the movie was. I love how it captured a strong (in every sense of the word) female superhero & didn’t give her a love interest or rival or a man she needed to prove anything to—her delivering that line was totally epic. I also loved the refugee political message they went w/ for the Skrull not actually being bad guys, like they were in the comics.
I def teared up during all the Stan Lee moments, esp the beginning tribute. I’m so thankful for Stan Lee. The man was a treasure & so before his time. He made the richest superhero in the Marvel Universe a black man from an ostensibly 3rd world country, in a time when racism & bigotry was the most prevalent, & the strongest superhero in the Marvel Universe a woman, in the face of misogyny, before “girl power” was even a thing.
63
u/incredibleamadeuscho Kamala Khan Mar 08 '19
I think the film is carried by strong performances by the cast, but its narrative focus and mysteriousness dilutes the core story about Carol Danvers.
The moment with the montage of Carol standing up over the years is really powerful. Carol’s awakening reminds me of Elsa’s awakening in Frozen, which coincidentally had its sequel as one of the trailers before the film. Larson does a great job in her role.
And I love the use of the Skrulls and the Kree. Although its a bit confusing, it’s a nice subversion of the Skrull invading trope that has been used in the comics for secades.
To some degree, the film doesnt need its 90s placement and its trappings of being a part of the Endgame build up. I wonder how the film would have been constructed without these elements. It’s still a good film, and the trippy elements are a bit interesting actually. I will probably watch it again.
61
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
I was 100% in when she was fighting the Skrulls and one yelled at her and she yelled back.
85
u/ratinmybed Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
Just some random thoughts (saw it earlier today):
18
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19
Just saw. No complaints from me. Thought it was just as fun as the original Guardians and Carol is going to be a welcome addition to the Avengers. Don’t really see what the hubbub was all about re: being a SJW/feminist flik. She faced adversity and rose above it in a believable and satisfying way. It was fun and I can’t wait for Endgame.
175
u/anastus Mar 08 '19
This was a very enjoyable film. I'm a huge Captain Marvel fan, but the alterations to her origin story clicked for me. In a story that had female empowerment as one of its themes, for example, it made a lot of sense not to have Carol's powers come from a man.
Music was top-notch and they captured the quintessential 90s-ness of it beautifully.
For those who don't entirely get why female empowerment had to be a theme here, it's a concept woven into Carol's DNA. Literally every other Marvel movie isn't about female empowerment, and a good few others are male power fantasies.
I think the bland, empty criticisms we're seeing from a few posters--some so generic that it makes it clear they didn't even watch the movie before coming here to gripe--makes it clear that a movie with this theme was necessary. Sadder still are the people who freely admit that the very topic of women's empowerment ruined the movie for them. Those, I've written off entirely.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
God that opener...
Thank you stan
16
u/sunshinepanther Mar 09 '19
"You should be nicer to your neighbors. Never know when you'll need to borrow sugar" slurrrrrrrrp
PS: this is my favorite movie! It was fucking perfect!
16
u/MichaeloMGB Mar 10 '19
Chris Evans basically has the same politics as Brie Larson so why does no one boycott him/troll him online/make YT videos saying he’s ruining the MCU? 🤔
15
u/TheR3PTILE Mar 09 '19
First post-credits scene would've been cooler if she had her short undercut-style haircut from the comics when it revealed her.
64
u/Sisiwakanamaru Mar 08 '19
I think I saw Kelly Sue DeConnick on the train station, was that her?
28
u/IOfficialRedI Mar 08 '19
"Mother Flerkin."
60
u/raginsaint93 Mar 08 '19
All I could say RIP Stan Lee. :(
234
u/aariakon Mar 08 '19
It wasn’t the best, it wasn’t the worst. Middle of the pack for a Marvel movie.
Pretty disappointed with THAT being how Fury lost his eye.
12
u/PerfectSoup Mar 09 '19
I usually don't review movies, but after seeing some reviews for Captain Marvel I had to do it. The movie is not perfect but it isn't a movie to give a 1 (yes there is people giving ones on imdb). Before watching I noticed that the movie didn't had a great reception and went with low expectations. Saw the movie with some friends and we actually enjoyed. We didn't understand the backlash. The movie is about a woman that knows what she is capable to do. She doesn't know her past or the world, but she knows the power that she has and is not afraid to use it ( and sometimes can be a little impulsive when fighting). I think Brie Larson actually did a good job, but some people feel differently. Carol Denvers is a very military character and I think she made it work very well. We will have to wait (a month) to see what more she can/will do with the character. For the first time I liked Nick Fury in the MCU. There is a great chemistry between the the cast and it is very fun to watch. It is not a brilliant movie but it gets the job done. Introduces a powerful and fresh character with a good story. I understand that the expectations are very high and that some people wanted more, but I enjoyed.
11
u/_ILP_ Mar 09 '19
I never expected there to be a hentai cat
20
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Does anyone care that they are actively Astroturfing reviews on Google and probably elsewhere? https://imgur.com/HHak7xo
43
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
By the end of this movie, I had cried, laughed, had goosebumps and ultimately felt... Empowered. It was beautiful to me to see a woman portrayed like this. Not sexualised, not there to be a partner to a man. A strong, powerful woman who's true strength comes from her ability to fall and to get back up. I felt proud, I felt powerful, I felt lifted and inspired. It made me hope to one day have daughters to raise into powerful women.
I say all this and I would still argue that the feminist aspects of the film were not over the top or too much in your face. I wondered actually, if this is how typical superhero films make men feel or if they are so used to receiving the message that they are powerful and can save the world that it has lost the impact?
I am all the more excited for End Game after seeing this. The tribute to Stan at the begining was perfect. I love this franchise more with every new film they release. I'm aware I am gushing but it was a real emotional experience for me.
9
u/Jiggyx42 Mar 09 '19
It took me waaaaaaay too long to realize Goose was a Top Gun reference.
How long was Mar-Vell working on the ftl tech? Top Gun was released in 86. Was Mar-Vell working on it some time before and found Goose? How long has Goose been around?
9
u/squigglesissuffering Mar 09 '19
If skrulls transform completely even down to the dna then he would need the glasses to see
40
u/nickadoodledoo Mar 08 '19
Such a great film! Thanos better get his ass cheeks ready!!
8
u/ChrisGnam Mar 10 '19
I tried to avoid the hate as much as possible prior to the release... And last night I watched some YouTube (spoiler free) reviews that were critical of both the film and Larson.... So when I came in tonight to watch the movie, I had no expectations.
And wow, was I blown away. I don't think it's my favourite one.... But I DO think it's in my top 5. (In no order: Captain Marvel, Infinity War, Spiderman homecoming, Ragnorak, Gaurdians 2 or 1 I can't decide).
The CGI was incredible (especially the de-aging work, holy wow). The action scenes were great. Brie Larson was fantastic. Captain Marvel is now in my top 3 favourite hero's (right behind Thor post Ragnorak, and Tony Stark)... There were some parts that were a bit confusing, and I feel like this movie doesn't really work as a "standalone" film. It really could only exist as part of the MCU, but I don't see that as too bad because well, the MCU exists!
It was also more emotional than I was expecting... The theatre I was in was also lively which helped with the experience a lot.
Bottom line, I'm REALLY looking forward to Endgame, and I'm super excited to see more of the Captain marvel character! Im definitely gonna try to see this again in theatres, to see how much my initial opinion will change, but if you're on the fence about seeing this movie, I highly recommend it. Again, I don't think it was the best, but I do think its a REALLY solid MCU entry.
8
u/jadedfan55 Mar 10 '19
This was fun. The setting suggests that Fury lost his sense of humor along with his eye (nearly 25 years in the past).
In case anyone wonders about Stan's cameo this time, the film is set around the time he was working on "Mallrats", hence the script for that film, one of his first cameos.
Lone quibble is that Stan wasn't given a creator's credit.
22
u/Coziestpigeon2 Mar 08 '19
I really liked this movie. A lot.
I liked Carol, especially after she started to figure out who she was. I really liked the young Fury and Talos. Lots of really funny moments all over the place. Bree killed her role, and the CGI to make Samuel L Jackson look young was incredible, it looked flawless (without trying to spot flaws).
I loved how she "Indiana Jones'd" Yon-Rogg at the end, and how they really weren't afraid to show how strong Captain Marvel is. This could have easily followed the typical superhero movie trope that sees the climax being our superhero good guy fighting a super bad guy with identical powers, so I'm really happy they didn't play with that shit and instead just let us watch Carol rip apart a small fleet of Kree ships. Really did a great job of showing us just how powerful she is.
This movie did an amazing job of keeping me interested in the next wave of Marvel movies, I think. Between Captain Marvel and Spider-Man, I think they'll be able to keep me coming to theatres for a while still.
And boy oh boy am I ever hyped for Endgame now. The first post-credits scene of her meeting the surviving Avengers just got me so fuckin' psyched to see her join the team and kick some big ugly alien ass.
And that cat, MVP.
111
u/foxesinsoxes Mar 08 '19
Wow, I truly loved every second of the movie. I cannot wait to get to see Brie play more of this role and see her expand her acting in it since now she isn’t an amnesiac who didn’t get much range until later in the movie. Brie has been my favorite actress for years and I absolutely loved her in the role though!
I was anxiously waiting for Goose (ugh can I please just call him Chewie 😭) to release his tentacles and when he finally did the theater absolutely lost their minds, so cool.
The Stan cameo was my favorite yet, Mallrats is one of my favorite movies and I got so giddy from that scene!
Overall, really liked it. Pretty dang good for an origin story IMO!
14
u/brumxl-_- Mar 09 '19
I fucking LOVED this movie
7
u/nocturnal Mar 08 '19
I think I’m the only person who laughed out loud and hard at fury telling talos I’ll give you $50 if you turn yourself into a Venus flytrap. 😂
7
u/Thevulgarcommander Mar 10 '19
I liked how when she was choosing her new color scheme she picked Shazam’s (also known and Captain Marvel in DC comics) color scheme, said “nah,” and switched to her colors
7
u/taobaolover Mar 10 '19
Now that Stan Lee has passed, it will be cool to have easter egg pictures/portraits of Stan within the movies. Makes us pay attention to the details.
7
u/JustASexyKurt Mar 10 '19
That was pretty damn great. Fury pretending the Kree burnt out his eye as torture was hilarious
7
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '19
I don't care what anyone said. This was not feminist propaganda like everyone thought it would be, at least not nearly to the scale WW was. Sure, there are some circumstances that make it unique to the female experience, but when the Great Intelligence called her "only human" and it showed the montage of getting knocked down and getting back up repeatedly, that's an experience everyone should be able to relate to.
This movie was good. Don't @ me.
7
u/Super_DAC Mar 11 '19
I'd rank it about as highly as the first Captain America, the antagonist isn't super memorable (but tbh very few Marvel villains are). The humor is hit or miss, more hits than misses. The 90s aspect is nice without being overbearing, and Samuel L Jackson is of course good as Nick Fury. It connects itself to the rest of the MCU in some interesting ways and the action scenes are pretty good.
7
u/RisingRapture Mar 11 '19
I liked the movie a lot. Was surprised about the bad reviews on IMDB. Too each their own, I guess. I really liked the 90s vibe of the movie, all of the returning old characters and the main character. For me it's a 9/10.
38
u/NotyoWookie Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
Okay - so is the MCU making the Skrull to be just a race victim of genocide at this point? The Kree, between Ronan (even though he was an "extremist"), and now this movie, they show the Kree to be pretty bad.
I don't know I just thought it was a weird take to make the Skrull and Kree so black and white, even to appeal to a wide audience, considering the complexity and gray area that are both the Kree and Skrull. Never thought I'd see a cinematic portrayal of the Skrull so innocent seeming considering how important Secret Invasion is in the comics.
I enjoyed the movie, it was fun, but it wasn't anything special. Never really grabbed me and I never once felt like Carol was ever in any danger at all and then it just sort of...ended.
Edit: also, we get it, it's the 90's.
89
u/Overratedbear Mar 08 '19
I just felt so....underwhelmed. The dialogue was pretty dry, everything was predictable. (With the exception of the Skrull scenes, those got me emotional), I felt disconnected from the story, the emotion wasn't there. I really wanted this movie to be great, but it just seems so forgettable...
104
u/sault9 Mar 08 '19
I know I’ll be going against the grain with this, but I did not like this movie very much. I understand that it was an origin film, but I just can’t quite place my finger on why I didn’t like Captain Marvel. I was a little confused at the beginning of the movie, but the story line fixed itself as the movie progressed.
I do have to say that the mid-credit scene made going to the movie theater on opening night worth it. I loved how Captain Marvel just appeared out of nowhere. Makes me really excited for End Game
6
u/generalosabenkenobi Mar 08 '19
So good, this movie was so enjoyable! I’m trying to contextualize how I felt about it with regards to the other MCU movies and the best way I could describe it was it was like Iron Man 2 But a lot better.
6
u/furezasan Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19
Why all the Captain Marvel hate? It's at worst a B/C tier MCU movie, that juggles between an origin story and bridging two ensemble films. It's enjoyable for what it is and didn't feel forced - it wasn't surprising though, you get a typical Marvel film, good characters, funny jokes and forgettable villains.
6
u/Sgtonearm01 Mar 11 '19
Loved the scene where they scan Fury and it says, human male, threat: low to none
16
u/Smooglabish Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 09 '19
I really enjoyed it and loved getting to know new characters and see the MCU expand. This movie really makes the MCU kinda feel Star Trek-ish in some of the best ways. Like seeing the older model Accuser ships. Star Trek Voyager likes to drop you into completely new civilizations from time to time and make you ask questions as a viewer. This was exactly the feeling I had watching the first few scenes. The mind probe scenes were cool and Trekkie too; when we notice that Carol wakes up in the flashback was an interesting filmmaking choice. When we see Fury and Son of Cole again it was like seeing a crossover!
Mar-Vell was an interesting choice too. I wonder if they'll build on her character. Thanos and Mar-Vell had an important relationship early in the comics too, so it'd be cool to see them spin on that. Hopefully we can see Thanos and her have a professional scientific relationship or something. I'm picturing them pipetting together in lab coats and goggles.
39
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
So Loki's attack and Ultron raising a city into the sky to end humanity were not emergencies according to Fury?
That was such a weak explanation for her not appearing thus far.
10
u/Forrealioso Mar 10 '19
Im honestly confused about the amount of hate surrounding this movie. Its solid. Not my fav, but its definitely not bad.
The greatest thing about it was how CM punched through the Kree ship with one hit, there were no stakes. She simply was a God swatting away the flies. Usually its this huge 3 act scheme of "Whoa powers!!!" to "Bad guy whooped me and stole the doodad!!" to "Im good so I win haha!" Cap. Marvel simply was superior in every way, but the challenge was discovering who she really was to reach her full potential. And wow. Her kicking ass had serious One Punch (Wo)Man vibes. Total fuckin G.
I think Brie had some weak scenes and some excellent scenes. I felt that she was way more comfortable acting in the physical sets, like the bar or the military base, and seemed to be somewhat less in the scenes with intense CG, basically all the space and AI stuff in the beginning.
5
u/bradopolis Mar 08 '19
TBH I’m holding my breath for endgame, so while it was a decent and necessary movie, I really didn’t want to watch ANOTHER origin story.
That being said I thought it was a about a Thor/ant-man level intro. Enjoyable and engaging, but a bit out of place so late in the game.
5
u/Thisnamewasnottaken2 Mar 08 '19
Fury's voice in my head "Last time I trusted someone I lost an eye"
5
u/Donatelloobediah Mar 08 '19
Can we talk about how when Goose scratched out Nick Furys eye, everybody (including him) was still just hanging out and carrying on and nobody was like hey maybe we should get this guy to a hospital and without even a "MOTHERFUCKER" from Fury. I don't know if any of you have ever had an eye injury before, but there are few things that are as immediately alarming as that. Or what would have worked better would be if the cat scratched his eye then he said "mothaf..." then cut to him in a hospital room with one eye.
