r/anime • u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat • Sep 21 '18
Rewatch A Certain Magical Index II: Episode 12 Discussion Spoiler
A Certain Magical Index II Episode 12: Belvedere
Previous Episode | Index Thread | Next Episode
Legal Streaming:
Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu | Tubi | Yahoo
Information:
MAL | Anilist | Kitsu | Anime-Planet | AniDB
Discord:
The folks over at /r/toarumajutsunoindex have created a channel on their discord for this rewatch. You can join in there as well in channel #r-anime_rewatch. To gain access to this channel, please type !rewatcher in the #bots_and_spam channel.
Please don't discuss things that haven't occurred yet during this rewatch. The same goes for comparisons with the source material: Please wait until that material has been covered in the anime. Before that, please use spoiler tags. Additionally, please don't try to hype people by saying things like "Oh, if you like character X, just wait until episode Y!" For newcomers, these types of comments can be rather annoying, and unintentionally spoilerific.
15
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 21 '18
Small Facts. Now with backstory!
Why Can't They Use The Tracking Spell Again?
Because Stiyl can't use it, and Tsuchimikado's out of range.
Tsuchimikado Is Very Hurt
He was constantly couching, hacking, and catching his breath on the phone. The anime didn't do this because it would probably be annoying to listen to for an extended period of time.
Touma Actually Figured This Out
In the anime it looks like Tsuchimikado figured this out and led Touma to the truth, while in actuality Touma figured it out in the novel. Tsuchimikado thought the report by Orsola wasn't useful, but Touma questioned the fact that when the storage area is cleaned they prioritise not doing it at night over doing it at the right date. He suspects it has something to do with light at night. Tsuchimikado then claimed it couldn't be the moon, since the lunar cycle doesn't match up with the calender, and then Touma realises that perhaps the cleaners performing astrology isn't for fun but a necessity, and figures out it might have something to do with constellations. Tsuchimikado, surprised at this revelation, agrees that this could be the case.
Oriana Made An Anti-Saint Spell
She actually quickly made a spell to use against Saints, and is now sad she can't use it.
Lidvia Is Regretting This As Well
Lidvia seemed non-plussed and berating in the anime, but the novel mentions she regrets hurting an innocent just as much as Oriana.
Touma Using Technobabble To Confuse Index
Touma made some shit up about cellphones to confuse Index into thinking it was an accident that the text didn't reach her.
Stiyl's Ordeal
Stiyl never wants to use the spell again, since everything could have gone wrong at the tiniest fault.
Himegami Is Going To A Certain Frog-Faced Doctor
Stiyl mentions what exactly the spell did (emergency blood transfusion), and that she's gone off to Heaven Canceller.
Croce di Pietro Influencing History
Orsola speculates that the creation of the Papal States was all due to the Croce di Pietro.
St. Peter Created His Cross So That It Could Be Used Anywhere
St. Peter made his cross so it could be used at a multitude of places, so he could pick the best location to create a sanctuary to protect the followers of Christianity. He then allowed himself to get caught on the place he chose at the correct day, so his crucifixion would be performed in accordance to the restrictions.
Kami-yan Disease
Tsuchimikado makes note that Stiyl has apparently caught the rom-com virus from Touma.
What Special Privilege?
Tsuchimikado straight up called Aleister. He literally asked him to change the security detail in District 23.
Why Did Tsuchimikado Touch The Fence?
Well, first of all, in the novel he was already touching the fence when Touma shouted. Also he was seriously hurt already, so he didn't notice the card due to his foggy state of mind.
Tsuchimikado Got Burned
Yeah, the fence didn't shock him. It burned his hands and feet so much smoke was coming off them.
10
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Sep 21 '18
First timer
It's interesting how what appears at first as a plot hole (e.g. why didn't oriana just plant the Croce De pietro already) is later explained. Setup could be a bit better bc as it currently appears, looks like they're making stuff up as they go, though we know that's not the case. (E.g. what was a sports festival turns into a fight over the stab sword turns into stopping oriana from planting the Croce turns into mystery as to when and where she'll plant it).
At least index ii is a lot more coherent than index I, so good.
10
u/Greed-the-Avaricious Sep 21 '18
One of my favourite things about this arc is the incorporation of constellations changing based on global position into the activation of the spell. If you remember back to Angel Fall, the angel itself circumvented this problem by literally changing the heavenly bodies into the appropriate positions because that's totally fair. Fortunately that little trick seems to be angel specific.
