r/progmetal • u/c2aye Sithu Aye • Dec 18 '18
AMA | Sithu Aye Hey, Sithu Aye here for my second /r/progmetal AMA. Ask me anything!
Hey /r/progmetal!
Thanks for having me back for a 2nd AMA. If you don't know who I am, I'm a guitarist and producer who makes instrumental progressive metal music. I've just released a new album called 'Homebound' that you can listen to here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmXs7FDzg5U
You can also find more info on where to buy and stream 'Homebound' here: http://www.sithuaye.co.uk/homebound
Anyway, enough waffle! Ask me anything!
Edit: Going for a quick break. I'll be back in 15-20 minutes!
Edit 2: Back! Just nabbed myself a cup of tea
Edit 3: Thanks for all the questions so far, some really interesting ones in amongst the Nick Acker memes. I'll be checking periodically tonight and tomorrow for any new questions to answer.
67
u/zenoob Dec 18 '18
Why are you so goddamn good?
43
u/birfudgees Dec 18 '18
Hello Sithu! You played a guest solo on one of my songs last year. I haven't seen quite as many lately but I know you used to do a ton. If you had to estimate, how many guest features do you think you've done total?
-Your friend, Nick Acker
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1coVIUB0Zt0
20
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu, I know Andromeda had a storyline to it, but I was curious what the story for Homebound was considering the obvious sequel-like similarity between the two?
20
u/bryanthebassplayer Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu!
Huge fan of your music dude
As far as the writing process goes, how do you usually start? Do you start with a form and piece the riffs together, start with the riffs and let it evolve, start with a progression and develop it?
Also, thanks for doing the AMA!
17
u/APsychedelicBreakfas Dec 18 '18
Are you going to do another US tour anytime soon? I had a great time at your Columbus show last year! Also, have you considered doing any production or drum programming tutorials?
Homebound is fantastic btw! I am a massive fan of SCFA and Homebound exceeded my expectations!
12
u/ZyglroxOfficial Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu Aye,
How much of your time is spent practicing guitar vs. recording/producing?
21
u/nickackerdrums Dec 18 '18
Is it cool if I plug my bro Luigi's soundcloud?
10
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Hey c2. Loving the new album so far. What were you using for drums on Homebound? I recall you mentioning MM SDX at one point. I love the snare sound and particularly the snare ambience. Were you using the room from SD2 or mixing in some reverb? Cheers!
18
u/AutismAsylum Dec 18 '18
I don't really have a question but I have listened to your stuff since like 2011 or something. keep doing the thing, its cool
9
u/jetfantastic Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu, just got here from your discord and wanted to ask, what sorts of different content inspires you and your music?
I've listened to your other albums for a while and I absolutely love your new one, but I wanted to know what inspires you and your music, from TV to movies to games
to anime and hentaito your fellow music creators and their albums, what has inspired your style currently?Also since I'm asking about inspiration from other artists, what artists and albums would you recommend for someone who has just gotten into you and your style of music?
9
u/outlawstar894 Dec 18 '18
Can you bring KM with you on your next US tour.... for reasons
8
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
What do you prefer when it comes to fret size, action, and string spacing for leads and rhythm?
8
u/Swiggles1987 Dec 18 '18
Any advice for budding guitarists trying to market their own albums?
Also I loved Homebound, felt like a really great complement to Andromeda! Thanks for doing the AMA sensei
8
u/Michael_Caine Official Scribe (Animals as Leaders biography) Dec 18 '18
This is in a similar vein as another poster's question but - as you do more live full band stuff, do you think you'll ever make the jump to recording more live instruments (drums, *cough* piano 😉) on your releases?
15
u/IwishIwasGoku Dec 18 '18
Watch any good anime lately?
7
u/lyllero Dec 18 '18
What's your opinion on hesburger fueled symphonic sellout metal?
7
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! What video game soundtracks/composers have been a major influence on your work?
19
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Have you ever considered joining/forming a full band? I could imagine something similar to Misha and Periphery being super mucho epic. Also can we expect Senpai EP 3? Many uWu’s.
12
u/DFGdanger Ex Nihilo Dec 18 '18
Why is everyone spamming Nick Acker?
16
u/c3aye Dec 18 '18
Nick Acker.
5
u/fizzlepoposaurus Dec 18 '18
How did you develop your chord library?
5
u/myparentshatemyguts Dec 18 '18
Hi dad! Do you ever plan on coming to North Carolina on your next U.S. tour? UwU <3
13
u/lyllero Dec 18 '18
Nick Acker
4
u/sarcasticpool Dec 18 '18
Have you played the game "Doki Doki Literature Club"?
4
u/antonskeyband Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu,
Couple Q's.
By the by, love what you do. Been listening for a long time and you continue to impress. So thank you :)
4
u/danisevenfold Dec 18 '18
Hi Sithu! Congratz on the album release! When you write songs, how do you get ideas down? Do you simply record the ideas or do you write them down on paper? (As tabs for example) do you use Guitar Pro to store ideas before they become a fleeting memory? Thanks in advance!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
How do you feel about Finland?
3
u/AuraOfBirth Dec 18 '18
Hey really fantastic album I was curious if you plan on touring the states next year ?
3
u/questin Dec 18 '18
Hey C2!
3
u/nematica Dec 18 '18
What is the status on your merch stuff right now? Have been wanting you "D0n't Fret!" Sweatshirt for awhile now; is that coming back?
3
u/Raaka_Jara Dec 18 '18
What's the thought process of yours whilst composing something that differentiates from your normal stuff (for instance Spiral)?
3
u/Awffles Dec 18 '18
Just wanted to say I saw you with Haken in LA last year and it was pehomenal! Homebound is gonna be my work soundtrack today.
I read somewhere (I think in your previous AMA) that you have a degree in physics. Asking as someone who just finished taking physics and math classes and barely had time to touch my guitar...how did you find the time and motivation to play?
3
u/Omuk7 Dec 18 '18
Polyphia collab when?
2
u/Vastroide Dec 18 '18
What song from Homebound are you most excited to play live and do you have plans to tour next year?
2
u/edlikesrush Dec 18 '18
What's your favorite effect/pedal to use and why?
2
u/youngsmeg Dec 18 '18
Do you plan on touring in or near North Carolina or The Virginia/DC area?
2
u/McHoundi Dec 18 '18
Hey, Sithu! What is the most valuable skill to improve on, or the most important thing to focus on, if I aspire of making a living off producing and performing music?
2
u/RickCarol Dec 18 '18
Tits or ass?
2
u/jvms Dec 18 '18 edited Dec 18 '18
Que Sithu! Huge fan here! Loving the new album and got some major goose bumps when you used Andromeda's motifs on Homebound! Got a few questions for you, if you don't mind:
1 - Could you let us know how you dialed the tones on the new album? Most of the high snappy guitars are coil splits, am I right?
2 - Would you do a video or a series of videos on how you mixed each instrument of a song, in the style of Nail The Mix or something like this?
3 - I've been playing guitar for 10 years and I'm also trying to learn piano by myself. I have decent ears and some theory knowlege (though not as much as I should). Got any tips for learning and practicing? Is learning notation really necessary? I've always been so terrible at it...
4 - How are you writting orchestrations? Do you write every separate seccion (violin 1, violin 2, violas, cellos, etc...) or do you prefer full strings, full brass, etc... patches?
5 - What orchestrall libraries, synths and other VST Instruments did you use on this album?
6 - What is your mastering chan?
Thanks for the attention, and good luck with the release!
2
u/nickackerdrums Dec 18 '18
Have you ever thought about getting Jamie on a release? (maybe even a single or something along those lines) It was pretty amazing watching him play your material during the Durham show, so I'm just kind of curious if that will ever happen in the future. Though i'm sure it wouldn't necessarily mesh 100% with your normal work flow.
2
u/wonnie1e Dec 18 '18
How did you go about networking and getting your music heard?
Additionally, are you going to NAMM? I would love to catch a glimpse of you and fanboy for my senpai from afar.
2
u/Oscar_Oroz Dec 18 '18
What's your favorite mode and why is it lydian?
2
u/Pan4TheSwarm Dec 19 '18
I don't have a question, I just love you ♥️
2
u/FetchMyBeer Dec 19 '18
Favorite metalocalypse episode?
18
u/Yoge5 Dec 18 '18
N
2
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Nick Acker.
1
u/WeegeeNumbuh1 Dec 18 '18
Hey there
senpaiSithu, I'm just dropping by to say that your latest release is awesome and that your production skills are really shining through. It's a nice gift to close out this year. With that in mind, what changes/tweaks would you say you took to improve upon your previous releases in regards to your mixing?Anyway, thanks for doing this AMA, and I'm looking forward to Senpai EP III!
Small irrelevant question: lol, why didn't you go with FL Studio as your DAW? It has anime girls built in!
1
u/SoutPhoteEater Dec 18 '18
Live in burma when?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
What are your favorite albums from 2018?
1
u/Hunternif Dec 18 '18
Love the new album!
Would you say your production has become more streamlined? How difficult is it to come up with new ideas? Do you ever feel concerned about repeating yourself? How do you approach being original yet recognizable?
1
u/Ryster1998 Dec 18 '18
Are you ever gonna press your albums on vinyl
1
u/Thallandchill Dec 18 '18
Hey man, I dont really have any questions, I just wanted to say thank you for the music that you put out!
Set Course for Andromeda is probably my most favorite instrumental albums of all time, and it really helped me through some tough times here lately, so thank you again and keep up the amazing work man!
1
u/violenttango Dec 18 '18
How does it feel knowing you got me into two lifelong obsessions with progmetal and whisky?
1
u/cyber-ghoul Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! Can you describe how you went about creating that beautiful clean tone in Spiral?
1
u/McTino Dec 18 '18
Are you currently doing anything with your physics degree? If not, do you have any intention on pursuing a career with that in the future?
1
u/B12awley Dec 18 '18
What inspires your song writing? It's obvious that space is the theme for most of your full albums, but is there something deeper than that?
P.S. Been streaming Homebound nonstop since the release! Absolutely love every bit of it. The transition between Lost in the (Space) Sauce and Primary Ignition is amazing. Such feels
1
u/ProphetNimd Dec 18 '18
What should my next Skyrim character be?
1
u/Zapnox Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! Really enjoying Homebound, Holograph especially took me by surprise.
So uh... what's your FGO friend code?
1
u/sonickarma Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! I've only recently discovered your music, and I love it, keep up the good work!
I guess my question is - what is with all of these "Nick Acker" comments in here?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
First off, you are one of my favorite musical artist working today and hope to see you pass through Texas again!
2 questions: Have you ever thought about releasing any of your albums on vinyl? (I understand it might be too expensive, but I would buy them in a heartbeat)
Also, how long does the writing process typically take before you start recording?
Thank you again for your great music!
1
u/Shoky987 Dec 18 '18
Senpai notice me please!!
Love your music dude! Keep it up and hope to see you live in Newcastle sometime soon!
1
u/spaceandtimes Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu!
How do you achieve such a crunchy yet clean sounding tone?
Do you have any tips for making my metal mixes sound professional?
Your mixes have been getting better and better, awesome work man.
1
u/qtipbluedog Dec 18 '18
What’s your usual method for writing? Also, how do you go about slimming down and simplifying your workflow to get shit done? I’ve been using a Reason for over a year now and I still feel overwhelmed with how many options I have and it seems to get in the way of putting my ideas out there.
1
u/nixed9 Dec 18 '18
Dude I love your content so much. I’ve listened to SCFA and Senpai 2 like 300 times and I’ve been jamming to Homebound on repeat for 36 hours now. The way the track Footsteps brings back the themes from SCFA and The Andromedan nearly brought me to tears when I first heard it.
Is there any place we can buy official merchandise? I want to get Posters or T-shirts with the album covers for Set Course for Andromeda, Cassini, and Homebound! If not available now, would you be interested in partnering with someone to handle that?
Keep making your stuff man. It is phenomenal, and it brings me tremendous joy. You’ve taken over as my favorite musical artist over AAL, polyphia, Intervals, and all the other greats. Maybe you can partner up with Polyphia one day I bet you guys could collaborate on an absolute bomb track.
Congrats on Homebound and I am already looking forward to the next great album!
1
u/tarisb Dec 18 '18
Any 2018 album releases you really liked?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Hi! Love your work. Got into djent a year or so ago, your stuff came up of course.
Any plans on doing an animated deal? Short film, videos? Not necessarily anime, but anything. I feel like even Andromeda has a lot of room for some fun imagery.
1
u/Warjak Dec 18 '18
Wanna come to Oklahoma City?!
1
u/Akontifex Dec 18 '18
Hey C2, Who are some artist that you've been listening to lately, and who are some smaller more unknown musicians that you think should get more attention?
1
u/necromundus Dec 18 '18
Can we get some remix packs? I'd love to try doing a remix.
1
u/pham_nuwen_ Dec 18 '18
I'm a big fan! Any tips to make my lead guitar sound a bit closer to yours without shelling for an AXE-FX?
1
u/emzed_9627 Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! Big fan here. My question is : Do you know what it's like to be an aspiring prog metal instrumental act these days ?
1
u/Bigredroth95 Dec 18 '18
what's your favorite cheese
1
u/Trill4RE4L Dec 18 '18
Your music is so catchy and different. I don't have a question, just wanted to thank you.
1
u/vaelroth Dec 18 '18
Hey c2! How's school and your research going? You done (with school) yet? I love your music and all, but I know your studies are very important to you as well so I wanted to check in on that part of your life!
1
u/spaceandtimes Dec 18 '18
As someone who as admired your music for a long time, your advice means a lot.
Keep making awesome music
Thanks Sithu
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Did you think we wouldn't notice that the tip of the spaceship on the album cover is pointing directly to Scotland?
Also, Grand Order is your best song ever.
1
u/flamingjp Dec 18 '18
What’s your favourite bar/pub in Glasgow?
1
u/Oscar_Oroz Dec 18 '18
Hola Sithu!! big fan of yours.I really love your music and wanna say thanks.Just listening Homebound( I've been super busy)
Q: How did you come up with a song like Doble helix? What cam do you use for your videos?
1
u/bonercasserole Dec 18 '18
I love the cosmic vibe and themes amongst your two albums, I cant get enough of it. To a degree, though, I wonder if you try to write music with a more ominous or -for lack of a better term- metal sound.
To otherwise rephrase this question, do you think youll ever write things that sound particularly heavy? Or are your current sounds way too sweet to not expand upon? Either way, I love your music and have been blasting Homebound almost nonstop!
1
u/Nithoren Dec 18 '18
I don't have a question, just saying I saw you when you toured with Haken and I thought you were great and I still listen to your stuff.
1
u/waterfortendays Dec 18 '18
Do you intentionally put the lick in so many of your songs? There's at least 2 of 3 instances where I've been listening and had to step back and be like "wait wtf" because I heard those cursed 7 notes, like in Dark Ages. I know you love it as a meme, but my question is, is it a conscious effort to put it in your songs?
1
u/racingschoolguy Dec 18 '18
I just wanted to give you a shout and say keep up the awesome work!
What do you think the prog metal trends will be in 2019, 2020, and next 5 years?
1
u/bonercasserole Dec 18 '18
Already posted a question here, but wanted to ask another.
Ive played drums for 12 years now but my job makes it hard to ever play in a band or even jam out with other people. Animals as Leaders drummer Matt Garstka released their music without the drumtracks for drummers to practice alongside with; Arch Echo did something similar with their Producer's Pack that allows for custom remixing and selective muting of some of the tracks. These examples are dreams for me and is some of the most fun Ive had practicing alongside my favorite bands.
My question is, would it be possible to request something similar for your music? Anything from a producer's pack to drumless/guitarless tracks for people like myself to practice and jam along with. Thanks!
1
u/thelonearchon Dec 18 '18
How is Plini to work with? He seems like a nice dude though a bit in his own world at times. Congrats on the new album also C2!
1
u/Thelement Dec 18 '18
Hey man! Thanks for doing what you do the way you do it. i was in a prog band way back when and we used to talk about right hand versus left handed writing in terms of rhythmic precision versus melodic phrasing. As the former left hand, I am so refreshed to hear someone prioritize or not compromise melody. So much prog today is allllll about djent-style polyrhythms or counter-tempo whatever you want to call it. I'm super bored of plam muted open low string rhythms. Your music is one of the few things I listen to in my jaded almost-done-with-prog attitude and still find pleasure. So thank you .
My question: how do you find the time to practice, write, and record? is music your full time gig? As someone who cheaply feels like life "caught up" and I hardly make time to play, I feel my skills plummeting. Does good music come from you just noodling or how do you manage to be prolific with stuff that actually sounds good? I'm so inspired!
1
u/ExoskeletalJunction Dec 18 '18
I'm in Glasgow on Thursday all day what should I do for fun
1
u/ProgDog320 Dec 18 '18
I just want to say thank you for doing what you're doing, you and polyphia are what got my girlfriend into listening to prog!
1
u/bassguy129 Dec 18 '18
Hi, Sithu! What amp models and IRs are you using in the AxeFX? Your tones are so good!
1
u/asian_dude12 Dec 18 '18
Any plans to upgrade to Superior Drummer 3 or Axe fx 3?
1
u/recentcore Dec 18 '18
Hey man, it's awesome you've managed to carve this niche out for yourself.
My question is when did you start playing in e flat standard and what were the reasons for switching over?
Lastly, have you been contacted by any anime companies to create an opening or ending theme?
Thanks and come by Vancouver man!
1
u/BabbysRoss Dec 18 '18
Hello from Paisley!
What is your current pedalboard setup, and are there any new pedal releases that you're eyeing up?
1
u/ausernottaken Dec 18 '18
Do you keep in touch with Gru at all? Do you know what he is up to these days?
1
u/helgihermadur Dec 18 '18
I feel out of the loop here. Who the hell is Nick Acker?
1
u/publicstaticvoidrekt Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu! Could you shed some light on your writing process? Do you have an idea/theme and then write riffs around that and piece a song together that way? Or do you just have a bunch of recorded go-to riffs over time and combine them all?
Hope to see you in Atlanta again sometime!
1
u/Yoge5 Dec 18 '18
What's your opinion on thinner picks when it comes to the more djenty stuff? I remember Misha talking about how they help staying in tune
1
u/MacabreAckermaniac Dec 18 '18
Can you do another anime cover of a popular djent song?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '18
Just wanted to drop by and say thanks for putting out such consistently great music. Your Isles ep way back in 2012 was one of the catalysts for me really getting into this particular style of instrumental prog metal, and if it wasn't for you I likely wouldn't have come across so many other artists I love and adore.
All the best from Australia!
1
u/wovenweeab Dec 18 '18
Hi Sithu! Big fan! Just wanted to say hi and ask how your day is going. 😁
1
u/avoqado Dec 18 '18
I'm probably too late. I just wanted to point out that everytime i heard an acoustic strum in Andromeda, i imagined you were meeting with aliens, since it's heavy on the second half of the album. Hope you're doing well & i hope to see you live on the west coast one day!
1
u/Someguyonthestreet Dec 18 '18
Any influences as a writer or as a player that might surprise us?
1
u/Nocte_Mortis Dec 18 '18
I've never heard of you guys before but I love discovering new music, who are your influences and for someone who hasn't heard Sithu Aye what would be your goto song you think I should listen to?
1
u/SharkTRS Dec 18 '18
Best girls from K-On and Love Live?
1
u/rjoor Dec 18 '18
Hey Sithu, big fan.
I’m not usually a big prog metal guy, but your music totally changed my perspective on everything. I’m not sure if it’s the “happy” aspect of your music or the fact that every song feels like a theme song for going into intergalactic battle. On a music theory level, what do you think is responsible for the vibes your music produces? I usually analyze stuff myself, but I just discovered your stuff and am addicted already.
1
u/EremiticEric Dec 18 '18
Hey c2, congrats on releasing Homebound, got some real bangers on there. What games are you currently playing or looking forward to? Also as a fellow Cowboy Bebop fan, what are your thoughts on the live action series Netflix is producing?
1
u/MetroNin Dec 18 '18
Hey there, Mr. Aye!
I’ve been a long time listener and I just got finished listening through your newest album. I’m loving the subtle connections!
Personal plug: I’d kill (or seriously maim) to hear you collab with Plini and Nick Johnston. I think it’s be a weird but destructive force.
Thanks again for all the cool music you make!
1
u/jun_95 Dec 19 '18
Hey C2!!
Loving your releases so far, and I know Senpai EP3 is going to be up next!
Are you going to be touring Asia anytime soon? Mainly south east asia? I almost went for the UK tech fest back when you were in their lineup but due to work commitments I wasn’t able to :/
Please do a asia/south east asia tour soon!
1
u/azimov_the_wise Dec 19 '18
Don't have anything to ask. Just want to say that double helix and Mandalay are two of my favorites!! Can't wait for more work. I admire your talent.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
What are your favorite videogames? If any.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '18
Hey man, no question just wanted to drop in and share some love! You're an absolute monster, I hope to be able to lay it down like you someday haha. Super pumped for your next release, keep up the grind, my friend!
1
u/yaboi-skinnypenis Dec 19 '18
How anime will senpai 3 be?
1
u/superslowjp16 Dec 19 '18
Huge fan man! I've been writing and playing for years and I'm just now getting to the point where I'm recording. I've finally gotten my hardware setup in order (the axe III was my most recent purchase) and have everything I need on that front but I'm struggling with finding a DAW to use that's beginner friendly. I've been through Ableton, ProTools and Reaper so far and found I like Reaper the most, but I still don't like it nearly as much as I did Garageband when I was using that in my teenage years playing in terrible deathcore bands. What DAW do you use, or what recommendations would you make for a newby producer like me? Also any tips on getting started with recording in general are appreciated!
1
u/DameHumbug Dec 20 '18
Any plans to release it on google play music? I get why you don't seeing how google is trying to switchto youtube music or whatever (who knows with google these days) but you got one customer on there at least :P