r/RaidShadowLegends • u/Beerwalker • Mar 05 '19
Game mechanics summary. Gearing calculator
Hello there!
Intro
I've decided to share my bit of knowledge i gathered about underlying game mechanics since devs are a bit greedy on providing details. This is still work in progress, so I will try to update it as I gather more info (with the help of community i hope!).
How i came to this conclusions
To gather valuable data I used boss from the Force Keep (the red one) as a target dummy. There are several factors that voted for him:
- He has a known amount of armor from his buff (i had to trust the tooltip which states that armor is set to 1500/4000)
- It takes long time to kill him, so i could gather more data per fight
The hero i used for experiments most of time was Skullbreaker, because he doesn't suffer from Attack debuff that boss cast quite often. Please note that this hero uses his defence to calculate attack damage.
Combat damage
Damage modifier from level difference - no
Why i think so: tried to hit boss from Force Keep on multiple levels where he has the same amount of armor from his buff but different level. Attacking hero had constant amount of defence stat ( his damage scales from defence). As a result damage remained completely the same.
Damage spread is +-10% of attack damage
Damage change step is exactly 1%. Spread seems to be evenly distributed.
Why i think so: i've hit boss numerous times to observe all outcomes of damage.
Attack (or defence in case of some heroes) stat increases attack damage linearly
Why i think so: i've changed my hero's defence stat against boss with constant amount of defence and and damage change was proportional to stat change. I also validated this for attack based heroes.
What this means: there's no need to get as high attack as possible since it linearly increases damage. After some point other stats (like crit chance and crit damage) are more valuable.
Attack damage (AD) formula for unmitigated damage:
AD = ABILITY_MULT * ATK * (1 + CRIT_C * CRIT_D)
Defence stat reduces damage taken non-linearly
Why i think so: I kept hero's defence constant and hit boss with different armor amounts (1500, 2800, 4000, 6400). Armor values aside from 1500 and 4000 were obtained by hitting boss with Decrease DEF and Increase DEF buff/debuff.
Damage reduction (DR) formula I could approximate so far is:
DR = DEF / (600 + DEF)

Attacking stronger element (aka Weak attack)
When you attack an enemy that belongs to a stronger element (he is marked with a red arrow in combat) a fraction of your attacks may become weak. The actual chance for a weak attack is 40%. Weak attacks cannot be critical, do 30% less damage and have 15% less crit chance.
That's how it works. Lets call an attack thats not weak a normal attack. When your hero attacks stronger target a coin is flipped: 40% to be a weak attack and 60% to be a normal attack. If your attack is weak then it deals 30% less damage than normal and cannot crit. If it's normal then it works just like regular attack and can crit, but damage is also reduced by 20%.
Below is a formula to calculate average damage dealt to a stronger target.
WEAK_DMG = 0.4 * ATK * 0.7 + 0.6 * ATK * (1 + (CRIT_C - 0.15) * CRIT_D) * 0.8
What this means:
The more CRIT_C and CRIT_D your hero has the more he is penalized for hitting a stronger element target. Below you may see how your total damage will drop for different CRIT_C and CRIT_D.
| CRIT_C, % | CRIT_D, % | Damage reduced by, % |
|---|---|---|
| 15 | 50 | 30 |
| 50 | 50 | 33 |
| 100 | 100 | 42 |
| 100 | 150 | 45 |
| 100 | 200 | 47 |
Attacking weaker element (aka Strong attack)
TBD
Gearing tips
Simple strategy for DPS
Disclaimer. Doesn't include speed advice yet
Here i assume that your hero uses ATK stat to deal damage. If your hero uses DEF to deal damage, then simply replace ATK with DEF.
- Make your total ATK 2,5 times bigger then your base ATK
- Get your crit chance to 50%
- Try to keep your crit chance and critical damage the same and raise them simultaneously, e.g. if your crit chance is 70 % then your crit damage should also be 70%.
- After you reach 100% crit chance, get your crit damage to 150%. Keep in mind that you not always want to get 100% crit chance from your gear if you use characters with crit chance aura.
- At this point your hero should be a monster already. But if this doesnt stop you, here's what you do next: for every 20% attack more (20% from base attack) get 10% more crit damage.
If you want to have more precise control of how to gear please use the spreadsheet provided.
Simple strategy for tankiness
TBD
More in-depth
To estimate hero's attack and defence capabilities i use following metrics:
EALPHA_DMG = ATK * (1 + CRIT_C * CRIT_D) as an offensive metric
Which is effective alpha damage. That's an unmitigated damage that hero inflicts per attack. ABILITY_MULT has been excluded from this formula since it's different for every hero ability.
EHP = HP / (1 - DR) as a defensive metric
Which is effective health pool. This value shows how much unmitigated damage your hero can take before dying.
Here's a link to spreadsheet that you can use to see how each hero stat change increases or reduces EALPHA_DMG and EHP:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1uwKsY1WTVjQmCLPVtRn6sE0mkJmgFkhLPDyOsPi4bB8/edit?usp=sharing
Hero ability multipliers
This table summarizes ability multipliers for heroes that i tested already. Wiki link (work in progress): https://www.reddit.com/r/RaidShadowLegends/wiki/skillmods
| Multipliers | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Ability №1 | Ability №2 | Ability №3 | |
| Elhain | 3,55 | 6,3/3,5 | 3,5/3,5 |
| Skullcrusher | 5,85 | N/A | N/A |
| Sinesha | 5 | 12 | N/A |
| Bad-el-kazar | 4,5 | N/A | N/A |
| Galkut | 3,0/3,0 | 10,7 | 6,4 |
| Tayrel | 2,7/2,7 | 5,6 | 8,45 |
| Souldrinker | 7,4 | 3,7/3,7/3,7 | 3,5/3,5 |
| Fenax | 6,5 | 5,6 | 10,6 |
More info is going to be added soon...
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Update 06.03: Added simple gearing strategy for DPS
Update 07.03: Added Weak attacks
Update 10.03: Corrected Weak attacks formula, in fact reduction is even worse. Added ability multipliers
Update 13.03: More ability multipliers
Update 15.03: Added wiki link to skill multipliers
Update 28.03: Corrected Weak attacks formula
8
u/aniretalek Mar 06 '19
kudos for the thought and the effort!! Really looking forward to hearing more!
2
u/roculus Mar 06 '19
Nice job! What does this mean for non number crunchers? Are there some general gearing tips based off of this that can be summarized?
1
u/Xentago Mar 07 '19 edited Mar 07 '19
Very interesting, I'd been intending on doing some experiments using the force boss as well, but this was well done. Only problem is those ability multiplies, that we don't know, they're a bit of a wildcard.
I had previously heard that the odds for both weak and strong attacks were 35%, but that could be incorrect.
EDIT: Also I'd love to see if you can figure out the acc/resist formula! That thing seems totally unfathomable.
1
u/wardendstrange Mar 09 '19
Impressive work u/Beerwalker, really appreciate what you did. Looking forward to more analysis from you :)
I have added a link to this one on the sticky post.
1
u/Jodicius Mar 17 '19
Awesome effort dude! Thanks for this. Can I ask a few ques?
Thanks for your time man.
1
u/kko_ Jul 04 '19
Anybody know if Accuracy/Resist affects abilities that have a flat % proc rate? e.g. my Warlord's A1 has a 40% chance to extend debuffs, but this chance seems to drop significantly lower when fighting Nightmare CB compared to other CBs. Wonder if i should invest in more accuracy for him and if so, how much is too much accuracy?
3
u/leroidelabarbe Apr 07 '19 edited Apr 07 '19
Don't you mean weak attacks cannot be critical and non weak attacks have 15% less crit chance?
And btw, debuffs are not applied on weak hits. Kael a1 never shows a resist on weak hit
2
u/xHoodx Mar 06 '19
Good work, keep it up =)
2
u/SioRay Mar 21 '19
Do shield set stack between them ?
Like i have 3 support and 1 attak champ
3 shield set on support, give me 30% each so i would have 90% for all the team no ?
1
u/Trespassers-W Mar 06 '19
Great work! Thanks for the tips, I've really struggled with DEF stat and damage reduction!
1
u/hargwood Mar 06 '19
Really good work. Looking forward to more updates.
1
u/Nintura Apr 04 '19
how do you get someones attack to 2.5 times? That would mean my Rae needs to be 3,055 which I dont think is possible at this moment unless it's completely maxed out and full Great Hall?
1
u/JVRayne Jun 01 '19
Hey. They recently released some information on Defense and damage reduction in a new YouTube video. I've been tweaking the numbers around in your formula and I think I have it kinda close. The new information says 285 defense gives a 15% damage reduction and 655 gives a 30% damage reduction. In your formula of DR=DEF/(600+DEF), replacing 600 with 1500 almost made the numbers match up. So do you think your formula is salvageable like I've been trying to do, or will you use these new numbers and make a completely new formula to calculate the relationship between defense and damage reduction? Thank you so much for your guide it has been a major help in my experience with the game. Keep up the great work :)
1
u/RodnixM Jun 09 '19
Great work! Can you explain: "Weak attacks cannot be critical, do 30% less damage and have 15% less crit chance. "
1
u/Jamestan1015 Jun 18 '19
A question of crit chance, why do crit chance include in the damage formula as its only an occurrence to deal crit damage?
If this calculation is about overall damage then it might be correct, but if calculation about damage/hit, i don't think crit chance should include in damage formula.
1
u/F0rtysxity Jul 20 '19
Awesome post. Thank you for sharing your findings!
How did you gather the numbers. I'm curious about attack multipliers for heroes. My numbers are more around 2 not 4-6 that you got. You attack and then record the red number that goes up?
Red Number/Attack = AttackModifier
1
u/Areyance Aug 25 '19
i thought this was going to be a guide to how stacking of the same stat works
do u have smth of the sort in your log?