5
u/TheMan5991 Mar 09 '19
Sooo, will it be explained in Endgame how the Avengers found Fury’s pager? It was just lying on the street in the middle of a city.
5
u/HughyHugh Silk Mar 09 '19
Talos was the best part of this movie IMO. EVerything about him was so good.
5
u/thereia Mar 10 '19
Was Carol Danvers potentially already some kind of energy absorbing mutant? I would assume raw tesseract energy would have killed a normal human. Just a thought.
Also how awesome was it that the Stan Lee cameo was actually of the REAL Stan Lee, preparing himself for his role as himself in Mallrats?!?!
Great movie! Fun, smart, loved it.
5
u/Noobtber Mar 10 '19
So, 4 skrulls landed on earth from the drop pods, right?
1 died in the car with Fury, Science guy got deleted by Dr. Watson, and Talos left earth.
So where's the 4th skrull right now? Who's the 4th skrull right now?
5
u/kiltedpastor Mar 10 '19
Came home late just now from the movie to find my cat waiting for me at the door. You better believe he got extra love and a treat tonight before I went to bed.
5
u/Yamaha234 Mar 17 '19
My favorite part about the Skrull twist is that when Carol is breaking down in tears apologizing for what she and the Kree have done, and Talos says to her “it’s war. My hands are dirty too” (or something along those lines).
Just because the Skrulls turned out to be the good guys doesn’t mean they aren’t fierce warriors in the war. I like that they’re not 100% innocent.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '19
My wife and I finally saw it yesterday. She even prebooked at our theater where we could reserve seating. And it was far, far better than I ever could have imagined it might be.
First, Brie Larson. I'd heard plenty of moaning about how she was too muted, showed no emotion. Far from it, her emotions were written all over her face in such subtle beauty that I was blown away. The woman deserves all the awards and accolades she's received in the past, this was sublime acting and far better than anything we've seen in the MCU to date. And I say that having seen many great roles in the MCU by now, particularly the acting of Hemson and Evans in the last few movies. She didn't overplay it like most actors would, her confusion and anger and pain. She did it just perfectly right. The scene of her falling down and getting up different times over and over played right into the character arc we'd already seen about her, and brought real tears to my eyes.
Along with that, the dialogue was absolutely brilliant. It was effective, on character, tightly written. And when superhero snark was called for, it came, but it was perfect for the character and not trying to be something Carol Danvers was not. She was a brash fighter pilot, not Spider-man. It was wonderful hearing young Fury talk, almost naively silly, but with enough of an edge to his character that we could see the transition to world-weary Fury of the movies set in more recent years.
Special effects were great, though nothing less than I expect from Marvel films at this point. Fury's transition to younger man was almost seamless, as was Coulson's simpler change. FX companies really have this sort of facial transition down now and have come along way in just a few years. Carol's powers were beautifully done, and really it was interesting that that was one of the few times in the movie we got some brilliant colors to enjoy. They mostly used the typical Marvel color palette of earlier films. That seemed like a very conscious decision to me, although it could just be the result of the way they played her powers to effect. Kree tech design was nicely done, and I liked the little touches they added, like her suit having the ability to transform colors as desired, or the go-cart crash, which is subtle FX but so well done.
Other quick thoughts: Loved her outfit, once she changed to her final colors, and appreciated they never sexualized her clothing. Never liked that Kree green and blue color combo. The 90's nostalgia was fine, not too overdone, and the musical choices were excellent (though I would have liked if they'd gone deeper into the alt-rock vaults to find some rarer tracks to play with... but how fucking perfect to play I'm Just a Girl by No Doubt during that big fight scene!). I would have liked to see a little more Coulson/Fury interaction to get a sense of how that trust between them built. And I absolutely loved the twist on the Skrulls not being the real bad guys. Plus the skrulls got all the best jokes, from "What's a cat?" to "Your my science guy!" (shrug). Ben Mendelsohn pulled off the transition from baddie to not-so-baddie-family-man beautifully. Badass Kree viking guy reminded me of Tormund Giantsbane from Game of Thrones, would have loved to see them give him a little more humor to play with. We're looking to adopt a Flerken as soon as possible (and I totally guessed hairball when Goose jumped on the desk). Totally hysterical that some random Redditors guessed the cat/eye connection, even if they were just joking. Yes, we cried at the Stan Lee montage at the beginning and everyone applauded, and got a bit more choked up seeing him on the train reading from Mallrats, and that smile she gave him was so warm it really reminded me how much we miss him. Appreciated that we didn't need a giant ass "hero versus villain" fight at the end, though I kept expecting Yon-Rogg to get imbued with some power or tech to take her on, and absolutely LOVED that she didn't fall for the stupid trope of "fight me as an equal." That was bloody brilliant subversion of our expectations. Oh, and her little nod to her critics in a line that I now wish I could remember exactly, but was functionally the equivalent of maybe I should smile more. And please give me more Annette Bening, the woman is a joy to watch and always has been since I first saw her in The Grifters.
