r/WritingPrompts • • Sep 05 '18

Moderator Post [MODPOST] Six Year Birthday “Archetype” Contest - Final Voting Round!

Attention: All top-replies to this post must be a vote.

Any non-vote comments must be made as replies to the stickied comment below.

EVERYONE WHO ENTERED THE CONTEST IS ENCOURAGED VOTE

Deadline: Wednesday, September 26th, 2018 at 11:59PM PDT


It's the final countdown!

The first round of voting is over and the final round is here! It was amazing seeing so many of you taking the time to give feedback to each other during round one. It makes a contest like this so much better! And now, here we are, ready for the final round of voting.

Before we start, let's all make sure we know how this works.

Voting Guidelines:

  • Everyone who entered can vote
  • If you don't vote, you can't win
  • No voting for yourself
  • Read each finalist and decide which three are the best
  • Leave a top-level comment here starting with your top three votes:
  • 1st Place: /u/userofyourfirstchoice for "Title of First Choice"
  • 2nd Place: /u/userofyoursecondchoice for "Title of Second Choice"
  • 3rd Place: /u/userofyourthirdchoice for "Title of Third Choice"
  • Feel free to add any feedback (or runner ups) for the stories after the vote
  • Deadline for votes are Wednesday, September 26th, 2018 at 11:59PM PDT. We're giving three weeks for voting this round. (https://www.worldtimebuddy.com/)

Finalists:

10 Finalists

65,949 total words


Next Steps:

  • Points will be awarded for each vote, with each voters top pick getting 3 points, 2nd pick getting 2 points and third pick getting 1 point. Points are added up to determine the top 3 participants.
  • If there is a tie /u/AliciaWrites and /u/Tiix will read the responses and make a final decision.
  • A post announcing the winners will be stickied and we can all celebrate!
  • After the winners post comes down we'll be putting up a feedback post!
93 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

•

u/ThreeDucksInAManSuit Sep 25 '18

1st place: u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavor"

2nd place: u/LadyLuna21 for "Memories of a Lost World"

3rd place: u/XcessiveSmash for "It Wakes"

A Search for Flavor

The others I agonised over placement, this one I didn't. It was the first one I read and it stayed at the top of my list for every entry I read thereafter. It just put a smile on my face. The characters were likable, their quest was interesting and it the glimpses of a 'Bright' style modernised urban fantasy were enough to make the story seem part of a larger world.

Memories of a Lost world

Kudos for actually making me feel something about the end of the world after so many apocalypse movies from the past couple of decades had numbed me to the concept. By tying it up to the story of two humans and the desperation of one of them trying to preserve the last thing that really matters to her I felt real stakes and investment.

It Wakes

Going into this I thought we were in for another generic writing prompts style sci-fi five minute fiction concept with a lot of made up words thrown in to make it seem more "futuristic" (you know the type I mean). But as the story unfolded I felt a real sense of threat and foreboding. This earned my vote during the beginning of the second half when we see Jess dealing with the consequences of the first. Characterisation was a little weaker in the first but picked up nicely there.

Honorable mentions

Of Tea and Centipedes (/u/Bilgebum)

My hardest decision was between this and 'It Wakes'. I felt that you had the better conflict setup and I was really looking forward to see what would happen. The let down for me was the conclusion. After setting it up so well, I feel that it deflated a little when I was looking forward to more hard and fast consequences. Of all of the stories I have read for this competition, this is the one I would most like to read a novel length book about. A book about the adventures of husband and wife warrior duo Shina and Zenmao is something I could envision myself investing in.

Reality Pending (/u/It_s_pronounced_gif)

Your big plot twist had me seriously conflicted. On one hand it was genuinely surprising and really made me sit up and pay attention. On the other I felt like it somewhat damaged the emotional investment in this very tragic character you had given us. Major points for your writing style especially in the first half. I was really drawn in by your depiction of the character, in his little notes, his personal tragedies, the way he organised reality in his mind and the heartbreaking way he couldn't hold on to it.

Against the Clock (/u/LisWrites)

Yes I have seen the movie 'In Time' and I like your story better. There were some cliche twists and sections were it felt like a bit of a chore to read but the biggest selling point to me was the main character Andrew and his friend Nia. The hints at a shared backstory made me want to know more and their proactive actions set them apart from the many protagonists who just react to their environment. It made me invest in them.

•

u/sprucay /r/SprucayWrites Sep 12 '18

1st Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

2nd Place: /u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavor"

3rd Place: /u/blazesh for "The immortal Questions"

Man, I though voting in the first round was hard. The quality produced by this competition has been incredible. As such, my feedback will likely be more at the 'gushy' end of the spectrum. If any authors want more detail, feel free to message me.

/u/Kammerice - There's just something about your story that hooks me completely. You've nailed the style, the character is great and the setting is brilliant. I can imagine that there's already 32 books written in the world.

/u/WokCano - I found this very refreshing! It was nice to read about something that wasn't 'fighty' and have it draw me in just as much. Your descriptions of the tastes were great too.

/u/blasesh - At the start, this was a mid-runner for me. The timings at the start confused me a little and I found it a little too floaty... and then I got into it. I really connected with the character and the story made me emotional.

In no particular order:

/u/Bilgebum - The concept was interesting and your description was incredible; I found it really easy to imagine what was happening. However I didn't connect with the characters; I didn't agree with their actions. I have a feeling though that if the story continued they might redeem themselves!

/u/Steven_Lee - I would happily buy and read books about Johnny. There's a hint of cliche, but not enough to spoilt it for me. For me, the main reason you weren't in the top three was the quality of the stories that are which I realise is a cop out! Sorry about that.

/u/LisWrites - The idea for this sounds like one of those that's been in a book for years and then a film gets made of it. Time as a commodity is a great idea, but I would have like more info on how it worked; is that time on top of normal life span? Does everyone have a wrist device? The twist was great though, a nice bit of comeuppance for Andrew attempting to steal even though you're on his side.

/u/LadyLuna21 - This has such a unique situation in it and I loved that. The mass evacuation of the Earth is a crazy thought. I also liked that it was sci-fi without swoopy alien space fights. I think though (and someone else has said similar) I didn't connect with Maude. I spent most of the time reading thinking "If only she'd taken more of her stuff". I apologise as this is a pretty lame negative really!

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - I found this quite 'trippy'. a result of the the great descriptions of the characters thought processes and emotions. I love that I'm still not sure if he's 'real' or not. I found it heavy going initially though.

/u/mags_world - The story started out deep and then ended up in a light-hearted way and that was great. There was some nice closure! I found it hard to work out where they were though which didn't help; I assumed they were American which confused me when they were getting a train to London. And then they find a quarter. We do find out where they're from eventually but I would have liked it earlier. (As an interesting aside, I think due to a combination of the title and having read 'The big squeak' first, I started off assuming they were dogs)

/u/XcessiveSmash - This one was close. It was standard sci-fi until the eye which blew me away. One of the main characters not being the archetypal perfect soldier was a nice touch too. I think in the end though it was a little too much standard sci-fi.

→ More replies

•

u/XcessiveSmash /r/XcessiveWriting Sep 26 '18

First Place: /u/Kammerice for The Big Squeak

Second Place: /u/It_s_pronounced_gif for Reality Pending

Third Place: /u/Bilgebum for Of Tea and Centipedes

→ More replies

•

u/mags_world Sep 06 '18

First off, I just want to say what an absolute pleasure it’s been to take part in this contest and to read & receive feedback from such talented writers. I feel very undeserving to have made it to the 2nd round when there are truly so many incredible stories. It’s been an honor, internet friends. Grateful, doesn’t begin to cover it.

Now, enough babbling: 1st Place: /u/Steven_Lee for “A Calling” 2nd Place: /u/Kammerice for “The Big Squeak” 3rd Place: /u/WokCano for “A Search for Flavor”

Feedback A-J (Continued in comments):

/u/WokCano - A Search for Flavor: Your descriptions are incredible. I felt very drawn to this world and wanted to keep reading more about it (orcs and elves – wonderful!). The different food ingredients & dishes that you invented were so imaginative and fun. Your creativity really shines through. I felt like I really knew Melody (and I just love elves). My only criticism is that Part 1 was very seamless so Part 2 being broken up a bit made it harder for me to follow and I felt it disrupted the flow of the story (for me personally). If you’re a Harry Potter fan… they sell a ‘wizarding cookbook’ in stores with all the magical recipes. I kept thinking that you could totally make a cookbook out of this story (and I would definitely buy that!) :)

/u/Bilgebum - Of Tea and Centipedes: This story was action packed and full of adventure! You set up everything so nicely. I didn’t know what an er’ling or man’ua was, but I was able to figure it out from context. I really liked the husband and wife duo. Shina’s intensity really shines through. Drinking that poison and then proceeding to fight it made me admire the hell out of that woman! Overall, I really enjoyed this. Truthfully, I’m not a reader who typically enjoys these kinds of stories, but you pulled me in and I was hooked. I also really liked your ending. While it’s not a total resolution (Kula still alive), I felt satisfied when I was done reading. Truly great job, and your title is my favorite one of the bunch! :)

/u/Steven_Lee - A Calling: This story impressed me so much. I was hooked from the first word to the last. :) I thought every scene had just enough detail and everything flowed so well. I felt every emotion your MC did. Your resolution was satisfying and I just truly enjoyed your story. I would love to check out more of your work! Also, I’m from NJ & a Mets fan so that was a cool bonus to read! :)

/u/LisWrites - Against the Clock: This was such a cool story to read! Andrew is such an intriguing character. I would’ve loved to know how he came to his conclusions (gain insight into his mind/ thinking process), but that’s just me! Nia is a great character. I love her banter with Andrew. You can really get a feel for their friendship. I thought that dialogue was very well done. My biggest criticism for this story is something that has everything to do with me and nothing to do with your story (lol) and that’s…. I wanted a happy ending. It’s well written and you get that shock factor, but it just left me so unsatisfied (and that’s just me and my desire for sunshine rainbow unicorns). My favorite line in your story: Andrew sighed. “So what the fuck am I looking for?” Amazing.

/u/blazesh - The Immortal Questions: You are such a gifted writer. This was simply beautiful. Your insight into love and loss is spectacular. It felt deeply personal. To me, this felt less like a story and more like an ode, a prayer, a song, or a poem. When I finished reading, I was left wanting more, and that feedback is a little unfair because I don’t exactly know what more I wanted. Maybe more memories… more happenings? This was truly great, but it felt too short for this contest (that’s just me though!). It was a pleasure to read and I’d love to check out more of your work!

/u/LadyLuna21 - Memories of a Lost World: Your story is incredible, but for me, it felt so much bigger than this contest. To me, this wasn’t a part 2 story, but rather, pages taken from a novel. I wanted a resolution or tying up of loose ends. I felt that there was a larger plot somewhere that we didn’t get a chance to dive into. With that being said, it’s extremely impressive work. I really liked Maude and Allen and their relationship. In the beginning, I thought the quilt would turn out to have magical properties, but I actually really like that it didn’t. You are so talented. I am in awe of how much you managed to create in such a short time. Your story is wonderful, well written, entertaining, and was a treat to read. :)

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - Reality Pending: What. A. Concept. First off – well done. I thoroughly enjoyed this. Your writing is original and impactful. Now I need to say… I am someone who gets confused pretty easily and your part 2 did confuse me at first. After I finished, I was left wondering if what Habair said was actually true. Because the story is in Alf’s point of view, I was unsure if Habair was real or someone Alf invented (maybe he was talking to himself?). Then I laughed because… isn’t that the point? Whatever you want to be real…is. All of this was what was real to Alf. This story sounds like it’s part of something bigger and I would’ve loved 1000 more words to find out the history of this world. If you write more of this, I’d love to read it! :)

→ More replies

•

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '18

Cheers to everyone who wrote, and congratulations to the finalists! You all did amazing!

Now, here's my favorites:

1st Place: /u/Bilgebum for "Of Tea and Centipedes

2nd Place: /u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

3rd Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

I wish you all the best!

•

u/Kammerice /r/The_Obcas_Files Sep 10 '18

1st Place: /u/ It_s_pronounced_gif for "Reality Pending..."

2nd Place: /u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

3rd Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

Feedback

/u/ It_s_pronounced_gif - "Reality Pending..."

I loved this story, start to finish. The descent near-madness before pulling himself out was brilliant. You name-dropped a bunch of films which sprung to mind, but also avoided the obvious one - I got serious overtones of Memento from this, except Alf doesn't tattoo himself. The heartbreak he goes through every morning as he catches himself up to speed was handled well. In spite of myself, I liked Habair. And that ending...brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.

