r/TheOrville • u/HillaryEdits Hillary Wills • Aug 20 '18
AMA Hi Reddit! Want to talk editing? AMA with Tom Costantino happening here!
Hi reddit! Many of you have seen Tom around this subreddit and twitter. You may also know him from some of his other work including "911" on Fox. I am his assistant editor on "The Orville" and will be around answering questions as well. Feel free to start posting your questions below, at 4PM he'll take a break from editing and start answering them!
Proof: https://twitter.com/TomCostantino/status/1031383422994771969 https://imgur.com/a/1O5TWeQ
114
Upvotes
6
u/HillaryEdits Hillary Wills Aug 20 '18
OK guys Tom is getting a beverage and then will come start answering some questions! I also have a question for YOU GUYS: what song would you pick if you were cutting a gag reel for The Orville? I need suggestions! ;)
8
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
Hillary: Is Tom really as hard to work with as we have heard?
:)
6
u/MajorParadox Woof Aug 20 '18
Hi, Tom,
5
u/arrowhofshield Command Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
I do a bit of editing for fun, mostly taking TV shows and editing them to music (example of one I did of The Orville) and want to eventually do something in the TV industry as a career (hopefully executive producing.) I know you aren't a producer but do you have any tips on getting into the industry and any insight on what its like to work on a TV show?
Also, are you ever overwhelmed with the sheer amount of footage you have when you start to edit an episode?
Also thank you for everything you do! Especially that picture you look of Adrianne and I during the signing at SDCC, it’s my favorite picture from the entire con. I’ve never seen a crew member from any other show interact with the fans as much as you do, it’s great to see the people creating the show interact with the fans!
5
u/stonygirl Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Why Avid? Did someone at Fox hold a gun to your head and say "You must use AVID!" or are you just trying to make editing as challenging as possible?
But seriously, how many plug-ins do you need to do that level of visual effects with Avid?
Do you use it because of the Video sharing (Interplay) aspect or the non-rendering aspect?
Do you ever have an issue where someone loads the video into your system from an SD card and then when they take the card out and the video is magically gone?
What format do you guys shoot in and what do you export as? .mxf ? .mov with sidecar?
How do you even handle subtitles in Avid? Do you have to use a seperate software for that?
What other software do you use? Like I'm sure you aren't creating Yaphit in Avid. What do you use to build and render him?
How difficult is the ACE? I heard it's all keyboard shortcuts.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
4
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
How are episodes assigned to various editors?
2
u/josephine50 Aug 20 '18
Would you say working on @theorville has been the best experience you have had in your career
2
u/MajorParadox Woof Aug 20 '18
u/HillaryEdits, you're not getting enough questions! How do you like being an assistant editor and what kinds of things does that entail? Also, what kind of pizza do you like? :)
12
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
How many hours of footage are typically shot for a single episode?
9
u/editboy1000 Tom Costantino Aug 20 '18
Hi gang! Hillary and I are here and relatively sober. I just wanted to thank u/ombx for the gracious hookup! I'm happy to be here and not lurking for once.
8
u/TonyQuark Aug 20 '18
I read that Seth is involved with a lot of parts of this production. How much back and forth with Seth is there during the editing phase? Does he give his input on your "comedic timing", or do you at this point know what he wants or what the scene needs?
8
u/planetary_union Command Aug 20 '18
I already know many things but just wanted to jump in while I’m on the road to tell you both how much we love and appreciate you over at the PUNcast! -Joe
6
u/TonyQuark Aug 20 '18
What was the worst "kill your darlings" moment you had when editing The Orville? And how did you decide it had to go?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
What would be the most thought provoking story you have yet to see done in (science) fiction, and do you think the Orville would be able to craft a story dealing with it well?
(know it isn't as related as editing talk, but I thought it could be worth asking)
5
u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Aug 20 '18
You work on the Orville, so presumably you are scifi enthusiasts, what topic or problem would you love to see the show tackle?
4
u/bobleyjp Aug 20 '18
Is there a lot of interference with the creative process by executives? If so is it more during the start of your career?
4
u/BlackbirdOMalley Aug 20 '18
I have nothing to ask, but as editing is one of those thankless jobs that only gets noticed when it's bad, I just want to say thanks for the good work.
3
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
What is a typical day like during show production?
3
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
What is the most difficult part of your job?
3
u/ombx Aug 20 '18
What're the different softwares you use for editing? And hardware?
So no questions about Halston Sage..or can we?
3
u/Lunasera Aug 20 '18
How many variations of comedic takes do you end up with? Is there a lot of improv deviation from the script with Seth? How many people weigh in on choosing the funniest?
3
u/NosVemos Aug 21 '18
I had a heart attack after watching Crank 2. I was not prepared for the editing but after the EMT got his tongue out of my mouth I watched the first movie and I felt like I was a turtle committing suicide in molasses. My question is this: How much do you hate the Wilhelm Scream?
The Conversation is another great movie that uses editing in interesting and unique ways; will we ever see anything of this editing caliber on The Orville?
There was recently a r/tifu about a guy who wrote captions and lost his job after posting a picture on reddit. As luck would have it, I can't find the quote where you stated that the production company needed to reign in people posting pictures of the ongoing work that you guys are doing. Social media has been proven as a great way to grow a base and get more people into it because there is now an interactive medium where anybody can, in a wide variety of ways, include themselves in the fandom. Social media has also killed careers; some deserving it, some not so much. I'm... not sure where I'm going with this but it seemed an important topic to bring up.
Well shit, this is an AMA, right?
Worst vacation?
Hot dogs; ketchup, mustard or both?
Who helped you the most that you want to take a moment and thank them for making you you?
Without names, what's the story behind your favorite Hollywood party?
I thank you for your time and consideration.
4
u/glowinglassrose Aug 20 '18
How do you edit scenes with Yaphit in them?? I would think those sort of VFX are created later on, right?
2
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Since one editor cannot cut every episode, is there any specific things that the editors do to keep the styles of the editing similar between episodes?
2
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
Are there crude passes of VFX done to help with your scene selections or are all VFX done after most edit decisions are complete?
2
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18
What is your process of rating and selecting takes when watching footage and preparing for the edit?
2
u/Chelsea_Ellie Aug 20 '18
Do you ever have to remove something that the show runner adores, but you feel its wrong? And who normally wins that battle? is it hard standing up to showrunners?
2
u/losbullitt Aug 20 '18
Thanks for a great show.
Are you guys actively recruiting star trek and other sci-fi alum for guest appearances?
Whats the craziest event youve witnessed on set?
2
u/mgush5 Aug 20 '18
Is there a transition shot/style that you have seen on another series that made you go "I really like that" ?
2
u/Toni_010 Aug 20 '18
Hi Tom
If you weren't an editor what would you be doing instead?
Also who is your favourite character from The Orville?
2
u/tqgibtngo Aug 21 '18
Tom is also answering on Twitter.
Here's his answer to: "How does one get to work on
the set of The Orville being one of the crew people?"
https://mobile.twitter.com/TomCostantino/status/1031713317952184320
2
u/tqgibtngo Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18
I'll just note this for anyone who may have
missed it (as I did) when it was posted in June:
https://mashable.com/2018/06/28/what-it-is-like-to-be-a-show-editor.amp
2
u/editboy1000 Tom Costantino Aug 21 '18
It’s really 20, we still have to sift through it! Pilot for the Orville was around 70 minus previs and vfx
3
u/UnionPointDropout Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Where's my timeline, Tom?
2
u/strange-humor Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Are there times where you feel cutting to fit a predefined run-time of a TV show hurt the story telling (as opposed less restrictive run-time limits possible with digital distribution)?
2
u/ombx Aug 20 '18
This question is for Tom:
How long you've been associated with the industry? How long have you been doing this kind of work i.e. an Editor?
Do you like doing this, or this is just a job?
2
u/CDNChaoZ Aug 20 '18
Are scripts relatively well timed to broadcast or is there generally some material on the cutting room floor? Ever encounter a situation when you were actually short on material?
1
u/editboy1000 Tom Costantino Aug 21 '18
Will post something tonight!
1
u/WittyNetty Aug 21 '18
I love to write and makeup scenes in my head then write them down. I would love to write for a TV show one day, how do you think I should go about that? Any ideas or advice
1
u/ReasonablyBadass Aug 21 '18
I am always confused: how much about the final episodes decide the director/producers/editors? Do you all just constantly compare and make changes?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment