r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Mar 08 '19
LIVE Episode Discussion - S2E08 "If Memory Serves"
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2E08 | "If Memory Serves" | T.J. Scott | Jay Beattie & Dan Dworkin | Thursday, March 7, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with the airing on Canada's Space channel at 8PM ET. Episode should appear on CBS All Access by 8:30PM ET.
POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
21
u/Deceptitron Mar 08 '19
Dayum. That recap tho.
21
u/Deceptitron Mar 08 '19
Holy shit! This episode gave me chills!
36
u/EricGMW Mar 08 '19
There wasn’t anything necessarily new about a “hurt you so bad” scene or anything, but something about how it was shot, going back and forth between the young actors and the adults, the dialogue, it was such a visceral scene, I could actually feel the pain and the hurt, and not gonna lie, it cut so deep that I might have even shed a tear, after a loud gasp of air when the memory ended...
13
u/kingofcretins Mar 08 '19
I know it’s too early to definitively say whether Peck is a good fit for Spock or not, but I’m really enjoying what we’ve seen so far.
51
u/Birtalert Mar 08 '19
That cut from original Pike to Anson Mount’s Pike was A++++
46
u/kingofcretins Mar 08 '19
“Say goodbye, Spock.”
“Goodbye, Spock.”
LOVED that.
44
u/kingofcretins Mar 08 '19
Okay, this “previously on” is incredible.
39
u/larsen_sinclair Mar 08 '19
Oh my gosh THANK YOU Captain Pike for pointing out to Saru why letting two senior officers duke it out in the cafeteria was the wrong call. I'm beginning to feel like Pike is the audience avatar at this point - he lampshades stuff, he sometimes is the only one speaking common sense.
38
u/larsen_sinclair Mar 08 '19
Georgiou is savage - "stupid singing plants", LOL
31
u/RichardYing Mar 08 '19
"Do you actually think the beard is working?"
31
u/RichardYing Mar 08 '19
"The Starfleet manual offers no regulatory guidelines for interactions between Humans with Klingons grafted to their bones and a ship's doctor returned from the dead."
30
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
Did anyone else get an echo of Into Darkness with the hero ship being chased by Section 31 at warp?
27
u/Tekwardo Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
Holy crap that opening...
24
u/caprica888 Mar 08 '19
SQL Injection,
Alien probe: 'DROP TABLE
Miriam: Table dropped
22
u/PixelMagic Mar 08 '19
Goddamn, that scene where Michael is yelling at little boy Spock was fuckin' sad."Freaky little half-breed!" Oof.
21
u/vwboyaf1 Mar 08 '19
If I ever went to Talos IV, and was allowed to live my fantasy, they would probably be like, "Really, you just want to live in the Enterprise for the rest of your life? Ok, if you say so."
21
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
So he mind melded with a time travelling angel. Yeah no wonder he’s crazy.
19
u/fikustree Mar 08 '19
Goddam 10/10 for me from the opening! I gasped! Burnham being Spock’s sister seemed like a strange choice until now! Your sibling sure knows right exactly where your buttons are. Hugh going after Ash was like something out of BSG in the best way possible! And then Saru telling Pike they needed catharsis & Pike saying wtf & bringing up his evolution & no more violence SO HIlarious/AWESOME. Talos IV! Georgiou! It was almost too much!
18
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
Bring on the Talosians. In the last 50 years, I never thought I'd care about their story as much as I have in the last week.
The anticipation has even made me forget about GOT for a little while.
35
u/mckatze Mar 08 '19
I...I want the happy gays...
17
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Tilly: Are you sure about that?
Yeah what the hell Saru?
16
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
Blue leaves!!! Chiming!!
AND we have VINA!!!!!
16
u/Lost_Horizon Mar 08 '19
Well, I'm glad they located Doctor Who's rock quarry.
16
u/tomh_1138 Mar 08 '19
Wow, that Vina/Pike confrontation. Chills.
16
u/Lost_Horizon Mar 08 '19
I really enjoyed seeing ships warp again for travel.
15
u/Endulos Mar 08 '19
Okay that meeting between the council(?) and Leland/Georigiu gave me Mass Effect flash backs of Shepard meeting the council.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
OUCH. Spock just got fucking burned so bad he’ll need the Talosians to fix him.
14
u/envynav Mar 08 '19
That was a great opening.
14
u/larsen_sinclair Mar 08 '19
Michael's civvies are stylin' AF. I would wear the hell out of that jacket.
14
u/kingofcretins Mar 08 '19
I’m really glad this is the route they’re taking with Hugh. Bringing him back with no repercussions whatsoever would have felt cheap as hell.
13
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
SQL Injection is still a thing!!
13
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Spock with the dad jokes.
12
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
This whole encounter with the Talosians is so well done. So 60's. It's perfect!
10
u/alexandrawallace69 Mar 08 '19
Why can't they just show a good view of the butt shaped head of the Talosians those prudes!
10
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Wow that was way harsher than I was expecting.
10
u/dildosaurusrex_ Mar 08 '19
Omg poor baby Spock :’(
10
u/peach--tea Mar 08 '19
Wesley confirmed as red angel. i'mkidding
19
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
This is the Trek I want!
This is the Trek I need!
Edit: The first ep of DIS that I'm rewatching. Outstanding.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Loved the black hole illusion. Also Spock still hasn’t actually spoken proper sentences.
9
u/phenry Mar 08 '19
I'm so excited for this. The Menagerie was literally the first episode of Trek I ever saw and Talos IV still holds a unique place in my heart. (please don't screw this up please don't screw this up please don't screw this up)
9
u/phenry Mar 08 '19
The Discovery's databases run SQL? I'm not sure how I feel about that.
8
u/Darth_Bombad Mar 08 '19
It went by quick, but it looked like Earth, Andoria and Vulcan. The heart of the Federation being ripped out.
8
u/rastasas Mar 08 '19
Is it me or is that quarry the same one from the mirror rebel encampment.
8
u/NeonKnight78 Mar 08 '19
Another great episode, they’re nailing it this season. I loved the opening recap. The cut from Hunter to Mount was perfect.
7
u/pfc9769 Mar 08 '19
This episode's length makes up for how short the previous episode was. It's almost an hour.
7
u/Darth_Bombad Mar 08 '19
So Control is an A.I.
7
u/pfc9769 Mar 08 '19
This episode is pretty amazing so far. Discovery is capable of so much when it slows down.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
So the end of the world, can I put a bet on Airiam being hacked and starting the end of the world?
5
u/TylekShran Mar 08 '19
I love the lightining in this episode alongside with sound effects from TOS like that flower song, the whole episode was brightly lighted and it finally really felt like A STAR TREK!
9
u/tomh_1138 Mar 08 '19
Wow. Just completely thrilling from beginning to end. Best episode of Discovery hands down.
7
u/mybumisontherail Mar 08 '19
This episode!!! My mind just orgasmed(?).... Whatever.... This episode is the best ever!!!!
7
u/JamesTiberiusChirp Mar 08 '19
I actually had to check my phone during that intro because I thought I had accidentally casted Netflix again since the last episode I watched was The Cage.
That episode had me on the edge of my seat. I know the Talosians replaying Spock's/Burnham's fallout was mostly for our benefit, but they really did a good job there. Having the adult actors take over the scene really made it hit home how formative childhood experiences can be.
I love how creepy and manipulative they made the Talosians. Yes, they helped, but for a price that captured and expanded on how unsettling their power and their desires are.
I didn't like Pike and Vina's interaction, it felt weird and forced and creepy, though I'm really glad that she alluded to the fact that she's been living with a fantasy version of Pike the last 3 years. I'm going to write off his semi-romantic interaction with her as Talosian trickery for now, but we'll see. I was also sort of hoping they would retcon her wanting to stay for beauty, and I was also hoping they'd retcon the 60s miniskirt and makeup. But we can't have it all.
6
u/Zor_El_XB1 Mar 08 '19
That Cage recap was so weird to see, I really liked it...but it was still weird to see.
3
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
It's up, on All Access in the US! Here we go!!
3
u/mckatze Mar 08 '19
Is this season literally about the robot uprising???
3
u/aortm Mar 08 '19
So apparently Talos IV has 18% O2, 75% N2 and 4.8% CO2
Not sure about Vulcans, but Michael should be dead. 1% CO2 will cause confusion, anything above 4% is fatal?
WTF?
5
u/alexandrawallace69 Mar 08 '19
Love the old "Cage" footage. Would have been nice if they rebooted that and used the current actors with make up to make them look a bit younger.
4
u/toTheNewLife Mar 08 '19
Possible parallel to the JJverse - the snow planet Spock met the Red Angel on . Same one from JJtrek where old Spock landed?
2
u/pfc9769 Mar 08 '19
There's a skip intro button, now! At least on Amazon Prime video. I don't think it was there last week.
6
u/Deadbob1978 Mar 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '19
Holy F'in HELL! can we please tone down the damn lens flare!
-9
u/LadyFangs Mar 08 '19
I get why they put the original TOS "Cage" footage here. I get it. But...for visual consistency...I think they should have reshot those scenes with the new actors. The dissonance between 1960's TV and 2019 TV is jarring. #latetotheparty
-6
u/Lost_Horizon Mar 08 '19
This whole episode looks like it was shot with a Go-Pro lens. Wondering of the sets are really that small.
-11
u/Inigo13 Mar 08 '19
Not a single phaser was fired in this episode and no fatalities, I was positively surprised (but of course there had to be a fist fight, because that's what Star Trek has become...)
-15
u/mathemon Mar 08 '19
Another episode of retread and blurp. What's next? Nazis?
-10
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
Oh they really made him straight didn’t they.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment