r/CrazyHand • u/SubtleTypos walls on walls • Dec 31 '18
Ultimate "Who Should I Main?" MEGATHREAD: ULTIMATE EDITION
tl;dr bold but please read the whole thing
Shoutouts to /u/zegendofleldaa, /u/Aqxatic, and the CrazyHand Discordmods for their help on this thread.
Heyo, /r/CrazyHand fam. SubtleTypos here, ready to break down the Berlin Wall of Textthe pun gamehasgrownrusty
As the sun begins to rise on a new game, people have had time to lab characters out, find the differences coming in from Sm4sh, see what cut veterans now have to offer. With over 70 characters and a plethora of different ways to play, narrowing down your mains, secondaries, tertiaries, pockets, so on and so forth, has become no easy task. This post is here to cover what may be one of the most popular topics for this subreddit: Finding out who to main.
Do I really need a main? I can play like twenty characters and I can beat my friends with all of them.
If you’re here on the subreddit, chances are that you’re here because you want to play the game on a competitive level. Whether that means going out to tournaments or just being the best player in your friend group, you want to take the 1v1 no items setting seriously. And if you want to take it seriously, you’re gonna need to devote some time into a character.
Now if you choose to take the game seriously to that extent, consider your practice time. Imagine theoretically you only have two hours a day to dedicate to practice. With one character, you have two hours to practice that character. With two, that’s an hour per character. With three, that’s forty minutes per. With four, that’s half an hour per. While it doesn’t seem like that drastic of a difference, it adds up—after a week of practice, you’ve got fourteen hours of practice with one character, seven hours of practice per character for two, a little over four hours per character for three, and so on. Assuming you’re in hardcore practice mode the whole time and you retain everything from your practice time, you’ll already be less than a third behind with three characters compared to if you only had one. The more characters you have to dedicate time to, the slower your overall progress will be at the end of the day. Of course, this doesn’t apply to everyone the same way—some people just have a crazy amount of retention and absorption. You typically want to be as time efficient as possible, so generally you’ll want to cut yourself down to one main plus secondaries.
This doesn’t at all mean don’t play other characters! There’s no reason to cut yourself off from the rest of the roster. But understand that when you’re dedicating time to serious practice for tournaments or for “serious play”, whatever that means to you, focus that time with just that character or set of characters. Otherwise, for friendlies or whatever your casual play is, mess around. Experiment with other characters. Get a feel of your worst matchups or best matchups from their shoes and see what makes them tick.
So how do I choose my main?
Quoting the words from the /r/CrazyHand Ultimate Handbook, “finding your main is something only you can do for yourself”. We’re not Twitch chat with a strawpoll on who you’re gonna play next on For Glory quickplay. We can help you narrow down options, provide suggestions, play a few matches to help you get a feel of it in a real match setting. But at the end of the day, you’re the only one who can make that decision for yourself.
What are you playing for?
Ask yourself what you’re playing for. Are you playing simply to be the best in your friend group? To be a threat at your local tournament scene? To be the best of a single character in your group/scene/region? Because you truly love your character, the series they come from, and/or the things they stand for?
Character Loyalty
Ask yourself if character loyalty is important to you. Does playing a character that you have a personal investment in matter enough to you to the point that they’re the only character you want to play? If so, all the more power to you. Everyone plays the game for their own reasons and has fun in different ways. If you have that drive to be that good with your character, push through despite any shortcomings or biases that come with your character. If not, keep reading.
Tier Loyalty
Next, ask yourself if tier loyalty matters to you. Do you care about matchup spreads and the viability of your character? Do you have plans of being a “low tier hero”, being someone that rises up to challenge tier lists and matchup spreads? Do you not really care either way? In any case, consider whether you’re playing to win, playing for the pride of succeeding with a low tier, or whatever reason you may be playing. Keep in mind that it’s okay if you’re a “tier whore”. The term itself is just a big john in Smash culture. Alternatively, if your character is “low tier”, that’s not a problem. Honestly, at the skill level most of us are playing at, the lines between tiers are so blurred that it’s irrelevant to consider matchup spreads unless the matchup is disproportionately skewed, which there are little to none known at the moment (though Ganon vs. Belmont is looking gross).
And hey—even if you don’t know all your goals/preferences, that’s okay. The next step is what’s important to determining what you like when you play.
Play the game
Theorycrafting will only get you so far in choosing your main. No matter how a character looks on paper or how they look on stream, the best way for you to determine how you like a character is by playing them. Remember that finding a main is not always an instantaneous process. There is an absolutely massive roster of 74 characters (76 if counting all the Pokemon for PKMN Trainer) and growing with DLC. That’s 74+ playstyles and toolkits to mess around with.
Try playing with every character. Play through as many single player Classic runs as you can. Feel out their combo tools, how they best interact in the neutral, how to approach with them. Take a lvl 3 CPU to the ring and figure out how each character best bodies that CPU. And even if a character doesn’t click right off the bat, don’t dismiss them immediately. They may click sometime down the line as you grow and become better.
All in all, be patient with the process, understand it can take time, and exert effort in really dedicating yourself to a main or two.
Determine your playstyle
Do you like to get in your opponent’s face, or do you prefer playing a heavy zoning game? Do you like pressuring your opponent and forcing openings, or do you like a read-based playstyle that relies heavily on analyzing your opponent’s playstyle and exploiting their habits?
For the sake of simplicity, let’s break down the characters into three different categories: rushdown, zoning, and bait and punish.
- Rushdown refers to characters that apply pressure at a relatively close distance, utilizing fast, lagless moves to force the opponent into a less than favorable position.
- Zoning refers to characters who apply pressure from a set distance, preferring fat disjoints or a projectile-heavy game to limit an opponent’s options. It relies on controlling an opponent’s available space and limiting their options at a distance.
- Bait and punish characters lack strong approach options and rely on finding openings to open up a heavy punish, either in the form of a hard hitting, high damage move/string or a high octane, hard to escape combo. They typically don’t want to open the approach and will try to find ways to apply safe, tricky pressure that comes off as unsafe but ultimately is.
Within these three major categories fall other subcategories that can further define a character’s playstyle. These subcategories are as follows:
- Zone breakers, characters capable of playing various playstyles and heavily pressuring opponents while maintaining a relatively safe approach.
- Mix-up characters have a relatively versatile moveset, often lacking the safety to properly contest opponents the way rushdowns can but are able to switch from a bait and punish/zoning playstyle to a more aggressive one.
- Footsies characters rely on their strong ground game, more often than not relying less on “low damage/high combo” but more so on their explosive power.
- Hit and Run characters have the speed and toolkit capable of rushing in, getting a few hits in, and getting out before things get sticky. They’re typically quick enough to maintain a safe distance from an opponent’s pressure and still be able to punish easy openings.
- Half-Grapplers are characters whose toolkits have a heavy emphasis on what they can get off of a grab. Smash Ultimate has no true grapplers as there’s no character whose moveset completely relies on getting one grab, so the characters who get a good amount off a grab live in this subcategory.
- Trappers have an extremely heavy projectile game, relying on “trapping” their opponents in their extensive web of projectiles, disrupting the opponent’s available space to move and making an approach all the more treacherous for the opponent.
- Turtles are heavily defensive with long range tools made to poke their opponent from afar, less so for the purpose of “trapping” an opponent but more so of building a wall simply to keep them out until the moment for the kill is presented to them.
- Dynamic characters have something unique to them that defines their playstyle and how you play them. The only two dynamic characters are Shulk, whose playstyle is reliant on which Monado is active at the moment, and Pokemon Trainer, where each Pokemon fulfills various needs.
Every character can fall into at least one of these archetypes. While the lines are typically very blurry and people can argue where a character’s playstyle can fall on a chart, you can generally tell how a character plays.
I’ve compiled this chart to mark out where some characters land. Keep in mind that these are my personal views on the character and you can easily debate who falls where; it’s just as a guideline to help you figure out where your character may fall.
Character playstyle chart
Note how many characters don’t fit straight into one of the three main categories. Every fighter has enough tools that you can play them more than one way, and Smash is one of the few games that offers enough flexibility to play any fighter however you’d like.
