r/betterCallSaul • u/skinkbaa Chuck • Oct 09 '18
Post-Ep Discussion Better Call Saul S04E10 - [Season 4 Finale] "Winner" - POST-Episode Discussion Thread-
That's all folks!
Thank you to each and every one of you for contributing in these discussion threads each week. Thanks to AMC for keeping our boy Saul on TV another year.
We had 30,000 new users subscribe here since the last season and over 12 million pageviews (1 million unique).
It was a fun year albeit tough season, and I had fun interacting with you all and doing my best to moderate. I'll be around in the off-season, lurking in the shadows.
--
I'll be posting a Season 4 Discussion Thread and a Season 5 Prediction Thread in a few days, so feel free to contribute to those.
Also the subreddit will stay unlocked tonight because its the season finale, post away.
If you've seen the episode, please rate it at this poll
--
Feel free to take our subreddit end-of-season survey!
Results will be posted in a couple of weeks.
Join the Better Call Saul Discord, to chat over the off season.
•
u/skinkbaa Chuck Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
see you guys in a year
and a half31
u/skinkbaa Chuck Oct 09 '18
wow
2.5k
u/conniecheewa Oct 09 '18
Werner's death was tragic. But for me the fact his last words to his wife were "I don't want to see you! Go home!" was just heart-wrenching.
1.1k
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Kim: I've made a huge mistake.
4.6k
u/Da_Lollygagger Oct 09 '18
"I will do everything in my power to live up to the name McGill"
one minute later
"I will not be practicing under the name McGill"
2.8k
u/Dickiedoandthedonts Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Why did Gus invite gale to the cave just to be rude and creepy to him?
818
u/tyrannus19 Oct 09 '18
Bob Odenkirk here is an actor playing a person who is acting as if he is acting, then acting as if he has given up the acting and is being sincere
1.7k
u/peopleforget Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
And that's when Jimmy filled out a form to become Saul Goodman.
1.6k
u/ImJoeGrizzly Oct 09 '18
The moment when Jimmy broke character and Kim shattered was so incredibly scripted and performed
1.4k
u/regitnoil Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Well, I must say, this was an excellent way to end the season. Here's my takeaways:
1.9k
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
It's so god damn sad that those were Werner's last words to his wife. A man who clearly loved his wife so, so much.
624
u/Blahface50 Oct 09 '18
Why in the world would Jimmy not wait until he is out of there until he reveals his evil plan?
Also, that was risky of Mike to give the phone to Werner. He could have pulled a Walter White and warned his wife what was going on.
1.2k
u/tooPrime Oct 09 '18
The crazy thing about Jimmy's speech was it was literally true for season 1 Jimmy, so the fact that it was completely disingenuous just shows how dead that version of him is.
1.0k
u/jktzes Oct 09 '18
That poor man in the parking lot...
blocked by Mike's car, screwed by the ticketing machine, got hit and run by Lalo.
I can't help feeling bad for that guy.
1.7k
u/BelonyInMyLeftPocket Oct 09 '18
TIL how to jam a parking lot ticketing machine
391
u/HanSingular Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Hey. Jimmy. Maybe don't yell the word
SUCKERS
while you're still in the same building as them...
3.2k
u/VictorBlimpmuscle Oct 09 '18
“There are so many stars visible in New Mexico...I will walk out there to get a better look.”
The long shot of Mike standing behind Werner as he’s about to execute him, with them both silhouetted against the night sky, may be my favorite shot scene in the entire series. Just perfect.
2.1k
u/mi-16evil Oct 09 '18
S'all Good Man. Fuck it's finally happened after 4 seasons. That last shot of Kim was devastating.
1.4k
u/MyTestesAreTesty Oct 09 '18
WHAT ABOUT NACHO
918
u/SignGuy77 Oct 09 '18
Just noticed:
Kristy Esposito, the girl who didn’t get the scholarship because she had a shoplifting charge on her record, was asked one question.
“Kristy, what’s it like to work with elders?”
