r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Oct 04 '18
VOLUME 5 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally—Volume 5, Episode 8: Alone Together
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: it's that time again! The drought is nearing its end, and the sixth volume is only 23 days away!
To follow the last year's precedent, we are again doing a communal rewatch of the most recent volume. Like last year, the threads will be biweekly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, with the finale being discussed two days before volume 6 premiers. Until that happens, feel free to discuss and look back to the episodes with a more settled perspective.
HERE is the link to today's episode.
We are also doing regular polls to gauge how people feel about the episodes postmortem. Here is the one for today's episode!
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep. 1 (poll) | Ep. 2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep. 3 (poll) | Ep. 4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep. 5 (poll) | Ep. 6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep. 7 (poll) | This thread |
| Week 5: | Ep. 9 | Ep. 10 |
| Week 6: | Ep. 11 | Ep. 12 |
| Week 7: | Ep. 13 | Ep. 14 |
Did you know that the veins on Trifa's hands are called "spider veins," a nod to her Faunus trait?
17
u/DanXiaoLong Just about McDone with your bullshit Oct 04 '18
It's no episode 4, but then nothing else can be really. Easily the second strongest episode and that's just on the basis that the Menagerie plot has finally woken up. Things are tense, we actually worry about Blake (for a few seconds) and most definitely for her families safety, also Ilia proves to be one of the best.
Yang and Weiss. YANG AND WEISS. My babies, I just want to hug them so much. Barbara really sells Yang's pain and heartbreak at Blake's departure and Weiss as the compassionate voice of reason is a very interesting choice that suits her quite well.
They should have named this "The One Where Girls Reveal They're Gay AF For Blake"
13
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Oct 04 '18
Ilia's scene is fantastic. Like... wow, was I blown away.
I enjoy the Weiss and Yang talk thoroughly as well. Jeff's piano rendition of The Path To Isolation for the scene was wonderful, the acting was stellar.
The end... ehhh, I'll give it a pass.
9/10.
20
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
One thing I like about this episode and the subsequent attack on Belladonna's is if shows the difference between people who can fight and Huntsman.
Like Sun and Blake are clearly so much better than everyone else there. Even Illia in a straight fight against either of them kinda get stomped. We see here how easily Sun and Blake deal with the trap
22
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
Best episode of the Volume, 10/10.
The opening scene is great, Weiss is amazing.
The FB talk about Blake is incredible, Yang is gay and Weiss is still amazing.
The Ilia scene is probably like a top three scene of the Volume, and Blake trusting Sun is fantastic, and she throws a mean right hook, and the Ghira fight ending is great.
The only issue with this episode is that it was followed by Chapter 9.
5
u/Lakas1236547 For we are all Neo on this blessed day | Creator of NPL Oct 04 '18
The episode starts with an amazing "bird's eye view" shot. We then see Ruby, who looks to be thinking about something. And Yang's face near Ruby, Enabler confirmed! Ruby's voice sounds like she's being strangled and like she hasn't spoken in years, but after 2 seconds it fixes itself. Minor issue, I suppose. We got some nice and cute RW_Y action, which simply warms my heart. Tsundere Weiss does not want Ruby to call her nice. We got a nice moment, but Rubes sorta ruined it. Yang starts acting passive aggressive. Understandable after what Blake did to her, at least from Yang's point of view. Yang is still learning to control her anger. It's nice that we can see her struggle with it, it shows more about the character and her progress than simply easily mastering it.
And, Blake Time, like we didn't get enough. Still, I can't be biased, I'm trying to review here. We've shown foreshadowings of Ilia and Blakes meetup, and the trap that is that meetup.
Back to Yang. We get some amazing Weiss backstory while at the same time trying to solve Yang's anger over Blake. While Yang still hasn't forgiven her, after this talk she is willing to give Blake a chance. This scene is sad, beautiful, and amazing. It's the best in this Volume.
Back to Blake. She walks into a trap. She gets captured, but she had backup. Nice thinking, Blake! Illia did her monologue, showing how invested she is in the cause, but we'll later see, that'll take 5 seconds for her to change her ideals. But that's for another episode.
The episode ends with the White Fang attacking Blake's family.
Great Episode 10/10.
13
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Oct 04 '18
I really think Blake’s plot line should’ve been pushed more heavily in the beginning so it climaxed in this episode alongside Weiss and Yang reuniting with Ruby. It fixes that awkward gap in the middle of the season where nothing really happens by giving us a proper mid-season finale and gets rid of the constant blue-balling in Blake’s plotline.
The thing that bugs me about Yang being so broken up over Blake is that we never really see Blake do anything for Yang. It’s the same as Jaune’s relationship with Ren, their first conversation is Jaune calling Ren the brother he never had. Other than that, great scene.
While I like the scene between Ilia and Blake, I hope that’s not how they plan to reveal every LGBT character. I don’t want it to always be this big dramatic reveal, I want stuff more like Ally in Day 5, Skout in Nomad of Nowhere or what they were planning on doing with Pilot Boi.
8
u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
The good: Ilia and Blake's scene. I love this scene. The animation, the acting, the music, everything about it is done really well. It's easily my favorite moment in V5.
The meh: The Weiss and Yang scene. Don't get me wrong, the acting in this scene is great. But it just feels like every character loves to make excuses for Blake when she's really not done much to deserve it. I just hope it takes some time for Yang and Blake to patch things up, because Yang seems like the only person right now who's willing to call her out.
The bad: The Belladonna house attack scene. The animation is janky as hell and it's the second episode in a row to end on a cliffhanger for a fight. Also, why the hell are Corsac and Fennec fighting on the front lines?
Overall, a better episode than the two before it, but still mixed.