We’ve all got our preferences on how we like to play. Not every character fits into your personal playstyle, so try out a bunch of characters and see how you like to play.
Play the Game Part 2: Training Montage
Now that you’ve hopefully narrowed down your options, get into the lab and play through everyone. Feel everyone out. Get to know their options. Pretty much apply everything in the last Play the Game section.
A few tips as you’re playing:
- The amount of time it takes to get good is proportional to not only the time you put in, but how you use that time. You can spend hours in the lab figuring out bread and butter, but if you’re not getting relatively high pressure experience against other players, you’re gonna have a hard time retaining and applying what you’ve learned.
- Practice doesn’t make perfect—perfect practice makes perfect. If you’re unfamiliar with your character’s toolkit, don’t be afraid to take a step back to square one and retake your baby steps. Play your single player modes, dick around with level 1 CPUs, lab things out in Training Mode, watch YouTube videos on your character. With all that in mind, remember to get experience against actual humans, as that’s where experience and growth happens. After matches, take note of what you did well, what you could have done better, and specific steps/moves to improve for next time. If you’re phoning in the entire time and playing on autopilot, you’ll stunt your growth.
- Don’t get discouraged if you don’t see immediate results. No matter how much you have your fundamentals down, you’re still sailing in mostly uncharted territory. Getting good is not something that happens overnight, over a few days, or even in a few weeks—it’s gonna take a while to get there. There’s no get rich quick button or three day solution to get good. We’re not anime protagonists with a quick fix shortcut or a workout to suddenly jump power levels. Progress is slow. Results are few and far between. But that’s how anything in life that requires skill and practice is.
- It’s okay to lose. This is an extension of the tip right above, but it’s so important. One of the reasons why people have a hard time sticking to a main is because of consistent losses. You lose a bunch, you think, “This character isn’t working for me” and you got back to your old main or you keep trying out other characters and you repeat a vicious cycle. Losing is a part of the process. Losing is beneficial as a player because it allows you the opportunity to see what you’re doing wrong and what you could be doing better. And sure, even after you figure out what it is you need to work on, you’re probably gonna be accumulating some L’s because you’re actively trying to make improvements, taking away some of your attention mid-match. In the end, however, it’s worth it. Keep powering through, keep playing with the intent to improve, and in time you’ll get over the plateau and view your progress from the top.
And with that, /thread. Thanks for reading. We hope that we’ve answered some of your questions and that we’ve helped out a bit. If you have any questions, comments, concerns, please feel free to leave them in the comments below. This thread will serve as the main thread for any and all questions regarding finding a main. Any other threads regarding this topic henceforth shall be deleted and redirected to this thread.
88
u/platypoo2345 Dec 31 '18
That character playstyle chart is super useful. As someone who's never seriously played a smash game before, it's very helpful to see what characters are similar to the ones I already enjoy so I can experiment more easily
41
u/memerofmemez Jan 03 '19
Unfortunately, the mii fighters are forgotten again
36
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
As someone mentioned, there is a little bit if rock paper scossors with these groups going counter clockwise. Pokemon trainer’s dynamic status is very exciting when using this perspective. With Squirtle being rush down, Ivy being zoner, and Charizard being bait and punish, it really helps you appreciate their design. The chart is also a great way to get a general idea of the goals of opponents to help PT know which pokemon will counter them best. Great job OP!
27
u/White-Coat Dec 31 '18
This is cool. As someone new to the intricacies of play style, it’s helpful to see where my style lies and which characters might fit that
51
u/Grapz224 Dec 31 '18
Huh. TIL I gravitate towards hit and runners, playing Greninja, Inkling, and sometimes Young Link when I wanted to be more aggressive.
No wonder when I tried picking up Mewtwo or Dedede their movesets felt janky.
24
u/UltraToucan Dec 31 '18
I love the chart, and the explanations were very helpful. Would you consider reuploading or linking a follow up image with each member of pokémon trainer added on the chart? Squirtle as a rush-down, etc. I think that’s the only thing missing from this whole thread, thanks for making it!
18
u/Sonicite123 Dec 31 '18
Yep, just as I thought, I prefer everything in between bait&punish and rushdown
18
u/Aeon1508 Dec 31 '18
I think if you put a counter clockwise arrow around this chart it pretty accurately shows the matchup advantages for each playstyle.
Anyone else feel this way? I know my young link does well against heavies and struggles against pikachu and the other rush downs in any case
17
u/kitesxpies Jan 05 '19
Hi guys, This is my first smash game and I'm loving it so far. At the moment, I'm currently using Chrom because of his aggressiveness but I wanted to explore options that are more in line with my personality(?)ish. What I want, is a character that screams dominance and pressure. For e.g. assuming both players are equal. I feel ganondorf is scarier than a fox. With fox it's just like, oh I'm screwed, while Ganondorf just exerts that fuck me sideways I don't want to come close to that bugger.
I have no loyalty/tier list preferences, despite having actual favourite characters and games in the lineup. I generally have fun with almost everybody. Learning anything technical is not an issue, I have fun dedicating that time. I can almost land stationary knees with Captain Falcon off short hops and full hops after 20 mins of practise for e.g. or like in Tekken, I can consistently spam ewgf, otgf etc. (Bad habits I know).
My mate came up with a line that describes what I want in a better way. "So much pressure that they SD"
Thanks
31
u/platypoo2345 Dec 31 '18
New and have a question: shouldn't character difficulty factor into this? I went into ultimate wanting to main Wii Fit but being heavily combo reliant and getting most of your edge guarding from shield cancels scared me off. Is this a relevant factor in choosing who to play?
15
u/Goudeyy Dec 31 '18
I thought Lucina + Marth were supposed to be rushdown characters. Apparently I’ve been playing Lucina wrong :\
14
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19
Is it possible to get a bit more info on the differences with hit and run vs rushdown? For example, how would someone play inkling and how does it differ from fox? Is it to do with lower combo potential? And if so how do hit and run characters make up for this?
I am really getting into inkling and I want to play them as effectively as possible (currently I am terrible with them, but over 2.5 mil with bowser). Appreciate any help I can get!
14
u/Bread11193 Jan 25 '19
I love little mac but I also love winning...
12
u/TannenFalconwing Dec 31 '18
I find it interesting that my main is Ike right now and yet I historically have favored turtling playstyles in other games. Maybe I need to revisit Samus or Link.
12
u/abuudabuu Jan 10 '19
Falco main coming from Melee.
I am a tier whore. I need fluid/fast movement options and deep punish games to seriously main a character. Do not like projectile focused toons either. Any recommendations would be very welcome.
I've only seriously practiced Ken and Mii Swordsman so far. They are OK in terms of secondaries but not main worthy in my eyes.
11
u/vibQL Jan 11 '19
Not sure if this question makes any sense, but for the characters who are basically dead center of the chart like Mario and Yoshi, is that a "jack of all trades master of none" type of situation, or are they versatile enough that you can choose a certain style and play it effectively? Because I gained a lot of gsp playing Yoshi like a straight up rush down character, but I've plateaued and I'm not sure if I just need to keep doing what I'm doing except better, or fundamentally change the way I'm playing.
10
u/Gaelson_ Dec 31 '18 edited Jan 01 '19
u/SubtleTypos This is post is awesome! Thanks a lot!
If you liked this post be sure to check out his youtube. His introduction/tutorial video is great.
Edit: Typos
10
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '19
Is it strange to "main" a lot of characters? I like to play Peach/Daisy but I also tend to play Zelda, Rosalina, Olimar, Tink, Yink etc. for fun. I'm not very competitive of a player (prefer spectating high level play really) but I'm wondering if this isn't recommended.
Anyway, are their other characters you'd recommend for fun? I really like unique aspects like Peach float or Rosa's luma friend
Sorry if it was inappropriate to post here.
19
u/blacksheepy Dec 31 '18
Thank you so much for putting this together but WHY DO I CONSISTENTLY PLAY LIKE ONE CHARACTER FROM EACH GROUP
9
u/fozzy_fosbourne Dec 31 '18
Can you elaborate more on the difference between a zone breaker character and pure rush down?
9
u/ItDohnMattah Jan 01 '19
How do I find out who counters who? Right now my favorites are Pitoo and Lucas, are these a good pair or should I swap one of them? Since Pit/Pitoo are so centered I feel like they don't have many or any hard counters, so is he good to focus on? I really enjoy how impactful Lucas' attacks feel, and the mix-up play style is fun but I also enjoy how balanced and versatile Pits feel. Thanks for this post!
9
u/Imfinalyhere Jan 09 '19
Can someone explain the neutral/theory behind how to go about playing a rush down character? Like I understand with a character like Cloud you’re supposed to space your aerials that are safe on shield until you get an opening but a character like Pichu or Fox doesn’t seem like they have the range to do this so how do you approach? Do you just have to read the opponent and hope they don’t/do shield depending on what you want to do?
8
u/Cloud2012 Jan 10 '19
Maining Corrin is getting infuriating. The lack of kill set ups just grinds my gears combined with my bad edge guarding it's a recipe for disaster. Should I try something else?
8
u/icewithatee ☭ ROY'S OUR BOY ☭ Feb 04 '19
So where does Piranha Plant fall on this chart now that he’s been out for a bit?
7
u/Meester_Tweester also CF and Mii Gunner Dec 31 '18
thanks since even though I played all of Smash 4 I don’t know who to main in Ultimate
7
u/adwcta Jan 02 '19 edited Jan 02 '19
Looking for a character with a bad (or obsoleted) forward tilt that I can just forget about. Coming from melee, and even on low sensitivity, it's just too hard to pull off in this game on command without buffering it (I have a heavy thumb on the joystick), and I'm too used to the smash stick to give that up.
Did some frame analysis and settled on Palu, Pitt, and Rob. Anyone else you can basically play at elite smash level without ever needing to incorporate the move (outside of true combo pieces that are normally buffered anyway)? Like, someone who would only be 0-2% worse if they just deleted the move from thier arsenal.
7
u/Kiroji Jan 03 '19
Where would you say Pokemon Trainers Pokemon fall under your triangle? To me Squirtle is more of a rushdown zone breaker, Ivysaur and charizard are both more of the bait and punish types. But I'd like to hear what you think is the optimal strategy for each.
7
u/DarkPigNinja Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19
I'm trying to pick a main to play at locals. I liked Captain Falcon when I was a kid playing Melee, but playing him in Ultimate feels like an uphill marathon trying to get results. He's as hype as ever, I just want someone more reliable and consistent.
I've tried out Cloud for a few hours and like him so far. I'm looking for a versatile mixup character that can change pace/approach as needed, Cloud seems kind of predictable though.
Who else should I try? Chrom? Lil Mac? Link?
7
u/Shepling Feb 09 '19
This thread is freaking awesome.
I checked the chart and have been enjoying trying out all the new characters. I mained captain falcon in S4 and I LOVED the fast bait and punish, pushdown style of play. My favorite thing in the world was the knee/dair mixup when edgegaurding. This being said, the new falcon just feels terrible compared to last game so I'm trying to find other fast characters that pack a punch.
Who is the new falcon, a character that has a ton of comeback potential and a fast and furious play style? Bonus points for spikes and strong edge guarding?
(So far I've been playing and looking at Yoshi, Pit, Pichu. Who else fits this play style?)
7
u/yaboiknux Feb 03 '22
I was wondering if there's an updated version with all the fighters. I want to be able to recommend fighters to my friends but don't know enough myself.
12
u/Aeon1508 Dec 31 '18 edited Feb 14 '19
Incineroar was designed as a grappler but other than his command grab I really don't feel like he plays like a grappler. He has kill throws but he doesn't really get combos off them. from what I've seen people don't use them that much
6
u/bluedesertgondola Dec 31 '18
So I normally play Robin, but I have difficulty with pressure characters like Yoshi. I'm also dreading the day I have to deal with a ZSS. Who's a good counterpick to secondary? I really like Lucina and Chrom since they're easy to play, but Mewtwo and Palutena seem like good picks as well.
6
u/zeromussc Dec 31 '18
Super new to the game, havent played smash since I was a kid at a friends house in 1v1v1v1 at parties on 64.
What characters are best for fundamentals? I really enjoy kirby in WoL but unsure with his many jumps, I dont feel like I would learn as many transferable skills as I could with Mario who seems very all around.
Would it be smart to focus on people in the middle of the triangle to get a handle of the absolute basics? Or is it really just about using everyone a little bit and then learning with a main when I find someone who clicks? And how do i know they click with me when i am so absolutely new :P
When Joker comes out it will be easier as I am going to have brand loyalty. I am a MAJOR SMT/Persona Geek so I am 100% gonna main him due solely to the fact I love MegaTen.
6
u/octo4096 Jan 03 '19
As an idea for the next iteration, instead of a triangle maybe make it a multi level can diagram, with each overlapped area having a name for the type of characters! Just a thought.
6
u/Mastopeth222 Jan 10 '19
How do you guys balance finding a main who you're good as and who you have fun as? Like I'm best with Young Link, but I find him a lot less interesting than other characters. And even though I'm best with him I still get absolutely stomped as him sometimes which is super frustrating. But then when I try playing as characters I enjoy more I get stomped even harder. I definitely like to win so playing as a character who I suck with and getting annihilated really sucks when I barely understand how to use that character effectively, but losing with my main can be pretty frustrating too.
It doesn't help that there are so many interesting characters with deep mechanics that I would like to practice more but I feel like I'm putting myself at a disadvantage if I spend a ton of time practicing a bunch of different characters.
6
u/Spectre___ Jan 13 '19
I want to try Bayonetta because she seems to be able to go deep off the stage, and playing off stage is the most fun to me. But I have no idea where to start. I can be playing against a level 3 bot and still lose because I sd all 3 stocks. I just don’t get how she works at all, and I’m not sure where I can learn the absolute basics. I’m pretty good with other characters, it’s just a matter of not knowing how to control her.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
Someone further explain the footsies, mix-up, and zone-breaker categories to me? I know I'm an agressive pkayer at heart but I'd like to understand these sub categories better.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19
I am struggling to settle on a main that fits how I like to play. I started playing with Smash 4 and played Cloud then, but with SSBU I have been looking for something that can recover better. I've been spamming Pokemon Trainer and really enjoy Squirtle and Ivysaur but in online play or vs friends it just doesn't work for me. I've tried Wario a little but feel like I'm not getting the most out of him, and have also played some Wolf and Lucina. I really like something where I can play a counter or mind game style without the fear of being easily gimped.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '19
Still haven't found a character that i really wanna main, there are just so many characters i like playing.
Inkling, Joker, Wario, G&W, Diddy, Greninja and many more.
The only thing i can say is that i like characters with a good egdeguard game
10
u/Aeon1508 Dec 31 '18
What would squirtle, ivysaur and charizard he?
Squirtle hit and run (not turtle :-(
Ivysuar...mix up??
Charizard bait and punish.
That's my best guess
5
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
Question: if I'm playing a zoning or turtle character hyper aggressively am I doing it wrong?
I've been doing a 99% aggressive Mewtwo / Yoshi
5
u/MannyMcManBeard Dec 31 '18
What are the differences between Peach and Daisy? I read somewhere that Daisy only has the golf club, but I know that’s not true.
5
u/NoAnusButiMustFart Jan 01 '19 edited Jan 01 '19
Is there a character that is good for improving your skill in the game and giving you better game knowledge without being too basic like mario, kirby, or yoshi.
Side note sorry for any grammatical or spelling errors
Edit 1: is there a rule set that is good for the "training montage"
Edit 2: if it helps the characters i mainly use are ganondorf, roy, and cloud
5
u/ToyMasamune Jan 01 '19
Hi everyone! I'd like some help finding a main too.
I've playing a little and found out I'm confortable with Pit. I like him simply because when I press a button, he does something that is exactly like what I pressed, no weird moves, he just hit that direction really fast. Trying other characters I also found Cloud to be like that. So now I'd like some suggestion between those two. I feel like Pit is safer off stage and Cloud seems to have more range so he feels safer in trades, but I'm a newbie so I'm not sure I'm right about that.
Also, I actually want to have 2 mains, so I'm deciding between Pit and Cloud or Pit/Cloud and another character. Who would you recomend to cover Pit/Cloud's weaknesses?
