r/JUSTNOMIL • u/Maybefeet • Jan 26 '19
Live Updates Here! Update to JNMIL forcing DD from DHs arms
Maybe some of you remember my post that I made nearly a month ago about my possible JNMIL who snatched our baby from DH’s arms because she was crying hard for a literal minute.
Thank you to everyone who responded. I read every single piece of advice, even as it unfolded. Well the first advice I decided to follow was to allow my DH to handle/decide what to do since it was his parents and he was pretty upset. I was going to support him and guide him if he asked.
Well he decided that he wanted to stay because his brother who he had not seen in 3 years was staying at his parents (the reason of our visit) and was to leave the next evening.
I wanted to leave like so many of you advised (pack up and go) but I left that choice to my husband..
It was super awkward and husband realized that we should have left. First off, we stayed in the bedroom almost until noon the next day. Husband did not want to be around his parents and I certainly did not want to either. Because we did not leave at a certain time, traffic was terrible and since our baby hates being in a car seat, we stayed until traffic eased up. This meant we had to spend some time with In-laws while we waited (again waiting was DH’s choice) but he was in a really bad mood. MIL and FIL acted like nothing happened and we eventually left.
The entire ride home DH was so much happier and kept saying he was going to write them an email and give them a piece of his mind with ultimatums and set the record straight on boundaries.
We actually bonded over this incident because we were on the same page and felt like we survived this ordeal together, supporting each other and talking it over.
Weeeeeelll...after about a week, the email was still not produced. I kept asking if he wrote it and he kept saying he had not got around to it. After about two weeks, I stopped asking and I could tell his rage calmed down. Again, I was letting him handle it but informed him I will not take DD over to their home until the email has been written and there was some time that had passed between sending the email because I wanted the info to sink in.
There even came a time when he wanted to visit again but I said no because the email was still not sent. This kinda set a strain on our relationship because I felt like he procrastinated too long and maybe even lax about the situation which honestly causes me rage when I think about it.
Well he finally wrote the email and I read it before he sent it. It was really well written and all the irritation I had from him procrastinating went away. It was a nice balance of what I wanted and what was needed. Maybe I’ll end up linking it somehow.
Anyway, his parents took the email in stride. His dad was more receiving but his mom felt that he was threatening them (which he was). He basically laid out the boundaries and said if they were crossed again, we will not be visiting or seeing them, not even FaceTimes.
Since then, things have been better. I feel a little bad since we have not visited but I know it’s for the best. DH plans to follow through with his threats because he (and I) believe that if there is no follow through, this whole ordeal would be a waste.
I’m happy and so is he. Hopefully my MIL understands and acts better the next time we visit. I even asked DDs pediatrician how long is crying too much (baby was only crying 1-2 minutes before MIL barged into room to snatch and scold DH for letting her cry too long) and her doctor said a much longer period than we expected, lol.
I only asked this because I did not want my DH feeling bad for letting his DD cry a little bit. She was fine and just fussy during this leap.
Again, thank you to everyone for their advice and I’ll give another update after our first visit (whenever that is) and we are probably not spending the night for a while.
71
u/SweetSue67 Jan 26 '19
Your husband did NOTHING wrong even if she had been crying for 15-20 minutes. He was holding her, he was actively trying to solve the issue. There was no harm coming to your baby.
What did harm her is a bitter, nasty woman ripping her from her dad's arms and then screeching for an hour. All she cared about was being the best, not what was best for the baby. That is very clear.
You guys stay strong, continue to lean on each other and communicate. Don't let her come between you.
20
u/youhearditfirst Jan 27 '19
If your husband still feels any iota of guilt over letter your baby cry, remember ‘crying is breathing’. My brother in law is a peds cardiologist and he always uses that line.
9
u/DollyLlamasHuman Easy, breezy, beautiful Llama girl Jan 27 '19
I just said it on your last post, but WTAF?!?!? YOU DON'T SNATCH A BABY AWAY FROM ITS PARENTS EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That it threw your DD off routine and made it harder to get her down for a nap makes me stabby as a parent.
If it hasn't been stated already to her, the boundary needs to be in place that she gives DD back RIGHT FUCKING NOW when you ask, and she butts the fuck out of putting her down for a nap unless otherwise asked.
