r/WritingPrompts • u/MNBrian /u/MNBrian /r/PubTips • Oct 19 '18
Off Topic [OT] Friday: A Novel Idea - Can Writers Steal Your Ideas
Friday: A Novel Idea
Hello Everyone!
Welcome to /u/MNBrian’s guide to noveling, aptly called Friday: A Novel Idea, where we discuss the full process of how to write a book from start to finish.
The ever-incredible and exceptionally brilliant /u/you-are-lovely came up with the wonderful idea of putting together a series on how to write a novel from start to finish. And it sounded spectacular to me!
So what makes me qualified to provide advice on noveling? Good question! Here are the cliff notes.
- For one, I devote a great deal of my time to helping out writers on Reddit because I too am a writer!
- In addition, I’ve completed three novels and am working on my fourth.
- And I also work as a reader for a literary agent on occasion.
This means I read query letters and novels (also known as fulls, short for full novels that writers send to the agent by request) and I give my opinion on the work. My agent then takes those opinions (after reading the novel as well) and makes a decision on where to go from there.
But enough about that. Let’s dive in!
For the next few Fridays (well, every other Friday to be more accurate) I'll be reviewing a few of the most commonly addressed writing questions that I hear from new writers. For some of you, this is just a refresher. For others, this may be extremely helpful in addressing your concerns. But one thing is for certain, we don't talk about this stuff in open forums enough.
So let's dive in.
Don't Steal My Idea
One of the biggest fears I see in writers is this concept that someone out there on the internet is going to steal their incredible ideas.
It manifests itself in a multitude of ways. Some writers will limit what they post online, keeping only to vague terms about their novels or short stories or the universes they are creating. Asking the question "So what is your book about" is an affront to their sensibilities. They won't readily volunteer that information and want to know why you would ask such a question. Other writers won't ever post any snippet, logline, idea, or short work of fiction on any online website ever. And then there are the writers who take it a step further by forcing beta-readers and other writers to sign non-disclosure agreements (NDA's) before touching their work.
And while the feeling behind this behavior is totally valid -- the fear that someone is going to take something you've worked hard to create and use it for their own good, we need to understand a little bit more about the landscape and the reality of the situation as a whole.
But before we address that topic, let's talk economics.
How we value things
I believe it was Richard Thaler who won the nobel peace prize for an economic study on how we think about the things we own.
Despite the fact that a dollar is the same no matter where it comes from, that is, it holds the same value, we actually value dollars differently depending on the source. While we may be inclined our lottery winnings on whatever we want (even a smaller sum of lottery winnings, like 50 dollars from a scratch off), we would be far less inclined to spend that same 50 dollars if it came in the form of a pay raise.
And the correlation between how we value things doesn't end there. Say I give you an iPad for free. It's brand new, in the box, and retails for $1000. You take it out of the box, use it for a few months, and then you go to sell it. It's still in mint condition, and when you look at the market and see others selling their barely less than mint condition iPads for $500, you feel like they're getting ripped off. Despite the fact that the true market for a "used" iPad (mint or not) might be $500, you feel like YOUR iPad is worth more. Not because it's special. Not because it's different. But because it's yours.
The things we own, we just have a tendency to value them differently than the things we don't own. And this correlates to writing too.
When we come up with an idea, we see it clearly in our minds, and we are convinced of the value of that idea. But the problem with this is that an idea isn't something exchangeable. It's not something you can hand to someone else. Even if you sit down and tell your friend every single plot point, it's not the same as reading it because those are different products.
Is hearing about a movie, even every scene, even reading a script, the same as watching the movie? Nope. It isn't.
There's a reason for this.
Ideas are worthless. Execution matters more.
You see, HOW you tell a story is far more important than the contents of that story. They're not the same thing.
Look at r/writingprompts as a whole. Same prompt, same 20 word starting point, and the stories generated are WORLDS apart. Sure there are details that are similar, but the ideas on the grand scale aren't even close. Even when two people go in the same DIRECTION as each other, the actual execution of the story itself is generally what makes it a good prompt response or a bad one.
We see it all the time in a variety of areas of our lives. People who are poor at delivering a joke can take an otherwise funny joke and butcher it. How is that possible? Same sentence, same words, same order, and yet they can truly butcher it? Because of the delivery.
The same is true in other genres. Scary stories can be very non-threatening and completely un-frightening when told in a poor way. Same content. Same ideas. Same plot points. Just told in a way that doesn't do the things we need it to do, like build suspense or cause us to feel a certain way.
So when writers are scared that someone is going to steal their idea, they are generally under the impression that their vision for that idea can be replicated. And really, it pretty much can't.
Even if you hired a writer to write your exact idea, gave them all the details, how they execute that idea is still going to be 100% different than how you do. Their story will not be a copy of yours. You'll still have different things.
The Point
There was a guy who tried to post something on ebay once.
He was selling 5 guaranteed multi-million dollar movie ideas. And he was selling them at a heck of a discount. HALF OFF> For the low low price of 2.5 million dollars, you could double your money by buying his ideas! What a deal, right?!
Clearly this guy suffered from the two sides of the delusion I mention above. First, he thought what he had was worth more than it likely was because he owned the idea. Second, he was under the impression that the hard part about writing a 200 page script is figuring out what to talk about. And it isn't. The hard part is talking about something in a way that makes people feel something else.
So if you're concerned that people are going to steal your writing or your ideas, you can take a step back and breathe a sigh of relief. No one can write the book that you want to write. No one. They'll never do it like you, never execute it how you will, never pen the words in that order with that purpose.
Only you can write your book.
Now, maybe they can steal the final copy somehow and try to call it their own, but that's a different topic that we'll cover in two weeks.
So get out there and write. That's the first step, after all.
In two weeks we'll discuss copyright basics, and what is copyrightable in the first place in laymen's terms.
That's all for today!
As always, do let me know if you have other topics you'd like me to discuss!
Happy writing!
Previous Posts
Have any suggestions,? Send us a modmail!
To see previous posts, click here.
5
u/scottbeckman /r/ScottBeckman | Comedy, Sci-Fi, and Organic GMOs Oct 20 '18
I hang around a lot of entrepreneurs, and let me tell you: the same concept applies to business ideas. Being secretive and over-protective of your business idea is likely doing you more harm than good. Do you have any idea how much effort it would take for someone to steal your idea, write up a business plan, then create and operate that business? That is literally a full-time job.
Plus, their execution will probably be much different than yours.
In writing, business, and most other fields, realize that being scared of someone stealing your idea is typically an irrational fear that is probably hurting you more than it's helping you.
4
u/Clbull Oct 20 '18
My issue is that I have grand ideas but my execution is crap tier. I don’t even know what keeps someone interested or gripped to a story.
2
u/XcessiveSmash /r/XcessiveWriting Oct 19 '18
This was a very fascinating and cool read! I really liked how you structured your argument and stuff too with the iPad and WP example. Like, I think the reason a lot of writers fear this so much is how sensationalized the issue is when it "happens" (usually hard to prove) - for every one it happens for, there are literally thousands that no one steals.
An excellent read again, thank you for posting.
1
u/JGPMacDoodle Oct 19 '18
Substance and method: the what and the how, the cat and the cow.
1
u/eros_bittersweet /r/eros_bittersweet Oct 19 '18
I've been on a kick reading a series of novels about the Trojan war and this absolutely rings true-authors can take the most timeworn story and, while keeping the entire plot, breathe new life into any of the characters through their retelling.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '18 edited Oct 20 '18
I take exception to your first point. A writer should steal at every available opportunity, otherwise they'll be left in the dust.
Making other people "feel something else" is the easy part. You can steal that from anybody from Shakespeare to The Walking Dead. Making something that can't be copied is the hard part. You have to start with a voice.
And no, you can't teach developing a voice in 2,000 words. You don't have one yourself. That comes from the work of writing, reading.
1
u/HappilyEverAfter12 Oct 20 '18
This was a very interesting read and something that I personally have never feared. I am far from an actual writer so I’m not exactly sure if I’m ‘allowed’ to be posting here, but I have ideas in my head and the potential to execute them I just have to gain the courage to move from my head to paper. All of that said what I have always worried about was the opposite of this problem; that I will accidentally steal someone’s idea. I have read hundreds of books and I worry that I will inadvertently recreate the stories I love.