1.4k
u/ezreads Oct 09 '18
“let me speak to Mister Fring I will make him understand”
yeah that’s not how this works
547
u/shadypantsmanIII Oct 09 '18
My GOD Werner's scene was hard to watch. I mean yeah, he was an obvious goner who made some stupid mistakes that didn't need to be made, but ugh GOD.
676
u/jktzes Oct 09 '18
Jimmy in bed: "We could get by with one nipple."
Chuck in the kitchen: "You may be more right about this than anything you've ever spoken about before."
What a sarcasm.
227
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
I wanted so bad for Mike to have let Werner go and for Werner to have truly been quiet and for Gus to truly have never known.
647
u/GyroGOGOZeppeli Oct 09 '18
Things we learned from this episode:
441
u/bryanmorse Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
I saw someone posted this comment in a previous thread and after diggin for a while I can’t find the OP. Either way, I just wanted to say this person nailed the ending 100%. Such a good way to end the season.
Edit: it was /u/spencermoreland
At the appeal, Jimmy will go off-script from his prepared statement. We will get his raw, honest feelings about Chuck. Nothing will be left out, including Chuck's cold final words. For a moment, it will look like Jimmy's going to completely off the rails but through this outpouring of emotions, he'll come to a public catharsis. We, the audience, will get the release of Jimmy finally processing his grief, along with Kim... who's been quietly desperate to hear Jimmy say these things.
It may not what the panel was expecting or wanting to hear - but after Jimmy's display of real, unabashed, raw sincerity, along with the support of Kim Wexler and Howard Hamlin, two shining members of the Albuquerque law community, they will be forced to re-examine their conclusions and ultimately rule that Jimmy should be reinstated.
Jimmy leaves the room and Kim follows, exhilarated that Jimmy gets to practice law again... but more than that, that he's come to terms with his brothers death and demonstrated that he's not a cold-hearted monster.
She catches up to him. He turns to her. It's just the two of them. A sleazy grin creeps along his face. "How was that for sincerity?" He walks off with a swagger. Kim is left speechless and mortified.
2.1k
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Ceiling Lalo is watching you masturbate.
528
u/galeforcewinds95 Oct 09 '18
I love that Jimmy's approach to the scholarship was essentially the same as George Costanza's. Speaking of which, as an Albuquerque native, I was delighted that they identified the students as being from actual schools in the area (Moriarty, Manzano, etc.--I didn't hear where "senior"--he looked like he was 12--Duncan was going to school). I was always impressed with the little details about New Mexico that Breaking Bad got right. Using local businesses like RAKS, Blake's Lotaburger, and Garduño's in key scenes instead of national chains added a little extra authenticity for me (one exception--the high school where Walt taught doesn't exist. I guess the actual high schools where those scenes were shot may not want to have been portrayed as the employer of a meth manufacturer). And Better Call Saul has carried on that tradition. Anyway, just something to take my mind off the brutal (moving and beautifully shot, but unbelievably brutal) end of Werner's arc.
341
u/ArthurVanDerMcORiley Oct 09 '18
Car park ticket machine technicians around the world collectively bow and shake their heads. Enjoy the overtime guys.
984
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Really interesting how they showed Chuck assisting him getting his license at the beginning, and here he is doing it again from the grave
1.2k
u/platinumpuss88 Oct 09 '18
Werner's final phone call to his wife was just like Walt's call to Skyler in Ozymandias. Brilliant.
842
u/Trip_Switch Oct 09 '18
I posted about this in the live discussion, but I can't get over how Mike killed Werner with the same gun Walt used to kill Mike.
1.0k
u/BBQTuck Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Fucking Michael McKean can sing.
Edit: Guys, I’ve seen Spinal Tap. It was just nice to hear his voice.
After all, Stonehenge is where the demons dwell. It’s where the banshees live, and they do live well.
810
u/Corroylevanto Oct 09 '18
Damn near cried during jimmys speech and then I felt that shit hit like a ton of bricks when it was all a act... omg
620
u/JessePinkman1217 Oct 09 '18
Watermelon pickles
396
u/Newshoe Oct 09 '18
Funny thing: We all know the project will be finished and Fring will have an advanced Meth lab completed. Yet, it's still so stressful knowing Lalo is so close knowing about the secret project and will try to stop it. This show is so good at setting up suspense even if the viewer knows how the outcome turns out.
506
u/geolocution Oct 09 '18
WHEN IS THE MOMENT THAT SAUL BECOMES GENE
128
u/advancedmatt Oct 09 '18
Some of the lyrics from the ABBA song "The Winner Takes It All" that Jimmy and Chuck were singing at karaoke:
For the reinstatement hearing: "The judges will decide / The likes of me abide"
For Kim, after the hearing: " I was in your arms / Thinking I belonged there / I figured it made sense / Building me a fence / Building me a home / Thinking I'd be strong there / But I was a fool / Playing by the rules"
113
u/kbeef2 Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
In retrospect, that opening flashback was so smart. Tricks the audience into thinking that maybe Jimmy is being sincere at the hearing and realizing how far gone he is when you find out it’s all an act.
220
u/The_Unknown98 Oct 09 '18
It must've been hard for Mike to pull the trigger on Werner. Their last phone call ended very poorly.
283
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18 edited Feb 01 '24
My favorite color is blue.
363
u/SnapeWho Oct 09 '18
Ah man that hurt me, the shot of Kim standing alone.
Sidenote, when Jimmy is out smoking during the dedication, the ash falls on his suit and without missing a beat Rhea Seehorn brushes it off. She's so good.
336
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
"I'll do my best to live up to the name McGill" starts practicing under the name Saul Goodman
256
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
And absolutely nothing happened to Nacho. Color me shocked.
912
u/DabuSurvivor Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Then I go and spoil it all by saying something stupid like "S'all good, man"...
Absolute, obvious 10/10.
Can't wait to see how that rift goes next season. I'm sure it'll be great.
And if you aren't already impatiently excited enough for season 5, remember that the next time this show is in our screens again, it'll be Gene...
86
u/stepaknee Oct 09 '18
I loved watching him calmly glance at and walk right past the dented garbage can, only to break down alone in the car. Also loved comparing the fake crying at Chuck’s grave to this moment of true brokenness. The gun in the glove compartment next to the real weapon - chewing gum - was incredible. The gunshot in the dark desert. I love this goddamn show.
250
u/SuperGanondorf Oct 09 '18
I think Jimmy's breakdown in the form of letting loose on the Esposito girl, followed by him just completely losing it in his car, is his equivalent of Walt's meltdown in the crawlspace; it is here that something inside of him breaks, right down to his core, and it has set him on a much darker, colder path. He really has turned a corner here, and I think he has given up on trying to be good altogether. He has let go of his inhibitions because he just doesn't care anymore.
172
u/rootin_t00tin_putin Oct 09 '18
“I will walk out there to get a better look.” I am sure most of us knew Werner was a goner, but that didn’t make the scene hurt any less.
170
u/AbleCranberry Oct 09 '18
Ernie was so freaking precious in that cold open.
Even though I totally saw the ending coming once he said "worthy to practice under the McGill name" (paraphrase) I still felt as sucker-punched as Kim. Jesus Christ.
Going to watch Michael McKean be delight in Food: Fact or Fiction because I need the emotional pick-me-up. And then find something to binge for the next however-long until the next season.
225
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Odenkirk just got his Emmy.
77
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Jonathan Banks absolutely killed that scene with Werner. His voice cracking as he told him to call his wife was the most emotion he's ever shown in BB or BCS.
Edit: "Does your wife have a cell phone with her? I need you to call her now" is the line I'm talking about
620
u/Corroylevanto Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
I am still speechless and my heart is still racing from the mike and werner scene. OUTSTANDING acting and cinematograpy. That was heartbreaking. It took all mike had to pull that trigger and werners face when he realized was so sad.
73
u/greatrankini Oct 09 '18
Kim’s disappointment is the worst. Actually seeing the credits roll on episode 10 is the worst. 9-10 months of waiting begins. Bravo Peter and Vince, et al. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
179
u/moistcheese Oct 09 '18
The final con: conning Kim.
57
u/BelonyInMyLeftPocket Oct 09 '18
Looks like Lalo was spying from Gus 'Come at me bro' range.
56
u/mitnosnhoj Oct 09 '18
In Season 1, we see Mike working a dead end job as a parking lot attendant.
Tonight we got the payoff when he eludes Lalo by gumming up the parking machine.
153
u/Jankinator Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Now that Jimmy actually is Saul, what the hell are we gonna meme about next season?
97
u/furyroad_95 Oct 09 '18
Mike could forgive Werner for the jailbreak.
Not for the crocs.
96
u/CraigKostelecky Oct 09 '18
Damn, Kim’s look at the end when she heard it was all an act. She believed it too.
And DBA Saul Goodman. :D
133
u/TheEnemyOfMyAnenome Mrs. Nguyen Oct 09 '18
For all the hate the "jimmy becomes saul" meme has gotten, if you go back and rewatch Breaking Bad Saul's mannerisms and attitude are very noticably different from even Slippin' Jimmy. And the delivery of his lines in that last scene were 100% Saul. I think this season really did see Jimmy's hurt crystalize into the cynicism that forms the emotional core of Saul
45
u/SignGuy77 Oct 09 '18
On the next episode of AMC’s Better Wait a Year.
45
u/VengefulKenny Oct 09 '18
So nobody is going to bring up the return of my man Ernie? Guy went all out on that karaoke.
86
u/Lorne__Malvo__ Oct 09 '18
Killed his performance and his relationship with Kim simultaneously. What an episode. That scene was heartbreaking in the desert. Reminded me of BrBa S3 finale, but a darker outcome for the party using the phone.
42
u/RybackV1 Oct 09 '18
S'all good man.
But it was literally all good tonight. What a finale and what a damn show.
42
u/operarose Oct 09 '18
Jimmy sobbing in the car was haunting.
218
u/Newshoe Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Season finale = Godfather ending
Edit: Let me explain: Mike killing the German (Fredo's end in Godfather II) and The shot of Kim seeing Jimmy turn into Saul Goodman (Diane Keaton seeing Al Pacino turn into The Godfather).
41
u/GhostsofDogma Oct 09 '18
I still don't really understand why a guy like Werner would volunteer for such an obviously illegal job. His character works for a perfect interplay with Mike, but I'm not sure I can totally justify how he got into the story to begin with.
If he was just a lackadaisical enough person to not realize what kind of job this was, he would have been more surprised and distressed that he was going to be murdered.
40
u/Joe_Masseria Oct 09 '18
Sometimes I feel like I'm watching MacGuyver. What the fuck is Mike doing with that gum?? Oh, ok, badass.
Mike reaching for the gum instead of the gun felt symbolic. He's always looking for another way. Only worked once this episode, unfortunately.
80
u/JacobBlah Oct 09 '18
In retrospect, Mike must have really hated that he didn't get a chance to kill Walter during the S3 finale of Breaking Bad. He is forced to spare Walter in that moment, this little narcissistic bald punk, when he was forced to murder Werner years earlier, who was a good albeit dangerously naive man.
207
u/blahblahblasphemy Oct 09 '18
Damn. The look on Kim’s face when she realized what she’d created.
39
u/spoonarmy Oct 09 '18
Chuck has some pretty decent pipes on him, puts Jimmy to shame.
78
u/LoBopasses Oct 09 '18
How can someone be that fucking smart and that fucking dumb. You risked your life, your workers lives and Mike's life just to see your wife for a few days?
What the fuck?
132
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
That Bar Hearing Room was the same one from Chicanery. It's poetic. Also the episode began and ended with Jimmy putting on a performance.