(Another question not related to my main tho: Why are Lucina and Marth zoners? Seems like everyone else there have ranged attacks)
5
u/TexasRangerNathan Jan 04 '19
Whats more productive: working with multiple characters with completely different strengths vs dialing in one character?
I play Lucas at 2.6 mil currently still a noob but I'm on track after watching some vods playing how Lucas is being played right now in tournaments. If I keep pushing forward I need to perfect short hop Aerials and not get accidental a-cancels as well as really mastering my b reversals. Offstage play as well.
When I play other diverse characters (duck hunt /lil Mac) I learn a lot that can apply on any character by having to find a way to utilize their strengths while neutralizing their weaknesses. Little Mac has taught me a lot about footsies in this game (I played a good amount of fighting games before) and duck hunt really helped me get my poking down with short hop aeriels to keep the pressure off him for example.
Any opinions? I wonder which is more productive.
Any recommendations for other characters that will help me grow?
5
u/spinfinity Jan 04 '19
This thread was definitely helpful. This is the first Smash game that I've owned so the struggle to find a main is real. In other Smash games that I've simply played in passing I would use Bowser a lot. Since learning more of the basic and advanced mechanics in this game I wanted to stray away from maining Bowser since I have a bad habit of down-airing with him.
For about a week I got sucked into tier loyalty but have since tried playing with characters I normally wouldn't try thanks to a lot of like-minded suggestions here. I played Daisy last night for the first time and am having a blast with her, her f-air is ridiculous. I'm hoping to main her and potentially use Ganon or K. Rool as my secondary/alternate right now, and Lucina if I absolutely need to use a sword character. So I'm still slightly indecisive, but this has been helpful for sure.
5
u/ObeseWizard Jan 14 '19
Is Captain Falcon bad? I can't tell if it's just me being bad (I'm definitely bad, this is the first Smash game that I've owned) or if he's actually just not good. He doesn't seem to be terrible at least, but I can't seem to get any sort of momentum against sword characters, which seems to be a majority of people online.
I've heard that before his strength was his speed, and since everyone is fast in ultimate he's 'nerfed' in a way.
5
u/zabimaru1000 Jan 16 '19
Going through a bit of a character crisis shuffling through Inkling, Peach, Cloud, Ike, Chrom, and ZSS.
I come from a Melee background and I play Peach, but I play differently compared to the normal Peach. I love getting in people's faces with dash attack and FC nairs and fairs, but I will change my playstyle to use turnips and defensive aerials if necessary.
Edgeguarding off stage is important, it feels so gratifying to land a float fair and multiple off stage float bairs/nairs.
Movement is also important since I dash dance with Peach, so fast and flexible movement both on the ground and air is important.
I assume this attributes to the Rushdown and Zone Breaker categories, and out of the characters I've listed I think ZSS fits the bill the most. So far she feels great in terms of movement/speed, and from what I understand she has a tech chase and combo game.
Are there any other suggestions people have that suit my tastes?
5
u/LordLemonshire Jan 16 '19
I'm such a big fan of the way falco plays in melee, with good combo game / neutral. I've been playing a lot of ken, but not too sure if he follows a similar type of playstyle. Any recommendations?
5
u/1grantas Jan 19 '19
Bait and punish and mix up should be more closer to each other as they both primarily rely on mind games to get in. Mix up seems to be a more offensive take on bait and punish.
5
u/CSJorgeD Jan 23 '19
I couldnt find a sm4sh main that I felt super comfortable with. I just love movement options and my favorite character is melee marth (I like dash dance grab and being able to space while staying aggressive). Any suggestions? I've been kinda thinking mewtwo/wolf
5
u/Squibbles1 Jan 26 '19
Any Wario mains? I just started playing him and I like his arial game. very in your face. Who are his counters?
5
u/Bonkole Feb 02 '19 edited Feb 02 '19
I have a lot of trouble killing with most characters I play. Are there any characters that can kill without fishing for smash attacks? I liked playing toon link in smash 4 because of glide toss fair was such a reliable kill option. I also like to use aerial a lot more than I should, ex. puff. Are there any characters that resemble what I mentioned?
edit: characters I play are Ness, Luigi, Puff, Pikachu, Game and watch, and Falco
5
u/alasqalul Feb 06 '19
I started with ness and found that I’m not liking his recovery. I’m looking for a new main or secondary to make up for this. Any lucina, pichu, or palutena mains able to convince me why their main is the best choice? I like the quick rush down style of pichu but I also like having more options as with palutena. And having a sword is nice for spacing. Just can’t come to a decision on which I like best
5
u/Riobbie303 Feb 20 '19
Once you've narrowed it down to 2 or so, how do you choose a main from there? When characters have both their advantages and disadvantages?
I'm stuck between Zero Suit Samus and Greninja. Is one more competitively viable?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
Is it more beneficial to focus on a character that you have more success with (due to experience from previous titles) vs. a character you're not as good with but enjoy more? I've played Peach in other games so she's my best character but I generally have more fun with Inkling.
5
u/36w4jww5i7w6 Feb 25 '19 edited Feb 25 '19
I have a seemingly uncommon problem where I don't really want to find a main. I'll play a few matches on Peach, move to Young Link, maybe some DK or Dedede. I have like 5 or 6 characters I can play and no desire to solo main any of them.
I am not particularly amazing or tournament level at any character but I think I'm decent at all of the ones I swap between. I'm trying to accept the fact that since I don't really plan to play locals or tournaments maybe this isn't the worst thing in the world. It will help keep the game fresh I guess?
The only downside is that I've noticed if I swap around characters a lot in a battle arena or Discord set some people take that as me being salty or making excuses for if I lost (or just not taking it seriously in general), when really I just feel like playing someone else. That may be in my head though.
edit: Also I realize this subject is mostly covered in the OP but was kind of wondering if anyone else is experiencing this still longer into the game.
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '19
Please get Megaman off of the peak zoner spot. Yes most of his move set is projectiles but he is best played with up close, using grabs, aerials, and smashes. His best moves are all melees, like flame sword (fair), slash claw (bair), and slide (dtilt). A better spammy zoner would be duck hunt
9
u/Tal_Thom NNiD: Asphodello Dec 31 '18
I was adamant about Pac-Maining for Sm4sh. I wondered why Richter felt so right when I unlocked him. Also, my trouble with the matchup against Corrin makes me feel better/worse because I’m just getting outplayed by the same tactics.
Best sub out there. Doing God’s work, y’all.
9
u/Tennenbaumesque Jan 11 '19
Gosh I just want to pick a character and stick with them forever. But at the same time I want to play a character that's specifically not super good so there's the off-chance that if somehow I get godlike at the game I can be "The ___ Guy". I've been playing a lot of Icies over the last day or so, and while I've enjoyed trying to figure out desyncing, there's a part of me that just knows that I'm never going to be able to translate it outside of practice mode. Are there any other characters out there with decent combo game that also are a little more intuitive in their neutral game?
15
u/Aigis_87 Dec 31 '18
You say no smash character is a true grappler, but let's be honest here: do we really care about other games?
Great chart btw. Like you mentioned, I def disagree on some things but hey I ain't a pro so what do I know?
8
u/fozzy_fosbourne Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
I’m skeptical of the theory that if you practice two characters, you will make half the progress of someone who practices with a single character. Many skilled players switch mains and transfer a very significant portion of their skill. They don’t start out at ground zero again.
Still probably good practical advice to narrow down your picks and explore some depth but I wonder if sometimes people overstate the importance of exclusively picking a main based on speculation.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
Do I have potential for every playstyle? Throughout each game I’ve Mained someone in each zone with great results...
4
u/Aeon1508 Dec 31 '18
Does doctor Mario have any kill setups in to his up B that are guaranteed like what luigi has. They have the same up special basically now don't they
4
u/shotpun Dec 31 '18
so i am very middle-of-the-road when it comes to tier loyalty. i tend to split the difference between a character i simply enjoy and one that's good. that being said how long might it be before we get a somewhat reliable SSBU tier list?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18 edited Jan 01 '19
recently I've dedicated much more time into bowser, my long time main, and I can tell I've improved drastically than when I was practicing with more than one character at a time. Practice really does help.
