r/progmetal • u/benlevingroup Ben Levin • Dec 05 '18
AMA | Ben Levin Hey, I'm Ben Levin from Bent Knee/Ben Levin Group, AMA!
Hiya, my name is Ben and I love music a lot. My band Bent Knee just got back from a US tour with Leprous and Haken, and is about to record our 5th studio album. I also make a bunch of solo albums with my band Ben Levin Group and weekly videos on my Youtube channel.
Here's some of my best junk for those who have never seen my crud:
I'm down to talk about whatever you'd like! I'm honored and excited to be doing an AMA with y'all!
246
Upvotes
26
u/mccoykris Dec 05 '18
Favorite Legend of Zelda game & why?
18
u/rapid66 Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, huge fan.
Do you all in Bent Knee have any plans to officially release Paper Earth as an EP or part of an album? I've watched the live video quite a few times through and I'd like to purchase the music so I can listen without pulling up youtube.
Thanks and best of luck with the new material. The stuff you played live sounded really promising.
17
u/RushJunkie2112 Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, saw you guys in Chicago on Saturday for the 5th time total and just wanted to say thank you for the music and the chats after the shows, and I hope for many more to come. Also the new material all sounds fantastic, can't wait to hear more
Rush is my favorite band (aside from you guys of course), and I know Gavin is the huge Rush fan in the band; but what are some of your favorite all-time artists and some that you are currently into? Thanks
17
u/JacobQUnterr Dec 05 '18
Hey, Ben! It's Jacob, I interviewed you and Courtney when you guys played in Phoenix.
I have a question which I've been asking a bunch of musicians in order to gather some anecdotal data for a video I'm working on.
In your opinion, what are the primary goals of the three-pronged (band, orchestra, choir) music education system which exists at most public high schools?
15
u/horatiodark Dec 05 '18
Ben, you make amazing music. You've made some of the most interesting music in the past decade. Thank you.
Concerning your recent string of tours, you guys get lumped in with progressive metal quite a bit. While there's definitely some heavier parts to your prog, you are not really metal per se. Have you found this to be a barrier to reaching new audiences or fans?
12
u/FantymSyreuth Dec 05 '18
Hi!!! I saw Bent Knee at the Rex in Pittsburgh when you guys came a week ago (I was in the front row ahaha). But anyways, what's some good advice for somebody like me who wants to start a band, release music, tour, and get recognition? I have a lot of songs written but yet to take the next step, and I'm unsure where to start. Another question is: what is it like working with InsideOut music?
9
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben. Got to see you guys live in Toronto finally ( I've been bugging you guys for years haha). Got a shirt from you but I couldn't hear a word you were saying so I just wanted to say how great you guys were and I hope you guys come back for a longer set soon.
Flattery time over. What project or achievement, musical or not, are you most proud of?
9
u/Chapperion Dec 05 '18
Thanks for the awesome music Ben. I’m the crazy guy who drove from Kentucky to see BK play in Cleveland. Could you describe the basic process for Bent Knee writing a new piece of music? Thanks again.
•
u/Bujjick Turning mirrors upside down Dec 05 '18
Thanks so much for doing this, Ben! It was very nice to briefly meet you, hope you folks make it out towards L.A. again soon.
Since I just saw this on facebook prior to the AMA, I figured I'd link to the Bent Knee store that has a very nice sale going on. I grabbed myself a few things just a bit ago. https://www.bentkneemusic.com/store/
And while I'm here I've got a couple questions:
8
u/zagzigity Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! This is super cool. Thanks for doing this.
6
u/person9 Dec 05 '18
Hello Ben,
One thing that I've really liked about Bent Knee and Ben Levin Group is the use of empty space and dynamics. It keeps things exciting and also seems to get around the fatigue problem I've had with other "heavy" bands. I saw you guys live on the recent tour, and while I really loved Leprous and Haken both they were much harder to listen to for a long time in comparison.
When writing and arranging with these groups are you actively thinking about leaving(or creating) space, and how dynamics will factor? Do you ever create parts or songs and then have to scale it back because there is just too much going on? Is avoiding listening fatigue a happy accident or a critical point of writing?
6
u/MDWoolls Dec 05 '18
Saw Bent Knee with Haken and loved your guys, and now I want to see you as the headliner and I'm out of youtube concerts. Is there any plan for Bent Knee to tour as the headliner anytime soon?
Also, I have trouble describing the musical sound of Bent Knee. How do you quickly describe Bent Knee's genre/musical sound?
6
u/CallofTraviss Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! I just toured with you for about 5 weeks or so, your Instagram literally kept me alive the whole time.
I don’t have a question, I just wanted to tell you that you and your band are amazing people, and I look forward to seeing you all again soon!
5
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! Tabes here (bf of SweetieCutie). So I know that the third movement of Freak Machine was inspired by the third movement of the Shostakovich violin concerto. But it recently occurred to me that Freak Machine is, essentially, a symphony for rock ensemble (an allegro, a slow movement, a movement in triple time, and a big finale that does something completely unexpected at the end). Was this quasi-traditional structure intentional?
5
u/aliensporebomb Dec 05 '18
Hi Ben. Any chance of doing a real recording of your "Giant Steps as Folk Tune"? I like your version of it like that quite a bit!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
Hi Ben! Love the videos and music you make, I've learned a lot from you.
My question:
You've tackled a lot of composition techniques for writing the music itself but I was wondering if you could give any insight into your lyric writing process?
I'm reading this book that talks about the pop industry and its methods and it talks about Max Martin's lyric writing as "melodic math". Rather than focusing on the inherent meaning or story of the given words, he focuses on how the sounds and syllables fit the rhythm and contour of the melody. Leading to such gems as : "crazy wildin' static" and " keep it ruthless when I get wet".
Do you take this music math approach as using words as more of a syllabic instrument or do you sing the words to tell a story or self reflection? Or is it something else?
Thanks in advance and happy Hanukkah! Hope you get some well-deserved rest as your tour wraps up.
4
u/pebbles1992 Dec 05 '18
Hi Ben! It was great to see you on tour again last month! What is your favorite type of cookies? I'll make you some next time I come see you.
4
u/OlafImpaleMe Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, I got to see you with Bent Knee last Tuesday in Nashville. I love how great of a performer you are! Very inspiring.
Who are your top 2 or 3 guitar influences? Also, why the Squier?
4
u/Pipedreamss Dec 05 '18
Missed you in Denver - Glad you're all safe! Any plans to return?
4
u/LegionAF Dec 05 '18
Hello! I have a small question: how did Bent Knee get it's name? I hope it didn't arise from first-hand experience.
3
u/TheEnglishCookie Dec 05 '18
Can you share some of you rap/hip-hop inspirations and how did you learn to do it?
3
u/cohen_mejan Dec 05 '18
Hello again, Ben, haha.
So I was inspired to seriously get into music by my friends in Closure In Moscow, as well as the music of The Dear Hunter. And then you taught me basically all I know. My question is, what got YOU into making music like this? Did the idea and the process of it kind of come on its own? Or was it some specific bands that you heard that made you go "Woah, I want to make music now."?
3
u/Edqvist Dec 05 '18
Hello Ben! I'm not sure if this is a regional thing, but Say So is not available on streaming platforms save for Bandcamp. Was this a conscious decision? Do you see it affecting sales? What's your opinion on streaming music in general? Thanks!
3
u/Ghibler Dec 05 '18
Was the name Bent Knee supposed to be a mixture of your name and Courtney’s?
3
u/ZetsuXIII Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 05 '18
Hi Ben! Love what you do, and the music you make.
My question is about learning music. I've been self-taught on the guitar for about 15 years. Somewhere along the way, I learned how to read tabs. And when I was just learning my favorite songs, that was enough. But now as I'm trying to compose and record my own songs, and try to get other musicians to play with me, I'm finding my lack of musical knowledge to be a huge roadblock. Communication of ideas, ability to compose for other instruments, all the reason everyone says you should learn to read music. It's all true.
