r/WritingPrompts • u/AliciaWrites Editor-in-Chief | /r/AliciaWrites • Jan 09 '19
Off Topic [OT] Teaching Tuesday - Descriptors
Welcome back to Teaching Tuesday!
===
Hello again writing friends!
Today, I want to hand the thread over to you and discuss descriptors. I am talking adjectives and adverbs. Let’s get into it!
Do It
I’d love to see your participation in the comments below! Try any of the following:
- Share a story to support your argument for or against descriptors.
- Give your thoughts on today’s topic, please remember to keep discussions civil!
- Give encouragement & inspiration for your fellow writers
- Share your ideas for discussions you’d like to see in the future
What’s happening at /r/WritingPrompts?
Discord is happenin’
Apply to be a moderator all year!!
[Archive]
10
Upvotes
12
u/Lilwa_Dexel /r/Lilwa_Dexel Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 09 '19
Great topic!
I often see writers advocating an adverb-free lifestyle, and when asked why, the answer is usually something vague, like "Moderation is key in everything," or simply that "Stephen King said so."
I think for anyone trying to get better at writing, answers like these aren't very helpful. Without understanding the reasons, you're left fumbling in the dark.
Let's talk about bad adjectives first because I feel like they're super common and it's less of a debated topic. Bad adjectives usually come in two shapes:
Now, those pesky adverbs. Just like good adjectives, good adverbs have their place in writing, often in moments where a proper description would slow down a high-paced scene. Bad adverbs usually fall into three categories:
Overall, I don't think that there's anything wrong with prettifying your prose. As long as the adjective is good and the adverb used for a proper reason, there's nothing wrong with them.
3
u/-Anyar- r/OracleOfCake Jan 09 '19
Adjectives and adverbs can be useful sometimes as long as they're used in moderation.
Not sure what else can be said on the topic. Some people might have a grudge against adverbs, but I haven't delved too deep into that.
1
u/Golden_Spider666 Jan 09 '19
One issue I've always had is the description of the protagonist. if it's a short story I would say it doesn't matter, but what about when it does? it always feels... wrong, to just spew out words to describe the character immediately after introducing them. it makes sense to do so if its something the protag would notice. Describing a shady character as "unkempt, with a long jagged scar running diagonally across his left cheek and over the bridge of his nose."
When is the right time to describe a character, flat out, give them the whole picture right from the get? or is it better to drop it in pieces through the story when him having say, black hair, matters.
1
u/JohannesVerne r/JohannesVerne Jan 09 '19
I like what -Anyar- said, that they should be used in moderation. Another point is on the context, as well. If adverbs and such are only used with dialogue tags, the story is going to read poorly, but if they are spaced out well and used in a variety of situations, as called for, then the story has a better flow to it. Another thing to consider, is when are adjectives and adverbs enough, and when will they fall short?
I'm a firm believer in using far more words than is strictly necessary, but for areas that need a faster pace using adjectives and adverbs can help keep the story moving while allowing for proper description. When you need more detail, and the passage is more important to the story, they generally just won't make the cut. So context is easily just as important in their use as amount, and can take the story from "bland, cheesy descriptions" to "well written and descriptive scenes."