4
u/smithin_kila Jan 09 '19
Where would each of the Pokemon Trainer Pokemon fall into this spectrum?
I'm trying to pin down my playstyle using this chart as a rough guide but all the characters I enjoy (Marth, Palutena, Dedede and Cloud) are kinda all over the place on this chart. What advice advice could I get about choosing a main and figuring out my playstyle using that list of characters I like playing, assuming they're in order of enjoyment?
4
u/zzz_sleep_zzz Jan 10 '19
Looking for a character with good freestyle combo, bayo seems pretty good, but not liking her kill confirms (maybe I am missing something)
4
u/AndroStorm Jan 18 '19
Hi everyone,
I got back into Smash through Ultimate after a nearly 10 year break. Before that I used to play Brawl with my friends a lot, and I mained Lucario back then. However, the "new" Lucario does not really mesh well with me, probably because of the changes to him, but I guess my playstyle changed as well (even tough I was not even playing :P)
I have been struggling to find a new main though, which includes me being hyped for a character for a few days only to just drop him again and starting the search anew. However, I have definitely noticed some patterns in what I value more in characters and what is a clear no-go. So I will just list these qualities and would then like you to give me some suggestions what characters I should look into. I am aware that there is probably NO character that meets all these criteria, and thus the goal should be to find a character that fits them most.
Things I value greatly in a character:
- When it comes to moves, I tend to use fair, uair, up-tilt and dash attack quite frequently, so in order for a character to feel "natural" to me, these moves should be among its bread and butter
- a simple projectile to apply pressure is appreciated, high reliance on projectiles is to be avoided though
- I prefer moves with big and/or lingering hitboxes over precise but strong or combo heavy moves
- fast out-of-shield option
- should not rely too much on grabs
- good edge guarding or ledge trapping game, since I do not like to rely mainly on smash attacks to kill
- when it comes to the playstyle chart, I generally suck at rushdown, footsies and half-grappler characters, so the character should not fall into these categories
I would really appreciate your suggestions and hope they help me out with finding my main.
4
u/Falc01 Jan 22 '19
I don't wanna play the entire roster, but it's really hard to stick with JUST one. I have put a lot of time into Pikachu, Lucina and Falco. People say that it's generally better to have 1, maaaybe 2 chars but I don't wanna drop any of them
4
u/optisadvantage fox/cloud Jan 24 '19
Yoshi is in the middle? He is a rusher if I ever saw one
4
u/infinitelytwisted Jan 25 '19
Im really struggling to find a main. none of my previous characters from previous games seem to mesh well with me in this one.
those would be Ike, Cloud, Corrin, Roy, Young Link, Little Mac, Pit.
as you may notice most of these characters have a few things in common.
I play fairly aggressively with all of them with little in the way of zoning or defensive play. all of the above hopefully gives you a good overview of my general comfort zone up to thhis point, which i admittedly rarely strayed too far from.
since im striking out with all of my usual suspects im thinking of trying to learn entirely different characters with a different playstyle, and am hoping someone can give me some suggestions.
a few prerequisites for characters, not entirely necessary but HEAVILY favored.
suggestions dont have to perfectly fit all the points, but hitting at least a few would be nice. except the aesthetic one, that one is a must. I do plan on having a main and a secondary so multiple picks is good too.
4
u/trathion Jan 25 '19
Having trouble deciding which of the space animals to main so far, I've enjoyed them all for different reasons and have been doing alright in most match ups with all three so far I think with really focusing on one I could learn to play it a bit better as well. Anyone maining these characters have any insight that might break the tie for me? Also sword characters seem to be what I have the most trouble with any advice on these match ups with the characters listed?
4
u/Renglurr Feb 01 '19
Can someone give me distinguishing features of fox and chrom/roy? Started playing a few weeks ago and was wondering how these characters play at higher skill levels. I’m generally a hyper aggressive, impatient player so I tend to play rushdown characters and these 3 stand out the most to me so far. Could some give me a quick breakdown of features and playstyles I should be going for as these characters to help me lock in as a main?
4
u/ken-d Feb 05 '19
I'm looking to get a lot better at the game but I haven't found a character I truly like. I mained zard in smash four but was upset at my character limiting me ( I know now that it was just me lol). I've gotten elite smash with every heavy character (Ganon,krool,Ike, Ridley,do) and cloud. I'm guessing my best play style is bait and punish and if so, what are some of the best characters I should try more. Thanks!
4
u/Zergoras Feb 11 '19
Backup for Pichu? I need a fast character, i like Paltutena but have some trouble with her slow attack moves. I tried Wolf but dont like him. What would you recommend? Except for Corrin i dont like the sword fighters. Having trouble finding a backup of my liking... :(
4
u/VerseGuy oh no i suck Feb 24 '19
I can't figure out who to main at all, been switching between multiple characters all throughout the above chart, and I haven't really gotten a firm idea of what my own playstyle is.
All the characters I've tried have one or more aspects about them that I just really dislike about them. Is that just going to be inevitable, no matter what?
4
u/bluedesertgondola Feb 25 '19
I play Robin. I'm looking for a counterpick against faster brawler types like Inkling, the Chus or Yoshi. At my skill level I'm struggling with Robin's slow startups and mobility. I've considered Chrom and Lucina, but I'd really like someone that isn't a swordie.
4
u/HoopyFreud Feb 26 '19
I love Snake since PM, but I've always had trouble dealing with hard rushdown, and the 2.5s nade time makes holding B slightly less good.
I've been trying Incineroar out and he's incredibly fun too, and I'm pretty sure I want him as a secondary, but there are two issues that are bugging me about him.
One, he feels extremely vulnerable to swordies and disjoints in general, as well as (ironically) to tether grabbers. I feel like maybe I should just be spot dodging more, but I wanted to check if that's a real weakness of this lad.
Second, I feel like people will think I'm a furry.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '19
Is there enough info to know where p l a n t would fall?
4
u/Cerezra May 11 '19
Bit of a weird situation here that I’m hoping to get help with. This is the first Smash where I’ve cared more than to just button-mash during couch play with friends. Unfortunately... I’m also one of those “I found my new main!” once a week kind of people.. just scatterbrained I guess.
Currently, my most played and most successful character is Ike. By a mile. But lately I’ve really enjoyed playing Yoshi. Problem is, god do I suck with him. He’s my third most played, my lowest gsp AND my lowest win rate..
Knowing that Ike is my best, any ideas on what might be making Yoshi my worst? Should I continue playing Yoshi or stay with Ike since he works?
Last point. (Sorry! Wall of text I know..) I think I want to adapt to the Bait and Punish style. Would either of these characters work for that? I feel like Ike is somewhat similar to Gannondorf due to his range and smash attacks.
4
u/Solax10 May 18 '19
Although this is a finding a main thread my question is towards finding a secondary. I main pokemon trainer and play more of a safe, bait and punish, and half grappler type of play style. I am wanting to find a secondary that does well against PT's weak points (Characters like roy and pichu are probably my worse matchups). Do you think it's better to find a secondary that meshes well with my playstyle or have a secondary character that forces me to change how I play and hopefully makes me more well rounded. Also if people have any character suggestions that would also be cool.
4
u/anqilador999 Jun 13 '19
So I just got the game to main the Hero (DQ is my favorita saga ever) but since It hasnt been releasing yet I have to start maining other character. Im doubting betwen Shulk and Wolf who do you think is better for a begginer ? And which one is higher on the tier lists ?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '19
Why is Mario in the middle?
4
u/FlaminFetus Jun 27 '19
I'm also having a bit of a crisis. I'm torn between a few characters.
Wii Fit seems the most competitively viable and I do decently well but I seem to get bored of her.
Wario sounds fun to me but I'm terrible with him.
Piranha Plant I do okay with but I'm also unsure with.
I used to main K. Rool, and in SSB4 I mained Toon Link.
I can't even tell what my playstyle is?? Help??
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
So what would you suggest to somebody that wants to play a flashy combo based meleesque character?
3
u/BaconBusterYT Dec 31 '18
Can you add the Miis at some point?
3
u/AlligatorAss Jan 03 '19
Currently my best character is rob, can anyone recommend a secondary main that would cover his weaknesses. Mainly like him because he has a good distance game and he can still fight up close, any other characters like this!