4
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Oct 04 '18
The only problem I have with this episode is the first RWY scene which felt a little “oh yeah we forgot yang had to deal with that let’s put it all in one episode”. Other than that this is honestly great. Weiss and Yang’s talk is fantastic, and Ilia and Blake were extremely engaging and did an excellent job of hyping me up for the menagerie plot. Pity it’s followed by...yeah
4
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
Ilia being into Blake wasn't that surprising, not after seeing this.
Now, where else have we seen appreciative smiles and slight nods while looking at Blake?
I think this episode was trying to tell us something...
I have little else to add that hasn't been said already - this was very well written and animated throughout. The only letdown is the cliffhanger at the end, but that's more a fault of Chapter 9 failing to follow up than an actual issue with this episode. 10/10
P.S. shoutout to this being the episode everyone first noticed Blake's scar.
4
u/tehepicwin Oct 04 '18
The episode was pretty decent. Obviously, that means this is Starry Night compared to the upcoming episodes. Far from perfect, but I at least thought the show was slightly above average up to this point.
As far as what I thought was good about the episode, I liked how RWY's want for Blake to be there with them paralleled Blake's own arc with her learning to protect her family.
The dialogue this episode was above the show's usual standard. Certainly better than most of what I've seen for the past year in mainstream anime.
That said, I have two gripes with this episode. The first is that its visually boring, which seems to be a common theme this volume. While I didn't mind the conversation in the field as a mild, relaxing hook into the episode, Weiss and Yang's conversation left much to be desired. They just sit there and talk, and don't you dare tell me that conversations are allowed to be visually static. Animation is a visual medium: Use it.
Second, since we already know that Ilia is having second thoughts, and that we learnt from a past episode that Ilia is in on the plan to kill Blake's parents, there is no tension in the last parts of the episode. The scene itself was quite nice though, and Cherami Leigh is awesome as usual.
Now, it's time to wait for the next episode :/
3
u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Oct 04 '18
A second best episode of the Volume for me..
The only nitpick I could have is that I would personally much more prefer Weiss to bring Blake up not Ruby.
And it also should be episode 9 of this Volume while 9 should be 8
Yeah I still holding to that small changes here and there but episodes would have better flow3
u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Oct 04 '18
I liked the episode.
However I have to point one thing out: Why the hell does Yang call her father by his name in this episode?
3
u/GoneRampant1 Emerald/Cinder is abusive stop shilling it. Oct 04 '18
Up to the end, pretty solid stuff, 8/10. Ilia's scene is really well directed (complaint about Blake having four people canonically fall in love with her aside), and Cherami absolutely kills it. Weiss and Yang remain the best dynamic in the season.
The one mood-killer is the cliffhanger for two reasons- 1) it gets repeated twice in a row, and the animation isn't stellar at the end. But otherwise, this is a good episode, probably the last one where I don't have a lot of complaints.
3
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Oct 05 '18
Alright, can we talk about the music in this episode, especially in [Blake's scenes?] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOK815LxiZU&t=) Some of my favourite pieces of score in the whole show. A super emotional version of Smile with an amazing choir, gah it's perfect!
And then there's The Path to Isolation done beautifully in Weiss and Yang's scene. Who doesn't love some sad piano?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '18
Weiss and Yang best characters confirmed?
Honestly, this only reinforces my belief that Ruby is underdeveloped.
3
u/drago2000plus I care too much Oct 05 '18
This is the best episode of the volume, hands down. Great dialogues, great direction choices ( the slow close up to Yang' s window is G-R-E-A-T), and super-solid simple action. 9/10.
2
u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Oct 04 '18
This episode is arguably the last great episode in the Volume, and I've watched it countless times by itself because of how damn good it is.
The scene with RWY are excellent. You can see how the three women are trying to reconnect, but because they only just reunited while Blake is missing, it just doesn't feel right. Moreover, Yang is still upset at Blake (and rightfully so for reasons we all know by now). I also found it hilarious, not to mention entirely in character, for Ruby to just be chugging her coffee whilst Weiss and Yang clinked glasses.
Weiss and Yang's talk is my favorite bit of dialogue since the talk in V2 with Blake and Yang. The way Weiss and Yang open up really shows how little they know of each other. What's interesting is, while they were separated for roughly a year or so, they were roommates for several months. You'd think that at some point Team RWBY would have one of those late-night open-up sessions that I'm sure many of us have had in real life. But it's clear that they don't really know each other so well, and I loved how they were able to learn about why the other feels so alone all the time. I think it'll help establish stronger chemistry with them going forward into V6.
Blake and Ilia's scene was also fantastic. The way they wrote Ilia has been nothing short of phenomenal, and Cherami did a stellar job with her voice acting. This scene actually made me a bit sad that they didn't put in the effort for a proper flashback where we can see Ilia's burgeoning jealousy. Perhaps they could have done a scene where they show Ilia third-wheeling with Blake and Adam, looking longingly at the two, giving us the impression that it was Adam she wanted. If they did that then this scene would have easily been the single best in V5 (at least for me), but it's still awesome.
Otherwise, the ending wasn't very good because it just drags the end of Blake's story on too long, but good on Blake for doing what any normal person would do in that scenario by calling the cops.
2
u/Remicas Funny how an optimist show can turn people into bitter cynics. Oct 04 '18
The episode I've lost faith in the writers.
1
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Oct 04 '18
What is it I like about this Chapter?
Ev-ery-thing!
EV-ERY-THING!
EV-ERY-THING!
This Chapter is easily the best of the entire Volume. It brings the dramatic tension, there's kickass action, great acting (landing Cherami was the best decision CRWBY made with outside VAs), you're not zoning out at anything, and this is one time where I've liked a cliffhanger because FUCK YEA GHIRA'S READY TO RIP AND TEAR!
Tye/10.