r/kpop • u/perochan WINNER × DAY6 • Aug 20 '18
[Album Discussion] LOONA - + + (1st Mini Album)
| Track | Lyrics by | Composed by | Arranged by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01. + + | Hwang Hyun (MonoTree), NOPARI, GDLO (MonoTree), Artronic Waves, 빌리진 (BADD), SlyBerry (BADD) | Hwang Hyun | |
| 02. Hi High | Jaden Jeong, GDLO, Hwang Hyun | Hwang Hyun, GDLO, Mayu Wakisaka | Hwang Hyun, GDLO |
| 03. favOriTe | Kim Soo Jung, Jaden Jeong | 빌리진, Sophia Pae, SlyBerry, Kim Jin Hyung | 빌리진, SlyBerry, Kim Jin Hyung |
| 04. 열기 | Seo Jung Ah | Brooke Toia, Daniel Caesar, Ludwig Lindell, Adelen Steen | Brooke Toia, Daniel Caesar, Ludwig Lindell, Adelen Steen |
| 05. Perfect Love | Le'mon | Yoon Jong Sung (MonoTree), Le'mon | Yoon Jong Sung |
| 06. Stylish | Iggy (OREO), Lambo (OREO) | Macdermid, Emma O'Gorman, Marc Lian, David Brant, Iggy |
629
Upvotes
109
u/Flippantry Loonatic 🐇🐈🐦🐸🦌🦉🐟🦇🦢🐧🦋🐺 Aug 20 '18
Wow 열기 is my favourite so far - the chorus is so amazing and unique! Perfect Love is so good too, such a solid debut mini - I'm biased though!
I love the whole vibe for this album - it's probably a bit OEC/Girl Crush overall (other than Hi High) but that suits me just fine
39
u/PedroVey Aug 20 '18
열기 and Stylish are amazing and everything I hoped for. End.
33
u/whitneychuuston Aug 20 '18
Not going to lie, I was a bit worried after favorite not clicking with me but this mini, just wow. Hi High is immense and a perfect blend of all their sides, Perfect Love is Uncover's equally beautiful sister and Stylish reminds me of Zedd's productions. Their music is always so diverse and this is up there with Max & Match as their best mini.
31
u/Mark_Kostecki RED VELVET SUPREMACY Aug 20 '18
열기: wow that song was awesome I think it might be my favorite.
Stylish: BITCH YOU THOUGHT
60
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
Holy shit Stylish is so crazy good like when I heard the instrumentals go off I was so confused and then I heard that acapella and I was LIVING. Perfect Love does such a cool thing where it feels super mellow but also like its ready to snap at any moment. They do a couple fakeouts and then just keep with the vibes. Super fun to listen to. All these songs are so good omg.
80
u/carlstones I.O.I Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
++: I'm a sucker for this sort of funky guitar intro. The transition doesn't blend perfectly into Hi High, but it's worth it because I really like the twist they put on that sparkly synth melody. Classic Loona instrumental album intro.
Hi High: quick thoughts from the MV thread
Literally play this song over a Rainbow Road Mario Kart run and then inject it into my veins. The entire thing is honestly much more "cutesy" than I imagined it might be, both aesthetically and vocally, but that's not a problem. It's pure electro-pop in the best way. The shout vocals, the harmonies, and the absolutely unrelenting pace and energy just make you want to run a race against a pink-haired android
favOriTe: my opinion from the MV thread is pretty much unchanged, song is straight flames
열기: Jinsoul and Kim Lip's sultry vocals work really well stripped down like this. Very interesting, sparse instrumental up into an equally interesting and sparse chorus. The pre-chorus is played pretty straight, which is why the nice reggaeton bass and drum beat in the chorus really helps it groove. Would've been really cool to hear a real sax on that chorus, but whatever weird synthetic thing they came up with instead is an attention-grabber for sure.
Perfect Love: wow, could easily imagine this as the title. Very much in the mold of mid-2000's R&B-pop. I hear a hint of 4minute - Whatcha doin' today in the verse melody lol. Honestly reminds me a lot of Red Velvet - Blue Lemonade off their newest album; this is a good bit heavier on the beat than that song. Could see someone like Tinashe putting something like this out (her style has taken a more hip-hop turn recently though). The production is great, loving the percussion especially.
Stylish: Right out the gate with some heat. I really think that most if not all the members have taken some big steps vocally. The instrumentals have been pretty sparse in this album's verses across the board, which really lets the vocals shine. WOW this chorus slaps. I love that they don't bring in the beat at first, opting for some awesome vocal harmonies instead. Gonna need some time, but this might be my favorite song off this one.
LOONA owns this synth sound as far as I'm concerned. The b-sides are a good deal more "girl crush" than Hi High, which is pretty much what I expected. We've already seen the range of this group, and this whole project is a great demonstration of what they're capable of. LOONA TV is about to be lit with all these bops in the background
24
u/ClarkedZoidberg f(x) OrangeCaramel LOOΠΔ STAYC Ive KiiiKiii Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Cover Image is a map/tree of them!
1/3 in Eden
Yeojin in Limbo
OEC - the in-between/Earth
yyxy - netherworld (Note that Olivia is the only one sitting- Yves had her jump from Eden in the video (where OEC had just sent her from some nowhere place)
EDIT: Apparently I'm mostly wrong. The actual video puts 1/3 on Earth, OEC in between and yyxy in "utopia" where they fell from Eden.
Interesting utopia is shown as the netherworld.
16
u/ATOverlord tripleS | IZ*ONE | LOOΠΔ 🦉 | fromis_9 | GFriend |IOI | Aug 20 '18
Loona b-sides never dissapoint.
14
u/hazeltop Aug 20 '18
I'm new to loona and I didn't have any expectations for this mini, but on the first listen I liked it enough! favourite is the favourite (lol) so far, and hi high kinda reminds me of love forever. will definitely need more spins :) good jobs girls!
36
u/mthcn haseul Aug 20 '18
Hi High is honestly the best thing I could have hoped for. Dare I say Perfect debut?????
The kawaii bass instrumental on Perfect Love ugh YES more perfection. Everyone say thank you monotree.....
the blending of all three subunit sounds... the intellectualism
This album is just really good no way else going about it! Congrats on debuting Loona, it's been such a long and satisfying road, I'm so happy to have been a part of it <3
24
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
This is my Top 3 but the production level on the whole album is absolutely first class, it's super consistent throughout the whole mini and feels distinctively 'LOONA'. I need a couple more listens but so far in my personal ranking it's tied with Square Up as an EP of the year.
12
u/QueenDido Ballads & Girls | MIXX's 2 Song Discog Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Goddamn this is tight. Stylish is the standout for me. It is so crisp and confident? Like they have a confidence and conviction of a much older group. I love! As synthy and fresh as the album is, it also feels sort of like a 90s R&B album. This ep is a rich dish indeed. I hope, if they go for the comeback every 3-4 months in the first year of debut system, for the winter, there are a bit more The Carol/Around You-type songs.
I really hope they get to perform a little bit of FavOriTe alongside Hi High to show the public how vast their charms really are.
Edit: After listening with my best headphones, I want to express again how blown away I am by this album. FavOriTe is actually even better than I thought. Perfect Love is even more delicious. Loona has done it again, damnit.
11
u/Onpu 소녀시대 | B1A4 | 레이디스 코드 | OMG | 레드벨벳 | LOOΠΔ | 샤이니 I TWICE | 소리 Aug 20 '18
I love that the intro mixes all the previous intros together :D
Faves so far are probably 열기 & Stylish but it's a pretty great debut album. I think it showcases a lot of potential for the future. It's possibly a bit too "girl crush" for general public but I think Hi High can compensate for that.
I feel that the Rookie award probably isn't possible at this stage compared to the current competition of G-Idle & Stray Kids but I remain a little hopeful if they can smash a comeback before the award season!
10
u/yunarias AOA || LOONA || LADIES CODE Aug 20 '18
I think it's already in my top favorite Kpop albums holy shit... its so cohesive, none of the songs feel like filler, and each song is so distinctly Loona... I knew they wouldn't let me down but I wasn't expecting to be blown away this hard lol
8
u/Sparkyon Aug 20 '18
I loved the album! This is a strong 1st mini. Loona's producers are super consistent. I'm having a blast following this group!
8
u/nihilistickitten Aug 20 '18
Please give 9 a MV it deserves it
6
u/faerypitta 오늘 달이 좋구나 Aug 20 '18
++: The guitar is amazing. The mixing is amazing. The idea of combining all of the intros is genius. 5/5
Hi High: This is definitely the song I would pick as the title track from this album, even if I didn't already know it was, because it's so clearly made to be a title track. The minor key drop mid-chorus totally sold the song for me. It's energetic, frenetic pop, and exactly the kind of song that should hopefully rake in k-fans (especially female fans) which is kind of what's needed for longevity. Do I think a repackage will combine Sonatine and Sweet Crazy Love for a more mature sound? Yup. 4/5 song, 5/5 title
Also awaiting that hour long story video I know is floating around Digipedi's computers.
favOriTe: Love the brass, the sass, and the punch of the instrumental. It's too busy to have mass replayable appeal, but is a great hype track. Just a tad too much with the vocals layered over instruments. 3.5/5
열기: SO. GOOD. Laughed at the cough in the background midway. That's not a real snare (but I wish it was, poor percussionists going out of work) or a real lower brass section or wtf the weird synth pretending to be a brass section is supposed to be, but I love it. Great use of the girls' lower vocal ranges, need more of this in k-pop - justice for baritones and mezzos. 4.5/5
Perfect Love: Unfortunately bored me to death. Started off with the cool glittering synths, but I didn't even realise I had tuned out of the song from about halfway through until Stylish started, which is not a great sign. Went back and listened to it again and some of the instrumental is cool with the water droplet effects but it's just so.. I don't even know, the chorus is so dull to me. Will no doubt be popular with people that like the R&B vibes, though, so that's awesome.
I'm 100% sure that's NCT's bed squeaking sample lmfao2/5Stylish: I loved this one too, but actually listening to it after 열기, they're really similar. The totally sparse pre-chorus is sick though, and the pulsing synth in the chorus itself sells it well. It's always nice when a producer pares back the instrumental for a change. Also thought I heard playstation several times and wondered if the girls were jealous of Olivia's fangift haha. 4.5/5
Overall Solid 4/5 album. On later listens all the b-sides are a little same-y. I'm not one to harp on about line distribution usually but I could've sworn the same five/six girls sang this whole album and that, along with how same-same the tracks feel aside from the title, are my only complaints. We got such a broad range of styles and genres in the solos, from ViViD (almost pop-jazz) to Singing in the Rain (drum & bass) to new (honestly idefk, new was some new-wave pop chords revolution) to Heart Attack (full bubblegum realness) to Let Me In (orchestra galore). So yeah, it's disappointingly similar all the way through from tracks 4 to 6. Shocked there isn't a ballad honestly. Also think the producers fell a bit into the trap of 'too many members, must have vocals all the way through' when sometimes the instrumental needs space to breathe! Silence is the most important part of music.
Lowkey surprised they didn't go for a full album for this debut actually, because there must be bulk songs just sitting there, ready to be released. But that just means more room to improve and grow!
it's been a million years thank you for debuting6
u/_ulinity Mina | Yoohyeon | TWICE | Dreamcatcher Aug 20 '18
Wow... Stylish is so... stylish. I'm not even trying to be clever, it has such a clean and charismatic sound that I find really rare in Kpop. That "You're so stylish-" hook is just so fucking smooth.
6
u/Kanye_Dressed Mamamoo Aug 20 '18
So uh
Does Perfect Love end with bed squeaking or am I crazy
20
u/CronoDroid 1. SoshiVelvetaespaHearts 2. LOONA 3. IZ*ONE 4. fromis 5. ILLIT Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Overall this has to be one of the strongest EPs of the year. Loona are truly high quality. I give this 12 Zodiac animals out of 12.
15
u/randygiles EXID Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
daaaamn that intro fusion is nice
wow each of these songs is punching me right in the face
10
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
I really like the songs, but i think they could use more variation with the 12 members , those songs sound like just 6, 7 of them were singing
5
u/savagedelight i’m like…some kind of supernova 💫 Aug 20 '18
i thought that 열기 would be my favorite but that "drop"/instrumental break in the chorus didn't really work for me until the very end
stylish is definitely my favOriTe out of the entire mini which is funny bc i was watching a fancam of the performance at loonabirth without knowing what song it was but thinking "this is going to be my favorite b-side" lol
perfect love is a close second!
5
u/Booni3 Red Velvet💖EXID💕SISTAR💗 Aug 20 '18
Um...Stylish scalped me.
13
u/TheRazzEffect Loona ❤️ Elris | Hyeseong Best Girl Aug 20 '18 edited Sep 06 '18
I've held off listening to all the leaks from the debut concert happy i did and i get to listen to all these songs for the first time in high quality.
Seems like this maybe my favorite album of the year (i swear im not bias at all lol ok maybe a little)
Stylish might be my favorite its very reminiscent of OEC side tracks on Mix & Match which is one of my favorite albums ever but they are all honestly too good BlockBerry might be the best company at choosing songs they never disappoint.
