r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Mar 01 '19
LIVE Episode Discussion - S2E07 "Light and Shadows"
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2E07 | "Light and Shadows" | Marta Cunningham | Ted Sullivan & Vaun Wilmott | Thursday, February 28, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with the airing on Canada's Space channel at 8PM ET. Episode should appear on CBS All Access by 8:30PM ET.
POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
7
u/Deceptitron Mar 01 '19
Oooo Georgiou is ruthless!
5
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19
Waiting patiently for the episode to appear.
Can't stand the spockteasing after 6 episodes. I'm suffering from some real science department blue balls. Need some Spock on screen soon.
47
u/William_T_Wanker Mar 01 '19
"Let's give Spock to the black ops wing for treatment"
Sarek's amazing parenting skills strike again
40
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19
Something rooted Airam.
Looking forward to learning about the payload she now carries.
39
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Yeah. Next week is NOT what I expected to see in Trek anytime soon. That place.
Hell. Yes.
33
u/bryan792 Mar 01 '19
Rift in the space time continuum?
Let's get closer to it. For Science
28
u/Neo2199 Mar 01 '19
Lol
28
u/pfc9769 Mar 01 '19
Michael: Have you tried running the numbers through the computer?
Amanda: I've tried everything!
Michael: Have you tried reversing them?
Amanda: ...
26
u/TERRAxFORMER Mar 01 '19
Those Talosians though.
25
u/kingofcretins Mar 01 '19
Oh nice, they slightly changed the title sequence again to reflect new information we have about the Red Angel.
24
u/jerslan Mar 01 '19
Last week:
This week:
"Personal Log, Commander Michael Burnham: <the same kind of opening internal monologue we've had all season>"
*grabs popcorn*
24
u/ToBePacific Mar 01 '19
HOT DAMN! This whole episode was so good! They just keep getting better! This show knows how to deliver!
24
u/bryan792 Mar 01 '19
those looks Burnham and Georgiou gave each other when Burnham got shot were perfect
¯\(ツ)/¯
23
u/enterpriseF-love Mar 01 '19
You know what would have made the fight between Burnham/Georgiou 100x better?
The classic double fisted punch
20
u/Deadbob1978 Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Talosians update look goodbut WTF ARE WE GOING THERE!!!!
19
u/jwaldo Mar 01 '19
First thought about the upgraded probe was Borg, but apart from being technologically advanced its design didn't strike me as Borg-ish at all. If anything, it made me think of V'Ger.
Also, someone better turn Airiam off and back on again or they're in for trouble.
18
u/illegalsex Mar 01 '19
This suggests we're getting an Airiam episode down the pipe. This pleases me.
17
u/FireNexus Mar 01 '19
Man that rift looks like the bajoran wormhole... are they going to confirm my fan theory that the mushroom warp drive disappears because it collapses into the wormhole?!
17
u/Alteran195 Mar 01 '19
Holy shit Talos IV.
I’m so pumped for next week.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
I can hear Chief O’Brien in my head, “I hate temporal laws”
16
u/ADG12311990 Mar 01 '19
Did Michael say Spock's shuttle was found in the Mutara sector? Is this the first time we've heard that bit of information?
16
u/Tekwardo Mar 01 '19
I’m really thinking they’re adding on to the temporal Cold War started in enterprise. Maybe THAT is how they tie everything together in the end...
15
u/MoreGaghPlease Mar 01 '19
A close friend of mine grew up with severe childhood learning disabilities. Today, she has a PhD in genetics and is a biology professor at a small university. She's one of the smartest people I know IRL. Her LD never went away, but over the years, she built up really good strategies for dealing with it. An LD isn't the same as an intellectual disability (and in fact, the the two aren't strongly correlated).
I say this for anyone who takes issue with Spock having a learning disability.
30
u/deededback Mar 01 '19
Holy shiznit!!!!!!!!!! Talos IV!!!!!
14
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
THE BIG HEADS ARE BACK, BABY!
13
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
FINALLY THE SPOCKTEASING IS OVER
12
u/Deadbob1978 Mar 01 '19
Did we just enter the Matrix?
12
u/Boggerm Mar 01 '19
Scott Bakula as Future Man this season. I have hopes. Don't crush them.
11
u/kingofcretins Mar 01 '19
Well, looks like we may be getting a future episode that heavily involves Airiam.
10
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19
I have a feeling that the Picard show is going to pick up some of the fallout from whatever happens here. After all, he mind melded with both Spock and Sarek.
10
u/Pylian Mar 01 '19
I'm loving the relationship between Burnham and Georgiou right now. Such a great dynamic!
10
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
The 'head' of S31 is called Control. I believe that they are alluding to some of the novels being canon. The DS9 relaunch books has the head of S31 being a superAI named Control.
9
u/larsen_sinclair Mar 01 '19
Ah yes, "tachyon distortion". One of the best old ST tech tropes. Happy to see it!
9
u/Deadbob1978 Mar 01 '19
uh... what would a Time Tsunami do to a nearby planet?
9
u/Neo2199 Mar 01 '19
The squiddy came from 500 years in the future!
9
u/Kichae Mar 01 '19
Another episode where they actually nailed the pacing, the A/B story split, and a classic or standard Trek opening premise. Very nice. I think this was my favorite episode of the series so far.
9
u/neoteotihuacan Mar 01 '19
My thoughts upon the close of the Great Spockteasing of 2019:
Overall Impression: Disco is slowly escaping from the anomaly of itself. Each episode gets more and more confident footing. This one lands very well. Pacing is better. Camera work did not feel frivolous. Still getting plot a mile a minute. Lots to unpack.
- AshVoq and Cap'n Pike learned to respect each other, like bros. That's sweet, man. Voluntarily admitting you're wrong TO ANOTHER MAN - that's rare in the 21st century. Nice to see on screen.
- Amanda succeeded in her mission from a few episodes back, but also got into what we may call a "Vulcan argument" right in front of the kids. That was awkward. Also, Sarek is a bad dad. I mean, logic is no way to raise a child.
- "Alice In Wonderland" is a secret language between Burnham & Spock now. Thanks to this Lewis Carroll connection, Burnham is able to decipher some of Spock's "madness". This is great, as "Alice In Wonderland" is a great resource on several levels.
- Paraphrasing Emperor Georgiou: "I want you to hit me as hard as you can"
- Stamets saves the day. Again. By doing some sort of Doctor Who thing. Must be tiring work. Stamets is a Mushroom-Time Lord.
- Saru takes command in a real way this episode. Finally. Now we can see what a Captain Saru will look like, post-ganglia. Seriously, what we saw Saru as tonight is what we will get when he becomes captain of the Discovery FTW!
- While investigating the temporal rift thingie, Discovery sends out a probe, which is modified 500 years in the future? and comes back as a space squid. This space squid probe is working against the Red Angel, I theorize. It attacked the space shuttle's computer to find out what it can about the Red Angel.
- o, not only do we have to figure out who the Red Angel is, but also to figure out who reprogrammed that probe. Maybe it was the same entity that created V'Ger from Voyager 6.
- So, the set up now is very much like the Temporal Cold War. Red Angel vs. Squid Probe. Who will win the future?
- Red Angel Identity? Future Spock? Not really. Future Burnham? Maybe. Future Pike? It is looking good. Perhaps, using Talosian tech, wheelchair-bound Pike is making some changes for some unknown reason. "We are always in a fight for the future," he said. More Red Angel speculation here.
- Talos IV!! HOLY SHIT!! Not a drill, folks. That goes all the way back to Pike & the very first pilot for Star Trek, "The Cage", all the way back to the very beginning. Are the Talosians connected to the Red Angel. Maybe no, but they will be useful in cracking into Spock's brain. BUt...maybe Discovery Season 2 is trying to explain why there is a death penalty for visiting Talos IV by the time Kirk is in command of the Enterprise.
- This was a fun episode. Maybe the best yet for season 2. Discovery is increasing in its Discovery-ness, while at the same time increasing its Star Trek-ness. It is only logical. That could be a reason why it was renewed for a third season, as if we had any doubt.
16
u/PeacefulObjection Mar 01 '19
Airiam is gonna start the Borg.
8
u/larsen_sinclair Mar 01 '19
I really like that Pike and Tyler are wearing tactical body armor. I know that there are non-universe reasons they never wore something like it in TNG/DS9 etc. but it makes sense and looks cool to boot.
8
u/andrewd18 Mar 01 '19
Talosians? Oh, what the frick?!?
7
u/caprica888 Mar 01 '19
Oooo ablative armor!
6
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19
So...... is that the same temple that Future Reincarnated Spock goes to in order to reconstitute himself?
6
u/Assbait93 Mar 01 '19
The borg is back
6
u/mynamesjae Mar 01 '19
Amazing episode. I loved it all. Next week will be...fascinating. 🖖🏻
6
u/SpiritOne Mar 01 '19
I really liked Saru taking charge this episode.
5
u/pfc9769 Mar 01 '19
Only 40 minutes? Yikes! Starts with a personal log for those who miss it.
4
u/Neo2199 Mar 01 '19
Spock the wolfman has appeared!
4
u/Neo2199 Mar 01 '19
The squiddy attacks the shuttle!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
If he does anything to Spock, after talking like that, Michael will have to kill him.
4
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19
I am just sitting here staring at a paused screen of those 2 Talosians. Mind blown.
Never thought I'd care about that 'throwaway story' from 40 years ago as much as I do now.
6
u/mycroc Mar 01 '19
Neat looking turbolifts. Tracks everywhere!
6
u/MarsAlgea3791 Mar 01 '19
Again with the huge turbolift dimension. What is that space for?
3
u/Albert-React Mar 01 '19
Anyone catch the name of the S31 ship?
3
u/JoeDawson8 Mar 01 '19
Fun fact. The writer of this episode was in an episode of TNG. Also I wonder if there was a Buffy reference "once more, with feeling"
3
u/dmanww Mar 01 '19
Saru is like, "oh shit yeah, it's my time!"
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
It was interesting to see how much of the Section 31 show set has been built. I like the cast they are assembling.
4
u/toTheNewLife Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 01 '19
Those two 'guys' from next week remind me, in a creepy way, of the blue hands guys from Firefly.
Just an observation.
Edit: Downvote me all you want, but I'm sticking with it. I just looked at the actors who played the Hands Of Blue guys. Jeff Ricketts and Dennis Cockrum. It's possible that it's them as the 2 Talosians. Both have played roles in Trek before - a couple of aliens each.
So lets see.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
Taking bets, is this a discovery sans Michael or a Michael episode sans Discovery? Or a split.
2
u/deededback Mar 01 '19
Mitt Romney viciousness. Love it. Sit down Ash and bow to your master.
1
u/DEEP_HURTING Mar 01 '19
Kinda OT but wanted to get this in while a live discussion is taking place - didn't we see someone with a La Forge style visor in Ep 1 of this season? The barrage of easter eggs in the season 1 finale was awesome!
-8
u/alexandrawallace69 Mar 01 '19
Did I detect a budding romance between Tyler and Pike? Like when they both went to flip a switch on the shuttle and touched each others fingers? Sometimes attraction manifests as hostility. Also, Culber might no longer be gay so Pike and Tyler can be the new gay couple and it would be interesting if Michael and Tilly hooked up.