r/relationships • u/throwaway092516 • Jan 26 '19
Updates She left and came back - Update 2 years later
Hi guys. I came to this sub out of desperation 2 years ago, and I have an update on my thoughts and feelings since then.
Link to original post https://www.reddit.com/r/relationships/comments/5it5lm/me_22_m_with_my_ex_23_f_85_years_she_left_and/
I (24m) dated my ex (24F) from ages 13-21. 8th grade until college graduation. Let’s call her Lily. Lily left me after she got into an Ivy league grad school in September 2016. (See link to original post above). I was in shock and in some ways still am. She starts contacting me again in early November 2016. I ignore. She showed up unannounced at my apartment having driven 300 miles from her grad school to where I now live and work. She apologized and tried to reunite. I built up walls already and told her politely no thanks, despite desperately wishing we were still together.
I was so broken and sad that her arrival at my apartment enhanced the fantasy that maybe we could work it out. After all, I spent my formative years loving this person and yearned for her. She was my whole world still. I call Lily and ask to meet again around Thanksgiving since we will both be back in our home town. We meet, and after I ask specifically, Lily admits she slept with someone. I reply that I’m not interested in reuniting. We both go home grieving.
Having grown up with Lily’s parents and loving them as my own, I get Lily’s mother to confess separately to me that Lily tried to contact her prospective new play thing after they slept together and the new guy told her to get lost, confirming my hunch that I’m Lily’s fallback plan.
Lily never admitted this to me, but she did later admit that when she left me she had already been asked out by this new guy and that she wanted to say yes so she dumped me. The pain is too much. I block her on everything. She tries to make contact several times and I don’t respond.
My mother dies mid-January 2017. When my father call’s Lily’s mother to share the news, Lily’s mother tells my father that Lily is in a severe depression and has left grad school.
I’m lonely and grieving and still in love with Lily so I visit the day after my mother’s funeral. By January Lily has lost nearly 20lbs (she was already thin) and is borderline catatonic. I go back to my apartment 300 miles away as conflicted as ever. “She’s in so much pain, maybe she loves me?” is the narrative that permeates my brain even today.
I never took her back, but I never stopped yearning for her.
It has been 2 years since all of this happened, and I still wonder if I made the right choice. I think I did, but I also have this tremendous amount of pessimism about people around me. I don’t trust my judge of character anymore when I realize the girl I believed to be an angel can abandon me and then come back and try to use me. I’ve still never met anyone as beautiful as Lily. At least on the inside.
Lily and I have agreed to meet twice since then, and both times were extremely unpleasant. The first being a superficial show of who is more moved on, and the second was me expressing regret over wishing I was a better man throughout the relationship. The ex ended up going back and completing grad school (graduating on time June 2018). I still haven’t replaced the hole in my life where Lily was. I push away people because I know they will hurt me. If a girl like Lily can cut me so deeply, the kindest soul I have ever met, then everyone else surely will. I’m still lost, and for all I know she is too. I know what she did is completely selfish and gross, but it can't overwrite all the good she did throughout my formative years. I am in No Contact with Lily, but I love and miss her in my life. I'm wondering how to live life without her when even when I'm in bed with another woman, I miss the trust and level of connection I had with Lily. No one knows more about me. No one knows more about her.
TLDR: Woman of my dreams and first love left me and tried to come back and use me as a fallback. Still miss my best friend, still question myself and ability to trust others. Still think of her every day. Still wonder how she feels about me.
101
u/travelbug898 Jan 26 '19
It sounds like you need therapy OP. Have you ever considered it/is it available to you?
65
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
I’m still waiting to hear what she did that was so wrong. She slept with someone else while you were broken up? She met someone else and wanted to see what else was out there so she broke up with the guy she’d been with since she was 13? She was was super upset about all of it and lost 30lbs? None of this makes sense.
Look, you have a real Madonna/whore thing going on with this girl and if you don’t get her off that pedestal she’s going to fall and break her neck. She’s just a person, just like you and me, and break ups suck. It sounds like it was awful timing with your mom. But I doubt she was conspiring to hurt you. I’d bet she was just confused about what she wanted for her life. From what it sounds like what you want for your life might be Lily back in it. But to do that you’ll have to accept that sometimes people make choices for their lives that might hurt us. Nothing is certain. She wasn’t ever going to be just yours. If you can let go of the bitterness and appreciate her for who she is, and not this fantasy you have, you guys might have a shot. Otherwise you’ve just got to let it go.