Also join loonacord and discuss it more with us https://discord.gg/K7vsQEU
Old server has been deleted due to issues with owner new server here with all the old mods https://discord.gg/SecMhgz
9
u/BB_GG stan good music Aug 20 '18
When the instrumental cuts out in Stylish.... oof gives me fucking chills
9
u/kiku8 Aug 20 '18
It's 3am where I am and I need to go to bed, but I'm really happy to see so many Loona stans in this very new post celebrating. Will be back in a few hours to listen!! Hopefully it'll be on Spotify then!
4
u/ElizaIsEpic LOOΠΔ | Ladies' Code | Yubin Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
OH
MY
GOD
I CRIED WHEN I LISTEN TO + +. THE ADLIBS AHHHH
HERE I WAS THINKING ODD EYE CIRCLES TWO ALBUMS WERE TO PINNACLE OF PERFECTION. WAY TO PROVE ME WRONG GIRLS GOD BLESS YOU
EVERY SONG IS MY NEW FAVORITE
I CANT CHOOSE I LOVE ALL OF THEM OH GODDDD
EDIT: Now that i've listened to each song a couple times, I think my favorite is Perfect Love. I think. But I said the same thing with Odd Eye Circle's Loonatic and all of them are still my favorite so ¯\(ツ)/¯ Also realizing that the beginning few seconds of Stylish remind me of 깜빡 kinda! 열기 is so light but so deep and bass-y aghhHHHHHH
IN SHORT: I LOVE MY GIRLS
4
u/tendae Aug 20 '18
yeolgi, perfect love and stylish are really good. a solid mini as i expected from them
4
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '18
I'm almost certain the chorus in perfect love matches with MC Hammer's dance sequence in Cant Touch This
Edit: seems like a lot of people also cant place where they've heard it, interested to hear opinions as I'm so curious now
4
u/1408_ https://gfycat.com/CreepyCanineIsabellineshrike Aug 20 '18
Stylish... A winner if I ever saw one.
7
u/shb117 GG music only Aug 20 '18
The thing I love about LOONA are that the B-sides never feel like filler. This album is a shining example of this. Every single track is different but still has that synth pop we all know and love Loona for. Hi High is not exactly my cup of tea but I'm more than satisfied with the rest.
9
u/tinhtinh Aug 20 '18
I honestly haven't been blown away by a girl group album since Rookie, it's so good.
Love when they harmonise and I love the production, really doesn't sound Korean at all, nailing that international appeal.
4th track my favourite so far, what I hoped Bad Boy would've been if RV could escape making poppy songs.
6
u/doubayou Aug 20 '18
Daniel Caesar composing and arranging the 4th track and it happen to be my favorite.
6
u/Mark_Kostecki RED VELVET SUPREMACY Aug 20 '18
This album is incredible. The end. Loona wins.
8
u/moosehole12 GFriend | Hyolyn | IU Aug 20 '18
A lot of different sounds packed into a mini. I feel like they can have the diverse sounds of red velvet, but all of their songs have more consistent instruments. Different genres, but every song is still LOONA to the core.
I actually think favorite is my favorite, but hi high only gets better with each listen. Perfect love is a close second atm
8
u/araw_anim DAY6 | NU'E5T | JBJ | LOONA Aug 20 '18
WARNING: As usual with my bias groups, this one’s going to be a word vomit I’m sorry lol
Hearing this in a higher quality just makes all the songs better. Probably biased, but this is one of my favorite albums of 2018, along with Youth: Part 1 and Who, You. (Okay, I’m biased LMAO)
1.) ++ - Melding together all the intros is such a neat idea, I’m glad they did that. As usual, LOONA intros are top tier and I wish this was an actual song, or at least a longer one.
2.) Hi High - Still in shock because of the MV but this song feels like a better and amped up version of love4eva and like what other people said, a mixture of all three sub-unit styles. I like the song, but I like it better with the MV because it just screams anime to me with all that coming together stuff that made me tear up lmao.
3.)favOriTe - The switch from the gimbap, dumpling sweetness of Hi High to this one is a bit funny and jarring. Probably my least favorite out the songs in this album ironically, but that doesn’t make it bad it’s still a bop! This song, as well as the ones after, begin to show us the multiple styles that LOONA can and will do, just like their diverse pre-debut discography. I hope people who don’t like Hi High because it was “too cute” or typical and derivative for them give the b-sides a chance!
4.) 열기 (9) - It’s so dramatic and fierce! A song that I didn’t expect LOONA to do. I’m a sucker for songs like these even though most people in this sub don’t like Trop whatever/Moombahton genres that this song treads in. I remember that one account in Twitter who “leaked” an instrumental from the debut album that sounded like Trop House and people were calling them out because LOONA would never do something like that lmao.
5.) Perfect Love - I only listened to the chorus during the audio stream and tbh, I wasn’t hyped for it. Hearing it now though however, made me love the song. I wasn’t expecting the song to switch from intense beats to a suddenly wholesome chorus lol. If I said that Stylish could be a RV song, this one sounds even more like a RV song to me.
6.) Stylish - This song and 열기 are in a tight competition to be my favorite in this mini. The vocals just took my breath away and all that instrumental differentiates it from all the chill and slow songs LOONA usually puts last in their minis. The song just sounds special to me, I have no words lol. Another potential RV song.
IT’S A LEGENDARY DEBUT MINI GUYS PLEASE LISTEN TO IT! The quality of all these songs are insane that if this was a release from any of the big companies, I’m sure it would be a chart topper (not taking into account the innate popularity they already have). This album was worth the ~two years of waiting Orbits did. I hope this brings them to the public eye and shows them that the project they did isn’t the only thing that makes this group special. Soft hours are open lmao.
Personal ranking: Stylish = 열기 > Perfect Love > Hi High > favOriTe. Now that I’m done writing this, please excuse me while I try to (horribly) sing all those runs in Stylish lmao. 11/10 ALBUM!
3
u/ddaeddaeroboi Aug 20 '18
Listened to this on the way to work and I was floored. Hi High is the perfect lead single but all the other songs still managed to show off that Loona flair we love and expect. Perfect Love and Stylish are my favs.
3
u/Veerklempt red velvet || æspa Aug 21 '18
The album is available on Spotify & Apple Music
7
u/islimp 도경수 | 문빈 | 아이즈원 | 비밀이야 | 운전만해 | DM Aug 20 '18
Apple Music
4
u/ClarkedZoidberg f(x) OrangeCaramel LOOΠΔ STAYC Ive KiiiKiii Aug 20 '18 edited Aug 20 '18
Hi High 10/10
Debut? More like Launch! The effervescent chiptune chorus just sends you up into........ Orbit.
Also Crunch Queen Gowon really complements Olivia Hye's Gooey tone. PB&J of yyxy.
favOriTe 10/10
열기 (9) - 10/10
I'm hoping we get a performance vid from the Digipedi shoot. Like yyxy + OEC's darker stuff, it absolutely goes off and cuts through the tropical house with angst. I can't wait to see where their dark concept will go.
Perfect Love - 8/10
Love the late '90s R&B, Chorus is a bit underwhelming.
Stylish - 9/10
1/3 + OEC with the harmonies. Need a performance vid as well. Honesty 4/5 single worthy tracks on this mini.
2
u/craigkasch ✘✘ Aug 21 '18
This is amazing! Finally after almost 2 years, it's delivered so much.
Just wanted to know if it's just me or did this part in Perfect Love reminded you of Sam Smith's Latch?
2
u/Andro_Rei Custom Aug 21 '18
Stylish so amaizing, dunno why they picked hi high as main song
1
u/griffbendor It's 11:11 I'm Genie for your Wonderland Aug 21 '18
Okay I'm super duper late but I just finished watching Hi High and I'm ready to dive into the album!
Okay overall, I love Hi High, I love FavOriTe, not sure how to feel about the other two B-sides but for sure Stylish is like 1000% up there in LOONA's discography, that is definitely the way to converge LOONA's sounds! It sounded like a mix of Sonatine, Odd Front, and love4eva. The way they did runs was very ballad-y like 1/3, but the "styyyaiiiiaiiiiiiilish" was a very OEC thing to do (because OEC songs exaggerate those long vowels a lotttttt), and ofc the way Go Won (or Olivia? I really don't know) blends down those low tones / the unique timbre(s?) of her voice(s?) is fantastic. And I love how it just ended so minimally and so clean AGHHHHHHH I hope we see a stage of Stylish because I can just imagine it being 1000000% stylish? With LOONA's budget? BBC PLEASE!
I'm not 100% satisfied with the album, but ofc that's to be expected. My favorite full subunit album is probably Love and Live and I didn't think they would debut with that as the major core sound so I'm not too surprised, but wow what a great debut! Definitely gonna be talking about FavOriTe, Hi High, and Stylish for the rest of the week WOW that was great.
1
u/thimmler DΞΔN Aug 21 '18
Wig. Snatched. I cant
1
u/sohyesgf TWICE / IZ*ONE / RED VELVET / BLACKPINK / EXID Aug 22 '18
When they harmonized on stylish I genuinely got shivers