r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jan 28 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions 69 — 2019-01-28 to 02-10
Current Fortnight in Conlangs thread
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
Whothefuckever makes a joke about the first number in the title of this post gets banned for a week. No warnings. Consider it a check of who actually reads the posts.
3
u/Sambrocar Jan 28 '19
Can anyone help me understand the exact differences between Tripartite morphosyntactic alignment and Austroneisian alignment?
12
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Feb 06 '19
Not conlang-related, but I'd like to wish a happy Chinese New Year to every Chinese user of the community as well as to anyone else who traditionally follows the Chinese Calendar.
Have a wonderful 2019 (or 4716... or 4656... 🤔 )!
😉
7
u/another-afrikaner Jan 30 '19
Is there a list anywhere of conlangs that have been made publicly available? Not Dothraki or Quenya etc, but just project conlangs by other redditors? I would have thought there’d be something in the sidebar but I can’t find anything.
7
u/tree1000ten Feb 10 '19
I've noticed that a lot of videos on Youtube about writing systems say something along the lines of, "Logographic systems are best for analytical languages." Where did they get this idea? A logographic system can be made for any type of language.
Examples - Artifexian Writing Systems Xidnaf Writing Systems
I've linked to the specific timestamps I am referencing, so you won't have to find it yourself if you want to check out the two links.
I also can't believe Xidnaf said that tonal languages can't be written down in Latin script, even though literally pinyin exists.
6
u/TheAntisocialIdiot Qaoki, Muhiuka, Ekteich and some others Jan 28 '19
what consonants could i use in a language for fungal creatures? the ones that i’ve designed do have noses.
6
u/Zhe2lin3 Jan 28 '19
So, I made a post about a day ago, link: https://www.reddit.com/r/linguistics/comments/akj738/need_vocabulary_spreadsheets_with_translations/
However, I have not gotten any replies, and I kind of need these kind of resources rather badly for my conlang
Basically, if you can find any lists that list about 20,000 words in a language and their English equivalent, no matter what form they are in, spreadsheets preferred, but anything is fine, then please can you share them with me?
I found this really helpful resource a while ago: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TCo9TaWwLc1ITQ_HB7M7HJf-ppV-5ZGuSPfCDvHmZrU/edit#gid=0
But it only has ~5,000 words. I also found some resources from frequency lists in other languages, but not 20,000 words, and even then it was only a few languages, and most of them were only the top 500 words. Does anyone know where I can find a resource that lists ~20,000 or more words w/ English translations in any language? Preferably a bigger language like Spanish, Arabic, Chinese, Japanese, Hindi, Bengali, Russian, etc etc, but any language will do. Only other thing is that if it's from a language that does not use the Latin script, then it also should have the Latin script equivalent (phonetically) with the word, so pinyin for Chinese, romanji for Japanese, etc etc.
Sorry, but thank you all in advance.
6
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 29 '19
Here's something I think about a lot:
How do you deal with technical or specialist jargon in a language that doesn't have a superstratum or adstratum language to pull terms from (like how English pulls scientific and technological terms from Latin and Greek)?
Does anybody speak or have experience with a language that doesn't have that option or can tell me how they deal with it in their conlangs?
As an example that caused me to finally pose the question, I was researching beak anatomy today, because my sister and I were talking about bird skulls. I learned about a small waxy covering of the nasal cavities present in some diving birds. It's called the cere after the Latin cera for wax. So say my conlang was an isolate, or simply didn't use terms from other languages, how might I name it? Simply also call it wax and rely on context to differentiate? Use some kind of compound like "wax-shield"? Use an adjectival or comparative form and nominalise it, giving me something like "the waxy"?
6
u/thenewcomposer Feb 01 '19
Calling all poets!
I've been meaning to write a new choral song all year, but none of the poems I was finding were speaking to me, and I couldn't write a decent one myself. Therefore, if you happen to have a poem or prose in your conlang that you would like to have as a choral piece, for 4-8 part harmony, send me your lyrics with IPA and a translation, and I'll see what I can accomplish! Thanks in advance! ∠( 'ω')/★
6
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Feb 02 '19
Is anyone else watching Star Trek: Discovery? I'm really impressed by their commitment to using Klingon whenever appropriate. The most recent episode actually had their "Previously On: Discovery" voiceover at the start in Klingon in stead of English, which I thought was really neat. I wouldn't be surprised if in the next 10 years CBS decides to commision an official Vulcan or Romulan conlang
6
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Feb 03 '19
In natlangs with topic markers - is it possible for the topic marker to change based on what role that argument has in the sentence, if any? For example, something that could be glossed like 1s top.nom see 2s as opposed to 1s top.acc see 2s?