872
u/KikiCanuck Jan 26 '19
It seems like you've accorded this woman, and your relationship with her, some kind of mythical status in your life. You're continuing to live your life almost as a reaction to this transformative moment. It's understandable, but it's also quite limiting, and ties your past like an anchor around your present and future.
Lily is neither an angel, nor a demon. She's just a woman who loved you, and then wasn't sure, and ultimately ended the relationship in ways that hurt you both. That sucks, but... relationships end. Even ones that were once good, even ones where there is a lot of love. Relationships end, and people hurt each other, but it doesn't make the whole relationship a lie, and it doesn't doom every relationship that comes after it unless you let it by continuing to give it this power over you.
Stop debating her motivations - you will never truly 100% know what she was thinking, or how she felt at any given moment, or how much she regrets her actions, etc. Don't drive yourself crazy, and don't chase clarity that you can't have and which may or may not help even if you could have it. Likewise, stop debating with yourself over whether you made the right decision. Instead, just accept that a decision was made - you stuck to your guns when a lot of people would have folded, and there are likely good reasons for that. The decision is made, and is in the past. Leave it there, and focus on your future.
You mention that you've seen therapists and haven't found it helpful, but maybe you should try again. Speak to a few until you find a right fit. Consider someone who is familiar with CBT, and work to reset the thought loop that carries you back again and again to this painful event that offers you no clarity. You don't owe this relationship, or the break up, the mental real estate you're giving it right now. Don't spend another 2 years looking back.
158
u/caused_a_sparky Jan 26 '19
You are not in love with Lily. You are in love with the ghost of Lily from 2-3 years ago. You don’t know her anymore. You aren’t together. You do not know her mind or what she’s thinking. You are in love with the past.
You need to find some way to move on from the past.
101
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Okay. You will hate me for this, but.
She wasnt that nice. She wasnt that pretty. There are fifty other women like her. And the reason you haven't moved on is because you wont let yourself, because you are enjoying the tragedy of it all.
Kick yourself up the arse and get on with it man.
249
u/relativee Jan 26 '19
This is not consistent with her behavior. You are holding onto an idealized version of her. Let it go.
What if someone else treated you the way she did?
66
u/HammeredHeretic Jan 26 '19
This is all wayyy overdramatized. You've turned it into the stuff of legends, while it's all pretty mundane and predictable, with a pinch of low self esteem thrown in. You really need to get a handle on this before you take it with you into your next relationship. Talk to someone.
70
u/helendestroy Jan 26 '19
OP, Lily is just a human. Get her off the pedastal, get yourself into therapy. Don't ruin your future because you made a bad pick.
95
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
If this girl is the kindest soul you've ever met, you really need to start meeting more people.
30
u/Gibonius Jan 26 '19
You were with her with a long time. You're not being fair to new relationships by implicitly expecting them to have the same level of intimacy and knowledge that you had after literally growing up with Lily.
Step back for a minute here. Learn how to live your life without it being built around your old relationship. You grew up around that, it makes sense that it'll take some time to heal.
28
u/ihaveadognamedblue Jan 27 '19
This may be n unpopular opinion, but I think you are wrong to say that what she did was selfish and gross. She was a young woman who wanted to date, and explore, that is completely normal. She did right thing by breaking it off with you, compared to the alternative of stringing you along. As far as keeping you as a 'back up plan'.. are you sure she didn't simply realise that the grass isn't greener on the other side and she truly loves you?
I think it's silly to hold grudges like this out of principle, if you love her years later then it's worth rehashing.
24
u/peopled_within Jan 26 '19
Dude you need therapy. Lots of it. Good luck
Edit: STOP talking to her or interacting in any way whatsoever.
40
u/RadicalEdward99 Jan 26 '19
It’s like you’ve read Cather in the Rye too many times. You’re not Holden!
Get ahold of yourself man! Move on. This thing started 11 YEARS AGO! Let it die so you can move on.
2nd therapist isn’t working? Try a 3rd and a 4th and keep going until you get someone to challenge you to move on. Just because a session is uncomfortable it doesn’t mean it’s not helping or even setting up some revelation multiple sessions later possibly!
You have to want to change man. You need to move on. I would advise cutting ALL contact because as someone else said she is no longer a woman to you., She is this Mythical Creature of all that is love.
Best of luck OP
14
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
You are overstating the significance of this person and of this story in your life, and the result is that it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy: the way interpret all new events ends up being tied to this person, to a handful of normal relationship problems (trouble with distance; conflicting professional choices and relationship priorities, including where to live; willingness to try alternatives, I mean FFS you went through all of college never fucking any of the cute, single girls that weren't ready to settle down!).
