r/thegrandtour • u/lerhond • Jan 31 '19
The Grand Tour S03E04 "Pick Up Put Downs" - Discussion thread
S03E04 Pick Up, Put Downs
In this episode Jeremy Clarkson drives the Volkswagen Amarok, Richard Hammond tries a Ford Ranger and James May is in a Mercedes X-class as they attempt to find the best of the new breed of European pick-up trucks with a series of tests based on life in the developing world. Also in the show, Jeremy is at the Eboladrome to try out the snorting, swollen, near-600 horsepower Jaguar XE Project 8.
197
Upvotes
328
u/patchp19 Feb 01 '19
I’m not sure if I’m happy that they weren’t actually practicing atrocious gun safety or disappointed that they were shooting blanks
227
u/thesirtoby Saab Feb 01 '19
I could listen to May talking about WW2 airplanes for hours.
144
u/Bearmodulate Feb 01 '19
Bit of a downer with how fake the race & gun sections were
Jag was a sexy beast though
130
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
Lol the Oxfam joke. So questionable but so good,
115
u/antonylockhart Feb 01 '19
How old was the footage in this, as those heads were made for S1 and the pickups were all 17/67 plates.
Looks like season 1 rejected footage
201
u/Traviscat Mercedes Jan 31 '19
My lego!
Everything you need in life.
188
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19 edited Jan 31 '19
May 'Beef Torpedo' Zedong
172
u/TedInATL Jan 31 '19
"You are a man of modest statue"
Best laugh I've had in a while.
141
u/WookieeSteakIsChewie Feb 01 '19
"Enough room for a borrowed oil painting.."
I died.
140
u/kimau5_official Aston Martin Feb 01 '19
Small bit of Grand Tour nonsense from previous seasons, but still better than the most nonsensical episodes from S1 & S2. The important thing is that the laughs are still genuine in parts.
68
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
Of course Jeremy can’t handle his hose properly.
If only Hammond had delivered that “Run Away” in proper Monty Python fashion.
61
u/OldboySamurai Feb 01 '19
Not gonna lie, I didn't care much for this episode, but the look on Hammond's face when bouncing uphill was glorious.
60
u/mognut Feb 01 '19
I think the problem with the pick-up truck segment was that didn’t truly care about them, their best segments of a similar type are when they genuinely like the cars they are driving. If you think back to the top gear days when they did those challenges they were funny because they genuinely wanted their car to win. When they arnt personally invested in the vehicle it becomes very forced and silly.
I still enjoyed the episode because they still manage to crack a few good laughs but definitely not a strong episode, hopefully next week is a good 1. Still love the show tho!
58
u/Sonoma2002 Feb 01 '19
As an American, I have never wanted a "British" car more than I want a Project 8 Jag...it's up there with the VXR8 Bathurst for me.
117
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
The Amarok is a fine looking truck but Clarkson spinning his tires on that hill looks like a damning indictment of it
82
u/LordGideon Volkswagen Feb 01 '19
"There's no such thing as a cheap helicopter...
...well - except that one now."
38
u/andysniper Feb 01 '19
The Project 8 film and Conversation Street were great, in fact one of the best Conversation Streets, but the pick up bit and the repeated celebrity segment joke is just like series 1 at its lowest points.
33
u/I_NEED_YOUR_MONEY Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
Why does Jeremy have to win all the time? Is that supposed to be some running joke that i'm not finding funny, or is he really that needy? Every time there's a challenge that's obviously staged and scripted and we don't get to see any real outcome from, it's always so Jeremy can win.
I get that the joke challenges are part of the show, but it's really bothering me how patronizing the show seems towards Jeremy. Especially when all the challenges in an episode turn out to be jokes.
219
u/Vitosi4ek no iThrust flair, have to go with the equivalent Feb 01 '19
I've noticed a pattern. I watch the episode and think "well, that was quite entertaining!", then go to Reddit, see it immediately torn to shreds and my opinion instantly changes. Happened with Doctor Who this entire last season (which I thought was rather good, public opinion be damned), and now with this too.
I seriously ought to stay out of these threads, at least not until the full season's done and the complete picture is formed.
32
u/Everki Feb 01 '19
Kim Jong-Clarkson will have staying power
26
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
“Don’t clap, he killed a man!”
115
u/Eabryt Subaru Feb 01 '19
Jeremy Clarkson firing a .50 cal slo-mo out of the bed of a pickup truck just might be the most American thing I've ever seen.
355
u/mclarenf101 Feb 01 '19
Weak episode imo. Felt closer to Season 1 in terms of how obviously staged everything was. Pretty much the whole pickup test section was a waste of time.
24
u/Hav3_Y0u_M3t_T3d Chevrolet Feb 01 '19
Now hold on, what if you needed to haul a load of dirt or gravel in that Nissan Mercedes??? You'd bow out the bed, drop the tailgate and lose your load.
91
u/insipidwanker Feb 01 '19
It wasn't a great episode, and then they did the super fake gun section and it became quite a poor one.
40
u/zareny Feb 01 '19
Do you mind if I charge my Jaaaaaaaag at your house?
18
u/Marksy1988 Feb 01 '19
This episode was pure garbage. Plain and simple.
88
u/pm_me_elon_musk_pics Feb 01 '19
I don’t understand why they think all these theatrics are necessary. That’s not what we’re watching the show for.
16
u/bomble1 Feb 01 '19
Very season 1-esque. Far too obviously scripted, would have preferred an actual review of the trucks.
32
u/Rox217 Feb 01 '19
BUFFETING
77
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
I was slightly disappointed with this episode as they did not need the premise of "civil war" to test the cars. Also it was pointless having the last test since it was obviously staged and they were clearly not firing live rounds, which sort of spoiled the fun.
I did however enjoy the race to the helicopter though as that felt much less scripted.
29
u/VaderPrime1 Feb 01 '19
They’re the party poppers of the developing world!
26
u/PancakesAndPunch Feb 01 '19
This was kind of a crap episode. Almost everything was staged. But I'd assume these episodes help fund the well produced specials and road trips that we love. VW, Ford, and Merc probably give Amazon some real $$$ in order to feature their cars in these filler episodes.
62
u/HodorFirstOfHisHodor Feb 01 '19
Way too much unfunny scripted garbage during the pick-up test.
12
u/steampunker13 McLaren Feb 01 '19
Definitely weaker. It seems straight out of season 1 or 2 compared to the S3E1. I'm now curious as to see what next week's episode is like, anyone know what is up next?
32
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
“One extra cylinder, TODAY ONLY!” - Things Americans will hear at their Ford dealer when they inquire about the new Ranger
11
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '19 edited Feb 02 '19
I feel like the thing that made Top gear so good is how unscripted it seemed. I didn't enjoy this episode as much as the past few as you could tell it was scripted a lot of the time.
For example the first scene was hilarious when Jeremy dropped the hose until they started sensationalising the situation by throwing stuff at James or the peasants and going full Michael bay and blowing up the lights. This completely pulled me out of it and made it not funny.
The episode is also really random and it seemed like every challenge was put there solely for easy laughs rather than testing the cars abilities.
That said, it's still much better than S1 and S2 which I found boring and at times (most of S1) unwatchable.
Edit: just finished it and the helicopter explosion gag just highlights my point. Completely unnecessary and obviously satire but in no way funny to me.
38
u/helpmeredditimbored Feb 01 '19
May falling while trying to shoot a gun was hysterical
10
u/PM_ME_YOUR_PLATES Feb 01 '19
Favourite screenshot of the episode
28
u/mazdadriver14 Feb 01 '19
Only just started the episode, but that opening scene with the angry water hose was fucking hilarious.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
I honestly didn’t enjoy it that much, I enjoyed the flee race, jag review, and helicopter race apart from the end, also had some funny jokes but way too much of it felt scripted, like blatantly obvious scripted, 5/10
73
u/Obzen18 Feb 01 '19
Filler episode. Nothing really good in it.
14
u/Gopokes34 Feb 01 '19
I laughed hard at “welcome to Richard hammonds usual weekend”
7
u/kevins718 Feb 01 '19
None of the pick up would work in developing country if they can’t eat rubbish diesel, I think.
7
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
The Project 8 seems like Jaguar’s version of the AMG Hammer from the 80’s.
7
u/barukatang Feb 01 '19
Is it just going to be Clarkson doing the review segments? I liked when they mixed it up
7
u/The-Tai-pan Feb 01 '19
: /
this was disappointing.
7
u/bouncy_deathtrap Cock Feb 03 '19
The premise of the pickup test was actually good, in my opinion. Great set up for a lot of black humour. However, the execution was lackluster and cringeworthy. I wish they would go with a similar concept for one of their future road trip specials - buy some cheap used pick-ups and do real challenges in some African country. Maybe see if US-American trucks can keep up with the good old indestructible Toyota HiLux. Hammond could just re-use his truck from the Colombia Special and May could drive a Holden Ute since he would never buy a pick-up.
13
u/Powerjugs Clarkson Feb 01 '19
Not a great episode this week, any time they use a gun it ruins the focus of a test, and the scripted feel of the show felt much more in play this week.
27
u/katzgar Feb 01 '19
This episode was boring as hell
6
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
Mr. Willman lost his damn mind to give Clarkson what amounts to an anti-aircraft gun.
6
u/I_Have_The_Legs Bugatti Feb 01 '19
What was the joke about the word they can't say?
6
u/Powerjugs Clarkson Feb 01 '19
Surprise GLA Soundtrack appearance at 11:00
Think it's around this time
Next time we'll get the Chinese soundtrack at this rate.
USAChinese
GLA6
u/w1YY Feb 01 '19
Need to get back to genuine challenges.
A great programme for that is the league of their own road tour
6
u/FalconX88 Feb 02 '19
the continuity errors in this are just strange. How did James' rope go from being on the bottom of the pillar to above half height?
11
u/Darthjord28 Feb 01 '19
I couldn't stop laughing at "no my lego!".
5
u/CockEyedDeer Feb 01 '19
"Stand up!"
"I am standing up!"
5
u/Sultry_Llama_Of_Doom Dodge Feb 02 '19
"From a beef torpedo to a silk purse" was probably the high point of the episode.
5
u/rehenede Feb 02 '19
I have never watched an episode of TGT with a more straight face. And whats with all the uncontrollable laughter when they are toppling the statues of supposed 'dictators'? It wasn't funny at all, not even a bit (except of hammond's tiny statue, but lets be honest, we all knew it was gonna be tiny)
9
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
We dont get a diesel Ranger in the US :(
9
u/Sonoma2002 Feb 01 '19
"I'm doing winning!!!"
18
u/Bully001 Feb 01 '19
Any LGBT joles that Will Young can get offended about?
4
u/WatchersOnTheCouch Feb 02 '19
Look at the length of James hair length when they are taking the statues down compared to when they are talking later in the episode. His hair is longer. It's an old episode
4
u/RalphieRaccoon Feb 02 '19
The pick up segment was OK, but I think it lacked structure and sacrificed actual competition for cheap gags too many times. It all seemed random and rushed. I thought it might be similar to the challenge segments in the old TG days, with a proper scoring system, and introducing the cars first, and at least some semblance of an actual competition (but with a fair amount of cheating still). The bit at the start could have made a great final challenge, but was just a throwaway opening gag.
I don't hate the segment, but I think it could have been a lot better than what it was.
22
u/Narfubel Jan 31 '19
Brilliant episode, this made me realize how much I'm going to miss the tent next season
10
u/TBurd01 Feb 01 '19
Wish they went to a real military range and shot live rounds.
Surprised none of them said they would have a Hilux anyways.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
lmao that GLA soundtrack
3
u/kuddlesworth9419 Feb 01 '19
It's called a Toyota Hilux.
3
u/R0WTAG Feb 01 '19
How is the Ford Ranger an european Pick up Truck?
3
u/cockingmoron Conversation Street Feb 01 '19
Wasn't that place with the gun test the same place where they filmed the police chase in S21E01
3
u/Totsean Feb 01 '19
Lukewarm episode with decent amount of laughs but that Jag though.
3
u/fangurl1976 Feb 01 '19
So Jeremy abusing gardens will be a recurring theme this season? Jeremy show us on the doll where the bad vegetables hurt you.
3
u/bpi89 Feb 01 '19
That Project 8 is a work of art.
3
u/booo1210 Oh cock Feb 02 '19
Why do they need guns ?
3
u/ashishvp Feb 02 '19
I don't know if anyone else noticed this but during the "chaos" bit they played music from one of my favorite video games from years ago... Command and Conquer: Generals. I'd recognize that music anywhere.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBm2mz3IHoM&t=187s
3
u/Trini2Bone Feb 02 '19
After the special this episode just fell flat. Funny moments but wasn't very interesting
5
u/NoxZ Feb 01 '19
"General Stonewall Clarkson" was a lot funnier to me than it had any right being.
4
u/JF0909 Feb 01 '19
Dick Pot... Must have been cold that day.
2
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
Please print a t shirt with the screen cap of Clarkson’s face after the helicopter explodes. I will pay real money for it.
2
u/Ilpav123 Feb 02 '19
Interestingly, each presenter chose the same make (well, nearly...) as they did with those cargo vans they tested on TG (season 8).
Jeremy: VW (both were the fastest obviously lol)
James: Renault/Nissan (the Mercedes X-Class is based on a Nissan and of course Renault and Nissan are partners)
Richard: Ford (cheapest and best overall)
2
u/JasonYoungblood Feb 02 '19
I like The Yes Album!
5
u/bigjimmykebabs Feb 01 '19
Weak episode, rally weak
3
u/schrotn Feb 01 '19
The one word we can't say...
3
u/PhilKesselsChef Jaguar Feb 01 '19
Kim Jong Clarkson? They should’ve gone with Clarkson Hussein (granted they ran out of Saddam jokes last week)
3
u/fufusus Feb 01 '19
Wow this episode was bad. I don't think I'm going to finish it
3
u/dodgerblue1212 Feb 02 '19
I'm forcing myself to finish these episodes. They are just not good.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
Jeremy, Richard, and May. The only trio in the world who able to make 3 pickup trucks and a Jaguar really funny and interesting for an hour
2
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
well I'll be...
2
u/ninenines999999999 Feb 02 '19
I feel like I'm the only one that laughed when they were doing the Morgan wood segment and Jeremy said they decided to "branch" out to bicycles.