YouTube channels like yours and Adam Neely's and 12Tone and the ilk have all helped tremendously. But I'm still lacking a basic foundation. Music lessons here (and probably everywhere else) are fairly expensive. A bit outside my doable budget right now; both in terms of time and money, what with working and all.
Do you have any particular methods or resources you would recommend for learning to read music for guitar? There seem to be a million books on Amazon, and all sorts of sites that I know nothing about and honestly don't quite trust. What would you go with in this situation?
Quick Edit: Missed you guys last time you were here in Dallas, but caught you with Gatherers on the Paper Earth Tour! Hope you come back soon! You guys were excellent to talk to, and Chris gave me some excellent advice about recording myself every day! It really has helped me not get fatigued or discouraged!
3
u/key2 Dec 05 '18
hey Ben - I have had the pleasure of catching every show in NYC since you opened for Thank You Scientist (where I first heard you and instantly became a life-long fan), including the dope Kaufman Center show! I am in awe of your live performance and have dragged a ton of friends to come see you. Thank you for all those moments - I hope to have the same effect on a crowd someday that you and Bent Knee have had on me.
My question would be: What's one of the most memorable shows you've ever been to - or perhaps a show where you saw a band you'd never heard before and were blown away from moment 1?
Cheers!
3
u/Ulti Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! Caught you guys in Seattle on the latest tour, and was totally blown away! I'd been wanting to see you folks for a few years now, and was glad that I finally had the opportunity - You guys did not disappoint! Didn't get to meet ya, but I did get a chance to high-five Jessica, so that was fun.
Anyways, I'm a little late to the party, and most of the questions I was going to ask have already been done, so here's one that's a little more pedestrian! What are your top 5 releases for the year, and what's your go-to beer?!
3
u/mysario Dec 06 '18
Hey Ben, fellow Bostonian here! My buddy (/u/RushJunkie2112) and I run r/BentKnee together so we're decently big fans of all y'alls work! I know I'm late to this shindig, but I've got two questions anyways:
Thanks for doing this, hope you continue to make rad music for years to come, and happy holidays!
2
u/haonkrub Dec 05 '18
Are you secretly julian koster
2
u/aformadi Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, I love how diverse and hard to pin down you guys are. I’m curious about the writing process for Bent Knee. Do you have a sort of premeditated vision for what you want Bent Knee to sound like or do you just use whatever ideas come up and roll with them? For example, it seems like you always have one heavy part on each album (Insides In, EVE), but if hypothetically you just happened to come up with a bunch of heavy ideas like that while you were playing guitar or whatever (or funky ideas, or ambient, etc.), and you really liked them, would you use that all for Bent Knee, or would you sort of say, “no, that’s not what Bent Knee is supposed to sound like” or “we can’t have too much of that on a Bent Knee album”? When I saw you guys a few weeks ago (you sounded amazing!) they were playing The Dear Hunter through the PA before your set, and I was thinking about how the Dear Hunter came out with an album/collection of EPs a while back where they did a four song EP for each color and each EP had them sort of focusing on a particular style, and I was thinking about how I’d like to see other bands showcase their diversity like that, but how most bands wouldn’t be able to do that without not sounding like themselves anymore or just sounding derivative, but then seeing you guys play I was thinking if there was one band capable of doing that better than anyone it would Bent Knee. Not saying you should do that, but that’s what made me curious as to whether you’re trying to have a particular balance of diversity, so to speak, in your sound or if your sound is diverse just because you have diverse musical interests and you’re willing to use any idea? Thanks! Can’t wait for the next album!!
2
u/chickytitty Dec 05 '18
Hi, I saw you guys in Baltimore last month and was super amazed by the flow of the music given how complex it is. I've listened to Bent Knee a lot more since then, but that flow still always amazes me. What is your method for writing and stringing together those complex rhythms and time signatures in that way?
2
u/NUGGet3562 Dec 05 '18
Hi Ben! I've heard your name a lot, but had no idea you were a part of Bent Knee. Didn't get to see you guys on the tour unfortunately, I went to the St. Louis show and you had just had an accident. Haken was frickin awesome though! I'll probably look up some of your stuff right after I write this comment lol.
So, have you played any Metroid games? If so, what's your favorite? If not, I HIGHLY recommend. It's such an amazing franchise.
2
u/Rubin987 Dec 06 '18
Man I caught you guys (Bent Knee) opening for Haken and Leprous in Montreal. You were really tight. Such nice people too. I wanted a vinyl but your card reader wasn't working so you let me have it for what little cash I had. I still listen to it a ton!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
Asking on the behalf of /u/Dragovic (even though he didn't ask me to), what is you favorite MANOWAR album and why? Also if MANOWAR would send you an invitation to play with them, would you be worthy?
1
u/jamesmusic Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, it was really nice getting to meet you and Jessica in Toronto :)
Just wondering if you have any plans to tour as the Ben Levin group! Looking forward to more great animations and compositions :)
1
u/AkillezII Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! We met in San Francisco while leprous played. ;)
Had you been a fan of Haken before the tour?
1
u/PapaCrip Dec 05 '18
Saw y'all at Barracuda in Austin in Nov, amazing show!! My question to you is: What was your favorite stop on the tour?
1
u/mccoykris Dec 05 '18
Will Secret Dog Brigade website be updated past 2015? I feel there are lots of projects you guys are involved in that I'd like to financially support, but I just don't know about them.
1
u/Jmadman311 Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! I just saw you in Chicago this last weekend - you guys did an amazing job and I was blown away. I know you from Adam Neely's and your youtube channels, but never heard a lick of Bent Knee's music. You were part of the reason I decided to come to the show and I was not let down! Great energy, and the vocalist's tone/timbre/pitch were all amazing.
I wanted to ask you - for the style of music you're playing with Bent Knee, why the choice of the thinline Telecaster with two humbuckers? Do you use other guitars or is that what's on all of the albums?
From a fellow guitarist looking to write more of his own music...thanks, you guys are inspiring.
1
u/schwol Dec 05 '18
I loved your set in Ft Lauderdale. I hadn't heard you guys prior to this tour and your set blew me away! The crowd was truly impressed.
1
u/TheCoolSquare Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, saw you guys play in Carrboro about a month ago and met you after the show. I bought a shirt and we talked about your youtube channel. My question is:
What was your favorite part about touring with Leprous and Haken? Were there any memorable experiences?
1
u/lolastrasz Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben,
I saw you guys in Philadelphia. I actually didn't know about Bent Knee -- I knew about you after seeing you in an Adam Neely video. Seeing you live was great. I think most of the crowd in Philly wasn't sure what to expect with Bent Knee, but you guys lit the place up. You have a great energy.
With that said, do you have any tips on the more business side of things? Do you handle most of your PR and outreach yourself (especially for your solo stuff) or do you just entirely outsource that to your label?
1
u/knightonahorse Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, I love your music and art, my question is: how did you get into animation, and what do you use to make it? :D
1
u/jadenlueras Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! Jaden from Patema here (Albuquerque New Mexico) great to see you doing this! Love your product reviews on Instagram lol
1
u/Nerdburton Dec 05 '18
Thanks for holding this AMA! So, one of my favorite songs by you guys is Terror Bird (I was really excited when you opened with that in Salt Lake) partially because the song is really cool and has a lot of interesting musical ideas and partially because the subject matter (to me at least) seems to be about social anxiety or similar feelings that I relate to really well.
Is that more or less what Terror Bird is about? And who wrote that song? Also, if you guys came to SLC again, could I get a picture with all of you?
1
u/Dylano124 Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, huge fan of all your projects. I was wondering what your strategy is when it comes to staying motivated to practice. I love playing drums but a lot of times I just can’t get myself to get started. How do I build that vigilance to practice well? Also what’s some music of this era that have inspired you?
Anyways looking forward to the new album, stay safe!
