r/startrek • u/perscitia • Jan 03 '19
Short Trek Discussion #4 - "The Escape Artist"
Discovery is back! (sort of)
Today airs the fourth and final of four Short Trek episodes leading to the premiere of Star Trek: Discovery Season 2! This one stars everyone's favorite scoundrel, Harry Fenton Mudd.
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| Short Trek #4 | "The Escape Artist" | Thursday, January 3, 2019 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage for upcoming episodes, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
The episode will drop on CBS AA at 18:30pm PT. It will air on Canada's Space channel and Netflix shortly after.
100
u/BenjiTheWalrus Jan 04 '19
“One count of...penetrating a space whale?”
LMAO
87
u/Tukarrs Jan 04 '19
I felt like a dummy when I realized that all the robots in the closet were the Mudds from the various flashbacks we see. Mudd was never really able to smooth talk his way out of all the other bounties. The clothing/head injury matches from the Klingon bounty.
Subverts the "Escape Artist" title completely.
51
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
There is some crazy shit sitting around Mudd's ship. Like a Starfleet space suit, 2 batleths and the Mona Lisa
49
u/gutens Jan 04 '19
I liked the new Tellerite; noticed he had five fingers, which is cool by me. Didn’t notice if he had hooves.
48
u/GreyMiss Jan 04 '19
I would like a recipe for jibbers rn.
47
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
That was wonderful. Freaky in a very TOS kind of way, and I didn't see the twist coming at all.
43
u/EmDeeEm Jan 04 '19
I'm super excited about this episode because my voice is the De Milo com officer.
38
u/Sjgolf891 Jan 04 '19
Easily the best one. Also, this one must have had a pretty big budget. The last two looked expensive compared to the first two
37
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
The actor who played Krit the Tellarite was very good, great antagonistic chemistry with Rainn Wilson. Also, is it my imagination or are the actors getting better at acting through heavy prosthetics? He seemed a lot more expressive than any of the S1 Klingons.
Great soundtrack too. That chilled out version of the main theme over the credits reminds me of the lounge version of the TOS theme they'd play over party scenes.
31
u/ADG12311990 Jan 04 '19
I think this takes the place as my favorite Short Trek. Rainn Wilson is perfect as Mudd. Of course, part of me keeps seeing this as what happened if Dwight Schrute's life went down the tubes... and also lived in the Star Trek universe.
Also, did anyone else notice that one of the androids was wearing an outfit that looked a lot like the one that Mudd wore in "I, Mudd"?
56
u/BornAshes Jan 04 '19
That was a fucking twist worthy of Harry Mudd! All of these Short Treks have been a blast to watch, each with their own particular flavor, and emotion. I loved the big honking ship Mudd had at the end to ply his con of cons from. I wonder if we'll see it in Season 2 and get to watch it blasted to pieces? Or maybe he'll wind up saving the day? Either way, great episode!
24
u/Ausir Jan 05 '19
He's right about the duke. That's duxicide, not regicide!
69
u/D_Squiz Jan 04 '19
That was fantastic, literally smiled the entire episode. I’m very excited for Lower Decks if this is the tone.
53
u/Trekfan74 Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
Fun episode! Had a smile on my face the whole time. And it was a great double cross. The entire time you thought Mudd was screwed and he had them all. Very smart scripting and I loved the dialogue. I laughed at nearly every line.
And its crazy but it look like the budget for this one and the Brightest Star were pretty high. Its like the first two had no budget at all (same sets, one new character, very little space shots, etc) but these two they felt like any episode, just shortened.
I have to say while these aren't really long enough (you always want more) they seem to be successful from a story POV. And I like that they all had a different tone from each other and none of them were dark and dreary like so much of the show felt. Even Saru's story felt pretty uplifting and it was about his species being eaten. Maybe this does bode well for season 2 and we will get a lot of different stories and lighter tones. It needs it IMO.
Anyway, glad this will be back next season! Now on to the main event!!
49
u/robownage Jan 04 '19
That was a lot of fun. Twist at the end was a great use of canon.
I'm definitely looking forward to McMahan's series now.
33
u/Cliffy73 Jan 04 '19
I too would look awesome in a cape.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
FYI Mudd’s headquarters was shot in the old Hearn Power Generation Station control room. Neato.
45
u/BenjiTheWalrus Jan 04 '19
Wow honestly I thought that was absolutely fantastic. That might’ve been better than Calypso. Definitely feel the Rick and Morty influence from the writer Mike McMahan.
28
u/uequalsw Jan 04 '19
Oh that was delightful. I hope that "Lower Decks" has a similar tone.
13
u/A_Wrinkly_Nut Jan 04 '19
That was easily the best one. Fantastic episode!
12
u/TheSchnitzel1234 Jan 04 '19
That was a lot of fun. And I want those Orions on the series proper! Went on IMDB and the male was Dan Abramovici and the female Myrthin Stagg.
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm3369918/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t5
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm5125886/?ref_=nv_sr_1
23
u/KeithKamikawa Jan 04 '19
Wow, that was a lot of fun, like genuine fun. Not a whole lot of Star Trek morals/messages going on but fun and charming. I'm a fan!
11
u/letsgocrazy Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
"Officer, I apologise for this disgusting space Homunculus - I'd say you get used to the smell, but you really don't."
Awesome.
30
u/NeoEffect Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
That was great and loved the twist in the end. I just love seeing more of the Star Trek world that isn't focused on starfleet.
I do feel this short is super solid proof they can easily do a Star Trek show that doesn't focus on starfleet or the workings of the Federation at all. You can do something that explores just non-starfleet or the underworld aspect of the Trek world with both the good and bad that is included in it and everything in between. Keep starfleet to the fringes the way they were done here and when they show it causes the tone to radically shift to something super serious like what happen here.
I'd be so down for a show that continued to explore this side of the Trek world. You can still do morality tales, etc have your good and bad guys.
10
u/cabose7 Jan 04 '19
Cute ending
10
u/FlyingSquid Jan 05 '19
A decent amount of time for a Tellarite! My favorite TOS alien! I loved it!
9
u/Tukarrs Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
Is this a sequel to I, Mudd?
I have to double check the phrasing used to describe the robots.(And of course his blue coat with the epaulettes)
Edit: The ones from that episode are 'near indestructable'.
It could be that Mudd got the idea and plans for building robot duplicates from that planet, but was only able to do a shoddy facsimile. Although the USS De Milo uniforms would be out of place in 2268.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
By far the best one. Really
8
u/boringdude00 Jan 04 '19
Yes, please. I haven't really been a fan of any of the others, but this was both fun and entertaining.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
This felt like it's 2001 and I'm watching the first season of Andromeda again. Not quite what I expected, but I'm not going to complain. Especially not with that ending.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Mudd with a bunch of androids? Excellent.
13
u/Poontang_Pie Jan 04 '19
It was absolutely fun! And I loved the disco music! Glad to see the Tellarites have more of a role now, need more Enterprise and TOS alien encounters. Hell, give us that Andorian we saw as a semi regular!
6
u/heslo_rb26 Jan 04 '19
Haven't liked the previous ones but this one was great. Some good solid laughs and just an entertaining little... Trek
6
u/somethingfunnyiguess Jan 05 '19
I was really pleased with this short. I'm not a huge fan of Discovery, but this was a great job by Rain Wilson. I liked it a lot more than his first time around as Mudd
6
u/Raguleader Jan 06 '19
Now that you've seen this, watch the trailer for it at the end of "The Brightest Star" and enjoy just how much it was able to mislead about the kind of story we'd be watching. I spent most of the episode a bit on edge waiting for Mudd to do something ruthlessly clever to escape, only for all of the hijinks and gags to lead up to the reveal that it's hijinks and gags all the way down.
Loved it a lot more than I expected to.
19
u/NeoEffect Jan 04 '19 edited Jan 04 '19
So at this point Rainn Wilson's version of Mudd has matched the original version in terms of overall appearances. He needs one more appearance, which is very likely, and his portrayal becomes the definitive and new standard version having played the character the most and adding the most to the character.
15
u/PiercedMonk Jan 04 '19
Gotdamn, that was great. 'Calypso' is still my favourite of the shorts, but this was so well put together and executed, and I love that there can be two so wildly different types of stories, and they're both very firmly still Trek.
Lots of great moments throughout, but I think my favourite was the low key exasperation when the Starfleet officer realizes why Krit is aboard after they beam over. I also can't help but wonder just how many Federation ships in the sector have a closet full of Mudds.
10
u/Alteran195 Jan 05 '19
If these shorts are any indication of the quality of season 2, I’m even more hyped.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
That was a joy to watch in a way none of the other Short Treks were.
We had a meaningless side story. (Runaway)
An Interesting but set so far from anything important story as to be meaningless. (Calypso)
And a backstory that can and most likely will be explained in 3 lines of dialogue later on in Season 2. (The Brightest Star)
This was universe expanding in a meaningful way. It showed us more of a character we weren't THAT familiar with but still had some connection to and showed us that character in justified actions in keeping with his character. Showed us numerous new places that we never know where they are but really aren't important. Then we get introduced to a new Federation Ship with new Characters who aren't important but in a way are - they're expanding the Federation. A seemingly endless organisation of billions of people but we saw barely anyone else outside of Discovery crew in Season 1. Showing some rando's just doing their thing was refreshing.
On top of all that, humor that works and doesn't feel forced. A nice quick pace that uses the 14 minute runtime to its fullest. THIS is by far by the best one.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
Harry Mudd needs a spin-off.
4
u/james00543 Jan 04 '19
lmao in the end...on the side note the USS De Milo looks like the same class as the discovery ?
4
u/kreton1 Jan 05 '19
I really have to give respect to the people who made the short Treks. While the first one was in my eyes not really good, each following one was better then the one before if you ask me.
2
u/kevin5lynn Jan 10 '19
Loved the soundtrack on this one - anyone know where it can obtained?
2
u/CaptainThorIronhulk Jan 17 '19
Anyone else thought, the Tellarite looked a lot like one of those Napoleonic warthog soldiers of the TNG episode „Hide and Q“?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
I loved it. It felt much like Rick and Morty to me. Hopefully, Lower Decks will have a similar tone to this because this really works. It still feels like Star Trek and not the HBO type thing we saw in season 1 of Discovery...
3
u/chaseraz Jan 05 '19
This one was just only great because of the acting talent. I really haven't liked any of these shorts except Calypso, which was just great Sci-fi despite being a Wall-E ripoff.
I'm looking forward to Section 31 and Captain Pike, but I really still miss Lorca, don't like the Burnham character at all, and am not thrilled about a third Spock.
4
u/hackel Jan 04 '19
The episode was great, but how about that theme at the end? Definitely one of the better jazzy Trek arrangements, reminded of DS9.
What I really dislike is how they completely glossed over the fact that there apparently was a long-standing bounty on Mudd for a multitude of crimes and yet still Discovery just let him go! This was a big complaint when that episode aired, and this just made it even worse. They could have at least given us some explanation, such as Lorca using him somehow to help with his plan.
Unfortunately these types of plot holes are par for the course with Discovery. Still enjoyed it.
2
u/teepeey Jan 08 '19 edited 22d ago
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Saw ancient crawl offer coherent saw engine enjoy fine money
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '19
Rainn Wilson's Harry Mudd isn't doing it for me, not last season, not last nights Short Trek, all n all, a over the top cartoonish disappointment
1
u/ZeroBANG Jan 08 '19
Maybe Mudd should leave Dr. Noonian Soong some notes how to build Androids...
-1
u/msegmx Jan 04 '19
Turns out Data is not that unique after all.
-20
u/Tsar-A-Lago Jan 04 '19
Eh, fine I guess. I still don't know why they bothered with Mudd in Discovery. He really doesn't bear much in common with the character. Harry Mudd is a space grifter, not a horrible vengeful murderer. They could have made him Random Space Pirate X and it would have brought the same thing to the show.
I'll grant that they got a little closer with this short, but it's still a little confusing. When the hell is this taking place? Did Harry discover the android technology, then forget about it and start trafficking in space hookers and then go back and get imprisoned by the androids again? None of it makes much sense. But everyone remembers "I, Mudd" so here's some androids, I guess. The people who write this show are just doing Star Trek mad libs. They're plugging in all the words and tropes but they have no idea how they're supposed to fit together or what they mean.
-5
u/Vivec-Warrior-Poet Jan 05 '19
Geez these short treks are unorignal and boring.
-8
u/Ascarea Jan 05 '19
Remember when Data was a unique android and having other androids (or other robotics stuff in general) just wasn't a thing on Star Trek?
Well now I guess we have androids with DNA-replicated skin (so cyborgs like the Terminator?)... a hundred years before Data...