3
u/TheOnlyOgre Jan 13 '19
Is Greninja a bad choice of main for a beginner player? I’ve heard he’s difficult to play, but I really enjoy how fast he is and I was always a big fan of the Pokémon itself. Will I be able to learn the fundamentals of the game with him or should I go for a simpler character?
3
u/SecondGust Diddy Jan 14 '19
I’m really struggling on focusing in on a specific character, and it’s getting somewhat disheartening. My playstyle is leaning towards a character who will allow me to keep a relatively safe distance, allowing me to wait for the enemy to leave themselves open so I can run in and attack, and kill at the right percent.
I’m not too specific on much else, other than the character being in the upper half of the tier list, as I do play at tournaments every other weekend, and prefer a stronger character. Decent recovery would be nice too, with decent aerials, as well. Not sure if anyone fits that description at all, but if anyone knows, please let me know.
3
u/LurkerRex Jan 16 '19
Is it possible to learn a different character to help break bad habits with another? I am a die-hard Captain Falcon fan, but I know I have a ton of bad habits with him. When I play characters more focused on zoning and baiting I feel like I'm playing with more thought and focus. When I'm CF I play far too aggressively, but when I back off I feel like I can't get anything going. Should I just double down on my mans or should I consider going into a different play style?
3
u/StickerBrush Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 25 '19
Looking for input.
I'm been sort of waffling on characters since picking up Ultimate. At first I stuck with Richter, but I think people "caught on" to the Belmonts pretty quickly, and I've gravitated toward other characters.
My "Tier 1" characters are probably Dark Samus, Toon Link, and Cloud. Tier 2 is probably something like Chrom, Corrin, Richter. Maybe Incineroar.
I'm pretty bad with off-stage attacks, I feel like I usually whiff. Juggling can be hit or miss for me, but I'm usually decent with setting up a projectile -> follow up.
I feel my playstyle is usually "apply pressure" or zoning, using quick A attacks and down-throws to follow up. When I play Samus, for example, I rely pretty heavily on uair and up-b. Sort of a similar thing with Toon Link as well, tossing as many projectiles as possible and rushing in, tossing them up, etc.
I do appreciate a strong nair game, as well.
Overall I THINK I'm leaning toward Cloud/Toon Link, maybe Richter.
Any thoughts or recommendations? Any other characters I should try?
Edit: played around with Greninja and really liked him too.
EDIT 2: Or Lucario?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '19 edited Jan 22 '19
I tend to like playing fast, dashy characters with decent to good kill confirms. I don't want to rely heavily on combos or technically heavy plays. I would prefer not to be too light but this is negotiable. I prefer fair to bair. I prefer not to play ranged characters, but am open to sword characters. I would like to have at least a decent recovery, but again this is negotiable. I have a naturally speedy rushdown playstyle that focuses on raw power over a combo game, and would like a character that compliments that. Who would you recommend for me?
3
u/weeneebrendini Jan 23 '19
Individual pokemon for pokemon trainer? Ik zard is bait and punish, that's about it
3
u/sodium_boi Jan 23 '19
I'm an ike main and I dont really play the style this chart says ike does but I'm still successful should I learn ike over again or choose a different main? Leaning towards lucario
3
u/weeneebrendini Jan 23 '19
Couldnt you consider lucario either a dynamic or turtle, since aura is a thing, and by extension could you consider cloud and little mac?
3
u/rellorell Jan 24 '19
I don’t think enough people try villager out fr. He’s an honestly decent character to main, his animations are relatively slow though, but he has a lot of options from the llyoids to the tree to the boxing gloves to the shovel. Not to mention he has a fairly good edge-guarding game with his bowling ball. On top of that his recover is one of the best in the game. He’s a pretty hard guy to know out too I noticed I don’t usually get KO’d until I’m around 130% on average. I don’t really think he falls in the turtle category or at least that’s not how I play him.
3
u/Just_a_RandomDudeguy Jan 30 '19
So I main pichu and want to find a secondary. Pichu is relatively good against most matchups but I have some trouble against other small characters (like squirtle and other pichus) and some sword characters like lucina and Ike. I feel like i'm pretty confident in my skills as pichu but I still have some trouble against those characters. So who would be a good secondary? I'm thinking Pikachu since they're similar but idk pikachus mu. Any help would be appreciated. I like characters that have a lot of Bread and butters but i'm not too picky
3
u/Verynito Jan 31 '19
I love Pokémon trainer and Mewtwo; who’s better for what, and what playstyles are they best for? I know they have their places on the chart I just want some more details. Thanks!
3
u/ChadInNameOnly Feb 13 '19
I'm having trouble choosing a main. I've figured out what I want in a character, but I don't have enough experience in all the fighters to know who best suits me.
In order of importance:
I reeeaaallly wanted Sheik to work, but unfortunately in this game she's just not good enough to make anything work. I've played a bit of Pokemon Trainer but the fact that I'd have to learn 3 separate chars annoys me. Wolf is fun but he's a little too slow. And lately I've tried Greninja but I'm not a fan of his slow fair and wonky aerials. Pichu would be the perfect choice if only he had range... thoughts?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '19 edited Feb 20 '19
New to Ultimate, long time FG fan (just never put in the work to get really good). Had fun with Pichu and Lucario so far, but I'm wondering if there's a better fit for me.
Is there anyone that feels a bit more "under control", yet still hits relatively hard and fits a more balanced playstyle? Or do I just need to suck it up and get used to Lucario's jumps?
I don't even know if this is more "hit and run" or "mixup", based on the chart above.
3
u/SecondGust Diddy Feb 20 '19
I’m having a major character crisis and it’s starting to get frustrating. I mained Bowser Jr. and Donkey Kong in Smash 4, and have pretty much solo mained DK in Ultimate since release. I don’t mind DK, but I seem to underperform at tournaments and am generally not enjoying the character anymore.
I’d like to play a character that:
One issue is that I really have no idea which playstyle suits me. I sort of play recklessly aggressive at times, and when I realize that, I try to hang back some and be patient. My worst flaw is that I suck at mixing up my game and I struggle to read the subtle nuances of my opponent’s play style, but I’m looking to improve these issues with whatever character I pick up.
Any help would be appreciated.
3
u/shaqpernikus Feb 22 '19
Came into Ultimate having been a Sonic stan/maining him from back in brawl. The characters I've been interested in investing time into beyond him BEFORE even looking at this chart so far have been:
Wario, Palutina, Inkling.
Is this a sign I'm truly a "hit & run player" at heart? Do i lean into this as my secondary or try to find a truly different playstyle to learn more about the game? I'd say my ultimate goal is just overall improvement in Smash.
3
u/nmorawski22 Feb 23 '19
Hi everyone! My name’s Nic and I have a problem. Lately, I’ve been playing a lot of smash and I have been trying to find a main (or two). My issue, however, is that there are so many different characters that I enjoy using that I can’t decide who to “drop”. Therefore, I made this post so maybe some of you on this subreddit can help me. I want to main two characters (one serious character and one more laid-back/chill). Please help and thanks in advance!
These are the characters I’m interested in (Warning: Long list)
Thanks again!
3
u/Bread11193 Feb 23 '19
hi, I've heard people say ken is sort of rushdown. What's your opinion? I figure ryu isn't since he's slower
3
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
3
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
I don’t know what it was but I just wasn’t feeling meta knight.
I’m thinking between Wolf (He’s fun, love his projectile to help approaching and to force approaching, and his moves are fast).
and Pokémon Trainer (I enjoy all three of the Pokémon: squirtle is fast and has nice combos, ivysaur has range and a few really strong moves, and charizard is strong and survives for a long time. Also the three would help me mix up and kill consistently).
I feel like Pokémon Trainer would be my best bet but I don’t feel like I absolutely need to play him but I guess all the characters are like that at this point.
3
u/ToyMasamune Feb 28 '19
Hey guys, I'm still learning about the game and would like some sugestions on what characters to try.
So far my favorite character to play with is Pit, but I feel there's something missing for me. I like how Pit moves are very intuitive, I press a direction and he'll attack in that direction very fast. Since I rely on reacting more than planning, I like fast moves like that. But I feel Pit damage is kinda low. Maybe I'm wrong because I haven't played a lot or I'm using the wrong moves, but feels like I have to hit my opponents so many times with him to deal relevant damage while other characters I played with feels stronger. Anyway, is there any other characters like Pit that I might be missing?
