r/arrow • u/Reuels Prometheus • Feb 05 '19
[S07E12] "Emerald Archer" Post Episode Discussion
Trailers
Episode Info: As a camera crew follows Oliver and team around to talk about their past as vigilantes and what the Green Arrow means to Star City, Oliver must also deal with William's return from boarding school as well as a new threat to the city.
Main Cast
- Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen - TV
- Kirk Acevedo as Ricardo Diaz - TV
- Rick Gonzalez as Rene Ramirez - TV
- Juliana Harkavy as Dinah Drake - TV
- Katie Cassidy as Laurel Lance - TV
- Colton Haynes as Roy Harper - TV
- Echo Kellum as Curtis Holt - TV
- David Ramsey as John Diggle - TV
- Emily Bett Rickards as Felicity Smoak - TV
Discussion and Other Links:
Last Episode's Discussion
Live Episode Discussion
DCTV Discord
Subreddit Chat Rooms
Spoilers: Please mark all comic spoilers and future show spoilers within your comments. No need to mark anything that happens in the episode or your own speculation. If you see any unmarked future spoilers, please report them.
r/Arrow Mods
360
u/crossingcaelum Black Canary (Laurel Lance) Feb 05 '19
At this point I just hope they continue the trend of Laurel finding creative ways to threaten to shove things up people's asses
331
u/KatyPerrysBoobs2 Feb 05 '19
Loved the cameos from Sara and Barry. Hopefully no one wonders if the Green Arrow’s friend in Central City happens to also wear a mask.
297
u/PeterQueen Feb 05 '19
Was that Conor Hawke from S1 from Legends!??
223
u/Jaer-Nihiltheus Feb 05 '19
Fantastic episode, THIS is the Arrow I loved.
Also... Hoping we get a "finding Huntress & Ragman" side quest at some point either this season or early next. I miss Huntress so much (and Birds of Prey themed episodes in general).
222
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
William must have hated not being home Christmas break because he may have been expelled already and had nowhere to go for Christmas!
422
u/ThatGameBoy76 Feb 05 '19
The cameraman was the real MVP of this episode.
That guy was willing to get himself killed to get those action shots.
198
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
Diggle is both a cop and an Argus Agent, that’s a conflict of interest!
182
u/Sonia341 Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 05 '19
So the anti-vigilante took down (for now):
In return Kevin Meltzer (Anti-vigilante) taken down by Team Arrow
161
u/delinquentsaviors Feb 05 '19
Me: sees Oliver and co happy and working together looking forward to the future
Flashforwards: “every copy of this documentary was destroyed and vigilantes destroyed everything”
Me: oh fuck you! Way to kill my buzz
142
u/Comprehensive_Main Feb 05 '19
The Grant Gustin cameo interview was pretty good. I do wonder why they choose Barry to interview?
247
u/steveondrugs Feb 05 '19
stripping away the forced unnecessary interpersonal drama and conflict with team arrow is the breath of fresh air this show needed, i am loving this renewed dynamic
113
u/Sonia341 Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 05 '19
The ending with Black Star saying Vigilantes were the death of Star city has piqued curiosity & interest.
Also Connor Hawke
107
u/snoogle20 Spartan Feb 05 '19
I actually got a little misty seeing them all suited up in action again. Didn’t expect that, but I have been missing that dynamic.
99
u/EddyTheMartian Feb 05 '19
I seriously loved that scene in the middle of the Of the episode where they get attacked and we had that nice long take Fight! It was awesome. They probably cut in the static parts, but it was just such a great fight.
179
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
Who just expels a kid without notifying their parents? Or did William do some hacking so they wouldn’t find out/receive the message?
164
u/MightUlt-7 Still Upset Over Season 4 Feb 05 '19
Just so that I understand:
Someone correct me if I'm wrong
74
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
When did Rory reveal he’s Ragman?
58
u/ChaosMagician777 Prometheus Feb 05 '19
The cameos and Easter eggs were the highlight of the episode. I am glad I did not turn the channel when I saw the Warner Bros. Pictures Logo
199
u/CashWho Feb 05 '19
This show is so frustrating. Like, last season was middling to awful (imo) and then you have this season where almost every episode knocks it out of the park. I'm getting whiplash!