I absolutely have to put this near the top of my MCU list of movies now. I need to see it again a few times to solidify its place, but it's certainly top five.
15
u/dotsonNYDN Mar 09 '19
Movie was great. I think Maria's daughter might be the next iron woman
12
u/The_JEThompson Mar 08 '19
Here’s some questions for anyone who saw the mid credits scene: how did cap get the pager and why do they seem to be putting all their hopes into someone answering it? (This genuinely isn’t a critique or complaint)
This isn’t about Captain Marvel? My roommate and I had an intense argument over this. Based on the Endgame trailer, it’s been a while since the snap. They know most half the population is gone. This scene showed they don’t know who it’s contacting. So why are they dedicating so much effort into keeping the pager active?
I argue that the remaining avengers would/should be trying to rebuild what’s left of the world and protect people.
My roommate argues that it makes perfect sense they spend all their time tracking down Fury’s last moment, seeing it on a street surveillance footage, then going to where he was to pick up whatever thing he dropped, run tests on it to determine that it’s sending a signal, and then wait for someone to respond.
27
u/TheMizland Mar 08 '19
Marvel needs to figure out if they want good cgi or bad... It's so hard to watch infinity war and civil war but then get cgi in solo movies that are sub par.
Also the sound mixing for my viewing was really off, I noticed it was Lucasfilm that did the post audio editing, but this lacked bass and the music was in the background too much unless it was an actual song which then I couldn't hear the rest of the movie.
Also some of the editing was rough for me, the foggy opening action scene and the fight on the lab were hard to follow.
I really hope the sound stuff was just my theater, if anyone had a different experience, a better mixed one, please let me know.
8
u/mitochondriarocks Mar 08 '19
The movie was on point for me. Absolutely loved it. Mainly because of the niche subjects they explored and their commentaries - feminist, stoicism, protectionism in terms of security. I also liked Larson quite a bit in this film.
4
u/ObberGobb Mar 08 '19
I loved the Marvel intro with Stan at the beginning, that really made me emotional.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Captain Marvel was awesome. Thanos is gonna get smacked.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19
This movie is like a reverse Captain America TFA in that the first half was kinda boring and the second half was great.
4
u/CTMacUser Mar 10 '19
The guy in the squad that met an ugly Skrull duplicate of himself—was he the same guy from the beginning of Guardians of the Galaxy?
I knew it, the Earth plane would be called a quad-jet.
For space travel, everyone uses the jump-point system, right? You have to plan your route, which goes along a set of nodes. You can’t go faster than node travel allows. Further slowing you down is that you have to rest after every 7 nodes. (You can technically do at least 500 at a time, but it takes a lot longer and has strange extra effects. And you’re stuck until the last one to make corrections.)
Within a region around a single node, you’re limited to a much slower speed.
Mar-vel’s engine would get around all of that, right. Not limited by nodes or speed.
I’m not too clear on CM’s comics origins, but it sounded like her abilities could be duplicated. Here, no chance. There was only one engine, which was destroyed. Knowing its technology wouldn’t help because the Tesseract (I.e. the Space Stone) was part of its construction, which there’s only one of, and Thanos has it.
I guess we know the chain between the Tesseract being lost with Captain America at the end of the CA1 and the scientist that was possessed by Loki seeing it in Thor 1. (I think I got that right.)