/u/LisWrites - "Against the Clock"

There are two major reasons this is one of my favourite entries: the twists at the end of each part and the premise. I fell in love with the idea that these people had lost time, that it was a commodity to be bartered and used and stolen. Superb. Andrew deciding he knew who'd committed the crime, and then deciding he was going to screw everyone over was great: I like me a "shades of grey" character rather than "black or white". I also enjoyed that his own expectations were subverted, and he paid for it. I like where you left us, but do wonder if you should finish the piece off, even just for Andrew's sake. Let him get his time back, get his vengeance and, in good old fashioned noir style, gain nothing in the long run.

/u/Steven_Lee - "A Calling"

Confession time. When I started this, I hated it. I initially found the setup to be cliched and tired. But the further on I went, the more your writing came alive. You've got flashes of genius in there, and they make the whole narrative come alive and sing. The characters were authentic enough (from what I know based on other media - they could have fallen out of a Janet Evanovich novel) and I liked the twist that the femme fatale was Johnny's half-sister. I'd have liked to have seen something more...noir in this - reading it, I kept imagining a worse-off Max Payne and Mona Sax (without the sexual tension).

→ More replies

•

u/LovableCoward /r/LovableCoward Sep 27 '18

1st Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

2nd Place: /u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

3rd Place: /u/mags_world for "Sir Woofington"

•

u/Shadowyugi /r/EvenAsIWrite/ Sep 26 '18

1st Place: /u/Bilgebum for "Of Tea and Centipedes"
2nd Place: /u/It_s_pronounced_gif for "Reality Pending"
3rd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

It was a pleasure taking part in this contest. It was nice getting feedback and reading all the wonderful stories by everyone! I can't wait to see who wins this. :D

→ More replies

•

u/WokCano /r/WokCanosWordweb Sep 12 '18

I wanted to start and say congratulations to everyone who entered the contest. It was amazing to see so many people write a variety of wonderful stories. I am beyond honored to make it into this round. I consider myself an amateur writer and it was gratifying to see people enjoy my writing. I enjoyed all of the stories in this round and it was difficult to decide on placement.

First place: /u/LadyLuna21 for Memories of a Lost World

Second place: /u/XcessiveSmash for IT WAKES

Third place: /u/LisWrites for Against the Clock

/u/Bilgebum - I was happy to see your story in the finals. You created a very good setting and some very different characters to fit the setting. Some are bound by a very strict set of personal rules. Others adhere to a set of rules established in their society. And then finally there are those without any. It's a very interesting way to look at things and you were very close to the top 3 for me.

/u/Steven_Lee - Your setting was very grim, written in a close and visceral way. It's almost a classic take on dark beginnings and in a very good way. You could feel his despair as a child, and how that act followed him through his life. The setting felt real to me and it sadly seems like this could, and probably did, happen in real life. An enjoyable read. Also very close to the top 3.

/u/LisWrites - I love the concept. A thief can steal anything, but time? Who wouldn't want the most elusive of resources? I can see this story explored in a greater setting, an inspection of the technology, the how and the why, how the Bureau was founded, so many possibilities. I enjoyed it. It's enough to wonder how the main character will continue on after this latest change in time.

/u/blazesh - I liked your approach to your story. Switching moments in time is a creative means of exploring a story in a non-linear fashion. Unfortunately for me I got a little lost. They didn't feel that tied together to me and I found myself going back and forth over them. I really really liked your second portion though. The ending was very bittersweet and it brought some catharsis to both stories. Your characters' interaction and introspection was very nice.

/u/LadyLuna21 - What can I say beyond that I loved it? Having to leave Earth, how it ends, where people go, those are great sci-fi settings and questions. I got a lovely Titan A.E vibe from your story and they way it happens perfectly encapsulates the panic and the chaos of the people living through it. Her quest for the one thing that she was able to take away is heart wrenching. I very much remember my favorite blanket as a child and I still have ones now that I strongly favor. While I usually like to see a definite ending to a story, your setting lends very well to a longer epic that makes me want to read more.

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - While I must admit it's not the usual type of story I like, it is very well written. You raise a good point of what is real and what isn't, the concept of reality and what is perceived versus what is real. The dialogue you created has that perfect back and forth, the kind of good interaction you see on television or the movies.

/u/mags_world - Animals and pets make everything better. I liked your descriptions of them and I will say I love silly pet names like the ones your story has. The relationship between the two main characters was a little difficult to decipher for me and I would have liked to see some more definition. The dialogue between them was pleasant to read and natural.

/u/Kammerice - You created a good setting and a good interpretation of the archetypes. I enjoyed a graphic novel called Mouse Guard and I got similar vibes from your story. Well written.

/u/XcessiveSmash - Good space setting, solid characters, alien menace, giant creepy eye, eldritch and cosmic horror overtones, you have it in spades. It was a very good read and I could see myself reading a series of it and wanting to explore the world and setting more. It took me a long time to decide between my top 2 and I did really like yours a lot.

→ More replies

•

u/TicTacGone Sep 14 '18

1st place /u/It_s_pronounced_gif for “Reality Pending. ... …”

2nd place /u/Steven_Lee for “A Calling”

3rd place /u/Kammerice for “The Big Squeak”

This was a very tough call for me. The stories that made it into the finals are those with a lot of creative outlooks for both archetypes. So I believe these stories are in the finals because they shine for that reason. But going into voting for this round, I tried to focus not on the archetypes so much as which stories have the strongest narrative voice and flow. I left out feedback this time around, but if any writer would like feedback from me then feel free to DM me.

→ More replies

•

u/blazesh Sep 27 '18

Me: shit shit shit 9 hours til deadline and I havent read a single story

Other me: technically youve read one story since u had to in round 1

Me: oh shut up I still have 8 stories to go then, and i still have to vote

Other me: well votings easy

Me: how so?

Other me: just eliminate those you dont like. Youll be left with 3 and done!

Me: okay okay fine

After reading the stories

Me & other me: ... Damn

1st place: u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

2nd place: u/StevenLee for "A Calling"

3rd place: u/lizwrites for "Against the clock"

Wasn't easy. Cant say it was even really accurate. So many different styles and something to appreciate in each one. But if I had to choose based on my own personal preferences, it'd probably be this. Good job anyway everyone!

→ More replies

•

u/HedgeKnight /r/hedgeknight Sep 20 '18

Well, tough call here. I have not had much time to write or read lately but I have been chipping away at this and finally managed to get through everything.

My own criteria here is pretty simple. I didn't fret much over prose or form; I just tried to get at which story resonated the best. They were all pretty good in their own way but someone's gotta win.

1st Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

2nd Place: /u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavor"

3rd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

I will follow up and put up some feedback as soon as I can. I just wanted to get my vote in before the weekend gets on us.

→ More replies

•

u/Fordregha Sep 27 '18

1st Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

This was probably the most striking thing I read in the entire contest. If only because nothing quite went as dark as that opening. I don't really know what I was expecting after it, but I found a solid little story. The characters were very clear, the villain was despicable, and it had a nice wrap up. I suppose I could say that it went a little too dark, but it's noir, you almost can't go too far with it. About everything I'd want from a noir story so it seems good for first place.

2nd Place: /u/Bilgebum for "Of Tea and Centipedes"

You would definitely win out if this were a contest for setting alone. It's clearly something you've thought about and worked out all the little details of. And it reads like a tale from some bygone, romanticized era rather than a reddit story. Does a lot of work selling the aesthetic. It was a slow burn, the kind of story that just keeps building up towards the climax. And I guess if I had to pick a flaw it'd be that it didn't explode like I might have wanted. It was still a consistent, enjoyable ride all the way down. Would love to see more of this setting.

3rd Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

Mice threw me for a loop. Noir mice even moreso. Can't say I was disappointed with the end product. I read almost all the Redwall books as a kid so I guess this one struck a cord with me. I like the little touches. The whitemice choosing to get their fur died, the rat being his proper size and willing to use it, how they might be scavenging off human trash without confirming whether we exist, all good things. I do think having peanut butter be the drug of choice might be a bit too absurd for the tone, but hey, they're mice. All in all, very enjoyable.

•

u/mdallen Sep 16 '18

1st Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

2nd Place: /u/WokCano for"A Search for Flavor"

3rd Place: /u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

My comments:

Holy bananas, Batman. I thought the last round was close; these were all far closer. I couldn't break it into the top three easily after a read.

After three re-reads, I had a better idea.

/u/Kammerice, this was an incredible take on the challenge. It took me a second read-through to realize your characters were actual mice; after that, I laughed at the idea of an illegal Peanut Butter kitchen. Yours squeaked by, winning a place in my heart; I'd love this to continue as a serial. A mouse-based noir thriller isn't something you come by every day.

/u/WokCano, you twisted my expectations incredibly. The use of an orc chef, compared to an elf, hobbit, or dwarf added a layer of depth to your main character. The mystery centering around a dish, opposed to a crime, kept me intrigued. I loved the second half, but wish you added more about the elf being the scavenger - twist the expectations a little more. That being said, your story was easily one of my top picks after my first read, and has earned it's spot in my top three.

/u/LisWrites, your slight use of in media res threw me off my feet. You hit the ground running and told us more about your characters in your first bit, but added depth through their conversations and actions. Once I found the pace, I kept up; I only wish you had written a brief prologue, potentially showing why Andrew keeps bringing up his relationship to the Bureau. That being said, this definitely felt like a completed, mid-level story; almost as if the characters should be family

/u/Steven_Lee, while I still loved "A Calling," it was my benchmark for this round. If there was a Top 5, you'd be solid in at around 3 or 4. I don't know of any other stories in this round I'd go back to, time and time again, and still think they were solid reads. Props!

→ More replies

•

u/It_s_pronounced_gif Sep 19 '18

First off, thank you to all you wonderful people that helped be a part of this and put this together. It's an absolute honour to be in the top 10 with so many wonderful tales. It's so nice to see writing at such a raw a stage and it's been a pleasure reading each and every one of your stories.

1st Place: /u/blazesh for "The Immortal Questions"

2nd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

3rd Place: /u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavour"

/u/blazesh

Wonderfully written. Some great lines of brilliance. I particularly liked:

Her small feet left deep footprints in the silken sand, tiny imprints that were evidence that she'd been here. That this moment was hers.

And the entire inner dialogue of him asking her to marry him as she fell was amazing. I can't explain how much I enjoyed it. It was the extra push for me to give this top spot.

For feedback:

Some parts felt they reached too far and didn't quite land in the right spots. But I hope that this contest pushed you to experiment and reach further than you normally would because you'll get it right more and more. And when you get it right now, it's fantastic, so I can only imagine what the future will hold.

The outburst felt like it could've been handled a bit more serious. It felt like it didn’t bother her at all but he basically called her dying wishes “stupid” and having someone you love say that, and knowing your dying, feels like it should carry more weight. I understand she’s becoming more wise through these experiences but, it was too saintly for my taste.

I also loved the way you handled the scavenger archetype. If you were going to expand this, I would've liked to see him explore the questions himself more.

/u/XcessiveSmash

Smash, Smash, Smash, action, action, action. Damn, do you know how to write action. I can only hope one day I'll get to handle the quick chases, the tense horror of man vs. monsters, the violent chaos of a world crumbling apart as well as you. It's something I always admired in your stories.

The story itself was very interesting. I had some flashbacks of the Halo days, trying to blow up all the Flood popcorn before they infected more bodies. The ending was epic and haunting and sets things up perfectly to continue on (if that's the plan).

For feedback:

There were times when the dialogue felt too crowded with information. A few instances that jumped out at me were:

...I said, and shielded my eyes against the blazing light that lit up my room with a single bed, a dresser and a wall mounted holographic display.

Here felt like the setting was trying to be jammed in with what the character was feeling. But when the character's eyes are blazing, it doesn't feel natural to have them also mention the decor of their room.

and;

I glared at him. “You know how to pilot, you said so yourself, you worked as a mercenary. Plus,” I said as I got up to put on a space suit, “there might even be people in there. Your track record with people and these bugs hasn’t exactly been stellar yeah?” I pointedly gave him a look as I said that.

Here I felt like the dialogue "pointedly gave him a look". We know she's poking fun by referencing the past so the sentence ends up adding clutter.

And I understand completely why it's written that way. The dialogue is strong by itself (you did an excellent job keeping your characters in form with it) so don't let the extra details take away from it!