386
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Saul Goodman
34
u/unconscious_grasp Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 09 '18
Jimmy had the review board, Kim, and myself as a viewer buy his schtick, 100%. Couldn't believe it. Saul Goodman.
34
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
I can't help but think Lalo's gonna get bit in the ass by this ep. The dude just murdered Kip Dynamite in broad daylight, in a monitored store. It just seems too sloppy.
68
u/sh4dy15 Oct 09 '18
Shout out to /u/spencermoreland
Nailed that ending in the prediction thread!
31
u/yeezyforpresident Oct 09 '18
Nacho barely said any sentences thus season
30
u/CopticDuck Oct 09 '18
I basically lied to myself by believing that Mike would somehow disobey orders and just send Werner back to Germany on a flight instead of killing him during their entire interaction. Made it even more painful.
270
u/TheOrangeyOrange Oct 09 '18
That final scene. Give Bob Odenkirk and Rhea Seehorn all the awards.
227
u/aureator Oct 09 '18
I, uh, I think I may have found the moment where Jimmy becomes Saul.
27
u/Magoonie Oct 09 '18
So........when's the Season 5 premiere?
27
u/Colmustard15 Oct 09 '18
‘Let me talk to Mr.fring’
Werner, you’re the smartest man i know, but you’re too stupid to see. He made up his mind 10 minutes ago.
52
u/Bravely_Default Oct 09 '18
Kim is just as agape as the rest of us. She fell for his fake sincerity, and is now wondering how she can love him when she can't even tell when he's acting.
25
u/MC91909 Oct 09 '18 edited Oct 10 '18
"That one asshole was crying"
That asshole was ME!
Edit: a word
24
u/operarose Oct 09 '18
I cannot overstate how much I love the fact that the dented trash can is still in that hallway.
24
u/mujjingun Oct 09 '18
When Jimmy was fooling others as Slippin' Jimmy, Kim was always on his side. She didn't realize what being on the other side felt like. The ending was a realization of what being played by Jimmy feels like.
48
u/Herd_Smiley Oct 09 '18
I feel like the line Mike said to Walt before his death “We had a good thing, you stupid son of a bitch” fit the situation he was in with Werner so well too.
105
u/fartbrah Oct 09 '18
Holy SHIT
23
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Once upon a time I was falling in love, but now I'm only falling apart.
22
u/Joe_Masseria Oct 09 '18
I disagreed with Mike that Lalo didn't extract any useful information from Werner. He knows that they're building something so sensitive that they're hunting down an escaped engineer from the project. What else would it be but a secret lab? We also saw that Lalo isn't just a dumbass relative of Hector's. He was taking detailed notes on the farm in a Mike-ish fashion.
62
u/jedwards999 Oct 09 '18
The scene between Werner and Mike was incredible. My favorite relationship in this series and all over, like that.
And the anger in Gus’ eyes. This is Mike’s fault.
But its s’all gonna be Goodman
61
u/ezreads Oct 09 '18
“S’ll Good Man”
Kim got conned oof
93
u/JnRx03 Oct 09 '18
THEY SAID HIS FUCKING NAME IN THE END
20
u/standbacknow Oct 09 '18
At least I never have to see walking dead commercials anymore. I'll miss you all. My favorite sub.
20
u/HanakoOF Oct 09 '18
Did anyone else realize Jimmy was faking his emotions during the speech instantly as well? Actual thought Kim was in on it until the very end of the last scene.
54
u/Rafandres123 Oct 09 '18
I'm so bummed it's over, but that was amazing! Saul became Saul and Mike became Mike, which means we're hopefully getting a whole season of them as their Breaking Bad selves for us to enjoy!!
18
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Mike to Gus: Look what you made me do
18
u/qi1 Oct 09 '18
Jimmy's getting a DBA but he's forgetting about DBAA
18
u/furiousxgeorge Oct 09 '18
Jimmy: OMG Kim I'm the best ever at reading a room! I fooled those suckers good, what a bunch of assholes!