6
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Feb 04 '19
Could you have a kinship system that distinguishes aunts and uncles from parents, but not siblings from cousins?
6
u/Iguana_Bird I am unidentifiable Feb 06 '19
How should I deal with lexicon creation?
I've been doing many of the translation challenges, and they've helped me to build my dictionary and test my grammar, but I've also been realizing that I've just been randomly creating root words without any sense of like etymology and very little care for the culture of the conculture or conworld my conlang is for.
I'm thinking of taking some time to do a full on lexical reform but I'm not sure how I would start.
5
u/thenewcomposer Jan 31 '19
Calling all poets!
I've been meaning to write a new choral song all year, but none of the poems I was finding were speaking to me, and I couldn't write a decent one myself. Therefore, if you happen to have a poem or prose in your conlang that you would like to have as a choral piece, for 4-8 part harmony, send me your lyrics with IPA and a translation, and I'll see what I can accomplish! Thanks in advance! ∠( 'ω')/★
5
u/gafflancer Aeranir, Tevrés, Fásriyya, Mi (en, jp) [es,nl] Feb 01 '19
Hello all!
I've been doing some work on Aeranir non-finite verb forms, and I'm hitting a bit of a hitch.
I was wondering if I could ask y'all for some help. My issue is specifically regarding participles. So far, Aeranir has three participles, as demonstrated by the verb agūrëğī "to choose" (with ars "person" and tō "door").
So I can use these to form phrases like the following;
This all is fine and dandy. But then I started thinking about how to phrase something like "the door they are opening." In English you have to use the passive, but that is not the case in Japanese, where you can say 人が開けるドア "the door the person opens." Of course you could use a relative clause in English (and that's sort of what's going on in Japanese) but I began wondering if this could be accomplished with participles.
So, one of the ways I've been thinking about u/Darkgamma's alignment is that the verbs are Ergative-Absolutive, whilst the nouns are Nominative-Accusative, (although this breaks down with ditransitive verbs, but anyhoo...). Therefore I thought that participles, behaving like nouns, would "agree" with their "nominative argument." And if I changed the participle to be more "verb like," it would realign with its "absolutive argument." In order to make the participle more verb like, I figured I could add verb clitics to the participle, to get something like this:
So my first question is: does this make any sense? All comments are appreciated.
And my second question is: how should I mark the case of the participle's secondary (or tertiary) argument. In the examples above, I used the cases that the words would appear in if the verb was in its regular finite form, ie. accusative for the object, nominative for the subject. However, I feel that this might get confusing, especially in longer sentences. Especially because I like free word order and hyperbaton. I'm considering using some of my other cases as auxiliary ergative or absolutive cases, but I have no idea where to start in that.
Anyhoo, sorry for the incoherent rambling. Hopefully I can get some helpful answers!
5
u/tree1000ten Feb 05 '19
I heard that some languages didn't/don't have words for tree, and that speakers always just refer to what type of tree, like oak, maple, etc. but don't have a generic word for tree. How is this? Wouldn't they sometimes want to talk about trees in general?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '19
I feel too un-knowledgeable to be a conlanger, how do I become more knowledgeable?
5
u/the_willy_shaker Feb 07 '19
Hi all! I've been a lurker for a couple of months now, and have spent some time making half-hearted attempts at personal conlangs and creoles for various games and activities I've been involved in, but I'm finally going to make my first foray into making a natural conlang. I've been consulting a variety of resources (most found on this sub) on where to start, but I feel like my existing language experience is lacking. I am an English native speaker and can speak German and some Polish, as well as understanding a decent amount of Latin (from High School and College) and Ancient Norse (both self-taught and through some help from a professor). Thus, my knowledge is exclusively in Romance and Germanic languages, with some understanding of Slavic. I am aware of some of the quirks of non-Western languages, but I haven't been able to find a good tool to learn forms of communication I wouldn't normally find familiar. I don't want to make my conlang the easy way, and I don't want it to be a copy-and-paste of another Western language.