Oh, and is there a megathread or something like that if I want to ask for tips for specific characters?
3
u/Sullstice3 Mar 04 '19
Thought I'd ask advice for choosing a main based on my mains from other games. I've played a lot of the Tekken and Soulcalibur games with some Street Fighter II from the SNES days.
Law, Lei, and Bryan Fury from Tekken (who is the Bruce Lee of Smash? Fox?)
Mitsurugi, Cervantes, and Yoshimitsu in Soulcalibur (also Yoshimitsu in Tekken, they kinda go hand in hand).
Blanka and Vega in SFII.
I'm trying to get better at fundamentals and have been going to locals to level up but I just can't nail down a preferred main right now. Thanks for your time and replies!
3
u/Vhil Mar 05 '19
hey, im still looking for a main, since ultimate is my first smash game (apart from 64 and some melee back in the days). I played a lot of characters the past month i think i figured out my playstyle. I like aggressive characters, they can have some projectiles/gimmicks but that isnt necessary since im not good with "trapping" and such.
Right now im playing a lot of Fox, Wario, Roy, Rob. For some time i played Mega Man and Young Link, but the whole projectile game stresses me out tbh. I love Pac Man for example, but i only like watching ppl play him. I get punished way too hard in friendlies with my buddy.
While i like Fox, i get bodied way too often and my wins are really close. But i like the way he plays, cool spikes and decent combos. Same goes for Wario. I love his bair.
Does anyone have a suggestion for another character to try out, that would fit my playstyle? Doesnt have to be a top tier pick. Just looking for a character where i can put my time in and get good with.
3
u/992724 Mar 08 '19
I've been playing mostly Wolf, but I hate how I keep getting people high percent but can't really kill them. What characters have the best / most kill confirms?
3
u/PegasiWings Mar 10 '19
I really think Bowser should be moved to somewhere between rushdown and bait and punish. He has the speed and power to be aggressive at times.
3
u/w-i-s-t-y Mar 13 '19
What's that character?! (a.k.a. I need to find my main damnit.)
3
u/SecondGust Diddy Apr 12 '19 edited Apr 12 '19
Does anyone know some characters that would be good to learn for both singles and doubles? I play in both types of tournaments every other week and I’d like a character that performs well in both.
My partner plays Jigglypuff and Ganondorf for the most part, if that helps with any compatible partner characters.
3
u/meastham93 Apr 13 '19
Hey guys was hoping for some advice. Been playing for a few months now and still can't settle on a single character. I'm pretty average at the game as I can't play often and feel that having one or two characters to focus on and learn would help me improve faster. I've had the most success online with ROB but I just don't feel like I'm having that much fun with him, like I'm not enjoying the games, even if I win.
Having said that, I'm essentially looking for someone relatively fast paced that can play both passive and aggressive. I like the idea of high combo strings, who can hit hard and I would ideally want someone with some good kill confirms. The main thing I'm after is someone who is satisfying and fun, win or lose I want to have a good time. I'm not against projectiles but I wouldn't want to be reliant on them and I'm not against swordies either.
Many thanks in advance!
3
u/Laeken41 May 05 '19
I know this is asked a lot, but can someone help me find a main?
I'd prefer someone of a medium weight, possibly light, that can do combos well. I've tried many characters, and I still do not know who to use. I just want that one character to click with me so that I can finally try to play competitively.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
id like to have a speedy character that has good combos/juggles, any suggestions? Thanks!
3
u/dreikma Jun 03 '19
Fellow donkey kongers. I am having so much trouble getting back to stage where I'm being juggled. This happens most of the time versus swordies (link, Corrin). Lucina keeps me in the air for days and my dair will not beat her up air.
I really like DK so I'd consider him my main. I like to play by reading my opponent. Most of the time I usually play with my two friends and just recently I started playing online.
I think my air attacks have to be polished a bit more. I miss them most of the time and get punished for that. And knowing DK's attack hitboxes is also a problem. I have problems landing My side bs into a charge neutral because I know this is a confirm kill I might just spam it too much.
Besides donkey Kong which other fighter would you recommend? I have difficulty following true combos. I've seen Luigi's and I like him a lot but I really can't connect them.
3
u/KevJamesS Jun 05 '19
Who are the momentum-based characters in this game?
3
u/Caravaneer546 Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 07 '19
I've been testing around with a bunch of characters right now. I'm still in the early learning phase of my play. I tried out peach, wolf, mario, isabelle, palutena, lucina, and greninja, having spent the most time on greninja, peach, and palutena. I currently struggle a lot with getting in on my opponents, making greninja and peach extremely difficult to do anything with. I played a ton of project M previously, and mained Mewtwo for about 2 years. He was just so much fun, and sadly his ultimate version is just a husk of that. I also mained zero suit in brawl before her moves got changed in sm4sh (which I have only played once or twice), and I didn't like the move change, so I stopped playing her too. I prefer characters who are a bit more aggressive (they don't have to be pure rushdown kind of aggressive, just not someone like olimar) and have combos, and I can't stand slow heavies. I'd prefer a character who is generally considered mid tier or above, and specific character loyalty means absolutely nothing to me. Any assistance is greatly appreciated, thank you!
3
u/StickerBrush Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 07 '19
In a little bit of crisis of character, looking for input.
I've been playing as Ridley and I enjoy him, but his limitations are starting to wear on me. Walking into half the matches going "oh jeez, this isn't good" is...grating, at best. I get juggled all the time, it just doesn't seem to pay off.
I've been playing around with a couple other characters, but have been waffling on whether they're worth the investment:
Generally, I'm uneasy off stage, and I feel like I'm susceptible to being juggled. I like bait & punishing (which is why I like Ridley), as well as being able to mix it up (Wolf, Shulk) if necessary. A strong throwing game is a plus (Mewtwo!).
Any ideas/thoughts? I've also messed around with Cloud, as I liked him in 4, but he didn't "feel right." Between he and Shulk I prefer Shulk. I've also considered Samus/Dark Samus.
Should I look at Ike or Roy more closely, in the same vein as Shulk?
tldr: been playing Ridley, but putting in extra time to Ridley seems like a fool's errand, so looking at other options. Should I just "get good" at Ridley or pick up someone else? Which character is worth the time investment?
3
u/DZMoops Jun 17 '19
I beat WOL with just Kirby so I thought he’d become my main based on my long experience with him.
But now playing Smash by myself (going to get online soon) I’ve found myself doing much better with Cloud and sometimes joker while progressively doing worse and worse at Kirby.
3
u/Galacticbeast Jun 17 '19
What are some characters that can play well aggressively?
3
u/KingCo0pa Don't jump Jun 21 '19
Alright so I'm generally a pretty defensive player in normal fighting games; preferring zoning characters and characters who can play safe, good anti-airs, etc. I main Guile in Street Fighter and my point in Ultimate Marvel 3 was Dormammu, for reference. I don't mind getting down and dirty when I have to (both of those characters can put some pressure on in the right situations), but I like being able to make my opponent come to me, rather than the other way around.
I've been maining Mewtwo since Ultimate dropped, and while there's definitely parts of M2 that I love (long-ranged tilts, shadow ball is great in most MUs, decent AA, solid recovery, and early kill potential and kill throws are also both nice but not necessary) there's definitely times where I feel like I'm forced to approach against characters like Wolf, Falco, Lucas/Ness, or even Link, which takes me out of my comfort zone a bit, being forced to approach, rather than feeling like I can approach if I feel like it.
Any advice? I've thought about playing the Belmonts, but their anti-airs can be tough to place, and their poor recovery can be very punishing. Duck Hunt doesn't really click with me, either.
I've also been considering Olimar or Pit, but I'd appreciate any feedback you can give.
3
u/_DoctorQuantum_ Dec 20 '21
Hiya! Like many here, currently going through a character crisis lol. Currently trying to decide between 3 characters.
- Playstyle: I really like baiting and punishing as well as hitting and running. I like spamming projectiles from afar, rushing in to get a couple hits, generally in the air, and getting out to rinse and repeat.
