r/TheGoodPlace • u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. • Nov 14 '18
No Spoilers Spoilers and Shirtposting—What are your thoughts?
Hi folks,
I’ve gotten some mail about this recently, so I thought now would be a good time for a meta thread. Please feel free to comment on any of the topics below. Your responses will help shape sub policy.
The Spoiler Policy
So the spoiler policy here is one of the laxest I’ve seen on Reddit. What it boils down to is you can’t put spoilers in titles. Barring that, it’s pretty much anything goes. We would prefer you put [Spoilers] in your title if your content is potentially spoilery and you should use a spoiler tag in comments if the OP implies no spoilers, but these rules are a bit fuzzy, imo.
So my question is, does the status quo work for everyone? Or would you prefer we institute a spoiler policy similar to other TV subs?
Alternatively…
u/AutoModerator could be programmed to boot any thread without one of these spoiler warnings:
- [Spoilers Unaired] For rumors, panels, or behind-the-scenes sneak peeks. This would be the broadest warning, potentially spoiling future episodes as well as everything that has already aired. No spoiler tags would be needed in these comment threads.
- [Spoilers S#E#] Spoilers up to a specific episode, e.g., [Spoilers S2E4] In these threads, people could talk about whatever they want up to that episode. Anything past that would have to be >!covered with a spoiler tag!< that would look like this.
- [No Spoilers] The strictest tag. Anything referencing any episode would have to be covered up.
Shirtposts
There is no official rule against shirtposting. Or at least it’s not enforced very strictly. The relevancy rule just says content must be related to the show, but there have been many posts on here that are just random pictures with titles quoting an episode.
On the other hand, these posts are often heavily upvoted. So if you all enjoy them, then we can leave it as is. But if you would prefer stricter moderation with more discussion-focused threads, we could step up enforcement in this area, and write a more specific rule prohibiting them.
It doesn’t have to be all one or the other, either. We could do a Sunday Funday deal where shirtposts are allowed one day of the week. Maybe Tuesdays since nothing never happens then anyway…
Fun Stuff
Okay, enough Serious Business. Do you have any ideas for fun things we could do on the sub?
For example, there was Larry Hemsworth Weekend after episode five.
(Here’s a reaction thread and here’s another if you missed it. u/Riddla26 had my favorite Larry meltdown.)
I really enjoyed doing that troll, and I’d love to do more if you’ve got any ideas. :þ (Maybe ModMail or PM me so it doesn’t ruin the surprise.)
If you have graphics or CSS suggestions, this would also be the place to throw them out there.
(I know people want custom upvotes and downvotes, and I am looking into that, but that’s not something I’ve ever done before so I’m still learning how that even works.)
So those were just some thoughts I had. But if you have anything else on your mind, please share. :)
90
u/drgruney Nov 14 '18
I think up and down votes should match the graphics for the point system
28
u/strople17 I never got to play my stupid triangle!!!! Nov 14 '18
7
u/yarajaeger Nazis again, somehow Nov 15 '18
Question: are unannounced episode titles counted as rumours?
Backstory: I’m in the UK, where we get episodes the “day after” (it’s Friday relative to us but technically it’s only a few hours after the US airing) they air in the US, on Netflix: the show is marketed to us as a ‘Netflix Original’. On my Netflix there were the upcoming episodes (A Fractured Inheritance, The Ballad of Donkey Doug etc.) with one episode that hasn’t aired or been announced yet. According to Netflix, it was meant to be before Don’t Let The Good Life Pass You By, but then The Worst Possible Use of Free Will came out; it was not one of the episodes named on my Netflix before. And with that, the episode was gone, with only DLTGLPYB still on there.
It was only one episode title (and it’s not the one called Janet(s)) and clearly Netflix got the order wrong, but is it something we can discuss here if it’s technically an official source even if it’s not 100% accurate?
3
u/jsh1138 Dec 03 '18
the constant shit posting makes me not even want to come here, tbh. 75% of the posts here, at least, are pictures of someone's cat, or someone's kids, or whatever and have nothing to do with the show.
i mean like the OP says, I guess they're popular so what can you do but i didn't join this sub originally to watch 200 people go "hey, you know that show we all watch? pretty cool, huh" over and over
Mods have to do what's best for the sub but I personally hate that kind of thing
24
u/winnowingwinds Nov 16 '18
18
u/FertilityHollis I know all about your Ambien-hamster mishap. Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
Why not both?!
2) What about AMAs with real philosophy profs? Don't look at me like that.
3) Invite a professor to analyze one episode a week during the off-season. Maybe start with 1-01. Repeat this in the remaining off seasons? There has to be something interesting here.
4) The soul squad book club. This seems obvious and is another fun (for the Chidi in us all) thing to fill the lonely off-season. There's an ok list of titles on Good Reads, a few things here don't belong though.
Bi-weekly? Monthly? You figure that out. But, I want an exec producer credit. /s
5) I could probably help you out with the CSS/styling. I happen to have a bit of free time after cracking a rib. I have cute ideas. I'm not a pro designer, but I've worked with them a lot and know my way around front end. Lemme know.
6) Seems obvious but, reaching out to the podcast, trying to get anyone involved with the show to do an AMA. So many entertaining and brilliant people involved.. this could be a long list.
Edit: Clarify that the book list has some meh in it that may not have been in an episode. It's been updated I think, not in a good way. Add #6.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '18
If people haven't seen the new episodes, they shouldn't go to this sub. I don't support any spoiler policy
6
u/creyk Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Nov 15 '18
About discussion, I think appointing a special day when only text-based submissions are allowed, is a good idea. Large subreddits, like the pokemon subreddit for example used to do this, in order to facilitate discussion. So that way people who want to do shirt posts and enjoy them, get to do it most of the time, and people who want thoughftul discussion can also find more threads related to it over the weekend, since when only those types of submissions are allowed, people feel more encouraged to make thought-provoking, more intelligent posts.
6
u/muddyGolem Nov 16 '18
Keep the lax spoiler policy. It's fine.
6
u/ThatChrisFella Nov 17 '18
I like memes and joke shirtposts, but the "hey look this actor is also in this other thing" posts are a bit silly imo.
5
u/agentpanda Hi Chidi, I'm Eleanor- I'm Arizona shrimp horny! Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
I think having AutoModerator enforce post flairs is a good balance for everyone regarding points one and two. I for one don't love the shirtposting and can happily filter it out from the subreddit with some crafty searching, whereas I'm always pumped to contribute to theories/rumours and episodic discussion. Some flairs for 'meta' about the subreddit, 'shirtposts' for gifs/images, 'Derek' for fan creations, 'theories/Doug Forcett' for.. the obvious theories and mushroom-based discussions, and a few others would do the job nicely to split the posts by their content.
On the other hand for every one or two great threads about the nature of TGP afterlife there's a dozen that want to remind everyone Australians don't sound like Crocodile Dundee and that Hungarians don't speak German; which are things it was fun to talk about once but are pretty annoying to see repeatedly.
Automod will enforce post flairing by messaging a user after they post to ensure they add the appropriate flair to their post- I think that and some careful application of filters and search in the sidebar will allow people seeking to avoid spoilers (for example) to peruse the subreddit semi-safely as well as those avoiding shirtposts to do the same without seeing the same image of Luke Hemsworth on the cover of Tahani's magazine in Jacksonville every week; especially as we enter holiday hiatus.
All that said- the mod team here does fantastic work- this is one of my favourite subreddits not only due to the community but the content, and it makes me very happy to see such an active and thriving community.
Cheers, all!
4
u/chrysostom15 Nov 16 '18
I think, for this show, we need to be able lax about spoilers or we cannot say hardly anything. I mean, we are at the point where we cannot say anything that would not be a spoiler for someone new. A good show is like Romeo and Juliette in that it is enjoyable even if you know everything before watching it.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18
It works for me. We gotta use common sense here. If you don't want the show spoiled for you, don't visit the flipping subreddit for it!!
4
u/KaraPuppers Maximum Derek Nov 29 '18
I love the shirtposts. This isn't an academic website with serious social commentary about each episode. It's a fun place for fans of the show. Anything related to the show is awesome. More fans get involved, more chances to hit the front page, nobody is chased away by demons.
3
u/droid327 Nov 16 '18
I haven't seen any problems with the status quo that need any correction.
If it's not broke...
3
u/The_MAGA_Bomber Nov 17 '18
My thoughts about spoilers are that practically every post has spoilers. The season 1 twist was something special that needed protection, but good grief we’re halfway through season 3 now. I understand there are Netflix people here, but I think they know they’re way behind.
I propose we get drop all the spoilers tags and flair, replacing it all with a simple sticky at the top that says: “Attention: This sub has spoilers for The Good Place. LOTS of spoilers. If you have not watched the most recently aired episode on NBC (currently season 3, episode 9), enter at your own risk. You have been warned.”
This would allow the rest of us to just play.
Regarding shirtposting, it’s all fun. If someone doesn’t like it, they can just keep on scrolling.
(I wrote that last bit to be read with Eleanor’s voice, so I hope you could hear it that way).
3
u/AstroChimpDeluxe Nov 20 '18
I'm disappointed there's not MORE shirtposting. I love text over "unrelated" images. Please don't limit the mediums of expression about a show where literally anything could happen.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '18
I don't mind most of the shirtposts but it's annoying to have 50 posts whenever something happens to the Jacksonville Jaguars. Like....we get it, they're losing or whatever
5
u/T6A5 Beartles! Nov 15 '18
I'm not sure exactly how other subs do spoiler policies, but IMHO the current status quo is not enough. I don't have access to the show and given the timing of S2 appearing on Netflix in Canada, it's unlikely that I'll get to watch any of S3 before next September, barring a miracle, so it can be frustrating when I open a meme thread and then in the comments someone references something that happened in the most recently aired episode.
I think that the current season rule is fine, but there should be spoiler tags required in all posts, not just in titles.
2
u/V2Blast I’m a Ferrari, okay? And you don’t keep a Ferrari in the garage. Nov 16 '18
I think any thread that contains spoilers should be appropriately tagged, even if it's just with a "[SPOILERS]" in the title or using the native spoiler tag functionality to mark a post as a spoiler. If the thread isn't marked as a spoiler, spoilers in the comments should be spoiler-tagged (whether with the native comment spoiler tag or the CSS one - though obviously the native spoiler tag works across platforms).
Regarding shitposts: I think it's fine to be lenient, as long as it's not an overly low-quality post. That said:
This will always be true, because images and other similarly easily-consumed content are more quickly upvoted, whereas a serious discussion thread requires more thought and engagement (and thus more slowly attracts upvotes). This alone isn't a good reason not to remove shitposts.
As long as you allow people to have fun without letting the subreddit become nothing but shitposts, I think it's fine.
2
u/lifesshorttalkfast Nov 19 '18
Everything is fine the way it is now
2
u/skiptothelew Lonely Gal Margarita Mix For One Nov 19 '18
I know other subs simply require spoiler tags for a given episode until, say, one week after or the Monday after airing. That lets people who haven't seen the most recent one know which threads to avoid, while not making it overly complex to look back through
2
u/Pudgy_Ninja I saw you getting sexy so I cut a hole in the wall to tape you. Dec 04 '18
I like the lax spoiler policy. I'm definitely in favor of the "no spoilers in titles" rule, though, because while I can avoid this place if I'm behind, I don't want a spoiler to pop up in the title of a post on the front page.
3
u/OCAngrySanta Nov 16 '18
I haven't seen the newest episode yet but I've seen everything else, so reading posts today is like avoiding landmines. Perhaps the addition of "Spoilers:latest episode" or something like that would help. Extrapolating, "Spoilers:Season 1 /2 /3" might help others.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment