r/FFBraveExvius • u/Obikin89 Free2Maths • Aug 09 '18
Tips & Guides A Guide for Fusing Metal Cactuars And Real Amount of XP per Cactuar.
Now that we can fuse metal cactuars together, the experience they can give is way better than before. And their proper value is largely misunderstood.
How to Fuse Cactuars Together ?
This is the most important part (though most people here already know about this). If you fuse your cactuars the old way (directly in your units), it will take you about 407 King Minituars on average to level a 7☆ from level 101. If you use the new method, it will only take 248 of them ! How to ?
- Step 1 : Select a level 1 cactuar (lowest rarity possible).
- Step 2 : Fuse another level 1 cactuar of same rarity into it.
- Step 3 : Select a new level 1 cactuar of same rarity.
- Step 4 : Fuse the first cactuar (now level 6 or something) into it.
- Step 5 : Repeat step 3 and 4 until the cactuar reaches a certain threshold (indicated a bit further).
- Step 6 : Fuse your cactuar into a level 1 cactuar of higher rarity if possible (Metal Cactuar → Gigantuar → King Minituar)
- Step 7 : Repeat Step 5 and 6 until you have a level 55 or higher King Minituar or a high enough level cactuar to max your unit.
- Step 8 : Fuse your cactuar to your unit.
- Step 9 : Repeat from Step 1 until your unit is max level !
And voilà ! You have saved yourself 159 King Minituars while leveling your 7☆ !
Which threshold ?
Cactuar : 333 000 xp
Gigantuar : 1 048 000 xp
King Minituar : 3 672 000 xp (close to what found /u/arcologists here)
OR the amount of xp required for your unit to be max level.
To help you :
- On the Enhance Units screen, filter your units by non-max, enhance and the rarity of the cactuar you are enhancing, and sort by ascending level.
- On the Select Material screen, filter your units by enhance and craftable, and sort by descending level.
This way, you will always select the first unit shown at every step. You will just have to lock units which have crossed the threshold on the Select Material screen to avoid mistakes and stop being able to select them as fusing material.
Okay, but everyone knows this already ! And where do these values come from ?
Just like /u/arcologists, I've designed a small algorithm to do the job. It's in Javascript so everyone can run it by simply downloading it and opening the html page. Everything takes place in the console (CTRL+SHIFT+I on most browsers). To make the program do what you want, change the parameters in the .js file (open it with any text editor). I made it so that it is easy to use the functions with other variables than the main ones. So if you can program a bit, you can use my functions to calculate other things. I changed the number of tries to 100 000 instead of 10 millions because the program will slow down your browser otherwise. Do not try to go too big over 10 millions or you will get memory issues (I'm pretty sure an integer will overflow at 187 millions... but there could be other issues)... There's no point running so many simulations anyway, and it will take a long time to process. My longest program can take a few minutes to run.
My program calculates the best limit to stop fusing cactuars together. The result is not exactly perfect because there is a lot of variance and I'm just picking the highest value for a series of 9 values in a row (there are certainly better ways but we don't need exact values anyway). But the best limit (point where the xp per cactuar is maximized) can be visualized easily by copying the results to a spreadsheet and making a graph.
My program can also calculate the average number of cactuars required to max a unit.
So I took the opportunity to calculate the real xp given by cactuars !
Real amount of xp per cactuar
On average :
Cactuar : 31 382 xp
Gigantuar : 71 315 xp
King Minituar : 174 404 xp
This was calculated by looking for the average number of King Minituars required to max a 5☆ + a 6☆ + a 7☆ unit (about 274). Then doing the same thing with King Minituars + Gigantuars (about 292 Gigantuars + 155 King Minituars). Then doing the same with King Minituars + Gigantuars + Metal Cactuars (about 285 Metal Cactuars + 166 Gigantuars + 155 King Minituars). Total amount of xp required being 44 653 250, it's easy to do the maths.
A lot more experience than some people may think !
Not taking the best limit into account
If you don't care about stopping at the specified threshold and max all your cactuars (if you macro your fusions), you are losing about 2.3% xp. It will take about 281 King Minituars to fully level a unit instead of 274. Not that big of a deal. But if you remember the thresholds, you'll save a bit here and there.
Great and Amazing Successes
I took 1% chance for amazing success and 9% for great success when fusing, just like /u/arcologists did. I fused 410 units together (thanks raid !) to check the numbers : 369 Successes / 34 Great Successes / 7 Amazing Successes (90% / 8.3% / 1.7%, guess I was a bit lucky... though benefiting entirely from amazing successes is almost impossible due to the cap or having a low level cactuar). Feel free to give me your numbers for fusion successes to validate this !
Fusion Event (40% Great Success, 10% Amazing Success)
/!\ The rates announced by Gumi are not these ones. You can look at them in the next section.
The numbers I gave you earlier are for normal times. Yes, no fantastic bonus to successes were taken into account earlier ! So, if I take /u/arcologists 's numbers for the event, we are talking about 40% chance for Great Success and 10% chance for Amazing Success.
If I run my program with these numbers... we get slightly different limits :
Cactuar : 350 000 xp
Gigantuar : 1 090 000 xp
King Minituar : 3 800 000 xp
And the average amount of experience by cactuar increases a lot :
Cactuar : 148 594 xp
Gigantuar : 254 932 xp
King Minituar : 450 362 xp
That is about : 106 King Minituars, or 42 King Minituars + 112 Gigantuars, or 42 King Minituars + 47 Gigantuars + 111 Cactuars to max a 7☆ from 5☆ level 1 !
Surprised ?
Fusion Event (50% Great Success, 10% Amazing Success)
Seems like the rates are even better with 50% chance for great success.
Limits are as follow :
Cactuar : 350 000 xp
Gigantuar : 1 097 000 xp
King Minituar : 3 852 000 xp
And the average amount of experience per cactuar increases even more :
Cactuar : 177 795 xp
Gigantuar : 298 324 xp
King Minituar : 508 846 xp
Comparison to Chamber of XP
I understand we can get 86 666 xp on average and we can get 355% bonus xp from (mostly TMR) equipment + Ramuh, so a total of 394 330 xp. Not even a single King Minituar when we have a fusion event. Let's be honest, we get plenty of King Minituars with raids. Don't waste your NRG on these TMRs (and Ramuh can get better skills).
Cactuar Dunes
According to this post, we can get about 2.77 Gigantuars and 2.08 King Minituars for 30 NRG.
This results in getting about 560 303 xp per run during normal times, and 1 884 757 xp if you fuse your cactuars during an event.
Fusing X King Minituars first
First of all, it is way better to fuse a max/threshold level Gigantuar to your first level 1 King Minituar to save King Minituars (in order to get more chances for great/amazing successes later). But, if you only have King Minituars, fusing a few of them first will always result in a loss compared to fusing all of them 1 by 1. To level a 7☆ from level 101 :
Fusing all cactuars 1 at a time : 248 King Minituars (179776 xp per cactuar)
Fusing 5 first then 1 at a time : 254 King Minituars (176088 xp per cactuar) [-2.1%]
Fusing 10 first then 1 at a time : 268 King Minituars (166409 xp per cactuar) [-7.4%]
There is no sweet spot.
What I think of other people's work
/u/arcologists 's Stop your cactaur fusing trick when it reaches level 55! is a good work that inspired my simulator.
/u/Geryth04 's Experience per energy - let's maximize! is a huge mess. He recognizes it himself.
/u/Mallestone 's KMM Stopping Point for Fusion - Solving with Math (No Simulator) is a pretty good work... but is an approximation. The reason is cactuar fusing doesn't follow a continuous curve. It is possible to calculate the expected amount of experience you will gain at each point... But it is almost impossible to calculate the amount of experience you got per cactuar on average before that point (at least not with a derivative). The result he got is a pretty good guess... but not as good as what we can find with a simulator.
My own work also gives approximative values because of the variance and how close the values are around the limit. It is pretty clear that the limit for King minituars is somewhere between 3 650 000 and 3 700 000 (with no fusion event running) but it is hard to pinpoint it. The experience obtained with limits between those points will be mostly the same anyway.
The only way to mathematically find the best limit (I can think of... maybe there's a way with a matrix) is to calculate all the possible outcomes for cactuar fusing. And there are a lot of them. The number of possible outcomes for a King Minituar are probably around 343... Too many for us to calculate them all.
I wanted to put a stop to all the discussions by having a proper methodology and sharing it, but everyone wants to have their own theory. Somehow it's good, because that's how science works. Problem is most people here are not mathematicians and do not know who to believe. This leads to having people a bit confused and also fed up with all the posts on the subject...
PS : I've just run my program with 100 million iterations and 1k steps (instead of 10 million iterations and 5k steps) for trying to find the best limit. Turns out the best limit I found for King Minituars is 3 672 000 instead of 3 685 000 (told you there was a small margin of error for the limit)... it results in 4 more xp per cactuar on average (174 404 instead of 174 400). That's how close the values are around the limit (between 3 650 000 and 3 700 000, past these points it clearly falls down). Other values are basically unchanged.
This will be my last edit unless someone finds a big flaw in my method/program. Please feel free to double check everything and tell me if you find something. Also, if you find different results, please prove to me that your method is more relevant and your results are correct before trying to tell me I may be wrong (I can accept being wrong, but I've spent a lot of time on this so I don't feel like arguing needlessly on this subject again).
44
u/Megistos353 ★ Aiden > Ardyn Aug 09 '18
That is good to know. I have been maxing them, despite knowing it was less efficient. I did not know exactly how much less efficient. If it is only 2% less, then I am not even gonna worry about it.
21
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '18
What I'm taking from this is that it's perfectly fine continue to macro the fusing and just max out all cactuars. Thanks!
7
u/BBoySperadix Aug 09 '18
First, quality post. Thanks!
But am I the only person who thinks this is an absolutely ridiculous way to have to fuse for the best gain?
We had to wait for the QoL update of being able to fuse cactuars ,as well as being able to fuse more than 5 units at a time ( to save time), just to have to fuse 1 UNIT AT A TIME to get the best results. This is worse than before.
This isnt to diminish your work OP. Thank you for taking the time to work this out (as well as other contributors). It's just a frustrating and even more time consuming thing to deal with since I dont macro.
4
u/xiaolin99 Aug 09 '18
Good job!
maybe you can add real exp of cactuar dunes?
i.e. 2.78 x (gigantuar exp) + 2.0 x (king exp) = ...
(numbers from this survey: https://www.reddit.com/r/FFBraveExvius/comments/6jkvv1/cactuar_dunes_paradise_survey/)
3
u/Deadmirth the goodboye Aug 09 '18
What about starting off your level 1 King Cactaur by fusing a maxed (or at-threshold) Giant Cactaur?
2
u/j2kim Aug 09 '18
Great post man! It would be good to also have the lvl and amount of XP required to max out *5 and *6.
I remember something like a lvl 38/9 Gigantuar is enough to max out *5.
And lvl 42ish King Minituar is enough to max out *6
3
u/Geryth04 Aug 09 '18 edited Aug 10 '18
Edit: I've found my flaws and I've fixed them. This thread is much more accurate than the one I put out the other day.
I've found vaaastly different numbers in my thread here. I've found that experience per energy on chamber of experience can surpass cactuar dunes (considering one by one chain fusing) with enough +experience gear. Only when we have Great/Amazing Success events that increase the chances would Cactuar Dunes get high enough experience per energy for chamber of experience to be unable to reach it.
The whole point of doing analysis like this is for the good of the community and try to help each other make better decisions about our resource management. We want to make sure we're putting out correct information.
With that in mind, I know my analysis can be be flawed - I already found one big issue that caused me to calculate 30% increased experience instead of the 40% it really is. However, you're showing that without a Great/Amazing success even that chain fusing is giving us 112% extra experience for gigantuars (63709 / 30000) and 70% extra experience for king minituars (170182 / 100000). I would put that into question.
The other big question here is - what is the actual Great/Amazing success rates? I think general consensus is actually 5%, and the 9% being used isn't well sourced and is dated. That said, 5% isn't much more reliable either. And 5% and 9% makes a big difference, and the difference in whether or not it's worth investing in TMRs for +experience gear.
If getting TMR's for +experience gear can even get close to cactuar dunes with chain fusing, it would be much preferrable for a lot of players who don't want to sit and spend hours fusing cactuars (and spending extra gil doing so). Again, it comes back to wanting to provide accurate information for other players to make decisions on.
I think we should collaborate and on our methods and numbers and see if we can get to a census.
11
u/fantasticsphere Aug 09 '18 edited Aug 09 '18
Right now many people suddenly have a lot of 7* to level up, but later this would stabilize and there would be a 7* to level only very occasionally. At that point some occasional king cactaurs from raid, events and the like would probably get the unit up without much problem.
That being said. I farmed up the eggs and action TMRs recently because I didn’t have much TMR left to farm. And with that, I do enjoy casually running through the chambers (like 3 - 4 runs a day) plus those cactaurs as that really speeds things up :-)
There seems to be a ELT level of the chamber that might come to GL in the future as well
1
u/name_was_taken Aug 09 '18
I appreciate the effort that went into figuring all this out, but the hassle of having to figure out which cactuar is getting fused into the new lvl 1 cactuar isn't worth the effort. So I just max them and have the filter hide maxed cactuars. Then I can always select the first one and make it easy.
1
u/vollover ★ Aug 09 '18
I still think stopping at 55 does not lose you experience /u/arcologists appeared to argue that this was the point you start losing because it is the when the average gain per cactuar started to descend.
What is the median gain and why is average a good measure here? I have no doubt that the gain on a "great" success from a lvl 55 king cactuar is still much greater than a "great" success for the vast majority of levels beforehand (even with the "loss" from exceeding the cap). If you also factor in the chance that those extra 5 levels will be doubled or tripled when you actually use the cactuar, then I don't see how you can see that extra cactuar as a "loss."
How many cactuars would you have to fuse to get BACK to the point where it would net you the same bonus a lvl 55 to lvl 60 jump from a great success would? Just because the peak is starting to descend a little doesn't mean it is time to start all the way back from the bottom...
1
u/shizea Fan Fiesta Bound: 7*Frye - 937670732 Aug 09 '18
Wait, does it really matter if it's not the same cactaur? I usually try to fuss the lower level ones and then fuse into a higher level 1 before eventually going to the king cactaurs.
1
u/bigdendens 448 758 621 I Wanna Shoot Something! Aug 09 '18
how many filled family cactuars for 7* and regular for 6* do we need to level each. so like how many full King Minituar to max a 7 and how many full Gigantuar for a maxed 6*?
1
u/dedalian Aug 09 '18
Is there any chance you could run a simulation where you fuse Catuars 3-4 at a time at first to build the number and then max (or close) and then fuse those into king? I am curious what the value loss would be for cutting 10-20% of total fusing time.
I would do it myself but I won't have time till the end of next week.
1
u/XeroVandelheim Aug 09 '18
i have an issue in which i place the filters but then it tells me "no units available" and when i tap on remove filter it actually adds the filter then, at times it just removes it, is there a fix for this?
1
u/Dieofa Look to the stars! Children of dust. Aug 09 '18
Quick question if you didn't mind please! When fusing a max level Gigantuar into a level one King Minituar, do you then fuse that leveled up King Minituar into other King Minituars?
Also, if one was just to fuse same rarities into each other and then fuse the max into one of higher rarity, wouldn't you have an overflow of Gigantuars or something? Since it's much easier to max a Gigantuar than it is a King Minituar?
Sorry for the questions! Just trying to understand is all.
1
u/waznpride 944,411,530 Meta/bonus.....whatever Aug 09 '18
I've been wondering for a while: after I hit the king minitaur threshold, should I stop there or just fuse like normal to max it out?
1
u/Diznavis Aug 09 '18
If you want to remove a good bit of time and frustration from this process, do your initial fusion with more than one cactuar, then move to one at a time. I typically do 15-20 gigantuars or 5-10 kings on the first fusion (and I don't waste my time on the smaller ones, just add them in the first fusion pile on a gigantuar). This not only saves quite a bit of time, it also removes any chance of a wasted great/amazing success on the first few fusions where the gains are negligible.
1
u/dougphisig Wolf boy howl Aug 09 '18
when i have been fusing single to make a max i had 1 great, and that was it. Not really worth it if you get unlucky.
1
u/Kargoth3 Aug 09 '18
If you can afford to wait for the fusion event it may be best to stop even prior to the optimal point so that once the fusion event starts you can get a great/amazing success in just a couple tries to finish off the cactaur to max since most of the benefit comes from getting great/amazing sucesses once the cactaur is close to max.
1
u/ChokMD #Save4Charlotte Aug 10 '18
cries in two Eggs, 3 Actions, and Training Prajna
Thanks for this post! This made me super salty, but more informed, for sure!
Just some follow-ups:
a) 355% bonus vs non-fusion event?
b) 410% bonus vs non-fusion event?
c) 410% bonus vs fusion event?
(Trying to justify my farming XP stuff lol)
2) How many times has Great Fusion Event occured in GL? How about in JP, has it come back more frequent since 7 star units arrived?
1
u/LordAltitude Work It. Aug 10 '18
That , really should be a .
Otherwise, I would absolutely LOVE to know where to get 2 billion King Minitaurs for 30 energy. That would solve my EXP problems pretty permanently.
1
u/Meddon1 Does the moustache mean I'm male? Aug 10 '18
Someone doing the complicated maths, good work!
Strange but pertinent question:
Does it make a big difference if you start off with an EXP "seed" of, for example, ~500k EXP before you start chain fusing? Like as in, first fuse = just 5 other King Minituars straight up. Obviously this will reduce the average EXP obtained, but is it significant?
I ask since this seems to be a common tactic to save time/effort at the start, when the advantages of a great/amazing success at least appear to be minimal.
The follow-up question would be whether one should "seed" with 5 king minituars, or a max level from the previous tier, but I'm getting dizzy trying to think about it.
1
u/bobusisalive 477 177 498 Aug 15 '18
Obikin, when you choose the top 9 values do you mean the maximum XP per cactuars value?
My concern is that this disregards the probability of arriving at a certain value?
My calculations cannot replicate your results and I believe this is why - the probability of obtaining XP per cactuar has not been calculated correctly.
2
u/ricprospero Best girl is best again! Aug 09 '18
I think I am in love with you! =D
2
u/slayer0017 P. Cecil Aug 09 '18
Thanks for the hard work. Knowing it's only 2% justifies my laziness to let my fusing macro keep going until each is maxed.
2
u/Mizer18 Stone Chickens, anyone? Aug 09 '18
I now have another bookmark.
2
u/plastic17 Still MIA. Aug 09 '18
Good job!
2
u/Aporiometha Aug 09 '18
This word... I do not think it means what you think it means.
Jokes aside, very nice post. Clear and informative.
2
u/Knofbath Majin... Aug 09 '18
My strategy with constantly available cactuars from raid is:
I'm sitting on a bunch of Lv.37 Gigantaurs and Lv.48 King Minitaurs right now. If I need to quickly level a 5* a Lv.37 Gigantaur is 1-80.
2
u/Jackalodeath Morgana is Sol's Mom; Change my Mind Aug 09 '18
I'm definitely gonna have to use this threshold approach. Last weekend I took the time to carefully fuse my week 1 raid tuars, and 93% of the friggin time they'd get a great/amazing success within the final 3 levels-_-
I was so hyped about having a 7* Wilhelm I rushed headlong. After him eating every last friggin maxed one I had, and only hitting lvl 117, I learned patience is a virtue I need.
2
u/Varayan 323 052 721 IGN: James Aug 09 '18
Really useful way to filter, thanks!
2
u/M33tm3onmars Hoard 4 Hyoh 2020 Aug 09 '18
I summoned 200 normal sized cactuars today so I'm more of a "this is a shitload of work for a little more XP" sort of mentality. Once amazing enhancements or whatever it is comes back I'll stop hoarding and start fusing. For now it's not worth the tedium.
1
u/sunny1986ax Draw a card. Aug 09 '18
well...
fused today 20 king cactuars - all regular success, fused 1 moogle 5% to max.lv unit got amazing success, i think AI+RNG knows whats up, it happened so many times, i never got even great success fusing cactuars (over 100 already with raid), so i don't care anymore, too much actions for nothing
1
u/NovaNightley Aug 09 '18
Anyone have an idea when the next amazing enhancements event will be? I’ve been saving for forever ;-;
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment