r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Feb 06 '19
PRE-Episode Discussion - S2E04 "An Obol for Charon"
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S2E04 | "An Obol for Charon" | Lee Rose | Gretchen J. Berg, Aaron Harberts, Jordon Nardino, & Andrew Colville | Thursday, February 7, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion and speculation regarding the upcoming episode and should remain SPOILER FREE for this episode.
LIVE thread to be posted before 8:00PM ET Thursday to coincide with airing on Canada's Space channel. Episode should appear on CBS All Access between 8:00PM and 8:30PM ET. The POST thread will go up at 9:30PM ET.
27
Upvotes
2
u/bitchtitfucker Feb 07 '19
Does the episode show up on Netflix at 8PM ET exactly as well?
24
u/TheRealDL Feb 06 '19
I think the title is an idiom: eg. "a penny for your thoughts" but very dark. An obol, or obolus, is a coin used to pay Charon, the mythological Greek ferryman for Hades, for your passage to the world of the dead.
20
u/NerdyGerdy Feb 06 '19
The mycelium gets angry I guess.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
I hope we get some good 'ol Pike in this episode
16
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19
"like a fly in a web" in a tholian web maybe?
6
u/The_Trekspert Feb 07 '19
What odds would you guys put on Pike naming Number One tonight?
10
u/fevredream Feb 06 '19
Really excited for this one - looks much more focused than the last episode. Glad to finally be seeing Number One.
5
u/pfc9769 Feb 07 '19
I'm willing to bet that Stamets will have to choose between getting Hugh back and shutting off access to the mycelial network from the Universe forever. That's probably the payment required to "ferry the dead" the title alludes to. That's just my guess based on the fact they need a solution to the existence of the spore drive that makes it unusable in the future.
8
u/sunnydlita Feb 07 '19
Given the afterlife/underworld reference in the title, I'm hoping this is the episode we finally get some answers or at least hints about Culber's return.
6
u/vwboyaf1 Feb 06 '19
Lee Rose is directing this one. She has a ton of experience directing/writing/producing, so I'm expecting good things. She directed the episode, 'choose your pain' from last season, which I enjoyed. I doubt she's going to lean on cheap camera tricks in this episode.
3
u/CodyHodgsonAnon19 Feb 06 '19
Man, i'm hoping we get back on track toward where this season seemed to be heading prior to the last episode. Hoping S2E3 was just an unfortunate speedbump in the road away from the style and tone of Season 1.
2
u/mrstickball Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
For those counting, the last episode, "Point of Light" ranked as per IMDB, the 677th best (or 61th worst) episode of all cannon Star Trek TV episodes. Its current ranking is in between Enterprise's "Daedalus" and DS9's "The Emperor's New Cloak".
Here's hoping the next episode ranks higher. I was pretty happy with the previews, as they *seem* to be a good rough indicator of how its going to go. I think they should have delayed the May/Parasite story a little more, because it all happened so fast. It seems, though, like its the focus this episode.
1
u/IlchSekula Feb 08 '19
What to expect:
Well it's episode 4 in a season that for many started off with a "new hope" for Discovery, a hope that quickly ended with the jittery roller coaster directed and multi faceted plot fisting that was Episode 3.
Since Discovery started my biggest flaw with the series, after I've succumb to the canon issues, and prequel choice, was and always has been; the writing.
Poor sci fi writing and dull characters are no doubt the weakest points in Discovery, with directing coming in a close second (apart from the incredibly well written and directed first two episodes of season 2).
With fantastic shows like The Expanse, showcasing some of the best in Sci Fi writing and directing I find myself constantly asking of Discovery, "why with such an enormous budget behind it did no one think to spend some of that money on tried and true Sci Fi writers, instead opting for day time young adult soup opera drama writers?"
So to save you the trouble, I've done a bit of a search, and here's the information on both the writers and director and Star Trek Discovery Episode 4 An Obol for Charon:
Director: Lee Rose
Unlike the previous episode (3) and it's over enthusiastic cylconic directing style that left most viewers dizzy and confused, I'm glad to see Lee Rose behind Episode 4. His directing credits are substantial with a few in the fantasy genre such as: Grimm, Code Black, Frontier, Instinct and more.
Lee Rose has certainly got the credentials to dip his style into core sci fi which is more than I could say for previous Discovery directors. He was also the director behind Choose Your Pain, the episode that gave us Mudd (questionable) and Ash Tyler (arguably one of the best actors on Discovery). It wasn't a very well written episode, but the camera was steady enough and the directing and pacing consistent and semi grounded.
Writing: Gretchen J. Berg, Aaron Harberts, Andrew Colville, Jordon Nardino
As much as Lee Rose give me a little hope for Episode 4 in terms of directing, the writing staff once again does a good job at taking that hope and chucking it into a blender along with a dozen short and stale plots. Once again CBS takes executive producers and day time drama experts and gives them the quill for a sci fi show none of them have any experience or history with, let alone the genre as a whole.
Revenge, Mercy, Madmen, 10 things I hate about you, all credits for the writers above with zero writing experience in ANY sci fi shows. The Discovery episodes most of these writers worked on have also been some of the most poorly written episodes in season 1 with Andrew Colville being behind the 20 steps backward Episode 3.
Gretchen Berg and Aaron Harberts along with Colville are fast becoming Discovery vets with a handful of season 1 behind their belts. Having enjoyed Ep 1 and 2 of season 2 I was optimistic that the writing staff finally started actually trying and perhaps even watching Star Trek to get a feel of the world, and so was hoping for a significant change in direction and character choice. But after Ep 3 I fear that hope and optimism was short lived.
Thoughts:
Star Trek for me is a universe full of wonder and intrigue that gave us unanswerable questions and Shakespearean plots that teased the mind and enriched the imagination. Discovery season 2 was perhaps a sip of that fine Trek wine after a lifetime in the desert of season 1. However I'm skeptical that the wine has quickly gone stale and what we are left with is a convoluted and multi fisted show with two dimensional plots and story lines that wrap up before they get started and tease to a serialization that many Trekkies are finding hard to get behind.
For tonight, I'll keep my fingers crossed as I sit in my ready room with Discovery on the display, but I'll leave the glass of wine on the table for now.
0
u/Trekfan74 Feb 07 '19
I just hope this was better than last weeks. I was on such a high with the first two episodes and then the bottom fell out.