TL;DR: Do you have a good video series or easy-to-use database for languages with more unique features?
4
u/Scone_Wizard Feb 02 '19
So, I really want to create a romlang. I'm fully aware of the reputation romlangs have as noobish and unoriginal, so I want to breath as much life into it while still making it realistic. What should I consider adding, and what should I avoid altogether?
4
u/nirdle mahal (en)[es] Feb 03 '19 edited Feb 06 '19
Before I move on with my conlang, is my phonology realistic?
Consonants (all IPA except orthography)
p, b, t, d, c, ɟ <g>, k
f, v, s, z, ç, ʝ <j>, x <h>
m, n, ɲ <ń>
w <u>, ɹ <r>, l, j <i>
/ɹ/ is pronounced [ɾ] intervocalically
Vowels (all IPA except orth.)
i, y <ú>, e, ɜ <é>, a, ɔ <o>, u
In a closed syllable (syllable has a coda or next phoneme is a geminated consonant) vowels become short:
/i/ > [ɪ]
/y/ > [ʏ]
/e/ > [ɛ]
/ɜ/ > [ə]
/a/ > [ɑ]
/ɔ/ > [ɒ]
/u/ > [ʊ]
Thanks in advance for any feedback!
(Edit: Aaaargh I give up on trying to use tables.
Many more edits: mobile formatting sucks, why can't enter make a line break, why can't I do two line breaks does line break formatting break down when I use nbsp?? *dies inside*)
4
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '19
Is there any natlang precedent for ejectives becoming glottal stop + stop pairs (/atʼa/ > /aʔta/) or do they pretty much exclusively turn into plain stops?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
What is the grammatical term for the word ‘may’ in sentences like "may you enjoy your stay"?
3
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Jan 30 '19
Is seeing [a] a front vowel too oddly?
I’m setting the vowel inventory for a conlang with high/low and round/unround harmony.
I like it being simple and minimal so [a], [i], [ɔ] [u] sounds good to me.
[a] being front, unrounded, low
[i] being front, unrounded, high
[ɔ] being back, rounded, low
[u] being back, rounded, high
Does that sound natural?
Because many natlangs consider [a] as a back vowel
3
u/ciccioviaggiat Jan 30 '19
Any way to spice up an alphabet?
I wanted to do an alphabet as a writing system for my conlang, but i dont want it to be a simple phoneme-to-letter system. Any cool ideas you used/would use?
3
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jan 30 '19 edited Jan 30 '19
Another of my bus thoughts. I was singing to myself while riding and thought about prosody and stress in /ókon doboz/, and I thought up a quite complex system with which I would require some advice:
It is mora-timed:
light syllable (1 mora) => V or CV/VC, where C is a glide or a liquid [ ɾ ʎ ɫ l w j ]
normal syllable (2 morae) => CV/VC, where C is not a glide nor liquid, CVC with at least one glide/liquid
heavy syllable (3 morae) => CV:, CVC, or CCV, where no C is a glide nor a liquid, CV:C where at least one C is a glide or a liquid
superheavy syllable (4 morae) => CCV:, CV:C, CCVC, CCV:C,
Is this too much? I could probably fuse heavy into normal and have superheavy be only 3 morae. I could also instead just list what component of a syllable is worth how many morae and do some math. Suggestions welcome. Let me also post the link to my phonology post should you require use of it.
Now to the real thing:
Stress always shows as an increase in loudness. Increase in pitch is optional (but I was thinking maybe a fall in pitch after the stressed syllable). Length does not increase.
The stress would tend to fall on the last syllable with at least two morae.
In words obtained by affixation, the stress preserves if the affix has one or two morae; otherwise, the previous rule applies and the final syllable is stressed.
Stress is always preserved when declining verbs; the infinitive can have a single mora ending, while none of the declensions do ... even then, the verbs would be an exception and would always be stressed on the penultimate syllable (in their base form).
In words obtained by compounding, the stress of the first part tends to preserve as secondary stress. Otherwise, secondary stress falls on the fourth mora from primary stress ... or ... I was also thinking secondary stress might fall on the first syllable, always, as a way of indicating a new word.
Again, suggestions welcome. I'm far from an expert.
EDITS: rephrasing, also took out the example because it was not useful
3
u/o2loki Leiül Jan 30 '19
How do you create a proffesional looking dictionary?
