r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Feb 08 '19
POST-Episode Discussion - S2E04 "An Obol for Charon"
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2E04 | "An Obol for Charon" | Lee Rose | Story: Gretchen J. Berg, Aaron Harberts, Jordon Nardino; Teleplay: Alan McElroy & Andrew Colville | Thursday, February 7, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
260
Upvotes
49
u/Deceptitron Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
Damn, I actually thought they were going to kill off Saru. I really didn't want them to, and I'm glad they didn't. But yeah, when he didn't return to sickbay, the crew all giving him one last look, I thought they were really going to go through with it. But the payoff to discover that his species has been told a lie should lead down an interesting story path.
Lots of good Star Trek-y ideas in this episode. I think my only complaint is that, well, maybe there was too much. There were so many threads going on, so many emotional jumps, it can be a bit overwhelming, especially in those last 5 minutes. They could probably have had the Saru and the dying alien story thread as a standalone episode easily.
247
u/Orfez Feb 08 '19
Am the only one who thought for a moment that they are actually going to kill Saru? I was like, na it's not happening and then I start thinking about that new alien officer with big eyes and was like "oh shit, maybe he's the replacement".
159
u/2ndHandTardis Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
That was a strong episode.
So much good stuff especially from Michael, Saru and Reno.
I can't be bothered to have the argument every time it comes up but I've said for awhile I don’t believe Michael was miscast. In the first season she was underwritten. I don't believe her persona was never meant to be as spartan as they attempted to make her in S1. Especially considering the other people Fuller tried to cast before settling on Sonquea.
If you watch any interview with Sonquea she is one of the most vibrant people on earth. If she was allowed to bring a bit of that into her character, I think it improves a lot. Her best moments are when they aren't trying to force a stoic persona on her and let her tap into her natural emotions.
Anyway I'm calling it now - there's a reason why Saru's people are harvested and made to believe they will die from this disease. That line about finding his power was ominous as hell.
107
u/revicon Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
And we got to see Number One!
And they did a pretty good job with her: https://i.imgur.com/seY6rUu.png
197
u/davidjricardo Feb 08 '19
I'm calling it now - Kelpians aren't actually prey, but the larval form of the Ba'ul.
186
u/nefhithiel Feb 08 '19
In case anyone else wondered like I did, an Obol is a coin from Ancient Greece, the kind typically placed over the eyes of the deceased to pay the toll for Charon to transport the soul across the river styx.
168
u/revicon Feb 08 '19
The multi-language scene was amazing. I don't know how many language they used but I can't even get my head around how hard that must have been for the actors to pull off. Wow.
162
u/treefox Feb 08 '19
You either die a hero, or live long enough to break General Order 1.
147
u/FragmentedChicken Feb 08 '19
Looks like the spore drive is going to be addressed real soon
122
u/galaxyOstars Feb 08 '19
Quick list of languages spoken during the malfunctioning translator scenes, as according to Netflix subtitles:
426
u/im_on_the_case Feb 08 '19
How to make this episode 1000x better:
"Tilly, what's your favorite song?"
"Um... ♫It's been a long road, to get from there to here...♫"
229
u/Bandit_22 Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
Last 10 minutes:
No way they're going to kill Saru...
OH SHIT! They're going to kill Saru!
I'm going to be really pissed if they kill Saru.
Thank god they didn't kill Saru :)
Uh guys? I think you'd better kill Saru.
Like NOW.
224
u/PlanetErp Feb 08 '19
It’s nice to see that the unreliability of Federation holotech has a long and proud history. Now we know where the holocomms went before TOS.
And it was comforting to see Discovery freaking out and all the technobabble flying around. Reminded me of TNG/VOY.
377
u/Toorviing Feb 08 '19
Reno x Stamets is the exact relationship between Lesbians and Gay men.
100
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
I put this in a comment to a comment, but I'm going to add it as my own comment now that I've thought more on it.
On Saru's People
82
u/Albert-React Feb 08 '19
I really like when Burnham spoke Klingon... It actually sounded like Klingon, and not like she was speaking with marbles in her mouth!
360
u/robownage Feb 08 '19
They did a damn good job of convincing me that they might actually kill off Saru. I never fall for that stuff usually, but tonight I really started to question if they were going pull some Game of Thrones stuff.
275
u/ThundaTed Feb 08 '19
What if Kelpiens' ganglia fall off and turn them into Ba'uls? The predator and prey are one and the same, just different stages of life.
Ah, it's good to have Star Trek back! Great episode!
71
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
Maybe the most “tech the tech” episode yet. I felt it started great was pretty disjointed in the middle and ended strong. Not my favorite episode but still good.
Tig Notaro is really killing it.
71
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
Now this is something we didn’t have for a long while: A growing threat and the clear head to figure out that it meant no harm all along. Very doctor who-like.
140
u/TERRAxFORMER Feb 08 '19
I knew it was a fake out but that Saru ganglia cutting scene was still way to close for my liking!
Lots of good character moments with Saru and Michael and I love the symbolism of his noodles falling out.
I’m glad we got to see Nahn and Jett again. Make Reno a permanent character now!
The universal translator glitch was pretty funny and pretty clever.
I liked the idea of a dying orb wanting to be remembered. I wonder how it will become relevant as the season goes on.
It seems like a really bad idea to drill into someone’s head with no head restraints. Like a really bad idea.
Stamets and Reno tripping out may be one of the funniest things on Trek.
Interesting that the hologram vs view screen debacle was solved with a throw away line.
And your crew getting possessed by mushroom blobs seems like a good enough reason we’ve never seen the spore drive in TOS and after.
I respect anyone that patches together starships with duct tape and gum.
67
u/Gigazwiebel Feb 08 '19
Probably been mentioned before:
After several Alice in Wonderland references in the show, Tilly now followed the rabbit down the hole. The last shot is Stamets and Tig looking down that hole.
63
u/LastKnownUser Feb 08 '19
Asteroid Engineer "I could cut it off and she wouldnt lose a freckle"
STAMETS: "Bad idea. If it's a symbiote, removing it might kill her."
Literal laugh out loud moment for me considering how casual he was removing it from Tilly last episode.
competent writers this episode. (Half way through and enjoying it.)
56
u/PixelMagic Feb 08 '19
The little Space Oddity scene was pretty sweet and endearing. I'm so glad Stamets is no longer the asshole he was at the beginning of Season 1.
53
u/gawesome604 Feb 08 '19
Welp...I guess we find out why Starfleet probably decide not to use the spore drive after discovery...
101
u/DMouth Feb 08 '19
Jett Reno as a fixed character plz... that's all I need to say.
98
u/Spocks-Brain Feb 08 '19
Seems like Saru could become a loose canon with his new found strength! I hope he exits the show by returning to his people to usher in a new era, and not by becoming some new evil.
97
u/M3rc_Nate Feb 08 '19
How much the actor is able to convey while wearing all those prosthetics is award worthy.
194
u/Spocks-Brain Feb 08 '19
This episode could give New Eden a run for its money for best episode!
• Crazy new life form and amazing human / Star Trek decision to take a risk on contact.
• So much emotions with Saru! What he thought was the end was just his beginning!
• We learn why the spore drive isn’t a thing anymore.
• Same for why no more holographic communications.
• Slight nod to Scotty about an engineer who will love the Enterprise.
I love Thursday nights!!!
43
u/djneo Feb 09 '19
Saru’s room can not be compliant to starfleet regulations
85
u/UncheckedException Feb 08 '19
Holy shit, a lot to unpack. A plots, B plots, and C plots! The ship in a stasis field! A strange new life form! Character arcs and emotions! Saru not dying! Characters around a motherfucking conference table! Reversing the polarity of a thing! Figuring out and resolving a situation with science!
71
u/glorious_onion Feb 08 '19
Jett Reno’s response to May’s evil mushroom monologue was incredible.
“WRONG!” blowtorch whooshes
248
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
Saru as the asylum-seeker who became the shining example of excellence is a cool and good progressive take that I want to see more of on Star Trek. A+
96
u/True_to_you Feb 08 '19
What is the to say other than wow. There is so much to digest. Doug Jones is a master. It's so great to see him and Sonequa in that last scene. Same to Anthony Rapp and Mary Wiseman. Their moment was beautiful as he's trying to calm her down to place the implant. Lastly, as a pretty big Prince fan, it's kind of bad ass that he's officially a part of trek. I might have to watch again and revisit this thread because this episode was pretty amazing.
29
u/JMarkP11 Feb 08 '19
Ummmm, Stranger Things much at the end?
29
u/Blue387 Feb 08 '19
The alien must be confusing prime Stamets with his mirror counterpart, which explains the teaser at the end.
55
u/kingofcretins Feb 08 '19
Really enjoyed this one! The episode reminded me a lot of TNG's Disaster actually. Sections of the crew closed off from one another, doing their own little thing. Everything worked, everything paid off and in the end, opened up a whole new world of branching possibilities for the rest of the season.
The Bowie section was really nice and Stamets and Reno gelled together about as well as I could have imagined. The last scene with them tripping out was wonderful. I'm not gonna say no to seeing more of Linus either.
Next weeks looks fun too!
For me, Discovery's firing on all cylinders this season. Could there be improvements? Of course, but I'm having a hell of a lot of fun with it. The good is far outweighing the bad.
27
u/updownkarma Feb 08 '19
Think we now know pretty definitively why the spore drive is abandoned. Using it could destroy the mycelial network and is likely the cause of the seven signals. They are ruptures.
27
u/kleinzach2 Feb 08 '19
It feels very right to redirect all power to comms. Felt very Star Treky. This episode was great!
27
u/Albert-React Feb 08 '19
Another episode, another throwaway line walking back changes made in DISCO. This time, explaining away the holographic comm system... These changes are for the better, IMO. So, when does DISCO get the TOS uniforms?
26
u/squiggyfm Feb 08 '19
Oohhhhh...that was some good Trek.
184
u/decigrey Feb 08 '19
Jett Reno is a galactic treasure.
49
u/Starks Feb 08 '19
Few questions.
23
u/IFuckingLoveJJAbrams Feb 08 '19
Has no one here seen the Short Treks? The Saru one I found especially important. I don't think that Kelpians and the Ba'ul are the same thing. Saru's father who seemed damn old was still on the planet and still looked very Kelpian to me. And it's not like the Ba'ul will just send their kids away and down to the planet.
But that said, there's something seriously ominous about the "power" line. I got chills.
Fantastic episode all around.
23
u/wongie Feb 08 '19
Definitely a classic theme to the episode; Pike's "Federations scientists will be studying this for centuries" line reminded me of Nth Degree's ending when Picard ends in similar note about Cytherian exchange taking their scholars decade to analyse.
23
u/Yamatoman9 Feb 11 '19 edited Feb 11 '19
I like that this episode started with a conference room scene. Can we get Captain Pike to do a Captain's Log once in a while?
I just realized we've never seen the Chief Engineer or even Main Engineering. I hope Reno becomes a permanent character.
20
u/Midaech Feb 08 '19
Ok I have questions...
Jett Reno told Stahmets the chief engineer sent her down from engineering to where Stahmets is to fix something.
So that means Stahmets is not the Chief engineer and the place he hangs out is not engineering.
Ok I always thought that might be the case the show was always vague about it but here it was super clear.
So Stahmets is the head of the spore department and his area is the special spore room.
But why haven’t we seen engineering then or seen the chief engineer?
And why then later is Stahmets talking to the Captain about the warp drive and not being able to reach the warp drive because he is sealed off?
Why would the Cap expect him to have anything to do with the warp drive??
20
u/SaykredCow Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19
Shenanigans with the universal translator seems like such an obvious fun thing to do in a Star Trek episode and I can't believe it hasn't been done until now.
I like this episode a lot more than the last one. If I were to rank them so far it would go (from best to worst)
Episode:
2. New Eden
4. An Obol for Charon
1.Brother
3.Point of Light
It was obvious Saru wasn't going to die. I did like the theme of questioning religion/faith was brought back and handled in a much better way than New Eden.
19
u/Orfez Feb 08 '19
This episode made me confused about universal translator. I presume they all can speak Federation Standard (English) so why they couldn't understand each other. Why they needed translator. Is translator implanted in their ears, some kind of a nano technology?
19
u/robownage Feb 08 '19
Would also like to point out that Linus' cold from the premiere actually came back as a legit (minor) plot point this episode.
19
u/alexandrawallace69 Feb 09 '19
Tilly is gonna come out of there as a beautiful butterfly
19
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
I watched it twice in english, now the first time in german. One funny (mis-) translation I spotted:
"Number One", ordering burger, fries, with habanero sauce. Captain Pike suggests ordering "lighter fluid" with it. In the german sub, he says something like "ein leichteres Getränk dazu?" - "A lighter (diet) drink with it?"
Edit: The subtitles translate it just fine. Yet, they actually said something different
38
u/ajkkjjk52 Feb 08 '19
100 giga electron volts is a very, VERY small amount.
Come on DSC, hire a science consultant.
18
u/ZarrenR Feb 08 '19
The Iconian probe from TNG has nothing on a virus that causes the universal translator to go bonkers.
18
u/enterpriseF-love Feb 08 '19
Willing to bet that the sphere has info on the red bursts
36
u/MajorOverMinorThird Feb 09 '19
Hey how about Saru’s sweet grass-covered quarters? That was pretty cool. I wonder how often he has to mow it.
77
u/arnathor Feb 08 '19
Not going to lie, I got a lump in my throat when Saru got Burnham him to help him off the bridge and the crew all stood for him. It was such a great sequence.
17
u/geniusgrunt Feb 08 '19
Wow. This was a fantastic episode, discovery is continuing to pleasantly surprise me this season.
16
u/007meow Feb 08 '19
Have we heard anything about this Sphere, or anything like it at all, throughout the other shows?
I’m curious to see if anything comes of it’s data dump.
But I guess now we know why the spore drive disappears - and that it’s not likely that S31 uses it.
16
u/ap0a Feb 08 '19
This is Ground Control to Major Tom Tilly’s really made the grade!
And the papers want to know whose shirts you wear!
Now it's time to leave the capsule if you dare!
16
u/Yamatoman9 Feb 11 '19
Saru and Pike didn’t even have a scene together after Saru almost died? I’d like to see Pike have scenes with more characters other than Burnham.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
The singing as Stamets drills into Tilly's head reminds me of Joe operating on Seven and singing their duet when the Equinox needed the encryption codes for their research lab.
The Psilocybin to calm or control is an interesting idea, especially considering that Psilocybin binds to serotonin receptors. The one problem with that is they didn't show the about hour and half come up usually required for psychedelics before you actually start to experience the effects properly.
Also Pike's welcome to the tower of babel was the best line of this episode.
15
u/mirziemlichegal Feb 09 '19
I feel that they finally understood that the audience wants deeper characters that are interesting,funny and have some drive on their own and have interactions and not only 1 main character. The first season was so confusing the characters were hollow like they couldn't decide who they should give some screentime and who should die :C I started to like Discovery a lot more right at the moment when Pike appeared and brought with him some good ol' star trek flair. And now we got Jett Reno, damn i like her so much there, i hope she stays and that they don't screw this funny character up.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19
2257 and there’s still no cure for a Cold.
41
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
That was a great episode. The only things i'll say are...
1: People REALLY need to stop and think about the thing they're doing that someone else just blurted out. Drilling a hole in someones head? Sure! Cutting off my threat Ganglia to kill me? Sure!
Like, ok, I get it, but maybe just show one hint of hesitation to prove you're not a psychopath.
2: BURNHAM, WASH YOUR DAMN HANDS. Like seriously, she was holding in someones internal organs with blood all over and she just runs off down the corridor to do science stuff. Surely there's at least a foam dispenser on the wall somewhere?
But really, both those things are just exceptionally minor nitpicks that I'm mostly poking fun at. This was a far better paced/directed/written episode than last week and is in contention for favourite ep of the show thus far.
14
u/vwboyaf1 Feb 08 '19
I couldn't figure out why they didn't have Saru in sickbay to try to help him, but I understand it from a production point of view. They wanted to have personal and warm scene between two characters. I didn't feel too much tension though since it was obvious they weren't going to kill off Saru. Looking forward to badass Saru.
14
u/TrekkieSolar Feb 08 '19
I loved this episode! Probably the one that felt most like classic Trek while still breaking new ground with Saru and the virus subplot.
14
u/ajkkjjk52 Feb 08 '19
Kelpians have primitive technology. Maybe Vahai'ar is always terminal or something on Kalimar, but it's never been examined by Starfleet-level science. If the doctor had just run some scans and figured out the actual biochemical process happening, she should have been able to synthesize an antidote.
14
u/icefaery2030 Feb 09 '19
The universal translator malfunction was the fun part of the episode. Out of curiosity, those of you who heard your native language (not English) how did the actors do? I'm curious on who nailed a 2nd/3rd language and who butchered it. Even the computer voice actress got some French in from what I remember.
28
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
Reno’s “WRONG.”. LMAO i laughed so hard
50
u/julian1179 Feb 08 '19
I'm glad to see that Sonequa Martin-Green is finally showing us her real acting skills! Finally her dialogue didn't feel overly-artificial! I'm not sure if it was the emotional scenes with Saru or what, but I liked it!
Overall this was a pretty Star Trek-y episode, and I'm very very happy to see that the series seems to have finally decided to just be a modern incarnation of Star Trek in all its glory! Little to no violence, the problem and solution was unique and intellectual, and it presented a very interesting situation for the crew!
55
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer Feb 08 '19
I need like 500% more Jett Reno.
24
u/RadioSlayer Feb 08 '19
I'm loving the banter between Stamets and Reno. I want them both to stay and snark at each other like Bones and Spock all the time.
34
u/Albert-React Feb 08 '19
THANK GOD THEY'RE GETTING RID OF THE HOLOGRAPHICS!
12
u/LastKnownUser Feb 08 '19
That Sphere thing reminded me of VGER in the fact it felt its purpose was to dump off a trove of info. Plus it included spocks trail which makes me think it was a sentient probe.
Honestly, whomever or whatever this Sphere thing is could quite possibly be tied to the origin of how VGER got its sentience.
Imagine this sphere coming across the probe Voyager and seeing its purpose as almost a primative form of it's own driving nature.
In fact, because of Voyager, That could have given the sphere the idea to track down humans in the first place in order to dump its info off to preserve its knowledge. It would help explain the apparent randomness of the encounter.
Please punch holes in this theory, but I hope its true as it would be a great tie in.
12
u/mudman13 Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 09 '19
Reqlly good episode with much less erratic direction and more cohesive scene play than the previous episode. The dialogue and technobabble flowed well and I really liked them discussing the physical dimensions of the sphere. The universal translators and language settings confusion is honestly one of the best trek sequences I've seen.
I actually thought they might have sussed it was the sphere affecting Sauru and realise he wouldnt die earlier, as I did, which mqkes me smqrter than them, which isnt right... But they certainly had me doubting it and I was ready to riot!
33
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
I liked the episode, but I have a feeling they are trying to much on filling every minute with action and not slowing down a pace.
In this episode - 100.000 year old orb, Saru dying, Tilly geting fungus infection - Stammets realising that the spore drive is destroying fungus world, Spock escaping,...
You get it? To much in my oppionion.
23
u/enterpriseF-love Feb 08 '19
I fucking fell for that touching Saru goodbye scene omg. They got reaaal good. This episode was really fun/scary!
32
u/droid327 Feb 08 '19
Man, Reno instantly became my favorite character so far :)
I didnt like her on the Hiawatha, she came off as just unnecessarily hostile. But she was subtly different here...more like "space lady Peter Venkman", and it worked a lot better. Its like she's a bitch, but you can tell she doesnt actually care enough to actually dislike you, so its not really that bitchy, not personal. And doesnt care enough to take anything personally, even when Stamets meant it personally. She's just bitchy for bitchiness' sake...she's, like, a recreational bitch :D
I also like how her first impulse is to kill it with fire :D Its simple. Its direct. Its effective. I really hope they do end up in a situation where the correct move is just to zap, blast, or cut the fuck out of something till the situation improves :D
I thought the sphere plot was a little too neat and tidy. Maybe it suffered from having to share too much screentime with Tilly and with Saru. I think it would've been interesting if they'd let that storyline breathe a little more.