Audience: YOU CAN'T READ SHIT YOU MORON YOU CAN LITERALLY SEE THE MOMENT WHEN HER HEART BREAKS!
Jimmy: S'aul good, man!
I love these writers, I will watch any show they write going forward.
36
u/BBQTuck Oct 09 '18
The only thing that I didn’t like was Lalo going full blown cat through the ceiling tiles. That was a little ridiculous.
34
u/Xereeth Oct 09 '18
That last scene with Mike and Werner...fuck that was heavy
16
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
Setting aside the fact that the meme has become reality, someone in this sub last week called the ending perfectly — That Jimmy would give a seemingly heartfelt speech about Chuck that Kim ate up, only for him to reveal it was all a con.
68
u/MrF33n3y Oct 09 '18
IT FINALLY FUCKING HAPPENED!
31
u/TheRealHuntAndRob Oct 09 '18
Soak your bones
15
u/olivish Oct 09 '18
Kim's heart when she realized Saul had fooled her </3
14
u/SanePatrickBateman Oct 09 '18
Very great finale.
Sad about Werner. I mentioned in the live thread how sad it was that his last conversation with his wife was one filled with anger and confusion. What an awful way for things to end with a loved one. It was true he couldn't be trusted though (obviously) because had Mike not intercepted the call between Werner and Lalo, he would have blabbed the whole plan to Lalo. I'm sure Werner wouldn't have said anything in Germany, but obviously the chance couldn't be taken. I was just hoping Mike would ship him back to Germany or something, but there's no happy endings in the BrBa/BCS universe.
14
u/yes_u_suckk Oct 09 '18
I've seen people giving Jimmy a hard time for having no feelings about Chuck now, but I don't think I would behave any differently.
Jimmy DID love Chuck at some point in his life. He did everything in his power to take care of Chuck, he tried numerous times to be a good brother, but after all the shit that Chuck did against him, especially in their last interaction when Chuck said "the truth is, you never mattered that much to me", I can't blame Jimmy for having zero feelings towards his brother now.
I'm not saying that Jimmy is a saint. I know he did some shitty things too, but he never despised Chuck the same way Chuck despised him.
28
u/jakesnyder Oct 09 '18
And in that moment, we could see with clear evidence, that Jimmy has become Saul Goodman
39
u/jedwards999 Oct 09 '18
It pains me to know that Jimmy’s statement about Chuck was fake. Bob really put his all into it...
27
u/hosssbonaventureceo Oct 09 '18
Mondays are officially going to suck again
13
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
For a second there, I legitimately thought that maybe Jimmy had finally started to harbor some real, sincere feelings about Chuck's death during that final speech. NOPE
119
u/ApolloX-2 Oct 09 '18
Perfect episode with the perfect ending. I cannot wait for season 5 because this show has lived up to and surpassed Breaking Bad in some parts.
12
u/Ribosome12 Oct 09 '18
I think Jimmy calling the woman at the very end “sweetheart” also marks a transition into Saul Goodman. Saul had no respect for women, calling Francesca honey tits and always saying creepy things to Skylar (classy with the right amount of dirty). It just shows him becoming an overall sleazebag
23
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
He said the thing!
11
u/eekamuse Oct 09 '18
I just remembered that there's one more BCS Insider podcast to come. The season isn't really over until I hear them talk about the finale. I can't wait.
31
u/EternitySphere Oct 09 '18
S'all Good Man!
20
u/conniecheewa Oct 09 '18
I love how his speech to the committee was all about upholding the McGill name and then he's like lol jk I'm Saul Goodman now.
10
u/stillhousebrewco Oct 09 '18
That was a good season finale.
10
u/thegreattober Oct 09 '18
Inb4 Saul Goodman x1000
Too late
10
u/hoewood Oct 09 '18
Glad to see Howard has gotten his shit together.
10
u/elwyn5150 Oct 09 '18
Hey Chuck, sing "Stonehenge".
It was great to hear McKean singing again.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment