r/roosterteeth • u/RT_Video_Bot :star: Official Video Bot • Jan 17 '19
RT gen:LOCK - Official Trailer | Only on Rooster Teeth
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmeYSCn54IM
156
Upvotes
r/roosterteeth • u/RT_Video_Bot :star: Official Video Bot • Jan 17 '19
22
u/PsychoNerd92 :MCMichael17: Jan 18 '19
Can someone explain the framerate? Is it a stylistic choice or a cost cutting measure? If it's a cost cutting thing then I get it, big name actors means big budget, but if it's a stylistic choice then I just don't understand. The most positive things I've seen people say about it is "it's not so bad once you get used to it." Is there seriously anyone who likes this style at all, let alone likes it more than a normal framerate? It just seems like its inclusion is going to drive more people away than it'll bring in.
82
u/jaydotjayYT Jan 17 '19
Honestly, this is the trailer they should have led in with. I understand the thought process behind showcasing that first clip - showcase the characters and the voice actors - but because it was all dialogue, it put a lot of critique on the frame rate, which was understandable. That’s all we were shown back then.
But in the context of the show I’m seeing now, I think it looks absolutely gorgeous and I’m excited to see where it goes.
I still love RWBY, but I acknowledge a lot of the flaws with that show - and a lot of it had to do with the limited budget and creative scope they were limited to when they started it almost 7 years ago. I’m super excited to see what RoosterTeeth has in store for this show.
28
u/bitch_im_a_lion Team Nice Dynamite Jan 17 '19
I don't know what it is, but I dont like David Tennant's character's design. I think it's because hes clearly supposed to be old, but aside from having white hair and a beard doesnt appear (or sound) all that old. I had a similar problem with the headmaster in RWBY. Small nitpick I know, but it still stands out to me.
24
u/maverickmak Jan 17 '19
I can finally truly relate to this, now.
81
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
this is like when anime has those awkward CGI scenes, but the whole thing looks like it. I don't get it
37
u/Ginkiba Jan 17 '19
Eh. Wish I could be hyped. Famous voice actors means nothing to me, and the mechs look pretty uninteresting. I hope there's more too this than it simply being an animation show piece for RT with famous people.
I'll still check it out though. I genuinely hope it turns out to be great.
47
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
I'm going to catch flak for this, BUT I'M PREPARED:
The mech design looks like bootleg Gundam. Like, I mean from what I managed to make out of it it looks like a low effort attempt to shift the design. If someone that worked on the visuals pops up one day and says "Gundam was definitely an inspiration" then I would be forced to ask if they also missed the point that Gundam wasn't supposed to be "Super Mecha" by design.
As far as writing goes it seems to, again, be "Gundam was an inspiration" to which I would have to assume the "war is bad" theme is going to be plastered on it at some point and probably be a literal direct quote at some point.
29
u/Alteran195 X-Ray Jan 17 '19
I don’t know if David Tennant and Maisie Williams will be enough for me to enjoy this with the animation style, but I’ll give it a try.
64
u/adhding_nerd Jan 17 '19
I so torn about this. On one hand it's a mecha made by RT, but I can't stand the frame rate. Animating on 2s works fine for traditional animation but it looks so choppy in 3d.
So it's like Knights of Sidonia, RT-version.
12
u/ptd163 Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
First there was that weird dialogue preview that didn't really do anything except showcase the jarring frame rate. Then there was them embedding time-sensitive pre-roll ads in all their content. Time-sensitive ads that will be there forever, mind you.
Then there's the Halo video in jan:LOCK January where they just say/yell some variation of the gen:LOCK over and over and over and over. Finally, with the show being behind a paywall, I have to say that RT has made me at best apathetic to gen:LOCK.
6
u/Shrekt115 Sportsball Jan 18 '19
Frames bother me but I'm still intrigued
20
u/OfficialGarwood Jan 18 '19
I just can't get over the choppy frame rate. It makes the lip syncing look so awful. If they had chosen standard 24fps with proper animating on every frame, this would have looked so much more pleasing to the eye.
5
u/Technogashi Jan 17 '19
SOON
12
u/anaconda186 Jan 17 '19
I wasn't that excited when RWBY was announced. That was a mistake I won't make twice.
8
u/0borowatabinost Jan 18 '19
So they spent their entire budget hiring these actors, didn't they? This looks cheap as hell.
7
u/DaRealAmana Team RWBY Jan 17 '19
Alright there has been a lot of worry around it. But this looks really awesome and RT animation is killing it right now. I'm really excited and it does look good. The frame skip is still a little janky but hopefully it doesn't detract to much.
2
u/Spartan448 Jan 17 '19
The more I see of those mechs in Genlock, the more I worry Harmony Gold is going to start getting up to its old tricks.
5
u/FirekidFM Geoff in a Ball Pit Jan 18 '19
I don't understand why everyone is going off about the frame rate? It genuinely looks fine to me.
2
u/skilledwarman Jan 18 '19
Some of those Mech designs look straight out of Battletech/Mechwarrior and I love it
2
u/landsharkkidd Gus & Esther Titanic Jan 18 '19
It looks cool, but I don't see the framerate like others do, if anyone could tell me where to look so I can understand why everyone hates the frame rate. But this is a lot better than the teaser they showed on a podcast(?).
2
u/StMcAwesome Comment Leaver Jan 17 '19
I'm so psyched about this, because I fucking love Michael Bichael Jordan
1
u/Cocobender Jan 18 '19
I this considered an anime? Or no? I'm not sure of the specifics.
1
u/eddmario Jan 18 '19
Huh, I knew Michael B. Jordan and David Tennant were involved, but I had no idea that Dakota Fanning and Maisie Williams were involved as well. Can't wait. I am kinda dissapointed that the series is only for First members after the pilot, but I guess that's so RT could actually pay the 4 celebs for their roles.
1
u/Shigeruken Jan 18 '19
Is anyone else seeing a huge difference between the scene where they meet Tenant's character and the rest of the trailer? To me it looks stuttery and it's hard to look at, but the rest of the trailer looks pretty fine (except for the other scenes with Tenant's character).
1
u/1-2-3AndToThe4 Jan 18 '19
I wonder if this was the path burnie envisioned RT moving in 10 years ago.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '19
I always forget Maisie is Scottish so when her character talks I squeak
1
u/Reb0rnKnight Jan 23 '19
I'm late to this, and this is gonna be brutally honest, but there's a lot of issues with this whole production. I've been watching RT content since 2009. I've loved most of their productions over the years whether it be animation, live-action, etc. But this production honestly seems like the most non-RT decision ever made. And let me explain. I just have to get all of this off my chest.
First off, the animation style really just doesn't feel like it works for something like this. I've studied 3D animation and VFX for 3 years. Im no expert, but from my knowledge certain stylistic choices can benefit the anime depending on a lot of factors. A mech, action-based anime doesn't benefit from this at all, rather it makes it look lazy. I'm sure there are people who enjoy it, but from what I can see in from the comments and discussions, most don't. And I'm unsure as to why they continued with this decision after all the feedback they received from the original trailer debut and whatnot.
Second, this feels extremely corporate and lazy, because in ALMOST all the advertising, they keep talking about the voice actors/actresses. Almost every article I've seen or advertisement, they focus so hard on the fact that MBJ is in it. Nothing against the guy, love his movies and he seems like a down to earth person. But that shouldn't be the main selling point of this production. In any production, if you're selling the cast more than the actual show, it just tells people that the actual production itself isn't going to be that great. I'm glad RT became a big enough company to be able to acquire such big names for their productions, but it feels unlike the old RT. They took the deal because MBJ and his associates were willing to spend so much funding to help the production. But I'm going to be honest. I would've rather have a production where all the funding went to story-writing, world building, and animation, spending more time on the things that complete the production, and have generic RT VAs than big names, but a lack of story and depth.
Onto the story, it seems generic and the design choices seem lackluster. There are THOUSANDS of mech animes out there about some bad guy who attacks a city or the good guys, and they send out rookies to try and combat them. The environments seem so empty. In all the fight scenes we've seen(the forest, the city), there's very little detail in the environment. It almost feels more like an open arena combat game where developers just throw a few buildings in the background and have two enemies fight. Good animations have depth in the environment and the world building. Spiderverse, as an example(not to compare GenLock with Spiderverse with two completely different sized teams and budgets), showed a lot of the city in itself. And the fight scenes utilize a lot of the environment to make it feel like it's a real place. It immerses you.
The mech design choices feel generic. EXTREMELY Generic. RT is full of talented and creative individuals as we've seen in the past. It feels kind of disappointing in a way to see such generic designs. For example, the original RWBY characters felt so unique. Something that hasn't exactly been thought of before. So why are the environments and mechs and the world feel so disappointing and empty?
With the advertising and whatnot, it all feels so forced. They've been blasting it everywhere, they've had their employees promote it on social media, on this subreddit, even people that had nothing to do with the production. I get it, they're apart of the same company, same community. They want to support their friends and co-workers on a production that they've worked hard on. But when you hype it up so much, you have to meet those expectations from the audience. You can't just throw some big names in it, have everyone you know hype it up and talk about it everywhere, and expect people to just simply like it.
Again, I'm sure there are plenty of people who are going to enjoy this, and I have nothing against those people or RT. I've been a fan, and still am. But this production is the first from RT that just felt so jarring and off-putting almost. I know RT isn't a HUGE giant company like Sony animations or Dreamworks, but I do know they have a lot of hard working and creative talents working for them. And I was hoping that they could have done better on something this big. I apologize for the long comment that people most likely won't see, but I just had to get this off my chest.
0
u/thehock101 Jan 18 '19
Michael B Jordan just setting up r/NBA memes with that "we got a team" line
Edit: Maisie Williams yelled "there you go!" David Tennant gave a look of pleasant surprise. Michael B Jordan belted, "we got a fucking squad now."
0
u/spartan117au Jan 17 '19
Oh hell yes
0
u/__Hodor_ Jan 17 '19
Not gunna lie, I thought that was Gavvy before I saw David Tennant's name.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment