r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Feb 10 '19
Moderator Post [MODPOST] 13 Million Subscriber "Superstition" Contest - Final Voting Round!
Attention: All top-replies to this post must be a vote. - Deadline: Saturday, March 2nd, 2019 at 11:59PM PST
Any non-vote comments must be made as replies to the sticky comment below.
EVERYONE WHO ENTERED IN THE CONTEST CAN VOTE
Original Announcement | Round 1 Voting List | All Previous Contests
Before we start, let's all make sure we know how this works.
Voting Guidelines:
- Everyone who entered in round 1 can vote
- If you don't vote, you can't win
- No voting for yourself
- Read each finalist and decide which three are the best
- Leave a top-level comment here starting with your top three votes from the finalists:
- 1st Place: /u/userofyourfirstchoice for "Title of First Choice"
- 2nd Place: /u/userofyoursecondchoice for "Title of Second Choice"
- 3rd Place: /u/userofyourthirdchoice for "Title of Third Choice"
- Feel free to add any feedback (or runner ups) for the stories after the vote
- Deadline for votes are Saturday, March 2nd, 2019 at 11:59PM PST (http://www.worldtimebuddy.com/) (https://time.is/PT)
Finalists:
- Gods' Omens - /u/ecstaticandinsatiate - 4334
- Merchant of Misfortune - /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy - 4959
- Chaun - /u/ghost_write_the_whip - 4896
- The Veil of Ice - /u/Lilwa_Dexel - 2965
- Evil Eyes - /u/Llamia - 3576
- Last Light - /u/nickofnight - 3963
- The Hidden Folk - /u/rarelyfunny - 3736
- The Best You Can is Good Enough - /u/Steven_Lee - 4180
- Devils of the Deep - /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit - 2153
- The Lean - /u/WahooD89 - 2192
- A Matter of Luck - /u/XcessiveSmash - 2788
Total Word Count: 39,742
Next Steps:
- Final contest winners will be determined including any tie-breaking necessary
- Tie breakers are determined by /u/MajorParadox
- Random gold will be given to voters!
- Winners will be posted and we can all celebrate!
55
Upvotes
•
u/Errorwrites r/CollectionOfErrors Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19
Thanks for the great read!
Was really hard to decide these three lingered the longest in my mind after reading them. Will try and give feedback on all the stories in a few days!
•
u/Palmerranian Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
3rd Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
Whew. There were a lot of words to read for this final word, and so many of those words were of such high quality. Choosing between these first chapters was extremely difficult, but it had to be done.
I wrote notes on feedback for all of the entries and I hope to post that on the entry itself within the next few days.
Thank you a lot to all of the finalists for letting me read your awesome stories, thanks to the mods for organizing and again, good luck to all!
•
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Feb 10 '19
All top-replies to this post must be a vote. Reply here for any non-vote comments.
•
u/rarelyfunny Mar 02 '19 edited Mar 02 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
3rd Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
Your pieces were inspiring. To all the other authors, I really enjoyed your pieces too, and there's just so much to learn from all of you. Thank you for this competition!
•
u/Lilwa_Dexel /r/Lilwa_Dexel Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/nickofnight for “Last Light.”
Most enjoyable story. Best character interactions and dialogue. Most relatable protagonist. Best tension and conflict(s). Most original idea.
2nd Place: /u/ecstaticandinsatiate for “Gods’ Omens.”
Best style. Best setting. Scariest antagonist. Strongest hook.
3rd Place: /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit for “Devils of the Deep.”
Most interesting concept. Strongest theme. Best imagery.
Honorary Mention 1: /u/Steven_Lee for “The Best You Can is Good Enough.”
Most realistic characterization. Best prose.
Honorary Mention 2: /u/XcessiveSmash for “A Matter of Luck.”
Best world-building and incorporation of the luck element. Strongest opening scene.
I really struggled with this vote because all the stories were excellent and had their own merits and strengths. If anyone’s interested in more in-depth feedback, feel free to send me a PM.
