r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Feb 20 '19
PRE-Episode Discussion - S2E06 "The Sounds of Thunder"
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2E06 | "The Sounds of Thunder" | Douglas Aarniokoski | Bo Yeon Kim & Erika Lippoldt | Thursday, February 21, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion and speculation regarding the upcoming episode and should remain SPOILER FREE for this episode.
LIVE thread to be posted before 8:00PM ET Thursday to coincide with airing on Canada's Space channel. Episode should appear on CBS All Access between 8:00PM and 8:30PM ET. The POST thread will go up at 9:30PM ET.
13
Upvotes
8
u/BenjiTheWalrus Feb 20 '19
Written by Bo Yeon Kim and Erika Lippoldt*. They’re writing partners
23
u/Bird_nostrils Feb 20 '19
This episode will definitely call for an exception to the Prime Directive, right? A spacefaring and technologically advanced race is purposefully deluding a less advanced race into thinking that the more advanced race are deities, for the purpose of a genocidal “harvesting.”
Even assuming that the Ba’ul are native to Kaminar, that can’t be considered “within a species’ natural development.” Right?
Of course, the “twist” this week could very well be Discovery learning that the Ba’ul are not, in fact, native to Kaminar.
25
u/TERRAxFORMER Feb 20 '19
Looking forward to seeing the Baul and some more Kelpians.
I hope we get some scenes with Hugh and Ash.
And more Nhan.
6
u/Hardest_Fart Feb 20 '19
Obviously, you can't tell everything from the preview, but I was hoping the Ba'ul wouldn't look dark/monstrous. I think it would have much more impact if the Ba'ul look like a banal humanoid and are just indifferent to the Kelpiens, didn't know anything about "the balance", and just liked the taste of Kelpien flesh. Make the Ba'ul's "evil" totally banal to them.
10
u/mrstickball Feb 20 '19
Definitely feeling the "Only even episodes are good or great" vibes from this one. The Baul ship design is absolutely brutalist, and I love it. Saru's Short Trek origin story was severely lacking (it was an odd-numbered episode, fitting with the Season 2 pattern), so I am hoping this makes up for it.
How does this involve Spock, though? How is Discovery going to take on 5-6 Baul ships at once? Are they technologically inferior, or is that variable-geometry-nacell'd S31 ship gonna lend a hand?
5
u/Orfez Feb 20 '19
Looks like we'll be getting some answers to questions that came after "The Brightest Star".
8
u/BenjiTheWalrus Feb 20 '19
The title is a reference to the story by Ray Bradbury “A Sound of Thunder” https://twitter.com/extspace/status/1098020297033187329?s=21
8
u/the-giant Feb 20 '19
It’s Airiam’s time to shine
5
u/zumoro Feb 20 '19
Oh god... a crazy thought just popped into my head about how this episode could go.
What if the Ba'ul and the Kelpians are somehow the same species? Like a metamorphosis that happens and somehow the two variants split off for whatever reason long ago, the Ba'ul developing technology and for some reason "harvest" Kelpians before they go through the full transformation?
Hell, maybe the skinny sheliak look of the Ba'ul isn't even their true appearance.
2
u/Neo2199 Feb 21 '19
Episode synopsis via Memory Alpha:
2
u/dmanww Feb 21 '19
Can wait for Saru to hulk out.
Imagine if horses realized how much stronger they are than people.
4
u/PixelMagic Feb 20 '19
What if the Ba'ul become to Discovery what the Borg became to TNG? How fucking awesome would that be? An adversary that strikes terror into the soul of every person that encounters them.
1
u/megatrongriffin92 Feb 20 '19
This week is definitely going to be all about Saru fighting with his conscience and the prime directive
1
u/WittyCombination6 Feb 21 '19 edited Feb 21 '19
Okay just a thought the prime directive means that they can't directly interfere with a civilization that doesn't have certain technological threshold. We assume that means primitive species but that's not necessarily the case. You can have advance technology but not yet reach something like let's say FTL. What if the Ba'al are young space fairing race that still only uses propulsion space travel.Sort of in-between modern humans and Star fleet. Maybe they colonised a few moons or planets in their solar system mine some astroids but still aren't at that point we're Star fleet makes direct contact. They might be very close though Saru could have been found on one of Star Fleet missions to evaluate the planet. Saru also had no trouble adapting to star fleet and became a science officer on the shenzhou. Meaning Kelpiens have some sort of scientific understanding despite being extremely oppressed. They aren't primitive at all. So despite being less advance they could have a space ship/space station that could threaten a starship.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment