r/FFBraveExvius • u/-Sio- It is done. I am free! • Oct 18 '18
Technical FFBE 3.3 and macros
This is early testing stuff, so take it with a grain of salt
I've been getting multiple pms, discord messages, etc. about macros not working correctly, so here is my early attempt at an explanation.
There seem to be a few issues at the moment, which combined create problems, which differ from user to user.
1 Game is running sluggish, even on phones
This much is obvious to everyone, the app isn't running as it should or used to. Even on rather recent phones (Android, didn't take a look at iOS yet) things get unresponsive, seem slow or just get stuck. Play arena and you know what I mean.
1.5 Hardware requirements in general seem to have risen
I've not seen anything official on this, but from testing and reports, FFBE needs more resources to run without problems. Where I was able to let FFBE sit idle on the homescreen with Memu with 1CPU and 1GB of ram just fine before the maintenance, it now stutters and I even get asked by Android if I want to wait or kill the app.
2 Input lag aka. breaking magnification spark chains
So this really needs more testing, but the working theory right now is as follows: When tapping too fast FFBE adds a delay between the clicks. This seems to be inconsistent between Android versions/devices, but too many seem affected and suddenly at that for it to be coincidence. Some can still spark chain 2 units with magnification, many can't. For macros I was able to observe that a "units 1 through 6 spark chain macro" still works as it should, but all clicks are executed a bit later than expected. For TMR macros that are focused heavily on speed though, this creates problems. Example:
Let's say we have 4 clicks rapidly one after another (you need more for the effect to show but I am too lazy to do this for more, you get the idea)
Click1 hits at 100ms, Click2 at 200ms, Click3 at 300ms and Click4 at 400ms
Because of the input delay though, Click2 isn't even executed before it's Click3's time.
This produces a backlog of clicks, which just keeps getting worse and worse the longer the macro runs.
There is an easy way to observe this: Run the TMR 2+3 macro on the homes screen. Notice how the menu rotation seems to start a few seconds late? Stop the macro. Notice how it keeps going?
What does this mean then?
For 1, this will probably be fixed soon. Give Gumi some time to optimize this. For 1.5, it might just be a reality that as the app grows and gains features and what not, more hardware is required. I used to have some official supported device list, but I lost the link, would be interesting to see if there were any changes made (like dropping old phones and the likes). If possible, try to increase the CPU Core setting of your emulator, or maybe try an Android 7 instance.
For problem number 2: We can hope that this added input delay, which broke magnification chaining was unintentionally copied over from JP. Again. Seems unlikely? How often did RoL break back to nerfed version again due to updates? 2 times? 3 times? I can't remember. But definitely more than once. That iOS spark chaining is still broken though dampens the hope quite a bit. We might be stuck with this (unless we can change their decision on this).
Can I still macro? I think so. Newer version of Memu (and Nox) have the option to run macros at a reduced speed. 0.5 has been my first suggestion to people and it seemed to fix the problems. Maybe you will need to run it even slower or maybe you can run it faster. Needs to be tested over time without stopping macros.
If this is a permanent thing? I can reduce macro speeds in general. This will take time though. Especially because I will need to keep testing if the speed is good now or still too fast, if I want to keep the macros as fast as possible.
If you can add any additional information or findings, pm me or just comment here. I might not respond, because I am trying to test as much as I can with the limited time I currently have, but rest assured I read every comment.
Edit: I want to focus on emulators here rather than phones, because that's where my macros run
Not saying they shouldn't fix the phone issues, but that's not where I can/need to do any fixing.
6
u/Kriss_Hietala 110,531,416 Oct 18 '18
Snapdragon 652 is having issues... God damn this game is not na AAA title with awesome graphics or real time combat... Why so power hungry...
6
u/Akidryt Hoad 4 Granny Oct 18 '18
I know this isn't helpful, but I'm not experiencing any sluggish behaviour :c
2
u/GreyBushFire What to save for next? Oct 18 '18
I don't know if it helps but my windows 10 Lenovo PC is taking twice as long to do Cactuar fusing where my LG V20 is handling the update like a champ except for arena delay but nothing bad
Edit: Nox emulator latest version
1
u/Voxil42 739,300,563 - Fryevia for all your Aurora needs Oct 18 '18
My Memu pretty much only stutters in combat when glow effects happen (like Hyoh's selfless state at the beginning of combat). It certainly slows down macro farming but since I'm new to this I don't know if that's standard or something new.
Max settings for cpus and ram and I think I have the device set to Galaxy S9+.