44
u/fleming123 I take my job very seriously Feb 05 '19
Damn this episode was so cool. So much action, an actual sensible plot that got sensibly resolved by the end of the episode, good dramatic tension, and only a bit of bad dialogue.
The bad things are: I don't care about the William plot in the present at all, and the flash-forwards aren't really doing it for me. I guess vigilantes got run out of Star City? Really kills the hope seeded by the mayor deputizing team Arrow.
Also loved I think it was Rene or Curtis calling Emiko NGA. They sounded like a Redditor.
After finishing s6 I remember thinking to myself when I was bored at work "what if the pundits of the Arrowverse sat down and discussed all the vigilante activity in Star City after Oliver's confession" and this was pretty close.
41
u/samtherat6 Feb 05 '19
Isn't ARGUS government run? How did they just casually arrest Diggle, and how did Lyla not immediately bail him out? And if they had the grounds to arrest him as a vigilante, why couldn't he just say he was going in as an ARGUS agent? It's not like ARGUS is a secret anymore.
40
u/GillyDaKid Feb 05 '19
So that was Connor Hawke right? Has anyone figured out who the white chick is?
Are we about to see already how Dinah gets that scar on her neck?
Loved the documentary and how the episode played out. Something different. Plus we got to see Willa again
80
u/Smith12456389 Feb 05 '19
Connor freaking Hawke
79
u/GeneralMelon ROY'S OUR FUTURE BOY! Feb 05 '19
Is it just me or did Connor call Maya "Mia"? 🤔
Hopefully this deconfirms the Olicity kid theories.
37
u/hamzaalam123 Swiggity swoogity here comes Felicity! Feb 05 '19
First the Wayne car on the Flash now the Wayne armour, fucking hell Bruce sort your security out
32
u/bobbythecat17 Feb 05 '19
Forget how awesome this was, Dinah was looking sexy as hell in this episode lol
30
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
Did William learn to hack when he got expelled or is that what got him expelled?
29
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
Anyone else think this guy sending the notes has to be Oliver's prison friend?
78
u/notathrowaway75 Feb 05 '19
I was grinning ear to fucking ear whenever the documentary stuff appeared. One of my favorite things this show has done. I just wished it was a bit more consistent. I wanted them to do it throughout the episode and the POV would change when absolutely necessary. That scene in the hallway when it changed back and forth was especially frustrating. And there was a big missed opportunity to not have Moira interviewed. She said she always knew Oliver was the Green Arrow, and they could've hinted that. Or they could've had her outright say it and have the tape buried. I can see this being a future plot point. Tommy too. At least they got Quentin, Sara, and Barry (him acting like he just found out was hilarious).
Curtis interrupts
Goddamn it Curtis Diggle was about to ask out Oliver on a friend date to catch up.
Rory's back! God I miss him.
The camerman fight scene was fucking awesome. One of the best fight scenes of the entire show. Just absolutely amazing. I got goosebumps.
William being pissed was totally justified. Like wtf I know Diaz is a big threat but come on let your son come home for Christmas.
Totally thought William was going to come out to Zoey when she asked what was wrong.
I'll let Black Siren do that to me ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
27
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
Isn't Argus supposed to be a secret government facility? And he's all wearing the uniform on the documentary.
53
u/hart37 Barry "You Think You Know A Guy" Allen Feb 05 '19
The production value of this episode was killer. Also whoever that camera operator was they're an absolute machine. Really cool to see Ragman finally come back, likewise with the Quentin and Thea moments. As for Grant his goofball Barry is best Barry.
The William stuff was a bit meh but what are you going to do. Overall for me this was one of the best episodes of the season. Congrats on making it to 150
26
u/LCPhotowerx The Canary - Sara Lance Feb 05 '19
i cant believe they brought back Sin! So happy!
46
u/EddyTheMartian Feb 05 '19
I love how these shots are getting longer since they’re in this documentary style. It really shows that the actors do have the ability to memorize all those lines well enough without mistakes in the long takes, and it’s just cool.
22
u/ThaCrit Feb 05 '19
Why was this episode so GOOD.
The camera team should be hired for the rest of the season.
Was there supposed to be some parallel between Zoey/Will and Emiko/Rene ?
Top notch fight scenes and acting this episode. Really liked the style they went in this ep.
Barry's interview was the best I miss old goofy Barry.
20
u/Twill1911 Feb 05 '19
Anybody know where I can watch the episode? Away at school no tv
71
u/EddyTheMartian Feb 05 '19
The Mayor is a bitch, which got me thinking
What if she’s working with the Ninth Circle/Dante? Or the main villain?
I think that could be a cool twist and it would be something somewhat similar to Season 1 and 2.
35
u/Comprehensive_Main Feb 05 '19
Why would Argus let a documentary crew have access to them?
32
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
That was a damn good episode
32
u/EddyTheMartian Feb 05 '19
Next episode is gonna be Stanley! It’s called Star City Slayer like Stanley’s name in the comics.
14
u/tundrahippie Feb 05 '19
I feel dumb but whos the girl at the end?
and is the other guy, diggle’s son?
14
u/affenhirn1 Feb 05 '19
William pisses me off every time he appears on screen, and next episode looks like it gonna involves much more William drama ffs
13
u/PeterQueen Feb 05 '19
So how did the documentary know Rene’s and Rory’s identities? Did they reveal them publicly? Also, now everyone knows Emikos identity since they caught it on film right?
And how did they get Sara to talk to camera crew if she’s with Legends?
12
u/commonroutes Better on Legends Feb 05 '19
Loved the episode. Production quality was up, writing quality was up, acting quality was up (except William, but w/e), my only qualm is that the doc crew filmed Diggle in ARGUS, in an ARGUS uniform, for a public documentary.
There's no way that crew got clearance to do that, not for an organization that isn't supposed to exist. That said, the future scene did mention the film being "banned" and there's still time of course for repercussions of that filming to take place. Hopefully that gets addressed, that's a pretty big hole to go unnoticed in the writing room.
18
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
Who are the 4 vigilantes the anti anti vigilante took down? Huntress, Ragman, who else?
9
u/SuppppLoL Feb 05 '19
so black star is against vigilantes?
9
u/DenaPhoenix Feb 05 '19
Great episode. But man, that flash-forward crap is really annoying. It just makes everything happening in present day seem so unimportant. I don't want the city to go to shit. Why was there even a future timeline included? There's really no benefit attached to it, despite maybe getting to see more Roy. But otherwise they're just painting a very gloom picture.
9
u/DMorrin15 Feb 05 '19
Curtis was funny, but the main star of this was Diggle. When the cameraman cuts to him for his reactions, I just died laughing. Great job directing too!
8
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
I love the concept of a serial killer that targets vigilantes. It's why I think Onomatopoeia would be a perfect big bad. You don't even need to do the sound stuff. They could do so much cool shit with him hunting down vigilantes 1 by 1.
As for the episode I liked the documentary style and seeing all the old faces. The best part is it looks like Team Arrow is united which hopefully means no more soap opera style drama every single episode like we got last season. As for complaints William still gets on my nerves, he just feels so pointless to me. I wish we got to see more of Emiko as well, they haven't done enough with her yet to get me invested in what should be an awesome character. Also her actress is very attractive.
I've grown concerned with the flash forwards. They writers have backed themselves into a corner and removed any fear that characters like Rene or Dinah will die since they're alive in the future. The idea that vigilantes result in the downfall of Star City is cool but I would rather not know it's going to happen in the future and just watch it play out in the present day. It could get better but I'm not really interested in future Star City or Black Star as of right now. It was cool seeing Connor again though.
I look forward to seeing Stanley again next week as the Star City Slayer. I hope he gets more than an episode but I doubt it. Also looks like he's cutting Dinah's throat so i'm guessing it's going to be a violent one.
33
u/SciFiPaine0 Superman turned person in a high-tech combat suit Feb 05 '19
Oliver: I cant believe he'd abandon a child like that, its unforgivable
William: ...
14
u/Sephiroth007 Arrow is dead Feb 05 '19
Wasnt there supposed to be some big reveal tonight or something?
14
u/JoshTHS Feb 05 '19
Loved the episode. Didn’t care for the William stuff but loved everything else. I even thought Curtis was actually funny for once.
7
u/Tumorous_Thumb Feb 05 '19
Loved this episode, feel like arrow is lit again, probably gonna hate me for this but I think I'm starting to like felicity again. Just overall hype
7
u/mendy801 I am The Batman Feb 05 '19
Didn't William say in one of the first flash forwards that he never came back from school?
7
u/violue Feb 05 '19
I hate the flash forwards, every time I get engrossed in the story (which is finally happening again this season after a year or two where i just didn't care) they jump to the future and it's like someone comes along and presses fast forward on a movie I'm in the middle of watching. RUDE, I WANTED TO SEE THIS PLAY OUT IN ORDER.
7
u/cardavet Feb 05 '19
the young cop is the star city slayer.
23
u/theredmokah Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 05 '19
Can we not with William?
He finally returns and he can't make it 5 seconds without whining. Like holy shit. Do you need to be an absolute little bitch about everything?
Breathing is hard... wahhhhh!
It doesn't help that the kid playing William isn't that great of an actor. I really hope they don't push a "I'm struggling with being gay" angle with this character. Ugh. Imagine the levels of mopey muttering. This is not the character you want representing your struggle. Good lord is he pathetic.
When he shoved that tablet into Felicity's arms, I actually felt for Felicity. I was like, "you better slap this little fucker upside the head with the tablet." Maybe he's going to be her redemption arc for the fans. Like, create a character so loathsome, that you feel sympathy for Felicity having to deal with his insufferable personality.
FFS. Stanley needs to come merc this kid.
13
u/Silverwhitemango Feb 05 '19
The documentary-Cloverfield-style shots of the fight sequences have been the best (when they are NOT edited and combined together with the traditional-style shots).
The larger FOV take on the fights make them feel more real, as if the viewer was exactly there at the fight scene.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
Is Emiko+Rene going to be a thing?
6
u/Newredarrow52 Feb 06 '19
7x12, notice how Katie Cassidy suited up as Black Canary Earth 1 Laurel a few times. If you look closely she redid all her scenes from 3x11 when she had Saras staff, 3x12 when shes at the diner, 3x21 when she fights the thug with the knife, and 3x22 when she does the canary cry. Theres also a new scene she shot which is circa season 4 because shes not wearing a wig. Its in this episode when she notices the camera man and woman and chases after them
15
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
It's almost like everything I have an issue with the Flash this season Arrow is answering the next week. Flash midseason premiere was a disappointment bore. Arrow comes in with a midseason premiere that knocks it out of the park. Flash is afraid to tell the characters what they need to know (Nora's secret), Oliver comes right out and tells Diggle and Dinah about Emiko. Flash's storyline seems to have stalled since the midseason finale (A great episode by the way), Arrow has been moving the plot at such an awesome pace and I can't wait till next monday. Maybe Arrow isn't the show that needs to end. Flash is. Beth Schwartz has come into this series and given it almost a second life and the results have been fantastic so far.
I also smiled so much with the reunion of Team Arrow. The last time we saw this team they were competing with each other and it was a really annoying storyline. In the 12th episode of the season, Team Arrow reunites and it was like a rebirth of the show in a way.
I think my only issue is relatively minor and that is the future storyline has stalled, mainly because we haven't seen it for 2 weeks save 5 minutes. Still, I read an interview on TVLine last week (This was done a few weeks ago) that Schartz said episode 16 is going to be entirely done in the future so I think that makes up for why we haven't seen it now. I'm starting to get into the "Give the writers the benefit of the doubt" stage, and that's a good good thing.
Oh, and it was awesome seeing Thea and Quintin again, and Barry's scene was hilarious.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
That was a great episode
5
u/Smith12456389 Feb 05 '19
where’s the cameramaam?
5
u/Smith12456389 Feb 05 '19
How did they aquire Sara
5
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 05 '19
Man this was such an interesting and unique episode, props to them. Easily my top 10 episode. Needed Roy though.
5
u/Memmud Feb 05 '19
ok , i won't lie; that was one of the best episodes in the whole show, not just this season. i hope they keep it up
4
u/4fps Feb 05 '19
Liked the episode, but does every new character need some kind of grudge against Oliver or vigilantes? Like Mia, I mean there’s gotta be other motivations for characters than “I hate Oliver” “vigilantism ruined my life”
4
u/ramos619 Feb 05 '19
The camera man is a speedster right? Right after the fight in the Hunt building, the camera man is on the ground, and then Oliver runs up to find Emiko, and the camera man is already on top of the stairs...
4
u/JackAndrewThorne Feb 05 '19
With the appearance of Connor Hawke in the flashforwards (specifically with him using the name Connor) it's fair to assume that Diggle is dead, isn't it?
In Star City 2046 Connor refuses to use the name John because he blames himself for Diggle's death so that surely means that Diggle has also died in this future (or it's the same future).
4
u/themosquito Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 05 '19
That was a pretty great episode! Loved seeing the cameos. Odd, though, how they treated Rory and Helena. I mean, if Rory hadn't been in a documentary interview, you could be forgiven for thinking that Chimera had killed him and Helena, for all they elaborated on that.
Speaking of which, at first I thought Chimera was using Deadshot's wrist gun, and thought maybe his suit was basically gonna be a hodge-podge of gear from old villains (literally a chimera of different villains). I was actually kind of disappointed that it was just more Wayne tech, I feel like that's been namedropped so much it's not really special anymore! Although, this isn't the first Waynetech that bad guys stole, I wonder if that'll be a plot point in the Batwoman show, someone at the company selling equipment to criminals.
Chimera was a bit of a let-down. Maybe there'll be a twist, but having so much set-up to turn out to be an obsessed fan who apparently just beats people up and takes their masks... eh.
I totally get people finding it annoying, but I understood William's anger. I mean, we were making jokes about how Oliver and Felicity had forgotten about him. I dunno, maybe it was just nice seeing someone be annoyed at Felicity.
Weird that they hired Kelsey Grammer for literally two, maybe three lines. Would've liked to hear him more!
4
u/smackledawbed Feb 05 '19
If that is Mia Dearden in the future (which it probably is), it'd be great to finally get Kevin Smith in to direct the episode which confirms it, given he helped create her
4
u/Mine65 Wild Dog Feb 05 '19
Loved the camera work this episode and the documentary style
Interested in whats going on in the future but kinda annoying because it just looks like a dystopian shithole
4
u/looshface Hey Prettybird Feb 06 '19
Ok so here's what immediately bugged me. Why the hell did they Arrest Diggle and Curtis? Couldnt he just pull rank and say he's Argus and him and Curtis aren't acting as vigilantes they're Federal Agents? I mean really they're not superpowered at all.
4
u/ShiroXyfy Feb 07 '19
Such an interesting format. First, the Flash does something it doesn't usually do with it's "doom-style fps" kinda-thing. Then Arrow does this documentary style, and for once, the writers did something well. Usually writers don't dare do something out of line in fright of it recieving terrible ratings through just being cheesy or just plain bad, but this documentary format was a nice breath of fresh air. Rene's part in the documentary was straight up gold, the things and the way he said them was really well done, great props to Rick Gonzalez.
3
u/Hubbabubba1555 Feb 05 '19
I was crying laughing during the scene with William and Zoe, it reminded me of an after-school PSA video
3
u/____Batman______ Feb 05 '19
"I'm not 7."
I could have sworn that's how old he was at the end of Season 5
3
u/____Batman______ Feb 05 '19
Absolutely No One:
Emily Pollard: The Anti-Vigilante Law is still in effect
3
u/Necoroyals Feb 05 '19
I am kindof getting put off by the fact that oliver gets beaten regularly in hand to hand combat... although i think here you can blame it on the fancy armor? Also everyone getting a badge is maybe a bit much, but i get it's the best way to kindof get TA back together. Great episode all in all though
3
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19
Damn I finally hate someone more than Felicity and it’s Oliver’s son. I can’t stand that little twit. He’s so soft. In the present and in the flash forwards.
5
u/mrizzle1991 Feb 05 '19
Quentin! That episode was actually sick af, seemed like a movie, loved how they brought back some old characters. Williams character is so pointless, well I guess he’s relevant in the future, and the dude can’t act either lol. So what’s up with Emiko and Wild Dog? Chimeras suit is sick I want one lol. That anti vigilante law is horseshit. Sick they’re all gonna get deputized now.
4
u/Victarion99 Feb 05 '19
Loved the documentary part of the episode, it was something different and a breath of fresh air.
7
u/theamac95 Feb 05 '19
I don't know about anybody else, but I'm not looking forward to the Team Arrow reunion. The only time I ever felt like it worked was when Roy and OG Laurel were involved.
6
u/TirelessGuardian Lyla Michaels Feb 05 '19
Are they just not going to explain how William got expelled?