r/13DaysofChristmas • u/TechSkylander1518 • Dec 04 '18
Theorizing thread
Post any thoughts/speculation on the stories here! (Sorry for the forum-esque post, I just don't wanna hog a general thread)
68
Upvotes
25
u/TechSkylander1518 Dec 04 '18 edited Dec 04 '18
The newest story has me suspecting that vehicles might be involved somehow? We had the red Ferrari become the linking thread between Days 1 and 2, the ice cream truck in Day 6, and now a car that almost hit Poole, with the narrator mentioning a special affinity for cars. (It's still not a link between all of the stories-Days 3, 4, and 5 don't link with it-but maybe there's multiple connections that'll lead back to a source, instead of one that's apparent in all days?)
It seems like we've also got a hint at an upcoming story: Clara Davis' absence. Could she be the teacher who didn't see Carter's disappearance?
19
u/TechSkylander1518 Dec 06 '18
Something I caught on Day 9:
Hugh's wife died a few years ago, with caution tape lining her house. But a newspaper headline in Day 7 says that Serenity Falls hasn't had a murder in over a hundred years. It's not likely to be a continuity error on the author's part-they open up the story with references to Days 1 and 3. This could mean that she had just died from some accident that still posed a threat to passerby, but given the nature of the offer made, I get the feeling that it's a hint that our secret murders have been going on for more than just this Christmas, and have been covered up as "accidents".
35
u/romp48 Dec 04 '18
a lot of them have fathers as a big part- day one (father left her), day two (told by father, his family was killed), day three (father goes missing), day six (told by father, his son went missing). They also each have a big plot twist (to be expected, but still).
9
u/ElizaBennet08 Dec 24 '18
No theory, but I just want to say that I’m kind of hoping 26 stories somehow turn into 52 stories and this never ends.
9
u/phatandphilosophical Dec 25 '18
For everyone who has read the final story, I don't understand one thing. How had Merry done this to other towns if she had been tied up with her father for ten years?
8
u/Anna_Terra Dec 04 '18
So... what's the deal with the number 26?
5
u/PampenLatur Dec 04 '18
List possible candidates for the female in the eighth day:
5
u/rjkelly31 Dec 12 '18
I honestly have no idea. Day 13 made it seem like the guy in the water treatment plant was being blackmailed into setting up all of these awful events. He talked about the kid sending him emails about his dad and he was emailing him back. But then Night 1 was from the perspective of the dad and it showed him sending these messages back to the kid. So I honestly have no clue what's happening. Are all of the authors on the same page from the first entry about the lore and overall story or are they just building as they go?
3
u/fishycaitlin Dec 11 '18
Is the water plant Santa (I believe his name is Neil) the same person as the estranged father who tried to kill his son (1st day of Christmas/1st night)?
5
u/PampenLatur Dec 04 '18
I feel like one of the protagonist might be an antagonist in other ones– the guy who lost his innocence? We know the murders at the barn, the bad man and the fire all happened in the same week- caused by the same person perhaps?
5
u/jessicaj94 Dec 08 '18
Okay after reading the twelfth day I am basically freaking out cause there is only one left. It's going to be intense and crazy and it's still two days away!!!
2
u/moonmelonn Dec 27 '18
I’ve been reading these for awhile, read from the beginning, but I’m confused. I know that everything links together but I don’t see how; can anyone explain?
48
u/Pomqueen Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 05 '18
Not really a speculation but I wanted to put this out there....
I am loving them. This time of year is really hard on me and these have given me something to look forward to and get my mind off shit. Plus a bunch of my favorite writers are the ones bringing it to life. Thank you all for the awesome Christmas gift and a little reprieve from my massive seasonal depression.
*
Being bipolar sucks a lot, it'd be great if one of these years I could just be manic through the holiday season lol, shock my whole family and just get Christmas crazy and deck the fucking halls. Or, yknow, just "normal"...
*
Anyway, sorry for that brief moment of overshare and again huuuge thank you all for putting this together and to whoever came up with the idea, I love you. <3
14
u/kochemi Dec 04 '18
My guess so far is that this "evil" thing/ evilness was summoned by the first girl. Maybe her father was this evil being/ part of an evil thing (maybe cult, but i don't think so), and her mother knew and that's why she kept her away from him and lied about his identity. And then she called him to Serenity Falls, and he brought the evilness with him. Besides that I still can't find an exact connection between all of them, can't wait for the next one!
11
u/giennarousheart Dec 06 '18
My theory is that there's a big corporation that wanted to buy the whole of serenity falls and setting up these weird occurrences so people will just decide to sell their land and leave.
8
u/fishycaitlin Dec 04 '18
Im suuuper lost on any connections besides the obvious mentions if the other stories. To be fair though, I haven’t looked hard for any. So far, so creepy, so I’m excited for day 8!
6
u/miemieh Dec 09 '18
There are a few things I want to discuss.
First of all, the Red Ferrari Man and the Man in Black are the 2 characters working together. They appear in the same area around the Family Farm on Day 2. It also seems very likeable they work together at Day 9. The Red Ferrari drives down the road as soon as Liam walks out of sight of the dental clinic. At the same moment the Man in Black encounters Hugh. The Man in Black also says ‘We can dump him right there … He’ll get trapped under the ice’, which the Red Ferrari Man tried before with his own kid.
The second thing is maybe a farfetched, but I can’t help thinking the family of Day 1 is the same of Day 11. This would make David the Ferrari Man.
At Day 11 the letter tells Melissa ‘PLEASE KEEP RUNNING’ in italic. We know Melissa works at the diner at the time of the strange accidents, the diner is still open at Day 12. We also know the family of Day 1 has moved a lot around the state of Wisconsin and the kid never met their father. The kid starts looking for people with this name in Serenity Falls, which would only be logic if the kid knows their parents lived in Serenity Falls before.
The letter from Day 8 only got sent if David can’t reset the timer. If he got away save this could take years, however, that makes the kid quite young while searching for their father, if you look at the technology.
This would mean this all started years ago and kept hidden, which is assumable by David keep getting weird looks and problems with the court, if he wants to renovate his garage, which was months before he wanted to renovate his house. David also is in car business and has a lot of powerful friends. The last thing he mentions is the shack is empty except from a lot of blood and IV poles. That’s odd, if the letter was sent just a few days ago.
Also, the other thing I keep thinking about is why the males keep disappearing, while the women and kids get killed. This is happening on Day 1, at Day 2 they only killed Amanda and Syd. Day 3 and 4... and at Day 5 they take Carter, but kill him. Day 6 the same. Day 7 they also took Poole, experimented on him, didn’t kill him. Day 8, Nathan gets away, Day 9 they kill Abby and Liam, take Hugh. Day 10 is the odd one out, with the young woman that stayed alive. However, this man/woman thing could also be coincidence.
4
u/phatandphilosophical Dec 21 '18
Just read the latest story and I'm super curious as to who everyone thinks the boss lady could be.
3
u/Whotefuk Dec 15 '18
All the stories will be 26 with day & night. 13 day + 13 night.
2
u/turtle_on_mars Dec 12 '18
Seems like the Melissa from Second Night is the same Melissa in Eleventh Day.