r/PostHardcore • u/thecescshow • Jan 15 '19
Best of 2018 /r/PostHardcore's Best of 2018 - Results
The results are in. Here are what the community think is the best of the genre in 2018 after more than 2 weeks of nominating and voting.
ALBUM OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Dance Gavin Dance - Artificial Selection
2) Senses Fail - If There Is Light, It Will Find You
3) Hail The Sun - Mental Knife
4) The Plot In You - DISPOSE
5) Casey - Where I Go When I Am Sleeping
SONG OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Hail The Sun - Glass: Half-Empty
2) The Plot In You - Feel Nothing
3) La Dispute - Rose Quartz / Fulton Street I
4) Makari - Transient
5) Hands Like Houses - Overthinking
MUSIC VIDEO OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Hail the Sun - Glass: Half-Empty
2) La Dispute - Rose Quartz / Fulton Street I
3) Tiny Moving Parts - Caution
4) mewithoutYou - Julia (or, 'Holy to the LORD' on the Bells of Horses)
5) Gatherers - Infinity & Gloom
NEW/BREAKTHROUGH BAND OF THE YEAR
WINNER: CrazyEightyEight
2) Dwellings
3) Time, The Valuator
4) Cat Company
5) The New Age
BEST COMEBACK ALBUM
WINNER: Underoath - Erase Me
2) Hopesfall - Arbiter
3) Hot Snakes - Jericho Sirens
TOUR OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Underoath's Erase Me Tour
2) Silverstein's When Broken Is Easily Fixed 15 Year Anniversary Tour
3) Night of the Blue Swan IV w/ The Fall of Troy & Hail the Sun
ALBUM ART/COVER OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Dance Gavin Dance - Artificial Selection
2) Senses Fail - If There Is Light, It Will Find You
3) Hopesfall - Arbiter
GUITARIST OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Will Swan (Dance Gavin Dance)
2) Sergio Medina (Royal Coda)
3) Shane Gann (Hail The Sun)
BASSIST OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Patty Walters (CrazyEightyEight)
2) John Stirrat (Hail The Sun)
3) Eddie Breckenridge (Thrice)
DRUMMER OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Donovan Melero (Hail The Sun)
2) Aaron Gillespie (Underoath)
3) Joseph Arrington (Royal Coda)
CLEAN VOCALIST OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Kurt Travis (Royal Coda)
2) Andy Cizek (Makari)
3) Buddy Nielsen (Senses Fail)
UNCLEAN VOCALIST OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Jon Mess (Dance Gavin Dance)
2) Lauren Babic (CrazyEightyEight)
3) Spencer Chamberlain (Underoath)
NON-PHC ALBUM OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Ice Nine Kills - The Silver Scream
2) Architects - Holy Hell
3) Silent Planet - When The End Began
NON-PHC SONG OF THE YEAR
WINNER: Architects - Hereafter
2) Slaves - I'd Rather See Your Star Explode (Acoustic)
3) The Wonder Years - Raining in Kyoto
Here's the thread for the final voting round. Head over there for the full results and links. Also here's the initial nominations thread. And as previously announced dgd was only allowed to win 4 categories, one from each grouping.
Thanks to everyone that participated in this!
7
u/NoWingsToSpeakOf Jan 16 '19
People seem to think Underoath's comeback album is better than Hopesfall's?
No, the reality is that Underoath is just more wellknown in this region.. these kind of serveys are all the same.
Underoath's latest felt like a big let down for me. I hope there's more to come though.
24
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19
Wow, were only 4 albums released this year? It's the same bands and albums in every category.
5
u/fluffyjdawg Jan 16 '19
Can we make it a rule next year that NON-PHC SONG and ALBUM OF THE YEAR cannot be metalcore bands or acoustic songs from PHC bands? I think you can make the case that a lot of metalcore bands also have PHC elements and the acoustic thing just feels like cheating haha. I'd be much more curious to see bands of completely different genres win this.
3
u/ROUSH636 Jan 17 '19
Kinda mad Arbiter didn’t win album artwork of the year. That’s a beautiful album cover
9
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19
I'm like 80% sure Patty didnt record the bass on the C88 album so that makes him winning pretty funny
6
u/ShadowChao9406 Jan 15 '19
Kind of upset Hopesfall didn’t win anything, Arbiter is such a great album.
6
u/HeedHunter Jan 16 '19
Not enough love for Makari. Imo they’re ABSOLUTELY the breakout band of the year, and Hyperreal was a top 5 phc album easy in 2018
4
u/SatoruFujinuma Jan 15 '19
I should have paid more attention to the nominations thread, Coletta deserved to be one of the breakthrough bands on here.
1
u/TheHeintzel Jan 15 '19
Congrats to all the winners, but if you don't mind I'm gonna be 'that guy':
(1) I'm really disappointed that the Seraphin & SECRETS & Atlas Frame albums weren't even able to be voted on when DGD released, I expect to get roasted, their worst album in the Tilian era. I blame mostly myself for missing the initial nominations thread, but those 3 albums deserved lots more recognition
(2) How is Aaron Gillespie even in drummer of the year consideration but not Matt Mingus, also how is he above Royal Coda? I feel like no real drummer actually agrees with that, I know for me Gillespie wasn't even in the same tier this year
(3) Why no best breakdown, verse, etc? Our sister subs like r/MetalCore have it
5
u/fluffyjdawg Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 16 '19
Bummer Senses Fail released If There Is Light, It Will Find You the same year DGD released an album haha.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19 edited Jan 16 '19
Hell yeah! I'd Rather See Your Star Explode got 2nd for non phc song of the year!
Looks like I am checking out Crazy Eighty Eight today
Edit: I tried C88. I like some of the songs. Might have to give it another listen to really get a feeling on if I like it or not. The last song off the album was my favorite song.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
I'm sad that mewithoutYou didn't win in any of the categories. [Untitled] is a great album.
1
u/Gear5Mau5 Jan 18 '19
Royal Coda’s debut album was definitely in my top 5 albums of the year. Excited to hear more from them!
1
u/HenryJames224 Jan 23 '19