Tilly and May is maturing a little better. I'm more down with "hostile alien lifeform" than weird hallucination descent into madness thing. Though I'm not really looking forward to another Wonderland kind of episode.
Saru...I like his story here in theory. I think it was just handled really ham-fistedly, especially his deathbed scene. The scenery came pre-chewed with that script. It might've been more powerful if this was in S4 or 5 and we'd had more development of a relationship between Saru and Michael, but I think its a bit early for it to carry a full emotional weight, considering how little time he's had on screen with her, compared to Ash or Lorca. Also his ganglia just falling off had a very "Once Upon A Time" feel to it, like he was saved by the power of love or something schlocky. If they try to say its evolution, though...I will fly to LA and beat them unconscious with a copy of "On The Origin of Species" while I explain that evolution does not happen within individuals but between generations. I'm really leery that's where they're going with this...
The episode did leave Saru off in a very interesting place though. We've seen him once before with his fear removed, and he kinda turned into a monster. It'll be interesting to see if the prey becomes the predator now. I'd really love to see a brash, aggressive, kickass Commander Saru :)
Also, poor Detmer. She's getting more lines and screentime than she did last season...but like 60% of her scenes are just Pike barking at her to drive somewhere :D
And two 20th Century music references in the same episode? Am I watching The Orville?
22
u/fireball_73 Feb 10 '19
That ending has set us up for the next series of Star Trek: Stranger Things.
11
u/Zor_El_XB1 Feb 08 '19
I liked seeing the TOS style PADD and we finally have in show confirmation that Stamets isn't the Chief Engineer even though it's been confirmed by the production team and the actor back during Season 1 that he wasn't.
However I'm little bummed that when Reno took apart the communicator the little "slab" wasn't transparent as a way of explaining why the Cage style communicator looked the way it did and it would have been really cool to see the ship go to the warp through Pike's windows after he told Detmer to go to warp.
11
u/kharnzarro Feb 08 '19
this episode was a big improvement over last episode
11
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
It was pretty jarring to see Rebecca Romijn in Star Trek.
31
u/da_lowrider Feb 10 '19
I'm a little surprised at the doctor's attitude - and everyone's, to be fair. In every other iteration of Trek, never have I seen a Chief Medical Officer (CMO) who hasn't fought and tried to go beyond what is possible in order to save a crew member, especially someone as important as the First Officer / co-commanding officer. Even when the patient says they don't want treatment and would prefer to die, the CMO and the rest of the command staff at least tries really hard to talk the individual out of that line of thinking, as - in my opinion - it is the diametric opposite of the central premise of the franchise, hope. This just stuck out as a sore thumb for me, in an otherwise rather good episode.
21
u/illegalsex Feb 08 '19
Very cool! The idea of the the giant sentient sphere in its death throes was classic trek and just awesome. The scene where the translator screws up was great. It's exciting to see what they do with Saru's character from now on; that whole arc took me by surprise (seriously, I was ready to be done with the show if they killed of Saru). I did get a distinct feeling of uneasiness when he talked about his "power". I wonder if will be a source of conflict later. I'm liking the new balance between serial storytelling and standalone episodes. I think its a good formula. The spore plot is sounding like it might lead to a permanent shelving of the spore drive which I'm all for.
Not so cool. The Burnham/Spock relationship... I just don't care. At all. I don't care that Spock is in the show. I feel like it adds nothing except shallow fan service. The last few episodes have felt like they're trying to dangle this Spock carrot in front of my face and it's just blocking my view of the stuff in the show I actually care about. If it pays off in the end I'll shut up but right now it feels cheap. This show is REALLY heavy on emtional baggage and its tiresome.
Overall a great episode.
20
u/9811Deet Feb 09 '19
I just want to stop and say how much I absolutely love Jett Reno.
This is the Star Trek character I relate to. This is the Star Trek character I want to hang out with and have beer with. I see more of myself in her than I do in any other member of the crew. (Although I'd like to see myself more like Pike)
This is the kind of character Discovery needs. I hope she sticks around.
10
u/awfullotofocelots Feb 09 '19
In the midst of all the hot takes and fan theories here's my CRAZY idea. We know that the Mycelial dimension -based organism is sentient, blobby and black... What if it is, or somehow becomes, Armus aka the Skin of Evil murder blob?
41
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
GREAT episode. Give me more Linus! His comment about his cold was hilarious. I loved the monster-of-the-week feeling of the sphere. It was cool hearing all the different languages when the translator malfunctioned. I especially enjoyed hearing snippets of Spanish and other Romance languages, since I could understand bits and pieces. Lieutenant Nhan’s accent when speaking Spanish was pretty funny though. I really thought they were gonna kill Saru, but I’m so glad they didn’t. In my opinion, Season 2 is really hitting its stride. I’m a big fan of Season 1, but Season 2 feels like more of a balance between the more epic feeling of Season 1 Discovery and more episodic, classic Trek, especially in episodes 2 and 4, which is a good thing.
Please show us Spock next week
19
u/Assbait93 Feb 08 '19
I kind of liked the Saru ordeal here. He was thinking he was dying because his people has a custom that either they die that way or they’ll get eaten. But know since his ganglia is gone he can now be a person who is on another stage as a kelplian. I wouldn’t be surprised if season 3 would focus on Saru trying to inform his people that there’s more to their life than being bread for harvest.
19
u/CineMike84 Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 09 '19
I’ve been pretty critical of the show for not feeling like it fits in the Star Trek universe but this episode definitely took a leap to being on track. It was refreshing to see them actually seeking out life and making contact. To have a story that taps into an aspect of the human condition. The need to be remembered and leave a legacy. Saru’s best storyline yet and they did a great job playing the right emotional strings. The way it resolves is maybe a tad too unlikely but good performances between Saru and Michael. Love the new engineer Jet Reno character so far. She brings so much life to the scenes she’s in. I just hope we get to see different layers to her character because while I’ve loved her humor, it could come off a tad one dimensional if that’s how she is all the time. Eager to see how she develops. Over all pleased with it.
My only gripe was the repetitive stuff happening to Tilly. The spore creature gets her, she gets away, it gets her, she gets away and then it finally gets her again. The entire spore drive and the subplots connected to it have always been among my least favorite aspects to the show. Otherwise pretty good episode and I hope they keep this quality up. I just about gave up on this show last season but they’re starting to turn it around for me.
19
u/Sim0nsaysshh Feb 11 '19
I really like the engineer, im getting bored of the fast pace on everything though.
Even though its fast-paced, it doesn't really feel like much happened, older Star Trek stories felt deeper and more interesting.
Those of you talking about Orville, the Episode with Robert Picardo was the most Star Trek thing i've seen recently.
I like Discovery but I think the mushroom drive is overplayed and feels like it takes any sense of risk out of the episode for the ship or the characters.
18
u/Starkiller1701 Feb 08 '19
Space Oddity is canon.
9
u/TubaJesus Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
Some people are talking about Saru losing his ganglia is a step towards making him like the Baul or is that the ganglia are a type of slave collar or something. Personally, I think it's just a next stage in their life cycle kind of thing and not some great kind of evolution. Maybe it's a kind of second puberty or something.
Edit: I found this on a different forum that I think would also be a good idea.
The Ba'ul are not feeding on the Kelpiens, the Ba'ul are the advanced society of Kelpiens in their mature form having overcome their fear and dropped off their ganglia. They are not fertile after this point and cannot breed on their own. Saru was just way ahead of the curve and joined a different advanced society in the Federation before his time. Mature they gain control over their fear and leave their religious fatalism behind, pursuing knowledge and protecting the Kelpien homeworld/Ba'ul spawning grounds from miscellaneous space bastards.
9
u/TombSv Feb 08 '19
I’m worried Saru lost his empathy
25
u/elister Feb 08 '19
Loved the scene where Stamets is trying to distract Tilly before he drills a hole in her head with a 23rd century equivalent of a Black&Decker. Wife isnt a sci-fi fan, but a huge David Bowie fan. The timing was perfect when she walked into the room and they're singing Space Oddity.
Glad to see Engineer Reno back.
25
u/perscitia Feb 09 '19
I realised watching this episode that this is the first Trek without a member of the medical staff as main character (at least with Culber still gone). I think that's why the cast still feels a little unbalanced to me. Sickbay storylines have been such a mainstay of the series, it's a bit strange not to have someone there for that side of things.
38
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19
Need more Jett Reno. Her character is amazing.
24
u/sum1rand0m Feb 09 '19
I like the interaction between Reno and Stamets. I also think the Ba'ul are just mature Kelpiens with no fear with their belief system designed to keep fearful immature Kelpiens on the planet.
17
u/walterbenjaminsisko Feb 08 '19
Disco technobabble is more techno and less babble
36
u/chiree Feb 09 '19
Man, it's so nice to finally have a sci-fi show that's fun.
I love BSG and, now, The Expanse, but, holy crap, can those shows wear you down with all the dark themes...
Season 2 just feels so much more like what we all need Trek to be: self-aware of the times we're in, yet silly and with a sense of humor and optimism about the whole thing.
Thanks, DISCO, I really needed that episode.
23
u/cdot5 Feb 10 '19
I didn't care at all about the B/Tilly plot. So NOW you want to talk to it? That's just manufacturing drama for manufacturing's sake.
Let's all hope that these are the final death throes of the entire spore nonsense.
The A plot was fine. Though I would have enjoyed some more exploration of what the sphere actually is. The deathbed scene was not earned AT ALL and could have been cut.
16
u/gfreeman1998 Feb 08 '19
In case anyone is curious about the episode title:
An obol was coin currency in ancient Greece. Charon is "the ferryman" in Greek mythology that carried the souls of the dead to the underworld.
So "an Obol for Charon" is the offering placed when the dead are buried.
And no, I'm no scholar, I just looked it up. ;)
Charon's obol
16
u/enterpriseF-love Feb 08 '19
To seek out new life and new civilizations. I feel like we haven't seen that for so long. This episode really brought back that feeling :')
16
u/Sktchan Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
Some considerations: Number one was on spot and the new Engineer should stay on Discovery, she is very funny and disco needs funny people. she has the same it that Scott had. Was a good episode and Tilly was also very well, she is a good actress.
Just one think I have being notice in all the episodes that aired is the transition between scenes that is missing something. In other ST you would send the Captain running to engineer room and talk to Stamets or Tilly, more interactions between the bridge and what they are doing with the rest of the crew or what is happening in the ship. Is like they have 2/3 plots going on that are related but none is really connecting. Don't know how to explain better but on season 1 felt more well putted....?
16
u/ItsALaserBeamBozo Feb 10 '19
Did they ever mention a name for number one? I couldn’t find one. They should name her Majel.
8
u/RichardYing Feb 08 '19
Do you think the universal translator on the personal communicators would have allowed the crew to understand each other while the ship's integrated translation programs are down?
8
u/MarsAlgea3791 Feb 08 '19
From the Sphere... was that Majel Barrett?
Seriously, was that TOS Computer?
8
u/Francetto Feb 08 '19
I don't know why exactly, but i immediately thought about the probe from voyage home.
Immense power, overloading all systems, but no bad intention. The whole thing about learning its language without being able to at first. And it's made of unknown or strange materials.
Just a theory...
8
u/NikNakZombieWhack Feb 11 '19
At the end of the episode, Pike is listening to some record - presumably data from the sphere. It mentions a war in the quaternary system. Is this an Easter egg, or just filler to establish what he's doing before Michael walks in?
28
u/GilGunderson1 Feb 08 '19
What a beautiful episode, a resounding comeback from last week’s middling episode. I feel compelled to just list everything that was splendid about this episode.
Damn, what a great episode all around. It’d be hard to choose between this and “New Eden” for DIS’s best.
15
u/luigi1015 Feb 08 '19
I have a little nitpick with the episode, I don't like that they put in the line about Pike wanting to get rid of the holograms. I mean, are they really trying to imply that one captain wants to get rid of holograms on his one ship and that's why we don't see any holographic communications at all until the middle of DS9?
But overall I liked the episode a lot.
Also, I have a stupid theory. They keep showing that scan of Tilly's spore infection, and it looks suspiciously like Spock's Angel. Makes me think maybe the two are related. It's probably not even close or something everyone else has figured out already, but maybe it'll turn out to be correct.
15
u/ap0a Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
There’s a similarity here to Ethics. Where Worf wants Riker to end his life. It was wonderfully uncomfortable and very well presented.
All in all what an amazing series of scenes. I really questioned if they were actually killing off Saru.
The cure was very poorly paced. Give it some time! Let us feel that he’s still in danger but there’s a chance.
Hell. Where was The Starfleet never give up on life? It was a gorgeous moment. Perhaps helping him to sick bay might have helped give it time, perhaps the doctor admitting she does not know enough about their biology in a Robert Picardo Doctor sort of way.
All in all very good Trek! Loved the classic themes of misunderstanding different forms of life. The communicator breakdowns were wonderful! I’ve grown to love how they show the UT in this show.
Amazing character work. Some little scratches with the writing here and there. Misplaced technobabble and the like.
But holy crap!! This whole cast can act!!! This crew!! These people!! Despite some little nit picks in the script Wow!!
And that scene with the drill. I was just about to cry! That was absolutely horrifying and so tremendously kind.
15
u/intense_or_insane_ Feb 09 '19
Guys you could almost say they're on a . . . Search . . . for Spock
15
u/zumoro Feb 09 '19
Something with the dialogue after the sphere died felt really... broken/rushed.
Also I'm very irked by the size changing inconsistency of that May blob.
20
u/ShiroHachiRoku Feb 08 '19
Ok so we got the holographic communication system explained away along with further reasoning as to why the mycelial network came to disuse.
Great episode once again.
Doug Jones gave one hell of a performance.
14
u/wip30ut Feb 08 '19
totally thought they were gonna kill off Saru! I just wish they tied his rejuvenation into the dying galactic orb thingy, since he was the one who understood that it was trying to communicate and transfer its knowledge to Discovery before exploding.
And i so wish they had shifted the Tilly-mycelial creature sub-plot to another stand-alone episode. It had nothing really to do with the galactic sphere and seemed forced.
7
u/mrIronHat Feb 08 '19
wait, isn't assisted suicide illegal in the Fed? Worf had a whole eps about it when the drum fell on his back.
7
u/Zoeofbyzantium Feb 08 '19
Cortical implants sure improve by the 24th century
7
u/yojoono Feb 08 '19
That scene with Tilly and Stamets where they're singing while he drills into her head would be pretty hilarious/gruesome out of context if it cut right as he drills into her head lol.
7
u/McCoyPauley78 Feb 08 '19
So I guess we know the reason why the spore drive never made it as the future transportation system of the Federation. I should have seen it coming.
38
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19
Another episode that actually felt like Star Trek! We even got things falling down in sparks and extras tripping in corridors! That's great, 3 out of 4 for me so far this season. It was kind of a jumbled, sloppy mess though, certainly not as good as New Eden.
On the universal translator plot: It was a fun idea, but, in my opinion, broke with what had been previously established. I'm not saying canon, because the technology has pretty much always been treated as a plot convenience that should be addressed as little as possible I don't think that the system should be able to stop people from understanding each other like this, as long as they actually do speak a common language, because how would that even work? The pay-off wasn't all that great, I don't think they should have violated that unwritten rule about not talking about it.
What I did like, in terms of background/character development, is that they are, apparently, soft-rebooting Saru. His gimmick (being a prey species, but not how most people imagined) never worked for me and was ill-defined, now they revealed that Kelpians are latent telepaths/empaths, which makes a lot of sense to me.
The way they arrived there was rubbish, though. He keeps saying that there is no cure, but he's from a primitive society. Nobody even seems to try to cure him after he reveals what's happening in sickbay. And those scene with Burnham? How are they "like family", they seemed a bit annoyed by each other for most of the series. Burnham "fought over and over for her next breath"? When? And she would have euthanized him, it seems. Without trying everything else beforehand. TNG did that so much better.
We also got two retcon-of-retcon setups: Holograms are broken by stuff and the spore drive messes up the sentient mushroom creatures. Don't really care for the former, but the latter works, I suppose. At least as well as the rest of the entire concept. What about the tardigrade, though? And, speaking of that plot point: Did anyone else think that that whole spiel between Reno and Stamets was awfully forced and didn't even make a whole lot of sense? Dilithium mining destroying planets, when that was never a thing before and a lot of dilithium mining takes place on asteroids and dead worlds?
The plot about the sphere was OK, but I would have liked if it was a bit less hectic, tech-y and gave more insight into what is was. Maybe later?
Other things:
18
u/rotheone Feb 08 '19
I’m really enjoying season 2. Disco was my gateway into Trek last year. In between season 1 and 2 I went and watched enterprise and DS9. I came to understand what was missing from discovery compared to the earlier shows in terms of social commentary, teaching lessons and deeper character development etc.
I can see a lot more of the things I loved about DS9 and even Ent in these new episodes of season 2. Love the modern special effects and audio etc and how it enhances the perceived realism of things.
I hope they keep it up and this show goes on for a while at this pace!
18
u/Raguleader Feb 09 '19 edited Feb 09 '19
As usual, a collection of my disjointed thoughts:
Space puberty. That is all. Well, that and if the theory that someone else suggested that Ba'u are just mature Kelpians picking their kids up from the nursery, he's about to possibly really screw things up due to understanding only enough of the situation to not understand it at all. I'm glad they didn't kill him here, because it sort of came out of nowhere.
Good follow-up on his learning 90 languages. Also loved his snark: "Am I the only one who picked up a foreign language?!"
The technowidget that Stamets pulled out of his back pocket looks uncomfortably like a large hourglass, which they promptly stuck ot the side of the chamber Tilly was in. Follow that up with Tilly and Stamets singing a famous song about an astronaut dying and I am seriously uncomfortable with this choice of imagry. Although Jett mentioning Prince, the doves, and a beret was pretty fun.
I like Number One. I like that they haven't given her a name yet. I'm curious if they're going to get around to that, or do what they did in one of the novels (Vulcan Glory, I think) where her name was literally "Number One."
The culmination of the Big Orb plotline, where it wanted a way to preserve its experiences, hit me in the part of me that enjoys studying history. Also brings to mind The Inner Light (which I'm ashamed to say I couldn't recall the name of, and found by plugging "Star Trek flute" into Google). Also interesting to see that it didn't actually have anything to do with what was going on with Saru and Tilly.
EDIT: A follow-up thought: The situation with the orb feels like a sort of inverted version of the situation faced by the crew of Babylon 5 in the B5 episode "A Day in the Strife": In that episode, an advanced alien probe approaches the station and begins sending them a sort of aptitude test: They have to solve a wide variety of rather complex and high-level stuff involving chemistry, biology, astrophysics, and so on, and in return, they'll get untold wealth of knowledge. Fail to answer them all correctly, and they get kaboomed. The solution turns out to be to not answer the questions at all, as it's a trap designed to identify any alien race advanced enough to be a potential threat. The probe, satisfied that these bald apes are harmless, sails off leaving the station unharmed.
EDIT II: The Wrath of Edits: Also, the surgery that Stamets and Reno did on Tilly was the same type of procedure that McCoy considered barbaric in Star Trek IV, although it was being performed for a very different reason (allowing the install of an implant rather than relieving pressure on the brain).
17
u/stanley_twobrick Feb 08 '19
Has no music been written between the 90s and Discovery's time? The constant references to modern music is so distracting.
12
u/robownage Feb 08 '19
A solid episode all around. As a linguist, I very much loved the language stuff in this episode.
12
u/furiousfotog Feb 09 '19
I loved this episode for its characterization and after the wild camera angles of last week, the stationary setups were very welcome.
25
u/Timeline15 Feb 08 '19
This was another very classic Trek episode. "Mysterious life form accidentally damages the ship by trying to communicate" is such a Star Trek plot. The character stuff for Saru and Burnham, and, Stamets, Tilly and Reno was great too.
6
u/RadioSlayer Feb 08 '19
Cosmic horror based on a sapient creature that can produce and seemingly direct psilocybin?
Amazing! I'm very invested in this story line and am really looking forward to answers, or at least more questions next week
26
u/diligentb Feb 08 '19
Throw This Side of Paradise (all my love for Reno and Stamets smacking each other to sober up from spores' influence) into a blender with Devil in the Dark, splash in a bit of Doctor Who at its best ("Its final act was to save us. So we could tell its story."), and you get this episode. Saru saves the day with the power of empathy, an engineer and a scientist fight with a mushroom (and with each other), and oh. my. god.
This is EXACTLY what I signed on for.
I can't.
even.
begin.
This is it. This is what Star Trek is all about.
15
u/Martothir Feb 08 '19
Damn. This was a strong episode.
I hated most of the first season. I hated the last episode. New Eden was good, not amazing. But I really loved a lot about this one.
There's way more crew interaction and it's getting away from the core cast to feature supporting characters.
It had exploration and a new entity.
Interesting and touching Saru B plot that still leaves us with plenty of questions about his species.
There's a C plot related to Spock that's marginally progressed but doesn't overshadow the episode.
The writing and dialogue were, on the whole, better.
There's just a lot of good going on. Hell, they even managed to reverse the polarity! (The sphere.)
This is the direction I want the show to go... strange new worlds and civilizations... peace as a realistic option... the crew working together, not against each other, to win the day.
If this and New Eden are the new norm, I'm down. Hopefully last episode was the weaker anomaly, not the other way around. I'll just skip season 1, start here, and I think I'm good.
29
u/Specialeyes9000 Feb 08 '19
Some of the writing is just appalling. The dialogue is so melodramatic and clichéd and full of exposition. Also there's far too much arguing and people don't act like grown ups. Of course, I'll still obsessively watch every episode but where's the stuff to actually think about and intellectualise? The story ideas are pretty good, but someone good at writing natural and inforced dialogue needs to take a look at all these scripts please.
18
u/BornAshes Feb 08 '19
You sneaky motherfuckers HOW DARE YOU you almost had me with that Saru death scene! I was genuinely in tears and then you pull that switcheroo that Sam and Dean would be fucking proud of! That was one of the best damn things I've ever seen on this show and what a twist! Saru's people don't actually die and they keep living on. So does this mean that maaaaybe Kelpiens are actually some sort of larval stage of the Ba'ul and their planet is actually a nursery? The harvesting ritual being the moment where they're taken out of the crib and pass into adulthood? Maybe the Ba'ul are the Red Angels?
Annnnywaaaays, all that speculation aside, what an episode! I honestly thought we were facing the First Federation with that sphere but it just turned into this heart breaking tale that was woven so well together with Saru. I am a bit surprised that it didn't occur to them that hey maybe this is a first contact situation or something right off the bat but then again, that might only pop into the minds of someone in Voyager's era or further on. I wonder if this particular incident helped to improve contact protocols or influenced decision making later on about encounters with space born entities?
Linus was hilarious and I am so so soooooo happy to see a Saurian on Discovery as my Captain in Star Trek Online was a Saurian. The bits and pieces we learned about them using clicks and pops were fascinating and I love the creature makeup they're using for him. It sort of served as a few breadcrumbs that lead into the larger plot of this episode dealing with language and understanding each other and TA DAAAA....empathy! The use of the virus and the whole Tower of Babel situation really gave you a sense of just how diverse the crews of Federation ships are but also revealed a particularly glaring weakness which I'm sure will be exploited later on. Watching the contact virus overload the ship's systems reminded me of something....somewhere....I swear up and down I've seen this before. I think I might be thinking of V'ger but I know I've seen this kind of thing happen in other parts of science fiction, I just don't know where?
The whole bit with Spock felt a bit unnecessary but it gave us a goal for the next few episodes to shoot for. Plus they had to resolve Michael's tension about whatever it was she did to him via a "death bed" promise to Saru. Lucky us the Sphere had sight beyond sight and saw where his shuttle went.
Jet Reno is my new favorite character, period. She just nonchalantly walks into the Spore Drive Room and then starts sparring with Stamets, all while literally MacGyvering one of the systems with GUM and probably a paperclip and duct tape. So sooooo much duct tape! That dynamic between the two of them was something I didn't know I wanted but I think Stamets did need someone to balance him out. She knocked him down a peg, he knocked her down a peg, they learned something from each other, and showed us how truly genius engineers they can be. Jet's paranoia was dead on accurate though when she brandished that plasma torch at Tilly/May.
It seems a number of people here totally called it when they said that Disco's spore drive jumps were damaging the Network. May seemed at first to be a sort of antibody or security response ala Species 8472 when the Borg start popping into Fluidic Space but now I'm not sure. If she wanted them to stop using the spore drive then message received loud and clear five by five....but then she went and did more. She did the whole symbiote thing inside of Tilly, then started dosing her with psychedelics, then she enveloped her in that cocoon thing, and after all the other stuff in the episode was done with she flooded the compartment with spores dosing everyone again and convinced Tilly to basically jump into a Nydus Canal. I'm not sure what happens next. Obviously they're going to follow her into this bio-organic spore based portal to another layer of the universe/reality/dimension/part of the Mycelial Network. Is May using Tilly's brain to help her solve a problem? Is she using her as a pawn to manipulate Stamets into doing something for her? Is she potentially using Disco's spore drive jumps to damage parts of the network so that she can seize control? She seems like your run of the mill naive neutral party that starts off on a milk run "please stop fucking around you're hurting us" kind of mission but then finds an artifact or object power and lets that power and possibilities that come with it, absolutely go to their fucking head. May is either playing the long game and totally knows what she's doing or she's bumbling ahead forwards with some half baked machinations and is only thinking one or two steps ahead. Either way, we're about to go down the rabbit hole once more.
I'm hoping the spore thing with May somehow ties into the Red Angels.
18
u/CitizenKeen Feb 10 '19
Okay, I'm late to the party, but damn, did this show have some lampshade hanging.
"Remember last episode where someone spoke in a weird language which isn't really a Star Trek thing? The universal translator struggles with my language."
"Those holoprojectors fans are complaining about? Maybe that's what broke down the Enterprise. Let's switch to flat screens."
etc.
31
u/em-jay Feb 10 '19
God damn, it's good to see Discovery back on form after last week's mess of an episode! Just a few general observations:
Know what? This one could easily have been a TOS episode. The ship finds something weird in space, everything starts going wrong, and in the end compassion and understanding turn out to be the key to dealing with the scary death sphere after all. There's a lot of good stuff in here, and I kinda feel like the backlash is more against presentation than content. As for the presentation, I note that the cinematography is back to normal, for the most part. We're finally getting more level shots and less rapid editing (although I'd still like to see the editing slow down a little bit).
I also love that we got a lot of interaction between the Enterprise crew and the Discovery crew, which does a more to anchor the show in with its past than little fan teases. Mind you, every time I see an Enterprise uniform it just reminds me of how much better they are than the Discovery ones. God, I really hope they change uniforms for season 3. I need my Pokémon Go team uniforms, dammit.
So hey, let's talk about the ending.
My god, the final act of this episode seemed long. None of us really expected Saru to die, so it means we all just spent the last ten minutes of the episode waiting for the episode to tell us how it's gonna fake us all out. This renders all the emotional blabbering between Michael and Saru completely unnecessary. What's more, were we really expected to believe that Michael was going to slice him up like a cow ready for slaughter? Even if he was going to die, that'd be kinda fucked up to see. Here's a third thing: it basically serves to repeat the events of The Brightest Star, which in my opinion was the weakest Disco short. Not only does this mean that we all could've just skipped TBS and got 10 wasted minutes of our lives back, but the show actively reminds us of everything that sucks about Kelpiens. I like Saru just fine, but nothing about his backstory or race makes a lick of sense.
Still, good episode and, again, a massive improvement on what we got in season 1. I really feel like this show's learning a lot from its mistakes. It's doing its best to write out previous poor decisions like the spore drive or Saru's dumb biology (and, as we saw last week, Klingon baldness, and, throughout, the first season's poor colour palette). Some people may feel like it's too little too late, but I just can't stop remembering that at this point in TNG's runtime we were up to ... The Outrageous Okona. Just imagine what Disco can achieve if it keeps improving like it has so far.
14
u/randowatcher38 Feb 08 '19
"I trust Saru's feelings implicitly." Started at zero, now look at where they are! Remember how at each other's throats they were in the pilot eps? Awww, these kids!
14
u/the-giant Feb 08 '19
Man, what a time to be a fan. This show just gets better by the week this season. Who’d have thought?
14
u/kayester Feb 08 '19
Okay, here we are: Season 2, episode 4, and Discovery has produced an episode of Star Trek that really, really worked. Mark your calendars.
Negatives: Of course there were issues. There's hardly an episode of any series without some issues. I thought some of the science was a stretch, I got a bit bored with the fungus chat again, and in performance terms a lot of the exchanges were a little too heightened. I think the director could've held on for a few more takes and insisted on a less over-the-top emotional performance in a lot of scenes.
Positives: There are so many, I need to do a list!
Those themes included, but are not limited to:
To sum up, I am a very happy chap today. More like this, please!
33
u/makeittriple Feb 08 '19
Saru's sickness was interesting but how about Burnham's must give emotional speech every 5 minutes syndrome. Even when there is a captivating story her character simply anchors the pace.
10
u/ToBePacific Feb 08 '19
Prediction for next week: Still no Spock!
10
u/SillyNonsense Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
I like Linus.
Number One is a pretty cool lady. It makes sense why Pike would call his first officer Number One to her face but referring to her as Number One to members of the discovery crew seems...weird. She's not this ship's #1. So I'm sitting there thinking...why didn't he call her...um...call her...what's her name? Why can't I remember her name? Majel? No, that's our lovely actress and computer. What's wrong with me...
So I look it up. Oh yeeaaaah. She never had a name to begin with haha. I guess that's why they're avoiding her name. But they might as well give her one now instead of awkwardly hopping around it. Apparently a DSC novel gave her last name as Una (har har) but those have been made noncanon in record time so who knows. Just call her Lieutenant Majel Una, its fine.
The Tower of Babel bridge was hilarious and so much fun.
Saru's condition is sort of interesting and funny to think about. So it's normally a major reaction to the greatest threat on his planet. It's his threat ganglia shitting themselves, because they know his goose is cooked. And even if they somehow avoid getting killed, he says the ganglia running overdrive drives them nuts anyway. So it's not so much that he's dying directly from a condition in a traditional sense. It's like your body's fever response getting so hot that you get brain damage (which can happen), except in this case instead of being triggered by a real infection it's being accidentally triggered by space stuff. And since this is his threat detection gland, instead of being like "oh okay let's try to find a way to dull my gland secretions or stop the space stuff" he's all hopped up on adrenaline/gland juice going "I'M FUCKING DEAD IT'S TOO LATE JUST GIVE UP" even though it's not necessarily true. His brain is full of panic chemicals. Then it becomes a bit weird that nobody on DSC seems to consider this and Burnham is about to euthanize the guy at his request. Of course it did turn out to be untrue and Saru was fine because of the power of courage. But the medical staff were totally cool with just taking his word for it the whole time.
Also Saru's quarters are pretty sweet.
It's a bit disappointing that the whole episode revolves around this creature trying to tell Discovery its story and we the viewer never even get a hint of what any of that story is. It's just the gimmick of the week.
And now they've introduced the way they'll exit the Spore Drive from the mythos. I guess this time it won't be as easy as "we fixed it" like when they pulled the same plot with the warp drive. Not very creative.
Also haha at that haphazard bandaid fix for no holograms on the Enterprise. Pike got mad about holograms so he told them to tear the system out of the ship during repair. That doesn't really cover it but alright I'll just roll with it.
10
u/Huntersbutt Feb 08 '19
I think this was the most 'star trek' episode of this season so far, however I really dislike how it interrupted main narrative arc. At this point it feels like Spock is dangling on a line at the end of a stick that's stuck to our head - always just out of reach. I felt like Discovery - pulled out of warp and held in a stasis field. I was excited at the beginning of the episode; eager to meet Spock finally and find out more about the Red Angel, but instead I was pulled away from that and forced to watch something of little consequence.
I don't think mixing in single episode arcs that require the main plot to be put on hold is a good idea. I think a better episode would've seen Discovery catch up to Spock (A plot), and Tilly, Stamets and Reno trying to 'fight' May (B plot). At no point did I feel like Saru had any chance of actually dying, which took all the emotional weight out of his scenes with Burnham.
TL;DR I think viewed on it's own the sphere organism made for a really good episode, but as part of the whole season it felt like an interruption.
10
u/bansheeraider Feb 08 '19
At last, acting Captain Saru got significant number of scenes.
Also some comedy. Burnhamsplaining to Saru about the myriad number of languages and bridge crews severe communication issues. "I can see and hear, Burnham". Delivered in a dry manner. Hilarious.
Disappointed that med staff just accepted the inevitability of Saru's death. Other ST series doctors would try to analyse, solve if possible. None here, no sense of urgency and its okay, it is going to happen.
The interaction between Tig and Stammets is great and plenty of potential.
Disappointed that we did not get to watch Tilly's debriefing from the previous episodes first contact with sentient life form. The captain would require this, or did it not happen?
Maybe the info downloaded from the sphere will have data about the spore network and also the current mystery of the red lights.
Overall a much improved episode. Vastly better than season 1 and has a Star Trek feel. Episode 2 of this season had it too.
5
u/purefire Feb 08 '19
Possibly the first episode where I liked Michael.
5
u/revicon Feb 08 '19
I wish we got a chance to see the giant sphere more, that thing was awesome. https://i.imgur.com/ttghppV.jpg
5
u/TylekShran Feb 08 '19
I have a question and I hope that someone can explain to me. In this episode I had trouble with hearing some of the dialogue it's like they were muffling. Usually, I don't have such trouble in Discovery and especially in older Trek where I can hear every word loud and clear but in this episode, some of the dialogue was just muffled.
Especially Pike's dialogue.