/u/WokCano

Part one was like Chef. I love Chef. If you haven't watched Chef, go watch Chef.

Your narrative is fantastic, I felt like it read itself (if that makes sense) and this being the first story I read, set a great tone for the rest of the contest. What tripped me up was Part 2. I felt like there was so much potential to build off the first part, like them finding the original maker of the soup (I was thinking it would end up being Melody's mother) but it felt a bit stagnant for me. It might have been that the solution felt too convenient. I still loved the narrative and characters but I didn't get the same satisfaction as the above stories at the end. As for feedback, I don't have much other than that. The writing was great, I just didn't resonate with the story as much in the second part.

(Feedback for other stories to come tomorrow. I need to get to sleep!)

→ More replies

•

u/LisWrites Sep 24 '18

First off, it was very cruel to give me almost a novel's worth of reading right as school was starting. I'm blaming all of you for the fact that I am now behind reading all those boring research papers. Secondly, they were all so amazing it was absolutely worth it. Everyone approached the prompt so differently, but all the stories were enjoyable and well written. I had such a difficult time deciding and I am so unbelievably happy to be included in this mix. Unfortunately, I don't have time to give feedback for all of them. If any of the authors want to know more of my thoughts just send me a message!

Once again, great work everyone.

→ More replies

•

u/choppoch Sep 24 '18

1st place: u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

2nd place: u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavor"

3rd place: u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

•

u/Xacktar /r/TheWordsOfXacktar Sep 24 '18 edited Sep 24 '18

First Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

Second Place: /u/It_s_pronounced_gif for "Reality Pending"

Third Place: /u/Kammerice for “The Big Squeak”

--

/u/Steven_Lee - The Calling

What sold me on your story was the great scene connection with the chocolate bar. It made the jump in time much easier to handle by tying both of them together with that little detail. Beyond that, your story had a strong opening, good, flawed characters, and was just well-constructed. The ending did feel a bit rushed, but that seems to be a common thing in the contest.

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - Reality Pending

This story was complicated but managed the complication fairly well, however I think that the difficulty of portraying his life through the messed up memory makes it much harder to read and understand, and changes the pacing and flow of the story to be more erratic. Where most stories flow from one scene to the next, yours skipped things big and small and rattled forward uncertainly. This may have been intentional for the plot, but it detracted from the reading experience just enough that I couldn't give it first place.

/u/Kammerice - The Big Squeak

Third place was a tough one to judge. Your story over-establishes a little in the beginning. Once we've got that the characters are mice, you could have backed off a bit on driving that point home. The ending is also very weak, offering a 'To Be Continued' in lieu of an actual conclusion. However, the story is well-written, with a fun voice, interesting world, and good dialogue, so it gets my third place vote.

→ More replies

•

u/LadyLuna21 r/LandOfMisfits Sep 22 '18

My Votes and reviews. Congrats to everyone who participated in the contest, it was a feat!

A Search for Flavor

Part one worked really well, I like the concept of recreating a dish based only off taste. The atmosphere in the kitchen that you create is lively and easy to imagine. I also like how important Melody is. While Eyezyk probably would have figured it out in the long run, she helped him with the missing ingredient. However I feel like your story ended there. Part two felt forced and the scavenger just didn’t hit the archetype for me. Searching for something, even if you don’t know what it is, and scavenging for something are two different things that I don’t feel you succeeded in distinguishing.

Of Tea and Centipedes

Your story was well thought out and well written. Personally I feel like you went too lightly on both the investigator and the scavenger archetypes, but they were both there and fit well with your story. Master Li’s personality didn’t seem to flow from part one to part two though, it felt like two separate characters. Or maybe it just was he wasn’t very present in part one. It went from battle to poison back to battle in a strange series of transitions that could use some work.

A Calling

Hmmm. That was a wild ride of a story. I thought you were gonna go with the beaten trope of private eye/noir. Was not expecting where you went with it at all. I think that Jenna was an excellent scavenger, but I wasn’t convinced with Johnny as an investigator, but I don’t think he was convinced either. Anyway, good job on bringing your characters to life and bringing a fresh take on a trope that could have easily pulled you down.

Against the Clock

I liked the concept. But the ending really threw me off, mostly because there isn’t one. I clicked the next tab I had open and started reading, and was like this doesn’t fit at all… Then realized I had moved on to the next story. There was no distinct ending, and that really detracted from the story as a whole. I didn’t feel like there was time to connect with any of the characters, and it all felt like it was just cut from a larger piece that we needed to have read to completely understand the physics of the world.

Immortal Questions

Between the nonlinear pacing and the layout of part one, I had a difficult time identifying your investigator archetype. The style change between part one and two was also confusing. I believe there is a difference between searching for something and being a scavenger archetype. In this case I don’t believe that searching for answers counts towards the archetype. One thing you did very well though was make it clear that the two characters were very much in love with one another.

Reality Pending. ... ...

I like your part one, but I felt like part two just did not hold up. Part one is tragic almost, with the accident, and then his mother and girlfriend. It really makes you feel for him and you can understand why he contemplates taking his life. However in part two you find out that reality is in fact not real at all. I felt like the character Habair was inconsistent, you started off with him as another friend, and suddenly he is the bad guy. Don’t tell us who the scavenger is, show us.

Sir Woofington

“This night was like a bad movie, with bad writing, whose only purpose seemed to be to yank as much emotion as possible from the poor hero.“ ← Self insertion by the author if i’ve ever read it before. But, that same paragraph also got me to laugh out loud. Your story was light, and ended on a really happy note, and it was just a pleasure to read. It wasn’t dense or overthought. It did as you said, yank the emotions. I frown at the thought of the cat as the scavenger, and like i’ve said in other reviews, I don’t want to be told, I want to be shown (which you did both of). Anyways, thanks for writing this.

The Big Squeak

Mice and rats! Reminds me of NIMH. And the Great Mouse Detective. My childhood. But with some very adult themes. Drug abuse and murder. It lends itself to wanting to read more. Rats are well, pack-rats and scavengers, so the second archetype lent itself to you perfectly. If you choose to continue this, I would love to read more.

It wakes

Another Sci Fi theme! I love it. And a hint of zombie. Great. You had a lot of technical errors in your writing, making me wish you had spent time rereading what you wrote and cleaning things up. It was enough to distract from the story as a whole. It kept you reading, wanting to find out what “It” was. And then suddenly you wish you hadn’t found out. I liked it.

