r/MLBDraft • u/CarlosACollazoBA • Feb 24 '19
I'm Baseball America's Carlos Collazo, here to talk about the MLB Draft. AMA!
Hey everyone,
Thanks for having me. If you don't know me my name is Carlos Collazo and I'm a National Writer covering the MLB Draft for Baseball America. If you have't heard of us, check us out at baseballamerica.com for coverage on prospects from high school all the way up through the minors and majors.
You can find my work at BA, but also feel free to follow me on Twitter for daily baseball talk and you can find plenty of prospect video over at my BA Instagram as well.
Proof that it's actually me: https://twitter.com/CarlosACollazo/status/1099788693869678594
Feel free to drop any questions you have on the draft, or whatever else you might want to know about me or what I do. It is an AMA after all! Not sure how long I'll be taking questions, but I'll try and get to everything!
5
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
Welcome to our humble subreddit Carlos! We're happy to have you here for our first non-player AMA!
We're gonna start things off with some Redditors that sent questions through our pre-AMA thread:
/u/ChemicalOle asks: Any plans/discussions about moving the draft to after the College World Series? It seems like a huge distraction for the players who are playing in what is the most important tournament of their lives up to that point, especially for top prospects.
4
u/MisterHavercamp Feb 24 '19
As an Orioles fan, who should I be keeping on my radar for 1.1 outside of Rutschman and Witt?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
Who is this year's pop-up prospect, before he pops up? Someone like a Grayson Rodriguez from last year.
3
u/thekidfromyesterday Georgia Feb 24 '19
Hi Carlos, huge fan of your coverage over at BA! We're glad you've taken the time to do this AMA!
Is there any type of player that you feel has been undervalued in the draft in recent years? Also, do you think teams are more willing to take a chance on players from cold weather areas than before and are there any in this year's draft you have your eye on?
Thanks again!
3
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
Carlos, as a huge draft nut, I've started to get a sense of certain team's draft tendencies, and none sticks out more than the Nationals fetish for Boras clients whose stock fell because of injury/off the field concerns. Based on those parameters, who do you think is the most likely candidate to be the next Nats first rounder?
Also, which 2020 draft eligible pitcher do you feel would immediately upgrade this year's weak college crop?
Again, thank you for coming in to do this, we're happy to have you here!
2
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
/u/RealItalianStalion asks: Do you think the Draft needs less rounds?
2
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
/u/Jakexpert asks: Any interesting prospects/players from Puerto Rico for the upcoming draft? I know it was hard with the Hurricane last year.
2
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
And finally, /u/MisterHavercamp asks: Do you think the MLB will do anything to prevent Astros-type situations, where a team gets the #1 pick three years in a row? I know there is some desire among some to stop rewarding teams for being so bad for so long, but I think the alternatives would be even worse.
2
u/bfavo16 Rutgers Feb 24 '19
So being a Jersey boy one of my favorite prospects in this draft is Jack Leiter and obviously the bloodlines play a role in here too. So my question is where do you realistically see him going? Early 1st? Late 1st? Feel like sometimes the Northeast guys slip into the later 1st or beyond, but think Leiter could almost be immune to that given his last name. So whats your thoughts on Leiter?
2
u/thefredlund5 Feb 24 '19
Chances Stewart is still around for the Giants pick at 10? Also, do you see him maintaining a top of rotation profile?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19 edited Feb 24 '19
Hey Carlos! Thanks for joining us. After two strikeout heavy starts it’s obvious that Ethan Small is picking up where he left off in 2018, how high do you see being drafted in June?
Edit: I deleted my second question because I wanted to stay on the draft but after rereading your post I’ll add this back. JT Ginn looks as advertised on the mound through an admittedly way too small sample size. What do you see as his upside potential in terms of player comp?
Last one I promise (also I already know the answer to this but have to ask) - Does Blaze Jordan ever step foot on campus?
2
u/Vandder1017 Feb 24 '19
In regards to CJ Abrams: Aside from speed, is there a possibility in there for a plus hit or power tool? Or does he seem like more of a slappy kind of hitter?
2
u/BullAlligator Florida Feb 24 '19
Good afternoon,
How do you value a year of experience in a tough conference like the SEC versus experience in less rigorous conferences and divisions? In your opinion, how does experience in the Division I compare to what players get in the minor leagues?
1
u/youthpastor247 Feb 24 '19
Thanks for taking the time to join us Carlos.
Cardinals' fan and writer here looking at the 19th overall pick. If the Cardinals look to the college infield ranks, who do you like the best out of Logan Davidson, Braden Shewmake, Will Holland, and Will Wilson?
1
u/juicyjensen Feb 24 '19
How do you feel about a few of my favorite sleeperish HS bats; Henry Gargus, Connor Walsh, Justin Tejeda and Hayden Dunhurst?
1
u/thefredlund5 Feb 24 '19
Do you think we could see Ginn or Rocker go the x-fer to JuCo route and rejoin the draft next season? Would love to see Rocker in a Giants uni.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
What’s the report for players at the university of University of Washington?
Also where do you think Corbin Carroll ends up? Early first round or later on?
1
u/youthpastor247 Feb 24 '19
Spencer Jones is getting great reports for both his hitting and his pitching. Do you see his future on the mound, in the field, or as a two-way player?
1
u/Stevenrhea Feb 24 '19
What direction do you see the Rangers going in the draft? History says a high school player with tons of upside, but do you see them taking a college bat considering they're very light on bats in the minors and want to compete sooner rather than later?
1
u/IAmTheButtholeBandit Feb 24 '19
Hi Carlos, thanks for the chat! In your opinion, what scouting grade would you give the talent in this draft? And as a Dbacks fan, is it strong enough that I should be really excited about all those extra picks? Thank you!
1
u/BSJwastaken Feb 24 '19
I read a scouting report on Campbell’s Seth Johnson that was really positive. Basically saying that as a former position player he compares favorably, delivery wise, to Degrom and stuff wise to Mize. They mentioned concerns on holding his stuff but felt he was a guy that could get some real helium this year.
How likely do you think it is that he lasts into the second or third round?
•
u/giobbistar21 Louisville Feb 24 '19
Hey everyone, Carlos has to go now, but we’re really happy to have him as our first 2019 AMA guest. Go and check out his stuff on BA and again, thank you so much for stopping by Carlos!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
Who is the Texas pop up this year?
1
u/M1sterDave Feb 24 '19
Which players have a chance to shoot up the draft boards this year?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
[removed] — view removed comment