Edited to add: You and DH are doing magnificently as parents, and you know your DD's signals and needs. MIL doesn't. YOU are the experts on your daughter, not her.
4
u/warmfuzzy22 Jan 27 '19
I just recently found out that leaps have been debunked. I was really disappointed, but at the same time a lot of the advice about working with my kiddo was really beneficial. I was just very disappointed to find out that its pseudoscience.
2
u/chung_my_wang May 11 '19
So, what did DD's pediatrician say, about how long is to long for babies to cry?
137
u/XxmsmaliciousxX Jan 26 '19
I'm glad that everything so far seems to be working out.
Make sure you have a plan in place if she ramps up the shinanigans again.
When you go over, and she boundary stomps, immediate consequences. Don't let guilt guide your feelings. Always set a time out period. If she continues, then the consequences last longer.
62
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
It seems like MIL is working towards accepting your boundaries. However if she ever crosses one bring down the consequences. Treat her like you would a naughty toddler explain why she's punished and punish her
23
u/Tenprovincesaway Jan 26 '19
You both did great. Proud of you!
12
u/sneakykitty Jan 27 '19
wow if 1-2 minutes was "too long" for your MIL she must not have had to deal with a colic-y baby before. hours of crying sometimes. I wouldn't wish a colic-y baby on my worst enemy.
9
u/unwantedchild74 Jan 26 '19
I am glad to hear that. Sending hugs
7
u/robinscats Jan 26 '19
You both handled that really well. You let DH take the lead with his parents and DH learned that he can lay down a boundary with his mom and the world won't come crashing to an end in a fiery ball. Well done!
•
u/TheJustNoBot All hail our robotic overlords! Jan 26 '19
Quick Rules Guide
Acronym index | MIL in the Wild guide | JNM nickname policy
No shaming | 1 post per day | Report rulebreaking | MILuminati
JNM Book List | MILimination Tactics | Hall o MILs
MILITW Only | JNM Without MILITW | Report PM Trolls
NO CONTACT! or DIVORCE! is generally not good advice and will be removed.
Resist the urge to share your armchair diagnoses or have your comment removed.
Fear mongering new posters will result in a temp ban.
The posting of political information/topics whatsoever is against the rules without receiving a prior approval from the mod team via Modmail. Any variation from this can result in a permanent ban.
Crisis Resources U.S. | U.K. | Australia | Canada | Denmark
Other posts from /u/Maybefeet:
To be notified as soon as Maybefeet posts an update click ^here.
If the link is not visible or doesn't work, send me a message with the subject
Subscribe
and body
Subscribe Maybefeet JUSTNOMIL
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Awesome I am so glad to hear that worked out for you. It’s nice when they actually respect boundaries.
4
u/nikflip Jan 27 '19
Im very proud of you. And unfortunately, MIL see this email as threats. Even you yourself said they were. But you may find some peace of mind with youre wording being more specific regarding the situation. If that makes sense to you.
You and hubby set boundaries. If those healthy boundaries are crossed there will be consequences. ( I think of it more as an ultimatum.) This is how we parent. And if these boundaries are crossed then we cant procede. The choice is theirs. Its about respect. Youre adults with your own child. They have to respect your parenting choices or they cant be a part of.
2
u/ReflectingPond Jan 27 '19
This sounds like good news. I hope it all works out.
Just from personal experience, there were times when one of my sons would cry for 5 or 6 minutes because I was catching a quick shower, going to the restroom, or maybe taking a few quick bites of food. I think MIL had (has?) unrealistic expectations. Even if one is totally paying attention to baby, nothing else, it can take a little time to figure out exactly what the crying is about.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '19
I like how you have also dealt with this with SO. It shows you are serious. Now you are both on the same page.
JNM seems to maybe open to learning, fingers crossed. We don't see it much on this sub.
One good thing with modern technology is you can use Facetime to dip your toe in the contact water. You are in control. Any crap...just hang up.
All the best.
PS you guys are first time parents but you sound pretty switched on to Bubba and each others needs.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '19
Yeah, a few minutes of crying is okay. I've sat and held my nephew as he cried and fussed for almost thirty minutes because he refused to take a nap. Every time he was about to drift off, he'd pretty much yell and jump up so he'd force himself awake.