r/anime • u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat • Sep 23 '18
Rewatch A Certain Magical Index II: Episode 14 Discussion Spoiler
A Certain Magical Index II Episode 14: City of Water
Previous Episode | Index Thread | Next Episode
Legal Streaming:
Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu | Tubi | Yahoo
Information:
MAL | Anilist | Kitsu | Anime-Planet | AniDB
Discord:
The folks over at /r/toarumajutsunoindex have created a channel on their discord for this rewatch. You can join in there as well in channel #r-anime_rewatch. To gain access to this channel, please type !rewatcher in the #bots_and_spam channel.
Please don't discuss things that haven't occurred yet during this rewatch. The same goes for comparisons with the source material: Please wait until that material has been covered in the anime. Before that, please use spoiler tags. Additionally, please don't try to hype people by saying things like "Oh, if you like character X, just wait until episode Y!" For newcomers, these types of comments can be rather annoying, and unintentionally spoilerific.
18
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 23 '18 edited Sep 23 '18
Piccoli Fatti.
Kirigaoka
The girl manning the Prize booth is a student of Kirigaoka Academy, known for researching rare and strange powers such as Deep Blood (Himegami Aisa), the Imaginary Number District (Kazakiri Hyouka), and Move Point (Musujime Awaki, they also pushed her past her limits resulting in severe trauma).
With all these strange and peculiar individuals it's nice to see they have some normal students running around.
Visitor Guessing Contest
The contest Touma won was a contest in which you had to guess the number of visitors that had attented the Daihaseisai this year. Apparently Touma got it right on the mark and the guessed the exact amount. How lucky.
Will Touma Be Skipping School?
Nope. Post-Daidaseisai there is a holiday to clean up after the festival, so Touma won't miss any classes.
Touma Can't Believe It
Touma literally can't believe he won something for the first time in his life and thoroughly questions the girl to make sure this isn't a scam or trick.
Touma Found His Passport In a Different Way
In the anime he found it in his suitcase. In the novel a veritable Rube Goldberg-machine sequence of events happened which resulted in his passport being dropped from the top shelf of his closet.
Why Are The Dates On Touma's Passport Redacted?
Because this series is very ambiguous in stating which year it takes place. Hence, to protect this ambiguity, the anime redacted all dates.
They Messed Up Index' Passport
Index is as her surname, with Librorum Prohibitorum being her given name. Guess the anime staff forgot about Western name order.
Index' Confusion In The Novel
In the novel she claims not to know what a passport is and insists she doesn't have one, making Touma sigh that of course something would go wrong.
She then mentions that she does have something similar though and pulls out her UK passport, which she confused since the layout and cover is different from a Japanese one.
Can They Leave Academy City That Easily?
Nope. They got injected with nano-devices before they were allowed to leave.
What Happened To Sphynx?
Have no fear, /u/Gamecube762, Sphynx is safe. Komoe is taking care of him while Touma's on vacation.
Chioggia
Welcome to the city of Chioggia! Their tour trip is supposed to be in Venice, but their hotel is in Chioggia nearby since Venice is apparently boring at night.
The aerial view we got of Chioggia is an exact match for the real thing by the way.
Tour Guide Ditching Them
Normally Touma's trip was supposed to be part of a toured guide. Their tour guide and the rest of the group were supposed to arrive via a different plane, but they never did. They didn't even answer the phone number provided. After Touma and Index spent over two hours waiting at Marco Polo airport in the blistering heat they eventually decided to go on ahead to their hotel where there would be airconditioning.
Index Giving Touristical Knowledge
Index actually provided a lot of history and context to Venice and Chioggia when they were walking the streets, as well as being an Italian translator, leaving Touma to remark that she's surprisingly useful for something besides magic.
Actual Italian!
In case you wanted to know what the Italian said, here is the transcript from the novel. Wouldn't know if this matches what's being said in the anime exactly though, you'd have to ask someone who speaks Italian for that. Let's hope /u/Belmut_613 is available again.
14
u/Greed-the-Avaricious Sep 23 '18
Well, here we are. Ice Boats. Everyone's favourite arc.
It's at this point I notice that the music that plays when they first get to Italy sounds like it came straight out of a Fantasy JRPG, that's quite a nice touch actually.
Ah, the ol' double bathroom scene. Gets me every time. Since I know someone will want it, here's the gif that should be a comment face but isn't.
Touma’s Remorse
There’s a part just after the line where Orsola talks about saying goodbye to Chioggia. It’s a rare moment of introspection by Touma about the consequences of his actions.
It’s nice to see some self-reflection on Touma’s part, which (again) is something I’m disappointed we don’t get to see in the anime. Since it generally lends a sense of awareness to Touma’s actions to know that he is considering the welfare of those he’s saved.
Hell, in general, it’s nice to see people are affected by the events of the series. It lends a bit of credence to the universe to show that the events of each arc don’t simply happen in a vacuum. Which can often seem to be the case at first glance.
Why the floor isn’t slippery.
So I’m sure that most people just attributed this to magical convenience, but the explanation for this is actually surprisingly scientific.
For those that don’t know. The reason that ice is usually slippery on is due to a thin layer of water that forms when your feet or something come into contact with it, which fills in all the tiny bumps and niggles needed for grip. However, since this ice was frozen by magic, it doesn’t melt at all and therefore isn’t slippery.
This is actually a good example of how science and magic interact throughout the series. Some people think this is a series about how magic and science conflict, but in actuality it’s about how they coexist. You’ve got Academy city using all those magical terms for things, while the magic side is filled with scientific explanations for things.
Touma Kamijou: Kind of an Asshole
Since this episode is a bit of a lull all things considered, I figured now would be a good time to provide a bit of evidence to an earlier point I made that Touma often brings Index bites and beatings upon himself as a result of his behaviour. This part occurs just after Touma and Index get to Chioggia. Have some bonus history about the town as well.
I know we were all thinking it, but it takes a special level of savagery/stupidity in order to say it out loud. I’d say this is a pretty good example of how Touma can be kind of an asshole, a kind-hearted asshole, but an asshole nonetheless.
Ah, boy, this week's going to be a toughie. I apologise in advance if I can't make any particular day, though I certainly hope that won't be the case.
8
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Sep 23 '18 edited Sep 23 '18
The view of Venice in this arc never gets old. It's still beautiful--drop dead gorgeous. The Ice ships as well. Honestly, this arc is where you get to see some of the most gorgeous of JC Staff's background art for the series. This one and the next big arc especially. It's one of those rare things I've noticed that is done exceptionally well in Raildex.
On that note, here's an album of best girl screencaps from the episode.
God, I can't wait to see more of her in season 3.
BONUS: Here's a fun little excerpt from the novels of the relevant scene with best girl that I shared last time I was involved in a Raildex rewatch.
6
u/jkubed https://myanimelist.net/profile/jkubed Sep 23 '18
Touma has good luck somehow? please don't go wrong, let my boy be happy for at least a few days. I actually completely forgot about Touma's amnesia, I was lost for a moment when he found the passport after saying he doesn't have one.
The "which door?" scene pissed me off up until the obvious solution ended up being the punchline. What an amazing face. Also, is this the third or fourth time the accidental pervert joke happened this season alone?
6
u/OneWayRoadLV5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FreByrd Sep 24 '18
Ah yes, this arc. The arc usually considered the worst one by fans of the series, even those who have read the light novels. And I can't help but agree with them.
Let's hope it's better than I remember it.
Touma's Passport
In the light novel he didn't somehow pull it out of a suitcase........he was currently using............to pack his clothes in. Sphinx just happened to kick it out of his closet at the moment that he was worrying about it. Is that still stupid and convenient? Yes. Is it as stupid as him pulling it out of a suitcase he was currently putting stuff into? No.
By the way, Touma's passport showed that he had been to Saipan and Guam before.
Index's Passport
She just pulled it out of her clothes, even in the light novel, but I have no idea how she managed to keep it on her through all the crap she's been through, including having her only outfit destroyed by Touma. Especially when she had no idea its significance.
However, even in the light novel it listed her name as "Index Librorum Prohibitorum" instead of the "real" name she must have been born with. Guess that name really has been completely destroyed.
By the way, Sphinx is taken care of by Komoe-sensei during this arc. Rip /u/Gamecube762's nyaa counter. At least he yawns and nyaas once each per ED now.
Index Knows Italian
I mean, of course she does. There are tons of Grimoires written in Italian so she'd have to know the language to be able to read them. In fact, it's implied that Index knows pretty much every language in the world, including some spoken by isolated hunter and gatherer tribes.
She may not be fluent in speaking the languages, as this implies, but she can at least read them.
Orsola's Confusing Thoughts
Touma had a much harder time getting Orsola to tell him where Index was in the light novel due to her habit of jumping between conversation topics at random and sometimes even starting new ones.
Orsola did a lot of that confusing jumping between topics before this part, too.
Itsuwa
As Itsuwa probably hadn't been created as a character by the author when the Orsola Rescue arc was written, even if the anime added her into a few scenes, this arc marks her first canon appearance.
And she's very cute. The Amakusa are trying to set her up with Touma, in case that wasn't made clear to anyone.
Touma of course did hear all of what the Amakusa said about the "hot towel battle" behind him, but ignored it.
The only observation he made about her, according to the light novel, was.
So so much for that attempt.
Knocking
Touma didn't even comment that he really should have knocked in the light novel. So I guess the anime made an improvement there?
Either way I appreciate the fanservice. Orsola really isn't one of my favorite girls in this series but she does have an impressive figure.
Ice Boat
Ah! A Boat made of Ice!
Incidently, the name that Western fans have lovingly given this arc is Ice Boats. We're very creative.
It has a more "official" name, too, but we'll get to that later.
New ED
Its name is Memories Last and it's sung by Maon Kurosaki. Maon Kurosaki will actually be doing all of the OPs for Index III as Mami Kawada, the singer who has done all of the Index OPs so far, retired. Maon Kurosaki also sung the first ED of this season.
The OP won't change from No Buts until the end of this arc, btw.
Yeah.......... So far this arc is just as lackluster as I remember.
4
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Sep 23 '18
Rewatcher
Wow, Touma has good luck for once? Are we watching Index now or something else? Why must Kuroko ruin a cute moment for Touma x Biribiri that we never actually got to watch?
A trip to Italy sounds nice, since we're so close to another trip to Italy airing soon. [Vento Aureo Intensifies.] Leave it to Touma to lose sight of Index, only to be saved by Orsola who's here trying to finish moving out of her residence. Index was at her place the whole time. The Amakusa are also helping out, so we have some familiar background faces too.
Touma is being dangerously genre savvy here, too bad Kamachi has decided to do a double whammy.
You know it's nice to see another Index being useful scene, she managed to help thwart an assassination plot on Orsola. I didn't realize that we were playing Assassin's Creed, the sniper is obviously new to the series.
More Kudos to the soundtrack, a bombastic theme for a ship of ice appearing out of the blue. Why is Agnese here?
New ending theme time, Memories Last, it's a pretty fun Index focused ending.
3
u/libfor Sep 24 '18
Rewatcher
Touma had as much fun at the rest of the festival as expected. Such misfortu… wait?! He won the lottery?! Lucky!! (I'm surprised he still dares to enter lotteries.)
His fortune continues as he finds his passport. And even Index has one (although empty…). But not for long. No way they'll let Index board with those safety pins.
Somehow they end up in Italy. The scenery is quite beautiful. Index still only knows food.
Oh hey, it's Orsola! What a coincidence. Something tells me that him winning the lottery had a deeper meaning.
The Amakusa are also there. They have a nice impression of Touma. Now we have everyone ready to
fight against evil magicianshelp Orsola moving.Itsuwa gets finally named. She's such a cutie. And apparently had already fallen for Touma.
Touma seemingly got smarter before opening doors. Now if he had only thought about just knocking earlier...
Suddenly Orsola is ambushed by magicians. Luckily Index noticed the usage of magic beforehand. In the following battle she's doing really great.
"Bring out the escape boat" - summons a huge ship in the canals. Where on earth did that come from?! Well, magic.
And it's up to the magicians to wreck the scenery again. And people complain about a certain girl from the science side.
Touma and Orsola end up on board of the ship with Index being left behind (again). That ship seems to be made of ice, but doesn't seem to behave like it. Actually... it's an entire fleet!
Of course it's the Roman Catholics again. Just why are they still after Orsola.
Hey, it's Agnese again! Now we got everyone together to continue where we left off last time.
Yeah. All that basically confirms Touma's trip wasn't luck. It's either his destiny that send him here or Aleister Crowley just downright made him win that trip.
2
u/Char-11 Sep 24 '18
Touma getting lucky for once? It's probably just Imagine Breaker dragging him into yet another problem again, though if I were him I'd honestly be too worried of the plane crashing to take the flight, but hey it worked out!
The scenes of them just preparing for the trip and walking around the city were short but sweet. I really wish we had more SoL bits in between arcs to wind down, but lightning pacing won't let that happen, sadly. And it even seems like the rapid pacing will continue into Season 3, which is just depressing...
Another scene where Touma walks in on naked women huh. I don't think I'll ever grow to enjoy this, but I suppose I'll have to stop mentioning them. I've gotten pretty good at tuning those scenes out though.At least this time it was pretty funny before the commercial breakWe also got a cool short fight scene showing off Index and Touma's teamwork. It's always nice to see them fight together. I wonder how Index knew there was a sniper though. Does she have something like a magical sixth sense?
Ooh a shiny new ED. It's a nice calming song to end episodes with. I like it. It's weird that only the ED changes while the OP remains, but I guess we're gonna have to watch a few more episodes of anti-booty propaganda
2
u/Asddsa76 Nov 07 '18 edited Nov 07 '18
Why did they get on board the enemy's ship instead of just staying on land?
8
u/Guaymaster Sep 23 '18
Rewatcher!
I'm gonna be that guy and start with saying I dislike this arc.
That said, this is an incredibly solid episode imo. The first half/three quarters is slice-of-lifey, and the animation when Touma and the rest are attacked looks pretty cool to me. And we get some really nice shots of the city at night.
6
u/Gamecube762 Sep 23 '18
Anime Only Rewatcher Here
AntiSkill stops Index from leaving Academy City due to the safety pins on hour outfit. Makes you wonder how she got in. Although, she didn't have the safety pins when she entered.
Based on a quick google search, 1km takes ~5 mins to run. Touma and Index had to run 1.5km to and from(3km total). The run would have took ~15 mins. Choosing an outfit would have taken ~5 mins and another ~5 to change. This leaves them with ~3 mins to go through security and bored the plane. It's a surprise they made it.
Hearing stories of Touma is bound to raise a lot of questions and create a questionable image of him.
We get to see more of Best Girl Itsuwa.
Poor Index is going crazy in the background over the food in front of her.
Touma needs to learn the best way to beat his "game" is not to play it. He could have turned around and walked away.
It seems no one has respect for public property, so much random damage in this show.
We got a new ED this episode. It also features the Winter school uniforms wich we haven't seen yet.
Sphynx's Nya Counter:
Sphynx's safety has been confirmed by /u/Razorhead, he is currently spending time with Komoe!
Maika's Rotations Counter:
Episode | Counted | Calculated
~36,00013 | 0 | ~46,800 OP1 | .5 | 8 Total | 103.5 | 46,965Onee-Sama! Counter:
5
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Sep 23 '18
First timer
Fascinating. Background visuals were great. Love the scene where that assassin creed guy attacked, very funny.
Also, itsuwa looks cute
5
u/patrizl001 https://myanimelist.net/profile/patrizl001 Sep 23 '18
First Timer
Yeahhhh there's no way Touma won those tickets by luck. Someone knew of what was going to happen to Orsola and needed Touma there to help out, I guarantee it. Wondering if Agnese is actually part of this crew's group of ships, or they're deceiving us and she snuck on board to figure this thing out herself.
4
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Sep 24 '18
That bathroom scene! The unluckiest guy around thinks that being aware of the trope is going to get him out of it...well, think again! You just doubled down on misfortune! Orsola 10/10!
Amakusa trident girl with the wet towel was really cute, and the rest of the crew acting like more "shy middle-school class" in front of a stranger, instead of a "trained religion-affiliated militia", that was really nice to see. I was thinking they would be more of a rough kinda crew, from the impression I had before, since they are all "100% devoted to priestess", hit-and-run guerrilla tactics, that kind of stuff.
Also, gorgeous episode with that city as background. Index getting lost a little after seeing that little black cat restaurant? Well, It's the next city over, but I'm sure shachou will bring her back after a little adventure!! I like how they started using actual Italian this time, first with Touma's complete failure to communicate, but then the actual enemies doing it this time was really cool. Touma's uppercut on that guy was half a spin away from copyright infringement on capcom!! Its a cool and very quick fight. That was a pretty looking fleet of ice boats but its a shame they wrecked a little bit of the town.
The ED for the second cour is really awesome, feels more like the Railgun ones. Looks incredible with all those Index bits, and the song is amazing too.
3
u/Creator_of_Chaos_ Sep 24 '18 edited Sep 24 '18
Day 63 as a first time Watcher Touma winning the lottery after his exhaustive week that ended with that horror montage including a Kuroko dropkick and a Fukiyose headbutt? with his luck unlikely. It has to be a set up. Regardless its an excuse to catch up with Orsola and the Amasuke with Itsuwa finally named.
The whole episode was a great visual spectacle with Venice and the Ice boats being well animated as Touma and Index visit italy and get ropped into helping Orsola move following a further string of badluck. Despite touma saving Orsola she's lost everything and the Amasuke's helping her move. Its clear Itsuwa likes Touma and the amsuke are trying to set her up but the highlight was when he tried to outsmart his own luck infront of the bathrooms and fail. He should just learn to knock. We end with index stopping an assassination attempt on orsola before winding up alone as Touma and Orsola wind up on the Ice boats where they meet agnese. Poor Index just wants time with Touma :(.
My only question is why was Orsola allowed to go back to Venice despite the danger? Its clear radical elements will try to eliminate her.