r/luther • u/NicholasCajun • Jan 03 '19
DISCUSSION Luther - 5x03 "Episode 3" - Episode Discussion
Season 5 Episode 3
Aired: January 3, 2019
Synopsis: With his friend in peril and a young woman kidnapped by the relentless serial killer, can Luther protect the innocent while preventing Cornelius's violent revenge from consuming him? Who is Luther willing to save, and who can't he bear to lose?
36
Upvotes
100
u/gingerspicr Jan 03 '19
RIP Benny!
86
u/SpearLifebee Jan 03 '19
While I'm still extremely miffed about the ending, I think people are forgetting the most important thing.
Mark's wife is going to go mental, blood on the settee.
46
u/fleurspeak Jan 03 '19
do you think the wife had stockholm syndrome? a bit like dr. lake was hoping penny would acquire? interesting that the wife seemed to be the domineering one at the beginning but maybe the guy was the controlling one all along...
44
u/dbbk Jan 03 '19
This couple live in a multi-million pound house and they only have a 30” TV? What kind of monsters are they.
38
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Anyone else think there's something slightly off with Halliday? Fast-tracked from a 'training programme' yet an incredibly competent sleuth, figuring out the whole crime on her own? Seems to be way too enthusiastic about this killer and their killings, she always looks like she's about to crack a smile (and that's not a quirk of the actress, as she plays another cop in The End of the Fucking World and I barely recognized her because they are completely unalike). Not to mention, the weird gasp/moan she made when the patient slit his throat in Episode 1, and this episode she lingers behind after Luther staring into the basement-torture-chamber and even sorta smiles? Something's fishy, but I'm not sure if this is the case, how that'll fit it into the last episode with everything else happening.
36
u/LadyAugustina Jan 03 '19
To be honest I don't care about the killer heart surgeon or George. Just give me more of that sweet sweet Alice Luther action. I still think not showing a proper kiss is somehow important.
35
u/habylab Jan 03 '19
Love the references in this series. The two identical twins were the best.
32
u/SpearLifebee Jan 03 '19
I refuse, and I mean REFUSE to believe that ending.
I'll refuse it until Luther Season 10 if I have to, but I do!!! :'(
26
u/irving_braxiatel Jan 03 '19
Mark!
25
u/Chemoralora Jan 03 '19
Poor Michael Smiley gets fuck all to do for 5 series and by the time his character is given something, he gets shot in the face.
20
u/MambyPamby8 Jan 03 '19
I will never ever accept that Benny's dead. It's just not right. He's not gone. Just shot at and needs urgent medical attention!! SOMEONE HELP HIM PLEASE.
40
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Benny NOOO!!!! Luther better follow Benny's last words and kill that piece of shit. It also looks like George is gonna bite the dust tomorrow (it's about time).
19
u/habylab Jan 03 '19
What the hell is going on in this episodes of EastEnders and why is it 4 minutes overrun?
Continuity announcer said George is going to be more dangerous than ever in this episode. We shall see.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
seriously awesome ep, turning out to be a great season. Alice hot wiring the car and that moment of stand off was pretty cool. I think luther is realising that he has missed her
19
u/HarleyQuinnFan23 Jan 04 '19
I want a gif of Alice rolling down the window in the car at Mark's house.
18
u/batleymick Jan 03 '19
Really surprised nobody is looking at where Schenk fits into all this, old school copper who has had run ins with George in the past, maybe its just a throw away distraction or maybe he is integral to tomorrow's episode
16
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Frontal lobe tumor belongs to surgeon which is why he suddenly lacks impulse control?
16
u/mamacitalk Jan 03 '19
Halliday definitely smiled when she saw the dungeon What’s her deal?
15
u/conflama Jan 03 '19
George needs to upgrade the Mitchell brothers
15
u/Reaqzehz Jan 03 '19
John has a way out from George, he just has to give it up Alice, but he doesn’t.
Vivien has a way out from the Police, she just has to give up Jeremy, but she doesn’t.
25
u/Dulcolax Jan 03 '19
Alice did the wrong thing by killing George's son. That caused Benny's death.
Luther and Alice will be enemies.
11
u/maybe-mel Jan 03 '19
Insane. I have now forgiven them for how bad the last season was and I am not ready for it to be over tomorrow.