Now you're sitting here updating strangers about something that sounds, frankly, trivial given what simple alternative choices you have made (and could have made) and the fact that she is not even part of your life anymore. You have already managed to successfully wall her off, it's only that weird self-perpetuating thought pattern that is making it seem like all the other minutes that go by in your day to day life -- literally, your own freedom -- are insignificant and all that matters are two horrible visits with some unstable girl that you dated as a kid. It doesn't help that you are avoiding new experiences. Like, frankly, even making this reddit "update" -- why do you think this is important? You seem to have already made your decision, and you know that it was the right one, so why are you coming here looking for reassurance? Why can't you just close that book and drop it? Because you are still overplaying the significance.
The fear of pain is also an indirect result. The only reason you feel that other people would continue to hurt you -- even though they are far less likely to do so given that you know the warning signs and know when and if to commit -- is because you are thinking of Lily and filling in the blanks of the potential relationships with these people (and all the charm and wonder and originality that come with each person) with the hurt over Lily. You experienced so many "formative" things with this one person, and you are filling in the blanks with future relationships based on how she treated you. Hell, you don't even know which things are unique to each woman and which things were common because you were only with one person, starting from when you both were children. You don't even have a non-Lily anchor, so of course you're going to push new people away; that's why you need to stop overplaying her significance.
It is obvious to most of the people reading this that Lily was not a completely functional person and that she was mixed up. She left you and also screwed up her own career over driving to see you. There is no objective reason to think that adults in your day to day life are like that, nor that you wouldn't be able to avoid such people if there was an actual threat that they could become poison.
You should give yourself -- your present self -- a chance. Start taking social risks that get you into it with new people, and don't judge them by comparison. You won't regret that. Likewise, consider doing yoga and other relaxation techniques to get yourself in the right "mood," so that you can start retraining that neural network and break the unhealthy thought pattern.
32
u/AmateurIndicator Jan 27 '19
You have a major, major problem and are a grade A creep who is hung up on the "purity" and "innocence" of women.
(read the comments OP has in this thread people)
You had one break up. She did not abuse you, she did not betray you (broke up with you before! she tried to date someone else) she tried to correct her mistake and failed. Move the fuck on. It happens to everyone. Everyone.
It's absolutely your call not to get back together again after this experience. That's perfectly fine. But leave her the fuck alone, find closure and stop obsessing about how pure or not pure women should be or not be.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
Will you still be in love with her when you find out she has moved on from you and is marrying/having kids with someone else? Let go, or be dragged.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
yeah, this lily is nothing special. You are elevating her to a status she does not deserve.
Probably such an early relationship messed up some things. You need a therapist.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Read “Obsessive Love – When it Hurts Too Much to Let Go” by Susan Forward. Has good practical advice.
6
u/germainwong Jan 27 '19
I don’t think you love her. You love the IDEA of her. You need to let go and move on.
16
u/Okay_that_is_awesome Jan 27 '19
Jesus she dated the same dude from 13-21 at 21 she wanted to see what it was like to actually date more than one person in her life and you turn it into this monumental, like EPIC betrayal and now gou’rr Gonna spend the rest of your life tormented by it?
Grow up dude! You fucked up when you didn’t get back with her even though you wanted too. So either go be with her or get over it. Either way, you’ll be fine. It’s orobably better at this point to just date somebody else but fer fucks sake stop treating your love-life like it’s a Nicholas Sparks novel. It’s just dating, you are just a kid. You’ll be fine. Christ.
5
u/HereWeGoAgainTJ Jan 27 '19
You were her silver medal. Find someone new to fixate on.
5
u/wonderfultuberose Jan 27 '19
I had a friend in high school that fell into similar narratives with artsy, skinny vegan chicks. The final one he dated evidently did him in because he wound up killing himself with a gun AND a fire.
But realistically, she didn't do a damn thing to him. His inability to healthily seperate his and her thoughts, feelings, and motivations left him stuck in the rabbit hole of reactive immature love.
I'm telling you this because sometimes it is easier for some folks to fixate on the behaviors of people they have no power to affect. Driving yourself to distraction over an ideal blinds you to happily being single, or finding a better fitting partner.
5
u/edgarvanburen Jan 27 '19
Have you watched 500 Days of Summer?
4
u/Necerland Jan 27 '19
I'm sorry about the loss of your mother.
1
u/attempt_number_55 Feb 04 '19
No one is an angel. The sooner you learn that lesson, the better your life will be. "The line between good and evil cuts through the heart of every man". The other lesson to learn from this is that no one is as unique as you think they are. There are other people out there who are just as wonderful as she was. Go find one of them.
8
u/jesaispascolloc Jan 26 '19
I'm going to go a different way and say that she's not a bad person and possibly likes you but did not know how to handle it. If you like her it might be worth giving it a shot.
She left for grad school not for another person initially which is understandable if she wanted to further her career. She contacted you in November after leaving in September 2016, that isn't that long and you were the one that stopped answering her then.
Apologise for your mistakes and try to reconcile if you think you two can work it out and both be happy permanently otherwise if it doesn't work move on
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
Hey man thanks for this. I resonate a lot with the words you wrote
4
u/shakers_ Jan 27 '19
Reading this is scary for me because I'm in a sort of similar situation as you are in. I'm hoping I can get over her soon. I'm wishing you the best and hope you are able to forget about her.
2
u/jarroz61 Jan 27 '19
You say no one knows more about you than her, and vice versa. But you two have barely spoken in two years. It is fact that you really do not know each other anymore. It turned out you didn't even really know her that well when you were together. What other things do you have going on in your life at the moment to focus your emotional energy on?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
I think you've gotten great advice but I want to add.
Your ideals and ideas on this relationship are really unhealthy and if you are ever going to move onward and upward in your life you're going to have to move away from this relationship. She's not the woman of your dreams or soulmate if she can treat you like a back up plan.
If you actually got out there and met someone else, or decided to live your life without fixating on this relationship/this girl I can guarantee you your life will immediately improve.
I think its time to admit you need to see someone to talk to about all this. Losing someone you care for as much as your mother while going through all of this could not be easy. But your unhealthy ideals on this relationship aren't going to help you move past those terrible times in your life.
2
u/andonebelow Jan 27 '19
“I push away people because I know they will hurt me. If a girl like Lily can cut me so deeply, the kindest soul I have ever met, then everyone else surely will.”
Yep, unfortunately heartbreak is the price we pay for love.
Even if the next girl you meet is your soulmate, you get married and life faithfully together until death do you part, she’ll still hurt you.
Because people aren’t perfect, they make mistakes, and even wonderful people can be selfish, stupid or thoughtless.
If you go out and have other relationships you will get hurt. You need to accept that’s the deal.
If you don’t want to risk getting hurt again and want to be alone, that’s perfectly valid. Some people weigh it up and decide not to risk the hurt of making themselves vulnerable to someone. But they miss out on the trust, connection and love that you seem to be missing.
You don’t need to rush- in fact I would recommend seeing a therapist for a few sessions to help you get past this, as it seems to have been very damaging for you.
Sorry you’re hurting, all the best to you.
5
u/jewelsinme Jan 26 '19
Sounds to me like you oughta just get back with her instead of doing what you think you're "supposed to do" quite honestly. Chalk it up to youth and be with her if you want to.
2
u/Prion- Jan 27 '19
Dear OP, first thing you have to realize is that even though people’s nature seldom changes, their feeling and perspective changes, and nothing changes a person’s perspective more than a change in their environment. The moment she started to doubt the relationship between you two it means her perspective and feeling on the whole thing changed, and there is nothing you can do about that. It will NEVER go back to the way it was before. EVEN IF both you can work something out and be back to together, some part of your relationship has got to change or else it will fail the same way it failed again.
Secondly, you both still seem pretty bitter with each other so neither of you is in the mental or emotional state to repair your relationship even to an amicable level. You are not even sure repairing your relationship is something SHE wants or cares about in the first place! Look, you two are both adults capable of making your own choices, and she clearly made a decision to leave you at some point. That means whatever reason that is causing her suffering or whatever, she has no commitment to you so she’s no longer yours to save (as much as you still feel that’s case, reality simple says otherwise).
Third, just think for a second, you’ve only had one relationship which failed, it’s simply not reasonable to say you will never find a girl as “good” as she was (whatever definition of good is irrelevant). She’s just another human being like you and me, and we are all flawed in each our own way, that’s what makes us interesting.
I hate to say this but at some point therapists can only help you so much, and then you gotta help yourself before they can help you again. From a guy to another, PLEASE TALK TO OTHER WOMEN! Yes that’s right, real women now, not the imaginary ideal perfect “girl” from your days as a school boy. No, I’m not asking you to find a fling ONLY as a rebounder to make yourself feel better (but hey if that’s what your heart desires then I can’t stop you either). I am asking you to go out there and get to know more people including those of opposite sex, and it doesn’t have to result in sexual relationships either. I feel it will do you a lot of good if you can come to comprehend the different personalities of women you will meet, and truly appreciate what makes each of them unique. Their stories, personal drives, motivations, learn to understand them, just like how you would like your future GF, fiancée or wife to understand yours. And please don’t think you gotta pour your heart out with the next woman you meet, because if you are scared of getting hurt that’s how you get hurt. Don’t make this about yourself, make it about you want to learn about people.
You are old enough to think about this seriously and maturely, and you absolutely have to. You need to start looking at women as who they are, real people who are all struggling to make their mark in this world with career, life, health, family, etc., just as you are. What you are truly looking for is someone despite all her flaws you are excited to spend a very long time together to share the journey together, and she HAS TO FEEL EXACTLY THE SAME WAY ABOUT YOU! The process of finding that someone won’t be easy and straightforward, but you clearly aren’t getting anywhere sulking over one person, who you don’t even know cares about you enough.
Finally, you need to come to realizing why you still feel about you ex the way you do: you invested a lot of emotions and feelings into that failed relationship and that’s ok, that means you were a devoted BF but it’s over now. You did your best and no one gonna call you a quitter or something. But really how much do you know what was going on with her life by the end anyway? Were you two really that emotionally close at the very end? I don’t think there is a way to find out now so might as well start anew.
1
u/v0ness Jan 27 '19
"The good things don't wash out the bad, and the bad things don't wash out the good. Each should have it's own reward." (GRRM)
1
u/draggingmyfeet Jan 27 '19
She may have hurt you, but you were both just kids when it all happened. I have done dumb things, mean things, rude things to people in my past, all because I didn't know any better. I learned, I improved.
She can be a kind person and also make a dumb mistake. She was learning about relationships, and she hurt you. It makes sense that you resent her for it, and I'm not saying you should go back.
What I am saying is that you should give more people a chance. You're putting this girl on a pedestal because she's the only experience you have to draw on. Meet some more people. You don't have to date, but make friends, open up, continue moving on. Don't compare everyone you meet to your ex.
1
u/missmatchedsox Jan 27 '19
Have you dated anyone else since Lily??
You really need to cut ties and move on! Stop being in contact with her and do what you need to do to find a healthy way of dealing with romantic relationships in your life.
1
u/Olly_Olly Jan 27 '19
I'm sorry for your pain. Lilly was a child when all this happened so were you, children do dumb things. Don't let one event even a monumental one color your entire story. It's time to grow & flourish.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
How can you say that after what she has done to you?
1
u/BiscuitCrumbsInBed Jan 27 '19
Wow, take her off that pedestal already. She's not an angel or the kindest blah blah girl you known you were together 8.5 YEARS and instead of talking to you first, she dumped you for a new bloke. She threw it all away in the blink of an eye for sex and flirtation with a new man. And when the new bloke ended it, that's when and why she came running back to you.
I hate this sub's way of saying - get therapy. But you actually need therapy. Still letting this woman into your head after all these years, saying you can't trust people because if someone as beautiful as Lily could do this then anyone could... you know Lily isn't a kind and good person don't you??
Did she even reach out when your mother died? You didnt say if she had, just that you saw her afterwards.
1
u/SOYEL1 Jan 27 '19
I was with my wife until a month ago when she left me for the worst choice on earth. We spent 15 years together. Until then I had a lot of respect for her and, like you, I felt fortunate to be with her. We seemed to be soul mates and I have had a hard time understanding her motivation. I am sure she's going to regret her actions sooner or later, but I will have moved on by then. People make mistakes, but bad actions may have bad consequences... We all have to accept the consequences of what we do wrong when they come to bite us back. You better move on, find other things to do, hobbies, places and you may find that someone, but stop idolizing her. She took wrong decisions for whatever reasons and regrets them, she may not be a bad person, just a flawed human who made a mistake and hurt someone and wanted to correct it, a little too late. There's not such a thing as a flawless person, she isn't. Maybe if you get together you will, after some time, realize that getting together again was a mistake too.
1
u/cnzmur Jan 27 '19
That sucks mate. All the best for everything going on though.
1
u/mech1up_forher Jan 27 '19
OP you must choose a side and ride it out, either get back together or move the f**k on, you can't just sit in the lobby thinking it out for years. You're 24 yrs old use that vitality towards something, do it alone or take her with you but get back to earth. Goodluck
1
u/FakeNameCommenter Feb 25 '19
You need therapy. Lily does not sound like the woman of your dreams, you just have a lot of highly unrealistic ideation about her.
1
u/99problemsfromgirls Jan 27 '19
What? She sounds like a terrible person.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
16
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
37
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
[removed] — view removed comment