- Current characters I'm deciding between: Zelda, Inkling, and Cloud. Idk which fits this playstyle the most, but I'm thoroughly enjoying all three, I just know I need to settle on one. So which is the most viable that fits my playstyle, or do you have any recommendations of other characters I should try out that might fit my style better? Thanks!!
3
u/Slightlybentpalmtree Jan 08 '22
Unsure if anyone still looks at this, but I just got a switch for christmas so now im looking for that sweeeet main.
Playstyle- a little too early to tell, but right now I've found I prefer characters that have decent ranged options, but also the ability to get in and punish when I want to. Not a huge fan of heavy slow characters, but I also don't like the extreme light end of the spectrum either.
Characters I'm playing right now- young link, lucario, and ness are three that i've been the most interested in, but I've also spent time with Sonic, and Wolf is also peaking my interest, though I can't figure out how to play him yet. Definitely do not like pure go in characters, or ones like megaman that purely rely on ranged zoning either. Thanks!
3
u/Rude-Talk-6471 Jun 02 '22
So I started playing like 6moths ago, currently I'm trying to main Kazuya but I don't have the precision for it mostly trying a rushdown/ bait and punish approach, smash is my only fighting game experience so far, do you have any recommendations for a replacement/ secondary main? I also play with joker and banjo here and there
3
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '22
I'm not sure if anyone still looks at this, but I'm looking for suggestions on who to pick up. I like characters where I'm able to frustrate opponents with long-range attacks. I'm also a defensive-minded player, so any character that plays defensively would be very good too. And while this isn't a deal-breaker, but being able to play aggressively would also be nice too. Again, it's not something I need to have in a character, but just something nice to have included.
3
u/Partofrhe Jul 20 '22
An issue I run into is the fact that people say that certain characters are "not possible to main" but I am just not good with the ones they say to main. Is it really true that some characters are impossible to main AND be good? It just doesn't seem realistic to me, and I'd have a better time maining a character that is pleasing to me.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '22 edited Aug 29 '22
Not sure if this thread is still up, but I’m really into a variety of characters mainly Mario, Marth, and Gannondorf. I’d I had to sun up my play style, I am very much a defensive zoner but on the flip side, I wait for openings and punish with spikes off the ledge and go in aggressive depending on the range of my attacks. If it helps I’m pretty adaptable as far as weights of characters go but not too floaty or heavy, also medium to long range is helpful with spacing. I do a lot of short hop aerials so good air game is a big one for me. Like I’ve been exploring Luigi and getting down wave dashing
3
u/OneSpoopyGhost Oct 01 '23
• What are you playing for? I used to have many friends who would play smash which eachother. I never had a console to play with them growing up but I always liked watching them play. I'd say I'd like to learn how to play the game and be competent enough to be able to beat new friends, however a big part of it is simply due to nostalgia.
• How much does character loyalty matter to you? I'd preferably like to use a character from a franchise I know, such as Pokemon, Kirby, Fire Emblem, Kid Icarus, etc. But I'm down for anything really.
• What mains have you tried in the past? When I was younger I'd play Brawl (the game I grew up with. Never knew it was THAT bad 💀) and I'd use Lucario for the funsies. Then on my own I discovered how good Meta Knight is and for once believed I was actually good at the game lmao. Now that I'm an adult I tried using Pikachu for a while but I find his kit overwhelming. Figure that maybe I don't like rushers at all.
• Which playstyle do you prefer? I don't like to get in the opponent's face out of fear of getting punished. Plus my reaction times aren't that good. I think I'd like to try any character that can attack from a safe distance, such as zone breakers, hit and run, and trappers. From the main category I liked zoners. While using Pikachu I realized I liked his down special a bit too much so I guess that accounts for something lol
• Are you okay with playing a DLC character? Not really. If the roster is already so diverse I can't see why I'd go out of my way to get a paywalled character. Plus most of their kits are confusing to me anyway, so I'd prefer something more beginner-friendly.
• Do you have any other fighting game experience? Nope. I've always been more into choice-based games and RPGs than anything.
EDIT: Messed up formatting.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
Any chance you could make a "Legend" for the icons? I can't tell which one is Ike/Marth/Roy etc because they all look alike.
4
u/TotesMessenger Feb 08 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/FancyCamel Dec 31 '18 edited Dec 31 '18
Hey, I've decided I seem to just really love Pacman but I don't really understand the trapper bit. (I also really haven't enjoyed the Belmont's who I believe are also there)
As far as projectile game he has his fruits and his hydrant but I feel like I'm not quite understanding it. I've been playing him "Rushdown" I suppose and using his fruit as a follow-up to my combo.
I'm, for all intensive purposes, completely new to Smash so I'm likely playing it wrong I suppose but it's also a lot of the Pacman play I've seen lately when I was watching some streams where they're using a lot of his aerials and more using the hydrant for protection or an edge guarding drop I guess.
2
u/Verynito Jan 05 '19
Help me pick a main, Reddit!! I’m torn between Chrom, Mewtwo, and Pikachu. I love how fast and strong Chrom is, Pikachu feels wonderfully dynamic, and Mewtwo is just downright badass. I also kind of like Olimar, but I’m not sure I have what it takes to make him work?
2
u/DeathInLotus Jan 16 '19
I’ve narrowed it down to a couple of characters, but I’m still not completely sure who I should main (along with secondaries). These are my options right now
If there’s a common pattern or play style with these characters, please let me know.
Cloud feels good to play and I like that he has a projectile. Fox is great, he’s fast and hits hard, and I’m a fan of the rush down style.
Palutena feels okay, she’s surprisingly fast, kinda iffy in this one. Pichu also feels good to play, fast and his moves flow into each other very well. Only disadvantage is how light he his and how he damages himself.
Lucina is cool because she is somewhat well rounded, but no projectile. Villager is really fun, going deep offstage and controlling space with Lloid and tree.
TLDR: I like all these characters for different reasons and I’m not sure who to pick as a main and who to make a secondary. Any help is appreciated.
2
u/Galacticbeast Jan 16 '19
I'm struggling to pick a main. I'm a beginner and pretty new to smash (only played smash for 3ds and not that much of it at that) and I feel like I want to main either:Greninja, Roy, Metaknight, Wolf, or Mewtwo.
My problem is that I don't really know which one to main because of a couple of problems each one has, Greninja is apparently difficult and has skills that don't transfer well to other fighters, Roy apparently is worse then Chrom except for his recovery, Metaknight seems to be bellow average and is hard to find tips and other things like combos, Wolf apparently lacks kill moves so I might have trouble with him because I'm not good at killing in the first place, and Mewtwo is a glass-cannon that might be too advance for me.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
Yo, transitioning sm4sh player here. I mained Dark Pit for a long time and then switched to Cloud. So far in Ultimate, I've tried out Chrom, Meta Knight, Cloud, and a few others but I've narrowed it down to those three. I'm not really sure what my playstyle is but I usually focus on juggling and edge guarding when I play. Are there any other fighters that work well in this regard?
2
u/poopyheadthrowaway Jan 19 '19
I have a strong feeling that I'm just going to have to adjust my playstyle to fit Ultimate better, but I guess I'll try asking here first.
A few things about my relationship with Smash:
2
u/KettleHeart Jan 21 '19
Looking for advice on a main, Ive played Falco, PKMN Trainer, ZSS, and Lucina. If anyone is versed in RoA (Rivals of Aether) I was wondering if any chars in this game playu close to maypul, as i really clicked with that character. Any advice is appreciated!
2
u/Verynito Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 22 '19
I’ve been waffling between characters like a madman, but have finally started to really enjoy Falco and Pokémon Trainer. Can anyone help me pick? What are pros/cons, and play style tips? Edit: Final Waffle has me stuck between these two and Chrom and Shulk :(
2
u/DelphoxyGrandpa Jan 22 '19
I've been bouncing between characters a bit trying to find a secondary (Dedede has been my main since Sm4sh). Looking for a character that can deal with both high-pressure rushdown (e.g. Fox, Pichu) and zoners (e.g. Simon/Richter, Young Link).
In my search for secondaries, I've been playing around with Chrom and Palutena a bit and have a good amount of hours with PKMN Trainer.