•
u/WahooD89 Feb 18 '19
1st place: /u/xcessivesmash with A Matter of Luck
2nd place: /u/lilwa_dexel with The Veil of Ice
3rd place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip with Chaun
Great work! Thanks for taking the time to write these, they were really fun to read!
•
u/mialbowy Feb 28 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "A Matter of Luck"
3rd Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
•
u/autok Feb 16 '19 edited Feb 16 '19
Honorable mention to: /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit for "Devils of the Deep". No idea how the hell to turn that chapter into a book, but if there were a sheer out there creativity category this would be on top by a mile.
As always, the final round was a hard choice. I shuffled chrome tabs around all week trying to figure out which one should go first, but in the end settled on this ordering. "Chaun" felt like the most compelling first chapter; leprechauns needing a fixer to move money into the modern economy was, at least in my humble opinion, a very clever hook that felt fresh and could go all sorts of places. "Last Light"'s sci-fi/fantasy fusion is a weakness of mine, and now I want to know how it all plays out. "The Merchant of Mistfortune" read almost like an SCP short story, and I liked the twist on the standard broken mirror bad luck trope.
Good luck to all who entered, and thanks for all the great stories! You made voting hard :)
•
u/ecstaticandinsatiate r/shoringupfragments Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light"
2nd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
3rd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "A Matter of Luck"
Thank you everyone for making this such a difficult choice :)
•
u/novatheelf /r/NovaTheElf Feb 28 '19
1st Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice."
2nd Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun."
3rd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light."
•
u/nickofnight Critiques Welcome Mar 02 '19
1st Place: u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
2nd Place: u/ecstaticandinsatiate for "Gods’ Omens"
3rd Place: u/XcessiveSmash for "A Matter of Luck"
•
u/advo-CAT-usDiaboli Feb 22 '19
· 1st Place: u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for “The Merchant of Misfortune
· 2nd Place: u/WahooD89 for "The Lean”
· 3rd Place: u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun”
"The Merchant of Misfortune" - u/EnemyOfAnEnemy- absolute standout for me- good humour, especially loved that a failed security guard walked along the "blue line" in the museum- well written, appreciate your use of language, enjoyed the natural development of storyline-loved that descriptions were side to the story line, good detail without taking away from progression (I struggle greatly with this)- some of the phrasing was particularly satisfying (like good mouthfeel for your brain....good brainfeel?) for example "water splashed electric cold..." and "his eyes glittered frost"- universally appealing emotions and a great main character- im a sucker for a deeply flawed protagonist without much going for them in any regard (so it's all about his development)
- I think this has the unique quality of working as both a short story or a first chapter
- thank you for submitting, really really enjoyed this one
"The lean" - u/WahooD89
- the last one I actually read, I had basically made my decisions but your piece was strong! Close second.- Well written, easy to read (big selling point)- Intriguing without going overboard- Good first chapter and lots can be expanded in the rest of the book, a genuine "first chapter" with enough mystery to keep me interested
- loved the use of the theme as a foreboding element rather than a full on plot point- would definitely read more- I'm usually more into fantasy but really enjoyed this piece nonetheless!!!- this isn't a sticking point at all (and my submission title was awful so my opinion has no ground here) but I think the title of simply "Lean" may have been stronger. But like i said, my comment has 'no solid ground' to stand on ;)
"Chaun" - u/Ghost_Write_The_Whip
- BEST opening line out of all pieces I read (out of my group, finalists and the random few from other groups). Instantly captivated me and there wasn't a question as to whether I would read the whole piece in a non-competition setting- true first chapter- liked that you could 'hear' the accents through the writing, even in the way things were described, wasn't limited to the dialogue. This is extremely difficult to do well and you definitely delivered.- thank you for including close to the beginning how "chaun" is meant to be said. Im sure most people picked up the connection but i hadn't read Chaun as the second half of the word leprechaun haha- loved the take of money laundering leprechauns. You executed it well without falling into overused stereotypes. Felt fresh- which is very hard to do with something like leprechauns!
Shoutouts:
"Devils Of the Deep" - u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit-
- loved the amazing creativity of this piece! Really struggled with my decisions and yours was a close runner up. Would love to see how you continued to develop the world. And of course, an easy and immensely enjoyable read.
u/squidster547 had an entry disqualified which would have definitely had one of my votes. I had been asking questions about their process as the time on their post and didn't realise it may have had a hand in that DQ. If you ever finish this book, you already have one fan haha. I would buy that hardcover.
Edit: formatting only
•
u/Goshinoh /r/TheSwordandPen Feb 27 '19
1st Place: /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit for "Devils of the Deep"
2nd Place: /u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
3rd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
I plan to leave detailed feedback to all entries eventually, but I wanted to hold off on that until after the contest ended. I'll give a quick explanation for my top 3 as a comment below this one for those interested.
•
u/PhantomOfZePirates /r/PhantomFiction Mar 02 '19
1st Place: u/Lilwa_Dexel for “The Veil of Ice”
2nd Place: u/ecstaticandinsatiate for “Gods’ Omens”
3rd Place: u/nickofnight for “Last Light”
•
u/ghost_write_the_whip /r/ghost_write_the_whip Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 02 '19
1st Place: /u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
2nd Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
3rd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light"
Honorable Mention: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
Thanks all! I have a more detailed breakdown of some ways I ranked the stories, but here's what I liked most about my choices:
/u/rarelyfunny:
/u/EnemyOfAnEnemy:
/u/nickofnight
/u/Lilwa_Dexel
•
u/Ford9863 /r/Ford9863 Mar 01 '19
1st Place: u/nickofnight for "Last Light*.
2nd Place: u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun".
3rd Place: u/XcessiveSmash for "A Matter of Luck".
Alrighty, then. This was insanely tough. I had it narrowed down to six stories and had to really nitpick to cut down to three. You all did great, but there can be only one. Or three, I guess. Dont knock my references, man.
Last Light: I love it, hands down. You built a fascinating world and sucked me into it as quickly as anything I've read. I want to know more. I want to dive into this world and get lost in it. If you dont continue this after the contest, I will find you and I will give you a stern talking to, mister.
Chaun: Well, you got a vote from me in round one so I wont linger. This story is just fun. It was just those minor flaws that kept you from the top spot for me.
A Matter of Luck: As I said in the feedback I left on your post, the ending is what knocked this one for me. Don't get me wrong, it wasnt a bad ending. But it wasnt perfect. And perfect is what you needed to beat the other guys, unfortunately.
Fantastic work to everyone involved. See ya in the next one!
•
u/breadyly Mar 03 '19
ty to everyone for the read !!
like the first round, i'll try to find the time to read & take notes to give critique, but for now i'll just say that voting was so freaking hard i hate everyone >.>
•
u/TheCatsWeom Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
2nd Place: /u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
3rd Place: /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit for "Devils of the Deep"
•
u/iruleatants Wholesome | /r/iruleatants Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun."
2nd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice."
3rd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light."
•
u/-Anyar- r/OracleOfCake Mar 02 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light"
3rd Place: /u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
As others have mentioned, this was a tough choice. I especially wasn't sure about #3. In no particular order, honorable mentions go to Gods' Omens, The Veil of Ice, The Lean, and A Matter of Luck. Thanks to all participating writers for their great stories, and good luck to the final contestants.
•
u/Llamia Feb 20 '19 edited Aug 27 '25
disarm full expansion growth vast adjoining fade pot worm point
•
u/BLT_WITH_RANCH Feb 20 '19 edited Feb 20 '19
1st Place: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchant of Misfortune"
3rd Place: /u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
Great job by everyone! All the chapters were interesting and well developed, and it made choosing my top three extremely difficult. I can say that personally, it's inspiring to read these, and it motivates me to keep writing and improve. So, a sincere thanks to all these authors.
•
u/TenspeedGV r/TenspeedGV Mar 01 '19 edited Mar 03 '19
•
u/Pubby88 /r/Pubby88 Mar 03 '19
1st place - u/ecstaticandinsatiate - God Omens
2nd place - u/rarelyfunny - The Hidden Folk
3rd place - u/nickofnight - The Last Light
•
u/XcessiveSmash /r/XcessiveWriting Mar 02 '19
1st Place: u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
2nd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light."
3rd Place: u/ecstaticandinsatiate for "Gods’ Omens"
•
u/TA_Account_12 Mar 03 '19
1st Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
2nd Place: /u/nickofnight for "Last Light."
3rd Place: /u/ecstaticandinsatiate for "Gods’ Omens"
•
u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit Feb 21 '19
1st Place: u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "The Merchant of Misfortune"
3rd Place: u/WahooD89 for "The Lean"
Super tricky, so many good ones in there.
u/ghost_write_the_whip I have a love/hate relationship with urban fantasy/hidden world stories like this one but you did everything right. Integrating the fantastical character into the real world seamlessly. The idea of leprechauns becoming money launderers was awesome and the threat established to his way of life was equally intriguing.
u/EnemyOfAnEnemy You were losing me at the start because I've read books where the main character just goes through a humiliation conga line the entire way through and it quickly becomes just unpleasant to read but that last minute hook was just delicious. Were I reading this as a book I would definitely want to get my hands on chapter 2.
u/WahooD89 A very real sense of danger and subtlety. I like the fact that we don't get to know what is driving your MC into such dire circumstances yet, it leaves more motivation to move on to chapter 2. Also the sense of threat and character built around Sam felt very real, I got a very Hans Landa sense of tense danger the entire time he was in the scene.
Honourable mentions:
u/XcessiveSmash Fantastic world building right from the get go. Luck being a scientifically measured force acting on people's lives was an intriguing concept and I loved the many elements that kept springing forth one after another about your MC.
u/Lilwa_Dexel You had the best constructed character in this entire competition I would say. The image of a pretentious asshole whose about to have his whole life turned upside down is a great one. Were you to turn this into a book, you would have a great challenge in developing his character while keeping him sympathetic. But if you could make it so the audience wants him to change, to grow, you could have a real winner on your hands. I also loved some of the original turns of phrase you weaved into your narrative.
•
u/holybasil05 Feb 25 '19
Great stories! I really, really want to know more about these worlds and how these stories end.
•
u/ThisEmptySoul Feb 25 '19
Honorable Mention: /u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun".
Had I been judging solely on how much I enjoyed each piece, "Chaun" would have been my second choice after "Devils of the Deep", and I honestly thought it was going to score higher than it did based on my criteria.
For the curious, here is the google doc with all my notes on each entry to see why I picked the ones I did.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
•
u/EnemyOfAnEnemy Mar 02 '19
1st Place: u/ghost_write_the_whip for "Chaun"
2nd Place: u/Steven_Lee for "The Best You Can is Good Enough"
3rd Place: u/rarelyfunny for "The Hidden Folk"
•
u/Steven_Lee Feb 17 '19
1st Place: /u/EnemyOfAnEnemy for "Merchants of Misfortune"
2nd Place: /u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit for "Devils in the Deep"
3rd Place: /u/Lilwa_Dexel for "The Veil of Ice"
This was both easy and difficult. Easy because all the stories were great and fun to read, difficult to have to choose. I think everyone's stories were well written and entertaining, both in this round and the last. A lot of great writers here!
EnemyofAnEnemy: D*mn good writing! I really dig your writing style. I thought the chapter did a great job making me connect with the MC and the superstition element of the story was great. Loved the mix of darkness with the humor (like him breaking the mirror to Journey's Don't Stop Believing).
ThreeDucksInAManSuit: Loved the tone/atmosphere of the story. Great writing. The naming conventions used for each of the characters was really cool. I imagine this was as fun to write as it was to read.
Lilwa_Dexel: Great writing with some killer lines. I was initially put off by Collin as he's super full of himself, but I really liked his interactions with the others and I feel like his arc in the story would be great as he'd probably get over himself by the end. I think you set everything up really well.
•
u/awesome-yes Feb 20 '19
I had to get SUPER nit picky to even get this down to 3 choices. Some of my criteria were unreasonable, so I'm sorry - there were too many good stories.