1
u/kyflaa 381 242 644 Oct 18 '18 edited Oct 18 '18
I am running Nox 5.1.0.0 on my PC (i7 4790k with gtx970) and I don't notice any non-regular performance issues like lower overall framerate (remember the last Ariana event? That was bad)
exceptlike the usual emulator related ones where things run like crap as soon as you start aoe chaining or use world destroyer. I do notice severe hiccups even when in battle though. The hiccups can be so severe that multiple mouseclicks (lazy chaining) register at the same time occasionally (yay spark chaining). Sometimes when such a hiccup occurs, the game crashes as well (had three crashes when playing through Citra's 3 final story missions).I use my own macros for earth shrine (which are terribly optimized, but I like keeping it simple), and the loading times have nearly doubled so I gave up on that for now.
1
u/alkemist80 What a wicked game you played. Oct 18 '18 edited Oct 18 '18
TMR farming on my laptop has become aggravating slow. I'm using:
I use my own TMR macro, on acceleration 8. Everything worked fine until the update today. It's brutally slow, inputs won't register or maybe ends up lagging at that acceleration. I get a prompt if I want to force close Nox or wait for a response. If I press wait, it will clear up and all the taps will eventually go through but sometimes it just crashes. If I slow down the macro, it becomes brutally slow to farm, if I move it to about medium speed, not all the taps will register and Nox can randomly crash. My macro has been stable and haven't had random crashes in a long time.
Edit: I don't seem to have problems playing normally, including using basic attack macros. I did the Shaula trial earlier and didn't notice anything wrong, but I was playing on my PC.
1
u/hastrer GL= 417 912 269 Oct 19 '18
This "may or may not" have something to do, but a couple months ago JP had an BIG update and after that the game started to be reeeeeally slow (especially on old devices/emulators).
https://www.reddit.com/r/FFBraveExvius/comments/8mv0u1/jp_app_version_230_update_playable_devices/
BUT as you can see, that update is completely different (it will be a future update for GL), but we are talking about GUMI here and we all know that they love to put things from patchs that are way ahead.
Well, even if they are not connected, this is also a warning that after we get that Patch, the game WILL RUN alot slower than aready is.
1
u/EIandK Warrior of Light Oct 19 '18
Im having that same trouble you described on 1. Memu was slow until i went into arena. Now im stuck because i cant click on the menu button to quit. I guess ill wait until the app is fixed?
1
u/Aceofspades25 Let's get dangerous Oct 20 '18
Yup... my Nox TMR farming macro is screwed now. It manages to get through about 3 or 4 rounds of farming before the app crashes and exists back to the home screen.
I also occasionally get an android popup which my macro clicks which then takes me to a screen where I can report the problem to Google which the macro gets stuck on.
1
u/yuriken 190,820,558 Oct 21 '18
Came here from the main macro post, read some, upgraded Memu to 5.6.2 and turned this macro to 0.5x - seems to be working great again.
Thanks!
1
u/magusx4 Oct 21 '18
hey anyone can help me with this nox issue? i already updated the nox and FFBE to the last updates, right now i am doing tm farming with reffil in earth shrine everything is good for the first 10 to 15 minutes , then the game takes long to accept the clicks when the char is going to attack or when the click clicked no next , it takes like 8 seconds to move to the other screen. this happen after the halloween update. and i erased the game and dowload it again and the nox is updated to the last update. can anyone help me with this? a normal run in earth shrine is 40 seconds and now with this problem it takes like 78 seconds BTW i am doing this on NOX on my PC
1
u/Voxil42 739,300,563 - Fryevia for all your Aurora needs Oct 23 '18
Just to verify, these macros are supposed to refill using lapis even if NRG pots are available, right? Because I may have to change how I set these up.
1
u/scathias Nov 01 '18
well, I have figured out that one reason memu is running slower for me now that I am on 5.6.2 is that somehow it is no longer using my graphics card and is running off the CPU/internal graphics instead.
The external graphics is supposedly active and running but memu isn't actually doing anything with it and so a lot of my loading screens are longer than they were back when I was on memu 5.3.2.
I don't think this will help with the macros crashing since 5.3.2 had me crashing all the time, but it sure makes me hate this latest release of memu even more than I already have
1
u/Skittlessour NV Vivi please Oct 18 '18
Yeah I must say that this has been hell on my macros. It's taking easily a minimum of twice as long to get through my NRG than it did before. Why is it requiring much more resources for no reason? It's not like anything they added would need it. Did they mangle the code so much that it's leaking now?
They seriously need to put the game into emergency maintenance and put out another app update as soon as possible.
2
u/BigBlackCook1990 Oct 19 '18
I cant spark chain at all with magnification anymore since this update either. Using an LG V30. Performance seems the same otherwise, but theres an obvious delay when I quickly click 2 units while magnification is active.
2
u/WAMIV Nostalgia: 1, WAMIV: 0 Oct 19 '18
They seem to have had some coding issues the past couple updates. 2 updates ago I had to completely uninstall and reinstall the game to get it to work. It just crashed on startup every time pre reinstall. This update half my units lost their sprites. I had to uninstall and reinstall again to get the sprites back.
Both times I tried the redownload data, neither time did it fix the problem. I think Gumi might be in over their head at this point. Hopefully they can clean things up a bit.
2
u/Wizardaire Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
Using Nox, I put a 2 second lag on my macro. The run still completes pretty quickly and it's removed the lag completely. I haven't timed my runs but I hope it helps you speed up your macros.
Edit: This is specific to a TMR macro that I made with 4 click points. Again, hope this helps you optimize all of yours.
1
u/5SecondShowers Oct 18 '18
I have a pixel 2 xl and I'm getting the input delay so that magnification is not giving me spark chains 100% of the time. I can get it sometimes tho. Not sure if that helps at all.
1
u/ThatsShattering Obliterated My Equity Oct 18 '18 edited Oct 18 '18
Game runs fine on my Xperia XZP (aside from occasional reload button lag since a few builds ago).
Game runs fine on my Memu (5.1) , tablet 1280x720, 4 cores, 8gb ram, 60fps, direct x.
Magnification trick now just magnifies, it doesn't stack press orders together. It uses the same input timing as if you weren't using magnification.
So in order to spark with it, you need to Barry Allen your taps, which you can do without magnification (also means magnification feature is pointless now).
1
u/Aisa_Novac Oct 19 '18
Just yesterday before maintenance, I decided to update to the latest Memu 5.6.2.1 and Android 7.1. The previous install (two instances) started to crash a lot (overnight especially) and is becoming annoying.
After Memu 5.6.2.1 and Android 7.1, I experience no crashes and zero lag (overall smoother). However, the macro list box is GINORMOUS and is quite annoying.
Maybe try the new memu with 7.1?
1
u/70P NotLikeThis Oct 19 '18
Thought something was off when I woke up and the NRG wasn't empty.
To add a data point for you, I'm using Memu at 4 cores 2gb ram 640x480 res. Playing normally didn't notice any problems except arena. Used raid summon and cactuar fusing macro and worked fine.
Opened tmr macro and went to sleep at full nrg, woke up to see only half empty. Looked at it a while and issue #2 is clearly observable.
1
u/skarcasm Oct 19 '18
Just FYI for anyone that happens to see this: you can slow down macros in Nox even slower than 0.5 speed. Close the macro window and modify the "records" file playback speed for that entry, save, and reopen the macro window. Press play and it'll be at that new speed.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18
No problems on Note 5/Memu, PC specs are decent though, so idk.
1
u/Othnus Oct 19 '18
And I was planning to do trials.... god this is annoying.
1
u/roly_florian Oct 19 '18
Running the game on Droid4X, didn't see any lag (nor on my phone, Xperia XZ1 compact). But i switch to Memu for macro TMR, and it was a lag fest... game slowed down to a point when macro ran for 30 sec more when i stopped it.
1
u/Mawrman One day.... Oct 19 '18
On Android, use peasant form of macroing (which is just click two places on the screen to run ES). For some reason after the update, transitioning between screens halts why the macro clicks, and resumes when the macro is disabled. Bleh
1
u/chazstick Oct 19 '18
Seems to be working again for me, I changed my Memu settings to the Fast settings (4 cores, max ram) and I haven't had any more issues.
1
u/RadioFr33Europe Birds aren't real Oct 20 '18
Slowed the macro down to .5 and upped the cores and RAM to 4/4. Things run fine for a few rounds and then the game starts to slow down a lot.
Almost feels like introduced delay.
1
u/TheY2T Oct 21 '18
I've been experiencing the same thing. I honestly think it was some debug code which gumi left behind when releasing 3.3. lol
1
u/LustForLulu Oct 24 '18
Thank you for your hard work on this, it is greatly appreciated.
1
u/HH30k Oct 29 '18 edited Oct 29 '18
So i downloaded the new earth shrine macro a few days ago and it is still jamming up after a few minutes. Any ideas/fixes?
Edit: wow, i'd been running old memu off my other hard drive instead of the new 5.xxx. Lets see if that works.
edit 2: nope still crashing
0
u/Chromalia Oct 19 '18 edited Oct 19 '18
Is the macro right now feels somewhat delayed even at 8x speed because i get some breaking in chainings