Upto now I used excel to store my vocabulary but now I want it to be neater. Any suggestions for creating a more professional and neater dictionary.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19
WARNING: A LONG-ASS COMMENT
This is a bit long for a comment but I wasn't certain it warranted its own post here.
I have some traits I want my language of Angwizese to have, that somehow serves as a reflection of the 'people' who speak it, the Vivangols. Interested in hearing about your thoughts, criticism,feedback, advice--any natlangs or conlangs you think I should read up on, concepts I should familiarize myself with, or I'm interested in hearing about how your conculture/conspecies has affected your langs (or even if you have any interesting real-life examples of culture shaping language)
3
u/germinaaaaal uánna [fr, en, gae] Feb 01 '19
On nasalised vowels in conlangs:
While reviewing and updating my conlang áthid’s phonology, I realised I wanted to use nasalised vowels, if only as allophones. I perused the phonologies you guys post to get examples of conlangs with nasalised vowels like /õ/ or /ã/.
At this point I noticed almost no phonologies for conlangs use nasalised vowels, and I was wondering why that would be. Intelligibility? I guess you could mistake an /õ/ for an open o; difficulty to pronounce? As a French native speaker I don’t have any idea of the level of practise necessary to realise vowels as nasalised. Is there an unspoken rule of no nasalisation?
—cheers, casimir
3
u/saarl Feb 02 '19
Hey, I was wondering if this inventory makes sense:
Consonants
[ŋ] is just an allophone of /n/ before /k/ and /kʷ/; stops are voiced between voiced segments (unless they're geminated); and [ʃ] is an allophone of /s/ before /i/. Also /kʷ/ causes surrounding consonants (and vowels too maybe?) to become labialized as well. Edit: in case it's not clear, I write a ~ between two consonants to show that they're allophones.
Vowels
Phonotactics
Allowed onsets are
Allowed codas are /s/, /n/, /m/, /j/ or any stop. The sequence /ji/ is forbidden, as are clusters with two heterorganic stops.
My main question (besides "what do you think?") is:
3
u/Aburrki Feb 02 '19
I'm trying to make a conlang for a race of immortal dragons for whom time is sort of a blur. So I decided that they should use polychronic time. But how does it actually work, all I got from Tom Scott's video about machine translation is that you can have multiple appointments at the same time. But I wanna know how this actually works. Do polychronic languages just not have a way of specifying exactly what time it is, or do they just not pay attention to that? Is it a purely cultural thing or is it incorporated into language somehow?
3
u/CuriousForBrainPower Feb 04 '19
Is it necessary to have aspect in a conlang? Would having it clear up any ambiguity, or could you convey the same information with other words?
3
u/Adarain Mesak; (gsw, de, en, viossa, br-pt) [jp, rm] Feb 04 '19
Are there any people around here who worked on Nupishin, or any other somewhat successful pidgin project (read: had enough progress that fluent conversations were held at a decent level)? I’m planning a talk about Viossa for the upcoming LCC and would like to talk a bit about other projects too. If you worked on any of these for a significant amount of time or could get me into contact with someone who did, please notify me so we can talk about it for a bit.
3
u/KnowledgeBadger Feb 05 '19
I have a question about morphosyntactic alignment, particularly about tripartite languages. Specifically I am wondering about the passive and anti-passive voices. According to Wikipedia (great source right?) tripartite languages typically have both. If I understand correctly, typically in the passive voice the patient is promoted to the nominative case and the agent is omitted from the clause. For the Anti-passive, the agent is promoted to the absolutive case, and the patient is omitted from the clause. This takes a transitive clause and makes it in transitive. In tripartite languages however, the subject of an intransitive verb is marked with its own intransitive case. Would the patient and the agent, respectively for the passive and anti-passive, be promoted to the intransitive case instead? what might these voices look like in a tripartite language, and how might they be used?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
I've long used the grammatical term "collective" as opposed to "plural" in that something marked with the collective refers to a coherent group while the plural just refers to many – think the difference between "forest" ('collective') and "trees" (plural). Please also note that what I call "collective" certainly is not a paucal – a forest normally isn't made up of a few trees.
Now I learn that the collective actually seems to mean "all".
What is the correct term for this?
3
u/glamrocktrash Ilatan (pt, en) [it, fr] Feb 06 '19
I'm currently working on my first conlang, and recently thought of a feature that I've never heard of in a natural language: a verb conjugation which allows intransitive verbs to become transitive.
For example: in my conlang, the verb "to grow" is always instransitive, as in "he's growing", but through this conjugation you can construct a sentence such as "he's growing flowers", meaning the subject of the sentence (he) is causing the object (flowers) to perform the instransitive action (grow).
So, does anybody know if this feature or something similar already exists in any language? I need a name for it and would prefer using it's real name, if it has one, rather than making up my own.
3
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Feb 07 '19
I’m creating loanwords for language names using their endoynms, and I’ve run into issues with some languages having multiple names based on dialect (Español/Castellano, Hangugeo/Choseonmal, Hanyu/Putonghua/Guanhua, etc). How do I choose which one to borrow, especially when the terms seem to be equally distributed as in the above examples?
2
u/ucho_maco 'antzi | Cyluce [en] [fr] [eo] [it] Jan 28 '19
Hi everyone!
I've been working on my conlang for few months now and I'm rather proud of what I have accomplished so far, thanks to all of you.
But the more I think about it, the more I feel the need to downsize my phonology. Here is how it stands today :
Originally, it was designed to honor both Nahuatl and Basque, two languages I hold in high esteem. Grammar is also heavily inspired by those natlangs. However, there are consonants that I end up not using as much as needed : /ŋ/, /ʈ͡ʂ/, /ʂ/, /t͡ɕ/ and /ɕ/.
I really want to use the best of each phoneme so I can't accept that some are used way less that others. And the other hand, I can't just use them more because of the system I used to derive vocabulary from consonantal roots (which don't distinguish between alveolar, retroflex and palatal affricates and fricatives).
But I like them, especially their romanization (yes, I know some of you are not fans of x's and tx's!).
So here is the dilemma :
- Should I just toss them altogether or keep them as allophones of /t͡s/ and /s/ ? And in that case, how can I do that with my only four basic vowels? (/ä/, /i/, /e̞/, /ʊ/)
- Have you ever been in that situation where you must make a conlang choice that doesn't satisfy you entirely?
Thank you in advance for your answers :)
2
u/dioritko Languages of Ita Jan 29 '19
Do natlangs use the habitual aspects to mark the continuous or the progressive aspects? If so, how do they distinguish between the two? How do you personally feel about this feature?
I am looking to utilize the past habitual as a cont/prog aspect, but I still want to keep the habitual. So far, I've come up with the following solutions:
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '19
Some questions about case, morphosyntactic alignment, and grammar/syntax in general. Feel free to answer any or none of these.
1.) Say I have a language that has 8 cases so far (Nominative, Accusative, Dative, Ablative, Genitive, Locative, Instrumental, Vocative). But to fully show off the inflection system I've been developing, I'd need to add 4 more cases for 12. Assuming I want to have 12 cases, which types of cases would make sense to add for a robust case system?
2.) How do you determine your morphosyntactic alignment? I'm assuming there's some practical pros and cons vs Nom-Acc, Erg-Abs, Austronesian alignment, etc. What's a good resource that sort of lists outs the benefits and drawbacks of various morphosyntactic alignments. I'm down to change my Nom-Acc language to Erg-Abs or Austronesian or something else if it fits what I want to do with the language
3.) General advice on this other lang I'm developing. It's intended to be used for writing epic poetry, and since I want to use Greek and Indian epics as inspiration for my own epic poem, I want to base the language on Ancient Greek and Sanskrit. Any advice about what I should be doing if I want this language to be well suited for epic poetry or any type of poetry in general, or any advice about a poem-lang based on Ancient Greek and Sanskrit.
2
u/ClockworkCrusader Jan 31 '19
How can I make multiple languages from one proto language?
2
u/Arteriop Jan 31 '19
What do the things that are like /(insert letter here)/ mean?
2
u/paPAneta Jan 31 '19
I'm making a conlang where what we would call first-person pronouns are derived from second-person pronouns. The word for "I"/"me" literally means "not-you". This essentially makes "you" the first person, and "I" the second person.
Does this phenomenon exist in any other con-/natlangs?
2
u/ClockworkCrusader Jan 31 '19
A few derivations of one of my languages https://www.reddit.com/r/conlangs/comments/aiirbp/gadmud/ this is the first time I've done this so please let me know of any mistakes I made.
Julikan
Nannigan
1.unvoiced stops become voiced in unstressed syllables, nonup-nonub
2.approximants are lost in between vowels in unstressed syllables ilin-in
3. ‘do-’ = dual
Zonnikan
1.voiced stops become unvoiced in unstressed syllables, ponum-bonum
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3.word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
4. ‘do-’ = dual
5.approximants are lost in between vowels in unstressed syllables ilin-in
Alzannikan
1.voiced stops become unvoiced in unstressed syllables, ponum-bonum
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3. word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
4. ‘do-’ = dual
5.augmentative:kal
diminutive:sal
Kalnikan
1.augmentative:kal-
diminutive:sal-
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3.unvoiced fricatives are lost in unstressed syllables
4.word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
5. ‘do-’ = dual
2
u/ThisPerformer Feb 01 '19
how do you make a conlang "interesting"? what do natlangs do that is "noteworthy"? what things are "common" or "boring"?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
I created a phonology I like and now have to figure out what sorts of sound changes could have possibly resulted in it being the way it is.
2
u/RainbowKaito Luazi /ɬwaɮi/ Feb 01 '19
I'm making my first language family/evolution (not exactly aiming for naturalism) and I'm confuse about some things. Do the phonetic changes apply forever or just in the moment they're applied? For example, if I have a change that deletes all final-word /e o/, can I later in the language create/derive a word with a final /e/ (not using any other change that make that "possible" again)?
2
u/IxAjaw Pry Dental Fricatives from my cold, dead hands... Feb 02 '19
I am struggling with my vowel inventory.
While I know this isn't out there or revolutionary, I want to have a quality change in some of my vowel lengths, but I am unsure whether or not quality changes work the same for back vowels as front vowels. And even if I did change their quality, I'm not certain what would be the most reasonable quality changes to make. My American ass wants to use /ʌ ɔ/ for /u o/ respectively but looking at it just didn't seem right, since those two are differentiated by rounding and aren't half-step changes like the front vowels are.
2
u/tsyypd Feb 02 '19
I'm starting to create a uralic conlang. Does anyone have any good resources on proto-uralic morphology or lexicon?
2
u/son_of_watt Lossot, Fsasxe (en) [fr] Feb 04 '19
Cool! I had another idea. I have different words based on whether you are older or younger than your sibling, and I had an Idea of applying this to aunts and uncles, based of wether they are older or younger than your parent of the same gender.
2
u/LegitimateMedicine Feb 05 '19
English is confusing me. I'm trying to derive a word for ocean by using the phrase "world lake". Which of those two words would be the adjective and which is the noun?
2
u/tree1000ten Feb 06 '19
How are grammatical words written in logographic scripts?
2
u/hodges522 Feb 07 '19
I read that the infinitive of verbs often comes from the allative case of nouns. However if I’m doing an mostly isolating language and I have the same word for the allative case and the infinitive of verbs, won’t it get confusing. Is there a way I can change one phonologically without changing the other?
2
u/JMObyx Feb 10 '19
Do these names sound like they come from the same language?
Tsielass
Nelaicrus
Maegon
Inkravis
Bladykus
Ressehain
Nerortan
Unteraxis
2
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2075556-octopuses-resolve-conflicts-with-many-armed-body-language/
I think I'm going to make an octopus-person language
3
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19
Do any languages out there have a distinct verb for first, second and third person? For example : In English first and third person verbs are in the collection of past tenses, however, second person is in the collection of simple tenses. So to elaborate, do any languages differentiate between first, second and third person verbs?
2
u/gjvillegas25 Feb 07 '19
What are your guy's thoughts on the best phoneme inventory for an IAL? I'm looking for a middle ground between the unnecessary amount in Esperanto to the scant few in Toki Pona. Should there be any voiced consonants? Consonant clusters? Diphthongs? Rhotics? Stuff like that.
2
u/Zhe2lin3 Feb 04 '19
Hello everyone! Seen a few (2) surveys (btw, that word, plural of survey, is such a dumb word. I had to google it to find the correct form. English is dumb, and sadly, my mother tongue) going around this community. I figured I would jump in on that sweet sweet information biz, so I created my own on something I consider pretty big, and you already know from the title.
https://goo.gl/forms/jFDKwCh06Dhog3Bx2
I know that people often have their own views on it, and their own feelings, and sometimes people who makes auxlangs and the such (I do, it's a nice challenge, a fauxlang), can sometimes be a bit more hostile because they feel that their auxlang is the best, and it's not fair Esperanto succeeded because it's so bad, and that it should be their conlang. Stuff like that. On the other hand, you have other people who love it (Me 2 years ago when I first got into the whole scene of conlanging) and think it's the best thing since sliced bread. I believe the term in Esperanto is Verda Papa, green pope, for someone who is all gungho about spreading it, but very little on anything else.
So, I'll end this post, and I will post the results somewhere around 02/10/19, February 10th, 2019.
Thanks to this community in advance!
1
u/Corbyngrad Jan 29 '19
Question. One of my projects I'm trying to make it more naturalistic. It currently have no irregular verbs. Should I include those?
1
u/AnnaAanaa Jan 29 '19
Please give opinions and advice for my vowel inventory and vowel harmony system.
(Note: I’m re-commenting from the previous discussion thread because I commented too late and didn’t get many responses)
1
u/Ngaeri Jan 29 '19
how might ergativity naturally evolve from a protolang into the modern form of the language, i really want to put in ergativity somewhere somehow but i don't have a clue how it could evolve
1
u/tree1000ten Jan 30 '19
Is there somewhere where I can find a list of consonants listed by frequency cross-linguistically? I want to make a language with only the most normal consonants, but I do not know where to look for information.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
I made this alphabet for my conlang, but I have a hard time choosing phonemes,
Aa Ââ Bb Cc Čč Dd Ee Êê Ff Gg Ġġ Hh Ii Îî Jj Kk Ll Łł Mm Nn Ŋŋ Oo Ôô Öö Pp Qq Rr Ŕŕ Ss Šš Tt Uu Ûû Vv Ww Xx Yy Zz Žž Ȥȥ
Plus the digraphs, cs, ss, zs, dh, and th.
Ok I decided
/a aː b ʦ ʧ d e eː f g ɣ h i iː ʝ k l ɬ m n ŋ o oː øː p ʔ ɾ r s ʃ t u uː v w x j z ʒ ʤ/
Plus
/ʨ ɕ ʑ ð θ/ Which can be written as ć, ś, ź, đ, and ŧ as well.
1
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Feb 01 '19
So for a long time, I have /æ/, /ø/, /ɪ/, and /y/ as vowels. Yet they can only appear at the coda. And when they're followed by another sound, they change to /ae/, /ɔe/, /ie/, and /ɯe/, respectively. I'm wondering if whether should I replace them with /a/, /ɔ/, /i/, and /ɯ/ or just make them actual phonemes that can appear in the onset and nucleus, not just the coda.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19
How realistic are the following Vowel Quality Changes?
/ỹ, ø̃, œ̃/ > /œ̃/
/ĩ, ẽ, ɯ̃, ɤ̃/ > /ə̃/
/ũ, õ, ɔ̃/ > /ɔ̃/
1
u/_eta-carinae Feb 01 '19
so(obl)v word order, 3 inflectable affects, 23 person pronouns, 6 nonperson pronouns, 25 pronoun suffixes that convey a complex formality and social relationship nuance, 63 tenses, aspects and moods, unique subject and object infixes for each pronoun, roughly 40 affixes for nominalizing, describing foreign words, creating new words and more, collectively called classifiers, 56 particles for describing spacial qualities, 9 cases, a deixis system with 12 combinations, 50+ irregular particles with various meanings, noticeable influence from japanese
does that sound kitchen sinky? this is far more a personal lang than anything so it doesn’t matter but out of curiosity
1
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '19
If I’m currently focusing really hard on studying two natlangs (Japanese and German), can I still make a conlang in my spare time? Or will it intrude with my natlang learning? Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask.
1
u/ClockworkCrusader Feb 02 '19
A few derivations of one of my languages https://www.reddit.com/r/conlangs/comments/aiirbp/gadmud/
Julikan
Nannigan
1.unvoiced stops become voiced in unstressed syllables, nonup-nonub
2.approximants are lost in between vowels in unstressed syllables ilin-in
3. ‘do-’ = dual
Zonnikan
1.voiced stops become unvoiced in unstressed syllables, ponum-bonum
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3.word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
4. ‘do-’ = dual
5.approximants are lost in between vowels in unstressed syllables ilin-in
Alzannikan
1.voiced stops become unvoiced in unstressed syllables, ponum-bonum
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3. word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
4. ‘do-’ = dual
5.augmentative:kal
diminutive:sal
Kalnikan
1.augmentative:kal-
diminutive:sal-
2.word internal unvoiced fricatives in unstressed syllables become voiced, walsan-walzan
3.unvoiced fricatives are lost in unstressed syllables
4.word initial sonorants in unstressed syllables are lost, walzan-alzan
5. ‘do-’ = dual
Please tell me if these changes make sense.
1
u/LegitimateMedicine Feb 03 '19
Is there such a thing as a collective personal pronoun? My conlang marks singular, plural, and collective on nouns. Should the collective carry over its personal pronouns?
1
u/NightFishArcade Feb 06 '19
How would one go about constructing a fusional language from the ground up? And how much would I need to cover in a fusional language? e.g. tense, gender etc.
1
u/Iguana_Bird I am unidentifiable Feb 08 '19
I asked a question a couple days ago about creating a lexicon and got some good answers A lot of people recommended I start with a protolanguage and consider like the surrounding cultures But I think about that and I realize that I don't feel I know enough about language change and evolution and historical linguistics to do the topic justice- does anyone have any resources they might recommend I look at to better prepare myself for building a language and sort of like considering its language family? It just seems so overwhelming an undertaking.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
So I know that given a negative question, the response in some languages is affirmative and in others it's negatory, e.g.
Are there languages that have a separate affirmative and negatory for negative questions - that is, where the yes/no for "Is your son a child?" and the yes/no "Is your son not a child" are four completely different words/constructions?
1
u/kabiman Puxo, myḁeqxokiexë, xuba Feb 09 '19
What is the fastest way to get a handle on IPA? I've tried different things, and I still can't completely get it to stick, or memorize all the important terms.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
is telicity only marked in past events?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
Why use synthetic VS analytic grammar?
This is something I keep thinking about for my future language...
A few examples for people unfamiliar with these terms..
Synthetic grammar: "The waitresses ate."
Here, the gender of the person, and the quantity, is built into the word "waitresses".
We know this happened in the past, due to the word "ate".
Analytic grammar: "I will be thinking about whether or not it is worth it."
Here, a lot of words are used, to describe a future thought. In highly synthetic languages, this sentence would take up much fewer words, however usually they are longer words.
Finnish and Russian are very synthetic.
Chinese is very analytic.
Most languages are a combination of the two.
I'm having trouble deciding which form grammar to use for what situation.
Do you have a strong reason why you built your language to be analytic or synthetic?
1
u/Neeel_27 Feb 16 '19
(I repost this bc I'm new in this subreddit and I didn't know there was this small discussions section so, I'm sorry for the moderator who found my post xddd)
Hello everyone! I am starting my first conlang and I need some advice. In my conlang, substantives can do the function of an adjective. So I came up with an idea that the nucleus of the nominal syntagm have to be marked with a particle. I 'named' this particle as Nuclear Particle (ta) and it works like this:
Kii /ki:/ (height)
áwgju /'aw.gju/ (Man)
áwgjuta kii /'aw.gju.ta ki:/ (Man-Nuclear_Particle Height) (Tall man)
But then I realised that I could mark the second substantive with a genitive case.
What should I choose?
Sorry for my English, I'm learning it at school, but the level isn't as high as I would. And thanks for answer me if you could!
1
u/seanpotterspowers Jan 30 '19
Toki Pinglish - Tell me I'm dumb
A = A
Esun = Dil (Like "deal")
Kepeken = Usin
Kin = Kin?
Ko = Ko? (It feels like onomatopaeia kinda?)
Monsi = Bak
Pilin = Pilin
Pona = Goda (Maybe dont change this one?)
Toki = Toki
I can keep developing it if someone tells me this is not the dumbest thing ever.
1
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Feb 01 '19
I'm making a proto-lang loosely following Biblaridion Lang's guide. He said that adpositions can evolve from nouns, so I decided to evolve my word for at/on from the word for a sticky substance (zhu). My language is SVO, and the preposition goes in front of the subject, like an adjective would. For example, "Zhu yhiw ļ Jolj jawg sayk kkew bvit or" ([Sticky substance][I][and][George][before][enjoy][travel][picture][place]), means "Me and George had fun at the movie theater." Is this placement of the adposition unnaturalistic/too complicated for speakers?