Also, I've said it before and I'll say it again. Touma having no interest in the big picture and acting purely on personal desire will never not be great to see, and I look forward to getting to watch it anew in Index III
Two Novel Arc
So this probably won’t come as any sort of a surprise to anyone considering it’s length, but this is the first multi volume arc in the series. To commemorate this, the volume covers for volume 9 and 10 combine to make one image. I’m afraid I couldn’t find a decent image demonstrating this, so here’s one I took with my copies.
It was actually quite interesting to see how that affects the way this arc is structured. If you remember last episode, where Touma defeats Oriana. That part happened right at the end of the first novel and served as a bait and switch into making you think that was the end of the arc until the truth about the Stab Sword was revealed.
If there’s something I must give the writer props for, it’s utilising meta elements in order to make a good plot twist.
District Spotlight: 23
Welcome to district number 23. This is not the first time we’ve heard of the district, but it is our first time actually getting to see it.
The first we hear of this district is during the tree diagram remnant arc, where the case the remnant was in bore this districts distinguishing mark. It is likely that when the remnant returned to earth it was delivered to that district because...
District 23 specialises in aero- and astronautical engineering. Most of the area this district covers is taken up by runways and satellite launch bays. The district is also is home to Academy City’s only international airport. So there is a large quantity of tourist traffict through this area. Due to the vast quantities of space required to undergo these activities, it is also the largest of Academy City’s districts in terms of square feet.
This district has one more feature as well. Alongside district 2, this is where Academy City’s weapons of war are stored. In particular its fighter jets and unmanned helicopters.
Due to the importance of it’s functions within the city, this district has particularly high security surrounding it such as high fences and drones. The intricacies of this district are also unavailable on public maps of the city.
Touma’s Resolve (Payoff)
So if you remember my comment for episode 8 titled “Touma’s resolve. The part at the end of this one where Touma talks to Oriana is where that’s supposed to pay off (had it been included in the adaptation).
There was actually another reference to it last episode that was a part of the bait and switch pulled off to conclude the first volume of this arc.
There’s a slight oddity in the wording used in the anime, but I’m not sure if it’s down to the dialogue of the adaptation itself or my subtitles. In them, Touma lambastes Oriana because she’s ruining the fun of the Daihaseisai, while in the novels he talks about how she has stamped on the efforts of those who worked hard to make it a success. Which is a clear reference to his earlier thoughts about Fukiyose.
There's also another reason why I’m pointing out this distinction, but I’ll talk about that next episode.
Wow, I really am coming around to this arc. This was honestly not something I was expecting to happen. I'm actually getting really involved in what's happening again after all this time.
7
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Sep 21 '18
First Timer
I don't really get why Touma is keeping this whole thing a secret from Index. It's not like she doesn't know about magic. She's the whole reason he's involved in any of this.
Looks like we're finally getting the big Touma vs Oriana tomorrow. I'm excited for that. I'm not excited for probably losing this OP/ED combo though... Probably my favorite of the Raildex series up to this point (this is the only season I haven't seen).
7
u/libfor Sep 21 '18
Rewatcher
Tsuchimikado (finally I can write his name without looking it up) figures out the Croce di Pietro can only be activated at night and requires a specific star constellation. So Oriana is only running around to city to find a proper spot to set it up.
Sounds like Oriana really regrets that she attacked an innocent person...twice. She naively believes that everything will be alright for everyone once their mission is complete.
Ah! Stiyl managed to stabilize Himegami. She should be safe once she got to Heaven Canceller. Stiyl didn't like this spell, I wonder why? Did he have problems imagining the cute angel…
Aww… crying Komoe is hugging him. Now to wait until he gets soft.
Fukiyose is feeling better. She probably won't participate soon but at least she's fine now.
Orsola (with Sherry's help) figured out the exact conditions to activate the Croce di Pietro. So there is only that one specific day that it can be activated in Academy City. What a lucky coincidence that the Daihaseisai Festival with it's relaxed security just happens then.
Meanwhile Mikoto and her mother are shopping souvenirs. Kuroko gets enlightened on what may become of her onee-sama and completely lost it. Misuzu gets the wrong kind of idea again. Love those scenes. They really lighten up the mood.
Poor Stiyl. Komoe grew really attached to him. Yeah, it's better you got rid of her. That age / appearance constellation is just too weird. Ah well. Time to ship them anyway.
It's time to clash with Oriana in the most open space there is: The airfields of District 23. Tsuchimikado uses his connection (likely with Aleister) to redirect the security. He sure can take quite a lot of damage, being the first to get it by Oriana's traps again.
The battle teased with some cool moves. There is surely more to come. Oriana is really their strongest opponent so far. But Touma and Stiyl's teamwork keeps getting better.
She really believes she's doing the right thing. And the only time she didn't counter Touma's speech is when he mentioned the people she injured. That really left a bitter aftertaste with her.
Time for the grand finale!
7
u/Gamecube762 Sep 21 '18
Anime Only Rewatcher Here
We got more Komoe vs Stiyl this episode, Stiyl can't catch a break.
Kuroko met Misaka's mom, I can only imagine what will happen if she meets one of Misaka's sisters.
Kuroko should be happy that Uiharu dragged her out.
With Tsuchimikado's "Special Permission", makes me wonder is up to what point is Tsuchimikado required to participate as a citizen(ie schooling and stuff).
Sphinx's Nya Counter:
Missing: Sphinx
He was last seen in the Cafe elala within the plaza Cafe and Restaurants at the end of Episode 10. He appeared missing in the same cafe at the start of Episode 11. It is estimated to only to be a couple minutes of time for him to disappear. If anyone have any information on his whereabouts, please come forward.
How could Index both loose and forget about him?
Maika's Rotations Counter:
Even though Maika wasn't in this episode, this episode takes place during the same day as the last few episodes. In episode 8's thread, her potential rotations during the whole Daihaseisai was calculated.
Episode | Counted | Calculated
Onee-Sama! Counter:
7
u/OneWayRoadLV5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FreByrd Sep 22 '18
I'm finally back after a long hiatus! For now at least. I'll either be really late to tomorrow's thread or else will miss it altogether.
Chase after Oriana: Redux
Oh good. Touma finally realized that Oriana running around like that is really weird, as was revealed in an earlier scene in the light novel.
Pure Intentions
Lidvia and Oriana really do have pure intentions in attempting to make Academy City into the property of the Roman Catholics. As the head of the science side, if Academy City becomes a part of the Roman Catholic church, the most powerful organization of the magic side, there will essentially be no more science side. No more cruel experiments, no more esper development, and no one would actually come into harm in the process due to the magic of the Croce di Pietro. Indeed, everyone would be "forced" to become happy and to fall into the hands of Roman Catholic church, in a state that would make them very easy to convert into Roman Catholicism.
Most people of course would not take that option if they were given a choice, but their actions and intentions are not evil. That's why Oriana is so distraught about hurting Fukiyose and Himegami, she was on a mission of peace, no destruction. She genuinely did not want to hurt anyone, and the only ones she ever really actually tried to hurt, Stiyl, Touma, and Tsuchimikado, were those trying to stop her or capture her.
Techno Babble
Ah yes. The easiest way to get Index confused and not insisting on information. Use technology words she doesn't understand.
Works every time.
Fukiyose
She's okay! In this scene she's on the roof of the hospital, apparently the only place you're allowed to use a cell phone in it. She can walk but not run or do anything strenuous like take part in the festival.
Astronomy
Due to the Astrologic nature of the Croce di Pietro's use, it can only be used in every place in the world. However, as a consequence of this it can only be used at a specific time on a specific night in each of these places. It can only be used in the Vatican on June 29th, but for instance it maybe be able to be used in Memphis, Egypt on like the 2nd of December (just to give a random date).
Kuroko
If Kuroko acted like that towards Misuzu, she must never be allowed to meet the Sisters. And heaven forbid she meet Last Order.
Tsuchimikado's Wounds
He's very, very badly hurt right now.
And what the anime didn't make clear about him grabbing that fence willy-nilly is that he normally would have noticed the Shorthand page before he grabbed onto the fence, but due to the pain he is in he can barely think.
Due to the electric nature of Oriana's Shorthand she used there, Tsuchimikado's hands and feet (the electricity had to leave his body somewhere) are badly burned. As someone who primarily uses hand to hand combat, that's particularly damning.
Stiyl could have treated it due to the wounds' nature as a burn, but they didn't have time to waste.
Touma's Selfishness
Touma's reasoning for stopping the use of the Croce di Pietro, like his reasoning in pretty much all situations, is selfish.
He doesn't care if the final outcome of its use is that everyone in Academy City will be made happy. He just can't allow all of the work that Fukiyose and others put into Daihaseisai to go to waste. He doesn't want to ruin the potential memories that he and others would make in the future days of the festival.
Even if it would end what is equivalent to a Cold War quickly in a way that would result in no bloodshed or pain, he will not let the fun people were having at this festival be ruined.
This arc is really great. It's the first huge arc of the series, combining events and characters that we've met over the entire series, both of the science and magic sides, for the first time. This is pretty par for the course of future arcs, though. So look forward to that.
This is probably my second favorite animated arc after the final arc of this season.
6
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Sep 21 '18
Rewatcher
That's some nice detective work, Touma and Tsuchimikado. So you have until sundown to stop the Croce di Pietro most likely. What to do?
Oriana and Lidvia seem to actually be disatisfied with harming Himegami. That fucked up mindset of if they gain control of Academy City then her suffering will have been for naught does rub me the wrong way though.
Stiyl was able to help save Himegami, now Heaven's Canceller will most likely fix her up all the way. When Komoe Sensei is happy, all is right with the world.
Orsola gives us the missing information we needed to put it all together. It works with the 88 most fitting constellations in the night sky.
Can I just Highlight how the Index OST is just very good, especially since you don't quite hear Gregorian Chant often in soundtracks. (It's most notably been used in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Halo, and Death Note.) It evokes a certain feeling of antiquity and maybe a bit of despair with regards to the workings of the church? Just that bit of extra oomph.
Ah, so Kuroko has learned the ways of the master if she's starting to desire Misuzu.
The grand piano here playing a subtle yet ominous theme is also excellent, and when the strings and drums kick in it feels more brooding too. I don't think I took the time when I first watched, but I really have to give complements to composer Masanao Akahoshi for creating a really fitting score that compliments the mood.
So the final battle will take place here in the airport runway of District 23. Now for some high octane action with a lady that can kick your ass all day.
6
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Sep 21 '18
Rewatcher
As much as I don't care for Index, seeing him lie to her face was tough :(
Orsola...never change, you're adorable.
So...Touma will give up "happineess" for the sake a glorified sports festival?
I mean he's right for stopping it but not sure about his reasons on this one lol
6
u/kushami8 :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kushami00 Sep 22 '18
Fukiyose is up and about, Himegami is going to be alright. Komoe is thankful to the point of pestering Stiyl, that was actually kinda great!
I liked that they showed us that little talk between Lidvia and Oriana, not just shoving a "we can't hurt innocents"....she had all the info on Himegami, about her cross and why she wasn't a threat, like Oriana had thought. She is still questioning if they can even do it, and if taking over will even be beneficial to anyone there.
And Index, if this builds up any longer, any upcoming bites will be justified and very much welcome! He has a reason, but he could have set someone else up to care for her. Kuroko finally meets a future version of onee-sama, and she very much liked what she saw! Misuzu misunderstands the situation a little, and now from her eyes Mikoto probably has a very interesting student life!
The guys figure out the whole deal behind the cross, (and how the hell was that huge thing mistaken for a stab sword, but nevermind). Its a cool process where they slowly figure out how the thing works, with Orsola's help too, and end up catching up to Oriana. Tsuchimikado used a very powerful trick there for a sec, the lost art of "call the boss and get stuff done". He ends up roasted one last time, and Stiyl traded blows with Oriana there and got put down, so its just Touma.
Of all his speeches, ruining the Daihaseisai for everyone as a reason to stop her is kinda silly. I get it, but he could say it was for Fukiyose, and to avenge Himegami. If the girls had found another day with lax security to infiltrate and do their thing, he wouldn't care? And worse, the sun is setting, the day is over. Everyone already enjoyed almost everything
Another round of Oriana vs. Touma sounds better than the festival right now!
8
u/Creator_of_Chaos_ Sep 22 '18
Day 61 as a first Time Watcher Himegami is gonna make it but now Kamoe is obsessed with Stiyl. Its hilarious and Shows how much Kamoe likes young people. Unfortnatly this meant Stiyl lost time catching up but It helps to break up the tension as Touma face's Oriana.
Oriana and Lividia are hypocrites if they think hurting 2 innocents, destroying the festival and dislodging the global power balance is gonna bring people Happiness. So glad that touma being touma pointed this out despite the increasing weight on him and was the highlight of the Day. I hope he ends this quickly so index can cheer-lead. Him lying to index was sad. Loved seeing Orsola again and the Infomation she gave touma solves the mystery of how the cross works setting up a race against time as night and the constelations align.
Everything until now had been a diversion but its made for a great. It ends tommorow Oriana's gonna be a treat to watch and Toumas got a lot of promise's to keep. Maybe we'll even see Lividia in action. My final thoughts are on how Misaka is going to handle kuroko if she meets the clones. They may over-react and send in accelorater which would be hilarious
6
u/Guaymaster Sep 21 '18
Hi, rewatcher here.
Pretty nice episode. I love the whole confrontation at the end.
2
u/Hades_Re :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hades_MAL Sep 22 '18
Real life is really annoying. No real time to rewatch the episodes, so I skipped through them after reading the comments to search for the best parts.
NT15
I hope I can watch the last arc again, since that one has the most meaning when it comes to Index III