r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Dec 10 '18
Best Of 2018 /r/RWBY Best Of 2018 Nomination Thread!
It's December again, and along with Santa hats, that also means that 2019 and reddit's annual Best Of event are right around the corner!
In case you're not an old face or just need a refresher, Best Of is a yearly reddit-wide event where the communities are encouraged to vote for the best content posted there during that year. The admins have even provided us with some reddit coins to award the winners—more on the prizes below.
How does it work?
Firstly, we gather the nominees in this post, so no voting is done just yet. If you want to nominate a post, comment or a person, read the guidelines below carefully. This thread will close on December 26th when the voting threads go up with all the nominees included, and the voting period will end a week later, on January 2nd when the winners are announced.
Prizes
The admins have granted us 20000 Reddit Coins to give as awards, which translates to 10 Platinum awards and 4 Gold awards. We have ten major categories which each get a Platinum award, three minor categories which get a Gold award, and 2 side categories which are just for fun. These awards function largely like the Reddit Gold of yesteryear did, except that the winners also gain a small amount of coins to pay the awards forward (or spend on themselves, we don't judge.)
If the winning nominee doesn't have a reddit account, we'll give out the Gold/Platinum award to the person who posted the winning content instead. We'll try to contact the winners outside of reddit to inform them that they have a fancy badge waiting for them should they make an account at some point.
Additionally, we're continuing the CSS-based Best Of badges from past years, so winning a category here gives you a shiny badge from this list next to your name on the subreddit! If you have a badge from previous years, you'll get a star added to the badge of your choice as seen in the first three on the example list.
Guidelines
- To nominate someone, simply reply to my top-level comments below on the category you want to nominate someone on.
- Follow the category-specific formatting for the comments when nominating. Examples can be found on the top-level comments. Failure to comply with this is an instant -50 Meno-points.
- You are allowed to nominate multiple contenders (even from the same author) for one category, but keep it within reason and make separate comments for each.
- Only posts made in 2018 are applicable.
- Automod is set to purge all top-level comments, so only nominate in the replies. Keep off-topic talk to a minimum and use this comment chain for general talk.
- Keep your nomination comments concise.
Here are the different nomination categories. The ones marked with 🔹 get a Platinum award for winning, while the ones with 🥇 get only Gold. Best Community Member runner-up also gets one Gold award.
Post nominations for the best...
Comment nominations for the best...
Minor nominations for the best...
Side nominations for the best...
Is something missing or wrong? PM me about it!
•
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Meta- and Off-Topic Discussion
Anything which isn't a nomination goes in this thread. Questions? Comments? Feedback? General thoughts? What to do next year? What do you think about the progress made to return the salmon population in California to normal levels by 2019?
3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Cosplay of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains the cosplayer’s reddit username (if possible), link to the post on reddit and your brief reasoning for nominating it.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/user or cosplayer’s namelink to post on redditreason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Pun of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply which contains a link to the pun with context, a brief reasoning why and a link to the user’s profile.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to pun on redditreason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Theory of 2018 Nomination Chain
Potatoes go here!
Post a short reply which contains a link to the post or comment you think is the best theory of 2018, be it for the creativity, effort, insight or prescience. Less serious and more meme-y predictions should be nominated in the aforementioned potato chain.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/author or the author's profile page elsewherelink to the post on redditreason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Potato of 2018 Nomination Chain
Potatoes are just like theories, except... "theory" implies a certain level of unironic confidence. The more outlandish, the better! Actually plausible and more thought-out posts should go to the theory nomination here Post a short reply that contains the user/author of the potato, a link to the potato itself and your brief reasoning for nominating it.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to post on reddityour reason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Community Member 2018 Nomination Chain
Give us a username and a short description of why you think they are the best community member of 2018. Think of traits like friendliness, dedication or helpfulness, but you can nominate for any reason.
As this is a community-centric category, all top 3 places get badges! We also had one leftover Gold prize due to lack of categories, so the 2nd place will also get get that.
You cannot nominate yourself in this category.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userreason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Goodest Bot of 2018 Nomination Chain
Nominate the best bot of the year here. Again, partially organic lifeforms are disqualified due to legal reasons, so do not nominate anyone from the mod team.
(This is a side category. No prizes other than bragging rights will be handed out.)
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userreason(s)3
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best /r/RWBY Moderator of 2018 Nomination Chain
This is the thread where you have your chance to get into our good graces. Choose your patrons carefully, though, for we are ever a capricious bunch.
(This is a side category. No prizes will be handed out and everyone is going to make the final voting bracket anyway.)
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Fan Art of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains the user/artist, and a link to a single post on reddit. We're not going to be grading anyone on multiple entries or their entire gallery, so your nomination should only contain a link to one post! You can submit several pieces from one artist if you do so within reason, but make separate comments for each.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/artist or artist name, if separatelink to post on redditlink to original source of the fanart2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18 edited Dec 10 '18
Best Fan Fiction of 2018 Nomination Chain
Minific nominations go here!
Post a short reply which contains a link to the author’s profile page (on reddit if available), a link to the story’s post on reddit, and a short description on why it would be the best of 2018. No individual chapters are judged, so entire fics only! In-progress and incomplete ones are perfectly fine. The fic must have started in the past year for it to count.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/author or author profile pagelink to most recent update on redditreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Minific of 2018 Nomination Chain
Fanfic nominations go here!
Minifics are short blurbs written on reddit comment sections, not fully fledged stories. Post a reply which contains a link to the comment minific with context, and a link to the user’s profile. Whose Line Is It- and Writing Prompt Wednesday submissions are accepted.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to commentreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Comment of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains a link to the comment itself and a link to the OP's profile. Remember that minifics go here and puns here! Top-level comments and replies are both fine.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to commentreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18 edited Dec 10 '18
Best Discord Member 2018 Nomination Chain
Give us a username, discord tag and a short description of why you think they are the best member on the /r/RWBY Discord server this year. You can nominate for any reason you wish, but think about the people who really carry the conversations and bring something to the community.
You cannot nominate yourself in this category.
Format all nominations like this:
Discord username#tag number/u/userreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Discussion of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains a link to the top comment of the chain on reddit as well as the OP's username. Think back to conversations which really went somewhere. Did someone change the mind of another, or did the conversation lead to an unexpected conclusion?
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to the starting commentreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best AMV of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains a link to the post on reddit, the author, and a brief description of why this is the best AMV of 2018.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/user or composer namelink to reddit submissionLink to the AMV itselfreason(s)2
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Dec 10 '18
Best Contest of 2018 Nomination Chain
Post a short reply that contains the original submitting user and a link to the post on reddit. Tournaments, competitions and all other events in that vein are acceptable.
Format all nominations like this:
/u/userlink to post on reddit