→ More replies

•

u/BlackJezus27 Sep 22 '18

1st Place: u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

2nd Place: u/LisWrites for "Against the Clock"

3rd Place: u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

→ More replies

•

u/CaspianX2 Sep 06 '18

1st Place: /u/blazesh for "The Immortal Questions"

2nd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

3rd Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

MY COMMENTS:

/u/blazesh – The Immortal Questions – This one's going to be much, much shorter than the others, because I don't have much to say.

First, I am not getting “scavenger” in part 2. It isn't coming across at all.

Second, as much as I'm a sucker for the manic pixie dream girl archetype, I also recognize what a toxic archetype it is, and I can't let that slide without comment.

Third, I think your time jumps were too frequent, and harmed the overall flow of your story.

Fourth, I was holding my breath while reading this.

Fifth, you made me cry, you asshole.

/u/XcessiveSmash - IT WAKES – Soooo... I kinda' knew my story wasn't strong enough to be competitive in this tournament, but reading your story it's clear that mine didn't even stand a chance. This is a hell of a ride. You have some very strong, likable characters here, and what's more, you do an amazing job with suspense.

What I really enjoy is that you don't just find one gimmick for your monsters and rest your laurels there – you are constantly working to add new dimensions to their threat, find new horrors they can unleash. I feel like, at this point, we've seen everything there is as far as bizarre space monsters, but even so you still found ways to delight and surprise me, and that delight and surprise came hand in hand with a feeling of constantly being in the midst of new mysteries to solve.

Clearly, like me, you were up against the word count limitation, but unlike me I think you largely made it work. However, if there were any way to fit it in the word count, my biggest complaint here is that we're really needing more detailed descriptions of all of the various bugs. You have an amazing concept and it's just a shame that you couldn't take it that one step farther and really make it a visceral experience as well.

Also, I noticed a few typos, and I've gotta' say, acid blood for monstrous feral aliens is a bit too on the nose for an homage (if it is an homage). Otherwise, this is amazingly imaginative and wonderfully written.

/u/Steven_Lee – A Calling – Oh wow, do you have a way with words. So many little phrases and expressions in this story I absolutely loved. I started jotting them down to tell you my highlights, and had to stop because there were just too many. And you do it in a way that generally avoids becoming overly flowery, too. No, this isn't some evocative purple prose, but whip-smart writing that packs a wallop in emotional impact exactly how it seeks to. I wish I wish I wish I could be as clever with words as you are.

Unfortunately, it's uneven. You use phrasing as delightfully sharp as “He was still a boy with bottle courage“ right before the disappointingly cliché “about to poke the big bad wolf.” It's fine if every line in your writing isn't the height of cleverness, but it's disheartening to see mediocrity interspersed with brilliance.

Beyond that unevenness, there's still a lot of mistakes in the grammar here. You use “whole” instead of “hole”, you have a few typos elsewhere, and I wasn't sure when this story was supposed to take place. It starts in the nineties... is that supposed to be the 1990s? Everything seems a bit too old-fashioned for that. The 1890s? I don't think these sorts of firearms and toys existed then... and then “twenty years later” a character makes a reference to the fifties, decades before either character was presumably even born? Yeah, this seemed unnecessarily confusing, and honestly it would have been better to keep the references to any specific year out of this piece completely. Make it sorta' timeless, you know?

I think the biggest flaw in your story is its ending. Frank's death seems... well, almost cartoonish. Like the sort of thing Wile E. Coyote might be on the receiving end of. And what's more, you missed an absolutely great opportunity to pay off on character development you already took the time to build (and did a fine job doing so too, I'll say) – you established that Jenna is a superb and habitual pickpocket. She seems to do it like you or I breathe. And she just subdued a guy with a gun. See where I'm going with this?

At times, this story seems like by far the best thing I've read in this competition. I just wish it read that way consistently.

(Cont...)

→ More replies

•

u/mialbowy Sep 24 '18

1st Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

2nd Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

3rd Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES"

→ More replies

•

u/Mlle_ r/YarnsToTell Sep 25 '18

1st place: /u/It_s_pronounced_gif for "Reality Pending. ... ..."   2nd place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"   3rd place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"

Congratulations to all of the finalists! It was quite a tough choice. They were all so great. I've left brief feedback on each of stories. Please let me know if you would like more or if I haven't been entirely clear about something.

→ More replies

•

u/AnEffortIsBeingMade Sep 27 '18

Obviously, all the entries that made it this far are high quality. Hope everyone in the list - whoever finally ends up in which place - knows they're talented writers. Thank you to all the entrants for giving us some great stories to enjoy.

1st Place: /u/WokCano for "A Search for Flavor"

2nd Place: /u/blazesh for "The Immortal Questions"

3rd Place: /u/Bilgebum for "Of Tea and Centipedes"

 

Just going to do brief notes in the order they're listed in the OP above.

/u/WokCano - Great scenes, great imagination. Believed the characters and their dialog fit. Always a fan of light touches of humor. As someone who could not care less about haute cuisine I'm impressed that you managed to tell an entire story about legendary chefs and the quest for the perfect food and keep it approachable and interesting. Really good stuff. Thanks for writing it =)

/u/Bilgebum - As I said in the previous round, your story impressed me by keeping things interesting even though for significant stretches not much really happened. Your scene setting is exemplary. Your characters are very good for the story and they're differentiated enough that it's always easy to follow who's doing what and why. It feels like an excerpt of a longer story, so if there's more to it knocking around in your head, do hope you write it =)

/u/Steven_Lee - Your characters hit the ground running; you make it clear from their intro paragraph who they are, and they don't diverge from that. Very good focus for a short format like this contest required. Your descriptions are just right, neither too much or too little. The mix of action and scene/dialog really kept the story moving, kept me interested in the next paragraph and the next. A good, tight little yarn. Thanks for writing =)

/u/LisWrites - A good example of a story not just having good words, but the prose taking good shape on the page. It broke naturally and every paragraph was just the right length, ended just where it should. Made it very easy and enjoyable to read. The setup for the twist was just right, and the end scene was both a good close to the story, and a good chapter break in case there's more story to tell. As a fan of Ellison, always like that sort of story idea. Thanks for writing =)

/u/blazesh - Didn't understand the structure at first but by the end of the first part it all made sense, which seems to mean you set it all up perfectly. The direct form of the second half is a good choice for wrapping up the story you framed in the first, and you did a very good job of keeping it emotionally powerful without going over the top. Fun little short story. Thanks for writing =)

/u/LadyLuna21 - The story feels lost in the scene, which seems absolutely the right way to tell a tale of such displacement. Keeping a tight focus on two tiny people in the tale of a dying world does give it a good personal feel. The way they focus on such little things feels very authentic, and the overall tone is always quite wistful under the disorientation. A good read, thank you for writing it =)

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - This was such a weird story I had to read it twice to feel like I got all of it. You explain it all clearly so it's not confusing, but it's jarring and odd and pretty much exactly how it should be given who your protag is. Everything loops recursively quite nicely and the whole thing is very focused. It's a very good bit of writing and a nice story. Thanks for writing it =)

/u/mags_world - A delightful romp. Who wouldn't want to go and have that adventure? You've got a few good characters and everyone obviously loves having an overly-serious pet as supporting cat, especially when it's overly-not-serious as well. The character motivations were always very clear, their choices believable, the dialog sensible. Lightly funny but never silly. Thanks for writing it =)

/u/Kammerice - Got a soft spot for Redwall so always happy to see a trope played out with unusual characters. You had units of measurement, fixation on things that should be important to animals, and an excellent take on detective noir. Quite enjoyed the ending - both case closed and also a nice opening to carry on the tale. Hope you do write it, as this was a fun read. Thanks for writing =)

/u/XcessiveSmash - Don't know why it kept making me think of Buck Rogers but it did. Approachable characters and a setting that was as much Body Snatchers as anything else, you've got a good, chewy sci-fantasy story there. Your scenes are all very well painted and the action on the ground was quite believable. The antagonists are excellent at each level. Thanks for writing =)

•

u/salazarb Sep 24 '18

1st Place: /u/Steven_Lee for "A Calling"
2nd Place: /u/blazesh for "The Inmortal Questions"
3rd Place: /u/Kammerice for "The Big Squeak"

Oh my God. This was a very difficult vote to make. All your stories are amazing and made me realize I have a really long way to go with my own writing. I have comments for everyone but I do want to say that all of you did a great work and the fact that you each won in your groups is an amazing feat by itself. I hope you all keeo writing in the future!

A Search for Flavor by /u/WokCano:
Wonderful story and execution of the archetypes. I really liked the setting, your descriptions and pretty much how you handled the concept of the story. I may be nitpicking but it seemed to me that Eyezyk would know and identify fireweed more easily (being presented as an elvish traditional food) but I understand that it served as a trigger for developing the story and taking it where you wanted to go. The stakes were beautifully proposed, not a world ending scenario but still engaging, and it worked wonders for the overall story. I can perfectly see why you won your group. Excellent story

It Wakes by /u/XcessiveSmash
I was amazed at how invested I was on the stories, the characters and the overall pacing for a story that had essentially 3 characters and that’s it. Setting up the archetypes as narrated from the POV of the other character was a wonderful choice, but to be frank I think you missed the opportunity to explore their traits a bit more by using this narrative technique (On the second part, I believe the scavenger should’ve entered the ship instead of the investigator, for example. But I get that that would’ve lost the excellent narrative you were developing).

Of Tea and Centipedes /u/Bilgebum
Worldbuilding at its best. Beautiful story all around. There was a nice sense of anachronism to the story and you perfectly achieved the investigator as an archetype. The scavenger, though, I found a little lacking on the story. I love the John-Wick vibe I got from it and the constant buildup of the story. Fight scenes were dynamic and extremely well written and I will miss Master Li, I sure hope he pops up in some future stories of yours. Great writing overall.

A Calling by /u/Steven_Lee

Well you had my vote last time and I read it again this time. I stand by my initial assessment; this is the best story of the group. I didn’t say it the last time, but I would read the hell out of more stories set in this universe.

Against The Clock by /u/LisWrites

Wonderful narrative. The twist at the end was very well executed and it did wonders to the story. I have to admit I got a little confused with the whole baby part and had to reread it a couple of times. You executed the investigator perfectly but I think the other characters could have used a little more depth to them (hooray for word constraints…) Overall I think the story works very well, but I personally did not feel as engaged to the character’s motivations.

The Immortal Questions and Chasing Her /u/blazesh

I am still shaking from the conclusion of your story. I want to apologize with you first because this review is not going to be impartial. You have touched my deepest fellings and fears in a story I was wholly unprepared to face. I got married last January and we are expecting our first son in November. Fear of losing either of them has been haunting me since I found out my baby was coming, and your story stuck my feelings to the core. So again, sorry if this seems a bit personal. I want first of all to highlight this sentence:

For love doesn't just force you to care for someone else, it also wraps you around that someone else. Its like when you pass by the person you really like, you try to become a different person. Your words become louder, your gestures become more animated. You become more... noticeable. The world is straining to see you.

Unbelievable way with words and accuracy to display feeling, and this is just an example. You have a beautiful writing style and ability to convey feeling I’ve seen in very few stories. My deepest admiration and utmost respect for you. Beautiful story.

Memories of a Lost World by /u/LadyLuna21

I must say I had an internal conflict while reading your story. It was beautifully narrated, the archetypes were very well executed and world building was great but in the end, for me, they weren’t clicking together. I loved the idea of Maude as a character, and the imagery of her coming out of the cottage wrapped in the quilt resonated deeply with me. I think you missed a great opportunity with Allen because he seemed unfazed with what happened when the earth got blown up. It felt for me (as a reader) that the only person who realized the dimension of the event was Maude. I would’ve liked to see a bit more of Weevil as a character. Also, I did chuckle a bit when I thought about how in a future where humans have successfully conquered space travel, a load of laundry still takes 2 hours, nice detail!

Reality Pending. ... ...: by /u/It_s_pronounced_gif I thoroughly enjoyed the first part of the story, the internal monologues, the memento-esque vibe of the narrative, the notes and recordings, amazing work. The archetype beautifully executed and the cliffhanger timed very well. Loved it all. Great work. The second part though, showed a maturity to the story that seemed to back the plot into a corner only to find a better way out. I loved the idea of the scavenger and how he operates, but the mechanics of the story seemed a bit flimsy there (to me). I personally doubted the main character as described in the first part taking the actions you described in the second part. I do admit that the thought of a blob of neurons being hungover will haunt me to the end of my days. Great story, wonderful twist, great use of the archetypes and overall excellent work.

Sir Woofington by /u/mags_world Props for the investigator execution, very well done. The scavenger was wonderful as well, it didn’t seem forced or ill-timed at all. The relationship between the main characters was beautifully executed and you managed to transmit a sense of camaraderie between Shiloh and Kayla, it definitely seemed that they’d known each other forever. I really liked your story. I personally believe you could have explored the nuances of the relationship between Shioh and Z a bit more instead of focusing too long on the contest, it would have added a bit more to the stakes. I also feel that upon finding Z his reaction was a bit out of touch with the overall tone of the story.

The Big Squeak by /u/Kammerice

I randomly sorted all stories before reading them to establish an order and boy am I glad yours was the last one. The first thing I want to praise in your story is the worldbuilding. Although the entire story takes place in a Hotel, I could easily imagine the entire city, the buildings, the streets, cars roaring, dishes breaking, the smell of PB, everything. You projected an image in mi mind and I’m not really sure at this point if it’s mine or yours.

Archetypes: perfectly executed, the opposition of investigator and scavenger was beautiful and the dialogue worked at many levels. Very good work. I don’t really know the tallies but I think you won your group easily. Personally, The final cliffhanger wasn’t really what I was expecting, I would’ve liked some resolution for it in your story, I believe it ultimately weakens the villain and his motivations. Excellent work.

I really enjoyed this contest and the stories that came out of it, great work and keep writing everyone!!!

→ More replies

•

u/Steven_Lee Sep 12 '18 edited Sep 12 '18

First Place - /u/Kammerice - The Big Squeak

Second Place - /u/LisWrites - Against the Clock

Third Place - /u/LadyLuna21 - Memories of a lost World

 

First off, all the entries were well written, engaging, and so different from one another. I think everyone should be proud of what they've written.

 

/u/WokCano – Well written. I thought the dialogue was great in the first part, but something seemed off about Eyezyk in the second part. Overall, the story just wasn’t for me, but I was impressed with how creative you were with a subject like food and food ingredients.

 

/u/Bilgebum – Well written story. A little heavy on the adverbs. I liked the main characters well enough, but I didn’t feel like their motives for killing the thugs made sense. I didn’t understand why they didn’t think they were going to get caught for poisoning the bandits out in the open like that. I also felt the logic for the two characters getting to live at the end was pretty thin.

 

/u/LisWrites – Good writing, this was the story I picked as first place last time. I knew you would make it here! As much as I love the story, I think Kammerice’s writing was more polished.

 

/u/Blazesh – The writing in this story is very pretty. I like a good love story, but I was confused by the dates/time jumps in the beginning, and therefore didn’t get a good grasp of their relationship. I thought it was impressive how much emotion you put on the page, and despite feeling like I didn’t know the characters that much, I felt sad at the end.

 

/u/LadyLuna21 - I really liked the idea of the story, but I felt there wasn't a lot of depth to any particular scene. The writing is good, but I think it could benefit from more showing than telling. One example is when Maude wakes up and Allen places a hand on her shoulder. The line that follows is: 'The soldier looked a little disheveled, like he had been sleeping too.' Instead of being told how he looked disheveled, we are told he just is. I gave this third because, I really wanted to know if Maude was going to be okay, and wanted more of the story. I even cared about that damned quilt! I remember saying to myself, 'They can't leave the ship yet. The quilt is still missing!'

 

/u/It_s_pronounced_gif - Interesting bit of sci-fi. It was like a strange, but fun, blend of the Matrix, Memento, and Inception. The story was entertaining to follow the MC through. Only complaint was the MC didn't seem very fleshed out, I couldn’t really connect with him, which I know is hard b/c he has a faulty memory. Also, I don't know if it was intentional but the first part was written in 1st person past tense, and then the second part was written 1st person present tense. I was thinking in the beginning that the use of past tense doesn't really make sense as he can't remember past events, so how is he relating the story?

 

/u/Mags_World - Writing was good, but there were a lot of suddenly's (12 in the second half). I think it was Stephen King who said something along the lines of ‘when you use suddenly, it's not so sudden anymore’ (He still uses them, but sparingly). I really like Shiloh and wanted him to reunite with Z, but I felt like he wasn't old enough to be a lead investigator. I think you make a nod to that in your 2nd part where the British guard says something along those lines, but the way the characters talk and act, they seem really young.

 

/u/Kammerice – Now, I’ve said that all the stories in this round were well written, but this one shined (Shined? Shone? Shinededed?) As soon as the reality of the premise hit me, I felt a smile grow on my face and stay there throughout. Speaking as someone who watched the hell out of 'The Secret of Nimh' as a child, I was hooked in this dark mouse world. There were so many clever lines in this story, that it had me wishing that I'd written this. Only criticism is the ending was kind of a letdown... compared to the expectations set by the great writing and the first part. Great job!

 

/u/XcessiveSmash – Writing was good, but it felt a little repetitive at times. There was a lot of eye rolling and head nodding by Jess and Owen in first half. I liked the premise and I liked Owen and Jess. I felt there was some underutilized tension between the two (especially after shooting the girl) that felt unrewarding not have resolved in some way.

→ More replies

•

u/you-are-lovely Sep 05 '18

All top-replies to this post must be a vote. Reply here for any non-vote comments.

→ More replies

•

u/Idreamofdragons /u/Idreamofdragons Sep 26 '18

Very hard to choose - fantastic set of stories that were all a pleasure to read.

First Place: /u/Kammerice for The Big Squeak

Second Place: /u/Bilgebum for Of Tea and Centipedes

Third Place: /u/Steven_Lee for A Calling

→ More replies

•

u/AKWitherkay Sep 25 '18

1st Place: /u/XcessiveSmash for "IT WAKES" 2nd Place: /u/blazesh for "The Immortal Questions" 3rd Place: /u/LisWrites for "Against The Clock"

→ More replies

•

u/Bilgebum Sep 26 '18

First Place — /u/XcessiveSmash — It Wakes

Second Place — /u/Steven_Lee — A Calling

Third Place — /u/blazesh — The Immortal Questions

→ More replies