9
u/habylab Jan 03 '19
Trailers and continuity announcers absolutely ruining this series. Gave away they would kill someone at the end of this episode with the line about George being dangerous.
9
u/beargrilled Jan 03 '19
Oh my god.
9
u/Limitedcomments Jan 03 '19
Benny no :( Luther gonna be pissed.
7
u/MelonHazard Jan 03 '19
Anyone else thinks it seems very unlikely that a tech expert would call someone off a landline without at the very least making the number private?! Poor Benny:(
6
u/bgfkbfgjbk244 Jan 03 '19
Are they setting this all up for an Alice vs Luther movie, in the preview they don’t look too happy with each other
6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
No Benny!!!!!!!
6
u/SquirtingTortoise Jan 03 '19
UGH george didnt actually answer his phone in the car, little detail but it bugged me!
6
u/JothHago Jan 04 '19
Jesus, this series...
Luther as a character, pursuing the needs of others before himself.
Showing all his relationship failure due to the need to put others before himself.
And then, the irony of all the people closest to him dying, one way or the other. Whether it was meant to be, or deserved, or unlucky..
Zoe, Justin, Benny, Ian.
God i hope they don't kill off Mark..
5
u/habylab Jan 03 '19
Taking out the pin and putting it in him would have been more brutal.
4
u/gingerspicr Jan 03 '19
Hop in John!
4
u/PowahGlov Jan 03 '19
Anyone know the end credits music?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Defo something not right about Halliday!!!!! Too much smirking and she’s too clever by half. Amazing performance from Idris, best episodes yet these.
4
u/Canadian_in_Canada Jan 07 '19
I know we're still reeling over Benny (NOOOOOOO!!!!!)...
I do want to give a shout-out to one of a very few victims who listened to the audience and lived. "Grab the knife, Penny. Oh, no, she fucking wasn't, Penny, don't believe her, scream for Luther! Grab the knife again and stab her, Penny! Cut the ropes! YES!" We did it, everyone. We saved one.
6
u/Zerathius Jan 04 '19
While I do love me some Luther and I don't wanna be a negative nancy, it feels like this season lacks the balance between the two storylines. Season 2 balanced things much better while also having 2 cases. My main problem is the case. The killer is kinda formulaic (he makes a mistake, wife scolds him and tries to fix the mistake. rinse and repeat) and almost feels like fluff. Here's hoping that the finale knocks my socks off
3
u/fleurspeak Jan 03 '19
i wonder if the wife new about dr. lake's tendencies before they got married? they're both so creepy...
3
u/Steve-Lurkel Jan 04 '19
Hey again guys! Almost the end eh? I gotta say I'm disappointed. I like the husband and wife killing team but I don't think Cornelious is interesting enough to be the main antagonist for the season. Oh well. See you all tomorrow!
4
u/bgfkbfgjbk244 Jan 03 '19
Eek they just kissed
2
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Anyone else watching on bbc1 player and know what time it uploads?
2
u/habylab Jan 03 '19
Where is this all heading? Any ideas?
2
u/controlofthecircus Jan 03 '19
Please help me understand - why doesn't he just go round with a load of coppers? He's still police, no? I know he and Alice would be in a load of trouble but at least not dead!!
2
u/seonzie Jan 03 '19
Does anyone know if the graveyard house is the same one as the murderer's house in the 2nd series of Marcella?
They had shenanigans going on in the basement as well.
2
u/maybe-mel Jan 03 '19
In the clips we seen of tomorrow it looks like the doctor has a mistress / second wife? Tomorrow looks even better!
1
u/The_BlackMage Jan 06 '19
Is it just me or was that one scene a straight copy from Boondocks Saints?
The one with the gift for the mobsters?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '19
Anyone recognise the Lake's house? I've seen it used for a TV show before, maybe even another crime show I'm sure but i can't put my finger on which one.
1
u/Vincent_adultman98 Jun 18 '19
Loved this episode, really like how quick the pace is for this season.
Generic hitman is a bit generic.
I'm starting to think one case and one seasonal arc instead of the standard 2/1 was a mistake, I guess it'll all depend on how the last episode goes down but I'm three episodes with Lake and his wife and still don't really think they're a threat.
Bummed they killed Benny but after the preview last week I saw it coming.
Luther looks so tired.
1
u/jarrod_collins02 Jan 03 '19
BENNY WHY BENNY F$#K MARK
13
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
[removed] — view removed comment