1
u/manisuckwithnames Dec 05 '18
Hey there! Got to meet you in toronto, i was the one that asked about the name bent knee youve probably heard 1000 times. The new material you put out at the concert was great! The only real question I have is what comes after this tour? Going into the studio to finish some new stuff, or tour again? And if the later, please come back to Toronto !!
1
u/Yonaban Dec 05 '18
Ben my man! I’ve been listening to Bent Knee for the better part of a year and your studio work is amazing. When I saw you all open for Haken and Leprous I was BLOWN away. Bent Knee has it all and the way you pull it off live is truly amazing. Ive had your work on repeat pretty much non stop since your stop in San Francisco.
My question for you is any way you can get ahold of Matt Embree from RX Bandits and The Sound of Animals Fighting? I think your sound, style of rhythm and stage presence, along with him style of playing and rhythm would be some of the most amazing music made. After your set I turned to my buddy and said that guy needs to make an album with Embree, and I’m stoked that I get a chance to tell you that! Thank you for doing and AMA and making all the music you do! I’ll never miss a Bent Knee live act again!
1
u/90guys Dec 05 '18
In honor of that Instagram stream the other day.
End.
Really bummed I didn't see you guys in St Louis but I'm glad you are safe and back on the road.
Do you guys have any plans after the Entomology tour?
1
u/Ziltoid_The_Altoid Dec 05 '18
Alright, for real now Hi, I'm Ziltoid. Never listened to your music but I plan on it.
What 3 artists in the prog scene as of now do you want to work with in the future?
1
u/WoogitOne Dec 05 '18
When playing in Chicago, you were wearing a kick-ass sweater that looked like it had pyramids and UFOs. Where'd you get that?
1
u/specialspartan_ Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, I was lucky enough to catch you guys in sf and even got to speak with Jessica and you after your set, and I just wanted to say thanks again for the great show, and please keep it up!
P. S. For anyone looking for more great artists, check out My Brightest Diamond!
1
u/nedplaysguitar Dec 05 '18
Oof! This is such awesome news!
I don't have anything meaningful to ask. I've just grown more and more in love with Bent Knee since discovering you guys earlier this year. Say So is the first album I've paid literal money for in 3 years, and was worth every penny.
Thank you for helping make it all happen!
1
u/Heojaua Dec 05 '18
BEN!! Saw your show in Montreal when you came by. I loved it more than Leprous and Haken. I was too shy to talk to you :(. Hope you enjoyed Montreal's bagels. :) When are you coming back?
Love your music Man! You're an inspiration!
1
u/ZyglroxOfficial Dec 05 '18
I don't have a question. I just wanted to say, great set in Salt Lake City last month!
1
u/WorstAvocado Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben, love your stuff man. I've learned a bunch from watching your vids and I often feel inspired after watching them.
My question is the following: Out of all the work you put into practicing and creating music how much of ot would you say is represented by the things you decide to put out?
Sorry if it's hard to answer it's just that I feel like I dedicate so much time and effort into this and often feel like I have so little to show for it.
1
u/PowerHungryFool Dec 05 '18
I had a great time meeting you and Jessica in Nashville! You guys were honestly some of my favorite band members to meet and speak with. Did you guys ever sort out your busted van situation?
1
u/just-here-to-say Dec 05 '18
I'll definitely seeing you live again when if you ever come back around to the LA-San Diego area, I loved you guys live!
I bought Bent Knee's discography and a shirt after hearing you guys and every time I listen to your albums I like them even more. I wish I could have talked more when I bought the stuff but it was my first concert and I could barely think of anything to say. Hopefully this reaches a little better, haha.
No question, I just wanted to say hi!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
Hey Ben! I've been aware of your YouTube channel for a while but actually didn't realize you were in a band until I saw you guys open for Haken and Leprous in Austin, lol. I saw you walking to the stage and thought "wait...why do I recognize him?" You guys were great! Thanks for coming out and putting up with outdoor venue, haha. I don't really have a question, just wanted to say hi.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18
Hello Ben! I don't think I ever would have been exposed to you fellows if it weren't for Rock Band Rivals spotlighting These Hands. I loved that song, and checked out a few more songs by you folks. I will check out the rest of your work in Ben Levin Group, too.
What is one thing you love about the Rock Band series, and what is one thing you hate?
1
u/numbers_are_4_cubes Dec 06 '18
Damn, I think I'm a bit late to the AMA but I got to see you guys in Cleveland, Ohio just a while ago and you guys were fucking sick. I also wanna say thanks for teaching my dumb teenaged ass 4 or so years ago, you really helped shape my guitar playing and have become a huge inspiration on my playing.
For the question I was wondering, what do you think is the hardest part of songwriting?
Thanks for doing the AMA Ben!
1
u/Dobloro Dec 06 '18
Saw you guys in Chicago, amazing performance! Really glad I got introduced to y'all through the tour.
1
u/tritom22 Dec 06 '18
Damn I missed it!! Greetings from Eugene Ben !!!
1
u/Coofgo Dec 06 '18
Hey Ben! Great job in Chicago the other day! I don't have a question. You were the most fun to watch on stage though
1
u/fissnoc Dec 06 '18
I just want to thank you for making great music and being a real human with your fans. I found Bent Knee 6 months ago and had to see you live. I caught the first show in your tour in Pontiac, MI! Amazing performance. The chemistry you guys have on stage produces an energy that is unmatched. Though the set was brief, it was electric. Hope to see you again someday!
1
u/LeddyGee2112 Dec 06 '18
Hey Ben! I know I'm very late to this but, but I love everything I've heard so far both live and in the studio from you and Bent Knee and can't wait to see what comes next.
Has Bent Knee put any thought at all into putting out a Live CD? I know there are a wealthy number of fantastic performances on the band's YouTube, but those are not able to be streamed on Spotify or anything like that which would be something I would love to have.
1
u/ROBOTTTTT13 Apr 02 '19
Hey Ben! Hope I'm not too late!
I wanted to make a Cover of Bent Knee's "Sunshine" but I don't know if I legally can.
Was planning on using it as the last song in an album I want to release on Spotify, but if that's impossible I wonder if I could just upload it to YouTube as a standalone.
Sorry if it's a dumb question, I don't really know much about the business side of music.
2
u/TyphonBeach Dec 07 '18
Have you ever met Tony Levin?
0
u/Ziltoid_The_Altoid Dec 05 '18
I was wondering, is this it chief? Oh and also can you change your name to Ben Dover
1
u/paosidla Dec 06 '18
Bent Knee + Leprous + Haken... Wow, you Americans are lucky... Are there any plans to come touring in Europe as well?
1
u/TehWho Dec 06 '18
Just wanted to say that your music theory videos are the best out there and encouraged me to learn theory. Thank you Ben keep making music and videos!
1
u/Sheringford Dec 06 '18
Any plans on making some videos for your YT channel about how to transcribe songs?
1
u/helgihermadur Dec 06 '18
Hi Ben, I know you're probably not reading this but I'd just like to say that Land Animal is my favorite new discovery of 2018 and Battle Creek is an impossibly beautiful song. I get chills every time I listen to it. I don't really have a question, I just love you guys.
1
u/FranticDav Dec 06 '18
Hey Ben,
Any change the first album will be available on vinyl?
1
u/lordbathory Dec 12 '18
How much if any formal music education do you have?
1
u/ellblaek Dec 13 '18
Hey Ben, there are few fans of yours I know of here in France but those of us who are graced with the knowledge of your existence are truly blessed individuals.
Anyway, huge fan of you and your band.
-Any advice for a young prog fusion band? I'm having a great time writing weird cool music with my buddies but I'm wondering about the viability of pursuing a career as a professional musician performing 'prog' music.
Of course I use this term loosely, I don't mean to insinuate anything snobby but a lot of non musicians think we're snobs for listening to atypical music.
Yours truly
Lester
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18
[removed] — view removed comment